17 ms·
The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets
- kens 2y agoAuthor here for all your NFC chip questions :-)
- cypherpunks01 2y agoHow difficult is it to clone MIFARE Ultralight EV1 chips? You mention the UID is signed, can you simply copy this signature? Do you just need to buy one of the magical chips of the same design, that allow uid/serials to be written? What is the actual mechanism behind the DESFire and other secure NFC chips that prevents cloning?
- kens 2y agoI haven't really looked into the security aspects. I think that you could clone one of the Ultralight chips, but it wouldn't gain you anything because the security is in the backend. It's a lot like a printed concert ticket or boarding pass. You could print as many as you want, but the ticket is still good for just one admission. The DESFire and other secure chips contain a cryptographic key that you can't access. Without the key, you can't make a clone of the chip. The cryptography provides authentication and encryption that you don't get with the cheap Ultralight chip. I think this is all market segmentation; they don't put more security into the Ultralight chip because they don't want to cannibalize their higher-end sales.
- lxgr 2y agoUltralight supports password authentication, and you can diversify the password from the serial number, meaning that until that password is revealed by a legitimate reader as part of a validation transaction (at which time the ticket is invalidated anyway), you can't clone it. Ultralight C does support actual cryptographic authentication.
- kens 2y agoI don't think the password authentication helps against cloning. You could start a transaction and stop after you get the password. Then you could clone the card. (The system could invalidate the ticket as soon as they get the UID, but that would be a reliability nightmare since a failure during the read would invalidate someone's ticket.)
- lxgr 2y agoYou could do that, but it still greatly raises the cost for an attacker, since they need to hang around a ticket validator for every ticket they want to clone, as opposed to e.g. a QR code ticket, which can be trivially copied by a simple screenshot. Also, many of these transit systems are eventually consistent (they're usually offline-capable for resilience, but usually manage to send all validation transactions to a backoffice system within at most a day, and often minutes). This allows detecting duplicate usage fairly quickly. In systems where you need to tap out as well as tap in to leave the turnstile, that's where ticket inspectors might take a sudden interest in you if you tap out with a cloned ticket. In the end, as with most security systems, the goal is not to make fraud absolutely impossible, but to make it economically non-viable.
- szundi 2y agoYou have to hang out to get the id of a simple 125khz tag too - this is what cloning means
- amluto 2y agoIn general, the card emulation devices (e.g. the chips in phones) try to avoid letting any arbitrary UID be set. This makes cloning these cards more difficult than it would otherwise be. It’s not terribly difficult to find devices (USB-connected things and battery-less cards) that do allow arbitrary UIDs to be set, though.
- josephcsible 2y ago> the card emulation devices (e.g. the chips in phones) try to avoid letting any arbitrary UID be set. I can't think of a much worse way to do security. That feels like trying to flood the market with lockpicks that don't work instead of making a more pick-resistant lock.
- amluto 2y agoI imagine this is because the locks contain chips from NXP (PN532 chips), the name-brand MIFARE chips are made by NXP, and the lock picks (also PN532 chips!) are made by NXP.
- jeffbee 2y agoIs this the same system used by Boston MBTA? I was surprised to see single-use tap cards when I visited there for the first time yesterday. I wondered why the ticket isn't reloadable.
- cypherpunks01 2y agoMost people who live in Boston use the reloadable CharlieCard (https://www.mbta.com/fares/charliecard https://www.mbta.com/fares/charliecard) - these report as Mifare Classic 1k, which is a similar chip There are single-use fares as well, the "CharlieTicket" that you might've encountered. More CharlieCard NFC info: https://medium.com/@bobbyrsec/operation-charlie-hacking-the-mbta-charliecard-from-2008-to-present-24ea9f0aaa38 https://medium.com/@bobbyrsec/operation-charlie-hacking-the-... https://media.defcon.org/DEF%20CON%2031/DEF%20CON%2031%20presentations/Matthew%20Harris%20Zachary%20Bertocchi%20Scott%20Campbell%20Noah%20Gibson%20-%20Boston%20Infinite%20Money%20Glitch%20Hacking%20Transit%20Cards%20Without%20Ending%20Up%20In%20Handcuffs.pdf https://media.defcon.org/DEF%20CON%2031/DEF%20CON%2031%20pre...
- jeffbee 2y agoYeah I figured but you can't buy a charliecard online to load into your smartphone wallet, and I only needed it the once, and since it took more than an hour to get to Cambridge due to some combination of circus acts I used Blue bikes for the remainder of the day.
- cypherpunks01 2y agoAh yes, it's not quite there, but almost. Contactless payment directly at the turnstile is coming to Boston MBTA this year, I believe. Like how NYC works now, where you can just use your credit card for entry.
- chgs 2y agoThis is the London system we’ve had for a decade, it was licensed to other areas a few years ago. I found myself in Paris having to cross the other day and forgot how terrible the old way of buying tickets was, amazed that it’s still the norm in so many cities
- modeless 2y agoI am interested in the plastic layer with conductive traces for the antenna. How are these made? Do you know of a source that talks about the production process for them?
- kens 2y agoI don't know personally about the antenna manufacturing, but one web page talks about printable conductive silver ink for producing RFID antennas. https://www.sunchemical.com/product/printed-antenna/ https://www.sunchemical.com/product/printed-antenna/
- politelemon 2y agoCould someone just use an nfc enabled phone to get it to act as a ticket?
- lxgr 2y agoFor MIFARE Ultralight, yes – it's essentially just a bearer token with no encryption/authentication. I believe there's a password mechanism, though, which might just be good enough for single-use tickets. That password can be derived/diversified from the card's serial number, making such a scheme still significantly better than e.g. simple QR codes. MIFARE Ultralight C and larger/more expensive chips allow challenge-response authentication, making them pratically uncloneable. These are usually used for reloadable and monthly passes.
- numpad0 2y agoLayer 3 and down yes, 4 and up depends
- ak217 2y agoThanks for the write-up. How does this fit into the broader NFC ecosystem? What do other big metro systems like Omny, Clipper, Smartrip etc use? Apple and Google seem to implement some NFC protocols in their devices but in a much more programmable way, how does that work? Is the protocol used in credit cards related at all? And how do these relate to Felica, the system used everywhere in Japan (which was in the news for a while because the factory where they made the chips burned down and they had a chip shortage - giving Apple an opening to move into the market with iPhone NFC)?
- kens 2y agoThat seems like a question for @lxgr :-) As far as I can tell, the NFC ecosystem is a mess of competing, incompatible protocols from different companies, as well as incompatibilities for historical reasons. For example, Clipper uses MIFARE DESFire, which is the more secure sibling of the Ultralight chip that I examined. Washington's SmarTrip cards use MIFARE Plux X. New York City's OMNY, on the other hand, is apparently built on top of the Mastercard payment network using EMV. Montreal's rechargeable OPUS card (not the disposable one I examined) uses the completely different Calypso standard. FeliCa was developed in Japan along a different path and has a different standard (NFC-F vs NFC-A) with different modulation, protocol, and data rates. The NFC chips used in phones try to be compatible with as much as possible. These NFC systems all use the same 13.56 MHz frequency, so the radio hardware is compatible across them.
