10 ms·
Chat Control: Incompatible with Fundamental Rights (2022)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- primitivesuave 2y agoFear will always lead to an erosion of personal rights. Fear of child predators will lead to erosion of privacy rights, and fear of terrorists has deprived all Americans of the right to protection against unreasonable search/seizure. Welcome to modernity.
- dtx1 2y agoI for one blame the NPC Population that can't think more than 5 Minutes ahead in terms of policy.
- sneak 2y agoThe NPC population doesn’t know about this and doesn’t care. They haven’t heard of this and they don’t know what “e2ee” means. They have “nothing to hide”. They are your parents and grandparents, and your friends from work. I blame people who do know and write internet comments instead of taking action. How many of you have deleted your Instagram and Facebook accounts? How many of you are still reachable on WhatsApp and iMessage? How many people have you onboarded to Signal? How many people have you taught to sideload?
- dtx1 2y ago> The NPC population doesn’t know about this and doesn’t care. They haven’t heard of this and they don’t know what “e2ee” means. They have “nothing to hide”. They are your parents and grandparents, and your friends from work. You got it right: They do not care. They do not care that privacy, democracy and freedom are taken away from them because they never cared that they had that in the first place. It's the eternal conservative vote that will never consider an alternative regardless of fact. They vote Republican in the US and CDU here in Germany. Doesn't matter if they vote for a convicted criminal or that they ruin the future of their children and grandchildren. They got theirs, fuck everyone else. Doesn't matter what I do there's a block of at least a third to half the population that is not open to argument, reason or even facts. Fuck those People!
- HPsquared 2y agoIt's not really a left/right thing. These things always have "bipartisan support".
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> blame people who do know and write internet comments instead of taking action Amen. I’ve worked on privacy issues in the states. Never again. The overlap between people who care about privacy and those who are too lazy and/or nihilistic to engage with the civic process might as well be perfect. If you care about this, call your elected. If you won’t, that’s the problem.
- cheeseomlit 2y agoThey're nihilistic for a reason, I won't call my representative because its a waste of time. Privacy-minded Americans are a tiny subset of the population vs. the most powerful corporate entities and intelligence agencies in the world, there isn't anything we (or my representatives) can do or say that's going to make a meaningful difference. If the snowden leaks weren't enough to trigger a reckoning on this issue then nothing will. At this point civic engagement on privacy in the US basically amounts to political masturbation, it feels good but does nothing
- guappa 2y agoCalling others "NPC" is really telling about what kind of person you are. Yes, you're the only person who experiences inner thought and a complex existence.
- HPsquared 2y agoI don't think many people fear those things, they're just used as a rhetorical cudgel.
- blurbleblurble 2y agoMany do, many don't.
- inference-lord 2y agoHow much is 'modernity' screwing up your life right now?
- eimrine 2y agoCovid measures, enshittification of internets. Chat control in Russia has outcomes in people being exploited by thugs in the whole country. How can you observe the world without immediately seing these?
- atlasy1 2y agoThe same reason most people are a bit “thick” , stuff just won’t go into their brains or register with them. They have the mind of children but are in adult bodies with adult voices
- inference-lord 2y agoI'm actually surprised people wake up an give two fucks about any of this to be honest. It sounds like people looking for things to complain about. The "enshitification" of the internet makes me laugh.
- eimrine 2y ago> The "enshitification" of the internet makes me laugh. Because doing that is your job?
- inference-lord 2y agoI work in open source (donations based) and I don't believe the internet has been ruined.
- survirtual 2y agoGiven it has suppressed an entire planet of innovation, prosperity, possibility, and experience, I would say it has negatively impacted all of us in ways you can't fathom.
- uyzstvqs 2y agoWelcome to post-modernity*. It's evil and communism in a progressive jacket.
- peoplefromibiza 2y ago> It's evil and communism in a progressive jacket funny to read something like this as a response to a comment blaming spreading fabricated fear.
