15 ms·
Then maybe "taking over the market" is a bad metric, and we should be optimizing for making a company that makes the workers' lives better. The US cultural bias
by stavros 2y ago
Then maybe "taking over the market" is a bad metric, and we should be optimizing for making a company that makes the workers' lives better. The US cultural bias is showing here, as it's assumed that profit is above all else, and a company that forgoes profit to make workers happier must thus be less good.
The vast majority of people in companies are workers. Let's stop optimizing for owner wealth and start optimizing for worker happiness instead.
- vrotaru 2y agoStop optimizing for consumers, start optimizing for producers. Maybe, you want to rethink that.
- stavros 2y agoWhy? It sounds good to me.
- vrotaru 2y agoJust an example. Should teachers be judged on how a pleasant life they live, or how good they teach?
- Qwertious 2y agoThat's not as relevant as you'd think - the "customers" of teachers are, arguably, taxpayers and not children. Alternatively it's parents, or perhaps politicians who set the budget. Focusing on children is the more pro-social preference, but children who attend schools famously don't have jobs in functioning societies. More importantly, the teaching system is basically un-incentivized by incentives - teachers in the US (focusing just on the US for a sec) are incredibly underpaid, and basically rely on masters-degree teachers putting in effort completely disproportionate to the pay. Everyone accepts this state of affairs specifically because we're all ignoring market incentives in favor of the good of society (i.e. the quality of childrens' education). So, let's suppose we judge teachers based on how well they appease politicians and parents who support their funding: they pass all students, regardless of how poorly they do on tests and how badly the children need to just repeat the year. This is a terrible outcome, and yet you're implicitly endorsing it.
- Droobfest 2y agoObviously by how well they teach, but if we give them a stake in their teaching performance, their teaching should improve even more…
- seneca 2y agoThey do have a stake in their performance. It's their salary. If their performance is poor, in a functioning system they lose that salary.
- vundercind 2y agoI assure you that being allowed to teach well would greatly increase the pleasantness of life for a hell of a lot of teachers. Nobody gets into teaching for the money—and, for that matter, there’s not a clear connection between doing it well and any kind of rewards at all, as it stands.
- chasd00 2y agoTeaching is a good example. When you teach in public schools which is basically where the "people own the means of production" since the school is paid for by the taxes collected by an elected government, you're absolutely right. No rewards for quality teaching basically at all. However, if you're really good at teaching you can teach at a private school and reap a lot more rewards. Better pay, better recognition, a better work environment this list goes on and on. /wife is a teacher and has taught in both public and private highschool
- vundercind 2y agoYeah. Depends—fancy upper-middle-class and higher private schools are like that. The majority aren’t that sort, and both pay and perform on a similar level to public schools, if not worse. But the good ones, the ones people really think of when they say “private school” (but not the actual majority of such schools) do pay better and often have really good perks (the PTA-equivalent Christmas and end-of-year gifts you get at some private schools—damn!) As a bonus, private schools are usually way more willing that public schools to tell annoying parents to get bent. Which is a pretty big perk on its own.
- kvgr 2y agoGood luck producing and not selling.
- Arainach 2y agoStop optimizing for financial leeches sucking value out of the system and externalizing all the societal consequences, start optimizing for the vast majority of the population. ....sounds better when you elaborate on the categories you selected.
- robertlagrant 2y agoThe vast majority of the population are consumers. Each of us consumes far more services than we produce. Making life better for consumers is making life better for everyone.
- tempfile 2y agoBy definition, the average person consumes as much as they produce. Generally speaking, the poorer someone is, the more they produce relative to what they consume. Making life better for producers improves the lot of the poor; making life better for consumes improves it for the overconsumers (i.e. the rich).
- brabel 2y agoYou're ignoring the proportions. Your happiness is maybe 80% related to your job and salary (at least up to a point where you can be considered wealthy, after that there's decreasing returns), and each product you consume from each different company affects your wellbeing by a minuscule amount. Even adding them all up won't give more than, say, 15% as most of your expenses are not on products, but things like housing and transport. Given that, if you could make everyone's jobs more fullfilling and increase people's salaries at the cost of things costing a bit more, you would definitely increase overall wellbeing. People would afford a small amount less, but that would not impact them significantly, or maybe at all. The problem I see is that in global competition, you may be put out of business by countries that give much less shit about worker's wellbeing because people will still spend almost all their money on the cheapest available option (even more so if they can afford less!), and that IMHO explains why American companies have taken over so many markets overseas (and now, China seems to be doing it even more). When that happens, everyone in the country loses. So there needs to be a balance, which I think Europe is doing more or less well: people still have great working conditions but can afford less than in the USA, where people have very near the worst possible working conditions (nearly no vacation mandated by law, no parental leave, no healthcare except for the best jobs), but can buy more useless stuff.