- Tijdreiziger 2y agoHow and why did you learn about this topic? :)
- lxgr 2y agoOn it, but I couldn't have said it better :) To expand on Felica vs. ISO a bit: Theoretically Felica is a different stack from ISO 14443, but it's close enough that it almost got specified as a variant of ISO 14443 as well (C; MIFARE and most other systems use A). NFC does specify Felica as one possible official tag type (then called NFC-F, as opposed to NFC-A and NFC-B), so practically, most mobile devices can just also read it. For anybody wanting to experiment a bit, I can highly recommend getting any Android device and installing NFC tag reader by NXP; it'll show you what technology exactly a given card uses, and in some cases can show you other interesting information as well. There's also an app that lets you read the current balance of various transit cards.
- teruakohatu 2y agoThat was a god read, thank you. Do you have any insight into the economics of this in general compared to other disposable solutions. Are manufacturing old school magnetic stripe tickets, or just optical scanning/barcodes a lot cheaper? I imagine magnetic stripes have a higher failure to read rate at the turnstile causing issues, while both them and optical scanning requires the ticket to be inserted into the machine, adding complexity and moving parts.
- kens 2y agoI couldn't find a nice price breakdown. I'd expect the magnetic stripe tickets to be cheaper to manufacture, but since the NFC tickets cost pennies, there isn't a lot of money to save. I agree with you that magnetic stripes would have a much higher maintenance cost due to the mechanical aspect and the read/write head. Optical scanning seems less likely to work the first time, based on my experience with airplane checkins. NFC is probably the best from an ecosystem perspective since it can work with credit cards and phones as well. NFC readers are probably the cheapest since they are produced in large volumes for credit card point of sale.
- amluto 2y agoI’ve occasionally gotten to watch transit workers open up and service the magnetic stripe card readers in the BART. Those things are complicated. It may well cost less to outright replace a contactless reader module on a fare gate than to service a magnetic stripe ticket machine once. Even an Adafruit PN532 board is only $40.
- teruakohatu 2y agoAnd if a machine jams not only do you need staff to spend hours to repair it, but you need to pay staff, or contractors, to do it.
- edub 2y agoI've not worked with the Adafruit PN532, but for an extra $10 you can get a Pepper C1 USB from Eccel which is very easy to work with. It is a stand-alone device, so you don't have to connect it to anything but power. Has WiFi & BT built in and has a built-in web server to configure it with, you can have it make calls via REST, MQTT, WebSocket.
- seizethecheese 2y agoI’ve been curious about the orientation of these devices. For examples, if I want to track an item’s presence in a box, would I have to coat the entire item in these chips to get one to be in the right orientation?
- kens 2y agoI think it depends on the type of antenna. A linearly polarized RFID antenna is sensitive to the tag's orientation, but a circularly polarized antenna is less sensitive to orientation. Systems can also use more than one RFID antenna to get better coverage.
- maaarghk 2y agoNot an NFC chip question, but what kind of microscope do you need to get silicon photos of a chip so tiny?
- kens 2y agoThe trick is to use a metallurgical microscope, which shines the light down through the lens. A regular microscope illuminates from below, which works fine for cells, but not for opaque chips. Specifically, I use an AmScope ME300TZB-2L-10M microscope, which my friends consider an entry-level microscope, but it works for my needs.
- throwadobe 2y agoHow much cheaper and smaller can they get before we see them used in parcel and freight?
- poslathian 2y agoSeveral such pilots for this have been in flight the last couple years.
- account42 2y agoYou already see RFID tags used in retail so I would not be surprised if that isn't already the case somewhere in the shipping industry as well. I imagine those can use even simpler chips that are completely read-only over the air and only have a UID programmed.
- rendaw 2y agoKind of a software question, but why isn't nfc with asymmetric keys a thing? It seems like at best this is a custom javacard app on select expensive cards ($4 per card if you buy 1000 on aliexpress) or $70 for a yubikey otherwise. Is getting the signature time fast enough just impossible with current hardware/tramission power restrictions?
- jFriedensreich 2y agoas always a delight to read ken! im curious about speculation how to do the bonding and mounting of these chips at scale. at this size even the general handling and cutting of wafers are hard to imagine for me. how did the connections to the antenna look like and was there an indication of different glue / adhesive layers apart from the coatings you described?
- caf 2y agoI'm curious about how the unique ID is programmed into each chip. Presumably all the chips on the wafer come out identical - at which point in the process are they individually selected and given a unique personality? Is it done with direct electrical contact that is then fused off, or using the near field link?
- grishka 2y agoMaybe some kind of custom NFC command that writes the UID into the EEPROM and sets a flag that it's now read only?
- account42 2y agoIt's probably done through normal write commands if there is any explicit lock bit at all (it could doesn't just check if any of the UID bits are already non-zero and then reject the write). You can actually make other parts of the memory read-only too by setting bits at a specified address [0] (which then cannot be unset again). [0] https://www.nxp.com/docs/en/data-sheet/MF0ICU1.pdf#G4008599 https://www.nxp.com/docs/en/data-sheet/MF0ICU1.pdf#G4008599
- kens 2y agoSince they need to probe each die to test it on the wafer, they set the UID at the same time. According to the datasheet, "These bytes are programmed and write protected in the production test."
- qaisjp 2y agoI really enjoyed this read, thanks. In the footnotes you said: > One complication is that the counters have an "anti-tearing" feature for additional security Two questions: 1. Why is it a "complication"? Is it just that it makes the counters more complicated, or is there something frustrating about the counters? 2. I would love to learn more about how the anti-tearing feature works!
- kens 2y agoThe problem is that if the user tears the card away from the reader in the middle of an update, that card can end up with corrupted data. This makes implementing the increment-only counters more complicated. For instance, the straightforward approach might hold 00 FF in two bytes. If you increment the counter by updating the low-order byte first, but the card gets torn away before you update the high-order byte, you end up with 00 00, and the counter has gone backward. A simple way of preventing tearing is to have two copies of each counter; if there is tearing, then the two values will be different. Looking at an NXP patent [1], they use a much more complicated approach, using a level of indirection. They write the new value to a different memory page and then update a pointer to the new page. There are various progress bits recorded along the way so they can roll back as needed. [1]: https://patents.google.com/patent/EP3226141A1 https://patents.google.com/patent/EP3226141A1 Here's an article describing an attack on the anti-tearing feature: https://blog.quarkslab.com/rfid-monotonic-counter-anti-tearing-defeated.html https://blog.quarkslab.com/rfid-monotonic-counter-anti-teari...
- crote 2y agoHow do they make the chips so incredibly thin? Surely they're not using 75µm/120µm wafers throughout the entire production process - that's literally the thickness of a human hair! Can a 200/300mm wafer of that thickness even support itself, let alone all the stresses in the production process?
