8 ms·
Traffic engineers build roads relying on outdated research, faulty data
- bluejekyll 2y agoSomething that makes this even more insidious, is that trying to change roads to be safer often triggers many studies about the impact of those changes. These range from studies on traffic congestion, to safety itself, local business impact, etc. What makes this so hypocritical is that hardly any of those studies were done when the roads were put in, or subsequently widened. There were no studies on how wide, fast roads would negatively impact neighborhoods. How they would make it dangerous just to walk around, or increase the local pollution (air and particulates ending up in streams). They didn’t study how these widened roads might negatively impact downtowns, etc. All of this car investment happened as though it was for the greater good, and many people still believe this.
- SoftTalker 2y agoStudies like this always seem to me to be a formality. The conclusions are what the person paying for the study wants them to be. If a local municipality is anti-car, they will run a study justifying adding bike lanes everywhere, even though once they are built you never see bicycles in them, and they create more difficulty for cars by narrowing or taking away lanes. Or they'll install "traffic calming" speed bumps, chicanes, or curb-extension bottlenecks on neighborhood roads when (almost) nobody in the neighborhood wanted them. On the other hand, if they are pro-development, their studies will show that a new or widened road will lead to more business development, more jobs, more tax revenue.
- jeromegv 2y agoBike lanes success are well measured and will often carry more people than a car lanes will.
- Filligree 2y agoThey carry more bicyclists, you mean. /s
- bluejekyll 2y agoNo, they also carry people on trikes, in motorized wheel chairs, scooters, joggers, people on those mono wheel things. Bikes might be the most popular choice, but many people are starting to refer to these lanes as “mobility-lanes” because they improve the lives of more than just bicyclists.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago> Bike lanes success are well measured Where? Outside of cities with very high density I don't see this being true. For medium density and less, what I've seen is that bike lanes remain empty. Bike counters basically show them to be failures, since the utilization barely increases over time or even lags population growth, while the car lanes remain fully utilized.
- oopsallmagic 2y agoAre these the same bike lanes that start and stop randomly and are often just the shoulder of a 45-mi/h road with a bike, and implied middle finger, painted on?
- oblio 2y agoHave you EVER tried to bike for commuting, grocery shopping, transportation in general, on those bike lanes? If cyclists aren't using them, they're not doing it to spite you. They're doing it because there's no network and 500m of bike lane doesn't take them somewhere useful or because they're badly designed and dangerous or very unpleasant due to heavy car traffic, pollution, etc.
- 2y ago
- tom_vidal 2y agoYour car bias is showing here. The reason bike lanes and traffic calming measures get installed is because people are literally dying due to poor road design that prioritizes car speed over everything else. You might not want traffic calming, but everyone else who has to deal with your driving does.
- bloomingeek 2y agoAnd isn't it really about how people are driving? In my state, we drive like maniacs, constantly speeding at least ten MPH over the limit. The term, "drive friendly" is scoffed at. Slowing down to let someone on the highway is unseen. On city streets, tailgating is common, jacked up pick-ups are drenching the interior of your car with their headlights after dark, making all your mirrors a blinding image. Can we please put our phones down for safety's sake? Sometimes I ride a motorcycle, so I'm hyper aware and see all kinds of just plain terrible driving practices. Most of it is simply a lack of patience behind the wheel. On the turnpike, when that car passes doing twenty over, do we really think they think about the possible consequences?
- bluecalm 2y agoYes, people in general are terrible at driving. Teaching them is hopeless that's why we need solutions that works. There are two right now: infrastructure that makes it hard and very inconvenient to go fast and heavy handed enforcement. The latter option only works in very well developed civilised societes like Switzerland or Nordic countries have. Most others are stuck with traffic calling measures as their population has too little too lose to care about safety.
- orwin 2y agoThe solution is easy, I just saw it implemented in a nearby town (8k people): make the road curb a little, never fully straight, add bollards everywhere on the side of the road, and narrow the road at every crossing (with metal/concrete bollards). Bollards are great: they protect pedestrian and are intimidating it seems. According to the mayor (I ate with him, friend of my mother) the architect who gave him the idea was a nudge expert, and they tested it first with thin, plastic bollards around the town (it worked, but wasn't protective enough). The city is halfway between two economic 'centers' (28k and 50k population) and see a lot of traffic as those cities grow. No pedestrian death in the last two years AFAIK, when pre-covid you had half a dozen injuries every year and a mortal accident every other year. So the bollards do seems to work. Install bollards!
