24 ms·
I'd like to hear an informed take from anybody who thinks that Facebook's fact-checkers were a better product feature than Community Notes. All of the articles
by tptacek 2y ago
I'd like to hear an informed take from anybody who thinks that Facebook's fact-checkers were a better product feature than Community Notes.
All of the articles I'm seeing about this online are ideological, but this feels like the kind of decision that should have been in the works for multiple quarters now, given how effective Notes have been, and how comically ineffective and off-putting fact-checkers have been. The user experience of fact-checkers (forget about people pushing bogus facts, I just mean for ordinary people who primarily consume content rather than producing it) is roughly that of a PSA ad spot series saying "this platform is full of junk, be on your guard".
- josefritzishere 2y agoGenerally fb has trended to worse rather than better. I already passed my personal tipping point years ago and quit fb.
- tptacek 2y agoIt is what it is. It's a hotspot for local politics, so quitting it isn't really an option for me.
- yieldcrv 2y agoAll the burning man camps I get invited to are a bunch of Gen X-ers conferring on Facebook groups so I wind up making a new Facebook account once a year for a few months although could see this moving to Discord across those same age ranges, I’m in some local groups there which overlap with festivals/events/things like the burn.
- Karrot_Kream 2y agoYeah younger millenials and GenZ tend to do this sort of conversation on Discord.
- yieldcrv 2y agoyeah exactly, its now a better platform and has enough critical mass. With Nitro/Discord's paid plan you can change your profile per server if you identify different ways in different groups I've seen Gen X-ers be notoriously inflexible about considering Discord or anything besides Facebook Groups, but as they say: nobody can prevent you from becoming like your parents I tell that cohort "you can't Google this, you have to join the platform and search that channel", and they balk as if their Facebook Group that's segregating them is any different back to burning man specifically, at this point it seems like I can get invited to different camps, so I'm excited about that. mixed age groups, stays fresh
- Karrot_Kream 2y ago> I've seen Gen X-ers be notoriously inflexible about considering Discord or anything besides Facebook Groups, but as they say: nobody can prevent you from becoming like your parents Yeah I'm a millenial with older and younger friends. I found that around 35 +- 4 years you generally have people get more annoyed and flippant at change. I get it, at this age you're probably at the peak of both career and life responsibilities, and you want to focus your energy on your family/career/other loved ones, and the last thing you want to do is learn something new for doing what you've been doing for the last 18 years (chatting about something online.) But it's been pretty fascinating watching the change as my older millenial/young GenX friends are getting into Back In My Day conversations while my GenZ friends talk about new fashions and music.
- grahamj 2y agoEvery Xer I know left FB years ago.
- viraptor 2y agoIt's also the marketplace in some countries. Wanna sell some furniture locally? It may be close to the only option.
- bag_boy 2y agoJust wait until they release a job board. They’ll figure this out soon.
- disgruntledphd2 2y agoThey tried this years ago, but didn't make it work.
- bag_boy 2y agoYeah, but same story with the marketplace. There’s a lot of hourly jobs that need to be filled. Restaurant jobs really…
- wat10000 2y agoIt’s amazingly bad. My feed is just endless blatantly obvious engagement bait, interspersed with occasional posts from people I actually want to see.
- internet101010 2y agoSame. I deleted my account in like 2018. Since then Marketplace has more or less destroyed Craigslist. So two months ago I tried to create an account strictly for Marketplace. My email, phone, and location have all changed since 2018. Despite verifying phone and doing the most extreme KYC step of taking a picture of myself with my ID I still could not make a new account. So maybe they should focus on that?
- tgma 2y agoSAD! Craigslist was a much better product and community even without the luxury of identity verification. It had some obvious spam but by and large worked fine once you got the hang of it. Marketplace is a cesspool of lowballers and sex workers with some shitty ML sprinkled on it, underneath it all some slow and clunky RPCs that need refresh all the time. Forget about the sucky product. Who has Facebook been hiring in the past decade that built that technical crapshoot.
- davidw 2y agoThe ideological bits are: * Dana White added to the board. * "Move our trust and safety and content moderation teams out of California, and our US content review to Texas. This will help remove the concern that biased employees are overly censoring content." - like people being in Texas makes them more objective?! The actual mechanisms of running a social media network at scale are tricky and I think most of us would be fine with some experimentation. But it looks pretty political in the broader context, so maybe it's just a way of saying that certain kinds of 'content' like attacking trans people is going to be ok now. I can't quite FB entirely, but Threads looks like a much less interesting option with Blue Sky being available and gaining in popularity.