- abainbridge 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wafer_backgrinding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wafer_backgrinding
- bobthepanda 2y agoThis wasn’t super obvious to me until later in the article but this is about the single use tickets. Neat stuff, though I can’t say I love the concept of e-waste NFC.
- adolph 2y agoIt isn’t different from other anti-counterfeiting measures, the printing just happens to be really small and electrically react to certain frequencies. Part of the “software eating the world” story is the decreased cost of precision that enabled the hardware substrate of software to be inexpensively and ubiquitously included in any mass produced object.
- kwhitefoot 2y agoAssuming that it doesn't become litter on the street what is the actual impact of such waste?
- Teever 2y agoAll of the waste that went into producing it of course. IC fabrication produces a lot of chemical waste, and I would imagine that these ICs aren't fabbed in a place that has a great track record on pollution.
- kwhitefoot 2y agoThese devices are so tiny that presumably this is also a tiny part of IC fabrication. I'm not saying there is none, just trying get an idea of how much of a problem this really is. We also need to consider what impact any alternative solution would have. What struck me from the description of the system was that it seems that no electronics is really needed at all, a unique QR or barcode would be just as good because the back end system records the use. But that would require the installation of optical readers in a system that might not have them but does already have NFC readers. Adding those readers would add a considerable amount of e-waste too.
- kens 2y ago
- webwielder2 2y agoSo how much more powerful is this chip than the ones NASA used in the the Apollo program?
- kens 2y agoI think this chip is implemented with a state machine rather than a processor, so it's meaningless to compare their processing power. The Apollo Guidance Computer had about 17,000 transistors, while I estimate that the NFC chip has about 45,000 transistors. So the NFC chip has more complexity, but the same order of magnitude.
- 486sx33 2y ago[flagged]
- BOOSTERHIDROGEN 2y agoI would like a comprehensive analysis of FeliCa.
- lxgr 2y agoSame here! It seems like a fascinating system, especially in the federated way in which it's being used by various Japanese transit agencies and issuers. Compared to MIFARE, it was definitely ahead of its time. Unfortunately, most things I could find are in Japanese, as expected; I suspect that the really interesting parts aren't public, as usual in this industry (there's still a lot of belief in security by obscurity, even if the systems actually don't need it). Singapore's CEPAS seems very similar conceptually to Felica (at least in application, in that there's multiple issuers of stored-value cards with interoperability), and the specifications for that seem to be available for purchase, but I'm not curious enough to bite that bullet yet :)
- rtpg 2y agoIt's not really on the technical side of thigns, but the unification of IC cards across transportation companies has a good write up [0] that has a bunch of fun details. My favorite thing is how the people working on the project just had a bunch of card readers from various transport companies all in one room. [0] https://www.ejrcf.or.jp/jrtr/jrtr62/pdf/6-15_web.pdf https://www.ejrcf.or.jp/jrtr/jrtr62/pdf/6-15_web.pdf
- lxgr 2y agoThat’s great, thank you!
- landedgentry 2y agoI'm a big fan of this blog: https://atadistance.net/2023/04/04/final-frontiers-how-suica-2-0-will-solve-the-ic-fare-region-barrier-problem/ https://atadistance.net/2023/04/04/final-frontiers-how-suica... The author understands Japanese sources and writes about how the various Felica-based systems operate and evolve.
- piombisallow 2y agoThe diameter of a neuron's axon is about 1 μm, this is getting close to biological levels of miniaturization.
- therein 2y agoIt is using a relatively old manufacturing process. It may be small but it is because modern chips are small, not because this is a feat of engineering where they've achieved incredible compute densities.
- phoebos 2y agoIt's small compared to the size of the card, sure, but not small for typical modern lithography techniques.
- Waterluvian 2y agoOn the topic of NFC: my iPhone ApplePay thing taps so much more reliably than any of my credit or debit cards. Is this because it has its own power supply and doesn’t have to first be powered up by the machine?
- adolph 2y agoAdditional conjecture: a device with upgradable software can take advantage of updates to readers and protocols. Whereas the physical card is stuck at the version it was created with.
- kens 2y agoNFC supports passive mode (where one side is powered and the card is not) and active mode (where both sides are powered). So, yes, your phone is probably more reliable because it provides a powered data transmission. An NFC card doesn't actively transmit data. Instead, it sends data using "load modulation", where it switches a load across the antenna to change how much power it absorbs. The transmitter can detect this change in power, but the signal is extremely weak (80 decibels below the transmitted signal), so it's amazing that it works at all.
- Waterluvian 2y agoThat’s insane. And yet when I see what we can do with coax or twisted pair, I anticipate we’ll get to gbps speeds one day. :)
- lxgr 2y agoThe iPhone doesn't actually use NFC's peer-to-peer/"active" mode (since contactless payments aren't an NFC application; see my other comments on that), but it does specifically include an NFC "field amplifier" IC (shown in some iFixit teardowns), which most other smartphones and of course all physical cards/tags lack. This does mean that iPhones can't do cool tricks like booting up the secure element purely from the field with a completely dead battery though that some earlier Android and Windows Phones could do (or at least Apple has intentionally deactivated that capability for a more consistent/secure experience) :)
- 2y ago
- localfirst 2y agoComparing Montreal subway with Vancouver's skytrain: - Montreals subway stations have this gritty, distinctively french atmosphere i loved it. - Vancouvers above/below stations have no soul, distinctively anglo but above ground ones i liked. - Montreal train cars use rubber wheels to my shock! Extremely loud. - Vancouver train cars use some sort of electric system which im not familiar with ( have a few variants (newer hyundai rotem cars, old ones: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W_BoeXqaV9c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W_BoeXqaV9c) - Montreal subway does not cover the entire region like Vancouver's skytrain. Getting around is difficult without uber. Road conditions are horrible (pot holes remain unfixed for decades, city went broke hosting olympics long time ago), I just shudder how you can get around during the winter. But the biggest shock was that in some instances, it was faster for me to walk then walk to the station and wait for the subway. - Arriving at YVR: Skytrain runs directly from airport to a satellite city where its numerous public buses cover almost the entire MV. I could just tap through the toll gate with my credit card and wait for a bus which arrives on time quite frequently. - Arrriving at YUL: Have to take a bus from airport for 30 minutes to Montreal but doesn't seem to respect time schedule. Got off somewhere in Montreal I don't remember (there was a large open artsy area) tried to wait for a bus but never came, gave up, got uber.
- osnium123 2y agoIn addition to how hosting the Olympics hurt Montreal financially, there was substantial tax revenue loss from the trend of corporate headquarters moving from Montreal to Toronto staring in the 1960s due to Francophone policies.
- localfirst 2y agoYeah they seem to do this every recession. I don't see any value in forcing French language which btw, people from France laugh and make fun of Quebecois. I've seen it at work too.
