9 ms·
Vets fret as private equity snaps up clinics, pet care companies
- metadat 3y agoPrivate equity is akin to toxic poison for everyone who isn't one of the (very few) general partners who bask in obscene amounts of scrooge-mcduck money. Think of making a cool $30 million+ a quarter, per partner -- thanks real estate (and apparently, emergency medical services) "investments"! This is a direct funnel to syphon money from the workers to the ruling class. That's even more cash than the top brass at FAAGs make. How can this phenomenon be reigned in and sorted in the medium to long-term? It's a loss for everyone (99.9999%) except the miniscule quantity of winners (0.0001%, yes, that's 1 in 1,000,000 - there aren't that many large-scale P/E firms). Housing owned by P/E couldn't be more soul sucking. Scratch that, this applies to every case I'm aware of where P/E firms own a thing. Anecdote: Last month my dear old dog was suddenly very ill and I spent $12k on emergency surgery to save his sweet life. No regrets, I'm grateful he was fixable. But in the waiting room I did the conservative math for what the SAGE Emergency Veterinary Hospital in Redwood City, CA makes in a year (before the comparatively small overhead, tax-deductible expenses) and they are pulling in at least $30 million in this single location. That's.. a lot, for many 20 total staff. Also they charged me $500 for each follow-up visit, which is way more than my real life surgeon charged me earlier this year! (Even including insurance, he didn't charge much for the follow-ups to make sure I survived.) Damn. For the dog lovers out there: Doggo is alive and well, can maybe last another year or two we hope. Btw, who owns SAGE? NVA, a P/E firm. https://todaysveterinarybusiness.com/sage-veterinary-centers-nva/ https://todaysveterinarybusiness.com/sage-veterinary-centers... https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/national-veterinary-associates https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/national-veterinary-...
- ryukoposting 3y agoShame.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hiddencost 3y agoId rather try regulation.
- eddythompson80 3y agoFunnily enough, heavily regulated industries are where PE and large conglomerates shines because they can centralize dealing with all the regulations and paper work. No private vet or dentist is gonna have a legal or accounting department to deal with that, nor do they want to deal with it themselves. It’s easier to outsource that to the major conglomerate that’s handling that for everyone else in the state or country.
- s5300 3y ago[dead]
- kbenson 3y agoIdeally you'd expect the market to deal with it how it normally does, which is to have people open up competing practices to undercut them. I think the problem is that VC has correctly identified this as not only a field where people are willing to pay a lot based on emotion, but it's also regulated enough that their strategy of buying out existing practices leaves them fairly safe from a lot of competition. I wouldn't be surprised if non-competes factor heavily into their strategy either. In that case I would hope the government could at least step in to combat anti-competitive behavior (which I think this definitely is), but that always seems to lag a decade after it's first needed.
- ceejayoz 3y agoLocally, the answer was that the folks who could open up a competing practice were under non-compete agreements if they left the PE-owned place. (We had a local legislator step in to help void them.) https://news.vin.com/default.aspx?pid=210&catId=3115&Id=11865695 https://news.vin.com/default.aspx?pid=210&catId=3115&Id=1186... > Marion said early efforts to enlist former VSES doctors or others in the community to start an ER were discouraging. Some VSES doctors had already left the area, some had signed contracts for new jobs locally, most were worried about the constraints of noncompete agreements they signed with Thrive, and "no one seemed eager to take on the tremendous responsibility of owning, managing and running an emergency hospital even with the help and support of the local veterinary community."
- koolba 3y agoWill be interesting to see how the recent FTC non compete ban plays out in this space. It seems like a prime candidate to promote competition as the key licensing is held by the individual (the vet) as opposed to the company.
- ceejayoz 3y agoYes, I'm hoping that holds up in SCOTUS.
- 3y ago
- Teckla 3y agoHow can this phenomenon be reigned in and sorted in the medium to long-term? Far more aggressive progressive taxation.
- koolba 3y ago> Far more aggressive progressive taxation. Why would increasing taxes lower costs for anything? If anything they’d have to raise prices further to compensate for additional tax payments.
- ceejayoz 3y agoGenuinely progressive taxation would aim to reduce the tax burden on small independent and non-profit vet practices, and increase it dramatically on the profits the big PE firms are taking.
- bongodongobob 3y agoIt increases the risk of turning a profit due to consolidation and lack of competition. Oh you made $20 million off that vet clinic? You owe $19 million in taxes. Makes it harder to gouge people because buying "all the things" becomes far more risky and natural competition has a better chance of doing it's thing.
- koolba 3y ago> Oh you made $20 million off that vet clinic? You owe $19 million in taxes. This type of myopic thinking is how you get asinine policy like the ACA “cap on profits”. Instead of incentivizing an efficient operation, we’ll have some other accounting shenanigans to pass on profits as some other form of income.
- bongodongobob 3y agoIt's an exaggeration of what progressive taxes do. I'm not suggestion 95% of profits should be lost to taxes at 20 mil.
- 3y ago
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThere's the general legal principle that everything not explicitly forbidden in writing is allowed. And often even laws already on the books are half-heartedly enforced.
