9 ms·
Hacker in Snowflake extortions may be a U.S. soldier
- antihero 2y agoCouldn't literally all of this just be a bunch of misdirection?
- mikeyouse 2y agoIn theory, sure, in reality it's almost always much more benign and they have terrible Opsec over time that allows people to piece together their identity. Especially if they reuse usernames across services.
- JohnMakin 2y agoIt's always crappy opsec that gets people otherwise very savvy.
- raffraffraff 2y agoKinda like how the big mastermind criminals like Capone get away with murder and racketeering but get fucked on tax evasion. Reading this guy's posts, his ego is the biggest issue, and it will be his downfall. The "I literally can't get caught" mentality inevitably leads to carelessness and blabbermouthing.
- brcmthrowaway 2y agoIt appears the government at times invents laws so they can go after criminal gangs (see RICO)
- kortilla 2y agoThat’s a little different. It wasn’t that Capone couldn’t handle taxes, it was that until that point nobody used it as a serious mechanism to take town criminals. It was only validated as a good approach by the Supreme Court a few years before. In fact, one of the primary pieces of evidence of his tax evasion were from communications from his lawyer about how much tax to pay to make his tax history legit in light of the recent effectiveness of tax convictions. Now major criminals launder money to avoid that.
- bitnasty 2y agoMaybe he “can’t get caught” because he is state-sanctioned.
- duxup 2y agoI feel like leaving a bunch of misdirection would also risk potentially just leave real traces behind that in some ways. At least in my mind leaving some false trails behind, when I run through scenarios, seems like it could leave actual trails / to the point of not being worth the extra risk.
- brookst 2y agoYeah. If you have a choice of giving an adversary no information or false information, no information seems safer. The choice of false information is information. Same way that people are terrible at picking random numbers and fraudsters are often caught because they avoid round numbers.
- antihero 2y agoIt would make sense if doing something illegal to do the former, but also leave "slip ups" that are complete red herrings, create trails to people that seem like opsec fails but are actually just framing others, etc. All about plausible deniability. Layers and layers and layers of dead ends that seem real. In this way, if you do actually slip up, it becomes near impossible to distinguish the real slip-ups with the orchestrated ones.
- brookst 2y agoThe problem is that false “slip ups” provide information. Sure, you waste investigator’s time, but once they rule out the false lead they have a bunch of information: - if the false slip-up used only public information about, you likely don’t have access to confidential information about that space. If it used confidential information, you do. - The geography and demographics of the false lead are probably not near-misses. The point of misdirection is to misdirect, so you likely won’t frame a coworker that will bring investigators to your own door. - Any mistakes in the false slip-up, from spelling to factual to timing, may reveal info. IMO this is a “too clever by half” scenario: leaving any trace at all is information. Leaving none is wiser. Example: you’re a master hacker. You’re going to repeatedly access a compromised system. Is it better to set an alarm for 3am each time to suggest you’re in a different time zone, or to use a RNG to close an alarm time? I say the RNG is better. Using 3am gives psychographics. Random isn’t clear if there’s any planning at all, or if you travel, etc.
- alsetmusic 2y ago> Kiberphant0m denied being in the U.S. Army or ever being in South Korea, and said all of that was a lengthy ruse designed to create a fictitious persona. > > “Epic opsec troll,” they claimed. If this were really a fictitious persona meant to lead investigators away from their true identity, they'd never admit to such. This sounds like someone trying to deflect upon being found out. I'd wager that this person is going to be caught. Krebs has an image of a mind-map at the end of the article showing links between the aliases.
- rudolph9 2y agoOr it’s part of the troll.
- uoaei 2y agoBothsidesism has crept into ... US counterintel agitprop?
- horeszko 2y ago> Kiberphant0m denied being in the U.S. Army or ever being in South Korea, and said all of that was a lengthy ruse designed to create a fictitious persona. “Epic opsec troll,” they claimed. This is called a "double cover story", a classic deflection when someone is caught or exposed.
- asimjalis 2y agoIt could be a triple cover story. The faked double cover story is meant to deflect.
- tedunangst 2y agoMaybe even skipping the quadruple cover story and going straight to the quintuple. A true pro.
- function_seven 2y ago
- gregw2 2y agoAny insight based on histogram of the timing of this person's posts, particularly ones responding to a just slightly earlier post? (ie was clearly awake and not an artificially-delayed response). Krebs knows about this timezone analysis technique, wonder if he didn't check this or it was inconclusive?
- t-3 2y agoIs that effective for people who aren't literally being paid a salary to do this stuff 9-5? A lot of people who spend too much time on computers have totally out of wack sleep schedules that would look like they're operating from very different timezones.
- alwayslikethis 2y agoYou can also schedule your posts, commits, etc to go out at some fixed hours each day.
