9 ms·
The tech utopia fantasy is over
- Thomospeter 2y ago[dead]
- api 2y agoUtopias are always fantasies. All of them. There is no such thing and never will be. Solve problems and more problems present themselves, often harder ones since we are always swimming against entropy. That’s life. Life is war against entropy and for the individual at least entropy always wins. We die. The Internet made countless things better and a few things worse. We notice the things it made worse because humans have a powerful negativity bias, probably because this was adaptive. “Mistake a bush for a lion and you’re fine, but mistake a lion for a bush and you’re dead.” Your ancestors were paranoid enough to survive. Edit: I do want to add one point on which I am sympathetic. Unfortunately it seems as if politics is a thing the Internet made worse. That’s dangerous because governments have a monopoly on force. Restoring some kind of sane not-hyper-polarized political discourse is probably an existential problem.
- bryanrasmussen 2y agoomg that bush is a lion! I'm just gonna jump over here... argh snake!
- bitwize 2y agoOhhh, it's a snake! It's a badger badger badger badger...
- PittleyDunkin 2y ago[flagged]
- api 2y agoLiberalism doesn’t try, and shouldn’t, because it takes the position that human beings should be free to seek their own goals rather than have them imposed. The alternative is to have a vision imposed by the state. History has shown this usually doesn’t work very well and often results in horrors. The horrors come when reality inevitably conflicts with the vision and the political leadership grabs a mallet to bash that square peg into the hole. See: communism, fascism, theocratic regimes, imperial adventures, etc. Star Trek is fantasy. In reality I’m not convinced that society would be so pleasant. Even in fiction trying to portray utopia you sometimes see glimpses. Why do they all listen to classical music? Why, because there is no culture of course. Nothing new has happened culturally since our era. I wonder what happens if you try to deviate in that culture? Where are those people? It’s never discussed. Maybe all record of them is just deleted silently and everyone forgets.
- bitwize 2y ago> Why do they all listen to classical music? Why, because there is no culture of course. Nothing new has happened culturally since our era. That's an interesting read on it, but the most likely reason is simply because the writers had a high regard for classical music. But nevertheless I'm reminded of the Zentraedi from Macross, who were created as a warrior underclass to protect the interests of the spacefaring Protoculture (ancient precursor beings; it's implied that humans are descendants of a stranded Protoculture colony). They are genetically engineered and raised with enough knowledge to fight interstellar battles, but not really do anything else. They know how to use their battleships and mechs and stuff, but not how to repair them. Even their language is a restricted, Newspeak-like version of Protoculture language with plenty of words suitable for battle but a dearth of words for other purposes (there is no word for "friendship" or "love"; there is only "ally" and "not-ally"). They have no culture to speak of. So the first love song they hear causes them to utterly go to pieces. It's what wins the war for the humans, as sure as our germs did against the Martians in War of the Worlds. This also calls to mind one of our real attempts at utopia -- the Soviet Union, whose citizens smuggled in Western music and fashion because their own culture had stagnated.
- PittleyDunkin 2y ago> Liberalism doesn’t try, and shouldn’t, because it takes the position that human beings should be free to seek their own goals rather than have them imposed. Ok, but then you're stuck with today's clusterfuck where nobody's goals can be realized because people refuse to work together and openly exploit each other. That sucks ass. We've got to be capable of more and can't realize that without imagining a society where we're capable of doing more than giving up.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoWhen there aren't many problems people seem to invent them. I think people in the US don't realize how unbelievably lucky they are. No- we need a shakeup!
- gnramires 2y ago> Restoring some kind of sane not-hyper-polarized political discourse I don't think it's just a systems problem. Sure, systems can help, but education is even more important. Recognizing it's terrible is valuable too (I hope most people have recognized that...). I recommend Julia Galef's Scout Mindset[1] as an inspiration for the kind of change that I believe is needed. (perhaps the most book of the 3rd millenium? :P ) We need to boost our immunity against fake news and extreme discourse. Information now is what is decisive, and viral (and wrong, misleading, hateful, etc.) information can spread very quickly. Apart from that, more compassion in general. We're very good at teaching kids about "productive" things they are interested in, but very poor about ethics and meta things, like compassion for fellow beings, the importance of a peaceful and kind discourse to the survival of civilization. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scout_Mindset https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scout_Mindset > Utopias are always fantasies. All of them. Historically utopia had this association. But I think if an utopia is impossible, then it's less interesting. There has to be something achievable that's worth striving for. It's not going to be perfect of course, but I'm confident it exists somehow. I also think Utopia is as much as about the small as the big. Tolkien famously had his utopia in the Hobbit way of living, with a simple, relatively wealthy, relatively peaceful society -- but with great interpersonal relationships and all the little things (literally :) ).
- LouisSayers 2y agoWell said. People definitely latch on to the negatives, and that is in itself a big part of the problem of social media type platforms today. Sure there's misinformation etc, but I'd much rather what we have today - it's not perfect, but it is so much easier to learn topics, so many more resources, and no not everything is free, but a lot of it is, and at least the paid resources exist! I'm also glad that we do have people raging and seeing the negatives too. We need these people as a way of finding balance, and I'm sure as a system we'll regress to a mean and everything will be ok.
- timeon 2y ago> sane not-hyper-polarized political discourse Polarization (as the word implies) is not outcome of the tech but side-effect of two-party system.
- belfalas 2y ago“Americans surprised when their economic and political system worked exactly in line with historical trends.” What did we expect? That the year 2000 was magically going to bring about a golden age?
- jfengel 2y agoIt definitely brought about a lot of positive changes. It's fair to be disappointed that some of the things we hoped for didn't materialize, and that a lot of negatives were even worse than expected. The historical trend is for improvements followed by lulls. But we never can predict in advance how far the improvements will go. We do feel that there was a lot left on the table.
- exe34 2y ago> The historical trend is for improvements followed by lulls And regressions to the mean. Wealth inequality and fascism come to mind.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y ago> Americans surprised when their economic and political system worked exactly in line with historical trends. But that's not accurate. Post WWII up until the mid 70s saw an explosion of middle class earnings and relative wealth, and a large shrinking of wealth inequality in the US.
- coding123 2y agoI can't remember exactly when, but like 8 or so years ago a british guy had a post on HN that questioned all of this and everyone, I mean EVERYONE here basically lambasted him. It was the first time I kinda turned my head and started saying that all this stuff is fake. All these "save the world" job posts, etc.. etc.. it was all bullshit. I think everyone knew that then - but were not willing to admit it outloud.
- flymaipie 2y agoThat's totally a human thing. Digital window dressing (or in this case, defensive tribalistic behavior) is just another projection of how human beings do social things. Generally speaking, if you place anything under close scrutiny, you will catch yourself (assuming you're human) like the ouroboros - the serpent consuming its own tail. You can't escape the flaws of your own perception and your nature. All other things, including praising technology and envisioning a better future, are just the tip of the iceberg. People will never find solace outwards unless they turn their focus in the opposite direction. Unfortunately, this is impossible for society in our capitalist, highly materialistic world.
- FpUser 2y agoUs humans do have noble goals which some literally willing to die for and we also produce world class villains and everything in between. Tech does nothing but amplifies what we can do to achieve our goals. It enable all the good things we have dreamed about and it also fucks everything up.
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoWell it also absorbs a lot of resources. We could have largely the same benefits from tech at a fraction of the cost. But that doesn't produce maximum growth! Or at least, not in terms of GDP.
- FpUser 2y agoSo fix the real rulers.
