10 ms·
DoNotPay has to pay $193K for falsely touting untested AI lawyer, FTC says
- flutas 2y agoHonestly not that surprised, the only surprising thing to me is how little of a slap on the wrist this feels like. It felt like a shaky premise at best as far back as I can remember. Even "standard" things often have many intricacies that a person might not know to say, and it may not let them know/ask them about it. As an example, think of all the questions TurboTax et. al ask about taxes.
- monkaiju 2y agoGood, AI shouldn't be anywhere near anything where accountability matters...
- ziddoap 2y ago>DoNotPay also did not "hire or retain any attorneys" to help verify AI outputs or validate DoNotPay's legal claims. Wow, that's brave. Create a wrapper around ChatGPT, call it a lawyer, and never check the output. $193k fine seems like peanuts. Sometimes I think about where I would be in life if I had no moral or ethical qualms. I'd probably be running a company like this.
- sixhobbits 2y agoDoNotPay predates GPT by quite a bit -- it used to be pretty positively received on HN e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13822289 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13822289
- ziddoap 2y agoNot sure about the history, I based my comment on this quote from the article: >[...] DoNotPay's legal service [...] relying on an API with OpenAI's ChatGPT. Perhaps they rolled their own chatbot then later switched to ChatGPT? Either way, they probably should have a lawyer involved at some point in the process.
- dragonwriter 2y agoMy understanding is that they had much more linear automation of very specific, narrow, high-frequency processes — basically form letters plus some process automation — before they got GPT and decided they could do a lot more “lawyer” things with it.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agoYes I think you are right about that. Someone else called it "mad libs" and that is very much what it felt like back in 2017/18. Idk why they needed to have a lawyer involved though. Many processes in life just need an "official" sounding response: to get to the next phase, or open the gate to talk to a real human, or even to close the issue with a positive result. Many people are not able to conjure up an "official" sounding response from nothing, so these chatbot/ChatGPTs are great ways for them to generate a response to use for their IRL need (parking ticket, letter to landlord, etc).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- everforward 2y ago"Lawyer" is a regulated term that comes with a lot of expectations of the "lawyer" (liability for malpractice, a bunch of duties, etc). You can't just say that something is a lawyer any more than you could do the same with doctors or police officers. Machines are also not allowed to be the "author" of court documents if they actually get to court (so far as I'm aware). A lawyer has to sign off and claim it as their own work, and doing so without the lawyer reading it is pretty taboo (I think maybe sanctionable by the BAR but I could be wrong).
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y ago>You can't just say that something is a lawyer any more than you could do the same with doctors or police officers Do you think WebMD should be renamed? Lawyers seem to be better at defending their turf than doctors or cops.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agoYes! I used this "AI" tool to help a friend write a letter to her landlord. It was not at all "generative AI" and seemed to just paste modules together based on her answers to its questionnaire. To your second point, it's very funny how OpenAI seems to have soured the tech crowd on tech.
- faangguyindia 2y agoIt's love and hate relationship with AI. All engineers I know in tech are bashing AI left and right and going home to work on AI projects in their free time.
- dukeyukey 2y agoYou can simultanously believe that AI: * Is massively overhyped by certain persons and companies, and * Is both interesting and has loads of promise, so is worth working on in your own time They aren't contradictory at all.
- bee_rider 2y agoActually, I think they are the opposite of contradictory. This tech is dumb, funny, new, and maybe it has potential in the right (low-stakes) applications. Meanwhile, I dunno, I have some begrudging admiration for the folks getting rich selling premium GEMMs, but eventually they are going to piss off all their investors and cause a giant mess. Like good luck guys, get that money, but please don’t take us all down with you.
- whatshisface 2y agoThe ship is sinking, and we're swimming towards the iceberg.
- shadowgovt 2y agoPretty classic hacker behavior. "This sucks. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to go make it better because everyone else working on it is an idiot and I, alone, see the True Way Forward."
- Aurornis 2y ago> it used to be pretty positively received on HN I think people love the idea of DoNotPay: A magical internet machine that saves people money and fights back against evil corporations. Before ChatGPT they were basically mad libs for finding and filling out the right form. Helpful for people who couldn't figure out how to navigate situations by themselves. There is real value in this. However, they've also been running the same growth hacking playbooks that people disdain: False advertising, monthly subscriptions for services that most people need in a one-off manner, claiming AI features to be more reliable than they are, releasing untested products on consumers. Once you look past the headline of the company you find they're not entirely altruistic, they're just another startup playing the growth hacking game and all that comes with it.
