9 ms·
Why Americans aren't having babies
- unsupp0rted 2y agoPersonally, I don't want to have children because the risks and downsides aren't even remotely close to the benefits. Best case scenario: 10% chance you and your spouse are great parents, who stay healthy enough to be good parents, who have a physically and mentally healthy kid, who doesn't end up in a life-changing accident or addicted to substances or down an ideological rabbit hole, and you don't lose your income for 18 ~ 24 years while the kid grows into a self-sufficient adult. More likely scenario: something (physical, mental, environmental) is way off and there's lots of despair and suffering in your family for years or possibly forever. I don't like other people's kids, who are seemingly healthy, and I don't want to roll those dice for one of my own, who might not be.
- D13Fd 2y ago> Personally, I don't want to have children because the risks and downsides aren't even remotely close to the benefits. I'd say that the risks aren't worth the benefits to you. But my weighing of the benefits is different. To me, my kids give meaning and purpose. It's honestly hard to imagine not having them. I think different people are just different. To some, having a purpose in life (to raise your kids) is really meaningful and more important than worries about the risks, all of which seem minor in comparison. But to others, it's a burden instead of a purpose, so it doesn't make any sense to have kids.
- mikewarot 2y agoIt's taken way too long to finally realize the "Atomic Family", just a couple who want kids, and their own house... was a colossal mistake. It's a pressure cooker designed to promote Post-Partum depression, and parents who are overwhelmed. Without an extended family and support network, raising a child becomes an overwhelming burden, and the parents end up feeling they were lied to about the supposed joys of parenting. I'm so glad we didn't move away from home and family.
- ryandrake 2y agoI thought it was already well known that birth rates always decline as a nation develops economically. Are there even counterexamples? The USA is not an exception. We should have enough data to study this by now.
- deepfriedchokes 2y agoIt’s the cost of living. That’s it. Everyone always focuses on the monetary cost, but neglect the emotional cost. Even for those who can afford it, they’re too emotionally burned out to give any energy to having kids.
- martinky24 2y agoPaywall...
- chadbennett 2y agohttps://archive.is/y4oTY https://archive.is/y4oTY
- darth_avocado 2y agoLet me guess, it's because it's too expensive to have them.
- RestlessMind 2y agoWrong guess, probably, given that it's the poor who have more kids than the rich - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_fertility_rate#Country_ranking_by_most_recent_year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_fer...
- mlinhares 2y ago* too expensive; * not enough daycare even if you do have money; * not enough space at home; * cities that are not made for parents and small kids; * atomized communities with very little help;
- lumost 2y agoThe last one can be brutal. It's tough to maintain friendships with people who don't have kids, it's doubly tough to form friendships with new people who have kids. Although it's mildly easier to build acquaintances.
- D13Fd 2y agoThis is so true. It's socially isolating. We don't have the support structures we had even back when I was a kid, let alone 20 or 40 years before that, when society was really built around families having kids. I can only wonder what it will be like in another 20 years, when my children are grown up.
- mlinhares 2y agoWhile unfortunate we were able to make friends with other people with kids so there's some sharing of responsibility (send receive kids at home when they need to be watched over) but this doesn't seem to be the norm here. Feels like most people are raising their kids by themselves.
- 2y ago
- bell-cot 2y agoDup of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41025704 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41025704
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- talldayo 2y agoGlances back at the pandemic from 3 years ago Gee I can't imagine why
- bryanlarsen 2y agoLots of people were predicting a post-pandemic baby boom due to couples being forced to spend more time together at home...
- klyrs 2y agoBecause chicken is still more affordable?
- chadbennett 2y agohttps://archive.is/y4oTY https://archive.is/y4oTY
- tonymet 2y agoThe economics theory is bogus when you realize that throughout history and around the world, the economics of raising kids have been far riskier, deadlier and more meager than they are now. People have always had kids even in life or death situations. People have always been always making babies , even when the risk of starvation, death from the elements and murder were extreme. Even the wealthier eras were challenging, with families having 3-5 kids in cramped 1-bedroom apartments containing multiple generations even. I'm the first to admit that prosperity has declined over the past 50 years, but the circumstances for making babies are still among the best compared to history and to 95% of the current circumstances on earth. The actual reasoning will make people uncomfortable, hence the economics cope.
- ImHereToVote 2y agoHaving kids often meant you have more free labour. Then it was just an affordable nice to have. Now it's a huge expense.
