27 ms·
Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity
- molsongolden 2y agoI’d also push for allowing early exercise along with secondary sales restricted only by a short right-of-first-refusal period.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> allowing early exercise along with secondary sales restricted only by a short right-of-first-refusal period Do you mean cashless exercise?
- tdiggity 2y agoI think he means 83b early exercise: https://www.esofund.com/blog/early-exercise-options-83b-election https://www.esofund.com/blog/early-exercise-options-83b-elec... Extremely beneficial when paired with QSBS and liquidity.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoDoes anyone restrict 83b elections? Is that even allowed?
- dilyevsky 2y agoIve seen it restricted so yes
- jjav 2y agoI think there's a confusion between the related events. Filing the 83(b) form with the IRS is between you and the IRS. Company isn't involved so not something they can restrict. However, filing that 83(b) only makes any sense if you are allowed to early exercise and that is indeed entirely up to the company. So if they don't let you early exercise you also won't be filing the 83(b). Pro tip: Never join a startup that does not let you early exercise!!
- dilyevsky 2y agoYes i assumed parent was referring to early exercise but maybe i misread. Imo early exercise doesn’t make a ton of sense when the company no longer qualifies for qsbs especially if long exercise window is offered so probably why it’s not offered - to avoid a ton of drama later on
- jjav 2y ago> Imo early exercise doesn’t make a ton of sense when the company no longer qualifies for qsbs I strongly disagree, early exercise is always optimal if the cost makes sense to you. The primary reason it is so valuable is so that you don't lose everything if you have to change jobs for whatever reason before a liquidity event. If you join a startup and don't early exercise, now you are going to have to work there for however long it takes for liquidity, which could be many many years. Maybe your life changes and you have to change jobs, but you're trapped, or lose everything you worked for. Always early exercise! If the startup doesn't allow it, find a different startup. Edit: I should add that by not early exercising you can still lose a lot even if there is a liquidity event while you're still there! I lost a staggering amount of money on my first startup due to not early exercising even though it went through an IPO while I was there. But later I left (lured to another startup) so I had to excercise (same day sell) all the option in the typical 90 day window after quitting. Had I early exercised years before when I joined, I could've held those shares for 15x returns.
- dilyevsky 2y agoSee my point about long exercise window - 5-10y is not uncommon now. I’d rather have that even though it converts to PSOs than gamble ~50k + amt on early exercise. Unless you’re super early ofc which changes the math
- jjav 2y ago> 5-10y is not uncommon now Is it? I'd be curious on survey data on that if something is available. Personally I've never encountered a startup that had anything other than the standard 90 day after you quit exercise window. I know these long exercise windows exist but as far as I knew they are pretty rare. > gamble ~50k That's a huge number though, I'd never gamble that much either. I'm talking about very early in the startup. If the strike price is above a few pennies, it's too late (although of course depends on the number of options and your personal budget).
- stanleydrew 2y agoWhat would this even look like? An 83b election is something I file with the IRS. Are you suggesting a company might have me sign a contract committing me to not file an 83b election? How would they ever find out if I did file, and why would they care?
- tdiggity 2y agoIt's been a possibility in my options contracts. However, the company must agree to it, cash your exercise check, and send the necessary paperwork to the IRS. If they choose not to cooperate, you're out of luck.
- jahewson 2y agoMy understanding is that 83b applies to stock, not options, so you have to first exercise the options and hold unvested stock. That requires early exercise.
- molsongolden 2y agoNot a restriction of the 83b election but a restriction of when you can exercise. Without early exercise you are stuck exercising as you vest so there’s more likely to be a taxable spread between your option strike price and the value of the stock. With early exercise you are exercising and making the 83b election when there’s no taxable spread.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- molsongolden 2y agoSorry, separate concepts executed at separate times. Early exercise (yep, 83b in the US) when options are issued then allowing employees to sell shares down the road, outside of fundraising events (Forge, EquityZen, sales to angel SPVs, etc.).
- stanleydrew 2y agoNo, although it could also be cashless. Early exercise is purchasing shares before your options vest, making you a shareholder sooner and solving a bunch of tax issues. The company retains the right (basically the obligation) to repurchase any unvested shares should you leave the company before fully vesting.
- stefantheard 2y agoWe allow early-exercise too but I (possibly, incorrectly) assumed that this was the standard for newly incorporated startups - at least within the last 2-3 years it has become significantly more common. "secondary sales restricted only by a short right-of-first-refusal period" I really like this as well, I've always found it confusing when private companies are anti-secondary for former employees especially. I'll look into adding something like this to our stock plan, ROFR protects against any hostile take over weirdness and I'm confident we could add something like this to make it relatively easy to sell on secondary under a certain % threshold.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoHmm, I’ll be controversial. Twinned secondaries, i.e. secondaries tied to a primary, are almost always a give away to senior management and the buyer. (They’re frequently syndicated at double-digit spreads.) If the company sucks, senior management gets cash back first while the investor gets top-of-stack liquidation preferences. If the company is doing great, the investor gets to buy stock at a price almost always lower than market. They’re common in Silicon Valley, because they’re good for founders and the Board members. But they’re rare in public markets. The closest thing I can come up with is the current clusterfuck with Shari Redstone.
- s17n 2y ago> They’re frequently syndicated at double-digit spreads What does this mean?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> What does this mean? Fund buys stock at X and simultaneously solicits LPs at 1.2X (whether by straight mark-up or, more commonly, by adding management fees, research fees, expense reserves and carry.) It’s why tenders have a few weeks between end of sellers submitting requests, confirmation of quantities and finally funding.
- s17n 2y agoInteresting, thanks! Not to get too far off on this tangent, but how is that different from the way VCs / investment funds work in general (taking fees from the LPs in exchange for their services)?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> how is that different from the way VCs / investment funds work in general (taking fees from the LPs in exchange for their services)? VCs usually raise a fund, i.e. a basket of commitments from LPs, before finding the investments. That means they negotiate the investment terms from a position of strength, commitments in hand. With tenders, the investor starts by commiting to the issuer and then finds LPs. To the degree they have leverage, it's in their access to the issuer. For the former, the fees are in exchange for risk. For the latter, they're for access.
- NullHypothesist 2y agoHaving only worked for larger companies (RSU stage), I'm curious what the typical breakdown of founder to early employee to investor to later employee equity looks like. I'm sure it differs pretty wildly, but I'd love to know what a 'typical' case for mid-to-late-stage start up looks like.
- parentheses 2y agoI can share some details. Employee 1: ~1% Employee 10: ~0.1% Employee 1000: 0.01% I'm extrapolating from past experiences in SaaS companies where I was employee number X and X has varied fairly widely.
- o11c 2y agoIf my math is correct, this fails catastrophically for companies with more than 15 tredecillion employees.
- atomicnumber3 2y agoThis always seems like a huge scam to me. Employee 1 gets 1%? It seems unfair from multiple perspectives. One is just a straight up naive sense of fairness. If I'm going to be in the trenches with you, I had better be able to see my ownership % in a pie chart with my glasses off. If we're out here both making chairs and when we sell a chair for $100, you get $85 (assuming someone took one of the standard-ish seed rounds that are usually 10-20%?) and I get $1? No thanks. The other sense is aware that the founder is taking various risks and blah blah blah. Ok whatever. Let's pretend somehow 1% is a fair number and just look at it from a payoff perspective. 1% of stripe? Yeah I'll take that. 1% of the other 1000 startups who had mediocre exits or just muddle along to finally do some kind of tender? I'm barely breaking even. 1% of the other 10000 startups that just folded? At least I can mop the sweat off my brow with the paper I signed. It seems like the only reasonable way to look at this is you either join a company for a competitive wage and get WLB, or you join a rocket ship in the hopes of becoming genuinely wealthy while pouring your blood, sweat and tears into it. So taking 1% and a shitty salary and having terrible WLB sounds like a huge suckers game.
- ajhit406 2y agoLove the movement and glad there are founders out there pushing the envelope for their team. (aside: 51 points but only 1 comment? It's a front-page worthy article, but sort of feels like there's some vote gaming happening. I've never seen 50 points w/ 1 comment.)
- dang 2y agoThat's actually a lot more common than people assume it is, and comments like "I can't believe there are X points but only Y comments" are more common than you'd think they'd be as well! My theory is that it's a sign of a good article, because more energy is going into reading it than into posting quick comments (which are usually less valuable comments). But I don't have the data. Edit: well... we have the data (to test this), but it would be enough of a pain to do the analysis that other things will probably take precedence forever.
- wiradikusuma 2y agoI'm one of those people who upvoted without commenting. I think it's just a way of saying, "I found this article interesting / I agree with the content, but I don't have anything of value to add". But hey I just commented :)
- kortilla 2y agoIt’s a vote bait title. (Type of thing people upvote without reading the article)
- bigiain 2y agoI wonder if that's something the algorithm can detect? Measure the time between when someone clicks a link to the article and when they upvote it, compare that to one of the "estimated reading time" metrics of the linked page... (Which, of course won't work, because at least some people (ie me) open a bunch of tabs for everything that looks interesting on the homepage, then spend a few minutes at a time over the entire morning choosing a tab and reading/voting...)
- stefantheard 2y ago
- josh2600 2y agoThe best startups have a concept which is summed up thusly: “We all go to the pay window at the same time.” It’s ok for founders to take a little bit of money off of the table if they extend that to their employees as well. Asymmetry is where things get weird. I’ve seen many founders who got deep into the fundraising cycles without ever realizing they could take a cent out. VCs will constantly tell you to let it all ride, and sometimes that works out, but for most people, having a little bit of financial security while you’re trying to change the world is necessary. The best startups figure out how to manage liquidity through financing in a way that aligns incentives, keeps the goalposts at the mission, while allowing their teams to thrive. It’s about alignment. If everyone is pulling in the same direction you’re going to execute the vision. Whether you win in the startup lottery is up to the threads of fate, but alignment is the straightest path towards a result.
- kneath 2y agoI have seen a lot of companies, a lot of rounds. I have known zero founders who have turned down an option to take money off the table (and zero A raises that offered that to employees). I love the idea of your universe, though.
- sashank_1509 2y agoThe very first startup I joined after grad school allowed all employees to cash out significant chunks of their stock in the Series A round. Also Elon famously put 200 million of his own money into Tesla and SpaceX to keep it afloat, which is the opposite of cashing out early.
- rytill 2y agoOnly a small percentage of tech companies raise a series A or beyond. To me, this just seems like a capital-efficient alternative to the founder increasing their salary that could be negotiated. I had no such perception that this was some “secret” thing, I assumed it happened since you can do whatever you want if the investors and founders agree that it makes sense.
