14 ms·
Bhutan, after prioritizing happiness, now faces an existential crisis
- no_wizard 2y agoBhutan sounds interesting. I would be very curious to know more about how life is there. Its one thing to provide certain things and prioritize happiness, it is another to provide fulfillment, which is what I suspect the countries young citizens leaving are finding to be the case. Though, with university free, if Bhutan has good, solid universities and produces students in reasonable numbers, since the country appears to be a highly literate english speaking one, I could see them leveraging that to raise the economy by founding outsourcing firms etc.
- user_7832 2y agoFrom my very limited experience having visited the country as a tourist, they appear to lead “simple” lives from the outside. Unfortunately many are not well off, “fortunately” the standards of living are oftentimes simple enough that it’s not a problem. What I can imagine, is that many (youngsters) may rather prefer a more “modern” life with McDonalds and iPhones, particularly if they are able to actually achieve it. Which one is better? I’m not going to comment. But I do want to add as a closing statement that the country (and people) were absolutely amazing. I’d definitely love to go there again if I can, the mountains are pretty much magical and the people really friendly. I hope they manage to succeed, socially speaking.
- amritananda 2y agoI think tourism, especially in countries that rely on tightly controlling the experience, can tell you very little about the function of the country itself. I've had many people say the same to me about Nepal, ignorant of the high youth unemployment rate, the corrupt politicians, the complete lack of any basic infrastructure (schools, transportation, electricity, etc.) in some areas, or the astronomically high number of people leaving to work as migrant labourers in countries that are the absolute worst in the world when it comes to labour rights. None of these problems are visible to you as a visitor. This is especially true if you stick to areas that are heavily trafficked by tourists which tend to be rich enough to cater to their needs.
- user_7832 2y ago> amritananda 1 day ago | parent | context | flag | on: Bhutan, after prioritizing happiness, now faces an... I think tourism, especially in countries that rely on tightly controlling the experience, can tell you very little about the function of the country itself. Fully agree. Much of these observations were from peering out of the van we were in, or casual chats with our guide/hotel employees etc. Coming from Mumbai, there were some “telltale” (If you can call it that) signs. For example do people heat the house, or do they only heat themselves? If home heating, is it electric or burning wood or some other fuel? A lot of homes reminded me of the chawls and 2 storey tarp “kuccha” homes.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jaysonelliot 2y agoI doubt that becoming another "developing economy" where you have to spend 8-10 hours a day working in a call center would increase happiness.
- no_wizard 2y agoAdmittedly I’m unimaginative. I edited that out because it does belie a certain connotation.
- bloak 2y agoThe official language of Bhutan seems to be Dzongkha. Now there's a pub quiz question not many people will be able to answer, I suspect. People being forced to work in call centres, speaking a foreign language, sounds like a kind of neocolonialism and hardly a recipe for happiness.
- conductr 2y agoI wonder if that would be seen as a net negative on the happiness scale due to the fact that people tend to dislike those jobs. I think if you’re taught your whole life to seek happiness, a younger generation could largely look curiously out into the world as a source of happiness. In the western world, when you poll any population of people asking what they are “passionate” about Travel is always going to be a top ranked answer. It brings people joy, exploration is an innate curiosity of humans. So, my guess/hypothesis would be they are looking for happiness as they’ve been raised/conditioned to do.
- devoutsalsa 2y agoI visited there in 2022 right they lifted Covid restrictions. You don’t really get an authentic experience with the locals as you’re with a guide at all times and the standard tourist trip is pre planned, but I’m quite happy I went. Although the daily tourist fee of $200/day just to be in the country felt excessive. I can’t really describe what Bhutan is like, but I did enjoy learning about Drukpa Kunley: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drukpa_Kunley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drukpa_Kunley
- itishappy 2y agoBhutan is also quite energy rich due to hydroelectric power and have been dumping the excess into bitcoin. > Bhutan is fifth among countries holding BTC, after the United States, China, the United Kingdom, and Ukraine. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/bhutan-cashes-33-5b-bitcoin-081756733.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/bhutan-cashes-33-5b-bitcoin-0... (Mistake in title, they've cashed out only $33 million, not billion.)
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoMaybe they could do something more productive with that surplus like host AI data centers? I know those are popping up out west in the US where green energy like wind is more plentiful.
- ponty_rick 2y agoData centers require an ecosystem of technology to exist - skilled manpower, fiber optic network, grid capacity etc, they're probably not up for it yet.