- II2II 2y agoAt least in my city, devices were installed in many bike lanes in order to count the number of userd. They show that people do use them. As for traffic calming, curb extensions, etc.: the city only started adding those modifications after pedestrian fatalities started going up and people started demanding them because they got tired of hearing about deaths all of the time. None of this is because the city is pro/anti-development since most of the projects could be construed either way. In a lot of cases it was simply to see which measures were effective because we often lack the data to know what will be effective.
- jimberlage 2y agoWe did a study in my neighborhood after two pedestrian deaths. The deaths definitely were the motivator for the community action and studies. You know why the idiot traffic engineers made the streets so wide in the area where these oversized cars killed two people? “The average commute on the road would be extended by 1 minute.”
- rootusrootus 2y ago> hardly any of those studies were done when the roads were put in, or subsequently widened Where do you get this idea? NIMBY works every bit as well on new or expanded roads, and it gets used constantly. Hell, we've spent hundreds of millions of dollars just trying to decide if we can build a new bridge, and that doesn't even involve actual planning. It's amazing we get any infrastructure projects done now given that every single person can stall them indefinitely.
- bluGill 2y agoonly when someone speaks up. The worst roads are in nobodies backyard (who likes on a stroad - nobody, they all live on cul-de-sacs off the stroad)
- rootusrootus 2y agoPerhaps you live somewhere were everyone is content? My neighborhood is full of people (admittedly, many older) who mobilize at the slightest rumor of change anywhere in our vicinity. Bigger road? No way, that means more traffic. More houses? No way, that means more traffic. The neighborhood associate is quite active about staying on top of anything planned for this region of the city so they can light up our inboxes with information. Probably the one thing they wouldn't really be bothered by is expanding that cul-de-sac, as long as it will still be a dead end and not a new connection that traffic might choose to use to transit across the neighborhood.
- panick21_ 2y agoThis might be true now, but it wasn't when all these massive highways, roads and stroads were built. US cities weren't destroyed because the people that lived there voted on it. For the most part you had a bureaucratic elite come in over the top and simply create laws and change the regulation.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago> US cities weren't destroyed US cities were not destroyed, and this is just misinformation, or hyperbole at best. In fact virtually all cities benefited from car infrastructure, since it brings people and things to the city, lets people efficiently get around, and so on. It helps the economic value of a city and also improves quality of life. If this wasn't true, there would have been a response with a broad political base. But there hasn't been. At best, a tiny minority of residents gets upset about roads and organizes into activist groups that make such claims. But the majority of the public enjoys and utilizes driving infrastructure.
- dmix 2y ago> Something that makes this even more insidious, is that trying to change roads to be safer often triggers many studies about the impact of those changes. These range from studies on traffic congestion, to safety itself, local business impact, etc. I thought you were going to say they spend all their effort on studies to appease every special interest group instead of actually fixing things.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 2y ago<< These are the sorts of systemic conditions that lead to many so-called road user errors. There is certainly an argument to be made that we are all outcomes of the system in which we operate. That is to say, we all victims of circumstance. Does that, however, mean bicycles should swerve between cars like motorcycles in CA ( and lately -- illegally -- in IL ) or go against the traffic diagonally? Both examples are admittedly anecdotal, but very recent and both from recent trip downtown. At the end of the day, it is the user error. Having a tank to drive just happens to be re-assurance that whatever happens, the other user will bear the brunt of their bad decision.. which is supposed to be deterrent. But, apparently, it is not. I honestly do not know what it is about bikes, but not completely unlike BMWs and Teslas, they seem to attract oddly aggressive drivers.
- bowsamic 2y agoCyclists just don't see themselves as normal road traffic, so they don't see themselves as having the same responsibilities or held to the same standard, which is something I'm guilty of myself. I've ridden against traffic for short periods or ran red lights on a bike before (where it's clearly safe to do so), since I feel "semi-pedestrian"
- imabotbeep2937 2y ago"Against traffic" is different as a bike or led though. Sometimes when lanes are very narrow and visibility isn't good, you need to go against traffic (on the shoulder) so that the driver sees your face and responds faster. And you can see to bail if someone hasn't made room. But if it's a Chicago intersection and you just said I'm on a bike all 12 lanes have to yield to me and you zoom diagonal in front of cars... the Darwin Awards are never short of applicants. E-bikes and scooters and stuff have made this 1,000 times worse. The number of drunk kids who think they can go max speed down a hill through intersections and cars will just magically make way for them... Terrifying.
