11 ms·
The migration app of choice appears to be .. xiaohongshu, or "little red book". I'm guessing this won't last since it wasn't intended to have lots of Westerners
by pjc50 2y ago
The migration app of choice appears to be .. xiaohongshu, or "little red book". I'm guessing this won't last since it wasn't intended to have lots of Westerners using it and neither government is going to be happy with that scale of unfiltered contact between ordinary Chinese citizens and US citizens.
In the meantime, it's the place for Luigi Mangione memes.
- __m 2y agoEven Top 1 in the german app store where TikTok isn't banned. People identify on Red as TikTok refugees
- science4sail 2y agoI think that the law "banning" TikTok applies to any Chinese app with over 1 million US users, so Xiaohongshu/Rednote or anywhere else the TikTok refugees flee will be a target - except YouTube shorts and Facebook/Instagram reels of course.
- lolinder 2y agoNo, the law doesn't give a users threshold: it names ByteDance and TikTok specifically, and provides a mechanism for the President to add new companies controlled by a "foreign adversary country" to the list. So anything at all by ByteDance is banned, but RedNote is owned by a different company that would have to be targeted separately under this law. https://www.congress.gov/118/bills/hr7521/BILLS-118hr7521rfs.xml https://www.congress.gov/118/bills/hr7521/BILLS-118hr7521rfs...
- tivert 2y ago> No, the law doesn't give a users threshold It does have a threshold: > (ii) has more than 1,000,000 monthly active users with respect to at least 2 of the 3 months preceding the date on which a relevant determination of the President is made pursuant to paragraph (3)(B); So if it stays unpopular, it's protected from this law. > but RedNote is owned by a different company that would have to be targeted separately under this law. I think that's a foregone conclusion if it actually gets popular with Americans.
- lolinder 2y agoAh, you're right—it's not a threshold that automatically kicks in at a certain number of users, but the president can't add one to the list until they reach that threshold. Thanks for clarifying.
- donatj 2y agoAs a casual observer, I don't understand why YouTube Shorts isn't the obvious successor? The UI is better than TikTok ever was and a lot of the most popular creators are already mirroring their content there?
- defluct 2y agoI use both and YouTube Short produces mostly just garbage for me. AI voice videos that will get your attention, but has little content. TikTok's algorithm on the other hand is much better and provides quality, half-long-form content.
- phobotics 2y agoShorts has a way worse algorithm, I don’t use TikTok because it’s too addictive but I get bored of YouTube shorts after like 5-10mins most times, which actually for me is a Feature but for YouTube itself is a drawback.
- cjrp 2y agoSame with Instagram Reels. Occasionally I'd be scrolling going "man my Tiktok feed is bad today", and then I realise it's IG.
- vile_wretch 2y agoAt least between Subway Surfer Reddit narrations and other garbage, TikTok shows me stuff I know I want to see. Instagram reels will start with something I'm interested in and very quickly pivot to people seemingly in the midst of psychosis, or literal porn. No matter how much I manually report as not interested.
- 8note 2y agoit seems to me like tiktok has a you model, where youtube and instagram have an everyone model
- donatj 2y ago
- commotionfever 2y agoLooks like that app may have a backdoor https://x.com/d0tslash/status/1878959715033694492 https://x.com/d0tslash/status/1878959715033694492
- alp1n3_eth 2y agoThe backdoor named "backdoor", the l33t h4ck3rs strike again.
- marcosdumay 2y agoIf it's for spying on Chinese people inside Chinese territory, there wouldn't be any need to hide it.
- glurblur 2y agoNah, I don't buy it. Chinese as plenty of programmers who can read code as well as you. This dude is literally dumping symbols. There's no proof that it's actually a backdoor.
- marcosdumay 2y agoAnd those Chinese programmers can't talk to anybody about what they find.
- alp1n3_eth 2y agoIt has been under heavy scrutiny by the security community for years, it would have already been found had it existed.
- pjc50 2y agoQuite plausible. To what extent can a backdoor escape Android/iOS sandboxing?
- 2y ago
- maxglute 2y agoWell it's more... Xiaohongshu is for cosmo PRC cool kids (read: lean wealthy), and also a large ecommerce portal that targets that demographic. Not sure if the userbase is interested in... western and RoW "riff raff" shitting up the content for too long. I say this more as an insult to Xiaohongshu, I like TikTok (or Douyin) because I like seeing entrepenurs sell neon signs and industrial glycerine between my swipes.
- _yb2s 2y ago> cosmo PRC cool kids (read: lean wealthy) What does this mean?