- samatman 2y agoWhen you said "productive", do you perhaps mean socially useful? It takes a lot of AI data center to derive a billion-dollar profit, which is the value just of the Bitcoin which Bhutan currently retains. Seems fairly economically productive to me.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agobitcoin is fiat digital money, its value is all based on how others think it is worth (due to scarcity or whatever); even worse it's price goes up and down rather quickly, making it not very useful as something to exchange goods and services with. AI can actually do productive things. Bhutan could start up a bunch of call centers staffed not by people, but AI agents powered by its green energy.
- andai 2y agoKing thinks democracy is a great idea. Everyone rejects it. King institutes it anyway. Wait a second...
- jollofricepeas 2y agoThe people could vote the same person or party in representing the interests of the king and his family. Dictators can be democratically elected. The real question is how do you protect people from themselves?
- mdp2021 2y ago> how do you protect people from themselves Education.
- flanked-evergl 2y ago> Every one of the popular modern phrases and ideals is a dodge in order to shirk the problem of what is good. We are fond of talking about “liberty”; that, as we talk of it, is a dodge to avoid discussing what is good. We are fond of talking about “progress”; that is a dodge to avoid discussing what is good. We are fond of talking about “education”; that is a dodge to avoid discussing what is good. The modern man says, “Let us leave all these arbitrary standards and embrace liberty.” This is, logically rendered, “Let us not decide what is good, but let it be considered good not to decide it.” He says, “Away with your old moral formulae; I am for progress.” This, logically stated, means, “Let us not settle what is good; but let us settle whether we are getting more of it.” He says, “Neither in religion nor morality, my friend, lie the hopes of the race, but in education.” This, clearly expressed, means, “We cannot decide what is good, but let us give it to our children.”
- mdp2021 2y agoNo, it is just that that one was not the context to discuss the details of sought education. That one did not go into specifics does not mean the specifics are not available in good amount.
- tivert 2y agoIt's sad, but I'm sure there's a certain kind of person who's gloating over this. As in "Haha, those assholes wanted happiness, but my awesome capitalism wins everytime!1!! Join us at the bottom, suckers!!1!" Personally, I kinda feel like people probably have perverse psychological impulses that cause us to make ourselves unhappy and discontented unless there's certain specific external constraints to control those impulses. Modern technology, in its quest to remove all constraint, eagerly removed the necessary ones. It's sort of like fitness: way back, there was no such activity as "exercise," because everyone got enough as a matter of course (e.g. by farming, hunting, walking everywhere). Now no one has to do any of that, "exercise" is a new chore that requires willpower, so we're all getting fat.
- nativeit 2y agoAny chance you were raised Catholic?
- ANewFormation 2y agoImagine a Star Trek existence where any meal imaginable was just a replicator away and a holodeck could enable one to be anybody, have anybody, and do anything - any time and for seemingly no or next to no cost. Many people seem to think this would be a utopia, but I suspect on reality there'd be a mass epidemic of suicide, drug abuse, and so on. It's not about having external constraints, but about having a purpose in life. Of course one could create a purpose but endless hedonism is far more tempting. The history of ancient emperor's, who could have or do essentially anything, and how they approached life is a clear example of both sides of the coin. The only difference between Aurelius and Calligula is one created an artificial purpose for himself, and the other simply indulged in the pleasures of life as an end in itself.
- incomingpain 2y agoAdmittedly I'm not familiar with bhutan. Besides basics, and buddhism connections. Lets take a look. >Prime Minister Tshering Tobgay believes it is ironically the success of Gross National Happiness that has made young Bhutanese so sought after abroad. They are 95th place for GDP. 125th place for HDI. I wouldn't even consider working on 'happiness' with the numbers that bad. Bhutan's balance of trade appears to be entirely negative. So the country is getting poorer. Their GDP numbers are 5% growth every year? That seems impossible. 3% unemployment and 65% participation rate. Lets call it a ~4-5% inflation average or worse. 6.8% interest rate, while never ever being below 6%? So they target what 5%? So its not that GDP growth at 5% is impossible. They are essentially saying they havent had gdp growth in decades, they are hiding a major depression? In the last 10 years Bhutan has doubled their money supply, while population is leaving? LOL incoming government collapse. government debt to gdp is ~130%. 100% is the magical threshold you're not allowed to cross. If you're the federal reserve and Tbills reputation might allow you to go above 100% like the USA in 2020... but Bhutan has no such ability. They likely cant cross ~40% if i were to estimate. Major deficit spending across the last 25 years. Sales tax of 50% Income tax of 30% >Bhutan was, and is today, largely a subsistence agricultural society. Many families still live in multigenerational farmhouses. I'd be leaving as well. Nobody is seeking Bhutan people. The bhutan people are fleeing the inevitable. Bhutan is about 20% debt/gdp from a venezuela level collapse. If by some magic they dont collapse there, they are about 40% from a greece like collapse. Bhutan is already about 10% higher than the Sri Lankan collapse. Fleee Bhutan while you can.