- adastra22 2y agoThis whole thread is leaving me very confused. Series A is the first priced round. You're saying only a small percentage of tech companies raise a priced round?
- mtremsal 2y agoA significant portion of startups that raise a Seed round (or equivalent) never get to a Series A. Maybe 30 to 50% fail at this stage.
- adastra22 2y agoAre we talking about just YC-style internet/app startups? Two of my startups have been deep tech where you can't do shit without a Series A, and the third was crypto in the start of that boom where VCs were begging to lead your Series A. So maybe I just work in a vastly different field.
- quartesixte 2y agoYeah deep-tech (which I am also in) plays on a different scale when it comes to funding rounds, simply because of how expensive hardware is and how big the headcount gets to just make MVPs. My friends in software startups balk at the sheer burn rate and funding rounds at mine. $100mm for a Series A is unheard of in software. Thank you Thiel for setting the bar so high (the famous, "you need $1billion in total capital to successfully pull off hardware startups" quote).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dmitrygr 2y agoThe title of the article is mostly clickbait. Anyone who's lived in SV for a decade or so knows this well. Startups are a scam unless you are a founder. They are a meat grinder that runs on naive young new college grads who buy into the bullshit that their options are worth anything.
- iwontberude 2y agoEven founders get shafted in later rounds where they are diluted out of their voting rights because they can't raise the capital to maintain their share. The only people not getting scammed regularly are the VC.
- dmitrygr 2y agoFounders have control of how things go, and have many ways to make money along the way (one such way documented by this article). How often do the first 2-5 engineers get any such chances?
- bigiain 2y ago> The only people not getting scammed regularly are the VC. Not to want to sound like I'm standing up for Vulture Capital, but while it's not "getting scammed" as such - I suspect most VCs lose money on most startups they invest in. And not all VCs land enough 100x exits to make up for all those losses. (The "successful" VCs are the ones who make all the losses end up in pension fund balance sheets, while ensuring most of the profits land in their friends and their own pockets.)
- babl-yc 2y agoFounders cashing out early may be more of an "open secret" but it warrants more discussion. I don't find the title overly clickbait-y. And a counterpoint to your perspective, I joined a startup a couple years out of college, had the most fun of my career, and the options were very much worth something. Working for a well-funded start-up is something I'd especially recommend early in your career when you can take more risk even if the equity doesn't always work out. If anything, I'd discourage becoming a founder as a new grad more than SV typically discusses. I really appreciated taking time to build up my savings and get experience before taking a shot at that.
- EternalFury 2y agoYou get Founder Liquidity because you managed to convince people who do just as much work that they couldn’t do just as much work without you. LOL I am so cynical.
- its_ethan 2y agoTo be fair, there is a skill in getting people to believe your vision and to take the risk to work for you. They also need to convince VC's of that vision to get the money to pay you in the first place. Generally they make more decisions that directly effect the odds of the company existing 6 months or a year down the line than the average employee does (with some exceptions obviously). You can still be cynical, I think all employees should be given the ability to get liquidity early, but it's not like it's totally unjustifiable.
- iEchoic 2y agoMaking less money isn't really the risky part about founding a startup. The risky part is missing out on years of other life experiences, stressing (or losing) your closest personal relationships, failing and feeling personally responsible for disappointing everyone you convinced to believe in you, and developing an anxiety disorder (or worse) from chronic long-term stress. Author's suggestion that they could have taken a "similar level of risk" as an early employee by taking secondaries as a founder is way off, IME.
- beambot 2y agoPerfectly illustrated by this statement: > I have been an early or first engineer at five different companies and have had three liquidity events in a 9-year career. A "big" success is a 10+ year journey. For an early employee, it is perfectly acceptable to give a few weeks' notice and move on to the next lotto ticket. This doesn't work for a key founder-exec -- they're likely going to commit to a decade working on one big problem, and investors want to incentivize them to shoot for the moon & stick with it for the long haul. It's definitively not the same for an early employee.
- jmward01 2y agoHaving been employee #10 a couple times now, there is a lot of that even when you aren't a founder. It would be nice if the 'de-risk your life' stuff this article describes for founders was also available for early employees.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoWork a high salary job and buy lottery tickets or 0DTE options instead. Half joking. Look at the success rate of outlier comp through liquidity as an early startup employee. If professional stock pickers can’t pick better than index funds, what makes you think you can do better picking startups, spending non renewable time, working for years vesting common shares that you might get liquidity for eventually, assuming they have any positive value. If you want to get wealthy, there are more efficient, less effort ways. If you want to suffer with low chances of success based on all available data, well, help yourself to the firehose of startup jobs.
- dsign 2y agoWe are talking SV here, and that's very different from my European experience. I've known of founders in Scandinavia who walked out from startups that weren't doing so bad and that could have gone for another round of investment because they were earning as much as a bus driver, had zero savings, and were experiencing burn out after almost a decade of work. Maybe that bit of SV culture that lets founders be on par with a highly paid engineer at a big company is up to something. Maybe if it were more of a thing in other parts of the world, we would be more competitive.
- givemeethekeys 2y agoHaving cofounded both bootstrapped and funded startups, I can say that in each case there was a deadline associated with success: for bootstrapped, we set hard targets in terms of maximum spending and time in order to test our hypothesis. This allowed us to fail fast in our own way and go back to a better paying day job. For funded startups - at least with a healthy seed round, the investors expected us to burn fast and hard in order to prove our hypothesis or fail trying as quickly as possible, but they also expected us to not pay ourselves very much. As we found product-market fit and raised Series rounds, it was understood that we would pay ourselves competitive salaries. Being stuck at the seed stage for 10 years is not healthy - neither in Europe, nor in Silicon Valley.
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoYes and that is why we call them Europoor out here.
- keeptrying 2y agoFounder liquidity doesn’t make up for much in the average situation. Making $400k after making $100k for 4 years doesn’t really change much. It gets you upto junior engineer level. The underestimated play is becoming a cofounder to a great CEO 2nd time founder.
- parentheses 2y agoThis assumes how much of the founders' shares they sell and the size of the raise. The $400k figure is just arbitrary here. I imagine when companies are raising Series B or later, founders are walking away with millions.
- keeptrying 2y ago$1-$2M after 6 years of working at $100k isn’t really much either in the Bay. (Which is the only place you’d get that.) Even that averages to a senior Eng salary for the very very few founders who get there. This has to be tempered by other realities - no social life - working 80 hours a week easily - risking personal finances - health problems - good chance of divorce / no deep relationships Starting a company is no joke. Very few get to series B/C.
- newshackr 2y agoThat may be true, but it is also true of early employees who stick it out for similar amounts of time and get nothing. $1-2 million may be the total amount they would get after a billion dollar exit.
- Sytten 2y agoGetting out of the SV bubble this is an insane amount of money. I boostrap my business and I make 40k a year. Most senior SWE around here make less than 100k.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoObviously everything is local. 40k is about $20/hr, which where I live is just a tad above what new fast food workers make. Fresh CS grads make more than $100k (or at least they did, obviously the past year and a half has been brutal). This is not in SV.
- mapasj 2y agoHow common is this? How many founders that raise series A are liquidating? What are the amounts typically?
- parentheses 2y agoIt's fairly arbitrary, but there is at least one constraint on how much you can liquidate: You cannot liquidate much more than 10%, because you're taking money from the company and investors would not appreciate that.
- blobbers 2y agoI think founders generally have 20 to 50x what the first employee has, in my experience. Employees rarely have more than 1%. Founders tend to start out with about 20-40% depending on number of cofounders.
- khazhoux 2y agoYeah that line in the article is completely off: > Ask most venture-backed founders why they get 10x more equity than employee #1 Employee #1 typically gets 1%. Sometimes could be up to 2%, but 1% is standard. So then the founder gets 10%? No way. I posit that very, very few early non-founding employees in SV startups have a true notion of how cheap they're working compared to the founders. Founders do founder-y stuff, the early engineers build and launch the full product, and if all goes well, the founders fly private the rest of their lives while early engineers make good progress towards a down payment.
- pojzon 2y agoAnd what happens in case it does not work out well ?
- temp90210 2y agoEmployee gets fired and founder may get something or nothing but get “fired” last and turn off the lights on the way out I would guess.
- khazhoux 2y agoIf startup goes to zero, then everyone goes home with nothing. The founders typically don't lose any money of their own -- that cost is shouldered by angel and series-A investors. Often though, the startup has a "soft landing" where it's acquihired by a larger company, and then the founders typically get executive or very senior roles (with large bonuses, etc) meanwhile the non-founders get standard employee packages.
- blobbers 2y ago
- s17n 2y agoI think most employees are mostly well aware that founders take a money off the table in every round, and I think that it absolutely does negatively affect morale.
- Joel_Mckay 2y ago"Silicon Valley's [worst] kept secret: [Loyalty will not be rewarded]" The fact remains that sweat-equity deals rarely work out in a founding employees favor. i. IP selloff to umbrella firm for $10 ii. contract restructuring or share dilution iii. jettisoned from a company months before an IPO Most techs have seen all of these events unfold... if you are around long enough. People always have their own strategic truths once significant money is on the table. Even moderate success can destroy peoples memory, and anything not legally watertight is just hot air. Best of luck, =3
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoThis is another reason why American companies beat out Canadian and many other companies by so much. In Canada even at Series A Canadian VCs will not offer you liquidity while at the same time allotting pennies in the first place. Absolutely conservative poor people. If things are working, derisking the founder so that they can focus all in on the problem is the best thing you can do as a VC.
- librish 2y agoMy guess would be that it has to do with the amounts involved. In a typical series A/B only the founders have enough equity (they have larger share, plus they've been at the company the longest so they've vested the most) to be worth the transaction cost of a secondary sale.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago> Why is it a secret that founders get liquidity in many venture rounds? Because it undermines the narrative of the founder who is "all-in." The story of the founder who mortgaged their house and lived on ramen noodles for years is compelling. A lot of startup compensation seems to rely on people not having transparency and honesty. The founders, investors, etc. all have very different risk and reward situations compared to typical employees and even non-founder executives. But for most it seems like a raw deal compared to working at a big tech company, unless you’re lucky and strike gold at a place like OpenAI or whatever. Another area where there is a lot of obscure but important detail is in the cap table, stock plan documents, and so forth. If company financials and cap tables were transparent, and if it was clear the various ways in which a company could screw over employees through various clauses deep in their documents, no one would take those jobs.