- sundarurfriend 2y agoYou can, but a lot of these pattern analyses work out because people get sloppy and overconfident over time, and don't use these measures even if their lives are on the line.
- aaron695 2y agoPolice raids in long sieges happen ~ 3:30-4:30am People have wacky schedules but it's about when you never work You could do an analysis on HN comments. It's very hard to fake, you'd have to schedule on all channels. For instance don't look at all of a users HN comment's just ones posted less than a hour after it was on the front page. I always set the time zone on my PC to a fake one. It cause's havoc sometimes and it's not even close to enough. It's hard once someone is after you.
- duxup 2y ago>‘BUTTHOLIO’ These guys always seem to have the most stereotypical or corny hacker handles. Is that expected / desirable in that community?
- taspeotis 2y agoI believe the hacker known as 4chan once explained they choose their handles “for the lulz”
- Apocryphon 2y agoLegion of Doom / Masters of Deception would like a word.
- tedunangst 2y agoPhiber Optik just doesn't have the same haha you said peepee vibe.
- Apocryphon 2y agoI do think it’s funny how that might be a character revealing moment, suggesting the hacker is Gen X or at least elder millennial age.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 2y agoI did toy with the idea of trying do analysis of HN aliases and keywords. It never went anywhere, because I forgot about it, but a longer weekend is coming:D But yeah, language betrays, who we are in references alone.
- gopher_space 2y agoThere's no way you could determine how old a person is or what technologies they enjoyed way back in college solely from a username.
- ChumpGPT 2y agoSeems like the guy has been fucking around for a while. No wonder none of our allies want to share intelligence or plans with us. The US Military is a liability when it comes to keeping shit secret, they leak like a sieve. They need to get a handle on this shit, who knows what this guy has given to the Russians or Chinese.
- 6510 2y ago"pay-to-play"
- excalibur 2y ago> Immediately after Kiberphant0m logged on to the Dstat channel, another user wrote “hi buttholio,” to which Kiberphant0m replied with an affirmative greeting “wsg,” or “what’s good.” It's kind of unfortunate for him that he didn't do a better job of referencing Beavis and Butthead. If his username was "Cornholio" or even "Bungholio", it could read as someone directly referencing the show and potentially unrelated to the other account, making his deniability a bit more plausible.
- boomskats 2y agoA true opsec troll is saving those references for the final standoff, for when they start really threatening him.
- red-iron-pine 2y agoyeah that's 3 or 4 layers in. until then convince them you're Iranian and Chinese first
- kordlessagain 2y agoThey have gone from "I literally can't get caught" to "Oh no, everyone on Hacker News is discussing my l33t hacker identity... checks notes ...Buttholio. Perhaps I should have workshopped that name a bit more."
- fnord77 2y agoBeing a high-stakes criminal is too difficult. One slip-up and you're compromised. There's a million opportunities for slip ups and there's a million opportunities for investigators to get lucky.
- alwayslikethis 2y agoTrue, but you only hear about the ones who slipped up. I wonder what is the actual proportion of criminals being caught due to poor opsec.
- brookst 2y agoTo turn it around: what percentage of people are capable of perfect opsec forever?
- flextheruler 2y agoFor internet crimes? Almost none in perpetuity. I’d think you’d need to go off the grid totally for a few years and come back without any reference to a prior life. For physical crime, my gut says quite a few people have avoided identification for decades until they were essentially caught by turning themselves in. Ted Kaczynski comes to mind, but there must be a few others. Perfect OPSEC to me, means near total isolation from socialization. Not something most people are capable of. If you’re a professional criminal of any kind you weigh the risks knowing that perfection is impossible. The government is a business with a monopoly on violence. The goal is to keep their ROI for catching you as low as possible. Every single man hour spent finding you is costing money and there’s a man upstairs who wants to see some results that reflect the money spent. Once you understand that premise, it’s easy to understand the why and how criminals are caught. The ones who are caught are always the ones who don’t know when to fold. Always the ones not to cash in and retire. The ones who get away with it, they fold they retire and society forgets about them and the ROI drops precipitously on catching them. Research statistics on cold cases.
- ethbr1 2y agoThere's a line at the beginning of Ocean's 11 to the effect of "the house always wins in the long run... unless you bet it all on a great hand, win, and then walk away."
- juunpp 2y agoI guess we'll soon find out how well the NSA normalizes its databases. Bring on that schema, folks.
- teractiveodular 2y ago> “Type ‘kiberphant0m’ on google with the quotes,” Buttholio told another user. “I’ll wait. Go ahead. Over 50 articles. 15+ telecoms breached. I got the IMSI number to every single person that’s ever registered in Verizon, Tmobile, ATNT and Verifone.” SBF levels of self-pwning right there. When, not if, they catch him, the Feds are going to hang this clown out to dry.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y agoI'd rather see them hang out to dry the 15+ telecoms who gave away "the IMSI number to every single person that's ever registered in..." because doing so was cheaper than investing in security.