- andrelaszlo 2y agoFear is a completely normal and often useful emotion. What scares me is how terribly bad we are at dealing with it. This is the weakness that terrorists try to exploit, of course. We, as a society, seem to posess the emotional intelligence and maturity of a toddler being scared of the monster under the bed but happily following the friendly guy with a van full of candy. It makes me so sad.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chii 2y agoIt's been known since ancient times that the road to hell is paved with good intentions.
- torginus 2y agoThe irony of this is I don't think this will substantially reduce either the percieved or actual danger present to children. I don't think this will make parents stop worrying about their kids being grabbed by strange men, and the danger will be just as present as before.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoThat's only a fraction of the problem though. You have no idea how easy it is for for example, kids on the fortnite subreddit to end up on the NSFW fortnite subreddits and talk to others and start exchanging pictures. The other thing nobody wants to talk about is that it's not always adult creepy men approaching kids, it's the kids themselves that seek out sexual conversations with strangers on the internet. Sure, this is also the parents responsibility. But even with open phone access, internet filters, etc they will find a way, especially if their school gives them laptops and there's open wifi everywhere. That's where this is also for. Parents cannot monitor all their children's internet access at all times. Children will resist and find ways around parents' control, as it has always been.
- dekken_ 2y agoWe are not lead by our betters, is all I can surmise.
- shrubble 2y agoAre the recent shifts in electoral preferences the reason for the push? As a backhanded way to surveil those politicians and citizens with the "wrong views" on remigration, etc.?
- k__ 2y agoIf anything, such ideas are usually to appease people who are in favor of deportation.
- gillesjacobs 2y agoEdit: well like someone pointed out instead of party programmes and declarations, we should look at past voting behaviour on the 2021 vote: https://mepwatch.eu/9/vote.html?v=134463&eugroup=ID https://mepwatch.eu/9/vote.html?v=134463&eugroup=ID Seems like only the Greens, The Left and Afd within ID were against that first version of Chat Control. ___ This isn't the case though: the right-wing Identity and Democracy faction is explicitly pro-privacy, digital rights and against Chat Control. - https://id-party.eu/program/ https://id-party.eu/program/ (ID Party Official Site) - https://idgroup.eu/news/online-censorship-is-a-threat-to-eur https://idgroup.eu/news/online-censorship-is-a-threat-to-eur... (ID Group News) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_and_Democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_and_Democracy (Wikipedia Overview) - https://id-party.eu/declaration-of-antwerp/ https://id-party.eu/declaration-of-antwerp/ (ID Party Official Site) The ID group is opposed to EU-wide surveillance measures, and promises to protecting individual privacy and national sovereignty. Now ECR is also sceptical and have expressed concerns, though their voting record on privacy related legislation is more inconsistent, I believe.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 2y agoThose people would be retarded if they think it won't used to find, identify, and prosecute them.
- andrepd 2y agoYes, the push for electronic surveillance that's been ongoing for at least 15 years was caused by last week's election result... Sheesh
- mro_name 2y agoI wonder how it can be legal to repeatedly undermine constitution and push or vote for later high-court-nullified laws and be allowed to repeat as if nothing was wrong with that. Like drunk driving forever. We ban counter-constitutional activities outside parliament and authorities. Why not inside? I am much for 3-strikes here.
- chopin 2y ago0-strike. It should be expected that elected officials respect the constitution.
- dustfinger 2y agoI agree with 0-strikes. Elect officials should be under constant investigation for any form of nefarious behavior and they should be prosecuted as any citzen would be.
- sneak 2y agoDo you understand what would happen to the system if politicians could be prosecuted for proposing laws?
- FpUser 2y agoWell, proposed laws would need to pass constitutionality test done by some constitutional court stuffed by legal field experts. If passed, no prosecution can occur. I could be prosecuted for driving if the result is death of pedestrian for example. I still drive. So why our fucking "servants" are special?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> proposed laws would need to pass constitutionality test done by some constitutional court stuffed by legal field experts. If passed, no prosecution can occur Congratulations, you re-invented the politburo.
- moralestapia 2y agoThe evergreen "think of the children" excuse to make you forego of your privacy rights.
- logicchains 2y agoEuropean elites seem willing to sacrifice all their liberal values just to crack down on people who oppose unlimited unskilled immigration.