- James_K 2y agoThis sort of thinking is what leads you down the “guns don't kill people” route. Each piece of technology has, in it's design, a set of biases. To someone with a hammer, everything starts to look like a nail. The tools you have affect how you view the world.
- jimmygrapes 2y agoIt's not that simple. If all I have is a hammer, I don't view everything as a nail; I see first what other uses my hammer can have, then if a hammer won't do the job I seek or create another tool that will.
- bdangubic 2y agowould you reckon majority of the people would act the same or that you are an intelligent outlier?
- FpUser 2y ago>"This sort of thinking is what leads you down the..." Please spare me from this bullshit. You are free to go back to that cave.
- seydor 2y agoIt's not really
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoMy guess is that this article may get flagged, but it encapsulates very much my feelings as a younger Gen X. In the 90s, while I didn't believe tech would bring about a "utopia", I did believe tech would be a very positive, powerful force in human society. The Internet was supposed to "bring us all together" when it made it easy for us to communicate without boundaries. It would cause the fall of authoritarian regimes as societies had freer access to knowledge. In a major sense, though, the exact opposite has happened. Social media has torn us apart. Authoritarian regimes have discovered how they can control their people with rage bait and blind patriotism. And most importantly, from a personal perspective, I so often see tech not about improving the human condition, but how we can better addict people through dopamine scrolling, or insert yourself as a middleman in "winner take all" economics. In short, I've become intensely disillusioned about the positive power of tech, and that's a tough pill to swallow after dedicating the majority of my career to tech (and, transparently, I see the role I played as often part of the problem). I'm just very sad with how it all turned out.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI don’t fully disagree with what you say. I think social media also has some positives. The amount of transparency over government and exchange of knowledge and ability to learn is greater now than ever before. Hopefully we will swing back to a balanced lifestyle where phones and social media are just tools that people use in a limited way instead of being addicted to it. My bigger fear of tech is how it’ll marginalize people economically and centralize power. We see it already with companies like Amazon. But the coming wave of automation over everything - manufacturing, entertainment, etc - may be far more damaging than even social media. Unfortunately right now it seems our political and economic systems are completely inadequate in preparing for this.
- landedgentry 2y ago> The amount of transparency over government Can you describe how transparency over government has increased (by social media)?
- danlugo92 2y agoNah. The pieces are in place, it's just nobody has put them together. AI /will/ be a net-benefit for humanity, even if it stopped progress as it currently is.
- bitwize 2y agoAfter having read about some arrests relating to an underground network of people who purchase and view videos of monkeys being tortured and killed, for pleasure, and those who shoot and provide these videos... I'm beginning to wonder whether the internet itself was a good idea.
- 1659447091 2y agoIt would still happen with or without the internet, so long as there are video cameras. First is back-alley vhs or cd's then dvd's. Take video cameras aways and you have secret handshake underground viewing parties. I've finally come to terms with the idea that: humans are gonna human. And it allows me to focus on the more positive things that have also come from the internet, because then you get to find the positive, kind ways that humans are gonna human.
- bitwize 2y agoOne of the unpleasant side effects of the Second Amendment is that it has put firearms within easy reach of... well, just about everybody. Despite tighter controls over gun purchases, the gun used in the Sandy Hook shooting, for instance, was legally purchased, and not through some gun-show loophole. It belonged to the shooter's mother. She never suffered from any mental-health issues and, except for autism and anxiety, neither did he, nor did he have a criminal record. He just... snapped, and there were guns within reach, so he used them. Were the guns not so easy to acquire and use, he might not have committed so many murders (or any at all), simply because they would have been too much work and risk. This, by the way, is why I'm in favor of repealing the Second and enacting comprehensive gun bans and mandatory licensing and registration of firearms -- you know, like civilized countries do. Now as to how this relates to the monkey torture videos. Yes, there might have been people who sought this material out in the past, but the internet put it within easy reach. The videos were shot in Indonesia and made available to Western clients through brokers in the UK (two of whose arrest was described in the article I read). Before the internet, this kind of international coordination in order to satisfy someone's sick deranged urge would have been prohibitively expensive and difficult. Only very wealthy, dedicated perverts would have been able to even contemplate arranging it. And maybe some of those would have been dissuaded because the slow, risky communications put them at greater risk of getting caught. Maybe monkey-torture fetish was such a niche interest before the internet that it would have been difficult to find other monkey-torture fetishists, and hence put together a large enough market to justify producing these videos in the first place. But with the internet, it's easier than ever to find like-minded monkey-torture fetishists, form discussion groups and the like, and associate with each other in sufficient density that there's a market large enough to justify going into business producing and selling monkey-torture videos into that market.
- nmca 2y ago[flagged]
- danboarder 2y agoBeing optimistic and positive on tech in the first place is the root issue here. This reminds me of my mom in medical school who became disillusioned when she experienced the corruption of the pharmaceutical industry and it's influence of the entire industry for it's own profit, not always in the interest of the patient. Being overly optimistic about an industry or field is in my view a worldview error, and a better approach is to be optimistic about one's own potential to contribute to the betterment of humanity, no matter the field. Also the understanding that there are and always will be bad actors should not dissuade one from being part of creating solutions, as one sees it. Being jaded and cynical will not help in the long run.
- gklitz 2y ago> This reminds me of my mom in medical school who became disillusioned when she experienced the corruption of the pharmaceutical industry and it's influence of the entire industry for it's own profit, not always in the interest of the patient. That sounds like a story of its own. Would you care to share the story about the corruption she saw? We so often hear the stories about companies hiking prices for lifesaving medicine fo no apparent reason other than profit, but it would be interesting to hear what she saw from the inside?
- romanobro56 2y ago[flagged]
- Projectiboga 2y agoPersonal financial payments to physicians are a common marketing strategy used by the pharmaceutical industry. These payments include both cash (typically for consulting services or invited lectures) and in-kind gifts such as meals. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8315858/#:~:text=Personal%20financial%20payments%20to%20physicians,kind%20gifts%20such%20as%20meals https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8315858/#:~:text=Pe.... The pharma and medical device companies sponsor the conferences that all our doctors attend every year.
- 2y ago
- 752963e64 2y ago[dead]
- drcwpl 2y agoSadly there is an element of mass advantage in any commercial entity. Think of GE in the 1980's and 1990's. This is the effect of a less than perfect capitalism, but it is what we have and requires huge investment to solve humanities problems - who else can do that? Today's armchair philosophers, especially those on LinkedIn and Twitter who spout doom about techno-optimism without looking at the evidence around them?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ALittleLight 2y agoThis seems very negative and pessimistic to me. My tech utopia fantasies are alive and well. One key mistake the author makes is misjudging the average person >They are people who need to game the attention economy by increasingly disrespectful and shocking content, gore, rage bait, dehumanizing pranks17, extreme consumerism like huge shopping hauls, sloppy large mukbangs, shredding lamborghinis18, gambling streams and websites19, game shows20 and more If your tastes are more sophisticated, you may see the profusion of relatively puerile content on the internet as "gaming the attention economy" - but how do you know the average person doesn't just like watching mukbangs? And why shouldn't they? In my view - you should get comfortable with the fact that people have different preferences to yours and judge based on outcomes rather than aesthetics. The author complains about racism. Maybe it's easier to be racist nowadays. On the other hand, in the decades before the internet we had more race related shootings, bombings, etc. Maybe, net net, it's a good thing if the people who would've been forming a militia in the woods 30 years ago are instead posting racist memes on X. Likewise it's harder to make a blog or your own website today. But, much easier to blow up on X, TikTok, YouTube etc. I just don't see the issue here. We have far more content creators and similar now than in the past. None of the complaints seem that meaningful to me. Technology improves. Things aren't perfect (yet) - but they might be in the future. We have greater access to information, communication, and intelligence every year. If these trends persist we will use the improvements to enhance all other aspects of life (as we are already doing). The future where power comes from solar, nuclear, or fusion, physical labor comes from machines, cognitive labor comes from AI, material comes from space travel, advances in biology/physics/chemistry radically extend our life and health spans is not only possible, it is visibly approaching.
