16 ms·
Google threatens to cut off news after California proposes paying media outlets
- baggy_trough 3y agoA tax on linking is absurd and would be deeply harmful.
- umvi 3y agoTax on linking = less linking. The whole thing smells like wealth distribution ("hmm, the journalism industry is struggling, but the tech industry is booming. The tech industry interacts with the journalism industry, maybe we can help the journalism industry by mandating a new wealth gradient flowing from one to support the other?")
- paxys 3y agoLaws like these help the top media conglomerates (who are the ones lobbying for them), not the journalism industry at large.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoI’m very pro capitalism but I do think redistribution makes sense in the context of giant corporations that are effectively immune to competition. Why do you think Google and Amazon and others can create entire products that never make a profit for years and then unceremoniously shut them down or reduce their investments in them? Everyone else has to try to survive based on their merits and actually make money. Platform owners can be very abusive because those dependent on the platform can have no choice and no voice to speak up. We see this everywhere - whether it is Amazon’s abuse of third party sellers or Google’s abuse of content creators (including news) or Apple’s abuse of app developers. We don’t need to craft a bunch of very targeted laws to reign this in - we just need to split them up and tax any company with market cap above $500B heavily.
- warkdarrior 3y ago> Why do you think Google and Amazon and others can create entire products that never make a profit for years and then unceremoniously shut them down or reduce their investments in them? It seems like Google and Amazon shutting down or divesting some products would make room for a lot of competitors to step in and dominate that space.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoMaybe, but a lot of the would-be companies often get starved of revenue and die before the big companies exit. Until then, the big companies are often giving things away for free, or at a loss, or bundling them in an anti-competitive way (see MS Teams). That doesn't leave much room for a startup to survive.
- ratsmack 3y agoThere is no love lost between me and Google, but then I have zero regard for "news" organizations that are attempting to strong-arm funds from Google for their failing business model.
- jeffbee 3y ago100%. I can't think of a less empathetic beneficiary of this bill than Chatham Asset Management and the other vulture firms that are overseeing the destruction of the news business.
- mc32 3y agoI agree with this sentiment 100%. They've (diff news orgs and gov'ts) tried this tactic elsewhere and they have failed, but there still are folks who think if they try again, this time they will be lucky or they can find a sympathetic ear in the gov't to do the dirty work for them.
- LegitShady 3y agois it news orgs or governments? News orgs can't enact taxes without co-opting governments to pass laws. But I agree these link taxes are a fundamentally broken concept where legacy media looks to strongarm funds out of others for sharing their publicly shared news.
- maronato 3y agoIt’s news orgs through lobbying
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hakdbha 3y ago[dead]
- blitzar 3y ago"We have long said that this is the wrong approach to supporting journalism." I have long said that google takes the wrong approach to supporting lots of things; but the execs just tell me to f'off and jump into their pool filled with $100 bills.
- yuliyp 3y agoI think that comment is just an allusion to their fights with Australia and Canada over doing the same thing.
- kemayo 3y agoI agree with Google on this one. Charging a fee just for linking to something is a bad idea. It does get fuzzier if you're also summarizing, and there's clearly some sort of spectrum from "just the URL" to "AI synopsis of the entire article". But at the level we see on Google News (headline + maybe a picture), I don't feel there's any good justification for charging.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- flavius29663 3y ago> Charging a fee just for linking to something is a bad idea. If you're profiting from it, it's not a bad idea.
- CalRobert 3y agoIf I run a newsletter that links to interesting properties for sale, should I be charged a fee for this?
- timothyduong 3y agoMaybe if your newsletter gets billions of subscribers and you’re making stacks from it, according to news outlets, yes
- bko 3y agoAren’t you providing marketing to the newspaper? Isn’t that what these news agencies pay google billions for? There’s a whole industry (seo) designed around getting your site linked. This looks like a money grab to me. What am I missing?
- Zak 3y agoWhy? What moral or legal principle entitles someone to compensation for linking to their website whether or not you're profiting from that? It's a different question when there's an excerpt or machine-generated summary. In that case, copyright applies, and in most jurisdictions it may or may not be fair use depending on what is copied and how it is presented.
- darby_eight 3y agoI'm actually ok with this given that google is the source of the internet's dependency on advertisements as its sole method of reliable income for non-subscribers. They are more than welcome to reintroduce less destructive methods of transacting over content.