- no_wizard 2y agoAll this seems to be conjecture. Maybe its true that their economy will falter hard, maybe not. I wish we could hear from actual Bhutanese people rather than look at statistics. I suspect the reason people leave is more complex than this.
- incomingpain 2y agoProblem: Young bhutanese are fleeing the country and its a huge problem. Government: "we're doing such a great job, people want to leave." That's the conjecture, or is it more comedy?
- haltingproblem 2y agoSouthern Bhutan’s Lhotshampa people, who were 100,000 mostly Hindu ethnic minority were cleansed under the “One Nation, One People” policy aimed at forced ethnic, cultural, and religious cohesion. They now live as refugees in Nepal. Behind Bhutan's Shangrila facade is a discriminatory policies favoring Buddhists & Drukpa culture remain in place as do discriminatory citizenship laws and restrictions on civil, religious and linguistic rights. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lhotshampa https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lhotshampa
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jaysonelliot 2y agoDespite the headline CBS gave the article, it seems the problem is not with happiness, but with the seductive appeal of materialism and the effects of exposing one culture to another. Social comparison theory is the idea that our satisfaction with what we have isn't an objective measure, but is actually based on what we see other people have. Young people generally seem to have an innate desire to leave their hometowns and seek out what else might be waiting out there for them. When you add in globalization and media influence exposing them to what looks like a "better" life with more things, it's not surprising that they've seen ~9% of young people leave Bhutan. The other question is, what will happen if Bhutan does increase their financial wealth as well as their happiness? Will they then see a net influx of people through immigration, looking for the lifestyle Bhutan promises? And will those new people be able to maintain the culture Bhutan has cultivated? It sounds like the concept of Gross National Happiness is a successful one, on its own, but it brings new challenges that couldn't have been forseen originally. That doesn't mean they can't solve them without giving up their core values.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cardanome 2y agoNah, the issue is the one that many developing countries suffer from: brain drain. The best people leave the country because the can earn orders of magnitude more money in the developed world. This is why countries like the US keep being so successful while developing countries stay poor. It is just the rational best decision for a young people to try their luck abroad and earn more money that they could ever dream of in their home country. Why shouldn't they? Idealism? There is nothing wrong with striving for a better life, it is what moves humanity forward. Offering great and free education will always backfire for developing nations. The solution is to either keep the population ignorant, hamstringing their education so they are less useful abroad and implementing a strict censorship regime so they don't get "corrupted" by the West or well force them to stay. We saw that all play out in the Soviet Block. There is a good reason there was a wall. I think the fairest solution is to NOT make education free but instant offer a deal of having to stay in the country and work for X-years in the profession one has been trained in by the state. Once they get older and settle down they are less likely to leave anyway. Being a developing country just sucks. There is a reason most never break the cycle of poverty.
- flanked-evergl 2y agoIf my government did something as stupid as introduce a Gross national happiness metric, I would be getting out as soon as possible to avoid the gulags that will be following shortly. The most fascinating thing here is that these people managed to convince others that they are smart. > Now this is, I say deliberately, the only defect in the greatness of Mr. Shaw, the only answer to his claim to be a great man, that he is not easily pleased. He is an almost solitary exception to the general and essential maxim, that little things please great minds. And from this absence of that most uproarious of all things, humility, comes incidentally the peculiar insistence on the Superman. After belabouring a great many people for a great many years for being unprogressive, Mr. Shaw has discovered, with characteristic sense, that it is very doubtful whether any existing human being with two legs can be progressive at all. Having come to doubt whether humanity can be combined with progress, most people, easily pleased, would have elected to abandon progress and remain with humanity. Mr. Shaw, not being easily pleased, decides to throw over humanity with all its limitations and go in for progress for its own sake. If man, as we know him, is incapable of the philosophy of progress, Mr. Shaw asks, not for a new kind of philosophy, but for a new kind of man. It is rather as if a nurse had tried a rather bitter food for some years on a baby, and on discovering that it was not suitable, should not throw away the food and ask for a new food, but throw the baby out of window, and ask for a new baby. Mr. Shaw cannot understand that the thing which is valuable and lovable in our eyes is man—the old beer-drinking, creed-making, fighting, failing, sensual, respectable man. And the things that have been founded on this creature immortally remain; the things that have been founded on the fancy of the Superman have died with the dying civilizations which alone have given them birth. When Christ at a symbolic moment was establishing His great society, He chose for its corner-stone neither the brilliant Paul nor the mystic John, but a shuffler, a snob a coward—in a word, a man. And upon this rock He has built His Church, and the gates of Hell have not prevailed against it. All the empires and the kingdoms have failed, because of this inherent and continual weakness, that they were founded by strong men and upon strong men. But this one thing, the historic Christian Church, was founded on a weak man, and for that reason it is indestructible. For no chain is stronger than its weakest link.