- dgudkov 2y ago>Montreal subway does not cover the entire region like Vancouver's skytrain. It's not supposed to. The new REM train network (a few stations already in use) will cover the region. By 2027. Maybe. REM will also go to YUL. PS. Fun fact, REM is also driver-less just like the Skytrain.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- justusthane 2y agoThis is fascinating. We were just in Europe where we experienced these tickets for the first time. I had trouble with them; I was trying to figure out how to scan them because it never occurred to me that they might contain an NFC chip. My wife, on the other hand, who is not at all technical, took it for granted that you would tap them and immediately figured it out intuitively.
- hammock 2y agoWhere do you live? Chicago has had these contactless paper tickets since 2013
- cbhl 2y agoAtlanta has been using a form of these contactless paper tickets since 2006.
- szundi 2y agoRomans have used tickets before AD, guy at the gate checked it without any contact
- justusthane 2y agoThunder Bay, Ontario. Pop. 110k. We still have the sort of carnival-style paper tickets. I would guess that most smaller cities don’t have fancy NFC tickets.
- hammock 2y agoI’m surprised you have a subway at all
- justusthane 2y agoWe don’t, we have a bus line.
- devl547 2y agoAll Moscow public transport powered by these chips (actually it was, nowadays the chips we use are clones, made in Russia itself) - trains, metro and buses.
- thriftwy 2y agoFor a few years now, you may usually do a contactless card payment - just tap your bank (debit or credit) card. The fare is often higher but so is convenience. Back around 2010 I remember reading these accusations that significant part of revenue went directly to Mifare for the massive number of chips. And for single rides, some of Metro systems still use these steampunk brass tokens. Sometimes, less authentic plastic.
- 1oooqooq 2y agoevery single transportation system that uses disposable nfc are definitely making a ton of money for the vendor. and every transportation system that pretends to run as a profit center and not a cost center also makes ton of money for the vendors.
- thriftwy 2y agoBuilding roads and selling cars, though, also makes an awful lot of money for the vendors.
- Tijdreiziger 2y agoIn the systems I’ve ridden, there’s usually some kind of plastic stored-value card for regular riders, and the (more expensive) disposable tickets are only used by occasional riders.
- Symbiote 2y agoA system I used in China had NFC plastic coins for occasional use, which were collected and refused by the exit barrier.
- amluto 2y ago> Presumably, the makers thought that making the card look like a smart card would help people understand it. The card actually uses an entirely different technology. It’s kind of the same, though. The physical communication layer is different, but the higher protocol layers are basically identical. Smart cards with contacts follow ISO 7816. These MIFARE contactless cards are ISO 14443 Type A cards, and their protocol follows ISO 7816-4. This shouldn’t be terribly surprising — the entire ecosystem built for smart cards with contacts wants to support contactless cards with minimal changes, and this includes the host software, the readers, and the logic in the cards. There are even plenty of devices where the same device supports contact and contactless uses — plenty of credit cards, bank cards, and FIDO devices are like this. This is analogous to WiFi and wired Ethernet. They’re have very different physical layers, but they are logically compatible, and the same software supports both.
- lxgr 2y agoOnly ISO 14443-4 uses the same protocol as ISO 7816 (another way of saying this is that ISO 14443-4 represents the higher layers of ISO 7816 over a different physical interface), though. MIFARE Ultralight does not actually implement 14443-4/7816/"smartcard"-style APDUs; it's significantly simpler, since the ICs are much less powerful. To make things more confusing, some MIFARE ICs really do implement ISO 14443-4 (e.g. their fixed-function MIFARE DESfire cards, and their programmable smartcard ICs like SmartMX), but not all of them.
- m463 2y agoIt would be more analogous to your wifi antennas looking like 6" cat 5 cables with an RJ-45 painted on the end :)
- schmidtleonard 2y ago...and now I want one.
- amluto 2y agoWe’re almost there. Try zooming in to the first picture on this RJ45 connector: https://www.truecable.com/products/cat6a-field-term-plug-shielded https://www.truecable.com/products/cat6a-field-term-plug-shi... At that price point, there should be a wifi module hidden in it somewhere :)
- lxgr 2y ago> There are multiple NFC standards with differences in speed, protocol, and range, including NFC-A, NFC-B, NFC-C, NFC-F, and NFC-V. The MIFARE Ultralight cards use NFC-A, which is defined by the standard "ISO/IEC 14443 Type A". Pet peeve: Calling these chips "NFC" is a bit misleading. NFC-A isn't defined by ISO 14443-A, but builds on it. NFC is an umbrella standard that defines a way of storing structured data on a wide variety of existing contactless IC technologies (including, but not limited to ISO 14443) and products (such as NXP's various MIFARE chips, which in turn are based on various layers of ISO 14443 up to -4). For the concrete example, it's correct to say that one possible implementation of an NFC-A tag is MIFARE Ultralight (that would be a NFC forum type 2 tag), but neither is NFC the only thing you can do with MIFARE Ultralight (and this transit use case almost certainly doesn't put an NDEF container on the ticket), nor is this the only type of tag you could use for NFC.
- moralestapia 2y ago>NFC is an umbrella standard that defines a way of storing structured data on a wide variety of existing contactless IC technologies [...] Yeah, then it's appropriate to call this NFC.
- lxgr 2y agoExcept that the highest layers in that stack is not used by many contactless systems. As an analogy, you wouldn't call HTTP or TCP "web protocols" either, even though the web uses both (but it can also run on QUIC, which is UDP, and you can do non-web-things via HTTP). Importantly, NFC standardizes a way of storing structured data like URLs or phone numbers on NFC tags; transit tickets most likely don't use tags in that way.
- account42 2y agoDid you google all of that on your PC?
- mschuster91 2y ago> The Ultralight chip has a few features beyond a printed ticket, though. The chips are manufactured with a unique 7-byte identification code (UID). Moreover, the UID is signed, ensuring that fake UIDs cannot be generated. The problem is, they can be just as easily cloned. Your average Flipper Zero can do that. If you want actual security, you have to go for a challenge-response scheme - i.e. every card is provisioned at the factory with a unique private / public key pair, and the public key gets signed by the factory. Then, to verify authenticity, the terminal gives some random nonce, the card signs it using its private key, and the terminal verifies that against the factory's public key. > Even so, there were a couple of times that I lost track of the chip and had to check some specks under the microscope to determine which was the chip and which were dirt. That is the really amazing part for me. We as humans have difficulty handling them, but how on earth does a machine even manufacture these, much less orient them consistently for the bond process to work?!
- lxgr 2y ago> The problem is, they can be just as easily cloned. Not if the validation system uses the password feature of MIFARE Ultralight. For single-use tickets, which are invalidated immediately after being read, this can be good enough and is much more lightweight on the IC side.
- chx 2y agoIt's utterly not worth it. Your time to get it working, the equipment... but even if you have all of those if you get caught they will throw the book on you to scare away others. You can be charged by Unauthorized use of computer, Fraud and who knows what else. All of that to save four dollars on a ticket? When every station has cameras?
