22 ms·
Web page annoyances that I don't inflict on you
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Waterluvian 2y agoIs there a way to instruct browsers, when available, to just go right into reader mode? I wonder if when your page is so minimal like this one, you may as well just do that instead. Or I guess at that point, you just don’t do styles? Of all the things some people don’t do with their webpage, I’m the biggest fan of not doing visual complexity.
- Zacharias030 2y agoMy iOS Safari has it. I turned it on for the NYT, because I wanted a dark theme and then turned it off again because I realized that I like what they do with their pages (still have an ad blocker turned on though, because subscribers still see tons of ads).
- homebrewer 2y agoBrave has this. brave://settings/?search=Speedreader https://support.brave.com/hc/en-us/articles/360045031392-What-is-Speedreader https://support.brave.com/hc/en-us/articles/360045031392-Wha...
- swyx 2y agothis is exactly the sort of idealistic post that appeals to HN and nobody else. i dont have a problem with that apart from when technologists try to take these "back to basics" stuff to shame the substacks and the company blogs out there that have to be more powered by economics than by personal passion. its -obvious- things are mostly "better"/can be less "annoying" when money/resources are not a concern. i too would like to spend all my time in a world with no scarcity. the engineering challenge is finding alignments where "better for reader" overlaps with "better for writer" - as google did with doubleclick back in the day.
- imoreno 2y agoTo me, it seems like basically everything on this page is both better for reader and better for writer. Which ones are not, in your opinion?
- lolinder 2y agoAll the tracking stuff is better for advertisers than going without, and most writers are paid by advertisers. So transitively it would be reasonable to say that tracking is good for writers and bad for readers.
- imoreno 2y agoPeople oversell this tracking/advertising. It's not a goldmine for every site. For this blog, if she wanted to include analytics into her decision about what content to produce, does she really need super high resolution stuff like where people moved their mouse? Would she ever make a significant income from these "ads", or selling the data for possibly pennies? Besides, just google analytics or something like that wouldn't be that bad (I know the blog author would disagree). A lot of sites go nuts and have like 20 different trackers that probably track the same things. People just tack stuff on, YAGNI be damned, that's a big part of the problem and it's a net drain on both parties.
- arkh 2y ago> just google analytics or something like that wouldn't be that bad Google Analytics is the worse. Not on an individual website but by the fact it is almost everywhere. So Google has been getting everyone's web history since more than a decade. Add Android, gmail, the social "share" or "login with" integrations and any Stasi member would have called you delirious for thinking this kind of surveillance apparatus was possible. Even more that people would willingly accept it.
- MathMonkeyMan 2y agoThe author isn't trying to profit from the reader's attention; it's just a personal blog. An ad-based business would. Neither is right or wrong, but the latter is distinctly annoying.
- nayuki 2y agoI agree with pretty much everything on that page except: > Web page annoyances that I don't inflict on you here / I don't use visitor IP addresses outside of a context of filtering abuse. This point bit me personally about 5 years ago. As I browsed HN at home, I found that links to her website would not load - I would get a connection timed out error. Sometimes I would bookmark those pages in the hopes of reading them later. By accident, I noticed that her website did load when I was using public Wi-Fi or visited other people's homes. I assumed it was some kind of network routing error, so I emailed my Canadian ISP to ask why I couldn't load her site at my home. They got back to me quickly and said that there were no networking problems, so go email the site operator instead. I contacted Rachel and she said - and this is my poor paraphrasing from memory - that the IP ban was something she intentionally implemented but I got caught as a false positive. She quickly unbanned my IP or some range containing me, and I never experienced any problems again. And no, I never did anything that would warrant a ban; I clicked on pages as a human user and never botted her site or anything like that, so I'm 100% sure that I was collateral damage for someone else's behavior. The situation I saw was a very rare one, where I'd observe different behaviors depending on which network I accessed her site from. Sure, I would occasionally see "verification" requests from megacorps like Google/CAPTCHA, banks, Cloudflare, etc. when I changed networks or countries, but I grew to expect that annoyance. I basically never see specific bans from small operators like her. I don't fault her for doing so, though, as I am aware of various forms of network and computer system abuse, and have implemented a few countermeasures in my work sporadically. > I don't force you to use SSL/TLS to connect here. Use it if you want, but if you can't, hey, that's fine, too. Agreed, but I would like HN users to submit the HTTPS version. I'm not doing this to virtue-signal or anything like that. I'm telling you, a number of years ago when going through Atlanta airport, I used their Wi-Fi and clicked on a bunch of HN links, and the pages that were delivered over unsecured HTTP got rewritten with injections of the ISP's ads. This is not funny and we should proactively prevent that by making the HTTPS URL be the default one that we share. (I'm not against her providing an HTTP version.) As for everything else, I am so glad that her web pages don't have fixed top bars, the bloody simulated progress bar (I like my browser's scrollbar very much thank you), ample visual space wasted for ads (most mainstream news sites are guilty), space wasted mid-page to "sign up to my email newsletter", modal dialog boxes (usually also to sign up to newsletter), etc.