- tim333 2y agoI'm not sure there's much correlation between governments wanting their people to be happy and building gulags. I'm not that up on George Bernard Shaw but there is now a World Happiness Report published out of Oxford, not far from where he used to hang out. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Happiness_Report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Happiness_Report
- alephnerd 2y agoTheir "Happiness" marketing was always bullshit. Ask the Lhotshampa (ethnic Limbu, Gurung, and other Janajatis) who were ethnically cleansed by the Ngalop majority 20-30 years ago. It's a banana (tsampa?) monarchy that only exists as a buffer between India and China, and it's entire economy is basically owned by Tata Group (who owns and manages Bhutan's hydroelectric dam used for exports) and Indian construction companies (who build all the roads and resorts in the country).
- 0xDEAFBEAD 2y agoThis article is an interesting case study in the difference between "monarchy" and "dictatorship". The way I think about it, the differences are as follows: * Under monarchy, one person is chosen to rule "at random". Under dictatorship, there is a competition where the most ruthless person gets to rule. * Under monarchy, the people believe the monarch rules by divine right. Under dictatorship, the dictator rules by fear. * Monarchies are more stable, meaning the ruler can plan with a long time horizon. Dictators are more likely to siphon resources while the siphoning is good, since they fear a coup. * Lacking popular legitimacy, a dictator is forced to consider the self-interest and loyalty of their underlings. This leads to extractive and regressive policy. See this excellent video explaining the game theory: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs * Under monarchy, criticism is kept in check while maintaining rule of law, via lèse-majesté laws which make it illegal to criticize the monarch. Under dictatorship, criticism is kept in check via repression. That same repression makes the dictator less popular, which triggers more criticism, and thus more repression, in a doom loop. Monarchy is an imperfect system. A lot comes down to the person who is "randomly" chosen to rule. But I do wonder if monarchy should be considered an option in countries where democracy has been consistently dysfunctional and the population is poorly educated -- Haiti perhaps? Most successful democracies were monarchies at some point in the past. Maybe it's just a phase of development a country needs to go through -- in order to achieve mass literacy and civics education, if nothing else.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoThere is usually nepotism in monarchy though, right? What about enforcing the "at random" part by implementing monarchy as sortition with one person?
- 0xDEAFBEAD 2y agoOr some sort of trial-by-ordeal, where winning the tournament is supposed to correlate with the characteristics that would make for a good monarch.
- aDyslecticCrow 2y ago
- jdietrich 2y agoBhutan's economy is growing, but it still has a nominal GDP per capita of only $3,700. Their youth unemployment rate is 16%, but 24% in urban areas. For all the talk of gross national happiness, it's hard to imagine a young person feeling happy in a poor country with very limited opportunities for upward mobility. I'm also not sure that mass emigration should be seen as an existential threat. Many developing economies have very successfully leveraged emigration and remittances as an engine of economic growth. If Bhutan can modernise into a more open economy, those young people could start returning home with the skills, experience and capital to do great things. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?locations=BT https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?location... https://www.nsb.gov.bt/wp-content/uploads/dlm_uploads/2023/11/Quarterly-Labour-Force-Survey-2023..pdf https://www.nsb.gov.bt/wp-content/uploads/dlm_uploads/2023/1... https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2024/03/11/a-strong-labor-market-is-key-to-bhutan-s-inclusive-growth https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2024/03/11/a-stron...