- idontwantthis 2y agoBikes don’t kill entire families when they crash. They don’t need to follow the same rules as cars. Forcing them to follow rules meant for cars makes the roads more dangerous.
- marcus0x62 2y agoAnd they sometimes get very upset when people call them out on their BS. https://www.vice.com/en/article/n7jq98/man-fined-for-engineering-without-a-license-was-right-all-along https://www.vice.com/en/article/n7jq98/man-fined-for-enginee... https://indyweek.com/news/wake/state-engineer-files-complaint-group-challenged-traffic-study/ https://indyweek.com/news/wake/state-engineer-files-complain...
- complaintdept 2y agoThere's data that suggests that the increases in vehicle/pedestrian collision is mostly due to the in car displays that require you to take your eyes off of the road to do anything. Most excess collisions since around 2010 collisions have been at night, when peripheral vision is less likely to catch movement, and when the screens will mess up your night vision. Also, smartphones being used while driving are a massive hazard that people aren't really talking about. The number of people that I, or my passenger, has seen texting while driving is really shocking. I'd wager it's a bigger problem than drunk driving ever was.
- imabotbeep2937 2y agoLiterally in the article.
- complaintdept 2y agoOh god the shame.
- SoftTalker 2y ago> the screens will mess up your night vision This was a huge problem in a car I rented recently. There was so much light coming off the dash I could hardly see the road, and there was no obvious way to dim it (all my older cars have a dedicated knob or wheel to control the dashboard brightness).
- Neywiny 2y agoMine has increase/decrease buttons but once the headlights go on it gets a lot dimmer. I like that except for when I'm going through a tunnel or something and it gets a bit distracting having so much change brightness at once
- hypeatei 2y ago> and there was no obvious way to dim it This is another issue that plagues a lot of modern cars. Lack of physical buttons and moving a bunch of functionality into the touchscreen which increases distractions and causes the driver to get flustered.
- imabotbeep2937 2y agoKey missing component: CAFE needs a rewrite. US emissions laws have a cutout so that larger vehicles have less stringent emissions requirements. The problem is that this is no longer a gap it's a chasm. Slight hyperbole but a Japanese kei car many Americans would love town own muat do closer to 50mpg, while a monster pickup can do 15mpg. It ends up that a small car can cost $15,000 and the giant pickup costs... $15,000. Many consumers compare the two and wonder if the econobox is really a good choice. The bright shining hope: Most Americans do not want these big cars. Legislation is making small vehicles less competitive, when it should be the other way. AKA - we have good, cheap(ish) electric trucks now. Legislation doesn't need to worry about farmers who can't afford electric anymore.
- SoftTalker 2y agoUnless it's a total stripper meant for something like a highway maintenance department fleet vehicle, a "giant pickup" will cost 3 or 4 times that amount.
- SkyPuncher 2y agoThe most popular F-150 trim level runs about $50k. It’s not stripped out by any means.
- Neywiny 2y agoYeah whenever I'm in an SUV I try to compare mileage. They'll get ~30% worse mpg than me in the same situation and I'm just a gas sedan, not even a hybrid
- krisoft 2y ago> I'm just a gas sedan We are trully living in the future. :) I heard that cars are getting smarter but you are the first i have the pleasure to chat with. Joking asside, i don’t know if I have ever seen a more succint example of how people identify with their cars.
- 2y ago
- tom_vidal 2y agoThe YouTuber Not Just Bikes made a great point in one of his videos: why in the world are public safety improvements up for debate? If people keep falling off a walkway, we don’t hold town hall meetings to debate the merits of pedestrian safety, we don’t do studies on the impact to traffic flow, we just put up a railing. Here in Philadelphia, advocacy groups spent years fighting to have a wide, lethal stroad that runs through the middle of the city put on a road diet. Residents were polled, and something like 70% of people in the surrounding neighborhoods were in favor of it. The city spent millions in planning and engineering, and then right before paving was about to start, a local councilmember blocked it and canceled the whole project on the half of the road that runs through their neighborhood. So half of the road was narrowed to two lanes and has no speeding, no fatalities, and generally sane driver behavior. The other half is a reckless free-for-all that’s exhausting to drive on and terrifying for pedestrians and cyclists. Millions in taxpayer dollars and the political will of a majority of citizens were wasted because our system allows one NIMBY to stop everything. A year later, there has already been a cyclist fatality on the road.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- throwaway22032 2y agoPutting up a railing has no cost other than financial. Narrowing a road makes it worse for its' primary purpose. You would definitely not just narrow a footpath on a busy high street without considering the impact.