- topspin 3y ago> given that google is the source of the internet's dependency on advertisements I remember the internet before Google. There were lots of ads. It was great watching animated GIF ads load at 56 Kbps. There were pop-up adds and crazy obnoxious flashing ads and NSFW ads. Google didn't create all of that: the ad-sphere was alive and kicking long before anyone heard of Google.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoYes there were obnoxious ads that popped up, but we didn’t have the same degree of monopolization in platforms or walled gardens, and we didn’t have so many industries whose existence depends on online advertising. Google and Facebook’s ads may not be as obnoxious but there’s more of them (look at how many ads there are on search results page) and they’ve affected the viability of many other parts of the economy in my opinion.
- darby_eight 3y ago> Google didn't create all of that: the ad-sphere was alive and kicking long before anyone heard of Google. I never said they did. Hell, print publications were nearly as bad as the internet has become—marketing is simply a large societal problem we have no solution for. I still place the blame for lack of other funding models squarely on them—any other funding model would have undercut their entire existence, and no other company has had such a profound impact on the web (particularly with the demise of netscape).
- pessimizer 3y ago> Google didn't create all of that No, they bought it in the form of Doubleclick, and its profits supported the rest of their money-losing business. If buying Doubleclick doesn't make you responsible for Doubleclick, I don't know what does. People wouldn't tolerate the level of online ad blight we had 20 years ago, there are ad-blockers now; the reason Google isn't going buckwild with ads is because it can't.
- pompino 3y agoGoogle penalizes link-farms, and websites who copy content from others, but adopts a holier-than-thou attitude for itself. Not very surprising. There is no inherent "legitimacy" when Google (as the worlds largest spyware vendor) does it.
- kemayo 3y agoThat seems unrelated to the issue? I don't think those link-farms should have to pay to link to things either...
- pompino 3y agoYes, but those link-farms get de-ranked by Google (which is a good thing IMO). Google is pretending that their particular case of linking is legitimate and deserves fair-use protection.
- kemayo 3y agoI don't think Google is pretending. Its linking is legitimate. Also, it feels strange to draw an equivalence between Google downranking a spam website and the government charging to link to things.
- netaustin 3y agoI work in news technology, including with many local news organizations, both corporate and independent, including in California. Google does not support all news organizations equally, and this seems designed to gain some leverage over organizations that do get a lot from Google. Their Google News Initiative is on its surface just a training platform for publishers to learn how to use Google’s tools but they’ve done quite a bit more for some publishers. This feels like an attempt to gain the vocal support of publishers who have been blessed by Google’s beneficence, many of which are earnest non-profit organizations who might take the bait about big bad hedge funds. I don’t know how they select who to help and who to ignore and our attempts to engage with them on behalf of publishers have had mixed results. But publishers’ collective frustration with Google is quite high. Given the implications that “it would be a shame if something happened to your nice journalism website” coupled with the appeal against the big bad hedge funds and ghost papers, it’s sort of a clever position but I’m not sure it will work.
- arp242 3y agoText of the bill: https://legiscan.com/CA/text/AB886/id/2832517 https://legiscan.com/CA/text/AB886/id/2832517
- jaredwiener 3y agoThis requires some nuance, since I think it goes beyond a "tax on linking," as I have seen it described. News is a strange product, and one that I think a lot of people in tech get wrong. The atomic unit of journalism is not an article....it's the reporting. Even deciding to write an article is an act based on the analysis of the reporting. Further, a good headline often tells the story itself -- and that is implicitly included when we talk about links. How often have you read a headline, and then not clicked on the link? Probably a bunch. But you still know OJ died, or the bridge in Baltimore collapsed, etc, etc. That level of reporting, the confirmation that it happened, all that stuff -- all was expensive, all required labor and other resources. So -- from the consumer perspective, what happens? You get clickbait. The publishers have to recoup the expenses somehow, and they need you to click through to show you ads, or a paywall. "This item in your cabinet could kill you!" Or, they cover the site with ads, hoping to get as much out of the few clicks they get. I am not saying this in support of the CJPA, nor in support of Google. Just saying this is an existential crisis that came from the simple act of aggregation. (Disclaimer/shameless plug: I'm a former journalist building https://www.forth.news https://www.forth.news, a social-media like news feed for reading news. While we are not there yet, our goal is to be able to revshare with the reporters/newsrooms who write the stories to be able to monetize those headlines.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jaredwiener 3y agoNo idea why this is getting downvoted, but would love to hear what people think is wrong.