- aziaziazi 2y agoCompany profits is not always aligned with consumer interests, didn’t understand why you switched them.
- Gormo 2y agoNot always, no, but as the general case, they are. At the end of the day, people need to be willing to pay a business in exchange for its goods and services, and if they don't feel like they are obtaining net positive value from the transaction, they won't be.
- JohnFen 2y ago> if they don't feel like they are obtaining net positive value from the transaction, they won't be. Excepting for the cases where people have no other choice.
- consteval 2y agoI think key word here is "feel". The reality is that modern products are absurdly complex, and consumers truly don't know what is (and isn't) worth their money. Which is why marketing, making people "feel" a certain way, is SO important. Maybe even more important than the product itself. I mean, do you know how any of your food is produced? If you wanted to verify that the ingredients are what they say they are, can you? If you're buying a car how confident are you the transmission is reliable? Do you actually understand how the transmission is designed OR... is it just brand name? It's brand name, right. Ultimately companies don't need to, and are better off not, producing high quality and safe goods. It makes much more sense to produce lower quality goods and reinvest the savings into advertising. The consumer won't know the difference, and they couldn't find out even if they wanted to.
- ogmanreal 2y ago[flagged]
- jandrewrogers 2y agoEveryone is both a producer and consumer, these are not different groups of people. While production is a prerequisite for consumption, producers have interests as consumers.
- kerkeslager 2y agoWell, it sounds like a step up from most companies, which is don't optimize for consumers, don't optimize for producers, optimize for shareholders.
- devnonymous 2y agoYep! ..and when workers are owners, optimizing either ways works !
- konschubert 2y agoExcept for the part where the company gets outcompeted and goes bankrupt. And no, we cannot just outlaw competition. Having an efficient economy is important and valuable because it allows us to have a higher standard of living while putting in less work.
- Nevermark 2y agoNobody suggested outlawing competition, or made any points that would imply anything related to that.
- consteval 2y agoThey get outcompeted because worker-owned companies aren't allowed to be leeches. You can't have your workers own negative shares. But, many companies (especially those really competitive ones!) just... don't make money. It's easy to be a big disrupter like Uber when you make -500 million dollars a year for 15 years. Naturally that wouldn't when you aren't on capital welfare.
- robertlagrant 2y agoHow does this work in practice, though. It's easy to say what you're saying, or go slightly further and say "let's stop optimising for work and start optimising for everything to be free". What's the actual plan?
- stavros 2y agoI'd encourage you to Google for some articles on how worker-owned coops stay in business. This isn't a radical new idea that's never been tried.
- robertlagrant 2y agoObviously they exist. But they are only certain types of business. How is a company that requires hundreds of millions of dollars before it's profitable supposed to be a co-op? Step by step?
- Nevermark 2y agoIt would be nice to have a legal framework for companies to increase employee ownership, but be able to do it incrementally with no requirement to go straight to 100%. Or ever. For instance, even public companies might increase the percentage of employee ownership over time. But capital needs could still be met, as the public or private non-employee stock class would still exist.
- robertlagrant 2y agoBut it would be nicer if everything were free, though. Why would an investor invest in a company that, if it fails, they lose their money, and if it succeeds, their ownership is taken away?
- Nevermark 2y agoNobody “takes” ownership. Owners are bought out. For a public company that just means buying back shares. A company whose employees care very much about share price sounds good to me. It is not much different from companies who let employees “take” options. That could be financially mismanaged too. There would need to be a rational structure.
- dash2 2y agoBetter still, optimize for social value provided. If taxes and regulation are right, companies that provide social value will make profits and their owners will get rich. The proposed changes would make that less likely to happen. If nothing else, (a) individual companies all optimizing their own workers' welfare does not add up to optimizing the welfare of all workers and (b) non-workers are left out of the equation.
- kerkeslager 2y agoAs opposed to now, when non-executives and non-shareholders are left out of the equation...
- jjmarr 2y agoThis is the purpose of the mixed economy in which most of us live. The government changes the rules of the game to try to align the profit motive with social good, because they are naturally not aligned. You haven't said why worker cooperatives optimizing the benefit of their own workers wouldn't add up to more welfare if the entire economy was based around worker cooperatives. in my opinion worker ownership of the means of production is just socialism, and that doesn't have a good historical track record.