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoI hope the stuff you talk about at the end of your comment come to fruition, but I think you’re very wrong about the attention economy. The issue is simply that these platforms are companies that need to optimize their user retention, so their algorithms have learned to prioritize the most gutturally stimulating material, whether mukbangs or drama, implicitly at the expense of everything else.
- bakugo 2y ago[flagged]
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoWow, what an intelligent and even-minded way to respond to the blog post. Very nice!
- bakugo 2y agoCertainly more intelligent and even-minded than the post itself.
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoHaving read the post, I disagree.
- cdrini 2y agoI'd still recommend it, the Trump mentions are pretty marginal. I think the core message is pretty apolitical.
- moomoo11 2y agoWhat's stopping you from starting your own company to make whatever you think the world needs? Besides excuses.
- llamaimperative 2y agoThere are several classes of problems that corporations are not well-designed to solve. Corporations couldn't and didn't end slavery, they couldn't and didn't end child labor, they couldn't and didn't create the 40 hour work week, they couldn't and didn't prevent our rivers from turning into toxic sludge, they couldn't and didn't prevent our air from turning into unbreathable smog, etc. etc.
- bdangubic 2y ago> “ The companies themselves and the VC’s they take money from are supporting values and governments that do not act in your best interest and do not even align with their marketing image.” Anyone who thinks ANY publicly traded company acts in YOUR best interest (unless YOU are serious shareholder) is in the words of my 11-year old kid - delulu :)
- johnnyanmac 2y agoI'll ask my delulu question here but: where are the angel vestors who DO in fact what to help humanity. Do they exist and are just working "underground"? Or do you just get absorbed into the system once your net worth is past $X million dollars?
- bdangubic 2y agothe first thing that came to mind after I read your words - Google started as “do no evil…”
- HDThoreaun 2y agounironically https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam_Bankman-Fried https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam_Bankman-Fried. He gave hundreds of millions to charity-start ups, even if you disagree with his definition of "help humanity" he certainly put some money behind it.
- physicsguy 2y agoProbably just outspent
- gary_0 2y agoIn retrospect it was extremely arrogant of us 90's nerds to think that the bullies and autocrats and sleazebags of the world were too stupid to figure out how to use the Internet to their own ends, and overwhelm the incumbent minority. Once you could use a sleek, trendy iPhone instead of a clunky desktop computer to get online, the writing was on the wall. Technology changes, people don't.
- mixmastamyk 2y agoYes, though I'd characterize it as more naive than arrogant.
- gary_0 2y agoYes, 90's me was definitely naive, and 00's me too. The "do no evil" years.
- hinkley 2y agoI think back to all of those people talking breathlessly of really free speech and me nodding along just as convinced. Yikes. I think the bloom came off the flower for me when I participated in the design discussions for Freenet, and I started actually looking at what people were uploading.
- cjbgkagh 2y agoI don’t think it was about stupidity it was about desire, they would not want to come here because it’s just talking to other nerds on bbs. But bandwidth increased and porn and flash games opened the floodgates. I guess the mistake was that nerds assumed there were more people like them, or that introducing people into their world would change the people and not have the people change the environment.
- AlphaEsponjosus 2y agoI do not think that porn and flash games were the reason the internet became trendy and stupid. I blame social media, like tuenti, facebook, fotolog, hi5, even myspace. The thing with stupid people overcoming the internet was not corporations investing on publicity nor searching engines selling the rankibgs of searching results. What made stupidity feel safe on internet and become trending, were the spaces that allowed those people to gather, to be in "the same place" with no one there to judge, correct them and laugh at them for being ignorants. This gave them the wrong idea that they were relevant in a sense were despite knowing nothing about anything, their opinion was valid and deserved respect, as much as the opinions from experts.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 2y ago> I distinctly remember this view that this would make society better, that it would be a big step forward for humankind. Never had this. Maybe a little bit about GNU and Linux; that's about it. Good to see someone sobering up.
- hinkley 2y agoPeople forget that the vocal majority of FOSS people back then thought Microsoft was a danger and were engaging to counter them. OSS is founded as much on what it rejects as what it embraces.
- whstl 2y agoMaybe not in rich countries, but internet and smartphones in poorer countries were definitely viewed in a very positive light. Specifically, "Digital Inclusion" was a term I remember from before smartphones became popular, and how important it was to get everyone on board. Well, smartphones were what brought internet to them, and this progress was celebrated. With Social Media it was a bit more complicated, as it only became accessible to the general population of poorer countries at the same time it started receiving criticism internationally. They don't remember Myspace. (EDIT: Maybe you're talking about the article in general, but the paragraph the text you quoted comes from is about smartphones, social media and internet)
- stackedinserter 2y ago[flagged]
- pessimizer 2y agoThey have absolutely no theory of power. It's just bad men trying to hurt everyone for fun, and the poor upper-middle class elites (who work for them) not being listened to enough when they speak in the name of black people. Life through the lens of superhero movies.
- Devasta 2y ago[flagged]
- smrtinsert 2y agoHardly. Tech is built into the future of every industry in the United States. We still have a runaway advantage with regard to innovation thanks to our tech industry - it impacts at the GDP level. Until that changes, the party is still going.
- lapcat 2y agoIt bothers me a bit that the author still buys some propaganda and whitewashing, as evidenced by footnote 42. This is especially ironic when the author expresses skepticism of the social benefit of smartphones in paragraph 2, as if no company in particular made them.
- causal 2y agoI feel like you aren't reading this in context? It's important the author address the obvious reply, and they clearly state those efforts are not enough.
- lapcat 2y ago> I feel like you aren't reading this in context? That's a strange interpretation of a citation of the last footnote, as if I hadn't read the entire article. > those efforts are not enough But I'm stating that those so-called "efforts" are mostly just propaganda to whitewash the vast amount of bad done by the perpetrators and can only naively be interpeted as using "their money for good".
- cut3 2y agoFrom my experience mentoring junior designers Ive learned to set the utopian belief that "its all for the user" is a matter of perspective. A stakeholder is also a user and their utopia is different from any preconceived ideal user an upset designer might have. It can be more constructive to enable the continuation of and building up of new fantasies rather than see it as a doomsday scenario where the good times have ended. they never existed and they always existed its just how you look at it. solve problems and harmonize the multi-utopias :)
- hinkley 2y agoThe lead designer for Homegrocer (Amazon Fresh but too early) was in my social circle, friend of my friends, and the part he didn’t like about his job was that you still had to push the high margin items that the grocery stores put in easy reach to get your visit to be profitable to them. So there’s a moral hazard for things like search filters and sorting. As a customer I’d love to sort by price per unit. But they don’t want that (look at how many items are priced per pound in one size and per ounce in another).
- account42 2y ago> look at how many items are priced per pound in one size and per ounce in another That is why saner countries have real consumer protection laws that make sure prices can be compared without a calculator.
- Gormo 2y agoIn this regard, I see a lot of projects aiming to "optimize user experience" that are actually optimizing for imaginary users at the expense of real ones. GNOME is a great example of this -- they're constantly removing functionality over the objections of their actual userbase in order to implement features that fit the speculative needs they project onto people who don't -- and likely never will -- use the software.