- jslakro 2y agoThis is a solid argument to motivate startups to build confidence on employees through any of the captable solutions available out there
- throwaway-blaze 2y agoI must be an idiot, I've been a cofounder or first hire in 6 startups (2 successful) over the last 25 years and have literally never been offered secondary during a Seed or Series A or B.
- askafriend 2y agoHow has your time in startups panned out? Were those 2 successes worth the failures?
- throwaway-blaze 2y ago100%. The one thing you get at a bigco is bigness -- you can release a product to potentially millions of customers on day 1. When you call on a possible customer or partner, they return your call immediately because BigCo is on the line. On the other hand, I can't stand how corporate politics corrupt a product's vision. Even low-level politics like "strategy taxes" are infuriating.
- damezumari 2y agoIt depends a lot on the startup. I have similar number of startup experiences, and only one had early stage secondary sales ( but those were even for non founders ). Mainly money comes from IPO or other exit.
- xyzzy4747 2y agoYou don’t necessarily get offered it, you demand it as a term. If it’s a “hot startup” you pick and choose your investors so if some don’t like it they can walk.
- jkelleyrtp 2y agoSecondaries have become more popular over the past few (5?) years but you need to know to ask.
- Finbarr 2y agoSecondary at Series A is very rare. Part of the reason more early employees don't get included in secondary sales is because of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 14e-2. If you have more than 10 sellers involved, the transaction can be considered a tender offer, which triggers additional regulatory requirements and disclosures. > As of 4 months ago I left a very successful stealth startup (which grew to 40M in ARR in two years) to become a founder and that is when it clicked - I expected to feel stressed, pressured, and the weight of all of the risk I was taking. Please let us all know how that's working out for you in 5-10 years. 4 months in and no stress? Must be easy riding from here!
- Finbarr 2y agoThe bigger secret is that stock sold in secondary sales by founders and employees is usually common stock, and the purchasers will often get the right to convert this to preferred stock. This means that the company is instantly encumbered with a greater liquidation preference, without the increase in balance sheet to offset it.
- laser 2y agoHow is that legal and not considered self-dealing and unjust enrichment? If I was a minority common stock owner in a business I assume I would have standing to sue for damages if a majority owner or officer made my position materially worse while enriching themselves in such a manner? Are you sure such a right is typically granted? I mean even the gap between 409A valuations and preferred valuations, as well as a huge amount of precedent, give a different material value to preferred and common stock. Giving that right out of thin air in a sale by an insider is effectively theft from common holders and I have trouble believing what you’re saying as I’m not sure how that could be kosher, if perhaps infrequently litigated. But is it really standard like you make it sound? That would be a very dirty secret and I expect would and should lead to litigation.
- lancewiggs 2y agoFlip it around - it becomes a condition of the deal happening imposed by investors, who themselves are motivated to present the best deal to founders, and to have founders less economically stressed. No secondaries - no deal, and that doesn’t help anyone.
- albroland 2y agoNice article, but it is wrong about liquidity events at WeWork. The author only discusses a tender offer that fell through at the end of 2019 after the failed IPO and collapse, implying there was nothing ever before. There was a tender offer in 2017 with the first SoftBank investment, and again in early 2019 (pre IPO attempt, closed in April) associated with the second investment by SoftBank. It is possible there were earlier events, but I had joined in 2015. That isn't to say things were roses; I know many early employees who, in the lead up to IPO, exercised their options and took enormous loans to pay AMT and were left in a terrible situation.
- stefantheard 2y agoThank you for letting me know about this - I searched for other tender offers or liquidity for employees of WeWork and couldn't find anything (and the 2 former WeWork employees I know joined in late 2019 / 2020 - so they had a pretty terrible experience) I will re-work that section so that it's factually correct
- albroland 2y agoI poked around google/ddg and didn't see any obvious public discussion of it so I can't blame you for missing it. If you have access (or have friends with access) to PitchBook, their file on WeWork would have comprehensive data about all the liquidity events.
- jmward01 2y agoI was mentally, physically and emotionally worn out when I left my previous startup after being an early employee. Despite that I really wanted to stay and be part of what my friends and I were building. Had I had the chance to 'de-risk my life' with some equity to replenish my empty bank account, which was empty from taking an early employee salary, I may have been able to stay but in the end I had to get out. Getting out for an early employee after funding rounds is expensive because buying options can hit you with massive tax bills on top of the cost of buying the options. Worse, the stats aren't great for a chance on return. Your lotto ticket gets expensive and risky as soon as you decide to leave. Articles like this one hammer home more and more to me how little VCs actually value early employees. Paying out founders to stay is a strategic move. Keeping them is worth it because they are the face of the company and turmoil at that level hurts their payout. Burning out early employees is not a concern because you can just swap them without drama. In fact, with the way options are structured and the 'industry wisdom' to hold off purchasing, it feels like a strategic move to burn out early employees since many employees that are forced out often can't even buy their options. They are left with nothing after all that work and risk. From a purely cynical view this is a great thing for VCs since now the company got all the benefit of an early employee and just lost all the costs. I don't know about the other three points, but I can guarantee you point 1 of 'right sizing perceptions' is wrong.
- FlyingSnake 2y agoI’m really sorry to hear about your burnout, I hope you’ve made a recovery and are at a better place now. I thought it was the prevailing wisdom here on HN that being the first employee almost always is bad for the employee. You’re right, the cards are stacked against them
- jmward01 2y agoMuch better now actually, thank you.
- CalChris 2y agoIf you were early, why didn't you purchase your options and file an 83b?
- tompetry 2y agoThe single data point here is Adam Neuman, so I have a hard time taking this seriously. I have raised 6 equity rounds as a founder of 2 companies. Never took a dime off the table, was never offered it, never asked for it. We actually did have early employees ask about it, and we encouraged them to not sell. Why would you, especially at early stage valuations? You're either bad at math, or you know you're about to fail. And who is buying these secondary shares? I don't know a VC or angel who would "de-risk" an early founder like this; it's not aligned with their model. It also complicates QSBS status if I recall correctly.
- adastra22 2y ago> Never took a dime off the table, was never offered it, never asked for it Well they certainly wouldn't volunteer the offer without you asking for it.
- tompetry 2y ago> The founder in this scenario was offered $400,000 of liquidity at Series A and $750,000 at Series B and encouraged to do so by their board of investors to de-risk their own life. This is from the article. I would tend to agree with you.
- adastra22 2y agoI straight up don't believe the article. (Edit: not saying author is lying, but that they're extrapolating from bad data.) I've worked as employee #3 at one startup, co-founded another which achieved >$3bn valuation, and am now solo-founding a third. I've networked with lots of other founders. I've never, ever heard of a secondary liquidity offer in a Series A. I think the paragraph above that quote explains it. They're talking about founders that "mortgaged their house and lived on ramen noodles for years." It actually sounds like they got screwed out of some equity. Rather than pay themselves a reasonable salary to support their lifestyle as they build the company, they instead traded equity for a one-time payment. That's a shitty deal, and I want to know who this predatory VC is so I make sure I never take money from them.
- varenc 2y agoI always thought there was another reason for VCs encouraging founders to sell shares: giving them a taste of wealth. If you're a founder that sold 2M in stock a year ago and a 200M acquisition offer comes along, you'd be less tempted now that you appreciate the difference between small millions and big millions. If you thought you had a real chance of going much bigger, having cash already makes you more willing to take that risk. And since VCs tend to make most of their money off a couple very big wins, it's worth it to have founders that won't settle for less than billions.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> another reason for VCs encouraging founders to sell shares: giving them a taste of wealth VCs are wealthy. Some of them weren't born wealthy. The best among them recognise that removing the worry about e.g. paying rent will make a better CEO.
- repomies69 2y agoIt is about aligning risk preferences. Being "all-in" is not likely a good thing for a founder. The founder prefers to take less risk which results to mediocre exit for the investor. The investor would rather have bigger exit or nothing, and giving the founder some money is helping to aling the risk preferences a bit towards the same direction. As for employees? They are typically not calling the shots about company direction. I don't see a reason why investors would care about employees.
- mezyt 2y ago> As for employees? They are typically not calling the shots about company direction. They can be motivated or not, knowing that the founder made big bucks and they made nothing is bound to lower motivation. Thus the title of the article, founder's liquidity is a well guarded secret.
- blitzar 2y ago> removing the worry about e.g. paying rent Only once the startup has matured at least a little, too much money too early and your hungry founders become lazy.
- aaronbrethorst 2y agoIf employees realize they are taking more risk than the founders, maybe they'll ask for more compensation, maybe they'll congratulate the founders and move on with their day, maybe they'll start yelling: "I'M TAKING SO MUCH RISK, IT'S SO HARD TO BUILD A COMPANY, I DON'T EVEN HAVE ACCESS TO LIQUIDITY!!!". And maybe they're right. This is why I think the term "Founding Engineer" is often just a fancy way of saying 'sucker.'
- carliton 2y agoMany companies don’t get to Series A and very few companies get to Series B. Even if they do get to Series A or B, they won’t be able to raise the amounts you see in the news and have heavy dilution. Very few founders have double digits percent ownership by Series B and Series C. Liquidity of $400k or more is a lot and isn’t available for many founders. All of this after 7 to 10 years of working 80+ hours week, no social life, loosing family, sacrificing health, taking less than $100k/year salary, constant worry of failure, dealing with ups and downs of employees, being a support system of everyone in the company while not being one for their own families, and no guarantee of success. All of this for seeing their dream come true because failure would be worse. I think the OP should work on his company for more than 4 months and have more than 10 employees for at least a year to truly understand what it is to be a founder. Also 20% option pool and exercising options up to 10 years are not uncommon. Source: 2nd time founder.
- ivalm 2y ago> All of this after 7 to 10 years of working 80+ hours week, no social life, loosing family, sacrificing health, taking less than $100k/year salary If you are taking less than $100k/year salary for 7 to 10 years while also absolutely no-lifing then that’s on you. It’s true that early on you prob take ramen salary, but that’s for one or two years. You can prob scale to 200k by year 3 if your thing is viable. No-lifing when your startup is in year 5 is just a personal choice. If by year 5 you aren’t on a path of unicorn then prob it’s time to evaluate if it’s worth so much sacrifice or if you should run it as a lifestyle business (or just go do something else).
- ZhadruOmjar 2y agoIf the product isn't making enough money to pay people by year 5 you're not a startup founder you're just unemployed with a side project.
- joeblubaugh 2y agoAfter the Series B for my last company the three founders owned something like 45% of the outstanding shares, and when they sold took out something like 40% of the price. What were the rounds like that led to less than 10% after 3ish rounds?