- malcolmgreaves 2y ago> good historical track record Please cite some sources that are not communist countries. You know, “just socialism.” You way want to also ignore the existence of Norway, much of Europe, and popular US federal programs too when you're doing this exercise.
- blackhawkC17 2y agoNorway has more billionaires per capita than the USA. It’s not socialist in any sense. It’s a diehard capitalist country with a lot of public services and welfare (funded by taxes generated under a capitalist system).
- trinsic2 2y ago
- wkrsz 2y agoWould those companies be able to compete in a global market?
- anentropic 2y agoIt's in the employees self-interest for that to be so
- arrowsmith 2y agoOveroptimize on worker happiness -> underoptimize for profit -> company goes bust -> workers lose their jobs -> no worker happiness
- stavros 2y agoWell, there are worker-owned coops, and they haven't gone bust, so how does that work? It's almost as if the workers don't actually want to lose their jobs!
- MichaelZuo 2y agoSurvivorship bias. You have to compare against all that have in fact gone bust over the same timeframe.
- dukeyukey 2y agoIf anything, co-ops seem to survive better than traditional companies - https://www.uk.coop/sites/default/files/2020-10/co-operative_survival_1.pdf https://www.uk.coop/sites/default/files/2020-10/co-operative...
- MichaelZuo 2y agoDid you reply to the wrong comment?
- _s_a_m_ 2y agoThat's the cliché, and I dont think it's even remotely true.
- vidarh 2y agoLast time I looked at data, worker coops were less likely to fail than most other corporate structures.
- Jensson 2y ago
- lupusreal 2y agoIf every company that offers goods or services prioritizes "worker happiness", by for instance refusing to excise unproductive divisions, then the result will be a world where everything costs more and takes longer. Not just consumer goods, but any sort of public infrastructure project, R&D, etc. If you think it takes too long or costs too much to build a school or fix a road in America these days compared to a few generations ago, it would only get worse. Every single sector of the economy would start dragging its feet with no regard for efficiently getting shit done. If only some companies are coops, then those have to compete with companies that aren't and consequently they have to work efficiently or fail. The idea behind making them all be coops seems to be removing this pressure to perform. Bad idea.
- stavros 2y agoEverything already costs more, because companies make crazy margins to make Bezos richer instead of making their products cheaper.
- lupusreal 2y agoIf coops could be more productive for less money they could beat out their competition without needing it outlawed. It should be easy for them if what you say is true, no Bezos means they have more margin to work with but they struggle to compete... Hmm..
- stavros 2y ago"If companies who don't optimize for profit optimized for profit they would be the same as the companies who optimize for profit" is fairly obviously true, and also useless.
- lupusreal 2y agoSo are you conceding that an economy built entirely out of coops would suffer from reduced productivity?
- perryizgr8 2y ago> we should be optimizing for making a company that makes the workers' lives better. Sure, you're free to optimize for anything you like. As am I and everyone else. I don't think there are any legal hurdles to set up a company that is fully owned by its workers.
- solidninja 2y agoWell maybe "taking over the market" is also a monopolistic and anti-competitive practice and if we had say, working regulation that forbade the existence of these behemoth companies then the landscape of value would look a little different.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 2y agoThis is maybe an underappreciated point, an employee-owned company with in a monopoly (or near monopoly) market position will act just as aggressively to screw over their captured consumer base as any other private ownership model. The employees may be better off, but the rest of us will suffer the same.
- throwaway7ahgb 2y agoAgreed, COOPs don't fundamentally change human behavior which has doses of greed. A large COOP monopoly will suffer the same fate as others'.
- shkkmo 2y agoThis is an assumption and one that I believe is faulty. Humans' caring is often related to the degree of connection. Employees at a company are more closely connected to their customers than investors and are thus more likely to care more about those customers. Monopolies are still bad either way, but I doubt that the failure modes at employee owned monoploes is the same as at outside investor owned monopolies.
- photonthug 2y agoYeah. Saying "COOPs don't fundamentally change human behavior which has doses of greed" is like saying that a kingdom works the same way as a democracy since hey, it's all just humans. Simply involving more decision makers is a meaningful change. Certainly involving more decision makers that are outside of the business/legal/accounting class is a meaningful change.