- audunw 2y ago> Narrowing a road makes it worse for its' primary purpose. The worst thing is, this isn’t always true. A good two lane street can have similar or better average speed than a bad four lane stroad.
- throwaway22032 2y agoWhich has higher throughput?
- Neywiny 2y agoMaybe those safety rating systems should include the things SUVs are bad at. I think there's one tester who does a body roll test and most SUVs fail to swerve out of the way of something without rolling. Unsure if that's still true. But with that and like a "how likely is your child to be squished dead" rating, maybe people will think twice
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bloopernova 2y agoUntil the US government isn't deadlocked and is able to pass new laws, this isn't going to get better at all. The huge hoods/bonnets on SUVs and trucks need to be regulated to make future cars smaller. I'm not an expert (I'll pontificate anyway) but could external airbags help at all? One issue with our neighbourhood is that SUVs use our road to skip past 2 junctions that get congested during school drop-off/pickup. The moms sometimes look ridiculously tiny in their urban tanks, but they speed through a residential road to shave off a minute from their school run. People in cars appear to act more selfishly than people outside of cars (has there been any research on that?) and I think roads should be designed with that in mind.
- swayvil 2y agoThere's a parallel between driving behavior and internet behavior. Both isolated, inspiring recklessness.
- bobthepanda 2y agoThe difference between Europe and the US is fairly simple. Euro NCAP has a pedestrian collision test as part of the safety rating and NCAP does not, only pedestrian avoidance. If you could not get a five star safety rating because your car mangles somebody when hitting them at 30mph the tune would change pretty quickly. See all the things tested in Euro NCAP in section 2.2. https://www.euroncap.com/media/80156/euro-ncap-aeb-lss-vru-test-protocol-v451.pdf https://www.euroncap.com/media/80156/euro-ncap-aeb-lss-vru-t...
- frankus 2y agoWhat's weird is IIHS (a non-government nonprofit) is publishing articles like this [1] and yet AFAIK doesn't incorporate pedestrian safety into its new-car ratings. One would think insurance companies would also be interested in the safety of the people whom their insured collide with. [1] https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/designers-must-make-vehicles-safe-for-everyone--not-just-drivers-and-passengers https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/designers-must-make-vehicle...
- 2y ago
- lolinder 2y ago"Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. Three times is enemy action." It sounds like the problem we have here is that each individual incident is analyzed and catalogued as an incident, so we never get to 'enemy action'. The most urgent issue to resolve is whose insurance is going to pay for it, which requires assigning blame, and in each case it's usually clear where the blame lies. This is all the system working entirely as expected and we can't really skip this step. What ought to happen next is that the incidents get compiled, trends turn up, and we change our designs according to those trends. The article is pretty light on details about the extent to which this isn't happening among traffic engineers. Requiring smaller vehicles or banning touchscreens has to come from Congress, so it's outside the control of any city's engineers. Anecdotally, the engineers in my own city seem pretty determined to consider the possibility that any given accident had a bad design as the root cause, and regularly fix and improve intersections and road markings according to what is happening. They're not perfect, but I don't get the sense that they're resting easy on the assurance that it's all user error either.
- romaaeterna 2y agoSome time ago, I read all of the published data on the safety of traffic circles, as I had often seen them recommended as a safer alternative to traffic lights. I was not very impressed. The confounding factors for the traffic light to circle projects were always far too large, and it always had to be coupled with the fact that it was usually poorest intersections that get rebuilt. I no longer have a high opinion of traffic safety research as a field. Regarding this article's claims in particular, traffic fatalities went up a certain amount after 2020, and I doubt that road design changes were a primary driver. (Policing trends are one possible candidate.) Regardless, in the last six months or so, my Tesla's autodrive went from "expensive joke" to "safer driver than me". IMO, leveraging existing technology could cut traffic deaths to a small fraction of what they are now over 3-5 years, were we to pursue aggressive conversion of the existing vehicle fleet.
- coredog64 2y agoThe city replaced a 4 way stop with a traffic circle and ever since there’s been a car-totaling collision at least every other month. One leg of the circle is fed from a highway off-ramp, with a good portion of folks entering the circle at 150% of the legal limit. Another leg is from a 4 lane road that feeds the highway on-ramp, and those folks are getting amped for highway driving. I’m always nervous in the circle as I can’t count the times I’ve had to quickly brake to avoid being t-boned by some moron who doesn’t understand what a yield sign means. Traffic circles really need a critical mass of drivers that know how to use them academically before they get installed all over town.