- hackingonempty 2y ago> I don't keep a "dick bar" that sticks to the top of the page to remind you which site you're on. I use an extension called "Bar Breaker" that hides these when you scroll away from the top/bottom of the page.[0] More people should know about it. [0] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/bar-breaker/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/bar-breaker/
- xp84 2y agoNice. This may be my pet peeve on the modern internet. Nearly EVERY site has a dick bar, and the reason I care is it breaks scrolling with spacebar, which is THE most comfortable way to read long content, it scrolls you a screen at a time. But a dickbar obscures the first 1 to…10? lines of the content, so you have to scroll back up. The only thing worse than the dickbar is the dickbar that appears and disappears depending on last direction scrolled, so that each move of the scrolling mechanism changes the viewport size. A pox on them all.
- nayuki 2y ago> Nearly EVERY site has a dick bar, and the reason I care is that when reading on my laptop screen, it takes up valuable vertical space on a small display that is in landscape mode. I want to use my screen's real estate to read the freaking content, not look at your stupid branding bar. And I don't need any on-page assistance to jump back to the top of the page and/or find the navigation. I have a "Home" key on my keyboard and use it frequently.
- oneeyedpigeon 2y agoTBF, many people don't have that Home key. I agree with you, though - there should be a better solution. At the very least, just have an optional "Top of page" toolbar button in your browser.
- P-Nuts 2y agoCtrl+↑
- imoreno 2y agoI agree with most of this. If every website followed these, the web would be heaven (again)... But why this one? >I don't force you to use SSL/TLS to connect here. Use it if you want, but if you can't, hey, that's fine, too. What is wrong with redirecting 80 to 443 in today's world? Security wise, I know that something innocuous like a personal blog is not very sensitive, so encrypting that traffic is not that important. But as a matter of security policy, why not just encrypt everything? Once upon a time you might have cared about the extra CPU load from TLS, but nowadays it seems trivial. Encrypting everything arguably helps protect the secure stuff too, as it widens the attacker's search space. These days, browser are moving towards treating HTTP as a bug and throw up annoying propaganda warnings about it. Just redirecting seems like the less annoying option.
- kdmtctl 2y agoIt's fine on a simple site. But lack of SSL/TLS also effectively disables http2 which is a performance hit, not just a security concern.
- drpixie 2y ago>>I don't force you to use SSL/TLS to connect here. Use it if you want, but if you can't, hey, that's fine, too. She accepts http AND https requests. So it's your choice, you want to know who you're talking to, or you want speed :)
- GuB-42 2y agoHTTP/2 doesn't matter in this case, there are only 4 files to transfer. The webpage itself (html), then the style sheet (css), then the feed icon and favicon. You can do with only the html, the css makes it look better, and the other two are not very important. It means that HTTP/2 will likely degrade performance because of the TLS handshake, and you won't benefit from multiplexing because there is not much to load in parallel. The small improvement in header size won't make up for what TLS adds. And this is just about network latency and bandwidth. HTTP/2 takes a lot more CPU and RAM than plain HTTP/1.1. Same thing for HTTP/3. Anyways, it matters even less here because this website isn't lacking SSL/TLS, it just doesn't force you to use it.
- andrewmcwatters 2y agoEveryone using HTTPS protects everyone. Having some operators choose to not migrate to HTTPS-only websites makes the web less secure by increasing the surface area of attacks on users.
- khana 2y ago[dead]
- yakshaving_jgt 2y agoI think many of these are just design trends. As in, I think in a lot of cases web designers will add these “features” not for a deeply considered reason, but simply because that’s the thing everyone else seems to be doing. I’ve had to be pretty firm in the past with marketing teams that want to embark on a rebrand, and say however the design looks, it can’t include modal windows or animated carousels. And I think people think you’re weird when you say that.