- LudwigNagasena 2y agoThose people would ban printing press and jail Gutenberg to protect the children.
- josefx 2y agoThey would not ban it, they would insist that only they have the moral high ground to use it. Whenever laws like these come up they write explicit exemptions for themselves into them. They don't see themselves as merely human, they consider themselves as our betters. The closest thing to a ruling class with divine mandate we have today. That von der Leyen got her position in spite of election results is only the icing on the cake.
- a_imho 2y agoDon't think they need to legalese around exemptions, they can just do as they wish - as the Pfizer-gate shows they are not wrong so far.
- maxwell 2y agoNo, the center of European power needed printing presses for their own propaganda. Instead the center of European power banned heretical works with the Index Librorum Prohibitorum and executed heretics like Giordano Bruno, Jan Hus, Michael Servetus, Aonio Paleario, and Lucilio Vanini. Even if they were already dead, like John Wycliffe.
- isodev 2y agoIsn't this a duplicate of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40715449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40715449?
- croes 2y agoSame issue, other source. The more the better.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- atlasy1 2y ago[flagged]
- WithinReason 2y agoThen why do they need this legislation?
- atlasy1 2y agoSo that they can stop the pretending and start prosecuting
- kalrGa 2y agoPerhaps they do not. Perhaps this was proposed with the goal that it will be rejected, so Germany and others can say: "Look how much we care about your privacy!" And then they scan in a clandestine manner. I do not trust any of these privacy apps, especially if certain people always try to discredit PGP. Or it was proposed because some MP needed something on his resume. Or they want to tie up the resources of freedom advocates so that they do not work on even bigger issues.
- uyzstvqs 2y agoIt's interesting how this isn't a left-right issue. Both the more populist left and the more populist right oppose this, it originates from our elderly-home technocrats whom are clinging to power, like von der Leyen.
- sReinwald 2y agoIMO, saying it originates from elderly-home technocrats really downplays the role of lobbyists who want to peddle their surveillance tech. In this case, Ashton Kutcher. https://netzpolitik.org/2022/dude-wheres-my-privacy-how-a-hollywood-star-lobbies-the-eu-for-more-surveillance/ https://netzpolitik.org/2022/dude-wheres-my-privacy-how-a-ho...
- jojobas 2y agoAnd, you know, the whole "intelligence community" folks.
- bilbo0s 2y agoExcept the intel community doesn't need a law. Nice to have maybe. But if you think those are people who let little things like laws stop them from doing what they believe they need to do, you're being a bit naive.
- jojobas 2y agoOne thing is to do little things and hide, another is to have the backdoors to everyone handed to you for your dragnet needs.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bratwurst3000 2y agohttps://netzpolitik.org/2022/dude-wheres-my-privacy-how-a-hollywood-star-lobbies-the-eu-for-more-surveillance/#netzpolitik-pw https://netzpolitik.org/2022/dude-wheres-my-privacy-how-a-ho...
- StrLght 2y ago(2022) More context: this was written back before the first iteration of chat control got turned down by European Parliament, and even links to that revision. A few details has changed since then -- still it's basically the same thing, although now you need to opt in, otherwise you won't be able to send images and videos. Allegedly, it could be passed by European Council tomorrow.
- agilob 2y agoAnother change is that some groups will be exempt from invigilation.
- mzajc 2y agoIt's a little ironic how the same legislative body that came up with GDPR is now implementing coerced consent. I believe they would also bar you from sending links, so no easy bypass with an image server.
- StrLght 2y agoIt's the same body indeed (European Commission) but all (or almost all) commissioners are new -- appointed in 2019, so they weren't behind GDPR.
- Bluestein 2y agoValid point. Let us not forget that it is an executive unelected body, but its policies and/or bent might (will) change as incumbents get replaced ...