- whatshisface 2y agoThere's altruism, running a business, and unrestrained avarice. Sometimes libertarians can be as prone to equating the first two as leftists are the latter.
- thrance 2y agoIn your world, it seems the leftists have it figured out. The purpose of a business is always to maximize profit. EDIT: yeah, yeah, I hear you. You can survive on VC money, and maximize share price instead of focusing on profit. You can also be a small business owned by good people just trying to make a living, but then you still have to not get drowned out by more ruthless competition. The purpose of a business is not always to maximize profit.
- dpassens 2y agoThe purpose of a business is whatever its owners want it to be. Typically, this is maximizing profit, but it could be anything, like getting paid for what you like to do.
- adventured 2y ago> The purpose of a business is always to maximize profit. That's false. The purpose of a business is whatever the owners of that business decide. I've known a large number of business owners that chose less profit in exchange for any number of other attributes they valued more than max profit: more of their own time (working less), better serving a local community by donating a lot of resources / air time (media company), paying employees abnormally higher wages (because said employees had been with them a long time and loyalty matters to some people a lot) - and so on and so forth. Max profit is one of a zillion possible attributes to optionally optimize for as the owner of a business. The larger the owner the more say they obviously will tend to have in the culture. Facebook as a prominent public example, hasn't been optimized for max profit at any point in the past decade. They easily could have extracted far more profit than what they did. Zuckerberg, being the voting control shareholder, chose to invest hilariously vast amounts of money into eg the Metaverse / VR. He did that on a personal lark bet, with very little evidence to suggest it would assist in maximizing profit (and at the least he was very wrong in the closer-term 10-15 year span; maybe it'll pay off 20-30 years out, doubtful). The pursuit of max profit is a cultural attribute, a choice, and that's all. It's generally neither a legal requirement nor a moral requirement of a business.
- gortok 2y ago> it used to be pretty positively received on HN Doesn’t that call into question the decision making of folks on HN rather than being a positive view of the product?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bongodongobob 2y agoYep. Turns out HN is just avg people that think they're really smart because they know how to write code.
- skinnymuch 2y agoLiterally why I stopped going to the comments or commenting. The blind arrogance of tech bros is up there.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoGiven the scope of the topic it appealed in 2016, parking tickets in two specific cities, I can see such a petty case like that be automated. The expansion in 2017 to seeking refuge seems like it'd be a bigger hurdle. But I wouldn't be surprised if that process can be automated a lot as well. Seems like the killing blow here was claiming it can outright replace legal advice. Wonder how much that lie made compared to the settlement. But yes, HN in general is a lot more empathetic towards AI than what the average consensus seems to be based on surveys this year.
- hinkley 2y agoOn a long enough timeline we all (with the exception of narcissists) see our younger selves as little idiots.
- KronisLV 2y ago> It's something I personally find very bizarre, but I've definitely noticed that a lot of people have a very strong mental block about doing things on a computer, or even a browser. It's interesting that many have expressed something similar in regards to the current LLMs, for programming for example: that even if their output isn't exactly ideal, they still lower the barrier of entry for trying to do certain things, like starting a project in Python from scratch in a stack that you aren't entirely familiar with yet.
- paulddraper 2y ago> it used to be pretty positively received on HN HN is a fickle beast
- ryandrake 2y ago> Sometimes I think about where I would be in life if I had no moral or ethical qualms. I'd probably be running a company like this. I think about this all the time. If I didn’t have a conscience, I would be retired by now.
- whiplash451 2y agoYou might be retiring in jail, though.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rollcat 2y agoUnfortunately, "if it's an app, it's legal".
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dangsux 2y ago[dead]
- gosub100 2y ago> if I had no moral or ethical qualms. I'd probably be running a company like this. You mean you'd be like any other corporation or property manager or attorney? If you operate in the confines of the law that's all that matters. If you give normal people the same power to litigate as a billionaire, that's a feature, not a bug.
- ziddoap 2y ago>If you operate in the confines of the law that's all that matters. This is uh.. Yeah. This is what I meant by having no moral or ethical qualms. There are things that I find immoral which are not illegal. I do not do those things, even though legally I could.