- knappe 2y agoLook, I've worked for 5 companies, 1 of which I knew would never sell and I had inklings that one other probably wasn't going to sell and instead was a lifestyle business for the founders, and the other 3 had successful exits. I won the lottery 3 times but I quit the game because I was tired of making VCs and founders rich while taking home breadcrumbs, comparatively. My first startup I walked with a paltry sum and the owners suddenly went from being doctors with a side hustle to private investors. That was my first warning sign and really drove home the need to invest in myself because it certainly wasn't going to be someone else doing it, despite the talk of changing the world. It was really, really obvious that the payouts were stacked in one direction and it certainly wasn't on the side of employees, early or not. I still enjoy working for small companies, but the hype and bullshit are really tiring and so very cultish. I'd really suggest treating the startup life like a scratch lottery ticket, because that is all it is. If you win, you're gonna get paid but it won't be life altering money, just like a scratch lottery ticket. Plan around it being worth zero and go in eyes wide open.
- throwaway2037 2y ago> Plan around it being worth zero and go in eyes wide open. This is the best advice I have seen on HN about start-ups. Note: I have seen it repeated multiple times.
- _heimdall 2y agoI've joined two startups now as the 2nd and 4th engineer. I went into both expecting nothing from options or shares, and knowingly accepted a lower than market salary because I liked the teams and projects. I couldn't be happier. Neither panned out for me with regards to stocks, and I definitely didn't get rich in the process, but I very much enjoyed the jobs and when I decided to leave it was only because the business direction wasn't a fit for what I wanted to spend my time on. It sure sounds like a privledged position, but it more came down to us living cheaply compared to our income and having the breathing room to trade a higher salary for work that I really enjoyed. I hope more people can make that tradeoff, it's much more fulfilling in my opinion
- 2y ago
- paulddraper 2y agoIDK how secret this is. But the reason for founder equity -- as with anything in a free market system -- has nothing to do with deserve and everything to do with demand/supply. There are many more we early employees willing to take 1% equity than founders willing to offer it.
- golly_ned 2y agoI wish I had known so much more about this before joining a hot AI startup a few years ago. It raised its Series C at $850MM valuation. The business was doing terribly; investment was exclusively speculative with no business success to speak of. The founders made tons of cash. Layoffs ensued. They're still kicking; they've pivoted to Gen AI which has given them new life. I had no idea how terrible the deal was. I regret so much about that time and the opportunity cost of joining that place.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- classified 2y agoI couldn't care less. They can keep their secret and stick it where the sun doesn't shine.
- saulrh 2y agoThe founders I've known were already wealthy when they decided to do a startup. They aren't at risk because even if the startup falls through without making a cent they have enough money in their bank account to withdraw $200k/year for thirty years. There's no risk there.
- bux93 2y agoMost can even file for personal bankruptcy and then lounge around in their parent's home for a bit. (Or a house in the name of their spouse-with-a-prenup.) My parents didn't have a garage for me to found a business in. When people helpfully suggest, why don't you start your own business, they usually have a substantially bigger than average support network and liquidity to begin with. I never get those suggestions from people who've actually experienced hardship due to job loss or financial stress.
- FactKnower69 2y agoWhy, simply pawn some of Father's apartheid emeralds to Tiffany's, why didn't any of you lazy imbeciles ever think of that?
- throrway12 2y agoI worked at a preseed company recently. Here's my experience: - Work 9 to 7 everyday. 6 days a week. - People are working 9 am - 5 am in crunch time. Then joining again at 10 am. - Monetary Comp is exactly market average. - Equity Comp is even more paltry since founders raised at a huge valuation. - Founders make unrealistic promises. Eg: It took a competitor with 7 people, 3 months to make a product. The founder told us Saturday that he wanted it built by Monday (with 3 total devs). - Founders message you 24 x 7. If you don't reply, there's a "serious discussion" to be had next time. - Non Accomodating of anything because "It's a startup". I left the place after 10 weeks. I saw 3 people leaving the 6 person company in these 10 weeks. The ones who stayed were under heavy financial stress or had drank the kool aid.
- throwaway2037 2y agoThis is a great post. No need for the throwaway account! > Founders message you 24 x 7. If you don't reply, there's a "serious discussion" to be had next time. That one is my favourite.
- blitzar 2y ago> Founders message you 24 x 7. If you don't reply, there's a "serious discussion" to be had next time. You drop them a bunch of messages to get signoff for the thing that absolutely had to go live on Thrusday and dont hear from them till Sunday because they are tripping on Ayahuasca in the desert. There's a "serious discussion" to be had next time about your work ethic.
- shoo 2y agoit's important to figure out where to set your own boundaries. people out to exploit you will seek to see how far they can push. congratulations for leaving. one thing that catches out some junior folks is that they may believe this kind of behaviour from bosses is normal and unavoidable as they have only worked for exploitative bosses at places with toxic cultures. you can do better, you're worth it. get out. find a more mature company with professional managers, where it's normal to leave the office on time and turn off all your work comms and leave all work-related messages unanswered until you're back in the office and getting paid to think about work again.
- tianleli 2y ago[flagged]
- surfingdino 2y agoThis and my own experience with employee stock options led me to reject any work for startups that offer stock options. It is a way to make you work hard and allow to be treated like dirt for less money. The lowest point was having to walk across town to the office to eat energy bars from the office kitchenette, because I could not afford a bus fare or food as my pay was delayed by a week over Christmas. Meanwhile, the founder was holidaying in Dubai, driving a BMW X7 to work, and showing off a house with a small park and a pond bought in leafy Berkshire. Employee #1 treated the rest of us like dirt. I got laid off in a round of cuts just before my options kicked in and thought it was unjust, but a year later the company was sold to a competitor and the investors got a nice return, the founder got another pot of gold, and the employees with stock options got nothing, because it was a private sale and not an IPO. Employee # 1 was in a bit of a shock allegedly.
- segfaltnh 2y agoI don't believe a private sale entitles one to ignore a stock options legal rights. What are the relevant details here I'm missing?
- surfingdino 2y agoIt was 10+ years ago. I don't have the details, but the riches they were underpaid for never came true. The founder made out like a bandit.
- throwawaythekey 2y ago1) The common stock that employees get via options is the last in line for the pot of gold. 2) There's plenty of bullshit that can be used to cheat an employee out of their options. One example here [1]. [1] https://techcrunch.com/2011/06/26/skypes-worthless-employee-stock-option-plan-heres-why-they-did-it/ https://techcrunch.com/2011/06/26/skypes-worthless-employee-...
- hmottestad 2y agoMaybe if the founder has a majority they can sell their shares to someone and the company keeps on running. If the new owners don't intend to ever do an IPO I guess the existing employees end up with options to buy stock in a company that they will never be able to sell. Only upside would be if new owners take out a dividend, since that would assumably be a fixed amount per stock regardless of who owns the stock, unless of course the new owners are able to circumvent that by doing an unequal dividend payout that only goes to certain owners.
- benjaminwootton 2y agoI think it’s entirely reasonable for a founder to take money off the table. The founder possibly walks away from a 6-7 figure opportunity cost working for a big corporate or FAANG. In return they take zero salary. All of the money that begins to come in is then used to pay employees. Maybe they raise some funds and pay themselves a below market salary for years. A few years later they are over $1 million in opportunity cost and still owning a lottery ticket. By this time they are a bit older, have a family, want to buy a house etc. They are also massively wedded to the project for as long as it takes, so strapped in for the long haul. The founder should be able de-risk at the next funding round and not continuing to roll it all for the benefit of VCs. The same is probably true of early employees, but a lot of the factors above are dialled down. They didn’t work for zero, salary wasn’t under market by such a degree and they haven’t had such a high opportunity cost.
- xandrius 2y agoIn what world 6-7 figures at FAANG is something a founder is actually "walking away" from? First of all, it assumes everyone wants to work for those companies and assumes all founders could get such high paying jobs with a snap of the finger.
- benjaminwootton 2y agoNot everyone can but most founders I know could be earning a very high salary in industry.
- gafferongames 2y ago^--- This
- wafriedemann 2y agoThe question I am most interested in is: How do people even get funding (or in other words: Who gets funding) I'd assume it's 'references', i.e. which school you went to, which university you went you, who you know/who knows you Where are early employees from? Are they still from the same elite circles?
- Terretta 2y ago> How do people even get funding (or in other words: Who gets funding) Second question first, early employees are from anywhere, just make sure they are hungry to ship. You want devs able to self-organize and self-manage amid ambiguity and pivots, and filled with an urgency to get working software in the hands of users to get feedback to iterate, and you want sales/product able to listen and drive focus on product that users believe could be 10x better than however they meet their need today. Answering your first question, this answer sounds cynical, but this is how the math usually has to work for VC to give outsized returns to pools of investors in VC funds: You need to have a 20% to 5% chance at 2x - 10x annualized growth generating high cash flow and high margins reinvestable in the business with ability to switch modes and cash out or IPO in 5 years to let investors exit by year 7. In other words, don't aim for a solid dependable low risk business plan. Aim for a unicorn business plan. To get funding, your business plan should be so compelling that in a funding round of 10 startups, yours is the one delivering returns that make up for the other 9 blowing up, and still giving the investors in the venture fund returns that are a multiple of the stock market. Remember VC have customers too, their investors. Their investors want a basket of startups that handily beat just parking their money in a market-beating ETF of Apple, Meta, Tesla, Nvidia, Netflix, Alphabet, Microsoft ... In practical terms, your business plan must convincingly show that the startup can grow exponentially (not just "up and to the right" but a curve) and overcome inherent risks (show you're risk aware, and already planning to beat the risks). Investors are looking for ideas that can stand out in a portfolio where the rare successes can de-risk returns that far outweigh the more common failures, for their portfolio to generate overall profitable returns. To get funding, position your startup as a standout gem for a portfolio.
- jensneuse 2y agoAs a founder with multiple years of experience I can say that this post and a lot of other comments are coming from people who don't understand the life of a founder. It's not so much about risk. My peers earn 5-10x my salary. I'm paying my employees more than myself. I have to provide for 3 kids and we have a lot of debt on the house. I'm working day and night, 24/7. I don't like the phrase "taking money off the table". If I can sell some equity, this is none of your business. I started this company with my co-founders. Start your own company and try reaching Series A. It's almost impossible. Most people are not capable of getting there.
- colordrops 2y agoTo be frank that's your call to work 24/7 with 3 kids and not the business of your employees. They are free to negotiate how they please and we are free to take issue with certain founder behaviors. It's all business and it's a free world.
- erremerre 2y agoSo you either you are neglecting your kids, or you are calling work at building legos with your kids?