- tptacek 2y agoI get how the partisan story is easy to tell here, but I'm saying something pretty specific: I think it would have been product development malpractice for this decision not to have been in the works for many, many months, long before the GOP takeover of the federal government was a safe bet. Community Notes has been that successful, and Facebook's fact-checkers have been that much of a product disaster. I've never seen a wrong Facebook fact-check; I am warmly supportive of intrusive moderation; that's not where I'm coming from.
- mike_hearn 2y ago> I've never seen a wrong Facebook fact-check; Probably because fact checkers are able to make content become unshareable so you not seeing them is the point? But "fact checking" NGOs have a long history of embarrassingly stupid, biased and self-serving decisions. To pick just one example, in 2020 an op-ed in the New York Post arguing that COVID might have come from the coronavirus research lab in Wuhan was banned from Facebook and Twitter because of being labelled by an anonymous fact checker. Who was this fact checker? Turns out one of them was Danielle E. Anderson, an assistant professor at Duke-NUS Medical School in Singapore, who had literally conducted experiments at the Wuhan lab and collaborated with its scientists. You can't possibly get more biased than that, but because she was an academic the sort of people who chose the fact checkers assumed she would be automatically correct. And worse, that anyone who disagreed with her - even mildly - should therefore be banned from the internet. That is the common pattern in every incident that make people mad at "fact checkers" and the reason they have no credibility is that these events happen all the time, are always in favour of left wing beliefs, and they never attempt to learn from these events strongly implying they're deliberate. Indeed the assumption that government funded people are always correct is basically hard-wired into the fact checker ecosystem. They don't attempt to actually work out what's true themselves, so they can't be fixed. This is the kind of thing that Zuck is referring to when he says they're discredited. Wrong fact checks are commonplace, you just won't notice them if you rely on news feeds they control.
- JamesBarney 2y agoYeah I'd like to hear this too. I use both and I love community notes. People are pretending like this is some big culture war issue and a win for the right but I've seen community notes call out Elon for retweeting bullshit more times than I count. (As well as calling Jacobin our on there's) I also appreciate that if I liked a post that community notes called out and I'm getting a notification that was misinformation.
- aprilthird2021 2y agoWell the presidential election was a win for the right. FB and Meta have always complied with and often been an arm of the US govt regarding regulating speech on social media, and they are not really changing that. It's the gov't that's changing.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- aimazon 2y agoFact checkers are the technocratic solution, they're a panel of experts to Community Note's jury of our peers. Fact checkers are a much better product feature than community notes if we want a feature that best serves people who care about facts. That's not our world, though. People don't care about facts, we are humans, our lives are lived based on vibes. The average person would rather listen to their idiot friend's uneducated thoughts about transgender women in sport than listen to a lecture from an expert. Community notes is probably a better feature for the real world, but it's still junk, "effective" is not a label the feature deserves, because the majority of misinformation on X goes un-noted.
- mhh__ 2y ago"People don't care about facts" is such an asinine reactionary way of thinking about macro dynamics in the world. It has no predictive power at all.
- aimazon 2y agoWe don’t. People are social. We care about what the people in our community think, whether it’s factually accurate or not is inconsequential. Those of us wasting our lives arguing on the internet in the pursuit of truth are a tiny minority of atypical people. People yearn for the warm embrace of affirmation, not the cold hard truth challenging them at every turn.
- encoderer 2y agoYou have too many abstractions between you and understanding other people. Most people in your country are actually not that different from you.
- cryptonector 2y agoIt resembles Objectivism. "The facts are the facts and you should see them the same way I do or else!!"
- 2y ago
- throw83838445 2y ago[flagged]
- mhh__ 2y agoI "trust" Wikipedia more than I do fullfact and so on. They've all overplayed their hand.
- throw83838445 2y agoYou can not sue Wikipedia. You could sue facebook.
- chrisco255 2y agoOf course you can sue Wikipedia. There's no law against suing Wikipedia.
- throw83838445 2y agoWikipedia is just a platform, it is not a publisher. Facebook was the publisher! Suing Wikipedia would be like suing email and SMTP protocol!