- diego_sandoval 3y agoIt's true, journalism is a tough business, but that doesn't justify bending the rules in their favor. Just like Open Source is though: you do all the work, companies make money off of your work without paying a dime 95% of the time, etc. Would that justify a law forcing companies to pay for the open source software they use? No. In the end, people choose to do open source knowing that they're not going to get much money out of it.
- dang 3y agoThe Google post is at https://blog.google/products/news/california-journalism-preservation-act-puts-news-ecosystem-at-risk/ https://blog.google/products/news/california-journalism-pres... (via https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40015355 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40015355, but I merged that thread hither since this article has more background). Also: California Assembly votes to pass the Journalism Preservation Act - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36165322 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36165322 - June 2023 (99 comments) Facebook and Instagram owner Meta threatens to cut off news in California - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36148877 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36148877 - June 2023 (27 comments) Can the Journalism Competition and Preservation Act preserve local journalism? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27943976 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27943976 - July 2021 (1 comment)
- skynetv2 3y agoThis is just another non-sensical law that allows the dying news publishers to shakedown other successful companies. News publishers have to evolve. NYT did a wonderful turnaround, as an example.
- setgree 3y agoThis threat is credible: Google shut off Spain's access to Google News for eight years for similar reasons [0]. [0] https://www.reuters.com/technology/google-news-re-opens-spain-after-eight-year-shutdown-2022-06-22/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/google-news-re-opens-spai...
- LegitShady 3y agoMeanwhile in Canada... https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/29/google-canada-online-news-act-agreement-publishers https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/29/google-ca... Although facebook/insta did refuse to be blackmailed, and many canadian news orgs are actually harmed by this sort of bullshit link taxing because their media can't be shared on facebook anymore, where a lot of older news watchers get their news https://about.fb.com/news/2023/06/changes-to-news-availability-on-our-platforms-in-canada/ https://about.fb.com/news/2023/06/changes-to-news-availabili...
- r00fus 3y agoSo essentially Canada gets to subsidize news outlets by having Google pay for them as a yearly subscription. No link tax, just a tax for news. Sounds... reasonable?
- jeffbee 3y agoGoogle and Meta had each been funding journalism — actual journalism, not vulture capital clickbait — voluntarily, which they are now not. Google is now paying $100m, most of which goes to huge corporations. Meta pulled out altogether, slashing traffic to canadian media sites by half.
- brevitea 3y agoHow were Meta and Google funding "actual" journalism vs. clickbait? Do you have any sources on that?
- 3y ago
- _ea1k 3y agoIIRC, Bard was limited in Canada due to some similar provisions? I wonder if this will have impact on their LLM access in California as well.
- diego_sandoval 3y agoCopyright laws are already strict enough in favor of the rights holders. Don't we all agree on that? Bills like this are like copyright law on steroids, making copyright holders even more powerful than they already are.
- pessimizer 3y agoEventually, of course, it will "only be fair" that we should pay a tax to speak about the news at all, to anyone. Or at least to submit what we plan to say about the news to the approval committee. Cass Sunstein is a pioneer.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoJournalism will cease to exist if everyone just reads the aggregator summaries instead of clicking the link and at least giving the news org some ad revenue. The reality is that the government has to do something if we want a free press to continue as vanishingly few are willing to pay anything. I dont think this is the best solution but Im not sure its worse than the status quo of "no one in journalism except NYT makes any money"
- duringmath 3y agoPrivate equity firms are buying up local news outfits then lobby to force google/fb to pay up. It's an extortion racket which news outlets refuse to cover for some reason.
- paxys 3y agoPeople were predicting this would happen when Google caved and started paying "link tax" to Australia and Canada and other jurisdictions with similar laws. Now – to no surprise – every government (really every media conglomerate lobbying arm) around the world wants the free money and so more such laws are popping up.
- tomComb 3y agoDunno about Australia but Google ‘won’ in Canada, where the government agreed to accept what Google had originally offered, and make it up to their corporate media buddies in the following budget.
- paxys 3y agoIt ended with a negotiation and Google agreeing to pay $100M+ annually to Canadian news organizations, so I wouldn't exactly call that a "win" for them.