- raegis 2y ago> I’ve had to be pretty firm in the past with marketing teams that want to embark on a rebrand, and say however the design looks, it can’t include modal windows or animated carousels. And I think people think you’re weird when you say that. Some small businesses create websites for branding only, and get their business exclusively offline. They just want to have a simple, static site to say "we exist, and we are professionals", so they are fine with the latest in web design.
- yakshaving_jgt 2y agoRight. What I’m suggesting is their simple static site should probably just show the content they want to show, rather than write extra code [and add additional complexity] which makes that content gratuitously slide around the screen.
- TRiG_Ireland 2y agoCarousels exist because everyone wants their pet project to be on the home page, and no one at the company has enough willpower to put a stop to that nonsense. No one actually likes the things.
- modzu 2y agothank you
- frogulis 2y ago> I don't pretend that posts are evergreen by hiding their dates. I didn't realise that hiding dates for the illusion of evergreen-ness was a desirable thing! On my personal site I added dates to existing pages long after they were uploaded for the very reason I wanted it to be plenty clear that they were thoughts from a specific time. For example, a bloggish post I wrote where, while I still think it's right, it now sounds like linkedin wank. I'm very happy for that one to be obviously several years old.
- arrowsmith 2y agoSupposedly it’s an SEO thing. The theory is that Google is biased towards novelty and so penalises older articles (although I’m not sure how removing the date would help because surely Google would still know how long the article has been online for.) I have no idea how true that is but I remember hearing SEO folks talk about it a few years back.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AHTERIX5000 2y agoSome content mills seem to display a date but automatically update it periodically. Sometimes you can outright see it can't be correct since the information is woefully out of date or you can check from Internet Archive that the content is the same as before but with a bumped date.
- dheera 2y ago> I don't do popups anywhere. You won't see something that interrupts your reading to ask you to "subscribe" and to give up your e-mail address. Every time I get hit with a popup by a site I usually just leave. Sometimes with a cart full of items not yet paid for. It's astounding that they haven't yet learned that this is actually costing them business. Never interrupt your customers. Same goes for stores. If I walk into your store to browse and you accost me with "Can I help you" I'll be looking for an exit ASAP.
- oneeyedpigeon 2y ago> Sometimes with a cart full of items not yet paid for. And then a week later you'll get an email "Did you forget to buy all those products we're sure you want?..."
- scarface_74 2y agoYet unlike the 20+ other websites that I can just copy the main url into NetNewsWire, it doesn’t seem to have an RSS feed…
- skydhash 2y agoThis particular button is quite visible on the webpage
- scarface_74 2y agoWith NetNewsWire even when you go to URL from the link https://imgur.com/a/DkifnBG https://imgur.com/a/DkifnBG
- oneeyedpigeon 2y agoOther posters mentioned her IP block - I wouldn't be surprised if that was the cause since automated netnewswire traffic might easily be confused with abuse.
- e28eta 2y agoThere have been a variety of posts semi-recently about a “feed reader score” project, and maybe NNW is particularly misbehaved? https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2024/12/10/feed/ https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2024/12/10/feed/ https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2024/12/17/packets/ https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2024/12/17/packets/
- scarface_74 2y agoNNW works for every other site that has an RSS feed and someone else just commented that while it’s a valid atom feed, when they try to use it in another newsreader, they get an empty result
- dredmorbius 2y ago<https://rachelbythebay.com/w/feed/ https://rachelbythebay.com/w/feed/> (Under the RSS icon.)
- albert_e 2y agoThey did not mention -- Text littered with hyperlinks on every sentence. Hyperlinks that do on-hover gimmicks like load previews or charts. Emojis or other distracting graphics (like stock ticker symbols and price indicators GOOG +7%) littered among the text. Backgrounds and images that change with scrolling. Popups asking to allow the website to send you notifications. Page footers that are two pages high with 200 links. Fine print and copyright legalese. Cookie policy banners that have multiple confusing options and list of 1000 affiliate third parties. Traditional banner and text ads. Many other dark patterns.
- lelanthran 2y ago> Hyperlinks that do on-hover gimmicks like load previews or charts. I haven't seen one that shows charts, but I gotta admit, I miss the hover preview when not reading wikipedia.