- zby 2y agoTo take over the market companies need to attract customers - i.e. make their lives better. Usually there are more consumers than employees - so I think that measure works quite well with optimising for humans. Profit is a side effect of taking over the market. But actually to have any employees companies need to optimize for workers lives anyway. And it seems that cooperatives are not any better in this area - otherwise everybody would work for cooperatives.
- kerkeslager 2y ago> To take over the market companies need to attract customers - i.e. make their lives better. Usually there are more consumers than employees - so I think that measure works quite well with optimising for humans. Profit is a side effect of taking over the market. Quantity of people benefitted isn't the only measure: magnitude of benefit is also relevant. The customer at a 7Eleven benefits in that they get to... what, buy snacks conveniently? Versus the worker who receives their entire livelihood and benefits, it becomes obvious that workers are the primary beneficiaries of a company. > But actually to have any employees companies need to optimize for workers lives anyway. This is quite obviously false. All companies have to do is present a united front on keeping pay low and benefits nonexistent to prevent workers from having better options. I.e. USA 2024. > And it seems that cooperatives are not any better in this area - otherwise everybody would work for cooperatives. Why is that exactly?
- throwaway7ahgb 2y ago>All companies have to do is present a united front on keeping pay low and benefits nonexistent to prevent workers from having better options. I.e. USA 2024. Can we leave the cynical antiwork comments out? They aren't helpful. This is obviously not the case for a majority of companies and anecdotes don't help. Everyone is for the highest pay possible until they run their own company and have to provide payroll.
- ClumsyPilot 2y ago> Can we leave the cynical antiwork comments out? They aren't helpful. This is obviously not the case for a majority of companies and anecdotes don't help. Major companies are regularly prosecuted for conspiracy to suppress wages. It if weren't for government intervention your wages would be much lower and there wouldn't be anything you can do about it. This blind faith that billion dollar corporations would behave ethically is highly inappropriate https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-tech-jobs-settlement-20150903-story.html https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-tech-jo...
- tomp 2y agoI think this is just your anti-capitalist bias showing. “Market” is meant in purely game-theoretic terms. > The vast majority of people in companies are workers. Let's stop optimizing for owner wealth and start optimizing for worker happiness instead. All these workers could set up cooperatives and work for / own them instead. The fact that this hasn’t happened suggests that in reality, the for-profit companies are better at optimising workers happiness than cooperatives (maybe they pay better? Maybe they enable more job hopping?)
- fileeditview 2y agoI think that's a bad argument. Founding your own cooperative makes you kind of an entrepreneur but joining one doesn't. Most workers are joiners not creators in terms of companies. And I bet more than a few of them would gladly become a partial owner of the company they are working for. But there are so few cooperatives that the chance of you joining one is very slim anyways.
- Aeolun 2y ago> The fact that this hasn’t happened suggests that in reality, the for-profit companies are better at optimising workers happiness than cooperatives Or everyone is too exhausted from their daily grind to even consider doing so, which is honestly not very surprising.
- bialpio 2y ago> All these workers could set up cooperatives and work for / own them instead. And some people do that (modulo creating coops), just not middle-class people. No-one without a decent cushion would be able to risk it. Especially with health care being tied to employment.
- consteval 2y agoThis only works if you assume we are in a free market. We are not, and no such market has ever existed. Setting up a coop versus setting up a company aren't on equal ground. One has clear legal roads, and the other is perceived as communism by 50% of Americans. Sorry, it just doesn't work that way. It's a similar argument I hear against unions - "well go work somewhere else!" The problem is that it's just not equal. Companies have infinitely more power and leverage than laborers. The labor market is EXTREMELY skewed in favor of companies. If we want the labor market to not be skewed like this, we will need to allow (and even force) laborers to unionize. That's just not gonna happen. In practice union busting is not only allowed, its perceived as a good thing.
- pembrook 2y agoThe point of a company is to make a product that customers want, and make it as accessible as possible. “Taking over the market” and producing profit is only a byproduct of doing that. A competitor would wipe out that profit if there existed a cheaper option that delivered the same value to customers. The minute you start optimizing for employees instead of customers, you’re delivering less value to customers (the world) and asking to be disrupted. This is good. In the US a vast majority of adults now own index funds (either via their personal retirement or public pensions). In fact, the largest shareholder in almost all public companies is some index fund. So workers do own the companies, in proportion to how much value they deliver to the world due to market cap weighting. The system we have now has evolved out of thousands of years of humans battle-testing various other systems. The current form has taken pretty much the entire world out of devastating poverty at breakneck speed. Seems like we shouldn’t redesign it based on the whims of armchair internet commenters.