- Aerroon 3y agoIt might be a win for Google. >Oh, you posted this story we really didn't like. Sorry, this month's check got lost in the mail. We'll sort it out in 6-15 business days. Businesses eventually become reliant on significant revenue streams which gives the party that provides them power over the business. It might not even be Google doing anything nefarious, just a case of "sorry, but our business is doing poorly and we might have to shut down Google News and stop paying if this keeps up."
- AnotherGoodName 3y agoIn Australia there were concessions where the Australian gov of the time thought that having Google negotiate an agreement only with the major outlets (Rupert Murdoch) was acceptable so they don't pay every paper, just the ones that agree with the Liberal party (a right wing party) viewpoints. The liberal party is now out of power but the labor party has no courage to stand up to Murdoch to repeal this. It was all very clever and basically a way to fund right wing media in Australia via big tech. Blatantly corrupt as fuck and people need to be arrested for what went on to create this law but definitely clever.
- johnea 3y agoIf you're using goggle as your news source, you're already assimilated... I'd be happy if the entire goggle corps left California: take my monopoly, please...
- standardUser 3y agoI would hope most consumers of news understand the difference between a source and an aggregator.
- kube-system 3y agoI don't think most consumers of news content really think about the difference between a source, a syndicate, or an aggregator. And a significant portion likely don't know the difference. Media literacy is a significant problem, both in the US and in many parts of the world.
- M4rkJW 3y ago"It’s well known that people are getting news from sources like short-form video, topical newsletters, social media, and curated podcasts, and many are avoiding the news entirely. In line with those trends, just 2% of queries on Google Search are news-related. Nevertheless, we want to continue making targeted contributions to the news ecosystem to help news publishers navigate this inflection point." Google acknowledges they had a part to play in causing the collapse of journalism but has no solutions to offer. People aren't consuming news, and when they do they choose the least accurate, most entertaining sources for it. Newspapers and local broadcasters are suffering because the public has lost the will or the capacity to focus. When will we start seeing white box Surgeon General warnings on Tiktok and Youtube that remind the user prolonged exposure can cause serious mental health issues? [1] Where's the DARE school-visit campaigns to remind kids that broadcast news is free over the air and their parents are chumps for paying streaming services' subscription fees? [1]: https://www.hhs.gov/about/news/2023/05/23/surgeon-general-issues-new-advisory-about-effects-social-media-use-has-youth-mental-health.html https://www.hhs.gov/about/news/2023/05/23/surgeon-general-is...
- Analemma_ 3y ago> When will we start seeing white box Surgeon General warnings on Tiktok and Youtube that remind the user prolonged exposure can cause serious mental health issues? We won't (or if we do they won't accomplish anything), because once you've moved to a low-trust society, which we are rapidly doing, any official statements telling you which information to consume/avoid are seen as Enemy Action and make you trust your outside sources even harder. You can find tons of Zoomers saying they get news from Tiktok specifically because it's not under the control of The Man (even though it's controlled by the Chinese government, the ultimate The Man). There are no easy fixes here.
- paxys 3y agoI wonder if these media conglomerates think the same laws should apply to them. If your news article has any linked information in it, you need to pay money to the owner of that link every time your article is opened. Seems only fair.
- wmf 3y agoThey never link out though.
- whycome 3y agoThat's also absurd that modern news sites think they are so trustworthy that they don't even bother to cite or link to the studies or subjects they're talking about. Sometimes it's a bit insane when wikipedia only requires a link to a news site to consider something verified.
- paxys 3y agoThey sometimes do. And even otherwise, most "news" these days is snippets and summarization of existing online content, the exact thing they are complaining about.
- tekla 3y agoCool cut them off.
- schnable 3y agoWhy is this done as a law rather than negotiated by the media outlets?
- wmf 3y agoThey have no leverage to negotiate with.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoIsn’t the issue that Google links to websites and then reduces their commercial viability by showing summaries in search pages or by having their AI present the data without letting the website get the traffic? If so, I think a link tax is justified. At that point, Google is creating value for itself by removing value from others so it seems fair to me. And we don’t need the law to be perfect - let’s just make it applicable to companies with market capitalization above 100 billion. But more than this, the big tech companies are just too powerful and their mere existence is anti competitive. I think that issue needs to be addressed independent of media outlets specifically. For example with AI, big tech companies are in a position to put themselves first in front of customers and prevent any smaller players from competing for users and market share. Now Apple and Microsoft are forcing their AI agents onto phones and computers, and potentially violating privacy of users and using all their data for training or other purposes. We’ve seen such a long history of anti competitive practices from these companies, and rather than dealing with performative court cases that drag out for years, we need to deal with the fact that they’re too big. They need to be split up. Or maybe just get taxed more compared to everyone else.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago> For example with AI, big tech companies are in a position to put themselves first in front of customers and prevent any smaller players from competing for users and market share. This has already been the case for >10 years.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoI agree. But it still has not been fixed or even acknowledged broadly. And with each new successive wave of innovation (like AI), it seems they are able to simply take up all the profits that could exist, without working hard and competing fairly for it.