- gosub100 2y agoso religious zealotry? man-in-the-sky said "no do that!" ? "This is uh.. Yeah." - can you clarify this remark please?
- ziddoap 2y ago>so religious zealotry? man-in-the-sky said "no do that!" ? What are you on about? I refuse to compromise my morals just because something is legal. That's it. My morals did not come from some god, and they did not come from laws. No idea where you are getting religious zealotry from. >"This is uh.. Yeah." - can you clarify this remark please? Sure. I stopped myself from saying something rude to you.
- photonthug 2y agoPeople that can understand the difference between right and wrong can’t really explain this to people who only understand the idea of what is legally permissible. It’s not about whether the explanation is rational. It’s just that if you really think the law is the last word on ethics and morality then you must be so self interested or ignorant or evil that you’re already not in a position to understand any explanation that’s offered. As a simple example, should we teach children to not lie, or explain that the real error is to get caught telling a lie that didn’t even maximize their profit potential? Do you want corporations or individuals that shape society to be better moral actors than children, or worse? If you don’t understand this kind of thing already, it must be willful.. retreating to the letter of the law in simple situations like this to plead moral and ethical agnosticism is such a transparent and weak position, rhetorically. Everyone knows that you just plan to profit from your willingness to engage in some kind of bad behavior.
- Palmik 2y agoDid they help regular people defend themselves while saving on legal costs or not? Most of these cases wouldn't be defended at all otherwise.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agoThis is exactly the right question. Did they provide value to the user? Yes, nearly any situation in life involving money can be improved with a top lawyer on retainer, but that isn't always viable or economical
- ziddoap 2y ago>Did they help regular people defend themselves while saving on legal costs or not? Do you get a free pass to do shitty things as long as you do some good things too? I am totally onboard with the concept of the business, just not this particular implementation of it.
- pb7 2y agoThat's a little bit how the law works. If you get sentenced for a conviction, your good deeds will affect the decision. Sometimes people get off entirely based on who they are (e.g. athletes, execs, etc).
- ziddoap 2y ago>If you get sentenced for a conviction, your good deeds will affect the decision. Definitely a valid point, but I don't feel comfortable applying the same idea to inanimate entities like corporations. >Sometimes people get off entirely based on who they are (e.g. athletes, execs, etc). On a personal level, I have never agreed with this.
- freejazz 2y agoIn that one circumstance. You don't get to do a little murder because you donated to a charity. Why even bother to act like this is some sort of principle that underlines the legal system?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoIs "brave" a euphemism for stupid.
- lexicality 2y agoI can think of very few situations where someone would say "wow that's brave" and not mean "wow you're an idiot"
- dr_sausages 2y ago[dead]
- omoikane 2y agoI heard it's the British way of saying "that's insane". https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/574974/etymology-of-brave-meaning-insane https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/574974/etymology...
- Narhem 2y agoCrazy people take any advice from people without citing the exact legal clause.
- pdabbadabba 2y agoThen you must find it very frustrating to actually receive legal advice, because it is often more complicated than that and there sometimes is no such clause!
- alexey-salmin 2y agoGiven how bad an average attorney is, I wonder if chatgpt would actually be an improvement.
- jcranmer 2y agoThe average chatgpt legal brief just makes up case law, which is definitely not an improvement even over the worst attorneys out there.
- exe34 2y ago> Sometimes I think about where I would be in life if I had no moral or ethical qualms. I'd probably be running a company like this. I invented smaller variants of deliveroo, airbnb and uber in my mind, around 2008, but I thought no, the only way to make any money would be to exploit people and break laws. honestly, what held me back was more the hassle of lawyers to make it all work. I didn't think I could stomach the effort.
- MangoCoffee 2y agoAnother Silicon Valley startup looking to get rich quick, following in the footsteps of Uber, Airbnb, DoorDash, WeWork...etc, which have all played in the legal grey areas
- bloodyplonker22 2y agoTo prove that that DoNotPay does not work, they will use DoNotPay on themselves to defend against this case.
- debarshri 2y agoDonotpay should have used donotpay to fight FTC ruling back. That would have been the ultimate outcome if they would have won.