- psychoslave 2y ago>Bhutan's economy is growing, but it still has a nominal GDP per capita of only $3,700. Their youth unemployment rate is 16%, but 24% in urban areas. For all the talk of gross national happiness, it's hard to imagine a young person feeling happy in a poor country with very limited opportunities for upward mobility. Is it really that hard to imagine? For someone not flooded by continuous stream of advertisements about how far better would be their live if they could buy the next crap the wonderful market planned with obsolescence included, it’s not that hard to imagine the lake of "upward mobility" as a barrier to live happily.
- bluGill 2y agoAdvertisement comes in many forms. Seeing the rich nobles and their kids walk around with something you don't have is a form of advertisement. Poor people are not stupid, they notice when the rich have something interesting and they tend to want that too.
- psychoslave 2y ago
- insane_dreamer 2y agoAnother factor not mentioned is that Bhutan is a tiny and quite isolated country; it's not at all unexpected that young people, who now have the means to go to other countries, would do so. It's a pretty natural thing. It's also possible that a number will return at some point -- enough time hasn't passed to see how this plays out.
- mrala 2y agoThe article literally states this fact: > Bhutan, which is about the size of Maryland, was largely isolated from the rest of the world for centuries. The kingdom was so protective of its unique Buddhist culture that it only started allowing foreign tourists to visit in the 1970s and didn't introduce television until 1999.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoyeah, the unmentioned factor I was referencing is not that it's small and isolated, but rather that it's quite logical that young people in such a situation, once given the opportunity, would explore other countries -- and need to emigrate to do so. It's not like a small country like Luxembourg where you can live there but are within a couple of hours' train ride of thriving major cities in half-dozen countries (why emigrate if you can spend weekends in Amsterdam, Frankfurt, Paris, etc.).
- non- 2y agoIf you don't get past the headline you might miss the most interesting part of this story. Bhutan is building a special economic-zone city, based on Singapore as a model, and designed by Bjarke Ingels. The renders are really striking, many of the major and most important buildings are designed to double as bridges over the river. Skip to 16:52 in the video to see the renders of the planned development "Gelephu Mindfulness City".
- wjSgoWPm5bWAhXB 2y agohow about renaming it to Lhotshampa hatefulness city ?
- tdeck 2y agoIn case anyone wondered this is referring to https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_cleansing_in_Bhutan https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_cleansing_in_Bhutan
- mark000 2y agoThis is an interesting thread related to the subject https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/gisa55/why_did_jigme_singye_wangchuck_exile_so_many/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/gisa55/why_d...
- amritananda 2y agoIMO also a good exploration of the ethnic cleansing of Lhotsampa and the subsequent hardships faced by the refugees is The Lhotsampa People of Bhutan, edited by Venkat Pulla.
- esperent 2y ago> designed by Bjarke Ingels Well, designed by his company which is called BIG. I always find it weird that people name-drop famous architects as if one person could design a city or even a single large skyscraper. That doesn't happen with other industries.
- mmmore 2y agoIf I were tasked with improving Bhutan, one of the things I would focus on is probably lead. 3/4 of Bhutanese children have elevated levels of lead in their blood. https://www.unicef.org/bhutan/press-releases/national-blood-lead-level-survey-bhutan-reveals-3-out-4-children-tested-have-blood https://www.unicef.org/bhutan/press-releases/national-blood-...
- throwaway2037 2y agoWow, this is shocking. What is the root cause? I could not find anything in the article.
- ablation 2y agoSome cursory investigations have revealed that there are lots of lead-painted surfaces [1]. Even children's play equipment [2]. And kitchen utensils [3]. And all the other usual sources, too. [1, 2] = https://www.researchgate.net/publication/365897933_Potential_sources_of_lead_in_children's_environments_Thimphu_Bhutan https://www.researchgate.net/publication/365897933_Potential... [3] = https://www.bbs.bt/national-blood-lead-level-survey-reveals-high-lead-levels-in-75-per-cent-of-bhutanese-children/ https://www.bbs.bt/national-blood-lead-level-survey-reveals-...
- cm2012 2y agoThis is very common in the developing world, due to lax regulations on lead in products.
- mmmore 2y agoThe typical sources are: - Lead paint - Water supply - Lead in cookware - Lead in spices, especially tumeric, where leaded dye is used to make it more yellow - Industrial airborne emissions Leaded gasoline used to be on that list but not anymore. Not sure about the specifics in Bhutan. If you'd like to help prevent lead exposure in countries like Bhutan, the two charities I know about are Pure Earth and LEEP. Not sure if they have Bhutan programs.