- mschuster91 2y agoThe thing is, you have to do it only once, and then the clones and knockoffs come. Like what, there's Tiktoks advising young dumbasses precisely what they need to steal and joyride cars.
- johnklos 2y ago"Tie die" Ha ha ha ha... Love it! Always informative and interesting :)
- stacktrust 2y agoYou can use these around the house or car for location-tap automation. Tap on NFC tag and mobile phone can trigger a custom shortcut for local action or SSH script to Linux SBC or micro PC. Response time is about one second. Even the iPhone SE2 has an NFC reader. For vision-impaired people, NFC tags can be attached to objects and the phone can read an audio description when the object is tapped against phone.
- ck45 2y agoThis reminds me a bit of Nabaztags, or maybe the reverse. They would also read something that resembles NFC and could perform an action.
- Tijdreiziger 2y agoAround that time, I recall there being a lot of hype around RFID tags. E.g. the Touchatag was just a bunch of RFID tags and a USB RFID reader, but marketed as a consumer product. This never really seems to have caught on, though. Nowadays, I suppose most consumers do have RFID tags (debit cards, transport cards, building keys, e-Passports), they just might not be aware of the underlying technology.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoAll the patents and "sekhurity" isn't helping. A decade ago, I ended up with a bunch of programmable NFC stickers that my Galaxy S7 suddenly wasn't able to read, because some MIFARE intellectual property issue retroactively bricked this class of NFC stickers. Good luck figuring out where on the compatibility matrix the Amazon listing you're looking at is.
- stacktrust 2y agoWe need a name for the phase of innovation curves after IP warlords have completed vision quests, leaving a stable landscape. This vendor has an array of RFID products: https://gototags.com https://gototags.com
- cypherpunks01 2y agoMy favorite household NFC usage? NFC alarm clock. Makes me get out of bed and tap my phone on a specific NFC tag placed somewhere around the house, in order to turn off the alarm. Then, I may as well wake up, since I'm already out of bed : ) It's a nice companion to help perform 'habit stacking' as Atomic Habits calls it. Want to do pushups right after waking up? Place an NFC card under your workout mat, so you're forced to the mat first thing in the morning. NFC Alarm Clock https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.nfcalarmclock&pcampaignid=web_share https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.nfcalarmcl... is a really great and simple Android alarm. Share if anyone has a good iOS recommendation.
- scrollaway 2y ago> Makes me get out of bed and tap my phone on a specific NFC tag placed somewhere around the house, in order to turn off the alarm. Neat, but is there an advantage between this and "Place the alarm clock further from the bed"?
- unholythree 2y agoThe noise maker (alarm) is still close to him.
- jeffreygoesto 2y agoFair. My mother used to put one of those old rattling alarm clocks with two bells on top into a metallic dish and placed that combo at the other end of the room. Similar concept.
- cypherpunks01 2y agoNot a huge advantage, but I'd say mostly range and flexibility. You may want to put the tag farther away than you could hear an alarm clock, if you want to go to another room. And you could customize the alarm so you're guided towards a different tag every day of the week, without needing multiple (or any) alarm clocks.
- hlandau 2y agoThe NFC chip I want still doesn't exist: a CPU and flash I can write a program for, directly, no VMs, no Java, without an NDA'd datasheet. These exist, but they're all behind NDAs and you're not allowed to have them. They're used for e.g. EMV.
- userbinator 2y agoHow about something like this: https://hackaday.com/2009/06/27/avr-rfid-tag/ https://hackaday.com/2009/06/27/avr-rfid-tag/
- bsder 2y agoIs there a problem with the TI NFC chips? They all seem to be purchasable and have available datasheets.
- Gibbon1 2y agoI saw an NFC chip that has 512 bytes of eeprom. Talks to a micro via I2C and has an interrupt that can be used to wake it up. I think it's a M24LR04E. Costs like $0.50. I think these could be useful for devices where you have a limited amount of data you want to read or transfer. Like why have bluetooth and all the crap that entails when all you want to do is configure a device once. Advantage of a separate IC is you can use it with whatever microcontroller development stack you have working.
- crote 2y agoThe problem is that it is simply a dual-interface EEPROM. It only holds data, it doesn't process it. Great for something like a device whose configuration you can update via NFC tap (think e-paper display), not so great if you want to do a whole challenge-response dance between microcontroller and NFC smartphone.
- hlandau 2y agoSee comment below. More generally what I'm seeking is something in the card form factor which is suitable to store cryptographic secrets (i.e., a smartcard). Separate IC is a disadvantage here since it creates a vulnerable security boundary and makes it infeasible to integrate the chip into a thin card.
- Nition 2y agoHow is a chip like this actually manufactured? Especially the analogue components area.
- kens 2y agoIt's manufactured pretty much the same as any other chip, using photolithography. Most of the analog components would be CMOS transistors, just larger. They might use a BiCMOS process with a few extra steps to make bipolar transistors. And there might be an extra step for the capacitors. But overall, the chip uses an old, simple manufacturing process, much easier than cutting-edge processors.
- rwmj 2y agoThe chip seems like it's almost too small? I don't even know how they would cut up the wafer and how they would pick each die and mount it in the paper card.
- kens 2y agoThey cut the wafer apart with a diamond blade, 20 µm thick. Laser cutters can make thinner cuts, but they cost more. Die pick-and-place machines can manipulate even smaller dies at high speed: https://www.syagrussystems.com/dts-2-die-sorter https://www.syagrussystems.com/dts-2-die-sorter
- Sytten 2y agoThey are going away soon (TM), the tech is cool but they are impractical. I will be happy to use my credit card or phone. Too many times I have been stuck in 15-20 minutes queues to buy those tickets and you cant refill them with an app... Plus south shore and north shore have they own system it's a mess.
- rendx 2y agoI dread the privacy implications. No thanks.
- vhcr 2y agoNo need to worry about privacy, facial recognition already takes care of that.
- akira2501 2y agoIs that admissible as evidence?
- Sytten 2y agoWhat privacy implication? You already buy the NFC with a credit or debit card so if they want to track the card use they can.
- lxgr 2y agoMany of the systems that account/payment card based ticketing is now replacing used to allow cash top-ups for their stored value cards.
- sircastor 2y agoBut you can still purchase these one-time use cards with cash? That’s the case with my local transit system. Are there places that are eliminating cash altogether?
- chgs 2y agoMifare is what’s been used in London’s Oyster cards for 20 years (not the ultralight ones mind), and Hong Kong for even longer. However oyster really is in its way out for most uses. contactless and especially a phone is far more convenient for non season use, and far less wasteful.
- akpa1 2y agoI'm looking forwards to the day they somehow manage to link a National Railcard to a contactless bank card.
- bobthepanda 2y agoI feel like the approach will probably be that railcards become digital wallet compatible.