- jlarocco 2y agoI'm not sure they mean "LLM based AI". To me it looks like they automated some boilerplate legal forms and marketted it as "AI" to capitalize on the hype.
- ziddoap 2y ago>I'm not sure they mean "LLM based AI" The article states that they use ChatGPT.
- datavirtue 2y agoWhat is morally or ethically wrong with what they did? Maybe it's morally or ethically wrong to prosecute them and take their belongings?
- ziddoap 2y agoI consider boldly lying about the efficacy of your product in your advertisements to be unethical. You don't, I guess. That's fine.
- fortyseven 2y agoLet's ask a chatbot and find out.
- lancesells 2y ago> Sometimes I think about where I would be in life if I had no moral or ethical qualms. I'd probably be running a company like this. And that's why you're not a criminal. This is a criminal act and approved and implemented by criminals. Main thing is in the US it usually pays to do white collar crime as long as it's not too big or too embarassing to politicians.
- guluarte 2y agolmao at least the should have finetuned gpt4
- refurb 2y agoThis is my issue with AI. We know it spits out nonsense sometimes. Not just random questions, but even code generation. It will no doubt improve, but somebody has to confirm that there are no errors in the output. If it has 1 error in 10,000 now, let's say it has a 3 log improvement, so now it's 1 in 1 million. Would that be ok for legal or medical decisions? I don't think so. How about business decisions? Nope. As long as AI is generating output with errors, it's going to have limited use.
- entreunemployed 2y agoWow buddy. I guess we could say the dollar amount you were willing to forego is the price of your sense of superiority.
- ziddoap 2y agoHaha, yeah, feeling very superior over here with my... not lying to my customers. Yep!
- nerdjon 2y agoI am honestly surprised the fine is not more. We need to see more of these come out as AI is shoved dangerously into places thanks to the ability to use it with little to no technical knowledge. Especially when you are really just shoving data into an LLM and expecting a response to do some job, you are not training it to do a specific task. Like the home buying AI that was on HN yesterday.
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoThe fine was about false advertising, not dangerousness. Three of the commissioners signed on to concurring statements emphasizing that they are not opposed in principle to the use of AI in law. (https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/public-statements/concurring-statement-commissioner-melissa-holyoak-joined-chair-lina-m-khan-matter-donotpay-inc https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/p...) (https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/public-statements/concurring-statement-commissioner-andrew-n-ferguson-matter-donotpay-inc https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/p...)
- whiplash451 2y agoLink to related thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41638199 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41638199
- gosub100 2y agoIf a tenant is able to file a case that costs his corporate, PE owned landlord $25k to litigate, that's a win in my book. That's the same landlord who increased the rent 20% per year for the last 5 years because "the Market", well, Blackstone, welcome to the "market" where each eviction now costs you a collateral amount for ruining a hard working persons life. Imagine that, if there were a consequence to greed?
- gradyfps 2y ago"In 2021, Browder reported that DoNotPay had 250K subscribers; in May 2023, Browder said that DoNotPay had “well over 200,000 subscribers”. To date, DoNotPay has resolved over 2 million cases and offers over 200 use cases on its website. Though DoNotPay has not disclosed its revenue, it charges $36 every two months. Given this, it can be estimated that DoNotPay is generating $54 million in annual revenue, assuming that all 250K users subscribe for 1 year."[1] $193K seems like a pittance compared to the money they're making off of this. [1]: https://research.contrary.com/company/donotpay https://research.contrary.com/company/donotpay
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agoThis is founder-raising-funds math (or VC looking for liquidity math). 200k subscribers might not mean paid subs and it certainly doesn't mean 1-year of paid subs. This could be $9M (a single-month of 250 paid subs) or lower.
- pbhjpbhj 2y agoTheir point still stands though. If the output should be reviewed by a lawyer, then the penalty should be all the profits (and maybe also the wages of the CEO) to deter others from doing the same, and ensure that they don't continue in the belief that an occasional 1-2% is perfectly acceptable 'cost of doing business'.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agoMaybe $193k is all that the FTC felt could be attributed to the "deceptive business practices." It's weird to think that the FTC is right about the investigation, but somehow flubbed the penalty
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoI think we need to start taking this sort of thing beyond money. I'm not sure if it's warranted in this case, but in general I'd like to see more shareholders going to jail for things their companies did. If my dog bites somebody, that's on me. It should be no different with a company.
