16 ms·
Scientists are learning why ultra-processed foods are bad
- cupantae 2y agoSummary: we still don’t know why, but definitely don’t eat UPFs.
- goles 2y agohttps://archive.is/EfaFI https://archive.is/EfaFI
- jjtheblunt 2y agotldr hint: the last 5 paragraphs get to the point, and are worth reading.
- ramon156 2y ago[flagged]
- snapcaster 2y agoCan you say more? Why?
- kkaske 2y agoBoth articles are the same. Right? Why is it silly?
- dukeofdoom 2y agoDon't they add food coloring from ground bugs sometimes. In case of sausage they add preservatives to make it last longer. Actual poison if you were just to eat a lot of it. Generally companies are liable if they make you sick right after eating their product. So they do everything they can to prevent that. Nobody is going to held liable if they give you cancer 10 years down the line. Super hard to prove. So not a worry for them. Backlash after the failed covid vaccine makes some reform more likely now.
- psunavy03 2y agoWhy do we need these kinds of sensationalist names for things? Why is it so important that they be "ultra-processed" foods? Can't they just be "overprocessed" or perhaps use some other more neutral term? It's like the 90s when everything had to be "EXTREME!!"
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- snapcaster 2y agoI think it's partly due to the people (this site is full of them) that would read any other term and go "what is processing? Cooking and cutting is processing hurr durr"
- cynicalpeace 2y agoI have had this exact argument on HN at least a half dozen times.
- snapcaster 2y agoyeah people still do it but at least adding the "ultra" indicates is not something a person cooking for their family would be doing to food
- tjpnz 2y agoUntil you add ketchup.
- nightski 2y agoIt's just as dumb though because the act of processing doesn't really mean anything.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoIf it didn't mean anything then why the findings in the article?
- csours 2y agoNobody knows = there is wide disagreement https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33309818/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33309818/ My personal feeling is that I can eat like a king every day of the week. If I only had access to one kind of dessert, I'd be fine. I'd get tired of it. Oh, vanilla ice cream again. But we have access to a wide variety of highly palatable foods, each with distinct flavor profiles; and advertisements reminds us how much better we'll feel after a snack! Big recommend for Guyenet's "The Hungry Brain" (randomly chosen podcast interview) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fl1g8l-MdZk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fl1g8l-MdZk
- thrawa1235432 2y agoI always take "Nobody knows!" "Nobody could have predicted!" as a warning for either something really dumb, biased, or uneducated take is about to follow.
- hunglee2 2y agoSurely not that mysterious - the adulterants added processed foods in order preserve it longer for the shelf, disguise the looks, mask the taste or simply bulk it out for max profit generally do not provide additional nutritional value
- tpm 2y agoSimply not providing nutritional value would be neutral from health perspective. We are looking for something that provides negative effects, either direct (something toxic) or indirect (like causing us to eat more which causes obesity...).
- Kirby64 2y agoFrom the article: > Even if the results show conclusively that processing, and not just nutrients, leads to poor health, policymakers will face another difficulty: the definition of upfs remains woolly. The Nova classification has no tolerance at all for artificial ingredients. The mere presence of a chemical additive classifies a food as a upf, regardless of the amount. This can lead to confusing health outcomes—a recent observational study from Harvard University, for example, found that whereas some upfs, such as sweetened drinks and processed meats, were associated with a higher risk of heart disease, others, like breakfast cereals, bread and yogurt, were instead linked to lower risks for cardiovascular disease. Dr Astrup warns that the current classification risks “demonising” a lot of healthy food. Insights from Dr Hall’s work could therefore help refine the understanding of upfs, paving the way for more balanced and useful guidelines. This to me is the most damning evidence against the current classification of 'ultra-processed foods' being absolutely, totally worthless. I look forward to the study noted in the article comparing high-density vs. hyper-palatable. I strongly suspect the study will show its a combinatorial effect... but we'll see.
- snapcaster 2y agoI agree it leaves a lot to be desired but i wouldn't say it's totally worthless. It's clearly identifying something and even a poorly understood adherence to avoiding UPFs would likely make the average person healthier. Overall though we obviously need to come up with better terms for this
- Kirby64 2y agoAdherence to avoiding UPFs, by the current Nova classification, would lead to most people having to radically change their diets, assuming you actually follow the Nova classification of UPFs to a tee. And assuming they're already reasonably healthy, there would be no meaningful health benefits I suspect.
- OutOfHere 2y agoThat's precisely what the food product industry wants you to believe.