- wodenokoto 3y agoMy understanding is you have to ask to be in the news wheel. Anyone can ask to be removed from the index. The internet is old enough that it has long been standard that search is opt out, when you are part of the World Wide Web.
- moribvndvs 3y ago[flagged]
- WalterBright 3y agoWith the increasing shift of media companies from reporting the news to selling an ideology, they should be welcoming people linking to it and summarizing their sales pitch. https://www.thefp.com/p/npr-editor-how-npr-lost-americas-trust https://www.thefp.com/p/npr-editor-how-npr-lost-americas-tru...
- philip1209 3y agoThis is a perfect example of Regulatory Capture: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture
- coretx 3y agoAnd Rent-Seeking: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking
- timothyduong 3y agoCatch 22? Let the robots scrape cause you want to be indexed, but at the same time, you don’t want to give the data scraped away for free. I mean realistically, shouldn’t the news outlets just not let those articles be scraped and be done with this debate?
- AJ007 3y agoWell it's more like, we want free traffic and also pay us for the privilege of sending it to us. That isn't happening and it isn't the way traffic works. Pay news organizations for the rights to republish the articles on Google (e.g. Reuters or AP feeds)? That's a business model. It also means the small one off news sites are dead. Once all of the third party cookie stuff dies, meaningful display ad revenue for non-mega publishers (Google, Facebook, Amazon) will evaporate. These news organizations are dead men walking already and the debate is a waste of time at this point.
- catlikesshrimp 3y ago>"These news organizations are dead men walking already" It means we are burdening zombies to create the real news. Who is going to do it after they are gone? Only paid for state propaganda and politico. That Doesn't sound too good. I am all for the unified newspaper membership, where you pay for a membership that pays newspapers for their articles. The problem is how much would that cost to really fund the journalists. They would obviously still need to run ads. But at least that might be a good start.
- shadowgovt 3y agoWhat search has done to news has for decades been the canary in the coalmine for what AI is doing to art now. Because news has weaker copyright protections than original artwork ("can't copyright facts"), Google et. al. have been free this whole time to use news as a data input and pull traffic away from the original sources. The end result is what has happened to the news industry, and we can extrapolate what will happen to commercial art if copyright protections on artworks are discovered to be similarly weak.
- wewtyflakes 3y agoSeems weird that if someone links to a news site, that the news site gets to double-dip advertising revenue, since it gets to advertise on its own site, and also get a cut of the advertising revenue of someone that linked to them. It will either mean everyone will want to classify themselves as news sites, or, people that link to them will no longer want to drive revenue via ads.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoThe issue is that most of the time the link doesnt get clicked on because the aggregators have summarized the content. facebook especially disincentivizes clicking the link.
- shombaboor 3y agoReminds me of this "Report: We Don’t Make Any Money If You Don’t Click The Fucking Link". The aggregators sucked a lot of the juice out from the properties themselves. https://www.theonion.com/report-we-don-t-make-any-money-if-you-don-t-click-the-1823460398 https://www.theonion.com/report-we-don-t-make-any-money-if-y...
- franze 3y agoJust do it!
- tomcar288 3y agowhy can't the news outlets just charge people when they arrive on the site? just paywall it and let people read the article for like 5 cents or something? i know this has been tried and supossedly didn't work. but why not? I would gladly be willing to pay 5 cents to read an article I like but I sure as hell am not going to shell out 250$+ yearly subscription for it (just to read one article), like most news sites do these days.
- paxys 3y agoBecause news organizations are used to double and triple dipping (get revenue from subscriptions, from advertising, and now from incoming links), and when things didn't go their way they are using their enormous lobbying power to force it to be so.
- trogdor 3y agoAs far as I know, there is no good way to process transactions on the order of a few cents. Micropayments are hard.