- defrost 2y agoBe kind. Don't be snarky. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- erremerre 2y agoMy point is that he is not working 24/7 as he says. He just have a business to run, that does not mean they work all the time, as they try the rest to convince us. Neither working all the time should be rewarded with a status in which they can't be critised, but even if such reward shall exist, he aint working that much.
- tock 2y agoAren't most early employees also working very long hours for 1/4th the pay and maybe 1% equity? A lot of them also have kids and debt. The life of a "founder" is not really that different from how most people in the world make ends meet. Heck most small businesses run on loans not VC money and are a ton more stressful.
- benreesman 2y agoSilicon Valley’s best kept secret is how Altman made his first few bucks. Everyone just buys that someone with a failed startup has capital that better founders lacked. Invested in X with what Y bro?
- sneak 2y ago> We allow employees to exercise options up to 10 years after they leave instead of 90 days. This always struck me as completely unethical. Your vested options are part of your pay; you should be able to exercise them years after leaving. I would never work for a startup that evaporates my vested options 90 days after leaving. That’s like clawing back cash comp, in my view.
- stefantheard 2y agoI could not agree more - I still have no idea why 90 days is the standard. It also exploits people who are ignorant about equity compensation more than people who are not - which I think is even worse.
- logicallee 2y agoWouldn't most 9-5 employees stop working if they had a sizable liquidity event?
- stefantheard 2y agoOn pro-rata basis most of these secondary liquidity events as apart of raises are not "retirement" level of liquidity - it's just "safety net" level of liquidity. So I think they would probably not be considered "sizable".
- KaiserPro 2y agoAs an early stage engineer that was bought out by a FAANG, I can assure you that most of the hype surrounding buyouts is mostly an exaggeration. Sure some people get millions, but most people do not, even early stage engineers. Think about it, you as an engineer, have deliberately avoided working at $bigCorp, and are about to be given $5m in shares. Would you continue working at $bigCorp? no, you'd take the money and fuck right off. Ok Ok you say, but look at the headline buyout figures Google buys a company for "450 million" that startup having raised 65m in capital for a valuation of x. so, you as an employee have an option for 0.1%. Awesome, you're gonna get 450k right? No. The 450M is the headline figure, The PR figure. Its not actually how much the company is bought for (well it rarely is) Google will pay off the 65M from investors, plus some amount, maybe give some shares. This will value the company at say 85-100M in terms of cash paid for actual shares. oh sweet, so you'll get 0.1% of 100M right? well not always. There is debt seniority and weird structures that mean that certain investors are paid more per share than others. So it might mean that the pool of employee money would be 10M or 1M. or even none. The structure is normally bespoke and deliberately opaque. Ok, so fuck, not that much money. If you are lucky, you'll get a job offer from google. This is where the head line figure comes in. Say Google pays 100M for the actual company, in actual cash, the rest of that headline figure comes from share offerings. That is, if you join google, you'll get the standard level of pay, plus the normal share offer. However you'll then get an additional share offer from the headline figure. This could be double, or many multiples of the normal share offering. TL;DR: The headline buyout figure for startups is mostly fiction. You'll only get lots of money, if you are part of the 0.01% that IPO and stay long enough to get the full offering, even then thats not a given. The second best outcome is getting bought out and serving your golden handcuff period.
- moss2 2y agoIt is too bad it is up to the founders themselves to offer liquidity to employees. Founders are financially incentivized to not offer anything, so you're counting on their sense of justice and morals to overcome their sense of personal gain. This should be regulated. (Yes, this is a political opinion. No, I am not American.)
- bux93 2y agoI thought "founder liquidity" would refer to the supply and fungibility of founders. I've heard that, although ZIRP is over, there is still a large supply of capital, which implies that there's not enough good idead / founders to go around?
- ergocoder 2y agoSupply and fungibility is more for kpop idols
- nikisweeting 2y agoWait wtf founders are taking liquidity in second rounds?! Had I known this was possible I would have totally changed my strategy years ago. I've founded 3 startups and always thought I could only take out whatever ramen salary I could defend to the most scrutinizing investors. I've given a heck of a lot more in employee bonuses than I've ever taken directly out of the investor pot, where was this "de-risk your own life" essay all those years ago!
- tempusalaria 2y agoOne under appreciated dynamic that has changed is that companies with limited revenue/PMF are raising more money at higher valuations. This mean that more early employees are being hired into less certain, less profitable situations, and the equity they are getting is a smaller percentage behind more liquidity preferences. E.g. There are numerous AI startups I’ve spoken to in the past year with negative gross margins, 8 figure raises, and >100x ARR multiples. $1mln in paper equity in such a company is probably intrinsically worth <$100k. Being an early employee at a startup right now is a really bad financial decision imo
- not_a_dane 2y agoThe entire system seems like a scam. Thankfully, the COVID-19 pandemic and the Ukraine war have deflated startup valuations a bit. I believe another crisis is looming in the near future, and once it passes, we should be in a better place for the next 5-10 years.
- franciscop 2y agoI feel like the article contradicts itself in this point: > Investors and founders both tend to think that if employees knew founders were getting liquidity that that would negatively impact employee morale (it wouldn’t) > If employees realize they are taking more risk than the founders, [...] maybe they'll start yelling: "I'M TAKING SO MUCH RISK, IT'S SO HARD TO BUILD A COMPANY, I DON'T EVEN HAVE ACCESS TO LIQUIDITY!!!". And maybe they're right. How is "not impact morale" and giving an example of employees shouting as a possible outcome when they find out not contradict each other?
- dumbfounder 2y agoI don’t agree with this sentiment: Investors, founders, and employees all believe that founders are taking more risk than early employees (this isn’t true once founders have exclusive access to liquidity) This completely discounts how much risk and stress go into the early stages before money is raised, or before enough money is raised to pay founders properly. They often go into debt, put many aspects of their lives on hold, and undergo outsized stress that is largely alleviated by the liquidity event, enabling them to plow forward and shoot for the moon. There are outliers that are insane, but you can’t throw the baby out with the bath water.
- KingMob 2y ago...? Much of what you described applies to early employees, too.
- dumbfounder 2y agoI have always taken a lower salary than early employees. And had periods before raising money and after the money dried up where I was taking no salary. I think it is way way way more common for founders to do this than early employees.
- KingMob 2y agoSo? I've been in the exact same situation as you, as CTO of my startups. Just because some things you wrote don't apply to early employees doesn't mean many things don't apply...which is what I said.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- doodda 2y agoThis post has managed to piss off everyone: employees who didn't realize founders were getting liquidity events while they're still sitting on their more-often-than-not valueless equity, and founders who feel they've earned it and don't like the implication they haven't.
- mattgreenrocks 2y agoThe mark of a good post!
- matsemann 2y agoIt also reminded me about another post I read here, probably a few years ago, that outlined how stuff works. And my takeaway from that one, was yet another way that early employees get shafted, as they get diluted a lot, and other employees being brought on later end up with a better exit in the end. But I can't remember the details or find it.
- blitzar 2y agoYou managed to make both parties sound like absolute tools.
- JonChesterfield 2y agoNot the founders clearing life altering capital returns from the pre-revenue company seeking product market fit. They're winning.
- arolihas 2y agoHow does the employee sound like a tool here?
- reportgunner 2y agoOh yes it's time to shoot the messenger.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- steveBK123 2y agoI was aware something along these lines was going on when a profitless not-quite-unicorn (and still private & profitless 6 years later) startup founder bought the nicest penthouse apartment in my building some years ago... and then spent more money gut renovating it. It wasn't Adam Neumann sized liquidity but certainly mid single digit millions at least. His company meanwhile has floundered with wave after wave of layoffs post ZIRP era.
- koalaman 2y agoI recently left a long career in FANG to roll the dice on an early startup. I was pretty surprised by the uneven terms between founders and early employees. From what I could tell the early employees takes more risk than the founders because they don't get that magic token dollar turning into their share of the founding equity event and have to pay the fictional valuation of the seed to convert their options. Depending on how hot your startup is that can be a lot of money. Anyway that ended in tears, but I got what I was looking for from it. A look under the covers of the hot VC backed startup roller coaster. I may be getting old and cynical, but it looked considerably more exploitative than what I saw at Google. Obviously depends on the character of the founders and leaders, but the structure seems to be setup for toxicity.
- palata 2y agoI have been working in multiple startups, I've come to think that it's a Ponzi scheme for the founders. Generally underpaid and quickly toxic. It is an experience, but it's important to know it.
- RhodesianHunter 2y agoIt's a Ponzi scheme for VC and other investors. Founders just get greased palms along the way if they're successful.
- koalaman 2y agoYeah agreed to both of you. I had the same thought.
- geepeeyoudata 2y agoI worked at a Series A startup as an employee, and wont be doing that anymore. Early engineers have all the risk (lose job the second things go bad) but little upside. They would offer 500 options, or 1000 options, or 30,000 options -- but when you look at the prices, that was worth $100-$10,000. Why would anyone take all this risk, and lower base salaries for that lottery ticket?! Secondly, they wont share the cap table, so you dont know what the denominator is. 30,000 shares of What!? No one would tell you. You should run. Third, the VCs installed a buddy from SV as CEO who was creative with revenue. Great -- so they make their bonuses based on creative revenue, but the company gets saddled with VC rounds they have to dig out of w/o showing real revenue growth. Once you get SV insiders being placed into the company, often with their entourage of cousins and neighbors' kids as Director of HR or Director of Finance -- RUN FAST. The company is being strip-mined for cash, while Engineers slave away trying to code their way out of the wreckage left by locusts. The C-Suite operated in a separate tier of the company with a heads-i-win-tails-you-lose setup. You could tell -- no way you are all driving Tesla Plaid on a "startup salary" -- the "startup salary" was for suckers, engineers, and those not in the VC-back-scratch loop. My advice to everyone -- if you want risk, be a founder. Not Engineer #1 or #10. If you want balanced risk, go to a Series C or D company where you dont have the risk of fake accounting. If you want money, go to a public company with real accounting rules, visible revenue, visible liabilities, and more accountability.
- demondemidi 2y ago“ Being a software engineer who has a strong preference for creativity, problem-solving, and autonomy” That’s nearly every engineer or programmer I’ve ever met, not some rarity.
- gardenhedge 2y agoThe difference is: no founder === no company at all. no first employee === not a problem, hire another one.
- api 2y agoIt’s all relative. Founders that actually make it to series A levels have options to take money off the table (usually) and often what most Americans would consider a great salary, but if you do the math vs getting a massively overpaid FAANG job and include the odds of the startup imploding founder is actually a tougher gig. I refer to dilemmas like this as "zeroeth world problems." Of course like I said… relative. It is nowhere near as tough a gig as schoolteacher or service industry worker, at least financially, though there can be a lot of stress and some mental health risks.