- Mordisquitos 2y agoI love the quote they included in their ads, purportedly from the Los Angeles Time but "actually from a high-schooler’s opinion piece in the Los Angeles Times’ High School Insider": > "what this robot lawyer can do is astonishingly similar—if not more—to what human lawyers do."
- gradyfps 2y agoTo be fair if legal paperwork follows a standard process with standard information, a "robot" can complete many orders of magnitude more than any human lawyer. (I'm also not a lawyer and have no idea if this line of thinking is applicable.)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- raverbashing 2y agoHonestly most lawyers (that I know at least) just keep templates of most common documents and fill in the blanks as needed For basic stuff this is 95% of the end product
- vundercind 2y agoI guarantee it’s going to be impossible to compete as a lawyer in most fields without doing most of the work with LLMs, probably within a few years. I expect the benefits of increased efficiency will be seen as temporarily zeroed inflation for legal services (prices actually going down? LOL) and a bunch of rents, forever (more or less, from the perspective of a human lifetime) to whichever one or two companies monopolize the relevant feature sets (see also: the situation with digital access to legal documents). Lawyers will be more productive but I expect comp will stay about the same. And I think that as someone fairly pessimistic about the whole AI thing.
- woah 2y agoAnd 95% of a doctor's job is just saying "your checkup looks OK Joe, just try to get some exercise and eat more fiber".
- manofmanysmiles 2y agoIt's amazing to me that people think they need other people to resolve disputes, or that "law" is some kind of magic... And yet people keep thinking so, both selling it as magic, and buying it as magic, and not once taking the time to consider what the words on the paper might mean.
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_consensus_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_consensus_effect
- toast0 2y agoIt's the same with plumbing, wiring, programing, writing, cooking, gardening, and most of the other verbs. For the most part, everyone can do these things, but it's nice to pay someome else to do it; especially in fields where experience gives expertise and hopefully wisdom. Also, it's handy to hire a licensed practicioner in fields where government requires licensure to sell services. Some people are really woried about making big mistakes that are expensive to clean when plumbing or wiring or lawyering. It's a legitimate thing to consider.
- twojacobtwo 2y agoIt's a matter of opportunity costs as well. If you want to be able to do plumbing, wiring, framing... you likely don't also have the time to learn the potentially vast amount of knowledge required to adeptly navigate the legal system. > Some people are really woried about making big mistakes that are expensive to clean when plumbing or wiring or lawyering. Even worse, if you lawyer wrong (or wire wrong), you might not be able to clean it up - you just do your time or perhaps die.
- krick 2y agoThere's a difference, though. Law and medicine are fields with very strong gatekeeping. You also need a licence for many construction engineering roles, and in fact both stakes and accountability there are much higher than in the former two (in fact, it is a bit appalling, how little lawyers and doctors are hold accountable for stupid shit they do, if they follow the playbook), and realistically you need to learn as much if not more to be a good construction engineer (but most construction engineers are not especially good, just as most lawyers and doctors aren't very good), but you don't see so much reverence towards construction engineers, and there are much fewer artificial borders for one to learn construction engineering.
- whoisjuan 2y agoThis is a very sneaky ethically gray company. Their app is not only of terrible quality but also full of dark patterns. I'm convinced that any revenue they make comes from people who can't figure out how to cancel. Stay away from it.
- ec109685 2y agoIronic given the app’s purpose.
- pnw 2y agoEven before AI, that website has been making overly optimistic claims for many years. It was never clear to me how real or effective it was. The Wikipedia article has more detail but it seems like this is the first time the government has actually called them out? Of course this didn't stop them raising $10m from credulous investors in 2021.
- popcalc 2y agoIn 2021 a literal discord group raised several million dollars so take that into consideration.
- beerandt 2y agoHas the chance to make their best marketing material yet.
- nashashmi 2y agoFTC overreached here: the AI was not tested to see if it is like a lawyer’s level of work. Why would anyone have to do this kind of study? Back in the day, anyone who touted AI generated works by default exclaimed that the work was not as good as a human. That changed now but was a valid statement back then.
- lupusreal 2y ago> Why would anyone have to do this kind of study? Because the company chose to publish ads with misleading claims about the efficacy of their system.