- metadat 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Everything_which_is_not_forbidden_is_allowed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Everything_which_is_not_forbid... This was actually just discussed/linked on HN this past weekend. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40242783 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40242783
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mattmaroon 3y agoThere are a lot of different PE firms that do a lot of different things, but I usually think they get the blame for systems that were broken long before they got there. They only own a small percentage of the real estate market (like sub 2%) but I see ten articles about them buying homes for every one about the real issues that are leading to the housing crisis, such as NIMBYism, other abusive local regulatory schemes, lack of tradespeople, etc. The people who are fucking up the system want you to worry about the PE firms instead. The way to get it sorted is to fix the market dynamics that have lead to ridiculous housing price increases. They’ll move on to greener pastures when homes in good markets aren’t appreciating at high rates. Vet care is increasing in cost pretty rapidly due to lack of supply, so the answer is more vet schools, perhaps government backed loans for people who want to open clinics, etc. Don’t fight the symptom (you can’t) fight the disease.
- shermantanktop 3y ago[flagged]
- mattmaroon 3y ago[flagged]
- toomuchtodo 3y agoCould it be “old HN” was the problem and intelligent people aren’t falling into a trap, but instead see a failing system’s failure points? Intelligent people making informed observations instead of blind nostalgia. Capitalism is broken. It is a tool. Fix the tool. If a bunch of folks connected with YC got wealthy off of a dysfunctional system, it is what it is, congrats on your lottery ticket. 90% of startups fail, 50% of YC startups are alive after five years, only a small minority achieving unicorn status; most fail, that doesn’t mean founders and commoner employees suck, it means they’re unlucky. Certain folks connected to YC have done well regardless of their startup failures. So just be interesting to people who will give you opportunities based on whatever their criteria and belief systems are.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> How can this phenomenon be reigned in and sorted in the medium to long-term? Most dentists, veterinarians and such don’t want to deal with administering their businesses. Particularly in heavily-regulated states. Simplifying paperwork and making it easier for juniors to open their own practices (e.g. nullifying non-competed and making commercial leasing smoother) would negate this effect. Private equity, in these situations, is a symptom of an unworkable bureaucratic overhead for small business. It’s not the poison, it’s the ulcer.
- the_real_cher 3y agoNot to mention the government regulations of vet training which keeps vet worker supply low.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoIt never ceases to amaze me how no matter how clearly and obviously this is just one of those issues that is directly caused by free markets, there is inevitably someone ready to find some damn regulation by the government and blame that instead. Markets have their place. They are not and should not be treated as the default, sole option.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoSeems like vet care is clearly one of those places where markets have a place. I don't think the people will accept socializing the cost of back surgery for someone's dog. I absolutely blame regulation. When my cat was dying I couldn't even by kidney friendly cat food without an prescription from a licensed professional.
- zargon 3y agoMy sincere condolences about your cat. I also had a cat with kidney disease, and the veterinary system was not very helpful about treatment. I had to learn most of it on my own. The "prescription" pet food situation is an example of free market entities subverting regulatory agencies. "Prescription" pet foods exist only through a selective lack of enforcement by the FDA. The manufacturers make claims that the food treats specific medical conditions. That's a drug claim. By law they would be required to test for efficacy and have it approved as a drug. But the FDA chooses to allow manufacturers to sell pet food that makes drug claims without testing or approval so long as they contract with veterinarians to only sell it under "prescription." It's not a prescription (it's not a drug!), it's a way to skirt regulation. For kidney disease you want foods high in moisture, moderate in protein and low in phosphorous. You can buy foods that meet these requirements at your pet food store. There are options that are much higher quality than said "prescription" foods hawked by Hills, Royal Canin and the like. They're just not advertised as treating kidney disease because they don't make inappropriate drug claims!
- nyjah 3y agoHow can this phenomenon be reigned in and sorted in the medium to long-term? I'm not trying to make a political statement. But in my experience, we need to elect the right leaders to ensure we can try to minimize corruption through lobbyists and government officials to get regulation right. And also hold corrupted officials responsible. It's not gonna solve everything, but it does help.
- metadat 3y agoThe P/E orgs are generally working within the confines of all federal and local laws, they never had to lobby or corrupt anything. It's more of a wide open exploit.
- ceejayoz 3y agoLobbying is frequently aimed at preventing new laws that would close such exploits.
- EMCymatics 3y agoThis needs to be talked about more.
- nradov 3y agoPrivate equity per se isn't a problem. Business owners have to be able to sell their equity, and PE firms provide a source of liquidity. Most deals work out well for the seller; it's not just the GPs who benefit. In cases where PE portfolio companies fail it's usually because the business was no longer viable, or they shifted the capital structure too much away from equity and towards debt. The former is just a regular part of the business cycle. I can't imagine how you would reign in the latter. Companies are allowed to issue bonds.
- weaksauce 3y agoevery contraction cycle the PE ghouls swoop in with a large war chest of money and buy up more homes/businesses/anything not tied down. it's a vicious cycle that eventually ends with them holding everything and everyone else is just sent out to pasture. no good way to fix it other than curbing the accumulation of wealth at the very top. it's unsustainable as a society imo.