- amalcon 2y agoIn the U.S. (relevant because it is home to the Wikimedia Foundation), you can sue anyone for any reason at any time. You might get immediately dismissed, sued back ("abuse of process" or similar), or something along those lines, but there is nothing structural that stops you. The structural reason that you can't sue email is that email is not an "anyone", it's an abstract concept. How would you even e.g. notify "email" that it is under litigation?
- paulddraper 2y agoNeither email not SMTP are legal entities. Wikipedia (or more precisely, the Wikimedia Foundation that owns it) is.
- comex 2y agoI don’t use either Facebook or X so I have no personal experience. But the New York Times cited this meta-analysis for the proposition that they’re not ineffective: Fact-checker warning labels are effective even for those who distrust fact-checkers https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-024-01973-x https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-024-01973-x They also cited this paper for the proposition that Community Notes doesn’t work well because it takes too long for the notes to appear (though I don’t know whether centralized fact checks are any better on this front, and they might easily be worse): Future Challenges for Online, Crowdsourced Content Moderation: Evidence from Twitter’s Community Notes https://tsjournal.org/index.php/jots/article/view/139/57 https://tsjournal.org/index.php/jots/article/view/139/57
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nomel 2y agoHere's the Community Notes whitepaper [1], for how it all works. Previous discussion [2]. [1] Birdwatch: Crowd Wisdom and Bridging Algorithms can Inform Understanding and Reduce the Spread of Misinformation, https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.15723 https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.15723 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33478845 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33478845
- tootie 2y agoNotably Zuckerberg did not cite any data for his assertions that community notes are effective.
- nomel 2y agoA way to quantify this doesn't immediately come to my mind. Maybe reasonable metrics would be: 1. What % misleading/false posts are flagged 2. What % of those flagged are given meaningful context/corrections that are accurate. It seems there's circular logic of first determining truth with 1, and then maybe something to do with a "trust"/quality poll with 2. I suspect a good measurement would be very similar to the actual community notes implementation, since both of those are the goal of the system [1]. [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.15723 https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.15723
- torben-friis 2y agoI don't care about the fact checking part but I do care about the "removing the limits on political content on feeds". I think everyone can agree that polarizing content being pushed into people's feed for engagement is a very very bad mix with politics. There is no benefit for anyone in doing this, except for meta's metrics and propaganda outlets.
- llamaimperative 2y ago[flagged]
- nailer 2y ago[flagged]
- llamaimperative 2y agoPeople who are floating using the military to steal territory from a NATO ally, as just one totally random example. Yeah, I know what the press release said lol. Do you typically take press releases as fact? Journalist: "Can you assure the world that as you try to get control of [Greenland and Panama], you are not going to use military or economic coercion?" Extremist: "No. You're talking about Panama and Greenland: No, I can't assure you on either of those two..." Journalist: "Will you commit that you are not going to use the military?" Extremist: "No, I'm not going to commit to that."
- nailer 2y agoNo, I don’t take press releases as fact - do you not see that mainstream opinion on gender and immigration is clearly not in line with what Facebook were moderating for? Compared to compelling people to believe in gender ideology, industrial scale suppression of dissent on private platforms, and teaching race based original sin in schools, being the third president to want to get control of Greenland doesn’t seem particularly extreme. Also, as was pointed out but you omitted from the question you’re quoting, asking a military commander their strategy is a very poor question.
- aimanbenbaha 2y agoAlso didn't know Meta was outsourcing fact-checkers which is a very terrible idea that sponsored a shady economy of ghost workers that were paid pennies for reviewing gore content. It'll really take a special mind to think Community Notes wasn't a positive feature added to the social network sphere. Musk despite his schtick did very bold things that other platforms wouldn't think of doing, such as open-sourcing the recommendation system or recently suggesting the idea of optimising content with unregretted time spent that will reward healthy content and punish toxic content even if the two had the same number of impressions. The overtone window is shifting towards a more open speech and less of self-gratifying echo chambers that promoted the toxic cancel culture.