- tonymet 2y ago"kids are a huge expense" is not an economics issue it's a philosophical issue. If you fall into a river, it's a huge expense to send a helicopter . The decision to save your life is not economical, it's ethical.
- ImHereToVote 2y agoSo it's an ethical issue on what you want or don't want to do? Or is it an ethical issue of what you do actually do, regardless of your wants?
- tonymet 2y agoIt's about what the population values and how that influences their decision about having kids.
- 2y ago
- 29athrowaway 2y agoVarious factors: 1) Peter Pan syndrome 2) Pressure to pursue career and higher education. See 3) 3) Cost of life
- wisconsiway 2y ago2) holds sway here mainly to the extent that it applies to young women. Last time I looked hard at the literature the only conclusion that replicated was that more women in the workforce and higher education => lower TFR. Countries like Russia, Hungary, and some East Asian democracies have tried subsidizing childrearing, reducing the cost of housing, making healthcare free, etc. Those measures have an impact, but it is small. The only thing that works long-term is making it high status again to have children and raise a family.
- 29athrowaway 2y agoIn the baby boomer era, high school was enough to get a good paying job that could support a family.
- wisconsiway 2y agoFertility is not a problem in many developing countries where salaries are far, far less than that. Men and women have reproduced above replacement level for literally millions of years. It's primarily a question of status and social approval.
- StrLght 2y ago> <...> in many developing countries where salaries are far, far less than that So is cost of living -- these two tend to be correlated.
- matrix87 2y agoBecause... They don't want to? People aren't obligated to justify their own family planning. Even raising the question in the first place is overreach And no, people aren't obligated to make family planning decisions that contribute to a desirable macroeconomic climate 30 years down the line. Not our problem, it'll sort itself out
- snapplebobapple 2y agoIt would be easier to agree with you if the welfare state didn't exist. As it stands there are benefits being paid to old people that don't really have any justification for existing if there isn't a younger generation for that old generation to positively influence and assist as grand parents. There are also tax breaks for marriage/common law that have no logical reason for existing if they aren't supporting a family. We should be redeploying these expenses to more effectively encourage a higher average birthrate, ideally by encouraging the rich to have a lot of kids, as this will have a positive benefit of more effectively disbursing large fortunes vs taxation that always fails.
- Amezarak 2y agoPeople are animals. When animals stop breeding, it is worthwhile to look into their environment to see why that is the case. "Want" doesn't really come into basic biological functions, it's an ex post facto rationalization.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- matrix87 2y agoIt also works the other way: people can be socially pressured into having children That outcome isn't "more natural" than a hypothetical where they aren't pressured and don't have children There's no way of distinguishing instinct from social conditioning at scale, this argument is just using naturalness as a moral characterization
- 2y ago
- mrmetanoia 2y agoI just don't think I'd be all that happy as a father. I feel like I'm in a constant struggle to claim as much time as I can for things that aren't paid work and sleep that interest me, and a kid has never been on that list of interests so I don't want to have one and then resent it consuming more of my time. I just like to think and make stuff while I listen to music, I don't want to be responsible for picking a child up or dropping it off or feeding it. And, I'm not particularly concerned with how long we perpetuate our human nonsense. I don't hate life, but I don't know that I'd have picked it for myself and I don't feel strongly about forcing it on anybody else.
- spacephysics 2y agoGiven describing a child as “it” and only the work involved and not the reward, if you want to dig deeper within yourself I would look at reading positive discussions about kids There was an instagram comment feed (of all places) where the OP asked people to post what their reservation for kids were, and many parents responded to those positively The next post asked parents to post what they were surprised most about being a parent. Some common themes were “I was afraid I wouldn’t like/feel attached to my child” and “I was afraid I would resent my child for the time commitment.” For the latter, dozens of responses say that something within them switched, and they wanted to bear the responsibility. It was fulfilling like a hobby may be, but deeper. Personally I don’t like the rhetoric that describe (others, not you) kids as leeches that take time and money, i think thats toxic to our society. If you know yourself and know you don’t want kids, then it’s best for everyone involved not to have them.
- surgical_fire 2y agoDude just don't want to have children. Nothing wrong with that. The world sucks at the best of times. The last thing someone should do is putting an unwanted child in the world. I have a daughter, who I love and means the world to me. But I wanted her, so all the work and cost is meaningful and rewarding. I wouldn't feel the same if I didn't want a child.