- seabird 3y agoUntil a few months ago, I worked at a company that was uneventfully owned by various PE firms for the last fifteen years or so. I was shitcanned after the PE owners of my company got their arm twisted into selling my company to a strategic buyer that had previously bought another division of my company and then played dirty under my employer's name. When the buyer was served the inevitable lawsuit, they played even dirtier and effectively goaded the judge into hearing out the weak case made by my employer. After that development, the buyer just threw in a massive offer (likely 4-5x the realistic value, but I wasn't privy to any details), bought us, dropped the suit, terminated any employee that testified against them, terminated any employee that didn't keep the lights on, and have been leaving the business to languish while they sort out multiple other lawsuit-riddled acquisitions they've made in the last year. Whenever an employee of the buyer shows up to a facility that belongs to my previous company, they come with a bodyguard/security, if you need any hints regarding their moral character. Most players in the industry refuse to deal with that buyer, so they just attempt to deceive acquired customers when making an acquisition, and throw a bunch of money and crook lawyers at the (many) lawsuits that pop up. This type of behavior is not strictly limited to private equity. The real issue is that people who pull stunts like the above will never get their teeth punched out for it, and they're a wolf in a henhouse when dealing with a legal system that's largely powerless to say "I know it when I see it". The punishment for being a piece of human dogshit in this manner is effectively nothing, and nearly infinitely less than the reward. I haven't thought of an answer that doesn't give discomforting power to those evaluating these cases, but as long as repeat offenders can paper over every bad-faith action by claiming they're following the letter of (some interpretation of) the law and never get punished for it, it will never stop.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- renewiltord 3y agoHousing being owned by private equity is only feasible because most localities work really hard to ensure that private equity gets good return on investment. They call it "neighbourhood character" and stuff like that.
- giantg2 3y agoSome financial companies are looking to open PE up to more people. I think the floor is still high - around $1M up front and $4M in liquid assets for additional funding (or something like that). I think there are some regulator restrictions on accredited investors. I would bet there's a legal loophole where you could group people into a mutual fund type structure but for private equity using some sort of legal entity.
- tadfisher 3y agoThe restriction is one of: $1 million net worth (excluding primary residence), or $250k/yr income. You meet that floor, you can buy private shares on secondary markets. I don't think it's a loophole to pool accredited investors into a company, it's called a private equity firm :)
- nradov 3y agoThe loophole is that regular people can become "accredited investors" by simply lying. In most cases no one actually checks the numbers they write down for assets and income. I am not recommending committing fraud here, but this is extremely common.
- immibis 3y agoThat's why you either die the hero or live long enough to become the villain: villain tactics *work* - that's why they do them!
- hinkley 3y agoIn the 80’s you had corporate raiders disassembling companies when their hard assets were worth more at auction than the purchase price of the company. It was violent and people didn’t like it. PE is a slower, less obvious strategy, working on a larger pool of companies. But I strongly suspect the same kind of human worked for both company types.
- snapetom 3y agoI work for a PE-owned company in another industry. My wife is a veterinarian, and I wrote my thoughts on those who complain about veterinary costs in another comment. You can't possibly accurately estimate how much SAGE is pulling in at that location. Not even other vets can do this. There are too many variables. As far as PE goes, thank fucking God PE is cleaning up my company and industry. This has been a good ol' boy network, full off incompetence, favoritism, and nepotism. PE are buying players and it's crashing down. Long time execs who haven't have an original thought in 20 years are being forced to retire. A female VP in my company left because a consultant called her "too emotional" recently, and the idiot CEO listened. He's close to getting canned, too. We're losing customers left and right because his old school, "feed 'em hookers and blow" playbook (dead serious) doesn't work any more.
- withinboredom 3y agoMy sister is an emergency vet at a hospital like this. She’s on call, usually sleeping in one of their little sleeping rooms above the hospital floor. She makes a ridiculous amount of money doing random surgeries like pulling pine needles out of dogs stomachs at 3am because the owner didn’t realize the dog ate half the Christmas tree before going to bed.
- krageon 3y ago> How can this phenomenon be reigned in and sorted in the medium to long-term? This is a valid question, but one that has a historical and clear answer already: Guillotines. Pretending this behaviour is anything short of deserving of immediate execution is frankly doing yourself and everyone around you a huge disservice. These are people that exploit others at scale. They know what they're doing isn't right and is extremely exploitative, but they'll keep doing it anyway because it lets them live like modern kings and queens. They're the worst of what humanity has to offer and they should summarily be fired into the sun.
- nojvek 3y agoI had no idea how expensive owning a dog was. Vet and dog food prices have all shot up. Before I used to say you should get a pet, now I don’t. Same with kids. It’s insanely expensive to have kids. You wanna stick it to P/E and capitalism? Reduce spending. Live like you’re making half the income.
- dhosek 3y agoAnother related issue with this has been the rise in the cost of getting a DVM and the associated debt load. The vets who would be at the point in their career where they’d be buying practices from their retiring DVM boss cannot afford to do so (based on anecdata from my brother who was trying to sell his practice last year but his cancer overtook him so he wasn’t able to complete a deal).