- snakeyjake 2y agoI have not seen any evidence that AI output can reach quality levels of a human. Any non-trivial code generated by it takes more time to debug than just writing it from scratch. Its "art" is abominably bad and repetitive. Text generated by AI reads like corporate ad copy written by several committees of committees. "Lovecraftian nightmare" best describes its video output. AI voice generation sounds like soulless ripoffs of famous voice actors (the Attenborough clone is the worst) with misplaced stresses and an off-putting cadence derived from being completely unable to understand the broader context of the work it is narrating. Its explanations on things are inferior to the first paragraph of any wikipedia article on the query topic. A child with a pirated copy of FL-Studio can make more interesting music. The wall being erected by AI customer service agents between a problem and an actual human who might be able to solve it is frustrating and useless. On top of all of that the answers it confidently gives (almost always with no sources) are often extremely wrong. Is there a secret AI product everyone is using that is actually good? Edit: AI is however extremely good at rapidly creating an endless stream of barely-passable content designed to distract very cheaply so I expect its use by marketing and social media firms to continue its meteoric rise.
- faangguyindia 2y ago> it's not about trivial vs not trivial. It's about how common the code is which you are asking the AI to generate and how much contextual clues it has to get the generation right.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoOfficial release: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/09/ftc-announces-crackdown-deceptive-ai-claims-schemes https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/09/...
- swalsh 2y agoThe problem with today's technology is it is indistinguishable from magic. Sometimes the magic is real, sometimes it's an illusion. It's nearly impossible as a regular consumer not deeply knowledgable of the current capabilities of models to know which is which.
- dboreham 2y agoOk well it seems my test for whether we really have AI yet (are there self-driving lawyers) remains unsatisfied. For me lawyers work is significantly easier to automate with some proto-AI than is software development or driving a car. So although recent AI progress is highly impressive, I'm not retiring until it takes over the lawyers.
- zulban 2y agoIt's not a question of how easy it is to automate it. It's about how frequent and costly the mistakes are. Lawyer AI is a high bar - plus the people watching you are human lawyers, exactly the kind of people who can make your mistakes more costly.
- BarryMilo 2y agoTruly one of the worst takes on AI I've seen. What is the purpose of a lawyer? It's not to read the law, the text is free (or should be). It's to advise you, based on the law but also on the immediate, historical and sociopolitical coontext, as well as on their understanding of the characters of all the humans involved. If that gets automated, we are in AGI territory.
- natch 2y agoYour first paragraph with very small tweaks (laws of physics etc., not law) could also apply to human attendants in elevators. The second paragraph… hard to make a call on that one.
- Palmik 2y agoThe legal system has a great sense of self preservation. They will surely fight anything that possibly encroaches on their domain, especially things that give non lawyers the tools to defend themselves without feeding the machine.
- lolinder 2y agoSometimes the enemy of my enemy is still my enemy. Many organizations that purport to be helping the little guy are actually just exploiting them for profit.
- RustySpottedCat 2y agoAs is the case with this exact company " Fight Corporations Beat Bureaucracy Find Hidden Money " this is exactly and entirely the thing a exploiting company would say it does.
- mcheung610 2y agoDoNoPay has to pay a fine is just an irony.
- abixb 2y agoHaha, my thoughts precisely. The first 4 words of the title were bewildering for me for a few seconds.
- throwaway29812 2y agoCould they...employ their own services?
- yapyap 2y agooh the irony
- K0balt 2y agoMy bet is they won’t pay.
- RobotToaster 2y agoMaybe they can use their own AI to get out of paying it?
- winddude 2y ago'''"None of the Service’s technologies has been trained on a comprehensive and current corpus of federal and state laws, regulations, and judicial decisions or on the application of those laws to fact patterns," the FTC found''' Wow!! That seems so simple, and literally a few weeks to do in today's ecosystem, now thoroughly testing make take a little more time, but wow, I wonder if it was evening attempting to do RAG.
- fudged71 2y agoLawyer Kathryn Tewson on Twitter has been calling them out for a long time https://x.com/kathryntewson/status/1838995653630083086?s=46 https://x.com/kathryntewson/status/1838995653630083086?s=46
- btbuildem 2y agoFunny thing is, they're probably still ahead financially vs if they actually hired lawyers to do this on the up-and-up.