- atoav 2y agoThe only data you can't leak is the data you don't have. Therefore some data should either not be stored at all or deleted after it served its purpose.
- dfedbeef 2y agoProbably hard for a telecom company to not keep IMSI -> account association somewhere
- mschuster91 2y agoYeah, in separate databases on separate systems. The network plane of a phone provider should only be able to access a database mapping IMSI -> account ID, and the billing/customer service department should only be able to access a database mapping account ID -> actual account data. Unfortunately, anything involving phones is based on literally decades of stuff that was made in a time where every participant in the network was trusted by default, and bringing up the legacy compatibility stuff to modern standards is all but impossible.
- 2y ago
- markus_zhang 2y agoMy two cents: - The "hacker" (I'm reluctant to use this term" seems to be too high profile for some reasons; - We should discard Telegram
- shdh 2y agoWhat does "discarding" Telegram mean?
- markus_zhang 2y agoWe should not use Telegram -- sort of. I wonder whether Signal is better.
- xvector 2y agoSignal is absolutely better. Telegram is e2ee in name only
- autoexec 2y agoNot recommending Telegram, but personally, I suspect that signal is compromised. They've been permanently storing sensitive user data in the cloud for a long time time (https://community.signalusers.org/t/proper-secure-value-security-pins-are-too-easy-to-brute-force-sgx-is-not-reliable-enough/15096 https://community.signalusers.org/t/proper-secure-value-secu...) but the very first sentence of their Terms and Privacy page still claims "Signal is designed to never collect or store any sensitive information." and they've been asked multiple times but refuse to update their privacy policy. I suspect that lie is being kept there as a giant dead canary. Making the change to start keeping exactly the data that the government has been asking them to turn over isn't a very good look. "Securing" user's data with something as week as a PIN isn't great either. https://www.vice.com/en/article/pkyzek/signal-new-pin-feature-worries-cybersecurity-experts https://www.vice.com/en/article/pkyzek/signal-new-pin-featur... Note that the "solution" of disabling pins mentioned at the end of the article was later shown to not prevent the collection and storage of sensitive user data. It was just giving users a false sense of security. To this day there is no way to opt out of the data collection.
- assanineass 2y agoThey already arrested them right?
- sans_souse 2y agoNo they arrested two others.
- IAmGraydon 2y agoThis seems like it would be rather easy for the government to narrow down. Check the logs of who applied for an NSA job on or around the date the screenshot was posted and cross reference any that are/were located in South Korea. I would think that would produce a rather short list that a bit more investigation would crack. The guy seems arrogant, and arrogant = sloppy. He'll get caught.
- readyplayernull 2y agoHe knows he's about to get caught, reason why he hurried to knock NSA's door. They might let him in after all.
- lukan 2y agoBut probably after they arrested him, to help with negotiations. And to pop that bubble of false confidence. The way he acted, would be a very red flag for me, if I were to hire him. Maybe skillfull, but careless. And that is not acceptable in that line of work. (Neither it is in the military)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ilaksh 2y agoYou might be able to get a rough show size and height/weight range from that photo.
- lph 2y agoI wonder how unique those floor tile patterns are? If that's taken on a military base in Korea, it might be possible to find the exact location of the photo.
- hn_user82179 2y agowhat a great article, I loved seeing the links that Krebs (?)/Unit 221B (?) dug up and all the info they managed to connect. It felt like I was reading a detective story. It sounds like this guy is doomed, the NSA application date alone basically identifies him
- Tepix 2y agoIf you have enough data, i wonder how much of this digging can be automated these days with good LLM prompts. Doing it manually is very time-consuming.
- jamestimmins 2y agoI think this whenever I read a modern detective novel (Bosch). So much of their work seems to be looking up data from different databases and trying to make connections or recognize patterns. I assume the FBI or whomever has automated this to some degree already, and I really hope someone does a great writeup of how LLMs/agents can do even more.
- CharlieDigital 2y agoThe real work doesn't happen in the LLM. Having worked with LLMs over the past year+ trying to get them to do useful things in various contexts, the real work is typically pretty boring data acquisition (e.g. scraping) + ETL and then making that data available to the LLM.
- polyvisual 2y ago221B is 221B Baker Street, where Sherlock Holmes lived.
- benreesman 2y agoJesus. Let’s tick another box on our late capitalism bingo card: our soldiers are so desperate for cash and so cynical around institutions that they’ve started doing mercenary crime. I can’t be the only person who has read of such situations throughout history.