- jonwachob91 3y agoJust a spot check - but a DVM at the University of Florida (the first vet school that popped into my head) is $30k/year for tuition and books. At 4 years, that's a $120k degree - but from my understanding, starting a vet practice is over a $1MM, so it's safe to assume buying an existing vet practice is at least $1MM, and I don't think $120k in debt would be THE limiting factor for buying a $1MM+ practice. (and that's assuming a recent DVM vet buying the practice, not a 10+ year experienced vet that's probably already paid off their student loads) [0] https://education.vetmed.ufl.edu/wordpress/files/2023/07/23-24-Cost-of-Attendance_UF-CVM.pdf https://education.vetmed.ufl.edu/wordpress/files/2023/07/23-...
- FireBeyond 3y agoIt stands in stark contrast to dentistry. Two new grads I know (of middle class means) were able to get $3-5M loans with little to nothing down, and no other collateral, to acquire a practice and to start a practice.
- atomicfiredoll 3y agoI've heard a similar complaint from my dentist, who said practices are being sold to private equity instead of dentists coming out of school. My understanding is that her field, it's happening through Dental Support Organizations and Orthodontic Support Organizations.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe only 24/7 emergency vet in our area was owned by private equity, who closed it after a unionization vote. They then tried to enforce non-competes on staff to prevent a replacement. https://news.vin.com/default.aspx?pid=210&Id=11633319&f5=1 https://news.vin.com/default.aspx?pid=210&Id=11633319&f5=1 Thankfully, a local legislator pressured them to release staff from the non-competes, and a non-profit emergency vet has since opened up with some seed funding. https://www.rochesterfirst.com/news/animals/bello-and-morelle-will-announce-funds-for-new-emergency-veterinary-facility/ https://www.rochesterfirst.com/news/animals/bello-and-morell...
- digitalsushi 3y agoMine here in NH got sucked up into one about 2 years ago and I'm easily paying double now. It was 2200 bucks to get my dog's teeth cleaned last year, 3 months before she died. In the same vein we have stopped going to McDonalds for, the family is kind of reorienting itself around not being a dog family. We just cope and joke that we outlived peak times. We can still get sushi though. There's still a long way to fall.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThere were no cheaper places within driving distance? Seems like incredibly high pricing to not attract competitors opening up shop.
- bootlooped 3y agoLast time I tried to get quotes for cleaning my pet's teeth nobody would give them over the phone. Not even ball park ranges.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoHow many places did you call?
- dhosek 3y agoEventually, though, you’ll have to follow the lead of Duke and Debbi when you get sushi.
- 1123581321 3y agoWell, that gets at what’s happening here. Paying $1100 regularly, to the point that it’s subscribing to that recurring service or not owning a dog, is way too tempting. There is a new captive market of pet owners who, through breed selection, diet, and/or aesthetic priorities have a much costlier relationship with their vet. An industry that used to struggle to bring in pet owners outside of emergencies has a lot more to offer equity than a younger doctor could afford. Because those trends (capital and changing relationships with pets) are hot, a practice owner is not going to give someone time to earn their ownership of the practice.
- mattmaroon 3y agoI don’t really think vets are fretting. It cannot cost that much to start a vet clinic, and if they’re such a great profit source that PE firms are snapping them up, surely some other banker of some sort would be happy to give loans to enterprising ones. The real issue is lack of supply. Which is good for vets, so I’m sure they’re not fretting too much about that.
- astrodust 3y ago"It cannot cost that much to start a vet clinic" implies vets are cheap. There is not an infinite supply of vets, especially those free from debt and who can borrow enough to start a practice.
- mattmaroon 3y agoCorrect, that’s the problem, which is what I said. Not PE firms, lack of veterinarians.
- ceejayoz 3y agoIf the PE firms buy up the practices and put all the vets in the area under a non-compete (not a hypothetical; see my other comments in this thread, it happened here in Rochester NY and is widespread practice), there aren't any vets to open a competitor.
- mattmaroon 3y agoNon-competes aren’t that simple, and in that very article it says they were forced to abandon it. There aren’t any vets because there aren’t enough vet schools.
- astrodust 3y agoDon't worry, hedge funds will snap up those as soon as they realize the potential they've created.
- qaq 3y agoIt’s not just vets it’s plumbing, hvac, medical practices. Small PE funds consolidate a few small ones then sell to a bigger PE fund which consolidates a bunch of those and so on
- jcomis 3y agoYeah, it's wild. The guy who fixed my garage door recently told me he sold his small time, but well rated garage door repair company to a PE firm. They also bought all his rivals. I had gotten a few quotes and everyone wanted to do a full replacement for several thousand, insisting it was all junk. He fixed it in 20 minutes for $80 and was firm that everything was absolutely in great shape except for the small problem he fixed. The back end of all these companies is the same, some call center/scheduler that manages everything very cheap. They run the purchased companies as fronts and jack the prices and push for big replacement/upgrades until reviews dip. Then they dissolve the company into a generic regional company and sell that to a national like servicepro.