- jhanschoo 2y agowell-traveled kids from well-connected families
- maxglute 2y agoXHS is for cool GenZ, bias female, urban, has money / disposable income, think coastal elite. I guess more lifestyle/gram, pushes beauty, fashion, wellness, food, luxury goods etc. Douyin (TikTok) is for masses... "less cultured" audience, more working class / hillbilly, pushes some of the above occasionally but also everything else from cheap widgets to industrial equipment.
- suraci 2y agoOr the Chinese version of instagram, by short
- sandspar 2y agoNot really. Little Redbook is like if everyone on Reddit was upper middle class instead of Reddit's low middle class. Plus Instagram daily life and friend photos. Plus TikTok algorithm videos. Plus Tumblr microblogging. We don't have a 1:1 equivalent.
- slightwinder 2y agoIn English, it seems to be called rednote. But I doubt that it will be a real successor. At the moment it's a funny meme, and for some people satisfied cultural curiosity. But we already see the problems appearing, from the poorly localized interface, to people getting banned for reasons outside their understanding. My guess is, at the end we will see maybe some million users from the USA and some more millions from around the world moving to this app, and maybe bringing a new interaction between the countries, but the majority will end up somewhere else.
- tivert 2y ago> In English, it seems to be called rednote. I know someone who speaks Chinese and uses that app. The name in Chinese Xiaohongshu clearly translates to "Little Red Book," and they're confused how anyone got "Red Note" out of it. > My guess is, at the end we will see maybe some million users from the USA and some more millions from around the world moving to this app, and maybe bringing a new interaction between the countries, but the majority will end up somewhere else. If that happens, Little Red Book will trigger exactly the same law that's banning TikTok.
- slightwinder 2y ago> If that happens, Little Red Book will trigger exactly the same law that's banning TikTok. We will see, but I would think if they gain 2-5 Million Users, it wouldn't but of much concern for the feds. Unless they gain access to a specific vulnerable group.
- tivert 2y ago> We will see, but I would think if they gain 2-5 Million Users, it wouldn't but of much concern for the feds. Unless they gain access to a specific vulnerable group. The way the law is written, any adversary-controlled social network with more than 1 million MAU could be affected. I think they'd ban it if it started gaining traction outside of Chinese immigrant communities. And it'd make sense to do it early, now that they have the legal power to do so, since it'd avoid controversy. No one would have cared about the TikTok ban if they did it when it was at 1-2 million MAU.
- giancarlostoro 2y ago> it's the place for Luigi Mangione memes I read a lot about TikTok the last few months from users all over the web. Trust me, that's not what TikTok is actually full of, its just what algorithm you got sucked into, for whatever reason. I assume there's some specific bubble for "current viral thing" that you're locked into. Make an alt and like completely different content, you'll see that your feed will be night and day.
- giancarlostoro 2y agoAdditionally, what's worse is, I've seen posts of people unable to get out of the algorithm bubble on TikTok no matter how many videos they dislike. I think some people even try blocking the accounts. It's the weirdest algorithm. I assume it works for MOST users (when its not a "MEME" Bubble, its likely content you actually like), but if you shove someone into a niche meme bubble, it can get weird.
- whimsicalism 2y agotiktok easily lets you reset your algo, not sure if reels does the same
- KwanEsq 2y agoThe "it's" to which that sentence is referring is the previously mentioned "xiaohongshu, or "little red book"".
- dspillett 2y agoIt is amusing that the reaction to using a Chinese app being banned because your government says it is dangerous to give them your information, is to give your data to another Chinese app instead. Not that I'd feel any less safe with Chinese companies having all my cat picks & ranting than I feel with American companies having the same (particularly under the upcoming regime). Not that it makes a lot of difference to me, facebook is the only social-media-y thing I use and that is just under sufferance (only way to easily keep tabs on what is happening with some people, mainly family) and because I sometimes like to “breakfast with Lord Percy”. I might try bluesky at some pint as many contacts are moving from fb to there (though that seems rather twitter-like and that has never appealed to me even before I even knew Musk existed).
- marcosdumay 2y ago> It is amusing Well, the US government has just successfully antagonized a bunch of their citizens... It's amusing on the "interesting times" sense, no doubt. But it's not something unexpected. They have been antagonizing their citizens for a while by now. At some point, something breaks and you get either an autocracy or real change. Some people claim they are already there but this is really still not clear.
- zem 2y ago> It is amusing that the reaction to using a Chinese app being banned because your government says it is dangerous to give them your information my guess is that nigh 100% of tiktok users think the app is getting banned because the government is some combination of capricious, bought, and incompetent. their stated reasons for banning it barely register.