- tempfile 2y ago> The point of a company is to make a product that customers want, and make it as accessible as possible. Who says? What if we said the point of a company was to make its employees' lives better? > In the US a vast majority of adults now own index funds in proportion to their wealth. That's the problem - ownership is distributed unevenly, and the inequality causes social problems.
- pembrook 2y agoWhat if we said the point of a company was to make its employees' lives better? Good news. The world spent the entire last century experimenting with that idea. It did not work out well. I’ve already explained why. But, you are of course free to start a company doing that. If it turns out to produce better outcomes for customers (the world), you will win and society will win! I’m guessing you won’t test your ideas though, and will instead vote for authoritarian central planners who will deploy this straight to production via laws. Then your country will cease growing, and will be forced to slowly dismantle this worker-optimized system as a result. See Europe over the next 50 years for more info.
- ozim 2y agoApple has 160k employees - biggest holder of Apple stock is Vanguard that has 50M customers who are de facto owners. Let’s skip other investment companies to make it easy and assume every Vanguard customer owns piece of Apple. By the virtue of your argument we should optimize owners wealth because there are more owners than employees. World is much much more complicated to be throwing simple arguments like that :)
- infecto 2y agoWhy are there so many more startups in the US compared to Europe? While not a perfect measurement, there is more innovation and economic generation that happens in the US compared to Europe. Time will prove which culture of business wins.
- kerkeslager 2y agoWhy is number of startups a metric we care about? Are we just asking rhetorical questions that pick out one data point that we think supports our presupposed notions?
- vundercind 2y ago… especially when those startups are overwhelmingly outsourced R&D for monopolists, not in actual competition with those monopolists.
- piva00 2y ago1. A larger, wealthier, cohesive consumer market sharing language, and culture. 2. A business-first, citizens-second approach to society. 3. Wealthier, and less risk-averse investors (ties back to point 2.). Simply put, very different societies (even more considering Europe is not at all a homogeneous block), with different priorities, both extremely wealthy by global standards. The question is more: which model is more sustainable as a society in the long-run, that play is still ongoing and we might not have a clear answer for the next 30-50 years.
- Gormo 2y ago>2. A business-first, citizens-second approach to society. This is meaningless. Businesses are activities undertaken by people. Everything resolves back to the people -- the same aggregation of the same individual people in all cases. Reifying the abstraction of "business" to treat it like some separate entity that's at odds with the very people who are engaging in the actual activity that term describes is a monumental confusion of ideas.
- Gormo 2y agoYou are making normative arguments, but the question is wholly empirical -- the metrics being applied here are the ones that actually measure the success and viability of firms, not metrics selected to fit the observer's emotional attachments. Firms that are optimized for turning market demand into revenue streams will naturally outcompete firms that are optimized for other goals, regardless of what ideals or preferences anyone bears. This isn't something that anyone can decide upon, so a call to action based on one's own "ought" preferences isn't really meaningful.
- danaris 2y agoThat's what laws and regulations are for: ensuring that entities that are trying to do the right thing and make life better for actual humans aren't "outcompeted" by entities that are trying to make things better for themselves at everyone else's expense.
- Gormo 2y agoThat might be what their proponents intend them to be for, but the extent to which they actually achieve their goals -- especially goals at odds with the manifest intentions of the actual market participants, including workers themselves -- is another story entirely. If reality works one way, but aspirational idealists are trying to "ensure" that it works in some other way, then their attempts will falter. Many regulatory interventions are at best performative rituals that measure their success in terms of creating the appearance that something is being done, with the question of whether what is being done actually resolves the actual problem (if there is one) barely being considered. In the worst case, these performative interventions create harmful unintended consequences at the same time, leading to them being a net negative. It's worth noting, also, that nothing other than "actual humans" are involved in any aspect of this. There are no non-human "entities" in existence that have autonomous agency and participate in economic exchange. Every question here is about interactions among humans, and the organizational models that humans use to coordinate their activities are not separate "entities" with independent intentions.
- nindalf 2y agoWe actually have two mechanisms: laws/regulations and customers voting with their wallet. Since we see that a majority of customers consistently go with the cheaper option, we know how they feel. So the "better" firm gets outcompeted. So regulation, you say. But those regulations are set by governments voted in by the same consumers. Their preference for lower prices is clear, and government follows their preference. Is your suggestion that the government go against the will of the people and apply those pro-worker-coop regulations anyway?