- paulmd 2y agocostco already has this for ID cards in the states (and I've also seen it for account ID for home depot and some other places where it's tied to discounts). the app will pull up an ID card with a QR code that changes every 60 seconds or so to prevent screenshotting and trivial reuse, which is analogous to the function the chip performs in terms of challenge-authentication.
- emmet 2y agoI'll have aged out before they ever manage this. Been on the to-do list for years.
- chgs 2y agoYou’d have to have a national railcard first. The only railcards that exist are specific ones for specific groups.
- akpa1 2y agoNational Railcard is the name that TfL uses to refer to all of those different types of card. https://tfl.gov.uk/fares/free-and-discounted-travel/national-railcard-discount https://tfl.gov.uk/fares/free-and-discounted-travel/national...
- ForHackernews 2y ago> a per-chip price of nine cents That still seems expensive for a $3.75 metro fare. 2.4% of the cost of your ride is the chip in the ticket itself? Maybe it's worth it because it lets them eliminate mechanical ticket-reading and unify paper tickets with other NFC payment methods.
- lbourdages 2y agoThese single use tickets are used essentially only by tourists and those who use public transport only on occasion. The vast majority of users will use rechargeable Opus cards [1] that can contain a variety of different fare types (single tickets, monthly tickets, etc). From an operator's point of view it definitely makes sense to only have to maintain one type of reader, even if that means losing a few cents profit on the low single digit percent of rides that use the disposable tickets. [1] https://www.stm.info/en/info/fares/opus-cards-and-other-fare-media/opus-card https://www.stm.info/en/info/fares/opus-cards-and-other-fare...
- idunnoman1222 2y agoThat’s not true in Montreal if you buy a single ride you get a paper ticket with a magnetic stripe that you feed into a completely different reader.
- lbourdages 2y agoI've never seen these mag tickets, the ticket machines all give out Occasionnelle cards even for 1 ticket. Maybe if you walk up to the clerk?
- tomoyoirl 2y agoI assume all regular customers will be paying a fare of $3.25 or less per ride on the reusable Opus card (fare purchased in a 10-ride pack). Essentially you’re paying for the chip with the very-occasional-commuter one-ride convenience fee.
- crote 2y ago
- MBCook 2y agoThe article says the chips are made on a 180 nm process and they come out about the size of a table salt grain. We’re now down in the single digits for fabrication in nanometers, although I know that sort of just a name. This chip is so tiny already, if you were to fab it on a process like 7 nm I’m guessing it would be unworkably small. Too hard to cut, too hard to manipulate individual chips once you did manage to cut them. So here’s my question: how small can we make a chip in area while still being able to cut them out and easily use them? It’s obviously not a concern for the hundreds of square millimeters of a large processor, but I’ve never heard about the opposite end of the spectrum before.
- kens 2y agoThere are a few issues. First, you lose 20 µm due to the saw cut between the dies. I saw an NXP patent that said this was wasting 30% of the die for their tiny chips. If you made the chips smaller, you'd be wasting even more. Another issue is that you need some area for the bond pads, so you can't make your chips arbitrarily small or they will be useless. Looking at a random die pick-and-place machine [1], it handles dies down to 0.2mm in either dimension. So you could handle smaller dies than mine with an off-the-shelf machine, but not a lot smaller. [1] The video of the die machine in action is pretty cool: https://www.syagrussystems.com/dts-2-die-sorter https://www.syagrussystems.com/dts-2-die-sorter
- MBCook 2y ago0.2mm per side? Wow that’s smaller than I’d expect. Thanks. The increased losses due to cutting make sense too. I was expecting the cuts to be wider than 20 µm, so that’s not actually as bad as I was imagining.
- EncomLab 2y agoKen is a treasure - he's a walking encyclopedia of all things electronic!
- egl2021 2y agoPhosphoric acid, hydrochloric acid, and boiling sulfuric acid: I should have paid more attention in chemistry lab. This is a neat project and answered a lot of questions.
- kens 2y agoIt's not as scary as it sounds :-) For a chip this small, I only need a few drops of chemical, which cuts the risk way down. I don't have beakers full of hydrofluoric acid and red fuming nitric acid, like the real decappers.
- AbraKdabra 2y agoYeah, I read it's cheap, like, really cheap... But I refuse to believe this is cheaper and simpler than a piece of paper with a barcode, why add complexity to something that has to be discarded after like, 1 minute?
- varenc 2y agoThe user experience seems superior with an NFC chip like this. It’s easier and more reliable for the user to tap a card than scan a bar code. It’s also probably cheaper and simpler for the subway system to use a NFC reader for everything since they already need to read NFC for their non-disposable tickets or tap-to-pay. And as a user it seems nice knowing that no matter your type of ticket you tap them all the same way.
- Charon77 2y agoI wonder why they don't use magnetic paper instead like how Japan is using? Seems cheaper
- lxgr 2y agoMagnetic paper can't do computations, so these tickets are a storage medium only and as such can usually be trivially copied. That puts higher requirements on the backend's availability in order to prevent fraud. Most people in Japan actually use (reloadable) IC cards, as far as I understand, and railways seem to be in progress of switching magnetic stripe tickets for QR code based ones: https://english.kyodonews.net/news/2024/05/362243d2c187-japan-rail-firms-to-swap-magnetic-tickets-for-qr-codes-in-green-push.html https://english.kyodonews.net/news/2024/05/362243d2c187-japa...
- jszymborski 2y agoMontreal used to but transitioned to these NFC ones recently.
- numpad0 2y agoThose electro-mechanical ticket readers are borderline lost technology and sadly don't belong in this software-eletronic era 0: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Vn-QxQOoqQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Vn-QxQOoqQ
- CraigJPerry 2y agoQR codes seem like a better ticket medium. This is like a 100 bytes, a qr code can be over 2kb This is a cheap plastic substrate with ink printing over the top. A qr code is just ink - or some other even cheaper printing process if you prefer. This needs a specific ticket technology supplier over the next 10’s of years. QR codes can be drawn on screens or printed on paper and you can change suppliers for every component - from mobile phone apps to paper type to physical printer and reader devices - until your heart’s content over the next years. That flexibility can’t be underestimated in a space like public ticketing over decades. Issuing replacement tickets needs physical presence to collect the ticket, vs qr code which can be emailed, sent on whatsapp, shared as a screenshot or photo if you need to, but of course you can still exchange physical paper qr codes if you prefer. The rfid reader for these are cheap and durable, the optical reader for qr codes can be almost as cheap and almost as durable but not quite, the rfid wins this one point by a small margin.
- grishka 2y agoThe problem with QR codes is that they are read-only. I don't know about Montreal, but Moscow public transport uses similar paper tickets, also Mifare Ultralight, except you can get them for different number of trips. When you use your ticket, the turnstile or validator would increment those one-way counters so that the next one would know how many trips you have left. You can't do that with a QR code without either the reader or the user's device having a persistent internet connection to some sort of central server that would keep track of all tickets, which is impractical.