- slimsag 3y agoRegarding several thousands for a replacement.. to be fair, garage doors are probably one of, if not the most, dangerous part of a home to work on
- ceejayoz 3y agoSure, but that's if it needs a replacement. OP didn't. I had the same happen with a toilet; the float needed replacement, but the big plumbing firm claimed it'd be better to replace the whole toilet. Toilet was fine.
- YeBanKo 3y agoWhat area are you in? I need his contact info if he is still in business.
- nitwit005 3y agoAnd then they go broke and people wonder why there is no toy store anymore.
- jmyeet 3y agoThis is capitalism working as intended. It's no an aberration. It's not a few bad apples. This is quite literally what capitalism is: it's building an enclosure and then jacking up the price. It's rent-seeking. It's regulatory capture. Private equity is infecting every aspect of your life and the tactics are the same: 1. Cut costs; 2. Jack up the prices; 3. Block competition by buying them up, legislation/regulation, etc; and 4. Loading the entity up with debt and cash out before it explodes. No value is being created or added. It's pure wealth extraction. Some cases are essentially state violence (eg buying up mobile home parks). Others are just downright immoral, like exploiting the love people have for their pets here.
- sMarsIntruder 3y agoso what’s the alternative to the free market?
- cess11 3y agoIt's not a free market. Capitalism is about capital accumulation, not fair markets in some sense.
- kibwen 3y agoYou can have free markets without having an aristocracy.
- mr_toad 3y agoYou can’t have free markets if you use Motte and Bailey arguments to justify rejecting all forms of free markets, instead of just market failures.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- demondemidi 3y agoyou think the free market EVER existed? oh you sweet summer child. it has been owned and run by the ultra wealthy since day one. there is no "fair" with the free market, because not everything is equal. education, defense, banking, healthcare are not meant to turn a profit, but here we are.
- fumar 3y agoIs there a PE alternative for small business owners or sectors looking towards PE as the solution? How can doctors or vets or other similarly time bound practitioners gain access to businesses acumen for long term success?
- nradov 3y agoThey can take business, finance, and accounting courses at the local community college. But most young physicians and veterinarians no longer want to devote their entire lives to running a small business. The hassles of dealing with paperwork and regulatory compliance have gotten worse every year. Those professionals would rather gain some semblance of work/life balance by becoming employees instead of owners. Doctors and vets who own their own practices have always been prime targets for scammers because they typically have both a lot of cash flow and a lack of financial sense. In many cases when they get cheated they're too ashamed to even report crimes to law enforcement. I am aware of several cases where trusted office employees were embezzling large sums and got away with it for years due to lack of basic accounting controls.
- riahi 3y agoI’ll actually push back against this narrative. A large problem is that people are coming out with insurmountable debt burdens from professional school and are simply unable to balance that and the start up costs of a new practice. Combine that with states having adopted certificate of need requirements since the late 1980s, it is literally illegal for some doctors to even try to open their own practice. In my state, I legally cannot open a radiology imaging center without spending thousands of dollars on a petition to the department of community health begging “please approve my imaging center” which then is posted publicly on a tracker website where in-house counsel for every single health system / competitor can sue to block you from ever opening. They can also sue to block you from upgrading your equipment when it’s long out of date. It’s untenable. While I agree there are many problems with poor financial savvy amongst highly trained professionals, I also realize that the average debt burden is over 250k and practice start up costs are not getting cheaper. A PET or MR or CT could easily cost 500k-1million alone, without including real estate costs, building/renovation costs, or bribes/legal fees battling for the right to open your doors.
- classichasclass 3y agoMy late father (small animal vet) got approached by VCA and Banfield multiple times to sell out, but he was pretty sure he wouldn't make the same amount and he liked having his own full scope practice. He was the minority even then.
- fprog 3y agoThe hospital system near my hometown just announced they are filing for bankruptcy. The parent company that bought it, which itself is owned by private equity, extracted nearly a billion dollars in profit from hospitals before going bankrupt, according to local reporting. I don’t know what the solution is, but PE is a parasitic blight on society.
- xyst 3y agoSimple - healthcare shouldn’t be treated as a business. Flipping profit on people’s illness is absolutely insane.
- renewiltord 3y agoMost hospitals are actually non-profits so in general you have what you want.
- rurp 3y agoNo, GP said that hospitals should not be run as a busniess. Non-profit status is just another way to structure a business and, in practice, those hospitals extract a similar amount of money from patients as similar for-profit hospitals.
- briffle 3y agoMy local 'non-profit' hospital is one of the most expensive in the state, and has a total monopoly over its area. It paid cash for a $140m new tower right as covid started, and complained loudly about losing $13m one year and having to lay off staff, and not having money to pay nurses more, while sitting on a $1B 'rainy day fund'.
- jcomis 3y agoMy vet got bought by private equity and it's turned to absolute shit. Now they basically won't approve any outside prescriptions. Have to buy heart worm, tick pills, etc through them. They are around 2.5x the cost of online pet pharmacies like chewy and allivet. They say they approve all outside vendors, but always twist it into buying from them or setting up an appointment to verify a bunch of stuff to get the approval.