- krick 2y agoFor me the "unelected" part is the key point here. I mean, if we ignore (totally valid) nihilistic views on the nature of governmental bodies, we are supposed to think that this is the point of modern civilized society (as opposed to "totalitarian states" like NK) where we rule over ourselves. We are even accustomed to call it "democracy" even though this is pretty laughable perversion of the word. But whatever, there is valid reasoning why "representative democracy" is the only solution, and there is valid reasoning why we need experts in the government, so long story short unelected institutions are ok and we are supposed to pretend that each of us kinda proxy-elected them. (I mean, I'm really going to pretend it is ok: after all, I don't consider USA presidential election to be any more real than "proxy-elections" of appointed secretaries/ministers, and in Russia, where people actually vote for a president and he has a lot of power so it actually matters who is the president, people will claim for various valid reasons that this isn't really a democracy and Putin is more like a king now.) But being as charitable to that world-view as I can be, EU structure feels way beyond that. Recently I tired to answer myself, how it came to be that I somehow "elected" Ursula von der Leyen? Or rather, how did "we" do it (keeping in mind that "we" as in "majority of voters" usually have different opinion than I do)? I just don't feel any connection. EC President is nominated by Counsel from the set of whoever-they-want (chosen behind the closed doors), and then voted-in by the parliament. AFAIK, the parliament never actually rejected a nominee, and BTW in Ursula's case 327/710 people voted against her, so she barely passed the bar. It somehow coincided that at the time my country's representative on the Counsel was "not really elected" as well, and by the end of my "investigation" I felt totally alienated. There is this European Commission thing, it affects me, I don't affect it. This is just how the world works.
- mihaaly 2y agoIt would be more fair incarcerating each adult male citizen for 5-7 days, all female citizen for 0.5-1 days of high security prison in the name of child abuse mitigation. Reasoning: they all have the opportunity to do such.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoThis is a weird take.
- rekoil 2y agoSo is mass surveillance as a solution for stopping CSAM.
- xanderlewis 2y agoIs that even the correct ratio? <= 14 males per female? Surely it’s even more skewed than that.
- MacsHeadroom 2y agoIt is substantially less skewed than that.
- INTPenis 2y agoAssuming it passes, what are some good alternative ways to communicate securely? I was thinking a webapp of an open source app such as Element (matrix) is a good candidate. Also converse.js, and Movim (xmpp). Me being Swedish I totally expect to have one Android phone for my eID app, and one with an open source OS for everything else. It was good while it lasted, making orders on my phone from anywhere in the world. But now I'll have to go home to get my eID device, which is fine.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 2y agoSince for now this is supposed to force the messenger developers a way to circumvent would be to directly download and install APKs of messengers that refuse to implement this and/or left the EU market. This is obviously merely a short term solution since it should be clear that targeting hosts and developers of non complying solutions would likely be the next step.
- idle_zealot 2y agoTechnical countermeasures have been doing a pretty good job at combating insane copyright rules for a while now. It's often said that technical solutions don't solve political problems, but I think it's important to retain our freedom to run whatever code we like on our computers because that does seem effective at enabling freedom of communication regardless of laws made to quash it.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 2y agoI don't know, mobile phones and messengers in particular are a very small target compared to general personal computing. There are very few relevant messengers and adoption rate is king, because at the end of the day we want to use these messenger to communicate with people. Getting people to try out new/different messengers is already a pain. And here every blow against an uncompromised messenger to make them harder to get will lower its usercount and push more people towards the compromised software they can easily get on the store. Sure I'd say some way of circumventing this will probably remain available for a while, but I'd say it is extremely easy to make this very inconvenient. After all this isn't about having some way to communicate safely, this is about being able to communicate safely in our daily lives is what I'd say.
- notresidenter 2y agoIt's a really nasty feeling to live in a society influenced by politicians in power with ideas so far away from my own, while also having little influence over their decisions, unless I give up what I like doing and go into lobbying (or politics, which seems to me like the poor man's lobbying) I've sent an e-mail to the permanent representative in the country I live in, but I feel particularly blindsided knowing about such a decision on the same day it is voted. And angry for all the people, especially journalist friends, that are out there and unaware of what's going on. I'm not sure this is what democracy is supposed to feel like, but if it is, it feels like shit.
- _def 2y agoOrganize. There are lots of digital right groups in many forms and shapes.