- bradleybuda 2y ago
- StefanBatory 2y agoThey pursued happiness by ethnic cleansing of Nepalis. It's why I can't look as a Bhutan as a good place. Bunch of hypocrites pretending to be saints.
- pie420 2y agolet he who hasn't engaged in some ethnic cleansing cast the first stone
- dominicrose 2y ago> The city will have its own legal framework modeled on Singapore's and will run on clean hydroelectric power, with the hope of drawing technology companies, especially AI. AI with an hydroelectric power supply? That's optimistic. At least the power-consuming part of this would have to be somewhere.
- Etheryte 2y agoWhy is that optimistic? Hydro is old, reliable tech, it's always online, and as pointed out in another comment thread, Bhutan has so much excess energy that they're looking for ways to make it useful. Not sure if I see the problem?
- Pikamander2 2y agoTL;DR - The leaders of a highly-religious, homophobic, low-HDI, faux-democracy country get surprised when some of their people want to leave for greener pastures. Turns out that inventing a specific measure of happiness that makes your country look more favorable than it is doesn't change reality.
- the5avage 2y agoWhen their smart young people leave to earn more money abroad, wouldn't it make sense to take smart young people from other countries that aren't that materialistic? Just asking for a friend...
- m3kw9 2y agoBasically saying money can buy happiness
- cryptozeus 2y ago“...pandemic hit Bhutan's economy hard, shutting down tourism. Recovery has been slow..” I wish them good luck however happiness does not put food on table.
- wb14123 2y agoIs it really prioritizing happiness tho? From Wikipedia: > According to the World Happiness Report 2019, Bhutan is 95th out of 156 countries. Not to mention its ethnic cleansing of the non-Buddhist population. There are definitely other things that have higher priority on the government's agenda than people's happiness.
- worik 2y agoThis probably very good news for Butan. The young people seeing the world, expanding their horizons They will be back, especially when they have children I am an interal migrant to a small city in Aotearoa (Ōtepoti) and it is striking how many people grew up here, left as youngsters, and came back to have children Bhutan is not a basket case, it sounds like a good placecto raise a family (as is Ōtepoti, why I am here). Exciting for Bhutan's future
- slibhb 2y agoThe slant of the article is that there's brain drain from Bhutan. But the meat is more interesting. Apparently, Bhutan is building a charter-like city: "A Bhutanese team is collaborating with experts around the world, seeking investors to help build the city, the cost of which is likely to run in the billions. The city will have its own legal framework modeled on Singapore's and will run on clean hydroelectric power, with the hope of drawing technology companies, especially AI." I like this sentence in particular, which showcases an admirable pragmatism: "When we say we follow the principles of Gross National Happiness, we do not mean we are happy with less… We also want to be rich. We also want to be technologically high standard." There has been some buzz around charter cities lately, particularly Prospera in Honduras which has been seized by the government. Bhutan seems like the perfect place for this kind of experiment because it is peaceful, politically stable, and English is taught in schools. There's a chance that we see more city-states like Singapore, Dubai, etc. These places offer something the US can't: social orderliness. Bhutan seems intent on preserving its national identity, which is also draw. Conversely, Dubai (and Neom, if it actually gets built) strike me as a bit soulless.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoSingapore has 8-9x more people than Bhutan, so you'd think Bhutan could become rich fairly quickly as a city state. It doesn't have a port, and it is pretty hard to get to, so I don't think it can be particularly populated unless they manage to flatten a few mountains to build a big airport. It is also one of the sources of the Shangri-La myth, it would be cool if they actually called a city that (China technically renamed Zhongdian Yunnan to Shangri-La, but that is very much a gimmick).
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoTheir northern neighbor infringing on the border and trying to reduce the size of the country?
- cm2012 2y agoIn the end, maximizing GDP per Capita pretty closely maximizes most positive social outcomes. Richer countries are happier, less lonely, kinder to each other, etc.
- MPlus88 2y ago[dead]
- pkphilip 2y agoYoung want freedom. They should be free to choose happiness or an alternate route. The problem is that Bhutan didn't provide that freedom and so now the young are leaving the country to find happiness their way.
- Jeff_Brown 2y agoForbidding skyscrapers will prove counterproductive. People are leaving Bhutan for more money. Cities are more productive because they pack people close. Bhutan can save it's nature and have cities. It can't retain its people without giving them better economic opportunities.