- wetpaws 2y ago[dead]
- tstrimple 2y agoI'm curious how you get car totaling crashes in a traffic circle. Generally the traffic circles that have been installed around me are all relatively small and greatly cut down on speed going through the intersection. I could absolutely see an increase in fender bender style accidents here, because for some reason how to operate a traffic circle is an impossible mystery to Iowa drivers. But how are cars being totaled? I remember when driving in SoCal, there was a massive traffic circle that I could see people maintaining fairly high speeds through and could see major accidents happening. But everything I see locally would be low speed collisions.
- robomartin 2y agoIt's a dramatic article likely intended to help sell his book (with an equally dramatic title). Missing from all of this is, well, data. He squarely blames large vehicles, SUV's. Now, I have no horse in this race, I prefer small vehicles for practical every-day driving. For moving family, dogs, camping trips, etc., a minivan is great. Yet, at a very basic level, some of what he is saying makes no sense to me. Take this introductory statement: "As a country, we hit the threshold of 1 million cumulative deaths in 1953, 2 million in 1975 and 3 million in 1998. While the past several years of data have not yet been released, I estimate that the U.S. topped 4 million total road deaths sometime in the spring of 2024." So, 4 million by 2024. Fully half of that by 1975. Care to guess how many SUV's existed in 1975? Also, I am going to guess average speeds where likely lower. He is blaming SUV's and claiming that making them 10 cm lower would have a dramatic impact on results. OK, well, if the data up until 1975 is any indication, this is nonsense. How about distractions, drunk driving and, yes, pedestrians and cyclists. Accidents are not always attributable to one side or a single variable. The world is a complex multivariate problem. This guy is trying to sell books by hating on everything and only blaming one or two variables: SUV's bad, wide roads, bad. And then there's are the circumstances of each accident. He gives the example of an SUV losing control, jumping a curb and killing a father and his kid. Well, not every accident is like that. And, no, life isn't going to be perfectly safe. You are not going to go down to zero accidents and zero fatalities, no matter how hard you might try. Which brings me to the last point: He offers not data whatsoever on how things would improve if his world view were to be adopted. If we ripped-up and modified every road and shrunk every vehicle by 10 cm. You see, it is easy to be critical of anything when you don't have to be accountable for any of it. Happens all the time with "experts". As an example, the financial world is full of economists who just "know" all there is to know about finance...yet none of them are billionaires and few (none?) run successful businesses at scale. Yes, of course, road safety is important. I just think that the solutions include far more variables than what this guy trying to sell a book seems to be focusing on in this article. In a few decades, self-driving cars might solve this problem nicely. Don't know.
- achenet 2y agoyou've got a good point about experts being critical with no accountability. However, when studying a complex, multivariate problem, if you find one or two variables that can easily affect the outcome (lower hood heights), it does seem sensible to optimize it, while obviously keeping in mind that you can optimize for other things.
- xyst 2y agoThere is overwhelming evidence against the increase of dependency on car centric transportation. Yet people just don't get it until it impacts them personally (ie, death of loved one, loss of limbs of friends, paralysis, DUI). I'm honestly done with trying to convince politicians, car-brains, "traffic engineers", transportation departments that they way we have been scaling our infrastructure is a tremendous waste of resources. Every talking point they have presented has a mountain evidence against it, yet they continue churning away at "wE mUsT bUiLd mOrE hIgHwAyS!!1 [at the expense of the federal/state/local budgets, environment, and communities near these projects]".
- GiorgioG 2y agoFor those of you that want small vehicles, they exist for the buying. For those of you who want big vehicles, you’re in luck, they also exist for the buying. Anyone that wants to limit people’s choices can shove it up your arse!
- jenadine 2y agoHow about the choice to be able to walk or cycle in a safe environment?
- oopsallmagic 2y ago[flagged]
- GiorgioG 2y agoThe idea that squishy humans can move about safely near 1500kg+ moving vehicles traveling at even average speed is a fallacy. The first cycling/car fatality happened in 1896. I guarantee you that vehicle size and weight was much less than what we have today.