- HPsquared 2y agoIs there even a proven causal link? It could just be another case of "poor people do thing X, and poor people have higher mortality".
- hyeonwho4 2y agoThe highlight of this article is the Randomized controlled trial: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31105044/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31105044/ So yes, causal for obesity.
- taeric 2y agoLooking at the amount of processed food available in Japan, it is hard to think it is just the processed food that is to blame. I think it is a cheap observation, such that I expect people to push back on me, but it is hard to ignore portion sizes. Will try and take a dive on some of the data around that. But a personal level, it is hard to grapple with the fact that I just got less food per place that I went. And it is frustrating, as getting the food, I would want a large burger/sandwhich/whatever. But waiting a small amount of time after a small snack/meal works.
- burnte 2y agoThere have been experiments that control for portion size, processed food still spikes glucose more, etc.
- taeric 2y agoIsn't that some of what this article was challenging?
- burnte 2y agoI don't believe so, I felt it was we know it does just not why yet.
- taeric 2y agoI mean, that is the headline. The thrust of the article was that a lot of the common things people offer for why don't have any real evidence. All we seem to have is that people eat more calories when doing processed foods. Specifically, the RCT showing that people eating ultra processed foods eat an average of 500 more calories per day is what I was looking at. Seems to basically align far more heavily with it being the volume of food than it is other qualities. Though, my memory was stronger in what that paragraph claimed.
- nightski 2y agoI honestly think stress and work obsession along with sedentary lifestyles has a lot more to do with anything health related than ultra processed foods.
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoThe end of the article gets the point. The problem isn't that food is processed; the problem is that extremely processed foods are much harder to moderate yourself on and present a much, much more appealing food to overeat on, which in turn causes health problems and is why so many people are so fat, along with other factors like people being lonely and depressed, and food being a quick and cheap way to make yourself happy, the broad availability of unhealthy food and the sometimes restricted availability of healthy food, the fact that people are too damn busy to find time in their schedules to prepare their own food, etc. etc. Which itself ties into other systemic incentives. Processed food is shelf stable, fresh often is not, so it's friendlier to logistical systems that deliver everything we eat, which means less of it gets wasted, which means the prices are lower and availability is virtually guaranteed. Put simply: it is far easier and more profitable to ship, stock, and sell potato chips than it is to sell potatoes, and because everything in our system is profit driven, the better things map onto that, the more they occur. Ergo we're drowning in potato chips and still starving.
- thrawa1235432 2y agoIn that case we can just take Ozempic or whatever guys! Just kidding, no that's not the problem. The problem is processing destroys/alter many molecules we do not even know about or know it's full "purpose"/role in nutrition and digestion. The commonly talked about vitamins and RDA and such are just the bare minimum so a broad population does not get sick, but does not mean optimum health for a given individual. Cf. eating 10mg of iron in a steak, readily bioavailable vs eating 10mg of iron from cereal. One is bound in easily digestible compounds, the other is iron shavings or rust. e.g The British Navy discovering that scurvy is fixed by eating fresh food; ensuring to add citrus to sailors diets, then forgetting about how it worked. Then retrying citrus, but cooking it one using copper vessels, which destroy much of the vitamin C content.
- jumpoddly 2y agoExcessively editorialized headline for the post to the point of trying to make the opposite point as the original.
- jaggederest 2y agoSo even beyond the factors in the article (calorie density and hyper-palatability) there's other contributing factors in processed food. First of all, the processing itself introduces several factors: mechanical and heat energy changing the structure (but not composition) of the food, usually into smaller particle sizes; and the potential introduction of new contaminants - one that has been discussed before is lithium grease[1]. The other thing that processed food does, partially discussed in the article, is sit on shelves much longer. I wonder whether we've detected the acute effects of spoilage (e.g. food-borne illness) but missed some chronic effect. [1]: https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2024/07/27/lithium-hypothesis-of-obesity-recap/ https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2024/07/27/lithium-hypothesis-...
- julianeon 2y agoThis is a great point and one that I think would change many minds. If you say "more calories" or "hyperpalatable", many people will think "I can control that with portion control - I just won't binge them." But if you say "it changes the physical form of the food" or "it has contaminants in it," it's clear that no amount of portion control can fix that.
- Dylan16807 2y agoWell that depends on what the form change does. Most form changes are just fine. And whether portion control can fix contamination depends on what the contaminant is. A lot of things are only potentially harmful above a certain level.