- oneeyedpigeon 2y agoSomething else that should absolutely be a browser-native feature rather than one each site has to optionally invent poorly and/or inconsistently.
- mystified5016 2y agoIt can be done tastefully. I think this commenter is talking about the brief period where it was fashionable to install plugins or code on your site that mindlessly slaps "helpful" tooltips on random strings. I always assumed it was some AdSense program or SEO that gave you some revinue or good boy Google points for the number of external links on a page. In the modern day we've come full circle. Jira uses AI to scan your tickets for non-English strings of letters and hallucinates a definition for the acronym it thinks it means, complete with a bogus "reference" to one of your documents that doesn't mention the subject. They also have RAINBOW underlines so it's impossible to ignore.
- joshdavham 2y ago> Safari recently gained the ability to "hide distracting items" I just looked into this feature and it looks awesome! Is there a way to do this in chrome? If not, are there any available chrome extensions that do this?
- wruza 2y agoIs there a way to do anything in chrome now? It became your personal google port and will soon disable any content-modification for the sake of your adsecurity and prinvadcy.
- wruza 2y agoI don't keep a "dick bar" that sticks to the top of the page to remind you which site you're on. Your browser is already doing that for you. A variation of this is my worst offender, the flapping bar. Not only it takes space, it flaps every time I adjust my overscroll by pulling back, and it covers the text I was trying to adjust. The hysteresis to hide it back is usually too big and that makes you potentially overscroll again. Special place in hell for those who hide the flap on scroll-up but show it again when the scroll inertia ends, without even pulling back. Can’t say here what I think about people who do the above, but you can imagine.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoFunnily enough for years I would say the general consensus on HN was that it was a thoughtful alternative to having to scroll back to the top, esp back when it was a relatively new gimmick on mobile. I remember arguing about it on HN back when I was in uni.
- dredmorbius 2y agoMost mobile browsers lack a "home" key equivalent (or bury it in a not-always-visible on-screen soft-keyboard). That's among the very few arguments in favour of a "Top" navigation affordance. I still hate such things, especially when using a desktop browser.
- oneeyedpigeon 2y agoI think some, if not most, mobile browsers - even apps - used to implement it via a space near the top of the window/screen. That seems to have gone away, though.
- dredmorbius 2y agoWorse: "pull to refresh" means that often when you try to scroll to the top of a page ... it reloads instead. The number of times this has happened whilst I've been editing a post on some rando site, losing my content ...
- ValdikSS 2y agoThe page is so narrow, like it's made for a vertical smartphone screen. That's ANNOYING!
- nayuki 2y agoLook up any typographic manual and you'll learn that you can't make lines of text too wide or else people will have trouble reading them. Example - https://practicaltypography.com/line-length.html https://practicaltypography.com/line-length.html . This is also related to why professional newspapers and magazines lay out text in relatively narrow columns, because they are easy to scan just top-down while hardly moving your eyes left-right. I do think that vertical phones are too narrow for conveying decent text, but you also can't have completely unbounded page widths because people do run browsers maximized on desktop 4K screens.
- dredmorbius 2y agoThat's true, but 60 characters is way toward the "too narrow" side of the scale. I'd fatten the page to ~45--55 em (or rem), and BTW, strongly prefer relative font-sized units to pixels, which ... are increasingly unreliable as size determinants, particularly as high-def, high-dot-pitch displays on monitors, smartphones, and e-ink displays become more common. Toto we're not in 96 dpi land any more. I also strongly prefer at least some padding around the edges of pages / text regions, with 5--10% usually much easier to read. I'd played with making those changes on Rachel's page through Firefox's inspector: html { font-family: garamond, times, serif; } body { max-width: 50em; } .post { padding 2em 4em; } To my eye that improves things greatly. (I generally prefer serif to sans fonts, FWIW.)