- MobileVet 2y agoThis is a great post and I am glad it is getting high visibility. Everyone involved in a startup should understand this and consider it as part of their 'do I join' calculation. Additionally, founders shouldn't try to hide it nor should they horde the returns. Clearly founders are the reason the business exists, but the whole team is the reason it succeeds, everyone deserves a piece of the reward. Mark Cuban is a famous founder that understands this and distributing gains well before his big win. [1] One piece of feedback on the terms, 3 month w/ 10 yr window is pretty rough for the company. You will end up with a bunch of random people on the cap table... people that didn't really contribute much in the overall picture. That is annoying as you raise and downright frustrating when you exit. I would suggest you go back to a 12 month cliff w quarterly going forward and maybe set the window at years served, rounding down. My 2 cents. [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/mark-cuban-employees-millionaires-companies-sold-paid-profits-2024-6?op=1 https://www.businessinsider.com/mark-cuban-employees-million...
- stefantheard 2y agoI don't know if I agree - but I'm open to being wrong. I can't recall many scenarios where I thought someone was a strong fit at 3 months but a terrible fit at 12 months. I can probably think of a couple of scenarios for 3 months and 6 months, especially with slower time to value roles like leadership positions. Right now 3 months is within my risk tolerance - and there is another side to the cliff that folks don't talk about too often, pre-cliff people will generally be less transparent with negative feedback for fear of being fired before the cliff hits. I'm ok with giving up a bit of equity and polluting the cap table if it increases transparency faster. Maybe the lower risk bet would be a 6 month cliff but I believe 12 months is too long to hold the equity hostage.
- rasengan 2y agoThis is weird AF. I gave 20pct to my employees and didn’t have to write a blog post about it.
- throwailearner 2y agoPosting from throwaway so I can be very open. I joined a YC startup as engineer #1 with close to $200k salary and 2% options vesting at the usual 4 years, with a 10 year window. I feel like this was bettern than usual, and for a while felt like I struck an awesome deal, but as time went on I realised I was building everything single-handedly, while getting (at best) 2%, which started to annoy me deep down. Over two years in I'm considering quitting, for multiple reasons. I still believe there is a good chance of getting to an exit at some point, but I don't like the vibe and culture here, and honestly between cashing out 1.X% and cashing out 2% I don't see the point. If I had been given a much higher chunk (>5%) there is a good chance I would've stayed, so we'll see if they value me enough with a counteroffer when I give my notice. All in all, and reading through all of this I would never join a startup under these terms again, if I'm engineer #1 then I'm getting at least 10% and essentially being a cofounder. Otherwise I want a salary that's on par to a bigger company.
- moneywoes 2y agohow much effort are you putting here wrt to your previous job
- sleepingreset 2y agoout of college directly, would you recommend a similar position? looking for early career options
- shortrounddev2 2y agoI don't think you could get hired as engineer #1 straight out of college
- disgruntledphd2 2y agoAnd even if you could, you probably shouldn't. Go get experience with a bigger company first, so that the startup experience is more useful to you.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gafferongames 2y agoTwo words: opportunity cost.
- palata 2y ago> Founders often feel guilty that they are getting liquidity (they shouldn’t) Well they should not feel guilty that they are getting liquidity, but I think they should feel guilty that their employees get pretty much nothing in comparison. > Investors, founders, and employees all believe that founders are taking more risk than early employees (this isn’t true once founders have exclusive access to liquidity) As an employee in multiple startups, I can tell you that I never thought that. One startup went well, the founders got rich and I did not even compensate the salary compared to being in an established company (and I'm not even talking FAANG). When the startup goes bad, then the employees are screwed as well. Employees actually have the risk of getting fired, of being lied about the finances of the company, etc.
- danw1979 2y ago> Investors and founders both tend to think that if employees knew founders were getting liquidity that that would negatively impact employee morale (it wouldn’t) It would. Knowing that founders are cashing out and I’m not able to would be a very good reason to walk away, in my rather old, maybe slightly cynical opinion. I get the need to hedge your bets, but employees should be able to that too.
- lenerdenator 2y agoAccumulating capital becomes easier as you gain more capital, which is exactly why we need to abolish stock option pay packages and tax these people. Film at 11.
- abpavel 2y agoIt's clear that the author is first time founder. The article is disingenuous in that it talks about secondary availability, but the solution is longer exercise and shorter vesting? That wouldn't solve WeWork situation at all. Also, the risk of founders and employees is not comparable. A good analogy of the relationship is Landlord vs. Tenant. Founder burdens statutory obligations, is responsible with their personal belongings, has to lay the groundworks, and get the investors. Employee has to pass a job interview. If company fails, both lose a job, so that part is shared. First employees are sometimes special, but they are not founders. Musk was not even an employee and he became founder of Tesla.
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoI've read that Sam Altman's net worth has ballooned from hundreds of millions (mostly tied up in Helion) while at OpenAI to billions, and that despite all his protestations of not making a penny from OpenAI, he also has/had a $10M investment in the (~100x profit capped) for-profit part of OpenAI... Given Altman's slippery relationship with the truth, I have to wonder if his sudden significant increase in wealth, if true, is due to having participated in an early "liquidity event" as the article describes. Did he sell part of his shares to Microsoft, perhaps ?
- davidguetta 2y agoHe was rich before ... he has a couple of villas
- nimish 2y agoBeing a "founding engineer" is a sucker's game unless you have some very specific goals. Nearly all the same risk, 99% less reward.
- bob1029 2y agoI just got off the ride (at a small startup) after ~9 years. Not much to show for it economically, but I did gain a lot of confidence and experience around how to actually run a business. I've picked up a lot of lessons, most in what not to do. I'd say it was absolutely worth it compared to alternative paths that I was previously on. My biggest takeaway is to focus on compelling problems, rather than delusions of financial grandeur. I've learned that solving a hard thing and hearing the feedback from the customer brings me a lot more joy than hypothetical promises of extra cash in the bank. The money is a mind killer for me, especially when it's not real yet. Stock options are no longer something that interest me. I'll negotiate additional salary instead. The only company with stock options I am interested in would be a company that I personally found and retain control over. One other lesson is to pull the rip cord the microsecond you think something doesn't feel right with management/leadership. I started thinking things like "does anyone care about the sales funnel?", "Why are we only talking to one prospect at a time!?", etc... The chances you will be able to "fix" some other person in this setting are pretty much zero, unless they actively want to be helped. I feel like I could have jumped off this ride at the ~7 year mark and walked away with 99% of the wisdom I have right now.
- hemloc_io 2y agoDamn I was writing a blogpost about this exact problem inspired by a talk w/ a friend of mine. Being an early engineer is the worst deal in all of tech, the people I've seen do it are either comfortably wealthy or just don't care about money.
- carom 2y agoI did it not caring about money and got burned so badly I was still mad. It's ok though, it is nice to return to work with good people earning more than 2x a founding engineer salary.
- yieldcrv 2y agoDelaware allows for employee shareholders to demand some transparency, but it doesn't apply to options holders. VCs and Founders should be far more forthcoming to sweat equity participants. Delaware could mandate that too. I've been on both sides, where leadership gaslights candidates and employees about why their tiny stock grant is so generous, diluted in the best case scenario. And on the other side where leadership is confused why someone with prior financial success would want to be an employee at all since its so obviously shit. That's sad to me that they can put on two faces, and its enabled in a way that securities laws were made to mitigate.
- jaksmit 2y agodunno why the writer opted for this: "Our equity packages vest over 3 years instead of the industry standard 4-year period." given it takes a long time to build companies; so on the contrary, many startups are instead opting for like 6 year windows. "We allow employees to exercise options up to 10 years after they leave instead of 90 days." - the reason that 90 days is more standard is that it's more tax effective than having options exercisable for 10 years, though many companies are making a compromise on this recently
- p0seidon 2y agoThis thread is more entertaining than both TikTok and Netflix combined, which is truly exceptional.
- stefantheard 2y agoI'm glad I waited for the dust to settle on the battlefield before taking a look at the comments - agreed, super entertaining! haha
- stratigos 2y agoAs someone who has worked in startup environments for 20 years, its rather offensive that anyone in 2024 would claim that employees arent taking risks. In todays salary brackets, one could be comfortably making 220k as a staff dev some huge healthcare/pharma tech firm. One may also feel the job is boring, soulless, and mostly uncomfortable. Then one may choose to work at an exciting AI startup for ~160k, and suddenly find themselves way happier, growing more, and engaged. One just took ~60k worth of risk right there, not to mention that it could be come $0 tomorrow, and one likely now has crap healthcare benefits, given the startup status. That 60k could be a million dollars in ~15 years if invested wisely.
- matco11 2y agoYeah. This misses the point that founders often go unpaid for long periods of time. Those payments catch founders up to being able to have a “normal” lifestyle - which enables them to perform their CEO or CTO jobs better. A CEO having issues with making ends meet at home, having personal debt, and eating ramen can sustain that additional pressure forever. It’s in the interest of VCs to arrange things so that founders can focus 100% on the success of the company.
- totorovirus 2y agoWhat shines better in a resume? ex-founder or ex-founding engineer? If ex-founder is a better role for next job, I think founders are taking much less risk than founding engineers. They get all the exposure to talking to rich people, VCs, learning how financial game works, which i regard much more rewarding career-wise.
- corry 2y agoThree interesting part of the discussion: (1) The opportunity cost to the founder of taking early liquidity: If a founder cashes out 10% of their position for $500k @ $25M Series A valuation, that de-risks a lot of their personal life. But when the startup ends up selling for $250M, that $500k of 'early' selling would have been worth $5M (less any dilution between rounds) - hard not to regret the choice in that case even if hedging is going to be the correct choice 99% of the time. (2) Meaningful vs. not-meaningful amounts: From my prev example, the founder sells 10% of their position for $500k. Well, if all employees were allowed to sell up to 10% of their positions too, would that even matter to them? If you were an employee and had $200k total value in your options, and you could sell 10%, you're getting $20k. Not really enough to de-risk your life although still might be welcome (and employees would appreciate having the choice). (3) Sellers need buyers: In order for there to be a seller of shares, there needs to be a buyer. The founder is effectively choosing his buyer and future business partner by taking investment and choosing to give that buyer more control over the corp by selling him even more shares (his personal shares). The buyer wants to make the founder happy and de-risk their downside so they can be more aggressive or big-picture or whatever, plus is happy to own more of the company assuming it's a hot round. But what does the buyer want to achieve by purchasing the employees shares? Just to own a little bit more % of the corp? For amounts that might not even matter for the employees and may de-incentivize them? It's all very complicated and perhaps there are nuances that make every situation unique.