- Bluestein 2y agoAnd if you can't find a group to your liking, create one.- At any rate, move. Act.-
- mihaaly 2y agoIt is easy to tune in to their frequency: just be an increadibly lazy pretentious figure with no talent to do real job that produces value that people are willing to pay for. From that perspective writing a short legal paper quickly that facks up the life of everyone is much more logical than catching criminals. The latter one needs some work, also some brain to do.
- christophilus 2y agoIt’s one of the reasons I’m against the continued growth of centralized power structures. Local governments aren’t perfect and tend to be more easily dominated by a little tyrant, but in general, the more decentralized the power structures are, the easier it is for people to change their situation. Your vote has a bigger impact, it’s easier to hold local officials accountable, and of course, you can move to a different town / county / province more easily than moving to a different country / continent. Warren Buffett said something to the effect of: “I prefer to invest in a business that could be run by a monkey, because eventually it will be.” A similar principle holds for governments. You will eventually (possibly consistently) have a government that is led by incompetent (or corrupt) politicians. How can you structure your system in such a way that their negative effects are minimal?
- Gloomily3819 2y agoBrexit looking good right now.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 2y agoBritain is already terrible when it comes to matters of privacy and/or encryption
- DrScientist 2y agoYep - or world leading depending on which side of the fence you sit :-) This is from 1981..... https://www.duncancampbell.org/content/big-brother-listening-phonetappers-security-state https://www.duncancampbell.org/content/big-brother-listening...
- mihaaly 2y agoThey are just lazy and occupied with other means of pretend right now, that's the only reason they did not pull a more drastic version of this just yet. It will come eventually.
- xandrius 2y agoYou must not have a great eyesight then.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoOne reason behind Brexit was that there were EU privacy laws in place that prevented UK citizens' data to be sold or exported to US based companies, like NHS data [0] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2019/dec/08/nhs-gives-amazon-free-use-of-health-data-under-alexa-advice-deal https://www.theguardian.com/society/2019/dec/08/nhs-gives-am... or https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/uk-us-data-bridge-supporting-documents/uk-us-data-bridge-factsheet-for-uk-organisations https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/uk-us-data-bridge.... Also with protecting the internal market; the UK is interested in importing US produce like chlorinated eggs and chickens, but EU laws said nu uh: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/25/business/chlorinated-chicken-uk.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/25/business/chlorinated-chic...
- amelius 2y agoCan we please also ban smartphones in parliament?
- zecg 2y agoThese fuckers are about to go to war with all the hackers in the EU
- thefz 2y agoImagine this is implemented and goes live, all we need for a rollback s a couple of leaks of very influential people's chats.
- qwertox 2y agoI'm really convinced that this should be done in a two-phase rollout. In the first phase, every civil servant must use (be affected by) the system, as well as politicians (including their families). Basically everyone who gets a salary or pension paid by normal citizens. Also, every piece of software used by the government, or providers, which is related to this policy, must be open sourced, and attempts at finding security related issues or bugs in general by anyone must not be considered an illegal activity, but considered a helpful activity. If they are ok with this for five years, and no unfixable problems or possibilities of misuse are found, then it can be applied to the rest of the population. After all, one must assume that child predators are also among civil servants and politicians. It would enable the measurement of the success of this policy.
- kvgr 2y agoOf course politicians will have exceptions and government made secure phones.
- pelasaco 2y agoLike guns for civilians. Nobody should have one, except the Politician body guard.. I am not advocating for guns in Europe! it is just an example. We can use the example with private health insurance, private schools and so on.. it is more like to exemplify the "Do what I say, don't do what I do" kind of politics
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoExcept that civilians CAN have guns, they just need - just like police and military - a background check, training, certifications and permits. Police and military can't take their guns home, anyway. On paper.
- marvin 2y agoIn most European countries, you are only ever allowed to be in possession of a gun in public if you are travelling to or from the shooting range.
- elzbardico 2y agoThe funny thing about the EU is that while they do all this theatre of parliamentary elections, the bulk of such decisions are always taken by an unelected organ, the EU commission. It is not that I think they have mischievous intentions, on the contrary, but any unchecked managerial bureaucracy always go to the path of endless regulation and control.