- jaggederest 2y ago> Well that depends on what the form change does. Most form changes are just fine. Agreed, I just think that e.g. mastication probably has more subtle effects than just breaking up food, so I wonder about peanut butter vs peanuts kind of effects on the human body. > A lot of things are only potentially harmful above a certain level. I question this. I think the more we see trace effects, the more we realize that there are things in the built environment that are problematic in parts per billions and parts per millions that we wouldn't have ever thought that from acute exposure testing. I think a lot of our current understanding of GRAS and friends is pretty badly flawed - obviously a lot of substances aren't doing massive harm, but there's a lot that's suspect still.
- cynicalpeace 2y agoSeems pretty obvious to me. Humans didn't have factories until a couple hundred years ago. This means we are not adapted to factory made food. This entire debate is hilariously overcomplicated by smarty pants "show me the study" or "aren't cooked carrots processed?" types. 40-60% of nutritional studies cannot be replicated. It's called the "replication crisis". Google it. Rules of thumb are greatly underrated on HN. Here's one: if it couldn't be made outside of a factory, don't eat it.
- makeitdouble 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_nature https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_nature
- cynicalpeace 2y agoGood thing I didn't make that argument :)
- makeitdouble 2y agoI'm not sure what argument you were making then. Assuming your point isn't that you used the "factory" terminology instead of calling it "unnatural", so it's not an appeal to nature. I'd actually be pleased to dig on the deeper part you were pointing to. PS: the "we are not adapted" to part of your post is the crux of it in my eyes: we're not adapted to a lot of things but that doesn't make it good or bad or problematic. We're not adapted to receiving MRIs, wearing glasses or looking at imaginary landscapes in VR, and that's totally fine in my book .
- cynicalpeace 2y agoIf I wanted to say unnatural I would have said unnatural. I said factory. Factories come with a mountain of lubricants, plastics, metals, agents, colorings, flavorings, etc that are poisonous. They are poisonous because we were not evolved to consume them. That's just 1 of many reasons factory made foods are bad. > we're not adapted to a lot of things but that doesn't make it good or bad or problematic These things would be good for you in spite of the fact that you're not adapted to it. There are far more many things that you are not adapted to that would kill you. Your list is hilariously arguable (VR might actually be bad for you lol). My list would consist of basic inarguable things like, fish can breathe underwater naked, humans cannot, and my list would be inexhaustibly long.
- ptero 2y agoTLDR: According to the article, people eat more calories when they eat ultra-processed foods. The reason is unknown, one possibility is more calories per bite as manufacturers remove water and some other ingredients during processing. Overall, a pretty underwhelming article. Not surprising, unfortunately -- I have been subscribing to the Economist for over 15 years since late 1990s until the slow erosion of quality made me drop it.
- thrawa1235432 2y agoYes, I agree with you, the Economist from the 90s was a different animal. If you ask me the above article is just paid shilling for Ozempic et. al. Not directly obviously, but in the mindset and viewpoint it wants to develop in readers
- swasheck 2y agoultra-processed people by chris van tulleken hypothesizes that it's because the food is less nutritionally dense through extraction and reconstitution to more palatable and economically expedient forms. additionally, these forms require less effort to process by chewing so we're able to ingest more calories more quickly before our biochemistry can catch up and signal that we've consumed what we need. finally, the processing of food breaks down the original nutrient "matrix" in the way that our metabolism evolved to process it. we evolved to metabolize an apple, i believe was his example, by eating it raw and in its original form, together with all that constitutes an "apple" and not simply the composite of nutrients that we can extract from an apple. the hypothesis is that the whole apple influences our biochemical response differently than the extracted nutrients that have been reconstituted in a different form.
- im3w1l 2y agoMy guess is water. Natural foods have a lot of water compared to processed foods. Consider dried fruit. Quite minimally process wouldn't you say? Yet as snackable as candy.
- mewpmewp2 2y agoThere's currently a lot of DHMO in all of those foods, which can be quite dangerous for humans and has been a cause for numerous deaths in the World, including young children.
- lifeisstillgood 2y agoI sometimes wonder if there are lessons from British period of WWII rationing. Huge numbers of people were enabled to have for free the right amount of nutrients instead of the malnourishment of the 1920s/30s. And millions more found it hard to get the excess sugars and fats. If we created a new rationing, with no processed foods, feeding the whole population what would happen tomorrow and in ten years? Imagine how unpopular the Prime Minister who started this would be. Then imagine ten years later when he would be the guy that got millions of people thinner, fitter and having more sex (I am told that’s what thinner fitter people do!) Imagine that election :-)
- makeitdouble 2y agoThe jump from a Brazilian doctor classifiying food to a British study tracking consumption under that classification, to end on a US study with 20 adults, waiting for another one with 36 members ending next year, kinda illustrate how hard it is to come with relevant data. And now that we've more and more ultra-processed diet food, we'll need a few more decades to have an idea of their actual effect at any scale.