- ethbr1 2y agoFacebook's approach to fact checking has always been cost-optimization. It would have been a drag on profits to hire professionals to fact check and provide them enough time to do their job, at scale. They quote numbers about how much they're spending as proof they're doing something, but that spend isn't normalized against the scale of their platform.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> It'll really take a special mind to think Community Notes wasn't a positive feature added to the social network sphere. Attributing it to Musk, though, would require a time machine. > recently suggesting the idea of optimising content with unregretted time spent that will reward healthy content and punish toxic content even if the two had the same number of impressions The precise sort of censorship and "cancel culture" he decried upon purchase.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- abtinf 2y agoI think both are atrocious features. It would be useful to know facts about a site or article: this is a new domain, this is a state-run outlet, etc. But other than that, how about I get to use my critical thinking to evaluate the content I access without my “betters” trying to color it first? Any day now, I’m sure Gmail will introduce a feature where Gemini will warn you that the article your grumpy uncle sent you is not nuanced enough. Or your cell provider will monitor your texts and inject warnings that the meme you shared doesn’t tell the whole story.
- threeseed 2y ago> how about I get to use my critical thinking Because no-one, including you, is an expert on everything. So there will be many topics for which you will not be able to make an informed judgement about the accuracy of the content. And on a social network centred around sharing it can be very easy for inaccuracies to spread.
- abtinf 2y ago> Because no-one, including you, is an expert on everything. As I said, god forbid I forget my place and use my mind in the domain of my betters.
- threeseed 2y agoYou can continue to use your mind. Pretend that the Community Notes are a conspiracy to rob you of your free will and ignore them.
- brigandish 2y ago<country hick accent>Looks like we got ourselves a reader… Yep, reading, researching, considering what things matter given your own life experience and situation, these are all meaningless in the face of THE EXPERTS! /s When J.S. Mill wrote about infallibility[1], I can't remember if he wrote about outsourcing that infallibility belief to others, but if he did, he predicted the last 5 years of pro-censorship arguments perfectly. [1] https://www.bartleby.com/lit-hub/on-liberty/chapter-ii-of-the-liberty-of-thought-and-discussion https://www.bartleby.com/lit-hub/on-liberty/chapter-ii-of-th...
- lossolo 2y agoIt doesn’t matter if they were better or worse, it’s all relative. It depends on who you ask, everyone will give a different answer. You are looking at this from a technological and problem solving perspective, while the people who made the decision prioritized these much lower on their list. You need to think like a politician and consider the PR side of things. This is not about solving the problem, it’s about perception, only perception. By implementing community notes, Facebook is shifting responsibility. Previously, the perception was that Facebook was doing fact checking (and no one really cared about the third parties). Now, the responsibility moves to the community. Not only does this shift responsibility, but it also makes Facebook appear politically neutral to Republicans, because they can say, "Hey, we did exactly what Musk did, and you liked it. We are politically neutral".
- bag_boy 2y agoIt also gives Facebook a new product feature that encourages user activity. It was the correct chess move given the current board.
- bombcar 2y agoThe most useful result of Community Notes I've seen is when someone posts something Y, and then a few hours later it comes out that actually it was Z, community notes have been able to attach "actually it was Z" to the original viral post, still being shared. I don't know if anyone cared much about fact checker reports (or if anyone even bothered to track how often they ended up being wrong when looking back in review).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- wilde 2y agoThe deep irony is that some of the original contributors to Birdwatch were working on this stuff at Facebook before being blocked for various reasons and leaving to work at Twitter. To steelman this a bit, early versions of Birdwatch had problems with unsourced notes and speed of note display. There’s a bunch of research that shows that 1st impressions of info tend to dominate, so speed matters a lot. In practice FB’s program was poorly resourced and overly complex so I’m not sure it ever achieved its theoretically lower latency.
- andy_ppp 2y agoI don't really mind how they police things and it's not the point of this announcement. The technology firms think Trump could be so dangerous to their businesses that they are willing to completely give in pre-emptively to this threat. What else are they willing to do given this, interfere in elections for example? Promote misinformation that benefits Trump? Undermine truth about vaccines and safety in our health system? The list of potential problems is quite long.
- datascientist 2y agohttps://gradientflow.com/the-moderation-dilemma-a-balanced-look-at-fact-checkers-vs-community-notes/ https://gradientflow.com/the-moderation-dilemma-a-balanced-l...
- jacksnipe 2y agoI'm not sure about better, but I'm concerned about a second Rohingya genocide. There was a lot wrong with Facebook's moderation system. Spend any time in any politically active groups -- or groups that like to discuss politics -- and you'll quickly find people complaining about deranking. Based on both the extreme frequency with which it's reported and my own experiences with Meta, I believe that they're not making it up. But Meta's moderation tools don't primarily exist -- as I understand it -- to keep discourse informative. They exist so that Meta doesn't accidentally become somewhat responsible for another genocide. I think that community notes may be a better move for public discourse, but most conversations on Facebook itself happen in groups, and in groups nobody is going to be posting Community Notes that go against the trend of the group -- even if they might be useful for totally public discourse.