- neilv 3y ago> In 2020 the company was acquired by JAB Consumer Partners, a global private equity firm based in Luxembourg. How much of the toxic private equity firms and investors are outside the US? I'm thinking, considering how destructive private equity is to US institutions, non-US involvement could help it be seen as a national security issue.
- CryptoBanker 3y agoSo what is domestic involvement then? Treason?
- jareklupinski 3y ago"light" treason
- anovikov 3y agoI bet the reason is that it's hard to become a vet and labor mobility is limited. We need to make it impossible for the government to regulate many things (not "remove regulation", but make it physically impossible in the future even if they wanted to). Maybe airlines need to step in to facilitate travel from many places to intentionally created hubs for certain kinds of cervices and Canada and Mexico: if someone can take a $400 ticket to a "city of dentists" or "city of vets" offshore where there are thousands of practices and fix their teeth for 5% of US price, there won't be a market for this kind of price gouging. Or in fact, make it actual offshore. On converted container ships outside the territorial waters. Where regulation just does not apply.
- tomrod 3y agoI don't follow your line of thought.
- anovikov 3y agoPrivate equity isn't a problem, regulations that enable it are. As long as there is a potential to reintroduce it, they will be empowered because no one will build a business that can become illegal or unprofitable by decree - no one except someone with the most money because these will figure the way out at best (because people still need vets let's say), or because they will drive regulation, at worst. Only something that clearly puts the service provision outside of government's reach, will fix it.
- cwalv 3y agoThe real gouging is in emergency clinics. They're board certified specialists, and/or you need the service now. $400 plane tickets won't help.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoI was thinking just last night that it feels as if we have easily eclipsed the grand rapacious greed that Wall Street made iconic of the 80's, and yet we're still accelerating in that direction, with very few signs of awareness of the situation from governments (as the only entity reasonably able to reign it in). If members of governments are profiting, and therefore incredibly unlikely to propose anything resembling a brake, what hope is there beyond "Viva la ...", which is very much an "it'll get much worse before it gets better" kind of resolution.
- tdb7893 3y agoDon't forget we are also cooking the planet and destroying biodiversity while we are at it. Greed is destroying many things we can never get back, it's made me not want to work for tech companies anymore as they are fairly emblematic of the problem
- demondemidi 3y agoHopefully this will change when most of this audience is older, but I recently started dealing with aging sick parents, and I've seen first hand what P.E. has done to skilled nursing facilities and convalescence homes. Because the same thing is happening as with vets. It's abhorrent and there is no choice if you aren't rich. People on medicare get a whopping total of 100 days of nursing care (that's it!) and have to pick from an approved list, but after the 100 days are over they have to pay out of pocket. Once they spend all their assets (with a 5 year lookback in case you try to hide them), they qualify for title 19 and the government pays everything but your choices are even slimmer. P.E. squeezes EVERY last dime for profit. Places that were nice 30 years ago when my grandparents were dying are now abysmal: dirty walls, broken beds, broken furniture, broken heaters & A/C, broken televisions, crazy roommates... it's heart-wrenching watching a sick parent try to buck up so you don't see how disappointed they are that they're basically stuck in a human kennel until they recover or die. U.S. healthcare for the non-rich elderly is a nightmare.
- SoftTalker 3y agoEvery aspect of elder care is a rigged game to separate people from their wealth before they die. Everything. Think long-term-care insurance will save you? Think again, it's a con too. They'll find a reason not to pay and they will drag their feet through the legal process if you try to sue them. Avoid it all, nobody gets out of life alive.
- demondemidi 3y agoAvoid it all? Like, just get sick and die? huh?
- SoftTalker 3y agoWell, yeah. That's how it goes for most of us, regardless. I'd rather die at home in my own bed than rot in a nursing home for an extra few years.
- shiroiushi 3y ago>U.S. healthcare for the non-rich elderly is a nightmare. It seems like just living in the US is a nightmare for those who aren't rich.
- xyst 3y agoPrivate equity is the equivalent of “pay day loans” for businesses. Instead of predatory or illegal rates, it’s a ticking time bomb in the form of increased sales pressure and profit driven culture. Often times PE gets these companies to take out massive amounts of debt. In some of these cases the debt is owned by some subsidiary of the PE.
- uptownfunk 3y agoWhy are you being downvoted? Firms regularly to saddle up the portco with debt and then completely gut and reorg the business and flip it up, that’s the model
- enumjorge 3y agoSomething similar is happening in the dental world in the US. Private equity companies are buying up individual practices, and with the sky-high loans required to go to dental school, it's becoming very difficult for new dentists to go into private practice. That means that when a dentist retires there's increasingly fewer individual dentists willing to buy the practice and they end up going to private equity. I truly believe this will result in poorer quality of care, and it's sad to see where we're headed, but I don't know if anything can be done.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoThen we'll be talking our pets to Mexico too now.
- paulcole 3y ago> it's becoming very difficult for new dentists to go into private practice I work with a lot of dentists and this is somewhat untrue. It’s challenging to open a practice and isn’t for everyone, but dentist offices rarely “fail” and a loan to open a dental office is up there with the easiest loans to get. I do agree that over time dental groups (either owned by PE or dentists) will become more common.