- baryphonic 2y agoI find this bizarre as well. The EU Parliament has no initiative, possessing only the power to approve or veto legislation proposed by the Commission. And then when they occasionally exercise their veto power, the Commission can just resubmit substantially the same legislation as before, as is happening here. This also means the Parliament has no independent power to repeal previous law that it might have regretted passing. It must again wait for the Commission to propose repeal. I can count how many times an unelected administrative bureaucracy has proposed removing its own power on zero hands. The whole thing strikes me as a sham democracy.
- Bluestein 2y agoIt is (a sham).- Then again, I am, personally, split: The standards, and process, to become a part of this technocratic body that is the EU are very high, and they will (ostensibly) select amongst the best candidates ... ... might this "technocracy" be an option in today's age of political mediocrity and populism?
- andrepd 2y ago>The standards, and process, to become a part of this technocratic body that is the EU are very high [citation needed] :) As far as I see it's just opaque dealings between the individual member-states' governments.
- ivan_gammel 2y agoPan-European party Volt is going to change that. They are slowly gaining popularity and on recent elections to EUP performed better in Germany than some mainstream parties (3% nation-wide, but much better in politically affluent Berlin). I‘m sure they will become mainstream in the next 2-3 election cycles.
- varispeed 2y agoThe direction of travel was known for years, but people were called tin foil hatters. The divine EU would have never even tried to do something like this. And if they do? Well, they are doing to for greater good and you probably have something to hide if you don't like it. EU is the best thing since sliced bread you far right flag shagging fascist!
- zmmmmm 2y agoIt's fascinating that this is what they are claiming the legal basis is: > The legal basis to support action in this area is Article 114 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU). The article provides for the establishment of measures to ensure the functioning of the Internal Market. In other words: in order to trade efficiently in goods and services with each other countries need harmonised regulations. Countries have started to introduce individual laws to combat CSAM. Therefore these inconsistent laws interfere with operation the "internal market". Hence the EU can shut down private speech. So somehow they twisted streamlining of commerce into termination of individual rights. It's wild to think how far that can be extended, if it can be the basis for this. It also seems particularly ugly if you actually do frame it within the context that they are claiming: this is not "think of the children". It's actually "think of the commercial profit" - they literally say it themselves.
- kloop 2y agoYeah, authoritarians love provisions like that. They abused a similar one in the US constitution (the commerce clause) to rule that growing wheat on your own land for personal consumption counted as "interstate commerce" (Wickard v Filburn) and backdoored into the federal government controling basically everything physical.
- cheeseomlit 2y agoYup, very easy to twist 'interstate commerce' clauses into anything you want and the US has a long history of it. The entire war on drugs on the federal level was justified by the 'interstate commerce' clause in the constitution as well, much easier than amending the constitution like they did with alcohol
- banku_brougham 2y agoWell, obviously everyone is against child abuse. If you are not for this kind of governmental regulation of all communications you are FOR CHILD ABUSE. And that makes your opinion irrelevant. /s The power of government + media, both nearly captured by unaccountable interests, has me worried. Does everyone remember the 'soft rollout' of Total Information Awareness back in 2002? There was even a logo for the proposed new government program (US). They have not given up on this for a single minute.
- paulcole 2y agoLive by the nanny state, die by the nanny state.
- pastyboy 2y agoThat will be the end of whatsapp then and any other mainstream secure messaging platforms. Probably will do eff all for the real bad actors, paedos and deviants.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoI don't think it will be the end because the vast majority of users will be completely unaware and/or indifferent to this - just what the parties behind it want them to be. But you're right about the real bad actors, they already don't trust these platforms anyway. That said, "grooming" in the broadest sense of the word happens on channels like Whatsapp, Instagram, even Pinterest for some reason because it's not blocked as social media by popular wifi filters. Ex: girl (14) our son was friends with "had sex" with someone who claimed to be 18, but he recorded the interaction and used it to blackmail her to do more / other stuff. I don't know the details but that kinda thing happened via Whatsapp.