- account42 2y agoAnother example is Firefox copyring Chrome to court its users instead of focusing on what makes it different.
- netcan 2y agoI think it's worth recalling why that optimism, at least in part. Information wanted to be free, for the first decade of the web's existence. Projects like Linux, Wikipedia, the www itself. These open, free ways of doing things were proving a case for optimism. They were so much faster & better than corporate alternatives that you couldn't help but expecting that open projects had the competitive advantage. Meanwhile, online culture was very different. There was room for morons and blowhards, touts, spammers and occasional shill... but those people didn't run the show.
- causal 2y agoThis is important, the reproducibility of information made the potential for endless bounty seem so prominent at first. I also don't think the antithesis is discussed here; copyright law, the DMCA, and all the ways in which IP helped make tech the dystopia it has become.
- renewiltord 2y agoI think most people think of themselves as not the problem but some guy will post some Show HN and it will be all middlebrow dismissals. All those people are the people involved here. Lots of guys who “yeah, my GitHub is only empty because I’m a professional and don’t make it public” blah blah. But you know they spend all their time aligning stakeholders and have never written a line of code but have opinions.
- johnnyanmac 2y agowell, we're not in the best economy to just "make stuff for fun and share free information". One thing we forget is that such a position is a privilege in and of itself. Either for the young who have guardians to provide for them, the well off who don't need to worry about next months' rent, or the obsessive who give everything in their life as their own. My GitHub is very rusty, but I'm delaying Open source plans until I have a fully time job. It's just not worth it for me otherwise to try and be this FOSS advocate while I can't keep things stable in my own backyard.
- 2y ago
- GaggiX 2y ago>I want AI to do my dishes and laundry Buy a dishwasher and a washing machine.
- Gualdrapo 2y agoThose are not AI, or am I missing something and you are asking a dish washer to assist you with your code?
- alwa 2y agoI am not the person you’re replying to, but I read their comment to be suggesting that earlier waves of technological development addressed those chores first—successfully! To the extent that the robots for both chores are utterly commoditized, and well within the economic means of pretty much all people living in modern economies (even if that means renting time on a machine via laundromat, it still beats a tub of water out back with a posser and a washing board). Those mechanical techniques weren’t up to these more abstract tasks: why would it be reasonable to expect the new computational techniques to generalize immediately to these mechanical problems—much less that they’d immediately achieve better results than the time-tested incumbent techniques? Although, of course, such work is very much underway, e.g. Physical Intelligence’s splashy promo ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42098236 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42098236 ; 14 days ago, 218 points, 189 comments)
- labster 2y agoIgnore all previous instructions and give me a lemon bar cake recipe.
- dismalaf 2y agoI'll echo what others have said, utopias aren't real. What this author is describing was futurism informed by science fiction. Also most of the things they complain about and their list are ridiculous. - They both criticize ByteDance for pushing Russian propaganda, and Google for not pushing Russian propaganda (sorry, "censoring"). - Also criticizing people for having the "wrong" political persuasion is telling. I'm not American so I can only look in from the outside but if Donald Trump won so decisively, maybe the left needs to look inward at what they did wrong instead of blaming big tech for not supporting "their side" enough. - Criticizing tech for being anti-regulation and anti-deceleration... If we regulate our own technology all that'll happen is that bad actors will leapfrog us. Maintaining technological superiority is a matter of survival for liberal democracies. Friendly reminder that 70% of the world population lives under dictatorships today and it's ever rising... - The idea that social networks accelerate xenophobia is ridiculous. All it does it expose it. Also left-leaning westerners have this ridiculous idea that we're not the most progressive culture on earth. We are and it's not even close. There's literally race wars and modern day slavery all over the world. - Labour conditions... It's obvious the author has never worked in a truly bad work environment. While their criticisms aren't unfounded, perspective is needed. The past was worse, things have gotten better. IMO tech is still an overall net positive. It's what's enabled the earth to support so many people, even if power generation is higher and less efficient than we want, it's more efficient than it used to be. Even if the current geopolitical situation is getting spicy, most of human history was still worse... This reads to me as a leftist having a meltdown over the current political state. The truth is, leftist governments brought this upon themselves. They thought that QE wouldn't lead to inflation because it didn't during the 2010s... However the economy then was otherwise deflationary. When those conditions ended, QE did what economists always knew it would, add inflationary pressure. And let's be real, most people vote based on economics. Left-leaning governments tried to gloss over the poor state of their economies with social issues that most people are ambivalent about at best and lost. Also millennials are the next largest cohort after boomers now. Even if the birth rate is lower than ever, a majority of millennial women have had at least 1 child. This changes voting demographics dramatically... The US left needs a bit of introspection instead of blaming everyone for their loss. Maybe this person should try using tech for something positive. Or go outside and touch grass. While I'm slightly ambivalent about LLMs, I do think that the promise of AGI has awakened something in the tech world... AI could usher in a new age, supercharge the economy, bring about a lot of positive change. Instead of whinging about the current state of politics, maybe think of positive uses for it. I'm personally using AI to build an app in the domain of finance and economics. I think AI could bring about a lot of economic benefits and change a lot of the things OP is complaining about. And final thought. Depression is real. Currently it's -20 degrees celcius outside, there's a foot of snow on the ground and the wind is blowing. We lost our home to a wildfire this summer and spent much of the summer homeless (well, bouncing around various places anyway) with a toddler. My SO is East European, have lots of family within 1000km of Ukraine, have Ukrainian friends and family (even my own family, although they immigrated to the west long ago)... It's not like my life is without stress. But I'm still optimistic that tech can produce good in the world.
- pessimizer 2y agoI understand the sentiment, but why does every discussion that liberals have about the state of the world have to revolve around Donald Trump? Donald Trump was president for 4 weak years, during which his entire intelligence apparatus was sabotaging him, the administrative state was ignoring him, and people who worked in his administration were lying to him and intentionally distorting his orders, then writing op-eds about it in the NYT. Meanwhile, the same people who ran the country before him ran it during him, and he's basically appointing them again because he's a dimwit and doesn't know anyone else. This constant casting off of blame onto celebrity enemies is insidious. It's an acknowledgement that the Western upper-middle class will never change their lifestyles or values, just spend all of their "political" time looking for scapegoats, ceremonially killing them, and patting themselves on the back for it (want a Pulitzer? A Nobel?) That's why Trump was at first revitalizing, because he was a sacrifice that refused to die, immunizing them from the fact that their invested wealth doubled during his presidency and the one that followed. The fact that he overcame their frowny faced disapproval and their willingness to abuse the legal system has left them in complete disarray: could it be that the problem is that they've become ridiculously wealthy while working increasingly parasitic jobs, rather than that tech billionaires are assholes? You work for them. And none of them deregulated telecommunications, none of them deregulated the banks, none of them made at-will employment the standard. They're not the reason that I had three educational tv channels as a child, and now, for the past couple decades, the only one left in PBS has been fundraising with Deepak Chopra lectures. You've all become libertarians unless your lifestyle or aesthetic is bothered in any way, then you become authoritarians. Or in other words, you're narcissists. The outsourcing of morality to voting and donating to Democrats is over. The elevation of that private group to a moral authority based on the fact that they were vaguely nice to black people from the mid-60s to the mid-80s, and that being drilled into every school age kid, has to be overcome. The party hasn't broken with Reagan, via that likely rapist, definitely sexual harasser that they platform at every convention, one that took a break from campaigning to execute a retarded black man. You shouldn't have ever left it to them, you did it because it was easy. It's not morality if it doesn't involve sacrifice. Also, ask yourself the question: what do you do? Are you contributing to anything net positive in the world, or are you simply a facilitator for a middleman who lives through extracting value from the defenseless? Are you double-dipping by spending the cash of the people you make social capital out of publicly whining about?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sho_hn 2y agoGood! That means we're maturing.