- xvector 2y agoI tend to blame the people actually doing the genocide for genocide, rather than a social media network. Ultimately I think one can clearly draw the line for personal responsibility well before literal murder. Tens of thousands of have been raped, entire towns have been destroyed, around 50k killed and 700k forced to flee. If Western countries actually cared about the human cost of this genocide, it would be almost a trivial matter to stop it overnight with a few well placed missiles against Myanmar's military, which continues to perpetrate the genocide even today. Instead, no real action is taken and it's just a talking point for "Facebook bad." Blaming Facebook for a genocide is like blaming videogames for an active mass shooter w/o actually doing anything to stop them.
- benatkin 2y agoHow convenient it would be for the social media network if people tended not to blame them. I just watched Zuckerberg say that he's glad about the "free expression" that could happen because of Facebook, and these genocidal posts getting boosted by the algorithm are an example of this. What is missing on Facebook is actual free expression, of people seeing posts from people they follow, including small business owners who would like to reach their customers.
- 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- benzible 2y agoHow about the fact that Meta killing their fact-checking feature will have a very direct impact on the quality of Community Notes? Per today's Platformer: "Another wrinkle: many Community Notes current cite as evidence fact-checks created by the fact-checking organizations that Meta just canceled all funding for." (https://www.platformer.news/meta-fact-checking-free-speech-surrender/ https://www.platformer.news/meta-fact-checking-free-speech-s...)
- paulddraper 2y agoI assume these businesses are ad supported. Does Facebook’s patronage constitute a significant % of the industry?
- BryantD 2y agoI don’t think the fact-checkers were a better product feature in the current environment. I do think that the reasons they aren’t a good product feature are linked to a concerted effort to convince people to distrust fact-checkers. I recognize that many people would say the distrust arose from the way fact-checkers behaved; I don’t think that’s true. From a product perspective, once it’s accepted that Community Notes go through an algorithmic filtering process (which they must), you have to accept that you’ve lost most potential for third party viewpoints. There is nothing stopping ideological companies from putting their thumbs on the scale. Back to product perspective: that means there’s no barrier preventing Notes from losing trust in the same way fact checkers have. The playing field is not static. I think the speed of the rollout will tell us a lot about how long this has been in the works. It’s not a one week feature, although I will remember that Meta produced Threads very quickly.
- dspillett 2y ago> but this feels like the kind of decision that should have been in the works for multiple quarters now My take is that while it must have been a potential plan for some time and switching to this plan can't have just been an “overnight” decision since the election, the timing suggests that either they were waiting for the outcome of the election and using that result in the decision-making process, or that the election result pulled the decision¹ forward. ---- [1] Or the implementation, if the decision had already been made. They may have already moving towards this happening, purely as a business decision based on internal effectiveness studies, no matter who was in power, but given the election result there are some political benefits to rolling the plan out now instead of in Q2 or Q3.
- andyjohnson0 2y ago> I'd like to hear an informed take from anybody who thinks that Facebook's fact-checkers were a better product feature than Community Notes. Zuckerberg's framing of this as being about "fact checking" is intentional misdirection. Very little checking of facts was actually happening. This is about moderation. Specifically, reducing the obstacles to posting racist/misogynist/political abuse amd threats. The objective is to make Facebook acceptable as a platform for the incoming US administration and its supporters, while simultaneously increasing engagement with more inflammatory user-generated content. So its primarily a demonstration of fealty to Trump and co, with upsides. Trump and Zuck recently met privately. I do wonder if these changes are, in part, also a quid pro quo for Trump undertaking to continue with the ban on TikTok in the US.
- sieabahlpark 2y ago[dead]
- freejazz 2y agoAh right, because calling it a product feature suddenly makes the assessment of it objective and non-political
- lisp2240 2y agoFacebook has a long, bloody history of expanding their services into areas without investing in content moderation first. Sometimes they don’t have a single employee who can speak the language of their users. As a result, tens of thousands of people have died in genocide. You can’t have community notes if you don’t already have a community established. Community notes won’t help if the community’s behavior is the problem. Many people will die as a result of this decision.
- sieabahlpark 2y ago[dead]