- chuckadams 2y ago> Toto we're not in 96 dpi land any more. Unless you're banging directly on the framebuffer, logical pixels haven't been tied to device pixels for literally decades. CSS specifies pixels at 1/96 of an inch, a decision that goes all the way back to X11. 1rem == 16px, though this can be changed in CSS (just set font-size on the :root element) whereas you can typically only change pixel scaling in your display settings. So yes, using rems is better, but pixels are not going to get dramatically smaller on denser displays unless the device is deliberately scaling them down (which phones often do simply because they're designed to be read up-close anyway)
- sircastor 2y agoOver the last year I’ve gotten a couple of offers from PCB manufactures to make my projects in exchange for a review and visibility in my projects and on my site. It was tempting, but every time I thought about doing it, it felt off. I really like writing to readers and not obligating them to anything else. No sales push, no ads, no sign ups. It’s nice that it’s just what I wanted to share.
- tasuki 2y agoThe one annoyance inflicted is the pointless container-for-everything with rounded corners. It makes the web page optically smaller on mobile and seems to serve no purpose. Just extend the background to the very corners like hacker news does!
- oneeyedpigeon 2y agoSuch a good list, I may have to copy it for my own site and stuff it somewhere as a "colophon" of sorts. Maybe this kind of thing should even be a machine-readable standard... Rachel, I'm curious as to your mentions of 'old posts' that may not be compliant, e.g. missing an alt attribute - is this something you've considered scanning your html files for and fixing?
- lenkite 2y agoactually bookmarked since Rachel has mentioned several annoyances that it is easy to accidentally include even if you have the best of intentions. Wish she gave this in checklist and categorized form instead of long-text. LOL'ed at "dick bar" - seriously that thing is so annoying.
- ajb 2y agoIt's amazing to me what people tolerate, just because it doesn't seem like a human is doing it to us. If a door-to-door salesman was told to do the equivalent of this stuff, they'd be worried about being punched in the face.
- wruza 2y agoThe logic here is that it's you who come to visit, not them. But the next issue is that everyone agrees it's not normal for a private service either, even if it's free, and it should be disallowed. But laws don't work like that. We simply have no law systems that could manage that, nowhere on this planet.
- nicbou 2y agoImagine if people understood consent the way the tech industry does.
- ryandrake 2y agoIf the world was a nightclub, the tech industry would be a creepy guy who goes up to everyone and says "You're now dating me. [Accept or Try Again Later]"
- rchaud 2y agoWhile an interesting post because of the number of examples provided, this does read like somebody patting themselves on the back for building a website like it's 1995, when websites were not designed with the intention of making money or acting as a lead gen funnel. Let's have a look at the websites she's helped build at her job and see how many of those old web principles were applied.
- niutech 2y agoYou can make a profitable text-only website, e.g. Craigslist. But not everything on the web should be for profit.
- xnx 2y agoPreviously I've used the "disable styles" shortcut key in the Firefox web developer extension to make unfriendly websites more tolerable. Today, I wish Chrome had a shortcut key for enabling reader mode to do the same.
- fwn 2y agoI use this bookmarklet to disable all CSS styling: javascript:(function(){var styles=document.querySelectorAll('style,link[rel="stylesheet"]');styles.forEach(function(style){style.disabled=true;});document.body.querySelectorAll('*').forEach(function(el){el.style.cssText='';});})();
- joshka 2y agoFor the style of reading I normally do, this particular width is actively harmful to my reading comprehension. I would prefer just a bit wider text generally. This is something which the site does inflict on the reader. I agree that many sites are too wide in general, but this feels is too narrow by about 33% for my liking. Additionally the way that the background degrades to a border around the text when using dark reader also causes problems in a similar way (due to the interaction between jagged text and a strong vertical line. These are subtle points though, and I appreciate the many annoyances that are not there when reading Rachel's stuff.
- bshacklett 2y ago> I don't do some half-assed horizontal "progress bar" as you scroll down the page. Your browser probably /already/ has one of those if it's graphical. It's called the scroll bar. (See also: no animations.) Sadly, I would argue that this is inaccurate. Especially on mobile browsers, the prevalence of visible scroll bars seems to have dropped off a cliff. I'll happily excuse the progress bar, especially because this one can be done without JavaScript.
- philsnow 2y agoJS progress bars also generally show you your progress through the main-content div or whatever, so even if they have a particularly egregious footer (I've seen footers that are over 1000px tall, with embedded youtube videos), the progress through the actual content is still somewhat faithfully reported. Better would be to ditch the absurd footer, but still.
- donatj 2y agoAndroid Chrome at least has a scrollbar visible as you scroll
- winterbloom 2y agoDisagree with a few of these There's nothing wrong with progress. Expecting a user to have a JavaScript enabled browser is reasonable You don't expect an online retailer to accept mailed-in cash, do you?