- Forricide 2y agoYou're correct, there are a bunch of different ticket options. Not sure about how it's actually implemented, though. Slightly tangential, but when I was in Montreal, I was blown away that you just purchase a ticket from a machine and you get a printed out ticket with an NFC chip inside. Not my favourite part of the trip (Montreal is beautiful!) but definitely a cool piece of technology to see being put to such a mundane use.
- chii 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kumarvvr 2y agoI am apalled at the crazy amount of waste this creates. Millions of tickets with chips inside them? My understanding is that they are one time use? In New Delhi metro, India, they used to use plastic tokens with these chips, but at the end of the journey, to exit the station you have to give the chip back. Nowadays, they use a printed QR system, and they have even gone paperless. I can buy the ticket with my mobile app, pay using UPI instant payment, and show the qr code on the phone to the scanner and then travel. For monthly card holders, rfid chip based cards are issued.
- zulban 2y agoThe fact that they cost just a few pennies each is a reflection of how little waste is occurring. If waste bothers you, focus on something worthwhile like canceling just one airline flight. Lifetime of a plastic opus card may even be more wasteful, by mass of plastic and chip, if not used extensively. For example, one time use is often for tourists, where a full chip opus would be very wasteful indeed.
- lxgr 2y ago> If waste bothers you, focus on something worthwhile like canceling just one airline flight. That's just whataboutism: If there's an alternative way of solving the same problem that generates less waste, why not use it? I find the contactless coin form factor for single rides quite clever personally, and I don't see any downsides compared to paper single-use tickets (other than that validators and gates need some storage container to collect them, which could be tricky in buses).
- zulban 2y agoJust because you don't see downsides doesn't mean there aren't any. Coins are lost or broken or intentionally damaged, and may need cleaning and staff to handle and transport them. It's not zero waste. In fact I suspect the STM solution may overall have less waste. If you read the article, the chip is the size of a grain of salt. Airline is not just whataboutism. It illustrates the absurdity of scale in your point. Imagine someone who is spending 20 minutes to save themselves 4 pennies on their electrical bill, but they are running 8 air conditioners with their windows open during a heatwave. Yes, that's whataboutism, but it's an informal fallacy, meaning I may still have a good point.
- kalleboo 2y agoI recently learned that you can just give a printing company a hundred bucks or so and have custom NFC cards printed for you, you don't actually have to be a big transit agency with an ongoing contract for millions of the things and a custom JavaCard NFC application or w/e coded for you. I used this knowledge to replace the QR code membership card to my friend's bar with an NFC card version, it looks really cool in your wallet compared to all the flimsy paper stamp cards from the other bars.
- Ekaros 2y agoYou can even get blank cards, I have a few from university days. And you can get card printer... Can't find exact price now, but not extremely priced. In theory you could just do whole thing in single location from coding the card to printing it, even with custom information.
- Arch-TK 2y agoInteresting discussions in the comments regarding reuse, waste, QR codes, etc. Worth bearing in mind that in the UK train stations have mixed NFC, QR and magnetic readers. The ones which are the least reliable are the magnetic readers which operate on paper cards. The NFC readers are used for pre-paid ticket cards and credit/debit cards. The QR scanners for so called "E-Tickets". I don't really ever see anyone have problems with the QR tickets (they're static and distributed as PDF or pkpass). Likewise with NFC. Only the paper magstripe cards commonly cause problems. Meanwhile in the Shanghai metro they use chip coins. Small, reusable and NFC. I think these paper NFC things are a unique combination of non-reusable, prone to damage, prone to jamming. But they are cool.
- solarized 2y agoTo peoples asking: "Why not just QR codes?" Again it's all about latency. QR codes take longer when you tap them at the gate: opening the app, waiting for the scanner to adjust, connecting to inet. While NFC handle these tasks almost instantly. A big difference in super busy places where queues are a nightmare. Again, this problem wouldn't exist if we can optimize WFH methods. We don't need to solving "physical problems" from start to finish. Making, distributing, and recycling all those ticket papers. No matter how advanced your transportation tech is, moving people long distances is still really costly. Sorry to "steer" this conversation into WFH and WFO topics.
- BOOSTERHIDROGEN 2y agohttps://atadistance.net/2024/05/31/jr-east-and-tokyo-private-rail-lines-agree-to-replace-mag-strip-paper-tickets-with-qr-starting-in-2026/ https://atadistance.net/2024/05/31/jr-east-and-tokyo-private...
- asah 2y ago1000s of people leaving a stadium faces the same latency: not a WFH/WFO issue
- solarized 2y agoHaha, absolutely! Just to generalize, those thousands of people can also watch the match by streaming, right? It's all about remote versus physical activities. We can't shift everything into remote mode. However, we don't need to hustle into physical mode every day either. Yeah, yin yang complexity, balancing everything out.
- zuppy 2y agoi’m not a sports fan, but the feeling of being there can’t be compared to watching the event from home. this is not the part to optimize, in my opinion.
- fennecfoxy 2y agoNot really a comparable thing versus the morning/evening rush every single weekday when forcing people in-office. It's the scale that makes it an issue, 1000s of people is nothing and more of an occasional spike. See how London deals with toob stations for pride, for example, by closing and controlling some, exit only periods close to the event, open ticket gates, etc.
- elric 2y agoFree public transport would make all of this stuff unnecessary.
- pluc 2y agoThere is no such thing as free public transport.
- account42 2y agoThere is also no such thing as public transport fully funded by ticket sales. If there are large government subsidies then it is a valid question if all the costs associated with ticketing are worth it.
- gpm 2y agoThere is. The same way as "non-toll roads", "fire departments", "public schools", and so on. If you want a concrete american privately run and open to the public example, see Stanford's buses in Palo Alto...
- reportgunner 2y agoI was living under the impression that the Oyster card already solved this problem years ago.
- vaughnegut 2y agoiirc (it's been over a decade), the Oyster card is a plastic card with an NFC in it. Montreal's Opus card does the exact same thing (and is probably modelled off of it and similar implementations in other cities). This article is describing the disposable, single-use ones. If you don't want to use disposable ones, the same kiosk that dispenses the temporary cards will allow you to buy a permanent one which you can load with fares as normal.
- _spduchamp 2y agoOMG! Last time I went to get on the Subway in Montreal, the line up at the station to purchase one of these tickets was crazy long that I just gave up. There was no way to enter the subway by paying directly. You had to purchase one of these tickets. In Toronto, you can just tap your credit card to get on the subway. Also, you see these Montreal cards laying all over the streets. This card system just seems so messed up in Montreal.
- xkcd1963 2y agoYes but this allows silly transit companies to retroactively charge your CC like in London
- wiz21c 2y agoFTA: > It's remarkable that these NFC chips can be manufactured so cheaply that they are disposable In our times, where we slowly understand that we have problems of resources and waste, I find it very disturbing that "disposable" is considered a positive achievement by the author.