- electrondood 2y agoMy cousins in France each have 3-5 children, because they have free daycare, socialized health care, etc. I plan on having none, because I can't afford it. Every wealthy nation sees a declining birthrate that falls below the replacement rate. The economy of every wealthy nation depends on immigration. This is a fact. If the nationalist right want people to have more babies to combat depopulation, they should be proposing and funding social support programs, not reproductive rights like abortion, IVF, contraception, etc.
- LUmBULtERA 2y agoQuick search yielded a birth rate in France of 1.83... so I don't think that anecdote is relevant. Any data for why you disagree?
- orangecat 2y agoMy cousins in France each have 3-5 children, because they have free daycare, socialized health care France's fertility rate is basically the same as the US. (1.9 vs 1.84 according to https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/field/total-fertility-rate/country-comparison/ https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/field/total-fertility...). Other countries with expansive welfare states like Finland and Sweden are even lower.
- themaninthedark 2y agoFrance's population is in decline though. Japan has free healthcare for anyone under 18 as well as free daycare if your income is low, etc. Their population is also on decline.
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- wnevets 2y ago> factoring in costs of daycare the cost of an "ok" daycare can be higher than someone's entire paycheck.
- Balgair 2y agoDaycare is ~$500/week per kid for us. $26,000 per year per kid. Rates vary wildly across the country. I have friends in the Bay that are paying about the same as us. I have friends in Oregon that are at ~$300/wk. I have friends in Nashville that are at ~$1000/wk. It's a super local thing. Look, anytime you have a waiting list for something, capitalism has broken. You raise prices until you don't have a waiting list. That's 'Business for 5th Graders' level stuff. But you just cannot do that with daycare. Our state does a good job with subsidies for the very poor (we have some at out daycare), but it is still really really expensive. We cannot wait until they get to state subsidized preschool, holy cow man. Also, Pro-tip: If you are even thinking of getting pregnant, go get on all the local daycare lists you can. Wait times can be >18 months for a lot of places.
- wnevets 2y ago> Daycare is ~$500/week per kid for us. Would you consider it a "good" daycare or is it what was available?
- Balgair 2y agoB/B- There are issues, like all places, but it works for us.
- RhysU 2y ago> Look, anytime you have a waiting list for something, capitalism has broken. Not entirely true. A day care has variable costs that jump at the kid count modulo something. Often a government-mandated ratio of adults to kids at various age groups. And adults that have to be paid some government-mandated minimum wage plus some benefits. Therefore, a day care may be profitable for N kids but not profitable for N+1 kids. So, the rational choice for a day care may be to optimize for always, always having exactly N kids. Hence, wait lists so when 1 kid departs another kid can immediately replace them. N might vary if the owner chooses to work as a caretaker. Has some sweet rent deal on a fixed amount of space. Etc. Notice, this sketch of why wait lists may exist isn't due to capitalism. It's due to a rational response to governmental mandates atop capitalism. > You raise prices until you don't have a waiting list. Nah, the parent decides to hire a nanny. Or to host an au pair. Or to move closer to family foregoing some earnings potential. That's the way to buy your way out via substitute goods using just money. (Notice those substitutes operate in different regulatory regimes. Notice also the day care has to compete against those substitute goods! There's a limit to what parents will pay.)
- inglor_cz 2y agoThe really interesting question is why such diverse nations as Portuguese, Scots, Poles, Greeks, Iranians, Mexicans, Singaporeans, Japanese, Thais, Koreans and Chileans experienced similar drops in fertility. Even frankly unexpected places like Saudi Arabia and Bangladesh are dropping towards 2.0 or less.
- locococo 2y agoIt's not the expense that is scary but the risk. Most of what children need, healthcare, food, shelter, supervision. Is directly tied to employment of the adults. If an adult loses employment you lose all pillars to support your child. The social safety net in the US is not sufficient for people to feel safe in having children. Further, the argument of why people should have children so the economy is supported is very shallow. I am not raising children so the economy can have more consumers. As a society we should have larger goals then the next quarter results of publicly traded companies.
- inglor_cz 2y agoThe social safety net in most of EU is much stronger than the American one. Fertility is absolutely abysmal, though, and even worse among the natives (less so among recent arrivals from Afghanistan, Africa etc.) Meanwhile the winner in the global birth rates is Niger, a country near the bottom of the world economic ladder. It can't be primarily about social security.
- red-iron-pine 2y agosecurity is relative. as a westerner most you, if you lose your job, will have no way to feed yourself. how many of you have the skills, infrastructure, and available bodies on hand to set up a subsistence farm? where is the land to be able to do that? the guys in Niger are a lot closer to the land, to traditional food-ways like herding animals, and don't have much by way of creature comforts, which means they don't have much to lose, may have things to gain, by having kids. in many ways it keeps them poor, but poor with a lot of kids is a society that continues, while rich but depress and to anxious to go outside and meet people and breed is a society that doesn't have a future.