- s3p 2y ago>...people in Brazil were buying less sugar and oil than in the past. Yet rates of obesity and metabolic diseases were still rising. This coincided with the growing popularity of packaged snacks and ready-made meals, which were loaded with sugar, fats and other additives. What. So they were buying less sugar and fat. But they were actually buying more sugar and fat?
- philipkglass 2y agoThey were buying less sugar and oil as ingredients to cook at home with. They were substituting home cooking by buying more ready-made foods and snacks that contained fat and sugar as components.
- dismalaf 2y agoI mean, look at the ingredients list on most processed foods. Much higher quantities of various sugars and starches. More processed foods are rarely 1:1 ingredients compared to less processed foods...
- ninalanyon 2y agoAccording to the BBC Inside Health podcast I recently listened to they are often bad for you because the processing removes fibre and vitamins and also makes sugars more available. And that to make them int4eresting enough to eat excess salt is added.
- a3w 2y agoWHO says "eat 30 grams of fibre every day". Which is a lot, unless you use whole grains without sweeteners, fat or meat on top (which reduces fibre per calorie). Or eat lots of roots or cabbage, and salads. Especially since you have to think of eating until 30 grams of pure fibre content is reached every. Single. Day. Of. A. Year.
- iterance 2y agoThis strikes at a problem with the definition of "processing" foods. Nixtamalization is "processing," but is mandatory to ensure one does not develop a vitamin deficiency on a maize diet.
- bobajeff 2y agoTo me it looks like it could be something of a plucebo effect. Like they are bad for us because we expect them to be bad. Minucebo effect?
- mchannon 2y agoThe article name is "Scientists are learning why ultra-processed foods are bad for you", the opposite of this thread's title. Everyone's ignoring the elephant in the room: fiber. Fiber locks up calories and makes the body miss a lot of them, or absorb them later in the digestion process. If we reduce the word "processed" to a single action, it's removing fiber. It's turning wheat berries into flour. It's ripping off rice husks to make white rice. It's crushing nutritious apples and oranges into sugar water. Western countries use calories as a metric, and it's a very hackable metric. If I eat 1000 calories of whole oats, a lot of those calories are passing through my body. If I turn those whole oats into oatmeal, fewer are. If I'm McDonald's I'll pulverize them to get all 1000 calories into my health-conscious deluded customer's bloodstream, so they buy more food from me. Of course you can add 100g of Metamucil fiber to a processed meal, but the original fiber's function was to lock in the sugar, which the new stuff can no longer do. So it doesn't help. Why are processed foods bad for you? Follow the fiber.
- xnx 2y agoAgree completely. "Processing" is mainly the act of removing fiber so more food can be eaten faster and more often. Fiber satiates, which is not a good thing for companies that are trying to sell as much product as possible.
- orev 2y agoUsing a blender is also processing, but it doesn’t remove the fiber. It does, however, break open the cells and makes the nutrients and sugars more easily available separately from the fiber. Eating healthy is just as much about the shape/structure of the items being consumed as it is about the nutritional stats it has.
- snapcaster 2y agoThis is something not talked about enough. I think it's one of those things where people really struggling with weight should be told CICO (calories in calories out) just to get their head in the right place but it's not strictly true for all the reasons you mentioned and others
- AJ007 2y agoWho made up this word? Before 2022 it more or less doesn't exist (per Google Trends.)