- indoordin0saur 2y agoThese are so tiny that throwing them away is a drop in the bucket in terms of waste. It's less waste than your morning coffee produces.
- lwptnsskog 2y ago[dead]
- neop1x 2y agoExcept coffee is biologically degradable and functions as a fertilizer. These chips are just dispersing sand grain dust everywhere.
- kens 2y agoNo, I do not consider "disposable" to be a positive achievement. I consider it to be surprising and worthy of attention that NFC chips are so cheap that they are disposable.
- ck45 2y agoThe article itself is a very interesting summary of the technology used. As for the comments, there seems to be a big discussion on whether NFC or barcodes (includes QR codes) are the better technology for public transport ticket I have a completely different view: No matter what technology you are using, after having used public transport in multiple cities in Germany with the same flat rate tickets, I wonder if this could be feasible in every city or country. Just not caring about a ticket seems to be the most user friendly option. It seems to work well, but such a system would need to prove itself in areas where public transport is already quite crowded, like London.
- JBiserkov 2y ago"Not only should municipal transit be zero fare, using it should provide tax credits." "This is a genuine, serious proposal. Cars and car infrastructure are so enormously expensive and destructive. Paying people to use public transit instead would be a net positive, and it's not even close." From: https://hachyderm.io/@jenniferplusplus/112667806776752372 https://hachyderm.io/@jenniferplusplus/112667806776752372
- bunderbunder 2y agoI'd actually go the other way around. I see a lot more value in getting smaller public transit systems onto a common standard. Getting set up to use public transit as a visitor to a top tier city like New York, Brussels or Montreal (I can't speak to London) is easy. Usually they have explanatory signage and staffed kiosks at all the major intercity transit stations. And good websites that clearly explain what visitors need to know to navigate the system. It's visiting a city with a lower-tier transit system that tends to pose a greater challenge. I'm thinking here of cities like St. Louis, Milwaukee or Portland. Stations may not have attendants, automated kiosks may not be well-maintained, websites tend to be ill-designed or be missing key information about how to use the system, etc. And, on top of all that, I'm not necessarily visiting there often enough to amortize the (already relatively high, due to the aforementioned problems) cost of getting to know the system across may visits. And I certainly don't want to have 15 different transit apps and payment accounts to juggle. Standardizing the fare structures and payment systems could be a big boon to visitors. There's potentially more value to the the smaller transit systems themselves in standardizing, too. None of them is individually a large enough system to achieve good economies of scale w/r/t the technical and administrative costs of maintaining their own special snowflake fare system.
- GnarfGnarf 2y agoIn the 60's I hacked the Montreal Metro's transfers, and rode free. The punched holes recorded time and date code.
- nayuki 2y agoWhile the chip technology is interesting, I found the human factors on Montreal's public transit system to be bad. This is based on my experiences in 2023. The reusable OPUS transit card expires after 4 years unless you have a photo registered. In almost all cities, adult transit cards don't expire and don't require photo/name registration. https://www.stm.info/en/info/fares/opus-cards-and-other-fare-media/opus-card https://www.stm.info/en/info/fares/opus-cards-and-other-fare... The system does not have a concept of a monetary balance ($). The system only has tickets (bought in blocks of 1, 2, or 10 with appropriate discounts) and unlimited passes (24 hr, 3 day, week, month). Note that I define a "ticket" as an abstract authorization to ride transit for one trip, not a physical object. There is no discount for using OPUS. If you buy a block of 10 tickets, it's the same cost whether you load it onto a disposable paper card or on a plastic long-term OPUS card. There is no incentive to reduce waste. The Greater Montreal Area is divided into fare zones, A/B/C/D. You can use any supported transport agency and vehicle (bus, subway, commuter rail, possibly others) to make your trip. Ticket/pass types have cumulative fare zones, i.e. A or AB or ABC or ABCD. This isn't wrong per se; this is just setting up a definition for what's to come. An OPUS card is locked to one set of fare zones for the purpose of buying tickets. For example, your card might be set to zone A, or maybe zones ABC. You can only buy and spend tickets of that type. However, you can buy passes for any zones, but they are expensive and intended for long-term commuters. A new paper card can be bought for any set of zones. e.g. If you want to travel from somewhere in zone A to somewhere in zone C, you buy a zone ABC fare ticket. A paper card cannot be reloaded after the initial purchase. There is only tap-on, no tap-off. So if you board at zone A, there is no way for the transport system to electronically know if you exited in zone A, B, C, or D. This also means that an open payment supporting credit cards cannot deduct the correct fare amount. There are random fare inspections from human officers to ensure you hold a tapped card with the correct fare type at the location of the inspection. In light of this entire setup, I can understand why an OPUS card is locked to one set of zones for tickets (which are counted down as you use them). If you tap your OPUS card at a reader in zone A but you own tickets of multiple zone types on the card, how does the reader know which ticket to deduct? Montreal has brought this problem on themselves by not having tap-off and also not using a money-based system. To make matters worse, the fare vending machines at subway stations are inadequate. There are not enough of them, the menus are slow to navigate through, paying by cash or credit card may have additional frictions (e.g. cash rejected, no change, card payment failure). Thus there is often a queue to buy tickets, making the travel experience that much worse. (Meanwhile, I found Japan's ticket-vending machines to be top-notch - very clear instructions, fast machine response times, and excellent handling of cash.) By comparison, Toronto has a different strategy and different problems on the PRESTO contactless fare card. The TTC has a flat fare and 2-hour free transfers within the system. GO transit has tap-on and tap-off for buses and trains. For a long time, there was no fare integration between transit agencies, so you had to pay separately on each system; this changed in Feb 2024 so that you pay more or less the maximum of what each agency on your trip charges rather than the sum of the components. Japan's transit systems mostly use tap-on tap-off, even many buses, and charge by distance. (There are small exceptions like the Kyoto bus being flat fare.) Transit pricing and ticketing is almost an entirely solved problem for decades; the rest of the world can learn from them. (There are still small exceptions, like how travelling between two different IC card regions, like from Numazu to Tokyo, requires a paper ticket.) As you can see, even if you live permanently in Montreal and own an OPUS card (e.g. zones AB), as soon as you need to make a trip outside (e.g. zones ABCD) your usual area, you need to interact with a ticket-vending machine and buy a paper card. Meanwhile, in Toronto or Japan, you hold one card and the transit systems deduct the correct amount of money based on the trip that you take. Heck, Toronto introduced open payments in 2023, so you don't even need to buy the transit card.
- wkjagt 2y agoI can't help but feeling a little sad about single use electronics. Not even from an environmental perspective (though there's that too) but just the fact that there's some pretty cool electronics, doing digital and analog stuff, wireless communication etc, that does it's thing once, and then never again.
- neop1x 2y agoThey use something similar in Athens, a paper one-use ticket with a tiny chip inside https://realgreekexperiences.com/locals-guide-to-taking-the-athens-metro https://realgreekexperiences.com/locals-guide-to-taking-the-...