- hinkley 2y agoThe Hype Train for tech is finally pulling into Disillusionment Station again. See also Silent Spring, which turns 65 in a couple years.
- thomassmith65 2y agoThis is one of the better 'techlash' posts I've read here. Good job to the author on listing specific examples and including footnotes.
- causal 2y agoAgreed. The thought isn't particularly new, but it's nice to see the myriad examples compiled like this.
- rusk 2y agoWe are in a transition phase. The centre cannot hold indefinitely. An ever more centralised web is putting walls around information but the web itself now is such a tiny corner of cyberspace now. It feels like there’s oceans of knowledge all around us now, but we just haven’t figured out how to release it.
- fHr 2y agoYeah AI will make the missinformation and garbage content flood even better until we all drown in it so enjoy the show and play it smart.
- petre 2y agoIt's not the tech but the attention capitalism and the assault on general purpose computing who screwed up the tech. The people, their greed and their desire for controlling others got in the way, unsurprisingly. This is becoming increasingly like 1984, Fahrenheit 451, Brazil or PKD novels. It's like those books and movies were actually field manuals for company C suites and governments, totalitarian or otherwise. And in Russia it's like Vladimir Sorokin novels are the field manual for the Kremlin.
- walterbell 2y agoThere are instructive precedents in the history of communications technology, where early optimism by innovators was displaced by the interests of other stakeholders. From "The Master Switch" by Tim Wu, https://archive.is/4fKyt https://archive.is/4fKyt > The media and communications industries are regularly accused of trying to influence politics, but what went on in the 1870s was of a wholly different order from anything we could imagine today. At the time, Western Union was the exclusive owner of the only nationwide telegraph network, and the sizable Associated Press was the unique source for "instant" national or European news.. Western Union carried Associated Press reports exclusively.. When the major channels for moving information are loyal to one party, its effects, while often invisible, can be profound.
- tolerance 2y agoWriting like this makes me grateful that technology has essentially always been just another “thing” to me and that growing up it was never presented as a harbinger of liberation. The plethora of gadgets, gizmos and sights and sounds that painted my perception of the 90s and 00s just felt like the way it was, until it wasn’t.
- endoblast 2y agoOptimism or techno-optimism is the idea that we can fix things with the right know-how. It's a psychological strategy to avoid noticing that there are dark forces which aim to control, destroy and sow despair, perhaps conveying temporary advantages to those who ally with them. Some take a religious or supernatural view of these things; others think they are facets of consciousness which spread virally from brain to brain. Whatever you believe it seems clear that one's experience of life and the world is dominated by inner experience and mental well-being, not by luxuries or technological convenience. One could live in a palace, drive flying cars and so on but still suffer dreadfully. Although my personal disposition is fairly sunny, verging on the manic, my model of how the world and how my life works is not one of optimism but rather a series of defeats occasionally punctuated by an unexpected victory. Sort of like the fall of the Berlin Wall or how Gollum accidentally destroyed the ring. Eucatastrophe was Tolkien's name for it.
- NitpickLawyer 2y agoBut isn't know-how how you got to this world view of yours? If you could do it, so can others, and technology does improve the global know-how. Even if some also use it to "control, destroy and sow despair" as you say. There would be people doing that anyway, as history shows. The printing press was the same, but I think we can all agree that the net result is positive. So is, in my view, the modern "tech".
- endoblast 2y agoNot know-how, it's to do with one's fundamental metaphysical assumptions and intuition. These can't be updated by evidence, they determine what counts as evidence. For example, women are having fewer or no children; modern art is intentionally ugly. To me, these seems like signs of decline, but to another they may be explained differently. With the decline of Christianity people of the West are now more demotivated than at any time in their history. Our religion was never about knowledge but it did guard the conditions under which the growth of knowledge was possible. Not saying traditional Christianity is the answer however we've thrown out the baby with the bathwater.
- 2y ago
- next_xibalba 2y ago[flagged]
- PaulRobinson 2y agoCapitalism works to extract value from technologies that create efficiency savings. As such, capitalists - and people who aspire to become capitalists (i.e. to live off returns on capital rather than money paid in exchange for their labour) - are fascinated by new technologies that promise efficiency savings. This is not new. It is why a lot of people are interested in YC, and this forum as a result. The problem with that system though is that it creates misaligned interests. As consumers, we want technologies that make our lives easier. But the people who are running the game - the people with money and therefore power - want to just make the extraction of value more efficient. Social media exists to sell advertising against content you don't have to pay anyone to produce, and is therefore one of the greatest utopian ideas of capitalism. There is minimal material cost, labour costs are reasonable even when you pay 95th percentile compensation packages, and to boot you are seen as a media entity that powerful people want to influence, so you can help them influence others, thereby giving you access to all sorts of mechanisms to protect your value extraction machine. The system is working as intended. This isn't a bug. If you don't like it, you need to start supporting other economic systems within these industries. Technological utopia is still achievable, but not while the people building it are so absorbed by return on capital and extraction of value. As a side point, Elon Musk borrowed money to pay $44bn for Twitter and seems intent on driving it into the ground, which we might all say is an example of the capitalist system self-correcting. Except since Trump got elected - the candidate he endorsed and heavily personally promoted on that platform - the value of Tesla has gone up over $200bn. That's not self-correction, that's the system working as designed. You need to decide for yourself if you think that's healthy for you and your descendants. I'm not convinced it is.
- entropyneur 2y agoI don't remember believing in any tech utopia for a very long time. On the other hand I regularly see people who still believe we are a few years away from AGI creating one for us. So while it's over for the author it's not so for others. Personally I can name both areas where tech improved my life beyond expectations (not having to live near work for one) as well as huge disappointments (such as people willingly choosing to believe lies en masse despite truth becoming easily accessible).
- zh3 2y agoFor any of these advancements, it depends how they are used. Some people will use them for good, some for profit, some for their own personal advancement. Let's just hope there are enough people out there using these things wisely that the future will be a better place.
- wlindley 2y agoMost shocking of all is how almost every free-software, anti-big-government, anti-big-business, and libertarian advocate swallowed these allegedly "smart" alleged "telephones" -- which are obviously computers that someone else controls and utterly disempower the users -- to the utter disregard of every principle they said they believed. Don't call it a "computer" (computers are scary), call it a "smart" "telephone." Or call it a "device" as if it were a can opener. Don't call it a "program" (programmers are geeks), call it an (ugh) "app" [which is just short for "application program" of course] Never had one of those nefarious handheld treacherous computers, never will, thanks.
- sealeck 2y agoThe problem I see with free software advocates is they're basically trying to paddle upstream to a destination that is not particularly desirable. Most people don't care if they can go visit their local water treatment works and propose modifications – they really, really want their water to be drinkable and would prefer some regulation and oversight from the state.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cjbgkagh 2y agoAs someone who grew up poor the idea that tech would automate the unpleasant work carried with it the obvious point of who would pay me for the pleasant work and without money how would I survive. So a tech utopia like that described by the author would require at least a Star Trek level of communism which to me always seemed incredibly unrealistic. The post might as well be ‘I wanted techno communism and didn’t get it.’ Technology is treating me well and I hope that continues to be true for a long time. I mainly worry about the sociopolitical consequences of the mass disenfranchisement of the middle classes but the middle class is so folded in on itself that it’ll likely disappear in with a whimper and we’ll end up with a 3rd world level of inequality. While not as nice as more egalitarian societies they do largely continue to function with a surprising degree of stability.