- mike_d 3y agoVision as well. Luxottica manufactures and wholesales 25% of all sunglasses and prescription frames in the world (Oakley, Ray Ban, Chanel, Coach, etc). They own the second largest vision insurance company. 20% of US and 10% of worldwide retail sales are in one of their 9,100 stores: LensCrafters, Pearle Vision, Target Optical, Sunglass Hut, Glasses.com, etc. If you decide to go to a local independent optometrist, they also own the two largest equipment manufactures.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe 20/10% numbers predate their merger with Essilor, it's even worse now. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luxottica#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luxottica#Criticism I dread the day they buy Zenni and take my $25 glasses away.
- fsn4dN69ey 3y agoDisclaimer: My partner works as a small animal surgeon, and I'm honestly appalled by seeing some of the comments asking for more government intervention in here. Private equity scooping up veterinary practices makes sense - it's a good investment. It's the same way PE firms will pool together a bunch of discrete dentist offices. I see many posters in here talking about how it's "rent-seeking" behavior, but frankly, these services are in demand and consolidating them is an increase in market efficiency. It's still good business to open up new clinics, even if the end goal is getting bought out (the standard practice for 95%+ of companies for which everyone here works for or is the beneficiary of). If people are willing to spend more, then nothing really changed. If anything, goods and services were mispriced beforehand. If they raise the prices too high, nobody can afford the vet services and they will go out of business. If they make prices too low, we end up in a UK-style NHS situation where your dog's cancer is in line to get treated 8 months after they die, and they go out of business. Prices going up is natural for a restricted supply of extremely skilled labor (yes, you still need surgeons, anesthesiologists, nurses, drugs, human-tier equipment) and growing demand for the services (people having more pets in lieu of children in western countries). People were getting "better deals" before and are now being priced appropriately. A big trend here is the increase in desire to spend on pets, particularly in the US, the richest country in the world. Yes, consolidation is one part of it, but we have to look at demographic trends as well. More and more people are spending more and more money on pets (in lieu of children). And yet, the increase in supply of skilled veterinarians has not increased nearly as much. Obviously, investment firms need their cut, but prices go up while owned by an investment firm does not make it evil, nor does it not make sense or outrageous. What might actually be considered outrageous around here is spending $20k on surgery for a domestic pet (common occurence as far as I can tell in a metropolitan area). Lastly - there's actually a competitive healthcare market here! I have enjoyed being able to peek behind the curtain and look at what procedures of this scale should really cost, e.g. we still need the same training, people, equipment, and time relative to human medicine (arguably with a much lower tolerance of risk), but the prices are...... reasonable. $10-20k for a crazy surgery would be highly affordable for a human, and these PE firms are actually competing with each other for clients for these expensive procedures. It makes me wish for a similar competitive pricing landscape for humans - even if they are PE owned. The last thing anyone needs when caring for their pet is a government bureaucrat handing out human-medicine style hospital monopolies to a "partnered provider" knighted by the government which will force a 100x billing charge to bill the govt and make it illegal to not have pet insurance while driving your premiums up 100x over the next 30 years.
- Fricken 3y agoLast fall I bought a bicycle from the Kona bicycle company. I found out a week ago that Kona hed been bought by private equity in 2022 at peak pandemic bike shortage and is now being sold off for parts. It seems everywhere I turn these days I encounter some other perfectly viable, useful business getting ruinated by private equity.
- siliconc0w 3y agoPE are basically black hat engineers that exploit unpatched vulnerabilities in our societal systems. You shouldn't be any up buy up all the competition in an area but nothing stops you. You shouldn't be able to buy a company, lever it, loot it, and leave it to die but again nothing stops you. Even if legislation happens, which it won't, it's far too slow to stop them.
- tdb7893 3y agoThis is what happens when someone has total control over an organization, they use it for purely their own benefit. This is why I would prefer more diffuse power structures for organizations in general.
- wahnfrieden 3y agocapitalism isn't sick and in need of remediation to restore itself to its proper path. this is how it goes
- nojvek 3y agoP/E are the new hedgefunds. Private, not much regulation and then can load up the companies they buy on massive amount of debt and juice. One single game - who can make the number go up the fastest. People be damned
- ta988 3y agoOur local vet is now one of those, and it is a disaster. The vets they hire are bad both with the animals and the owners, service is sub standard and they jacked the price by over 50%, the rooms aren't cleaned properly and they try to push you to buy their pseudo "insurance" that would reduce the cost (and is in reality owned by the same company). My understanding is that the previous owner has been disallowed to open nearby when he sold.
- wnevets 3y agoThe parrels between what private equity is doing to this country and companies that buy popular extensions then "monetize" them are uncanny [1] [1] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/01/malware-vendors-buy-chrome-extensions-to-send-adware-filled-updates/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/01/malwa...