- locococo 2y agoThat was my second point, the political environment does nothing to convey why people should have children
- martythemaniak 2y agoJust ask yourself: what level of effort was required from your parents, especially your dad, to raise you? What about the effort required from your grandparents to raise your parents? We all know it takes a much greater amount of effort to raise a kid today because our standards are so much higher, which is particularly true of fathers. You could be a "good dad" in the 80s if you only beat your children in response to them doing something bad versus randomly beating them when you got black out drunk. I would definitely say that dogs today receive a higher standards of care (nutrition, toys, doctor visits, training) than children did in the 50s.
- asadm 2y agoThe west wants women to be ambitious, which I fully support. BUT we aren't building any infra around this. Example: we need in-office nurseries/light-weight daycares. Without this, both parents cannot work AND reproduce. Daycares are a scam. I would rather not work than offload my kids to randos.
- Balgair 2y ago> we need in-office nurseries/light-weight daycares Absolutely no. If your job lays you off or you get fired, then you just lost your childcare and all that community for your kid. I don't see a lot of parents taking that huge of a risk.
- asadm 2y ago> If your job lays you off or you get fired, then you just lost your childcare. That happens regardless. Or is regular daycare free?
- Balgair 2y agoI mean, daycare is really local. Some have huge subsidies, some are run by a church, some are very small. It's quite variable. Generally though, if you lose your job, you can go get another job and still stay at the same daycare. I think we've all survived through credit cards for a while in between work. But that doesn't work if the daycare is through the job.
- asadm 2y agobut having daycare far from workplace just means mothers are at a disadvantage. Either they take time off during formative days or balance 2 jobs at the same time (and commute between them) Co-location is, i think the key to solving this.
- Balgair 2y agoI think the economic principle of 'revealed preferences' shows up here. If co-location of daycare and work was something that people valued highly, then you'd see it happening already. The daycare nightmare has been going on for quite some time.
- altruios 2y agoHousing is too expensive, childcare is too expensive. I do not desire to feed the capitalistic beast with more wage slaves: if I have children - it must be because I can give them a better life than I've had. That will not be the case for the foreseeable future...
- tonymet 2y agothis isn't economics it's philosophical. if you had a reason to live you'd also have a reason to make babies. money would not be a major factor.
- altruios 2y agoThat logic is a non-sequitur. A reason to live has nothing to do with making babies... A reason to make babies is a reason to make babies, a reason to live is a reason to live... maybe some overlap, sure... but the Venn Diagram is far from a circle. There is no ethical consumption (period). If I am to raise consumption in society by bringing another human into it... that cost must be offset. An economically lush environment makes that feasible, the lack of funds makes that less feasible (to the point of impossibility). Cry some more about how 'the poor' aren't filling the factories with their children anymore (since they've wised up) ... /s
- tonymet 2y agoThat’s long winded nihilism.
- altruios 2y agoLet me be clear. Pay me to have children enough for them to live comfortably: I will have children. The reason is purely monetary. More money - more children. Ethics, philosophy, you can argue along those vectors all you want. It will be useless and moot. The answer isn't 'let me change my mind about my opinions about sending a child into wage slavery' the answer is to 'convince me (with money) my child won't have to be a wage slave and having one won't make my family homeless due to financial strains; convince me that my child will have a good life'. You want more children - pay up: 3C7tm5a1UMgsnwGF5GtYQazLxnG9y23v2B - btc address. The answer really is as simple as: more money is needed.
- dvh 2y agoAs a '80s kid I've heard "overpopulation" everywhere, it was one of the biggest threats. So naturally I decided not to populate. It was conscious decision. If you want to reverse the trend stop using that term (in school, in media) and in 20~50 years people will start having 2 babies again.
- autoexec 2y agoOverpopulation is still a problem today. People look around and see that there is still plenty of place to cram bodies into and assume that it's fine, but any given environment can only sustainably support so many people and most of the places we like to live in are way over biocapacity. Earth Overshoot Day is just weeks away this year (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth_Overshoot_Day https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth_Overshoot_Day) Population decline is bad for our unsustainable economy, but it's a good thing for the environment and our increasingly diminishing resources.