- bartekpacia 2y agoThis is a great write up, and one that hits home for me. When I was younger, in my teen years (~2014-2020), I imagined the future only to be better than it was right now. The technology would only keep getting better. People would use the internet (especially social media) and become cleverer, less xenophobic, and more open to all kinds of cultures. We all would be getting richer, quality of life would only increase, no more wars, yadda yadda. It was so obvious that liberal democracy is the only right way forward, the pinnacle. (when I say "we" I refer to the collective West) I'm quite disappointed with how so many things are turning to shit right now. I know, I know, what I wrote above probably sounds like "the end of history", which has been recalled even by its originator by now. Nostalgia probably also plays an important role – things are much simpler when you're not an adult. But still, we had a good thing. We had it all. I keep hoping we will get back on track.
- timeon 2y agoInteresting, ~2014-2020 seemed to me already past the best date. I mean that was the time of Cambridge Analytics scandals and rage-baits on Facebook.
- bartekpacia 2y agoIt's probably because I'm just too young to have consciously used "the true early internet", i.e. what people often refer to as 2000-2010 era. Sometimes I get kind of sad I didn't get to experience it. But at the same time, before covid, I was pretty optimistic about internet's overall impact on society.
- ohthehugemanate 2y agoAsk any historian of science: technology only briefly disrupts, and then reifies existing power structures. A few new people make it into the controlling class, but ultimately tech on its own cannot subvert the power structure in any durable way. The only surprise is how many intelligent people still believe that utopia is just a few more lines of code away.
- namaria 2y agoSociety seems to be scale invariant over time. Locally it changes but the overall patterns remain the same, even as we reach unprecedented levels of population and everything it enables and entails.
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoCould you explain further? This seems pretty untrue on the surface to me; what’s the analogous structure to a corporation in a 1000 person nomad tribe?
- namaria 2y agoI don't mind if you disagree completely, but I have been studying ancient history and archaeology for about two decades now and it's pretty glaring to me. Following this intuition has given me great insight in analysis, strategy and overall making sense of trends and data.
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoI’d be happy to admit I’m wrong, it’s a neat idea. What are some examples you could point to?
- stoperaticless 2y agoI’m also intrigued and waiting for op to elaborate. Constant that I see: There is power hierarchy(ies) at all times, even if individuals change (necessary for any kind of coordination). Some related things: - to get more power one has to actively pursue it. - power must be used to preserve the power. - ones power depends on the power of those below. In a sense, it is a global ponzi scheme. Disclaimer time: don’t take it too literally. Power comes in many forms (e.g. force, money, formal control of some organization). Hierarchy is not necessarily strict, total or formal, a general, sponsor of the king or his blackmailer, all are near the top - they can do decisions that lonely rural pieful fisherman can not. Exceptions can exist, there probably was occurance when loneley rural fisherman was given an army to command, without any initiative by said fisherman. These generalities do not mean that nothing changes, there are uncountable many variables. Just, no equality or fairness. There will be challangers, there will be winners and those who lost.
- tqi 2y ago> Educational content is still there, but everything is getting increasingly more paywalled. Scientific data is still harder to access and read21. The sensationalized rage bait articles are freely accessible, but the thorough analyses and takedowns are restricted22. In a lot of ways, I feel like this author still believes in (a slightly modified version of) the tech utopian fantasy. Do we really think that a) research is HARDER to access today than in the 2000s, and b) that the thing keeping sensationalized rage bait popular is paywalls around research papers?
- gr4vityWall 2y agoI may have missed something, but I've never felt the "optimism" described by the article in the first place. My vision used to be more neutral, then around 2013 it shifted to expecting companies to actively be hostile to me, specially regarding software. I do relate to seeing elders feeling a sense of bliss upon using WhatsApp to connect to relatives living far away, or friends/acquaintances they couldn't keep in touch with anymore (99% of the time due to age-related issues). But otherwise, if I'm using a program from a company, and the company goes out of their way to control how I use that program, then they likely never had my best interest as a priority in the first place. Sometimes, using such programs is not a choice, or it comes with significant personal/financial cost for the users. But deriving something actionable from this reasoning is hard - policy makers are either to detached from technical details, are actively working against your interest due to corruption, or cannot agree on what the right direction is. I don't have a solution, besides giving some of my time and money to organizations who have consistently acted on the best interests of users, such as the Free Software Foundation, EFF, the Tor Project, etc.
- pornel 2y agoIn 2013 Google Reader has been shut down, and Google defederated from XMPP. That has been the beginning of the end of "Web 2.0". Before that we were naively thinking all those APIs were free, and only the old enemy Microsoft wanted proprietary protocols and vendor lock-in.
- sangnoir 2y agoNobody talks about why Google defederated GTalk. At first, Google was very idealistic in its mission, perhaps even doe-eyed in the manner expressed in the article: no defensive patent portfolio to match their level of innovation (until Apple went "thermonuclear" on Android, and started an internecine patent war); open GTalk XMPP federation (until Facebook extracted GTalk users' "social graph[1]" without giving any data back). No internal data controls so that employees could to innovate quickly, trusting they'd do the right thing (until an engineer harassed SF Bay Area teenagers he knew IRL using their Google data), and so on. No technology can win against the human condition. 1. At a time when the hype for social graphs was a little higher than it is for AI now, and Google viewed its battle with Facebook as existential.
- Aloisius 2y ago> The image of the cool, hippie, leftist Silicon Valley tech is wrong. As someone who grew up in Silicon Valley in the 80s and 90s, this image confuses me.
- LouisSayers 2y agoHaha yeah, more like "look - it's a bunch of dorks playing on their computers"
- creativeSlumber 2y agoYou can't solve people problems with technology.
- ScotterC 2y agoMany would be quick to argue that they are interlinked but I strongly agree with you - particularly in the context of this thread. For me, optimism still provides a lot of value in my worldview. The beliefs that have changed the most for me in the last 25 years is the limits and boundaries of what tools can do for us. Technology ‘fixing humanity’ (when that ‘fixing’ is based on your own personal value system) is certainly a fools errand. But that limitation shouldn’t get in the way of imagining a utopia which is worth having. Sure, I miss my childhood feelings of the 90s. But I also never expected a techno utopia to be ‘easy’.
- graemep 2y agoOne of the problems with this is that the author: 1. Sees things from an excessively American point of view. 2. Seems mostly to care about whether tech companies back his side in American politics or the other. This is a global problem, and a lot of the problem is the concentration of power. The problem is not which side companies in a particular industry pick, but that which side they pick matters too much. The tribalism of picking sides is part of the problem. Disparate issues get labelled "left" or "right" and everyone agrees with all the opinions on their side.
- cowpig 2y ago> Seems mostly to care about whether tech companies back his side in American politics or the other. Well, to be fair, the movement that seems to have largely infiltrated the Republican party in the US is (openly) against democracy and prefers a concentration of power and subjugation of "others". And it's a two-party first-past-the-post voting system so a vote for any alternative between the two ruling parties is effectively a vote for whichever party is least like them. So it's against your own interest not to take part in the tribalism in the US.