- lifeisstillgood 2y agoYes, I get it they did a bad thing. But most of what they are setup to fight is people abusing the legal system so it’s not unfair to fight fire with fire surely? As an example I parked my car to drop my daughter off at a party and paid online - but mistyped the little number for the car park and ended up paying for 3 hours parking somewhere across the country. Naturally the private car park tries to charge me 20x the parking fee as a “fine” - which they can whistle for frankly. But they sent varying letters that sound but don’t actually say “court” or “legal action” (things like “solicitors action prior to court” I kept sending them the same answer they kept rejecting it Then they actually sued me in county court. Oh wow I thought I better pay. And as a court judgement is really bad on credit record (one above bankruptcy) it’s serious. But I checked the court website anyway to be extra careful. And Incoukd challenge it - actually appear before the beak and say “hey it’s not my fault”. So I filled in the form that says “yes I will challenge it, see you in court” That might my wife said don’t be fucking stupid they have won pay them So I went back the next day - and guess what - they had after 9 months withdrawn their action against me, no further need to progress, cancelled I called the court to find out WTF They had, and do every week, mass spammed the court with hundreds of parking cases, knowing that pretty much everyone would act like my wife pay a couple of hundred quid not to risk their credit record. I mean a county court judgement and you can kiss a mortgage goodbye. That is simple abuse - an overworked courts system, hundreds probably thousands of rubbish claims that are put simply to strong arm people to pay up with legal threats, and no genuine attempt to filter out cases with merit, or even only look at “repeat offenders” But is it worth the time of any parliamentarian to take this on (well frankly yes it would be great backbencher cause celeb, but what do I know. Anyhow there was a point here - there are many many legitimate companies whose ficking business model is based on legal strong arming anyone who makes a minor infraction and that’s ok, but having a scam my business model to fight the scammy business model is bad? Yes DoNotPay could have stayed on the right side of the line - but then would frankly run out of money. I guess we can only put our Hope in the hands of our elected representatives:-)
- balls187 2y agoIn the US, parking and private parking lots are easily one of the scammiest businesses.
- shahzaibmushtaq 2y agoI think DoNotPay and find out is the vision of this company.
- system2 2y agoI am stopping myself from releasing shitty chatgpt wrappers which I see at every trade expo. I am just not doing it because I don't want to add more shit to the shitshow.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dcchambers 2y ago> initially was advertised as "the world's first robot lawyer" with the ability to "sue anyone with the click of a button." There is no world in which allowing that to happen is a good idea.
- praveen9920 2y agoI understand the sentiment but to be fair this is currently happening everywhere but only the rich people have access as they are the only one who have lawyers on retainer. Access to legal services to poor will change things. In short term, judicial system will be overwhelmed and are forced to adopt new and efficient procedures.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rideontime 2y agoAbout time. I've been waiting on this one for a couple years now.
- Crackula 2y ago1. Amusing title 2. Yea it sounds like a smug and shitty company But 3. If I get some parking ticket or some small wrong doing I am totally going to consult with GPT before I go ahead and hire a lawyer. A well trained AI could definitely do the work of most lawyers better than they could. Lawyers and judges usually just recite rules, previous cases and known loopholes. They are a human search engine and they cost quite a bit.
- tonygiorgio 2y agoThere’s a lot of hate for the AI marketing aspects, and that AI isn’t up to par for full lawyer replacements, but they’ve been around with a very working and usable app before way before the AI hype. Lawyers at huge firms or companies automate the hell out of their legal actions against normal citizens and get things wrong all the time. But it’s okay if they do it because they’re part of the same cabal keeping the legal system afloat. Say what you want negatively about some dark patterns and marketing BS, they’re making legal things affordable to the every day person. The fine seems fair for overhyped marketing claims, but I hope they keep going and improving.
- op00to 2y agoI prefer to tout the unfrozen caveman lawyer.
- this_steve_j 2y agoIf you mess with the bull, you get the horns!
- delilahnoah 2y ago[flagged]
- theknocker 2y ago[dead]
- Habgdnv 2y agoWhat a title: "DoNotPay has to pay." Can't they ask ChatGPT to write some objection and, at the end of the prompt, put "but make it look like it was written by a lawyer" and send that to the court to waive the fine? Please read my comment as a joke. The title really sounds funny!