- hiatus 3y agoThey could take a PACER approach and only charge when you've viewed enough articles.
- sattoshi 3y agoCanada hit Meta with a similar law with the same, predictable result. It’s hard to not be cynical and thinking that the current government wants people to be less informed, as it hurts them in the polling.
- pmontra 3y agoThat's reverse advertising. Instead of paying Google to display links to their sites where everybody looks (Google News) they want to be paid to be where everybody looks. Anyway, Google News has been off in Spain for 8 years. News sites didn't disappear. It reopened in 2022 when the law was changed https://blog.google/products/news/google-news-returns-spain/ https://blog.google/products/news/google-news-returns-spain/
- raggi 3y agoDoes anyone have a source or confirmation that Google is doing what the article says? If I search for journalism bill I get the politico article, and san francisco chronicle in the top stories list.
- raggi 3y agoI see, it's slight and deliberate misrepresentation/under-presentation. Google did talk about it in https://blog.google/products/news/california-journalism-preservation-act-puts-news-ecosystem-at-risk/ https://blog.google/products/news/california-journalism-pres... Specifically: To prepare for possible CJPA implications, we are beginning a short-term test for a small percentage of California users. The testing process involves removing links to California news websites, potentially covered by CJPA, to measure the impact of the legislation on our product experience. Until there’s clarity on California’s regulatory environment, we’re also pausing further investments in the California news ecosystem, including new partnerships through Google News Showcase, our product and licensing program for news organizations, and planned expansions of the Google News Initiative. You could of course say it's tit for tat, as this is also somewhat misrepresentation and misleading.
- whoitwas 3y agoThis sort of legislation makes no sense, shows how out of touch regulators are with tech, and does the opposite of their intent as tech companies simply don't link the content.
- AlbertCory 3y agoThere's an inconvenient fact that Google prefers to ignore: -- Frequently, the headline and snippet is all you need. "Inflation still at 3%" is often enough for a lot of readers. An awful lot of them aren't going to follow the link. Yes, they are trying to preserve a business model that doesn't work, but that doesn't mean they have to provide free services to any and all. If Google just had a link labelled "News on Inflation" the paper would probably be happy. "You can just use robots.txt if you don't want to be crawled" is a canard. You can just not have a website, too.
- dweymouth 3y agoIf you're a news site and you want Google to have a link like "News on Inflation", then just give your article the title "Unpacking the latest inflation data" and save the actual info for the article itself. A lot of internet publishers have already figured this out and it's why you see titles like "These 3 states have the most affordable homes" that just entice you to click on the link.
- AlbertCory 3y agothe problem is, they also want the headline to entice people to buy the paper. Contradictory desires.
- melodyogonna 3y agoI don't understand this. How does Google owe them billions if it doesn't host ads on Google News and instead pushes traffic to publishers?
- javier_e06 3y agoI agree with California. Just like other computer data brokers, Google services benefit from content creators not all the way around. Pay the human content creators.
- kccqzy 3y agoThe human content creators aren't necessarily paid highly. The news business gets paid. They are merely enriching the likes of Murdoch.
- paxys 3y ago"The news media industry is dying because of tech" is a massively successful myth perpetuated by the news media industry. Back in the day before tech platforms there used to be 5 successful news companies and 5 failing ones. Today there are 5 successful news companies and 500 failing ones. Tech reduced the barriers to entry and made the playing field more level, giving rise to smaller publications and indie journalism. But the appetite for news consumption is still the same, so everyone can't be successful. Lobbying and passing rent-seeking laws only helps the conglomerates on the top.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> "The news media industry is dying because of tech" is a massively successful myth perpetuated by the news media industry. Why do you think that's a myth? The news industry was always reliant on advertising for revenue. The tech giants of the Internet era all figured out how to better target advertisements, so a huge amount of that advertising money shifted from news to tech giants (and not just tech "giants" - Craigslist basically killed classified ads, and Craigslist isn't exactly a "giant"). I don't really know if the news media industry is "dying", but of course tech was hugely instrumental in reducing the overall amount of revenue that goes to journalism.
- paxys 3y agoThe news industry is still getting money via ads, same as before. The only thing that has changed is the broker that is connecting them to the advertisers. Print media had its own ad ecosystem, and the online one is controlled by Google and Facebook (but of course the media companies can use whoever they want or even talk to advertisers directly). So what is the complaint exactly? That Google shouldn't take a cut? Except that the law isn't even about advertising, it's about link aggregation (which Google also happens to do, but that is completely separate from its advertising arm).