- code_biologist 2y agoThe phrase as originally coined is from the Nova classification system, proposed in 2009 by researchers at the University of São Paulo, Brazil: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nova_classification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nova_classification
- anonym29 2y agoDukeofdoom's original comment: ``` Don't they add food coloring from ground bugs sometimes. In case of sausage they add preservatives to make it last longer. Actual poison if you were just to eat a lot of it. Generally companies are liable if they make you sick right after eating their product. So they do everything they can to prevent that. Nobody is going to held liable if they give you cancer 10 years down the line. Super hard to prove. So not a worry for them. Backlash after the failed covid vaccine makes some reform more likely now. ``` My response: Several food colorings (e.g. Red 40, Yellow 10) are synthetic dyes derived from crude oil and other petrochemicals. At least here in the US, it seems many people believe that if it's available for sale, that means a government agency deemed it safe, neglecting to consider that what a government agency declares safe may not actually be safe. This happens routinely for a variety of reasons - corporate capture (big business teaming up with big government to screw over human beings), gross incompetence of government employees (who in turn, are nearly impossible to fire, even with cause), complex modes of unsafety (per- and poly-fluorinated substances are bioaccumulative and persistent, and the relationship they have with our health remains ambiguous), complete lack of awareness of the risk (in the last week or so, we just discovered chloronitramide anion exists in the water supply of about 1/3 of the USA, little is known about the health effects it has on mammals in general, let alone humans), etc. Reality is complex. We are basically one step removed from cavemen still, and need to remain humble, curious, and intellectually honest about the sheer extent of that which we do not know. That's missing in so many people these days. I think more (but not all) people would benefit from undergoing an ego death and reintegration experience that so many others have found in psychedelics, which are nonaddictive and generally safer than legal drugs like alcohol and various combinations of amphetamines (ADHD medication).
- nobody9999 2y ago>At least here in the US, it seems many people believe that if it's available for sale, that means a government agency deemed it safe, neglecting to consider that what a government agency declares safe may not actually be safe. This happens routinely for a variety of reasons - corporate capture (big business teaming up with big government to screw over human beings), gross incompetence of government employees (who in turn, are nearly impossible to fire, even with cause), complex modes of unsafety (per- and poly-fluorinated substances are bioaccumulative and persistent, and the relationship they have with our health remains ambiguous), complete lack of awareness of the risk (in the last week or so, we just discovered chloronitramide anion exists in the water supply of about 1/3 of the USA, little is known about the health effects it has on mammals in general, let alone humans), etc. That's not actually how it works in the US. The standard is "Generally Recognized as Safe" (GRAS)[0], which requires the manufacturer to "confirm" that an additive is "safe." At least that's been the requirement since 1958, although some 700 existing additives were declared exempt from the potentially biased/unconfirmed testing of the manufacturer. If, as you suggest, "...many people believe that if it's available for sale, that means a government agency deemed it safe", those folks are woefully misinformed. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generally_recognized_as_safe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generally_recognized_as_safe
- 0xEF 2y agoLiving in the US, my takeaway is this: Food manufacturers do not care if we stay healthy, but they're also not interested in harming us on purpose. Their goal is to maximize profit, which usually means cheapest ingredients with addictive properties produced as quickly as possible by low-cost labor. But they also know this only works if the market allows it. If nobody bought their snack cakes (random example), they would stop making them. But their snack cakes are designed to make you want to eat the whole package and sold cheaper than an alternative like a healthy fruit and nut mix, making the consumer's choice almost a moot point since consumers tend to trade their own best interests for convenience and "saving" money. And so, they give the market what it buys. Simple as. But I do hate it. I have to put a stupid amount of effort into eating healthy because I don't have room for a garden and healthier alternatives are often more expensive. I can see why most people just reach for the snack cakes and call it done.
- 0xEF 2y agoIn retrospect, I realize the food industry probably took a page out of the cigarette industry's playbook. Or was it the other way around?
- filipheremans 2y agoThere is a clear link between the two industries: https://neurosciencenews.com/hyperpalatable-foods-big-tobacco-23906/ https://neurosciencenews.com/hyperpalatable-foods-big-tobacc...
- feoren 2y agoThis game theory problem, where consumers are buying unhealthier options because they're cheaper, and companies are producing unhealthier options because they're more profitable, is exactly what regulation is for. I don't understand why we've all collectively forgotten why regulation exists and become so cynical that it can actually work! Actually I do understand: it's industry interests spending hundreds of billions of dollars on intentional misinformation and government capture for a half century. A reasonable counter-argument is "but the science is extremely muddy here, so effective regulation is especially difficult", which is unfortunately true, but I'd point out that the science is extremely muddy largely because of industry efforts to intentionally poison our understanding of nutrition.
- rbranson 2y agotl;dr is that "ultra-processed foods" are engineered to be more palatable and that tends to result in more caloric density.
- giantg2 2y agoGeneralization is the real issue here. You can't just say "processed" food is bad. There are tons of definitions and different forms of processing. It would be much better to look at individual ingredients. A good start would be to change the GRAS process. There's no real investigation being done on many food additives and the evidence many use for GRAS is flimsy at best.
- arichard123 2y agoUltra processed people by Dr Chris van tulliken and for for life by Dr Tim Spector are good reading on this. The first is more focused on this issue.