- layer8 2y agoProgress bars are annoying because that’s what scroll bars are for, and because horizontal progress bars (a) have the wrong orientation and (b) look like a loading/download indicator.
- cpill 2y agoGee, if only there were a search engine that penalised pages and down ranked them for any of these annoyances, especially advertising, so one could get results that didn't annoy you when you visited them. oh wait, that would be a Google killer... don't want to go there...
- alex1138 2y agoI genuinely can't tell if this is sarcasm but yeah Kagi aims to do that
- aflukasz 2y agoNice read. I wish there was one more paragraph though: "I don't use trailing slashes in article URLs. Blog post is a file, not an index of a directory, so why pretend otherwise?" But then it's http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2025/01/04/cruft/ http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2025/01/04/cruft/ , so I guess they don't agree.
- tasn 2y agoBack in the day it used to be the way to do it. Web servers would serve example.com/foo/index.html when visiting example.com/foo/ and it was the easy way of not having example.com/foo.html as your URL. Later on Web servers made it easier to load foo.html for example.com/foo, but that wasn't always the case. It's been a couple of decades since I had to do it, but at least that's my memory on why I've been doing this since forever (including on newer websites, which is admittedly a mistake).
- layer8 2y agoI like it as a clear visual indication of where the URL ends. And a page often consists of more than just one file (images etc.) (the HTML portion of the page is just an implicit index.html in the directory), so it does make some sense.
- aflukasz 2y agoI like your argument about implicit index. But is an article an index to the attached media? Not even "just", but "at all"? Is this the right abstraction? Or do we have a better one, achievable by simply removing the trailing slash? We discuss this in the context of cruft, user friendliness, and selecting proper forms of expression, which the original article seems to be all about, by the way.
- layer8 2y agoMy point is that “an article” generally doesn’t consist of just a single file. Or maybe rather, that the distinction between a file or document and a folder isn’t necessarily meaningful. Physical “files” (i.e. on paper, as in a filing cabinet) actually commonly used to be folders. And there is little difference between a zip file (which are used for a number of popular document formats) and the unzipped directory it contains. Unlike in file systems, we don’t have the directory–file distinction on the web, from the user perspective. Everything shown in the browser window is a page. We might as well end them with a slash. If anything, there is a page–file distinction (page display in the browser vs. file download). I agree that URLs for single-file downloads (PDFs, images, whatever) should not have a trailing slash.
- watersb 2y agoObligatory take on web design process from The Oatmeal: https://theoatmeal.com/comics/design_hell https://theoatmeal.com/comics/design_hell . I'm not affiliated with the Toast. But invoking this cartoon, I occasionally describe a web design as "Toasty".
- Terr_ 2y agoAh, but that's just the stylistic churn. There's also monetization, illustrated by this dark and terrifying tale, best-viewed in a desktop browser for proper impact: https://modem.io/blog/blog-monetization/ https://modem.io/blog/blog-monetization/
- einpoklum 2y ago> I don't do some half-assed horizontal "progress bar" as you scroll down the > page. Your browser probably /already/ has one of those if it's graphical. > It's called the scroll bar. ... unless you use GTK, and then it hides the scroll bar because it's sooo clever and wants to bestow a "clean" interface upon you. Yes, I'm looking at you Firefox.
- okwhateverdude 2y ago`layout.testing.overlay-scrollbars.always-visible` in `about:config` is your friend.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kristianp 2y agoA web page can be looked at as a document or an application. Those publishers that use it as a document produce a wholly better experience for reading text. There's a lot of pressure to go down the application path, even Wikipedia has done it, which sucks big time.
- mleonhard 2y agoA couple more: - She doesn't change the color of the scroll handle to make it invisible. - She doesn't override my browser's font size, making the text too small to read. - She doesn't configure the page to <expletives deleted> disallow pinch-zooming on mobile.
- jeena 2y agoMy website is almost as polite, the differences are: - I don't store the date in the URL - I redirect you to https automatically, but perhaps I should rethink that - My Photos page lazy loads pictures, because it shows over 1000 thumbnails and it took very long to open it on the mobile phone - Some of my posts link to YouTube videos and embed that video, so this is what comes from a different origin Yeah, still pretty OK I think.