- neilv 2y ago> If a founder cashes out 10% of their position for $500k @ $25M Series A valuation, that de-risks a lot of their personal life. But when the startup ends up selling for $250M, that $500k of 'early' selling would have been worth $5M (less any dilution between rounds) - hard not to regret the choice in that case even if hedging is going to be the correct choice 99% of the time. IMHO, it's very easy not to regret, with those particular numbers. I'd take $500K now plus possibly $45M later -- over $0 now and possibly $50M later. I'd take that deal even if "possibly" were "guaranteed". (Who might regret that is a founder who was otherwise already wealthy.)
- 2y ago
- nbardy 2y agoI’ve got a job as a ML Researcher without a degree. I have experience building multimodal generative products. Because I was able to learn on the job at startups. I get to work on the problems of my dreams for the rest of my life now. 10 years ago the only jobs for machine learning were for PhDs at big companies. If you want to join a nascent industry and you’re not a top college graduate you have to find a way in the back door. Don’t do startups for the money do it for the career growth. 10 years in startups out of college. Even with two good exits. I didn’t make much money as an early employee, even in success, compared to FAANG peers. If I went to big companies I most likely end up doing a lot of web development and Im rich off the stock market.
- didgetmaster 2y agoI joined a startup as an engineer about 30 years ago. I was one of the first employees and one of the last to get some 'founder stock'. I took a big risk (low initial salary and even lent them money to make payroll) but it paid off. When the company was purchased 8 years later I did fairly well. Not enough to retire wealthy, but well worth the risk I took. I am glad I did it, but it could have turned out to be a big mistake. Everyone working for a startup might have a different story to tell. Some good. Some bad. Tread lightly if you wade into the startup waters. It CAN be very rewarding but it can also lead to nowhere.
- light_triad 2y agoWhile I agree that employees should get more equity and liquidity, I think it comes down to supply and demand: - If the founders are de-risking appropriately it will take years of no pay/low pay work before they can even consider taking on employees. Building a valuable asset is not done overnight and takes extreme commitment - plus reputational & financial risk, opportunity costs etc. - It's very rare for companies to get past the Series B stage. When they do, the founders have accumulated non trivial and non replicable knowledge about the market and the customers. The liquidity they get should be worth much more down the road. Now of course if you are an early employee that is expected to 'make the startup work' like a founder and get none of the benefits there's a problem. On the other hand employees are replaceable & 'swappable' in a way that founders are not.
- riemannzeta 2y agoThis is a wonderful article and kudos to the author for his moral sensibility here. The lack of liquidity and anti-dilution rights for any except a handful of key persons is a dirty secret of Silicon Valley. Most startup employees do not end up better compensated than they would at a larger company on a net present value basis even when their startup is successful -- and they don't as easily get liquidity along the way although there are more private secondary market brokers than there used to be. The other angle worth observing here is the tax angle. In many cases, the founders are taking liquidity at valuations that are only loosely tied to tax valuations of the company. These valuations are fine for the founders and preferred by the buyers/investors, but undercut the premise of the tax system that was redesigned after the options backdating scandals of the early 2000s, in part, to ensure that taxes were getting paid in accordance with the actual capital gains.
- apinstein 2y agoThe only fair way to analyze this is by looking at opportunity cost, which isn’t what TFA does. Founders often have slightly higher market value (though not always) than first employees, so they are giving up more to go the startup route. Separately, TFA further underestimates founder risk as they are typically not taking salary during pre-seed, and no or low salary during seed. However employees 1-5 typically get mostly cash, often much closer to market. Thirdly, there is also often a lot more stress in being the founder. It is a complex, all day job. You have the weight of keeping things going for all employees, and when cash is low it’s your paycheck that gets delayed/cut first, not your employees. That said I am all for reasonable early stage liquidity where it makes sense, but as many other commenters have mentioned, it tends to not be life changing super early for most early employees. Most employees would rather keep the bet on the table. Also, I am strongly against large founder secondaries. I think it’s helpful for founder to remain feeling “not financially successful”, especially first time founders, so that they keep their heart in the game. I followed this practice with my companies.
- openmajestic 2y ago> Thirdly, there is also often a lot more stress in being the founder. It is a complex, all day job. You have the weight of keeping things going for all employees, and when cash is low it’s your paycheck that gets delayed/cut first, not your employees. I've seen startups from a founder perspective and from an employee perspective (VC style startups). I agree there is more stress as a founder, but people really underestimate the toll as an early employee - the gap is smaller than many people think. Particularly those ideal missionary-type early employees, they take on just as much mental ownership burden as the founders. It is also an all-day job. Let me tell you, when the money runs low, it is immensely stressful as an early employee - it is both hard to be the one making the decisions and it is hard to not be the one making the decisions. The ability to walk away isn't a benefit, it's a burden. Their jobs can be different (or can be very much the same - depends on people and every startup is its own beast) with founders needing to deal with fundraising, board management, and ultimately having the impossible problems land at their feet which is often out-of-scope (and out-of-sight) for early employees. But the same core problem exists for both - your actions will dictate the success of the company. And there is a huge amount of understanding of the founder burden and support for them, from financial to emotional to reputational. Where are the support networks for early employees? People will say the founders, but this is a load of crap for the same reason that founders rely on relationships with other founders rather than talking to their board or teammates. Early employee is probably the worst engineering gig in Silicon Valley on most dimensions. Unless you just want to 0 to 1 build things. Then I haven't seen a job that can compare.
- notanadvice 2y agoPeople are talking about angry founders and angry employees, but there is another side to this post: Prospective founders who work in big tech companies and have a family which depend on them. I include myself in that group, and I thought I needed 10 years worth of savings to venture on creating my own startup. But from the discussion, in about four years it is possible to match big tech compensation. I feel more motivated to start a company now.
- divbzero 2y agoStartups are far more founder-friendly than they used to be (thanks in part to YC’s contributions) but we have a ways to go to make them more employee-friendly too. To call out the employee-friendly equity policies that OP has instituted at his new startup: > Our employee option pool is 20% which is double the average > We have a 3-month equity cliff which is 9 months sooner than the average. > We allow employees to exercise options up to 10 years after they leave instead of 90 days. > Our equity packages vest over 3 years instead of the industry standard 4-year period. > … only taking liquidity if I can also offer it to employees as well. The 10-year exercise window is especially noteworthy since the cost to exercise options can be substantial.
- sealthedeal 2y agoI think its less about more risk etc, and its more like, they are the ones starting the company lol. 1. They are providing jobs 2. They are responsible for growing business 3. They are accountable to not only the employees but to board and investors, etc. They take money off the table because they are in a much different position than say an engineer. It might be bad to say, but the engineer is responsible for one part of the business, the founders and CEO etc are responsible for all aspects of the business, and should be compensated appropriately for it, whether secondaries or higher salaries etc. Also, secondaries at seed and A are not as common as they were during the 2020-2022 run up.
- bink 2y agoAre founding engineers not also taking on risk? They're typically taking a much lower salary in exchange for their shares. They're avoiding vacations, nice cars, fancy houses, and other expenses that they could purchase if they worked for a larger, public company. In the example from the article WeWork founding engineers would've gone 9 years without seeing any value from their shares while the CEO was cashing out billions. The difference in responsibilities is already accounted for in their disparate salaries and ownership stakes. I don't think it's very relevant to whether or not they should have the option of cashing out some of their stake during funding rounds.
- AlwaysBCoding 2y agoThe situation I recently went through reads like a horror story: > was the founding engineer at a startup, essentially do co-founder work for 18 months getting the company off the ground. > company is a breakout success, raises a large growth round. > founders each take a couple of million dollars off the table in secondaries, no option for employee liquidity. > founders start thinking about early employees as "problems" because they have too much equity and could easily hire multiple FAANG engineers for the equity comp they're paying the early team. push all early employees out of the company. > horrible ego-based decision making such as this kills the company culture and runs the company into the ground. company is a mess, stock is now worth significantly less. --- > early employees have to pay money to exercise their stock options which are worth millions on paper. early employees have to front money to pay taxes on the capital gains on the stock. > founders have pocketed millions, off the backs of other people's work, while the employees who built the company all owe huge tax bills and have no path whatsoever to ever seeing liquidity with the floundering company. > all of this is because the employees did their jobs too well, the company grew too fast, and the founders egos got completely out of control. To be blunt, situations like this should be illegal. joint-stock companies aren't slush funds for three people to personally enrich themselves off the labor and capital investment of others, they're supposed to be entities where all shareholders participate in the upside of the value creation together. Until there's some sort of legal framework for pursuing class-action lawsuits against founders who defraud their employees like this I don't think this situation will ever get better. There are already laws against self-dealing transactions by company executives, I don't see what is different in cases of extreme founder liquidity off the backs of other people's work.
- gedy 2y agoNot to put you on spot, but this behavior is unprofessional, and you should name names IMHO.
- AlwaysBCoding 2y agoThe company is Phantom, and the VCs are Paradigm.
- goalonetwo 2y agoIn my 20s I joined a couple startups as "early engineer" or "founding engineer". I quickly realized those are the absolute worst positions to be in. You take almost as much risk as the founders but almost none of the upside. One startup died, the other one sold for 100m$. Out of that I saw 400k$ as an exit. Not too bad but even with that exit I ended up making way less than if I joined a FAANG. In both cases the founders made millions (through the exit or through liquidity) Now I'm a realist. Either you create/found a startup or it's not worth joining one as an employee. You have way more upside at a FAANG/pre-IPO mid-life startup that already found a great product market fit. Essentially, founders are pushing a crazy narrative of Startups being worth it to early employees because they need them. It was sometimes fun but I wish I just joined a FAANG like most of my friends, I would have a couple millions by now if I did.
- abvdasker 2y agoI second this. I took a large salary cut to be 1/2 of an engineering team at a seed stage startup for ~1.25%. After 2 years of pretty grueling work I left to go back to big tech for 3x the pay. I wouldn't call it a total waste of time in the sense that it made me a better engineer, but it certainly wasn't worth it financially. The company still exists and has had a relatively successful series A and "A extension" but I don't think my equity will ever be worth anything. I really wouldn't recommend anyone work as an engineer at an early stage startup unless you're getting ~5% or more (this would be unprecedented) because the risk is barely less than the founders and the pay is generally terrible. Series B or later (growth stage) may be a sweet spot where the salaries are decent and there is still significant equity upside without the insane hours.