- PeterisP 3y agoNo, the news industry isn't still getting money same as before - the total ad revenue the industry is getting has significantly decreased. Newspaper ad revenue has simply collapsed (https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/11/28/audiences-are-declining-for-traditional-news-media-in-the-us-with-some-exceptions/sr_23-11-28_sotnm_3/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/11/28/audiences...) and it's not being replaced by digital media as digital ad revenue for news industry (as opposed to total digital ad revenue) is shrinking every year.
- alecnotthompson 3y agoThe problem with everything is capitalism
- tehjoker 3y agoThe US is worried that if even private journalistic entities are strangled to death, then it will have to stand up a national news service like the BBC and won't be immune from the "state sponsored news" label it loves to apply to other countries. However, Google's interest, despite being entangled with the US quite deeply, is to not spend money to save the ecosystem. Most likely, they have their own plan for this eventuality. After all, if they would be single-handedly supporting multiple news companies, why shouldn't it be its own mega-news company and keep the additional revenues?
- zmmmmm 3y agoI have sympathy for news publishers but I worry a lot about the principle of asserting that linking to something is an act that the link target has proprietary rights to over. At some level, it is almost a free speech issue. If I can't refer to what you are saying, without owing you something, you have power over not just my speech, but a power to limit how your work is subjected to criticism and debate. It's effectively an extension of copyright law to expand copyright holder's rights. Obviously all this is hyperbolic based the actual text of the law. The law doesn't directly apply any sort of link tax, and it is shamelessly targeted only at Google and Facebook (to the point that they wrote Facebook in there by name, which is kind of stupid if you ask me). But if you drill into the reasoning it hits at the foundational level on this basic logic, and it's pretty concerning if we assume then that this will be significantly extrapolated and expanded - as has been the history with all other aspects of copyright in the past. Honestly I would rather that governments come clean and just admit that the problem they are trying to solve is actually a "social good" outcome, and therefore directly tax the platforms and then redistribute the revenue to a fund created by government for news journalism themselves. Trying to artificially construct that through introduction of significant new precedents in copyright law engenders huge risks of unintended consequences and potential future extrapolation and abuse of this principle.
- cush 3y agoNobody would be complaining if google was just linking…
- notatoad 3y ago>I have sympathy for news publishers i have very little sympathy for news publishers. I have sympathy for the journalists actually doing journalism, but news publishers have spent the last couple decades making their websites absolutely unusable, so that unless somebody links to an article externally there's almost no point in going to their site directly. And even after you've followed that link it's almost impossible to read an article around the ads, login prompts, and chumboxes. News websites are terrible, and it's their own fault. Giving them more money to do the thing they've spent so long failing at isn't going to solve this problem. >directly tax the platforms and then redistribute the revenue to a fund created by government for news journalism themselves yes. and specifically, make sure the fund is actually funding journalism. a link tax that gets paid out to news sites only incentivizes them to do the bare minimum amount of journalism to still qualify as a news site, and then fill up the rest of the site with SEO clickbait to maximize their clicks for the link tax.
- probably_jesus 3y ago[dead]
- laweijfmvo 3y agoCan’t news outlets just throw up a robots.txt and then charge for access to their sites? unless they’re incapable of producing content people are willing to pay for and actually ~want~ need Google to drive traffic…
- spaceguillotine 3y agoGoogle: We can only exist on the free labor of others at every turn.
- brevitea 3y agoIs Brave or Firefox doing away with news? How about Hacker News? If not, I'm not worried about Google cutting off anything. Google is only illustrating why depending on them for "truth" is a thing of the past. Same for Meta.
- suddenexample 3y agoNews organizations are doing important work and I completely sympathize with them in a world where companies are claiming that they can replace your entire company with an ML model. But I totally agree with the other comments that linking should not be something that you can demand payment for. And I find it equally absurd that they're demanding payment from platforms that funnel users over to them in the first place.
- GabeIsko 3y agoAt the end of the day, it's the section 230 that should really be re-evalutated right? Google and Facebook can promote lies all day long along side reputable journalism, and then deny all legal liability, because it isn't them saying these things! The market won't decide what is true or not, no matter how many taxes and fees you try to impose.