- yachtRockEye0 2y agoI really loved this. It fits me exactly and because of that I read to the bottom. Thank You
- pabs3 2y agoI just disable CSS/JS/etc, the web is much nicer when you do that.
- habosa 2y agoLegitimately curious, what interesting websites are usable without CSS?
- pabs3 2y agoA lot of the web is fine without CSS, many are improved by disabling CSS, especially ones that use CSS based paywalls. Also when disabling JavaScript you will get a lot of broken sites, unless you also disable CSS.
- tppiotrowski 2y agoAnother one: No "Sign in with your Google account" popup covering the upper right corner of the page
- thoughtpeddler 2y agoYou can disable this as a browser setting in some browsers (like Chrome). It was driving me nuts until I figured out I could just flip a global flag for it.
- Huhty 2y agoHow??
- knallfrosch 2y agoThere's probably a better way, but I use this graphical element zapper from Ublock Origin to hide distracting elements. Works wonders for sites that I visit regularly. StackOverflow: Do I need related posts? The left sidebar (whatever it is they have there, I have forgotten already)? Their footer?
- Animats 2y agoShe also avoided the other extreme - white monospace text on a black background. Some people seem to think that looks cool.
- dinozarw 2y agomax-width: 600px; That's one annoyance inflicted on me.
- ghxst 2y agoSomething I wish more site owners would consider is that if you expose endpoints to the internet, expect users to interact with them however they choose. Instead of adding client-side challenges that disrupt the user experience, focus on building a secure backend. And please, stop shipping business logic to the frontend - especially if you're going to obfuscate it so badly that it ends up breaking on non-Chrome browsers because that's the only browser you test with. Of course, there are exceptions. If you genuinely need to use a WAF or add client-side challenges, please test your settings properly. There are websites out there that completely break on Linux simply because they are using Akamai with settings that just don't match the real world and were only tested on Mac or Windows. A little more care in testing could go a long way toward making your site accessible to everyone.
- cookiengineer 2y agoThis. My favorite experience was trying to file taxes on Linux in Germany. Turns out the backend on ELSTER had written code that if Chrome and Linux then store to test account. It wasn't possible to file taxes on Linux for over 6 months until they fixed it when they went online as a mandatory state-funded web service. I can't even comprehend who writes code like that. Took me also a very long while to explain to the BKA that I did not try to hack them, and that they are just very incompetent people working at DATEV.
- eviks 2y ago> I can't even comprehend who writes code like that. The government. Case in point...
- verzali 2y agoIt sounds like the easiest solution would be to install another browser (e.g. Firefox) until they fixed the issue. If it is only the combination of Chrome and Linux that is the problem, that is.
- defanor 2y agoBeing nitpicky, and since the article itself focuses on things not inflicted on users, here are a few things it still inflicts on users: - Changing line-height. - Changing fonts (or trying to, if it is allowed in a web browser). - Changing colors (likewise). - Changing body's max-width, margins, paddings. - Adding a mostly useless header. I find these less annoying than the ones listed in the article, and they are easily mitigated by the reader view, disabled CSS, or custom global CSS, but there they are.
- emsixteen 2y agoI think this is beyond being nitpicky.
- handity 2y agoI used to agree with you, but a pure text web looks like Gemini, which I abandoned after a few days of getting lost in endless identical looking blogs. There is no reason that websites shouldn't have room for some creative expression. For as long as writing has existed, images, fonts, spacing, embellishment, borders, and generally every imaginable axis has been used as additional expression, beyond the literal meaning of the text. The body width is necessary because web browsers have long since abandoned any pretense of developing html for the average joe. It is normal to use web browsers maximized, so without limiting the body width the text is ridiculously long and uncomfortable to read.
- elric 2y agoMy favourite pet peeve is opening an interesting looking link in a new tab, and then when I finally get around to looking at the tab, it's just a giant overlay with a prompt for an email address, with no hint of what I was actually trying to read. Letting marketing folks on the internet was a mistake.
- atotic 2y agoHas anyone built a search engine that indexes only "no annoyances" web sites?