- kortilla 2y agoWhat does this have to do with late capitalism? This has happened all throughout history and you just said you read about it yourself
- benreesman 2y agoThe root of all failure at the level of the society is the fungibility of inherited wealth into political power, which rapidly gets deployed to impoverish everyone else including soldiers, and on its way it tramples institutions once revered.
- laborcontract 2y agothey could have just had an alcoholic parent.
- benreesman 2y agoI’m a pretty easy going guy in general but others might take offense.
- causal 2y ago> The root of all failure at the level of the society is ... Or maybe the real root is our tendency to fixate on simplistic reductions.
- 542354234235 2y agoSoldiers have a guaranteed paycheck, food, and housing, are not "at will" and can't be fired without cause and a formal process, and have "free" healthcare. It is one of the most socialist jobs you can have in the United States.
- Simon_ORourke 2y agoDoesn't that just mean they won't ever to subject to prosecution by the International Criminal Court?
- paganel 2y agoThis Krebs guy is a doxxer through and through, I wouldn't take anything that he writes down as being serious. If he thinks he knows something and he has palpable proof for it then he should contact the relevant authorities.
- richbell 2y ago> This Krebs guy is a doxxer through and through, I wouldn't take anything that he writes down as being serious. Can you explain your definition of "doxxing" and why you believe that means nothing he writes is serious?
- paganel 2y ago> Can you explain your definition of "doxxing" Revealing people names and addresses and implying that they have done something illegal, while the person doing that (this Krebs guy) does not represent the Law/the relevant authorities. See the Boston bombings debacle on this very website. > why you believe that means nothing he writes is serious? See the Boston bombings debacle on this very website.
- mtlynch 2y ago
- Bengalilol 2y agoI don't get how such people could be as verbose as shown in this quite precise article. And I'm not even getting into the idea that he could be a US soldier ...
- red-iron-pine 2y agohe's not. it's gear you can order online or get at any local surplus store. I'm not even in the US and a quick look shows it's trivial to get. it's another layer of obfuscation. strippers telling you their name is April (but then whispering to you that their real name is Stefani)... but their real name is actually Angela, and it's just another deflection to keep off the stalkers. same idea with IT OPSEC
- cedws 2y agoIt's a good thing that independent cybercriminals like this are so arrogant that they make the most basic opsec mistakes and expose themselves.
- victorbjorklund 2y agoIt is always really bad opsec that gets them. Always.
- 0xDEAFBEAD 2y agoI noticed he seems to have posted a photo of his camouflage uniform? Pretty sure those are unique to every soldier...
- bityard 2y agoNo, they are a very standard pattern.
- andrewflnr 2y agoMaybe GP was thinking about lining up specific pattern features with e.g. pockets and seams to identify a particular uniform.
- 0xDEAFBEAD 2y agoCan you show me an image where 2 soldiers, both wearing fatigues, have an identical camouflage pattern? Every image I find on Google Images has a distinct pattern per soldier.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- therealfiona 2y agoIt isn't a per-soldier thing. It's just pieces of fabric that are all cut differently. They aren't out there making sure one person has a specific pattern that matches every single one of their uniforms, and doesn't match someone else's. I get the line of thinking, and I tend to agree that if they really wanted to, they could figure out a way to match the pattern of a uniform to the person if the person had published a picture of themselves wearing the article on something like Facebook. But that's a big if. When I was in the military, I think I posted like one picture of me in camo and the resolution was so low that you probably didn't have enough detail to come to any conclusions.
- 0xDEAFBEAD 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bityard 2y agoSome serious testicular fortitude in that guy. If a civilian gets caught doing something illegal, they are entitled to a fair trial with a jury of their peers. If a military member gets caught doing the same thing, the court martial is a mere formality, they just more or less go straight to jail for a very long time.
- brcmthrowaway 2y agoWait, you give up civil rights to be in the military? Is this outlined to people when they sign up?
- LeftHandPath 2y agoYes. See the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Code_of_Military_Justice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Code_of_Military_Justi...
- throwup238 2y agoYes it’s made very clear in the enlistment contract (the military equivalent of an employment agreement) that they’re waiving certain rights and submit themselves to military jurisdiction for offenses covered under the UCMJ. This topic has been litigated a lot in front of SCOTUS like with Standard Form 86 (where one waives the right to free speech for security clearance) so there’s certain language they have to contain to be valid.
- gzer0 2y agoWow, TIL that if you're drafted (and forced to serve against your will), the government can subject you to military law (UCMJ), which limits many of your rights, like the right to a civilian trial by jury. Courts have upheld this because Congress has the power to regulate the military, but it still feels like a huge shift in rights for someone forced to serve. It feels... intuitively unjust that the government could compel service and then subject individuals to a system that limits their constitutional rights.
- 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Reaganpacco 2y ago[dead]