- swasheck 2y agowas going to reference ultra-processed people. i walked away with some of the same general sentiments that are here - 1. nova classification is imperfect, but is better than what we had before it and i hope that we can iteratively find something more refined 2. so many nutrition studies are so woefully biased because of sponsorship (and antipathy) that it's laborious to extract meaning from them because much of the effort is tracing the money and potential bias.
- blackoil 2y agoI find two principles work best. First, grandma's wisdom is mostly correct so prefer home-cooked culturally aligned food. Second moderation, you can have one can of drink and one meal outside power week of anything. So burger and coke or Indian sugary desserts all are good if you can control frequency.
- robnado 2y agoEvolution has selected animals that, when they have access to foods with high caloric density, will gorge on them. This has been advantageous to their survival, because the history of life has been characterized by famine feast cycles for most species. Now, what UPF foods are is foods that have had most of their non-caloric content removed or been processed to increase calorie content, triggering this gorging behaviour. This is probably 80% of the obesity epidemic today. The rest is probably additives that affect our hormones that control hunger/satiety signals in the body. In my opinion, effective regulation would control the caloric density as food as well as ban any additives that can affect hormonal hunger/satiety.
- cynicalpeace 2y agoWhy the insistence that these foods are only unhealthy because of the calories? Have you heard of poison? 0 calories. Can kill you in the right doses. Food factories contain dozens of these toxins in the form of plastics, lubricants, agents, flavorings, colorings, etc. Calories are important. But the insistence that it's simply calories feels almost conspiratorial to me.
- zahlman 2y ago>Now, what UPF foods are is foods that have had most of their non-caloric content removed or been processed to increase calorie content, triggering this gorging behaviour. This is probably 80% of the obesity epidemic today. It's been possible to buy prepared pure sugar (even granulated) and pure oils and fats for centuries, and eat them straight out of the container if one wished. Yet the obesity epidemic is much newer than that, and hardly anyone gorges themselves in that particular manner even today. There is clearly far more to it than "had most of their non-caloric content removed".
- stuaxo 2y agoSome part of it must be how small all the parts get when processed so you take in everything really quickly.
- VeejayRampay 2y agodon't we though? they're known to contain very little nutritional value, to be stuffed with salt, fat, sugar, to feature next to no vitamins and natural fibers, which naturally corral sugar to the stomach instead of letting it go through the intestinal barrier freely so basically it's food that promotes poor variety in gut bacteria and inflammation that we pretend like we don't know is very surprising to me, it's not exactly shocking that the american diet is bad after some 50 years of it running amok across the world
- slowmovintarget 2y agoGiven standard home kitchen equipment and techniques, could you prepare this item? Yes -> not UPF; No, requires a factory -> UPF. This is kind of like the Jeff Foxworthy jokes. If you remove so many of the nutrients that you have to try to spray vitamins back on... you might make a UPF. If your product has ingredients where there is no evidence that those ingredients can actually be digested by the human body... you might make a UPF. If you have to add dyes so your product doesn't look like sawdust or poop, you might make a UPF. ...
- sabbaticaldev 2y agolots of people know but they don’t advertise on the economist
- workflowing 2y agoIndeed, you need scientists to simply pronounce the ingredients that are processed into, and into, food.
- Horffupolde 2y agoMy fast rule is to only eat food that’s been around for 1000 years or so.
- peterashford 2y agoOooohhh... not so sure. Bound to be a little moldy by now
- snapcaster 2y agoFrom reading these comments, i wish nobody was allowed to post on threads like this without posting a pic of their body so we can calibrate their opinions
- nitwit005 2y agoSmokers are often experts on why cigarettes are bad for you.
- snapcaster 2y agoI don't meet smokers arguing smoking isn't actually bad though...
- nitwit005 2y agoI have. You just haven't run into someone delusional enough. It's apparently a lie concocted by white people.
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoI haven't met one that argued it isn't bad, but many have certainly downplayed it, or they have wildly different standards. Like...15 years ago, I dated a girl that smoked, but wouldn't eat anything with artificial Blue or Red color because supposedly those cause cancer. I said, "You know those cigarettes cause cancer, right?" and got met with a "yeah whatever". That relationship didn't last (for many reasons), and I'll never again date a smoker. I always felt we were limited on the things we could do because she HAD to have that cigarette every ~30 minutes.
- tstrimple 2y agoMy mom switched from Diet Coke to full sugar Coke because she heard that Diet Coke causes cancer. All while being a pack a day smoker. It’s crazy out there.