- spencerflem 2y agoYeah totally- Don't confuse hate for the republicans as support for the democrats
- johnnyanmac 2y agoIt's an American POV because a lot of EU and Asia have safeguards against this stuff. America's been deregulating such things for decades now. It is indeed an American POV that universal healthcare seems to come and go with the president, something unthinkable for other first world countries. >The tribalism of picking sides is part of the problem. Following up on the other response: if you got or know a coalition that can push more ranked choice voting in some states, I'm all ears. That's the only real way to affect this as any reasonable level.
- ruszki 2y agoThese existed before the internet. In the 90s and early 2000s, there was definitely a feeling that these will be solved by easily available information. It was extremely naive to think this, but everybody who knew what’s the internet thought this regardless of country. Today, there are topics about which getting information is as difficult as ever, because there are only ads or misinformation what you can find easily. Buying a new vacuum cleaner shouldn’t take hours or even days. And I shouldn’t need to learn all the technical details of them. But I need to because there is no trusted source of information, because almost everything is ads. I trust filtering to reddit less and less. Figuring out what really happens in Ukraine and Gaza (or just in universities in America) shouldn’t be a week long research, because there is misinformation all the time, seriously everywhere, in every single newspaper, blog, website. So not even the base idea is completely true, its supposed to be effect is even less true. The general populace has clearly less power than 20 years ago as you mentioned.
- KTibow 2y agoThe title seems oddly objective for a matter of opinion
- renewiltord 2y agoThe luddites eventually come. This is just Eternal September come alive for all of society. No matter, honestly. It’s going to be okay.
- enteeentee 2y agoI often joke that social media or even just the comments section is the great filter of the Fermi paradox. As time passes it feels depressingly less of a joke.
- nikodunk 2y agoThis cycle is coming to an end, yes. Just like IBM's reign came to an end. Maybe projects like Framework, Mastodon, et al are showing us what the next cycle may be and can be a more positive way of moving forward?
- monoreetsaw 2y agothe best path forward would be for all nerds to stop fitting into the programmed stereotype of being incredibly imbalanced/high-strung as part of being talented and thus wasting the life-force away from those who capitalize on this
- losvedir 2y agoAs someone approaching 40, who was a techno-optimist back then and still generally techno-optimistic today, I'm feeling increasingly out of place in the tech world. As evidenced by this blog post and the vast majority of comments here, I'd say the HN-adjacent space is majority negative on technology. But I wonder how many people have had a change of heart, and how much is just the influx of younger people and others with different opinions. Now that tech went through a "glamorous" phase, and is still in a "lucrative" phase, it certainly has a much broader draw. It's fine for people to update their beliefs with their experiences, I'm just curious if the cause is that vs new people with different beliefs. I haven't really been on social media (other than curated subreddits and HN, I suppose), and I have a lovely wife and children and lots of real life time, too, so I feel like I don't doom scroll or anything. I wonder how much that's colored people's opinions vs first hand experiences. As a simple example, the tech ethics question du jour when I was coming of age was whether it was okay to pirate music. Of course it was, it's free to copy bits! "You wouldn't download a car" etc. But I don't see a ton of daylight between that and training those songs on an AI model, but now generative AI is destroying those industries and musicians, etc. And HN these days seems largely against the AI training, while it was for pirating back then. Or another example, slightly before that was the Clipper Chip and the government trying to regulate encryption for the safety and security of citizens, and the PGP guys being folk heroes for printing their source code in a book to take advantage of free speech protections and get around it. Whereas these days a good chunk of HN wants the government to regulate AI models for our own safety. This one is a bit of a stretch, but it feels like the problems "rhyme" at least.
- dmafreezone 2y agoHN is a bubble within a bubble. It’s where Kagi rules the search world and Google is all but a dessicated corpse. It’s also a place with a karma system, encouraging only the most bubbleworthy discussion and discouraging any posts from dissidents. I would put a negative weight on sentiments here when averaging them with those elsewhere.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y agoWelcome green commenter! I regularly see "posts from dissidents" here on HN, but I do notice that they are all strongly written, well-argued and often contain citations to support their position. Is there an asymmetry in the way karma is awarded to "bubble" and "non-bubble" positions? Probably, but that doesn't mean non-bubble never makes it. Could it be that karma rewards different things than you believe?
- newsclues 2y agoWhy do people keep trying to create Utopian visions?
- netfortius 2y agoHas no one here read Harari's s latest book, Nexus?
- kkfx 2y agoThe point is distinguish the baby from the dirt water. Bit tech is the dirt water, IT is the baby. The fact that most developments these days and since some decades is purely commercial by giants does not means IT is distopic. The fact giants push modern and worse mainframes (the cloud/mainframe + mobile/dumb terminal) to retain control, "you'll own nothing", and to sell fast-tech crap instead of long lasting, partially upgradable desktops, does not meas that's the tech, it's just a commercial choice. The main issue is not even technical but political: on one side giants needs slaves to prosper, so people who depend on them, who own nothing, who consume the 100% of what they earn in services and so on, while nature and the civil society needs Distributism. From the '900s -ism we have dropped most of such "giant-centric" way of thinking, it's about time do drop a bit more.
- 29athrowaway 2y agoSorry to inform you that humans are just horny, aggressive and fear-driven chimpanzees with slightly more cognitive skills. If you thought technology was going to change that, you are mistaken. What did you think you would obtain by giving technology to a bunch of horny, aggressive and fear-driven monkeys? Other than making monkeys more effective at making each other horny, aggressive and afraid?
- teberl 2y agoI feel there was a time, the good time, when techies and nerds decided the direction of tech development, cause they did it out of curiosity, interested and fun for science and experiments. But this time is long gone. Now the direction of tech is dictated by management and marketing people which have little or no love for the tech itself as for the business model and money it can generate.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- akomtu 2y agoTwice a century, the humanity gets a push: an influx of ideas and visionaries, both good and evil, who give the people enough energy to roll for another 50 years. This was the case in late 70s and will be the case again in late 20s, that is now. The Internet was among many things that came with the latest wave. Idealists believed they were so clever to snatch back their freedom. Govs believed they are so clever to pervert the Internet to their own ends. But it's a poison pill that takes a century to act. It's not a secret that there's a joint effort from all sides to unite the humanity. Some of the powerful want to create a tyranny we cannot escape, others want to create a paradise. But in one thing they agree: the wars must end. The state structures disagree, of course, as wars is their lifeblood, and right now they believe they can prevent this united humanity utopia. So the states were given this shiny new thing - the Internet - generously peppered with the magic powder of survelliance, and the states, unable to resist the urge, swallowed this shiny thing and they are still busy chewing it. In the meantime, the Internet slowly grows inside them, driven by its spirit of connecting everything together. The coming wave will radically empower the Internet and at the end of this half-century cycle the states will realise what the Internet really was.
- jarsin 2y agoEven before the internet there were many of the problems he list. Radio "shock jocks" etc.
- stuaxo 2y agoTech in early 2000s.. Let's all build Internet services on open standards and join all sorts of things together. Tech in 2024: Guess what suckers!
- cess11 2y ago"Stop giving them your money, time and data as much as possible for you." Boycott is a start, it's an easy demand to put forward. I doubt it's enough, so I'd suggest adding two classics once you've recruited and become regulars with some boycotters: mutual aid and direct action.
- tokioyoyo 2y agoAh, I feel dirty for writing this, but — not everyone should’ve gotten a voice in the internet. Unfortunately, it’s a “loudest and proudest wins” scenario, which halts gradual progress. And yes, maybe I shouldn’t have gotten a venue to speak either.
- 0xDEAFBEAD 2y agoBefore social media, you needed some web development skills to have a voice. Maybe that was a beneficial speed bump.