- lynx23 2y agoThis is reason enough for me to support leaving the EU. I always suspected it to become something else. And since VDL it has become rather clear that staying will make things worse.
- pastyboy 2y agoThe Irony is in the UK we are about to get a socialist state, not renowned for their libertarian acceptance of other points of view. I am sure the new Labour government will make sure we have the same system in the UK in the name of co-operation.
- Robin_Message 2y agoIf you think Kier Starmer's Labour party is socialist, you need better sources. His platform is notably unambitious and centrist, more so than New Labour, who managed to be in power for thirteen years without introducing gulags.
- lynx23 2y agoSorry, but Brexit so soooo long ago, I really dont care anymore about the british whining. They kept the EU hostage for far too long during negotiations, I am glad its over, and I really really dont care anymore. Move on, its over.
- jeremiahlee 2y agoSweden's parliament just voted to support chat control in the Council of Ministers at EU level. https://alpaca.gold/@Jeremiah/112637416326793501 https://alpaca.gold/@Jeremiah/112637416326793501
- raverbashing 2y agoAs per the comments there, this still has to go through Parlament and the ECJ is the 'last stop' on this
- Macha 2y agoMy understanding is the ECJ can overturn legislation that has been passed and appealed, but it can't pre-emptively block legislation?
- raverbashing 2y agoThat's a good question, I'd say you are right but I'm not sure of all the details (but then again, between passing and actual implementation there's a much to unfold)
- sethammons 2y agoI'm surprised the law doesn't require operating systems to duplicate all network calls over to a govt sink.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoIsn't there a law - or intelligence agency mandate - that does that already? See Snowden, FISA court requests, etc from 10+ years ago. I ask "does that already?", but the way these things work is that they are not allowed to publicly say whether they channel messages to intelligence agencies. If you're doing things that intelligence agencies may find interesting, you already wouldn't be using these services.
- chaostheory 2y agoThis is more proof that the GDPR was nothing more than a part of the EU’s trade war on its best ally for defense.
- detourdog 2y agoRespecting the Fundamental rights of the individual in the digital realm is really the only thing that needs regulation on the internet. All the various AI, targeted ads,... regulation could be solved with that simple focus. I see arguing about chat control or AI as downstream of the central issue. If real privacy was the norm with minimal data collection the other issues take care of themselves. I believe the issue is linking the digital world to an individual without their knowledge.
- osigurdson 2y agoI'd love to see Europe again becoming a beautifully decentralized region - with many shared values but no shared politicians.
- Ragnarork 2y agoCan you give more details as to when, and how, it was a "beautifully decentralized region"?
- eimrine 2y agoIn my opinion it was so before the American smartphones took the prevalent market share.
- Freak_NL 2y agoAbsolutely. Brexit proofed that this is a really great idea. Who doesn't want to start paying through the nose for roaming again? The idea that just abandoning a thing with some issues is better than trying to repair it (or even just keep it as is), does not seem quite realistic today. Even the various national politicians who wanted to do a *xit before the UK did this have quietly dropped those ambitions. Dumb laws exist globally. Don't expect this to go away if tomorrow it was all up to the national governments again. Collectively getting bad laws like these repealed or changed is much more likely though.
- EasyMark 2y agoThey really should just be an economic block and only have laws to ensure fair business and tax structures across the continent and drop these totalitarian schemes pushed on the people to take away their rights. Hopefully they will wise up after a few of these violations of their basic human rights.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sim7c00 2y agoThe way to win a war, is to demotivate and demoralize a population, not win a battle or destroy an army, but to make it so that the army never mobilizes. Look how demotivated and demoralized everyone in the EU is becoming. I really wonder why that is.....
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hnpolicestate 2y agoThere isn't one EU country willing to say no to complying with this legislation?
- thefz 2y agoItaly wants to stop people streaming soccer illegally and the lawmakers can't even understand what a VPN is, I am confident we can be sure nothing fully working will ever be implemented thanks to the sheer incompetence of our politicians. Seriously this law cannot be enforced.