- grumple 2y agoI have a friends group where everybody is hopping to this in the group chat. They are so eager to run from one addiction to another - and I told them so. They are so eager to give China all their data and to focus their own lives around an addictive app. It's baffling. Go live your life, enjoy not being indoctrinated by bullshit and having your time wasted by manipulative algorithms.
- ixtli 2y agoIt depends on how they respond over the next 1-2 weeks.
- screye 2y agoTeens are rebellious & want to be far away from parents. It disqualifies mainstream apps like Twitter, Reddit, BlueSky, Reels & now Snapchat as well. This leaves Tiktok and now international apps like Xiaohongshu as the obvious alternatives. The more the US govt. forces youths to use American mega-corps, the less they want to use it.
- dingnuts 2y agoparents aren't on Discord
- screye 2y agoNo one is one discord because its UI is impenetrable. Amazing VOIP though.
- jacobgkau 2y agoDiscord is more of a small-group or individual communication platform. I don't think it's suited as well for the one-to-many or feed-based appeals of social media such as TikTok. (Large, public Discord servers absolutely exist, but they're often themed around something specific; and even if they weren't, you can't just have an algorithm determine which messages in a channel you do or don't see.)
- LeroyRaz 2y agoI don't think rebellion has anything to do with why kids use Tiktok. Nor do I think the US has any interest in forcing kids to use social media...
- polygon87 2y agoIt’s not why they use TikTok but it’s why they don’t use other social media apps. Once an app becomes too popular with older people the quality and vibes decrease, plus everyone feels awkward about posting. It’s something I’ve been thinking about outside of generational gaps, new social media apps are fun because you add all the people you’re comfortable with. After some years you now have a ton of connections from past stages of life, and start feeling restricted again in your personal expression. Plus there’s the dual use issue – IG is too commonly shared now so I have current and former coworkers there plus everyone I’ve ever been interested in as friends or more at a party. So it’s not the place I’d want to feel free and creative. IG tries to solve some of this with Close Friends and other lists but people don’t really want to spend their time constantly organizing a list of friends.
- dang 2y agoRelated ongoing thread (though not much there yet): ‘TikTok refugees’ flock to China's RedNote - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42709236 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42709236
- metacritic12 2y agofor those curious why an app would name itself Little Red Book despite the association, obviously they could have been better about the naming, but they're actually not the same name in either language: The social media app Xiaohongshu (小红书) does literally translate to "little red book" in English. However, this is completely different from Mao's famous work, which was never called this in Chinese. Mao's book was informally known as "Hongbaoshu" (红宝书) meaning "red treasured book" and formally titled "Quotations from Chairman Mao Zedong" (毛主席语录). The apparent connection in English comes from translators using "Little Red Book" for both terms (maybe due to training or an agenda? who knows, choosing word-by-word translation for one and popular translation for another), even though they're distinct and unrelated in the original Chinese, and of course in the official desired English "RedNote" too.
- segasaturn 2y agoThe way people are talking about the name of the app feels very stupid to me, in a way I can't put my finger on. I guess it smacks of more Red Scare paranoia, trying to tie anything Chinese to scary, nefarious communists. I doubt that they were thinking of Mao at all when making the app, Xiaohongshu is an app tailored for young, wealthy, cosmopolitan Chinese as an alternative to Douyin which is more for the masses, I wouldn't call that very Maoist.
- nonethewiser 2y ago> The way people are talking about the name of the app feels very stupid to me, in a way I can't put my finger on. I guess it smacks of more Red Scare paranoia. Is it paranoia if Mao Zedong is still revered? If the government is the communist party? I realize the CCP is not perfectly communist in many ways but they are unapologetic about communism and their roots. It is a coincidence that the original work did not mean little red book. But thats how it was translated, and the translation of the app is correct. So obviously now when you have the same name coming from a country that doesn't denounce communism I think it's fair to be concerned about communist influence.
- 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- polski-g 2y agoIs there a problem with Youtube Shorts? Or Facebook videos?
- tartoran 2y agoYes, they're shoved in user's faces and cannot get rid of them, disable them, etc.
- kpennell 2y agoIt's pretty wild in there...I remember seeing the comment 'IN THE CLERB, WE ALL LEARN MANDARIN'...I went in there and started commenting about Tienenman...curious if I'll get banned. It's very wild to see so many CCP memes and Chinese military people making content. Very odd experience so far.
- kccqzy 2y agoIt definitely won't last because even the medium is different. TikTok is all about short videos, but most of the content on Xiaohongshu are static images, and some even an image of text.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- DeusExMachina 2y agoIt wouldn't be that hard to keep users separated by location.
- extraduder_ire 2y agoI would be amazed if the company who runs that application wasn't working around the clock to make it a better tiktok replacement and to retain this swath of new users.