- sotix 2y ago> The US cultural bias is showing here, as it's assumed that profit is above all else I asked my Greek teacher what they biggest change she experienced moving to the US was, and she said that in Greece, her community prioritized happiness above all else, but everyone she met in the US prioritized making money. I also asked her what the financial crisis was like in Greece, and she said that you couldn’t find an empty seat at a taverna in her village on the weekends. They barely had any money, and few around her were employed, but they had certain priorities. Meanwhile in the US, I had a teacher condescendingly tell me that the Greeks were lazy (ignorant of the history that led to 2008). It can be hard to see through certain cultural biases. Particularly when the primary goals are so different.
- stavros 2y agoYeah, this is spot on. It's just that the priorities are different (even unemployed Greeks scrape enough money to have coffee with their friends), which can seem to Americans like we're lazy.
- pavlov 2y agoI was recently in Lisbon and was surprised that an espresso still costs 70 cents despite the influx of tourists and expats. If it's the same in Greece, I can easily see how an unemployed person can afford to hang out.
- InitialLastName 2y agoWhen I visited a rust belt city recently, it was amazing how many of the coffee shops and bars were still open of my preferred "sit and have a quiet conversation" variety. In my VHCOL city, where commercial rents are absurd, the only coffee shops/bars that can stay open are the ones that can drive tons of business (and thus push patrons through like cattle, with all cues pointing towards "you shouldn't be hanging out here").
- xeromal 2y agoMy buddy lived in greece for a bit and he laughed at how he could order a one euro coffee delivered to his room or office almost anywhere. He couldn't comprehend how it works.
- imgabe 2y agoYou are responsible for optimizing your own happiness. A company can't and shouldn't do that for you. Unhappy with your job? Find a different one. I don't presume to know what will make you happy and dictate to you how you need to live to achieve that and neither should you presume to do that for me. Some people are happy focusing on their family. Some people are happy working hard in their career. Some people just want a job to pay the bills and plenty of time to play video games. These are all fine and valid choices and no company is going to optimize for all of them.
- sqeaky 2y agoIt is easy to "find a new job" but things like healthcare, geographic location, and creditworthiness are tied to employment. If employment were more isolated this argument would still only be superficially reasonable, because we also live in a society with structural sexism and racism and other bigotries. Plenty of people have fewer employment options because of the circumstances of their birth. Then look at me, I am professional contractor and not the obvious target of any of those bigotries. 16 contracts (often 6 or 12 mo), in the past 20 years. of that maybe 3 weren't complete shitholes. How long is one person supposed to keep making major life changes to search for a job that doesn't abuse them? Because a 1 in 5 hit rate implies some things. Setting a floor on how shitty companies can be to their employees would a boon to everyone and likely make the whole economy more productive simply by reducing depression by a double digit percentage.
- imgabe 2y ago> Setting a floor on how shitty companies can be to their employees would a boon to everyone and likely make the whole economy more productive simply by reducing depression by a double digit percentage. Yes, we do that. It's called "labor laws". There are many of them. It's a question of agency. If you assign responsibility for your well-being to others, then you're always going to be at their mercy. Sure, there's structural whatevers and bigots and all sorts of things. Some people won't hire you because you remind them of the kid that bullied them in 3rd grade. Whatever. It's still up to you take control of your life. Nobody else is going to do it for you. Every time you try and demand that someone else do it for you, you are going to end up disappointed.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoIf coops make it harder to raise capital, then they make it harder to invest in new tools, which makes it harder to increase productivity. Workers keep more of the profits but there's less produced so there's less to buy? That doesn't actually make workers' lives better.
- osigurdson 2y ago>> optimizing for making a company that makes the workers' lives better Companies should not deliberately make workers lives bad. But, optimizing for the worker seems fundamentally unworkable as this would essentially mean financial independence at the time of hiring followed by bankruptcy.
- giantg2 2y ago"The US cultural bias is showing here, as it's assumed that profit is above all else, and a company that forgoes profit to make workers happier must thus be less good." It's possible companies with lower profits don't survive when they can be outcompeted by the higher earning companies. This sort of competition has killed plenty of companies.
- WalterBright 2y ago> we should be optimizing for making a company that makes the workers' lives better In the US, you are free to set up a company any way you like.
- conradev 2y agoHow do you make decisions where firing 10% of the workforce is good for 90% of the company’s happiness?
- 0dayz 2y agoEven I as a somewhat skeptic of capitalism and supporter of coops can tell you this is not a USA only thing but a certain interpretation of said capitalism.