- HKH2 2y ago
- 00N8 2y agoSo when I mix whey protein isolate into pineapple juice with plain Greek yogurt, is that considered an ultra-processed food? It seems like it would be, but I doubt the criticisms of UPFs really apply here. My understanding is that these are healthy ingredients, in a blend that's fairly optimal for strength training, despite one of them being highly processed. Is there actually anything wrong with whey protein? Or can we find a better definition of the problematic UPFs?
- hnpolicestate 2y agoThe children were served some bizarre meat substitute chicken nuggets today during lunch. Tastes one once. Literally just matter. Flavorless. If they want to do meatless days they should serve well seasoned lentils or something.
- DidYaWipe 2y ago"Robert F. Kennedy junior, Donald Trump’s nominee for secretary of health, has likened processed food to 'poison'" Wow, a bright spot.
- klik99 2y agoPutting aside the vague hand wavy definition of what "highly processed foods" literally means, my suspicion is that there are two things making processed food worse for you. I've heard drinking juiced fruits is worse for you than eating the equivalent fruits, as the sugars in the fruit are wrapped in fiber that make the sugars "slow release" into your body, and those are broken down when juiced so the sugars hit you at once. I suspect processed foods "mainline" nutrients in ways that unprocessed foods don't. Secondly, I think a lot micro-nutrition is ignored when comparing processed food, like the fat, carb, salt, etc is equivalent between potato chips and, say, a baked potato with butter, but there are a lot of small things that our body needs that are not part of that equivalence. At least for me, when I eat potato chips I eat more because they never quite satisfy me. I suspect this is because the micro nutrition is cooked or processed away, so I end up eating more carbs because it's not quite giving me all what I need, just the big macro needs.
- disparate_dan 2y agoI agree. I think there is a third thing: processed foods are more likely to contain additives like colorants, emulsifiers, preservatives and stabilisers that humans have been eating for decades rather than centuries so we don’t have the same body of knowledge about them or their health-related impacts.
- kalaksi 2y agoAnd maybe to a lesser extent the plastics in packaging.
- klik99 2y agoGreat user name btw
- tremon 2y ago> that humans have been eating for decades rather than centuries That's false btw. We humans have been eating emulsifiers and preservatives for centuries, even if we only classified them decades ago. Examples: - Lecithin (E322): naturally found in egg yolk - Citric acid (E330): naturally found in lemons and oranges - Agar (E406): found in red seaweed, an edible crop from southeast Asia - some sulphites (E221, E226) naturally occur in wines. Old wines are actually likely to contain more sulphites than modern ones since we now have a body of knowledge about them and their health-related impacts
- blueyes 2y agoRobert Lustig has been preaching this for years: https://www.amazon.com/Metabolical-Processed-Nutrition-Modern-Medicine/dp/0063027712 https://www.amazon.com/Metabolical-Processed-Nutrition-Moder... A good rule of thumb if you care about avoiding UPFs but don't want to overly limit your diet is to only buy foods with 5 ingredients in them (plus or minus 2 :).
- luckycharms810 2y agoI think the rub is actually here: "The participants received either ultra-processed or minimally processed foods for two weeks before swapping diet for the next fortnight. Participants in both diets had access to the same amount of calories and nutrients like sugars, fibre and fat. People were free to eat as much or as little as they wanted. The results were striking. People on the ultra-processed diet ate about 500 more calories per day than those on the unprocessed one" My understanding is that caloric intake is king.
- BizarroLand 2y agoWeight loss/gain is specifically tied to calories consumed vs calories burned, yes. But that is not the purpose of the study. 2 groups of people, 2 diets, and the 1 group given an unlimited amount of relatively healthier food, chose to eat less of it and lost weight. The other ate more junk food and gained weight. That implies that there are non-conscious factors at play and that diets may be more naturally successful if they are comprised of healthier less-processed food even without restriction. Additionally, this implies that there must be an X factor that takes place in the processing of foods that causes overweight people to keep eating when they have met their caloric requirements. For context, look at the data regarding nutrient density in vegetables over the last 60 years and see that the nutrients aside from fat/carbs/protein have been on a steady decline year over year. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10969708/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10969708/ When I put these things into perspective, my hypothesis is this: Being overweight, commonly viewed as a weakness of character or a sickness of the mind or body, is more likely a symptom of some larger issue. Evidence of this can be found piecemeal from studies on human diets the world over. The foods that are readily available to people are making them sick, my guess is that this is from some form of malnutrition. This may be a nutrient malnutrition or some compounding effect that the overprocessing of foods has on the human body that isn't trivial to differentiate from its non-processed counterparts. I feel it is reasonable to assume that in general overweight and obese people on an ultra-processed diet are overeating in a non-conscious attempt to compensate for a lack of fundamental nutrition in the foods that are available to them. Therefore, to test the hypothesis, the underlying nutritional issues should first be addressed by eliminating ultra-processed foods from the diet and replacing them with minimally processed foods, the higher in "quality" the better. Theory: An overweight person will naturally reduce their caloric intake when their diet meets or exceeds their nutritional requirements. The results, listed in the article above, seem to suggest that this theory is correct.