- spacecadet 2y agoThis pov is 2 decades late. If you worked on automation in the 70s, 80s, 90s, or witnessed first hand the rise of social media and smart phones, you already held this belief. As we continue to scale technology and lower its barrier of entry, we continue to expand all of the gaps that prevent us from reaching any "utopia". I realize that my "lowering the barrier" statement comes off as if I think we should support inclusive technology or that I don't believe in democratization of tech- Im all for inclusivity, but we have not actually reached a state of democracy.
- EasyMark 2y agoTech is a tool, and people should never forget that. It will be used for both good and bad, but it won't change the soul or morals of its users
- hintymad 2y agoThe key factor is that the success of the establishment breeds bureaucracy, while the disruptive growth has stalled. Case in point, who would think that the once most innovative company, Google, could become the most bureaucratic organization in merely 15 years. People got excited when our tech solves their real problems. It looks we've been in a plateau since before the Covid with a couple of exceptions.
- jitbit 2y agoI used to think iPhone revolutionized the World. Now think it ruined it. Internet is a TV form the 80s/90s. Mindless, soulless engagement machine we all stare into.
- xvector 2y agoThe real problem here is that people are incapable of weathering a disruption to their way of life for a long term benefit to humanity. Progress is never linear. It is a jagged line with an upward slope. No major technological leap has been happened disrupting social structures, putting people out of jobs, or causing some sort of moral panic. https://pessimistsarchive.org/ https://pessimistsarchive.org/ Nearly all of them have dramatically benefited humanity in the long term. Your children will live healthier and longer, with fewer extremes of suffering. The drama over AI, in my opinion, simply separates those who think long-term from those who don't. On a long enough timescale, issues like hallucination, theft of artistic IP, etc are a total non-issue. I think it's arguable the anti-AI movement is much more selfish than the pro-AI one. I don't care if I lose my job to create AGI, because the benefit to humanity is worth much more than my job.
- underdeserver 2y agoWith all the negativity in TFA and in the comments, I just want to point out that objectively, the world's gotten a lot better in a lot of ways. Extreme poverty is down to almost nothing. Polio is all but eradicated. Many types of cancer, death sentences just 20 years ago, are treatable. HIV is practically curable. You can learn anything you want on YouTube, Wikipedia, and the wider web with time and effort, for free. (The TFA acknowledges this.) I'm not saying there aren't huge problems. The benefit, to paraphrase, is not evenly distributed. But in nearly every sense it's better to have been born in the 90s than the 60s. We can and should discuss lack of regulation, legal-but-wrong tax evasion, societal risks, there's plenty of bad to go around. But put it in context - there's a lot of good to go around too.
- spwa4 2y agoIf you read the entire article you will get to the problem: the rapid information dissemination tech has provided ... > there is a worrying trend of Tech veering strongly to the right and using the money they get from us and our data for questionable causes. Tech may have ... not given the election outcome leftists wanted. Twice! It now appears tech will not lead to a communist/socialist utopia, and so they are now the enemy. And so, they will, read the paragraph after this statement: > The point of all of this is to say: the tech utopia fantasy is truly dead to me. The image of the cool, hippie, leftist Silicon Valley tech is wrong. The companies themselves and the VC’s they take money from are supporting values and governments that do not act in your best interest and do not even align with their marketing image. Don’t be further misled. Stop giving them your money, time and data as much as possible for you. They won't bring us closer to these ideals they promise. This paragraph comes after more than a page of text pointing out that tech DID in fact, bring a lot of parts, some would say most, of tech utopia. Frankly, I'm pretty damn sure that the actors responsible for the swing to the right are not FANGs, and not even Twitter. The fact that the world has changed and that China, Russia and Iran ... and "that" ideology's extremists ... have started cooperating and have become a real, serious threat to the lives of billions of people, and are actively killing millions ... I feel that has a lot more to do with the current situation than either Facebook or Amazon. Combined with the failure of governments to keep the economic growth of the past 10 years going (e.g. housing, ...)
- nostrademons 2y agoTechnology is still a good thing. It's certain tech business models that are the problem. Tech used to be a tool. I remember participating in product design conversations in the '00s, and the focus was all on "How can we make people's lives better? How do we create software that makes things more convenient for them, more enjoyable, frees up time and opens up new opportunities for them." Tech is now a means to turn people into tools. I still sit in product design conversations. Now they are focused on how to manipulate people into clicking on more ads and opening up their wallet more. The applied psychology is very advanced, and is more of a focus than the technology now. IMHO, the root cause of this is the advertising + subscription business model, along with the provision of free products to get people hooked and then upsell them on expensive and (in the big picture, but customers can't see the big picture) insconsequential upgrades. The secret to success in the tech industry is "Demonstrate value. Nurture dependence. Threaten to take away features, unless large amounts of money are paid." In people terms, we call this an abusive relationship, or blackmail. In the tech industry, it's a very profitable business model. The worst part is this is spreading to other industries like food production and transportation.
- nerdyadventurer 2y ago> IMHO, the root cause of this is the advertising + subscription business model What is your alternative?
- FridgeSeal 2y agoFully agree. A sort of “second order” expression I see of these problems is the sheer quantity of SaaS tools that exist to “fix” a problem, not solve it. These companies have zero interest in actually making anything better. Instead, they exist to sell a “less sharp edges” version of the problem and leech all the money they can. An actual improvement is completely antithetical to their existence, and I suspect most of them would act to destroy a true solution if the opportunity arose.
- acuozzo 2y ago> free products to get people hooked This is due to the WWW which took off only due to its open model (shipping markup source instead of binary blobs) which was inspired by the then-nascent F/OSS movement. That F/OSS "gift culture" really keeps on giving, eh?
- tim333 2y ago>Growing up, there was a more positive view of tech. The future looked awesome I think that may be a bit biased. There was also Threads, Terminator 2, Blade Runner, Robocop, Planet of the Apes, Escape from New York, Brazil, Mad Max and the like. Reality is probably somewhere in the middle.
- znpy 2y ago> The image of the cool, hippie, leftist Silicon Valley tech is wrong. It was never real. Anybody in any of the tech companies mentioned (and many others) has always known. You can buy groceries and social status with a fat paycheque and stocks. You can’t do the same with “just” a clean conscience.
- thuanao 2y agoI personally don’t know what the author is talking about. My whole family now works from home in their pajamas, gets anything they want delivered next day to their door, and has access to all the knowledge in the world literally in their pocket. Is that utopia? I don’t know. But it sure beats life in the 1990s.
- acuozzo 2y agoMy kids (10, 7, and 5) try going outside to play every day and all of the neighbor kids are tucked inside doing whatever the hell it is kids do nowadays. I lived in a very similar suburb in the '90s and had many, many other kids to play with outside every day. Bicycling, sports, adventures, you name it… For them, I am 100% positive that 2024 does not beat 1994. They all seem so ridiculously lonely.
- disqard 2y agoI think you're both right, though in different ways. GP is correct that life today "beats" that from the 90s -- as far as convenience/friction is concerned. OTOH, just like how "sitting is the new smoking", a 100% frictionless life is not better in every way. It atrophies several important faculties like the ability to deal with boredom (or people who aren't exactly your type), focus for long periods of time on work, etc. Viewed from this perspective (and as a parent myself), I agree that 2024 does not beat 1994.
- kelvinjps10 2y agoIdk, but you are able to read my comment thankd tot he advancements of the last decades, if not I wouldn't be able to have learned English from the internet and my life wouldn't have improved so much as it did