- legitster 3y agoThere's really not an alternative to this problem. Private equity is gobbling up these practices because there is no one else who is going to take them over. Owners are retiring at an astonishing rate. But young professionals don't have the money to buy up the practices, that is assuming any business acumen they might have had would not have been weeded out by schooling. And even if they did - there's no reason to buy an established practice off of a retiring owner when you can just grow your own (granted there is a buyer for you at the end of it). There's also the tax aspect. Even if you wanted to gift your business to your family/employees, you would be immediately loading them with a massive tax burden for an asset they don't immediately get to benefit from. (Linus of LTT fame actually does a good job describing this problem: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Faa-b2uq0gA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Faa-b2uq0gA) The same thing is happening everywhere - family medical, law firms, mechanics, and even farms.
- dang 3y agoRelated: As private equity dominates wheelchair market, users wait months for repairs - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40250056 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40250056 - May 2024 (314 comments) The fishy death of Red Lobster - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40233029 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40233029 - May 2024 (379 comments) Private Equity Is Gutting America – and Getting Away with It - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39223209 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39223209 - Feb 2024 (11 comments) Hospitals owned by private equity are harming patients, reports find - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39036526 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39036526 - Jan 2024 (66 comments) Private equity piling on debt like never before - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38962454 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38962454 - Jan 2024 (68 comments) Quality of care declines after private equity takes over hospitals - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38773426 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38773426 - Dec 2023 (163 comments) 44% of All Single-Family Home Purchases Were by Private Equity Firms in 2023 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38522937 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38522937 - Dec 2023 (25 comments) Private equity is devouring the U.S. economy - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38069197 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38069197 - Oct 2023 (506 comments) Private equity: A fee too far [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37072374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37072374 - Aug 2023 (47 comments) Who employs your doctor? Increasingly, a private equity firm - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36747572 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36747572 - July 2023 (401 comments) Private equity is buying everything from vet offices to tech conglomerates - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36313967 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36313967 - June 2023 (349 comments) Private Equity Is Now Dominating the US Hospice System - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36108182 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36108182 - May 2023 (243 comments) Why does private equity get to play make-believe with prices? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34292166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34292166 - Jan 2023 (33 comments) When private equity takes over a nursing home - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32597326 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32597326 - Aug 2022 (89 comments) Entire telecomm infrastructure of Iceland sold to private equity? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32143631 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32143631 - July 2022 (113 comments) Private equity may be heading for a fall - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32013295 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32013295 - July 2022 (177 comments) Private equity groups that buy companies they own - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31822914 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31822914 - June 2022 (62 comments) FTC acts against private equity firm’s acquisition of veterinary clinics - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31728350 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31728350 - June 2022 (279 comments) I lost count at that point.
- eitally 3y agoMy brother-in-law is a veterinarian who primarily practices in Virginia but is licensed to practice in Colorado, Wyoming and California, too. He spent the first 10 years or so of his career as an emergency vet, first with full-time employment at a clinic and then increasingly picking up relief shifts at a set of clinics around the region (and occasionally even out of state). Here are a few facts: * Relief vets can charge $250-325/hr for a 12hr shift, plus a percentage of their production (= revenue share), often 20-25%. This means a single relief shift can net an experienced vet upwards of $3000. * Frequently, clinics will pay travel expenses for relief vets if they can't find any local. * Just like the AMA, the VMA restricts the number of new vets in the pipeline, so there's a scarcity of skilled labor. * It used to be that vets got paid about the same as independent family practitioners -- in the $150-200k/yr range * The rise of veterinary insurance is what is primarily responsible for the dramatically increased charge rates in veterinary medicine. Since an insurer will pay, vets can charge. This has had the effect of turning what was a $2000 surgery into a $8000 surgery, or a $75 vaccination into a $250 vaccination. * Private Equity and corporatization (e.g. Banfield, Petco) have been ruining things for independent vets and also pet owners. Yes, you sometimes get the convenience efficiencies of a corporate service with plug & play employees, but everything else goes downhill. The effects mirror what the human healthcare industry has been experiencing. * Startup costs for a new clinic can be as low as about $400k once you have the office lease. Lots of the equipment is leased to clinics so the capital expense to get running is pretty low and the costs are easy to amortize over time through operational cashflow. * Lots of vets -- my brother-in-law included -- have said "to hell with this" and started concierge services. It's pretty easy to make a good living with VERY low stress if you only have 40-50 subscribing clients, and the hassle and headache is lightyears lower than working for a clinic (especially a corporate clinic). * Board certified vets get paid the same as people doctors, especially in specialities (ophthalmology, dermatology, neurology, etc). $300-600k/yr depending on region, and that's just the base salary. * A well-run veterinary clinic in a mid-sized city that has 2-3 vets on duty at any given time can easily gross >$100k in a weekend. It's not unusual for my bro-in-law to drive $25k production during a single relief shift, and that's completely above board, high quality medical work using established price lists -- not any kind of gouging. The ones making bank are the clinic owners, and until very recently (convenient carve out to appease private equity -- boo!) there was a requirement (just like dental offices) that clinic had to be owned by DVMs. Now that this isn't true, you've seen massive buyouts and franchise growth driven by both corporate interests and PE. We as consumers are suffering for it.
- Tollen 3y ago[dead]