- dareal 2y agoThis is very valuable sharing, thanks
- habosa 2y agoFounding engineers are so underpaid relative to founders. I’ve seen it be founding CTO with 40% and founding engineer with 1%. It’s ridiculous and we should not accept it as the standard. A few good early hires can be just as valuable as good founders.
- joshuamerrill 2y agoFounder liquidity events are done in secret in startup land. There's a simple reason for that. It's wrong. Startup employees, especially early ones, take on most of the risk that founders do. They take pay cuts. They work insane hours. They sacrifice. And they have the same liquidity needs, too. It's wrong to make them wait a decade for a fraction of the liquidity that founders got in the Series B. It's wrong to force them to absorb the risk of the Series B, C, D, E, F, and IPO. All while the founders were set for life years ago. If founders are going to take money off the table, they should extend the same liquidity offer, pro-rata, to their employees. Period.
- riazrizvi 2y agoI don’t understand the framing here, where they need to justify why they get paid. They created and secured a thing and sell off chunks of it along the way when it suits them. What’s strange about that? If you buy a cheap stretch of land in the middle of nowhere and develop it and sell pieces of it off, that’s just understandable. When you come on board as an employee, you’re just not in the same situation.
- craftkiller 2y agoUsing your analogy, this is Alice bought a cheap stretch of land in the middle of nowhere, and wanted to develop it, but she couldn't afford to pay Bob to develop it. Alice then offers to pay Bob a smaller portion of money and some of her land in exchange for developing it. Bob has other clients looking to pay him more money, but he decides to take Alice's contract because he wants the land. Why is Bob not in the same situation? They both are taking a financial loss in the hopes of having more valuable land to sell. Why shouldn't Bob have the same right to sell his portion of the land that Alice has?
- otoburb 2y agoThere's a moral justification, and a desire to change the social norm, versus the terms of an agreement. This is where educational articles like this are important to improve the understanding throughout the industry so that employees can make informed choices. >>Why is Bob not in the same situation? In this specific circumstance, Bob agreed to an arrangement that contractually doesn't put him in the same situation. Hopefully Bob will learn from this experience and, if possible, negotiate better (or equivalent rights) instead of willingly agreeing to unequal rights. Pragmatically, unless and until more workers are willing to take the risk to become founders themselves, the balance of power usually is in the founders' and investors' favour (i.e. capital).
- billy99k 2y agoWhen I was younger, I worked for multiple startups and received stock in each one. How much is that stock worth now? $0. I no longer will put that much time and effort into something, unless I am the founder.
- blizkreeg 2y agoFounder liquidity is wrong -- and not because employees don't get the same deal. It's wrong because it is NOT uncommon for a founder to take chips off the table sometimes enriching themselves to the tune of millions only for the startup to then "fail" -- either go bankrupt, sell for peanuts, or sell for only a modest multiple. You're not done until you're done. But founder liquidity has now become a path to getting rich when the outcome of the company is still unknown and up in the air. If venture backed founders don't want that risk, they should start bootstrapped companies. At a minimum, there should be a cap on it (not % but $), and yes, it should be extended to early employees too.
- bagels 2y agoWhen is the outcome 'known'? Only when the business fails?
- sub7 2y agoI was an early (first 5) dev at a company now valued north of $5B I have seen only a few hundred k so far while both founders have bought over $30m of real estate and who knows what else...
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 2y agoThe other aspect that's not factored in here is that often founders can spend years in search mode, living on savings or some early stage pre-seed VC, with zero guarantee of success or ever even finding something to work on. Took you 5 years to get to a concept that finally justified hiring someone to help you grow it? Equity is the only form of compensation you have for all that work, and it might still be worth $0 another 5 years later. In the meantime the ICs are getting paid, are getting benefits, are having a life beyond the company. The rewards have to be deeply asymmetric for this system to work, otherwise nobody in their right mind would even consider it.
- blizkreeg 2y agoThe asymmetric reward is the _company_ having a liquidity event thereby enriching the founder, NOT a funding round enriching the founder.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 2y agoAt least in my personal experience of doing this, you're often many years of living on savings and are in a bunch of debt and being able to get some cash from a funding event really helps with relieving the stress of barely making ends meet. Investors expect you to stay hungry for as long as possible, so even your salary is complete garbage, and the funding secondary is an absolute life saver that lets you sleep a little bit better at night after many years of dipping into the piggy bank.
- aj7 2y agoFounder risk is total myth. I was at a startup where, when it was apparent there would be no more funding, the vc’s permitted principal founder to essentially embezzle the remaining few $M. He and his cronies then lived off the proceeds for the better part of a decade in a kind of “brown dwarf” of a company of the same name. And it was the SECOND time he had done this in his career!
- scndrythrwy 2y agoFounder here who turned down an offer to secondary in our B round. It would have brought ~$5M before tax. This would have been a material change in my financial security. I live in a high-cost US city and have been putting off starting a family. It would have removed many concerns that are holding us back from feeling like it's the right time for us. My thinking has evolved, but is roughly: (1) The argument from VCs in favor of a secondary is often: If the founders take some money off the table, they have downside protection and are more strongly incentivized towards only a massive outcome. This aligns their risk profile more closely to their (Seed/A/B stage) VCs who model their portfolios based on bimodal (boom or bust) outcomes. It helps prevent scenarios where the founders safely exit for $Xm leaving the Series B VC with a 1x'ish return that's against their profile. (2) I didn't take the offer because I felt it would be unfair to our early employees who took a big risk leaving FAANG compensation to come build with us. I ruminate on this often. It would have changed my life, and the only difference to them would be some numbers in our cap table being 10% different. In retrospect, doing it pro-rata for everyone would have solved this, but I'm not sure the VC making the offer would have gone for it. Who knows. (3) I do not think founders and early employees deserve exactly the same treatment. While early folks took a similar financial risk as I did, they aren't chained to the company in the same way. They can quit tomorrow and go back to FAANG jobs. A founder has to either find their own replacement, sell the company, or run a long and painful wind-down process and return money to the VCs. All of these options take months-to-quarters of work, create reputational risk, suck emotionally, etc. And that's in addition to still losing all your money like the employee did. I don't think it's the same. (4) You don't get nice-guy points for turning down the offer. Nobody on my team knows that my cofounder and I turned it down, so we get no credit for doing right by them. Telling them about it feels somewhere between a humble brag and guilt tripping them into working harder. The motivation to do "the right thing" has to be purely internal. (5) If you're starting a company I strongly suggest you give your employees the option to early-exercise / 43b their shares. Few folks seem to know enough about their options to take advantage of this but it prevents the lock-in scenario where someone wants to quit but can't because the AMT bill would devastate them. We have had this since the seed round but sadly only a few people pay attention to it, and I can only suggest it so much without creating a financial-advice legal risk. While I feel like I did right by my team, I can put an exact price on the cost of that positive moral sensation. My team might even think I'm stupid for not taking it when they would have. It's pretty easy to say what's obviously right and wrong in HN comments, but when all you have to do to pocket a life changing amount of money is say "ok", the decision feels much heavier.
- guhcampos 2y agoI like the discussion you folks are having in this post and all, but haven't you asked yourselves who is this guy? Because there isn't much information about him on the Internet and that website has that single one post up.
- stefantheard 2y agoI'd be asking the same question, it's a fair criticism. I wrote this expecting 10 people to read it and I wrote it as a part of a writer's feedback group. I'm just a random guy who has worked at a lot of startups, nothing special!
- iainctduncan 2y agoBackground: I work in technical diligence and talk to a lot of companies just before they do exits to PE firms (i.e., usually the first big cash-in). One of the things I see over and over again is just how much great people matter. Not only do they matter for getting you there, but they matter for how much you get when you get there. Our work is used at the negotiation table: piles of tech debt and stuff that needs to be seriously fixed up comes off the top... a "hair-cut" as they put it. Your pile of tech debt and ignored security issues and so on could be millions off the deal. So... I agree with this writer that it there is likely more value to early founders than they think in doing that which motivates star-level early employees to join and stay.
- pedalpete 2y agoI'd be very careful with a 20% option pool and a 3 month cliff. My assumption is this means the founder is providing double the equity, meaning that at 3 months the potential of not insignificant amounts of equity can be walking out the door. We've had the experience where we had a contractor who we thought was a good fit. We decided to hire them as an employee, and back-date the cliff to when they started. We had a very big somewhat bet the company deadline which their work was key to, and this deadline was about 3 weeks past the cliff date. They walked 2 weeks before, and didn't deliver. Literally waiting until they could claim some equity. Of course, this is what bad leaver clauses are for, but there is a reason why some of the terms exist. I agree with the long exercise options. Vesting timelines have arguments for longer and shorter, which is why I think the standard 4-years is settled on.
- hchak 2y agoWow. This is relevant to me as I am choosing a big company versus a backed pre-seed company with 4-5% at a $5M valuation. If someone could offer the time to walk me through the liquidity scenarios, it would be much appreciated.
- hdivider 2y agoBad founder behavior is quite prevalent and should be called out for sure. I disagree though with the general notion that employees are taking similar or even greater levels of risk. If you get a stable monthly paycheck, and the reasonable worst case is you're laid off because the company runs out of money (or downsizes), then the risk is in finding a new job. That situation exists in a job at a large company too. Founders however are so tied to their ventures, that getting a new job is effectively out of the question, because it very likely means the death of the company. And starting a company is an exceedingly difficult, stressful, and sacrificial thing to do. There is a clear and significant asymmetry in risk, and frequently in blood, sweat, and tears. So the nonlinear rewards should be commensurate too.
- myarr 2y agoOh please. There’s definitely no blood. Most likely no tears. I’ve been burned by two startups. So done with this asymmetrical inequality
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kats 2y agoDo something meaningful. The people I know who make the most money, do absolutely asinine stuff that they don't even bother explaining to other developers. They just hide behind the phrase 'I work at X.' A lot of the best people I know are not web developers. A lot of people making the world meaningfully better in scalable ways, are not developers.
- kelnos 2y ago> Investors and founders both tend to think that if employees knew founders were getting liquidity that that would negatively impact employee morale (it wouldn’t) Not sure I agree there. If employees widely knew founders were getting liquidity but the rank-and-file aren't, I think there would be a hit to morale. Of course, the solution there isn't secrecy, it's giving employees some liquidity.
- __lbracket__ 2y agoAt this point, you have to be colossally stupid to work for a startup. Assume options are worth $0, demand market salaries, and close-to-market benefits.
- interludead 2y agoSilicon Valley was my dream destination when I was a child