- everdrive 2y ago- Women in the workforce and higher eduction, almost universally leads to lower birthrate. - Modern helicopter and "attachment" parenting styles are significantly more resource and time-intensive than in other generations. - Abundance of birth control. - I would also argue that the breakdown of communities plays a much larger, and likely subconscious psychological role. Whether valid or not, people don't feel like they have a support network, and don't feel like it is safe to have children. Please bear in mind, I'm not arguing that any of these points are either good or bad, but just suggesting that they contribute to declining birthrates.
- readthenotes1 2y agoThe breakdown of the extended family, which I guess is a part of the community idea, certainly has to contribute. Generations past that grandparents aunts or uncles they could depend on the babysit from time to time. That's not all that available when you don't live near your grandparents and the parents may have one sibling...
- dividefuel 2y agoI think people simply do not want to have kids as much as they used to. Usually these topics emerge with the same three major factors for why people aren't having children: 1. Can't afford to raise a child 2. Concerns about the future state of the world, e.g. climate change 3. A huge loss of freedom Anecdotally, I personally feel like #3 is by far the biggest reason why people aren't having children. Every time someone in my peer group (mid 30s) announces that they are having a child, there's widespread acknowledgement that we are going to see MUCH less of them from now on. This is a tradeoff, and those who really want children will still choose to have children. But for those who are deeply engaged in something else -- hobbies, social life, career -- or simply enjoy a low-stress life, having children would upend that. Modern living gives a lot of opportunities to go really deep into a few different facets of life, but most people have to limit that depth once they have children. It doesn't help that modern child raising seems to be endlessly shuffling children from one structured activity to another, with little help from a broader social circle. Plus, there's less social pressure than ever to have children. If many of your peers aren't having kids, you're not the odd one out anymore. So I think many people of childbearing age today see a much higher cost in childraising than what people saw in the past. If they aren't especially enthusiastic about raising children in particular, is it a surprise that many are choosing not to?
- red-iron-pine 2y ago#3 is because of #1. money buys the freedom. "broader social circles" are just a low-cost substitute; aka Grandma does the daycare. You'd be surprised how easy it is to have a kid when you can afford daycare, lots of toys to keep Junior busy, and day-to-day life conveniences that make the rest easy to manage. i.e. freedom isn't an issue because I can send kiddo to summer camp, after school programs, and dance classes. and it's easy to snag a pizza or tacos on the way home from grabbing them from said events. the wee one sleeps really well with white noise generators and temperature controls for the room, and has lots of books to play with (plus a yard + the dogs) when she's not sleeping. it's the money.
- RestlessMind 2y ago> it's the money. Richest societies are having the fewest babies and poorest people are having the most. So this doesn't ring true.
- igorramazanov 2y agoThe birthrate in Norway lower than in the USA, so seems economics aren't the culprit.
- rich_sasha 2y agoPerhaps the worthwhile question is, why did people (Americans included) have babies in the first place. As many comments say, children now are expensive, expensive and expensive. Back then they were less so, fine, but still expensive and not somehow magically more fun. So that can't be the whole story. Was it the lack of contraception? Surely not just that, in 1970s or whatnot a typical family had maybe 1-4 children, but not like 10. I suspect it was a combination of status, expectation and ease. Having children was simply a milestone on the roadmap of life that was hard to skip. Grandparents were younger then, and thus more able to help, and more likely to live nearby in the first place. As the societal expectation to have children waned, people stopped.
- incomingpain 2y agoOO I like the point of view. >Perhaps the worthwhile question is, why did people (Americans included) have babies in the first place. Rural/farmer pov it's slave labour. Go feed the chickens! Urban/city pov it's slave labour. Go put out the trash! >and not somehow magically more fun. Extreme high quality toys. You would have to be a king to have this much choice and quality. You get to play with the toys of your childhood. So much more fun to be a parent today. >Was it the lack of contraception? Surely not just that, in 1970s or whatnot a typical family had maybe 1-4 children, but not like 10. People point to the 1950s as when it seemed to be easier. When yes, you had 10. Planned parenthood developed the pill in the 1950s but only widespread use in the 1960s. Contraceptives impacted the 1970s numbers. 1972: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eisenstadt_v._Baird https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eisenstadt_v._Baird Abortions are about that time as well. This isn't even the whole story. https://www.uspharmacist.com/article/most-estrogen-in-drinking-water-not-from-the-pill https://www.uspharmacist.com/article/most-estrogen-in-drinki... You might expect pills accidentally being flushed down the toilet for example to start showing up in water supply, but it's not statistically significant because our drinking water has so much estrogen in it already.