- Suppafly 2y agoUntil they come up with a term that actually means something definitive, I pretty much ignore anyone going on about ultra-processed foods. Ultra-processed is meaningless.
- djoldman 2y agoSeems like the cited studies confirm things we already know: when humans are given tasty high caloric-density foods, they consume more calories than when not given those foods. I didn't see a cited study showing that these ultra-processed foods led to worse outcomes when caloric intake was held constant. Did I miss something?
- illusive4080 2y agoNo you didn’t miss anything. Everyone is freaking out about “processed” and “chemicals” and ignoring the obvious answer: high calories and low nutrition.
- hgomersall 2y agoThe processed and chemicals may be a proxy for high calories low nutrition, but generally they are used to create hyper palatable foods that are low nutrition. In general, it's quite hard and expensive to produce high palatable foods using real ingredients; food engineering changes that and makes it easy for cheap food to mess with our senses. As far as I can tell, this is the generally accepted argument for the problems with UPFs - they make people want to eat more cheap crap food.
- rexpop 2y agoI haven't read the article, but research has identified several components of processed foods that are detrimental to health beyond their caloric content. *Trans fats*, often found in hydrogenated oils, raise bad cholesterol levels and are linked to heart disease and diabetes[3]. *Added sugars* and high fructose corn syrup, prevalent in many processed foods, increase the risk of obesity, diabetes, and heart disease[1][3]. *Sodium* is another common additive that can lead to hypertension and cardiovascular issues[1][3]. Additionally, *refined carbohydrates* cause rapid blood sugar spikes, contributing to metabolic disorders[3]. These components collectively contribute to chronic health conditions and increased mortality risk[2][4]. Citations: [1] https://nutritionsource.hsph.harvard.edu/processed-foods/ https://nutritionsource.hsph.harvard.edu/processed-foods/ [2] https://www.ama-assn.org/delivering-care/public-health/what-doctors-wish-patients-knew-about-ultraprocessed-foods https://www.ama-assn.org/delivering-care/public-health/what-... [3] https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/318630 https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/318630 [4] https://www.yalemedicine.org/news/ultraprocessed-foods-bad-for-you https://www.yalemedicine.org/news/ultraprocessed-foods-bad-f... [5] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6146358/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6146358/ [6] https://www.afmc.af.mil/News/Article-Display/Article/3781462/health-risks-of-eating-ultra-processed-foods/ https://www.afmc.af.mil/News/Article-Display/Article/3781462... [7] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10260459/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10260459/ [8] https://www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2023/06/27/ultra-processed-foods-predigested-health-risks/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2023/06/27/ultra-pro...
- gdjskshh 2y agoThis touches on, and then completely ignores, one of the most probable areas of concern - additives. Emulsifiers that disrupt your intestinal lining, artificial dyes/flavors/sweeteners, fillers, consistency changers, and all the other tools in a food chemist's toolbox. Those should be individually investigated and problem ingredients eliminated (e.g brominated vegetable oil). Also, fiber. The standard american diet is lacking fiber and protein.
- didibus 2y agoDo I read this correctly in that the only thing they found for now is that those eating UPFs ate 500 more calories per day, thus indicating the negative health effects could just be attributed to the weight gains?
- valval 2y agoA Ctrl + F for “healthy” into this thread returns numerous results. I’ve never found a convincing definition for such a common word.
- teleforce 2y agoI'm surprised the article and nobody here is mentioning the popular the usage or the abuse of Boric Acid and Borax in processed foods mainly for preservation purposes [1]. In most countries they are banned but process food manufacturers have been using since forever. [1] Abuse of Boric Acid and Borax in Foods: https://www.cfs.gov.hk/english/multimedia/multimedia_pub/multimedia_pub_fsf_131_01.html https://www.cfs.gov.hk/english/multimedia/multimedia_pub/mul...