- darekkay 2y agoKagi Small Web (the index is open source) comes to my mind, even though it doesn't specifically focus on UI annoyances. https://blog.kagi.com/small-web https://blog.kagi.com/small-web
- cocoflunchy 2y agoNot exactly this but https://search.marginalia.nu/ https://search.marginalia.nu/ will probably return sites that match these criteria
- voidUpdate 2y agoI do my best to follow these as much as possible, though I think I am still doing a couple. I just haven't updated my own website in quite a while :/
- brazzy 2y agoThat's a lot of words to say "I don't need to make money from this, and really only want to publish some texta". Everything follows from that, but not just in a bad, dark-pattern profit-optimizing way. If you provide a paid service, you need auth, and then you damn well better use HTTPS. If you have anything more complex or interactive than text-publishing, you'll quickly run into absurd limitations without cookies and JavaScript. And animations and things like sticky headers can genuinely improve the usability.
- cannibalXxx 2y ago[dead]
- arkh 2y ago> Now about SSL/TLS, we programmers are often forced to do this because there are many users who, when faced with the absence of the padlock on the page, don't even bother to continue for fear of having their data stolen. I got to experience this last week: some family member uses the gmail app to consult hotmail emails. Suddenly the app started asking to reenter login information: the message looked like a fishing mail. When you clicked on it it popped what looked like the outlook openID login page but without any address bar shown. Is it the app? Some webpage? Looks like fishing. Perfect job from the UI team: either you don't update your credential because it really looks like a fishing attempt or you get trained to use those credentials in random apps / website.
- trollbridge 2y agoOne of my gripes with venture capital is that, were I to accept a large amount, I would be required to do all of those annoyances as part of the marketing plan they would impose on me. And I feel a lot of those measure have been unnecessary - thinking back to time at enterprise software product vendors, they had myriads of those kind of annoyances to track "engagement" on their page. The actual customers? Basically the big banks, in one case. Just how much were all those marketing/tracking cookies and scripts doing to secure those sales leads? Each bank had, essentially, its own dedicated salesperson/account manager - I don't think any bank is picking a vendor because one website had more marketnig tracking scripts on it than another.
- sharpshadow 2y agoRecently some webpages started failing with an JavaScript error message, something is not supported even if my JS is activated. Probably the device which I used was „outdated“. Obviously the webpage and its full text content is shown to me for 3s before the error message appears and blocks the access.
- chrsw 2y agoIt's great that some people are fighting back against this. But it's too late. The modern web is unusable without browser extensions or ad/annoyance blockers.
- theandrewbailey 2y agoI agree with pretty much everything (and have implemented my own blog like it), but I would like to expand on a few things: > I don't load the page in parts as you scroll it. It loads once and then you have it. Lazy loaded images are helpful for page performance reasons, as done by <img loading="lazy">. I have a script that flips one to eager (so it loads immediately) every few seconds depending on page load speed, so that it you leave the page alone for a while, it fully loads. > I don't put godawful vacuous and misleading clickbait "you may be interested in..." boxes of the worst kind of crap on the Internet at the bottom of my posts, or anywhere else for that matter. Most of the posts on my blog[0] are whatever videogame that I was just playing. Often, I'll play through installments in a series, or mention one game while talking about another. While I litter the text with links back to previous entries, I feel that it would be helpful to have a collection of these near the bottom of the page. How else would you know that I've written about the sequel? (I don't like to go back old posts and add links to newer stuff like that.) I have a "you might be interested in" section. My algorithm: do a search on the post title (up to the first number or colon, but can be customized), then add recent posts from the category you're looking at. Limit 6. I feel that genuinely shows everything relevant that I got and not be 'misleading' or 'clickbait'. > I don't force people to have Javascript to read my stuff. Agreed! JS should be used to enhance the experience, not be the experience. This mindset is so baked into how I write it, that most of my blog's JS functions have "enhance" in them. > I don't force you to use SSL/TLS to connect here. Use it if you want, but if you can't, hey, that's fine, too. Didn't we learn anything from Snowden? The NSA has recorded your receipt of this message. [0] https://theandrewbailey.com/ https://theandrewbailey.com/
- LtWorf 2y agoI was reading the pypi blog on my tablet the other day and it had an annoying "back to top" popup that kept covering the text I was trying to read.
- 0x38B 2y agoMaybe it's a combination of my Framework's 2256x1504 resolution and the 2x scaling I'm using, but some web pages' "dick bars" cover a full third of the screen - it's infuriating. It makes sites like Rachel's doubly refreshing (1). 1: And Hacker News!
- thenthenthen 2y agoWould be hilarious if the page hijacked your history (breaking the back button)