- krisoft 2y agoOkay. So the two choices come into conflict. How does that old adage goes? "Your Liberty To Swing Your Fist Ends Just Where My Nose Begins"? How does it differ when you are not swinging your fist but using a multi ton vehicle to move people down? If I take your comment at face value it seems you are arguing that we should ban all cars not just the very heavy ones?
- oopsallmagic 2y ago[flagged]
- oopsallmagic 2y ago[dead]
- tzs 2y ago> And our reality is one where more pedestrians and bicyclists are getting killed on U.S. streets than at any time in the past 45 years – over 1,000 bicyclists and 7,500 pedestrians in 2022 alone It links to https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/yearly-snapshot https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/yearl... for that 7500 pedestrians in 2022 figure. Yet on that very same page there is a table of pedestrian and bicyclist deaths going back to 1975, which shows that 1977-1981 all had more pedestrian deaths (7732, 7795, 8096, 8070, and 7837) than 2022 (7522). Several of those years are within the last 45 years. For bicyclists 2022 is indeed the biggest year just edging out 1977 (1084 vs 1003). This might be forgiven as just being a little sloppy. If he'd just have said "past 40 years" instead of "past 45 years" then it would have been accurate. But wait...the US population was 338 million in 2022, and around 220 million in 1979. We really should look at rates. 2020 pedestrian deaths per 100k population were 2.22. They were above that every year from 1975-1991. Same for bicyclists--every year from 1975-1991 was higher than 2020. For pedestrians the rates peaked in 1979 at 3.76 then declined fairly linearly to 1.33 in 2009, then rose again fairly linearly to 1.95 in 2020, then jumped a bit to 2.22 for 2021 and 2022. Same pattern for bicyclists. Here's a graph of the rates by year [1]. The bicyclist rates are per 1m instead of per 100k to make them easier to read. [1] https://imgur.com/a/BJ2h9o9 https://imgur.com/a/BJ2h9o9
- Gunax 2y agoI just want to thank you for this effort post. It looks like the general thrust of 'pedestrian and cyclist fatalities are increasing' may be true, even if the particular examples given are not
- fransje26 2y agoCan you do a correlation plot or a comparison plot with the percentage of SUVs being sold/on the road? Edit: Mmm.. Possibly correlates more with smartphone usage..
- tzs 2y agoHere's something [1]. Data on the car market makeup by year is from here [2]. I only used the data for every 5 years because it is in a stacked line chart and I had to turn it into a table by measuring the heights of the various sections and lack the patience to do it for every year [3]. I omitted pickups and vans/minivans because the pickup share hasn't varied much and vans/minivans have a small share and including them made the graph too hard to read. Here are the shares in table form so you can mentally add them back if you wish. Minivans Sedans & Truck Car & Pickups Vans SUVs SUVs Wagons 1975 13% 4% 2% 0% 81% 1980 13% 2% 2% 0% 83% 1985 13% 6% 4% 0% 78% 1990 13% 9% 4% 2% 72% 1995 15% 11% 7% 2% 65% 2000 15% 7% 17% 4% 57% 2005 13% 7% 19% 4% 57% 2010 11% 4% 22% 9% 54% 2015 11% 4% 28% 9% 48% 2020 15% 2% 37% 11% 35% 2023 17% 2% 46% 11% 24% [1] https://imgur.com/gallery/pedestrian-death-rates-car-market-makeup-SAVFN8u https://imgur.com/gallery/pedestrian-death-rates-car-market-... [2] https://www.theautopian.com/heres-the-exact-year-suv-sales-overtook-sedan-sales-in-america/ https://www.theautopian.com/heres-the-exact-year-suv-sales-o... [3] Yes, I first tried ChatGPT. It was able to turn the chart into a table, but it too only did every 5th year, and some of its numbers were quite a bit off.
- CHB0403085482 2y agoThese Stupid Trucks are Literally Killing Us by Not Just Bikes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jN7mSXMruEo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jN7mSXMruEo
- mannyv 2y agoNo matter how you slice it, a large moving object will do severe damage to a pedestrian or bicyclist. The only car that's safe for pedestrians is the one that isn't moving, which is why pedestrian impact isn't a factor in safety.
- tstrimple 2y ago> The only car that's safe for pedestrians is the one that isn't moving Funnily enough, my first major bike accident as a kid involved me running into a parked pickup truck and ended up with a tooth going through my lip. Definitely my fault and not the truck's for just sitting there. But I thought it humorous that there are indeed people injured by non-moving vehicles.
- sharts 2y agoThat’s pretty obvious if you’ve visited any major city