- anotherevan 3y agoJournalism professor Jeff Jarvis has written a lengthy analysis on this. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1HHcDuUW8ca3il1bAc6lzqG_4PTe-O40L/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/1HHcDuUW8ca3il1bAc6lzqG_4PTe...
- baryphonic 3y agoCalifornia's building a paywall and they're making Google pay for it so they can make articles great again.
- cush 3y agoGood. Hopefully other states follow. The headline might as well be, “After Decades of Freebooting Their Content, Google Threatens to Kill News Rather Than Pay Journalists for Their Work” Google is now the modern, lazy business equivalent of a bum asking for free stuff in exchange for “exposure”
- Lucas-YANG 3y agolol
- throwaway5959 3y agoI’m failing to see a downside of them doing that. The news is poisoning people, either left or right.
- alfiedotwtf 3y agoThis same scenario has played out before around the world with either Google or Facebook saying they will pull out, but every time they’re still there. Search seems to be the one service that they won’t shutter
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoIt's like these so-called "tech" companies want people to believe the internet is useless without their "assistance". As if no internet user could ever retrieve news from its source through the internet without using an intermediary website that performs surveillance, data collection and sells ad services. (And makes more money from ads than the news source.) "Without intermediaries, this internet is useless. Cannot find anything. Cancel my subscription!" Yeah, right. The internet is incredibly useful. "Big Tech" is not the internet. It's just a giant leech. Why is "Big Tech" putting the squeeze on news organisations, killing off an essential function of a democratic society. What, are we suposed to stay informed via amateur blogs, Facebook pages and YouTube channels. It cannot kill the news businesss off completely, at least not yet, because it needs news organisations to produce the bait used to lure ad targets to its interstitial websites. In the end "Big Tech" will have to pay. The only question is how much. The "We will cut off the news" negotiating tactics exemplify the total lack of humanity of the people behind the scenes at these intermediaries. That's what happens when someone spends their entire life in front of a computer screen. No doubt these people believe all news is untrustworthy, worthless. No wonder they do not want to pay for it. Without that news product, they would have far less traffic and far less profit. Why else would they continue to intermediate it if it is not worth anything to them. "Big Tech" needs to get into the content business or get out of the way. It's content that www users want. They do not care about some intermediary that has nothing to offer. Using these intermediaries to get content is just a means to end. Not surprising that we are seeing an idea such as "generative AI". Copy content from others and then generate "new" content without having to pay anyone.
- throwaway14356 3y agometadata is more valuable than data
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- matrix87 3y agoWhat's stopping them from just delisting news sites? Doesn't the first amendment protect that?
- pjerem 3y agoI don’t have a lot of sympathy for news outlets methods (at least in my country) but each time I read "$megacorp threatens to cut $service" it infuriates me. Do it, close your service and ftsu, I don’t care if you can’t agree with your partners, that just means your product is not viable. It makes those companies looks like they are so important that the world can’t work without them. Chances are no other company than Google could make a Google news competitor because they would have serious issues with media companies, only Google can do this because they feel like they are invincible. Sorry for the rant I’m really fed up with GAFAMs acting like they are essential public services.
- d1ss0nanz 3y agoThey did the same in Germany a few years ago. Guess what?
- teh_infallible 3y agoI love this quote from the article: “The testing process involves removing links to California news websites, potentially covered by CJPA, to measure the impact of the legislation on our product experience.” If that’s not a veiled threat, I don’t know what is. I read that as, “The testing will demonstrate how screwed your media outlets will be when we delink them.”
- SJC_Hacker 3y agoThe obvious next step is for Google to just buy the media outlets, like Amazon did.
- red_admiral 3y agoMy browser, OS and a few apps at work are all trying to opt me into letting them show me news (and breaking news, news alerts etc.) at times of their choice. It feels like every other time I open edge I'm asked to opt in to news feeds on my new tab page. (Edge is required for company intranet/SSO unless you want to piss people off by "tampering with security measures".) I'd be in favour of charging google, MS etc. enough for news that they stop doing this. If I want to read the news, I can open a tab myself.
- HPsquared 3y agoEditorialised title. Google "threatens" while California "proposes".
- dhfbshfbu4u3 3y agoEnacting antitrust protections for a select group of companies to pursue collective action against a single player seems a tad unconstitutional and anticompetitive. Wouldn’t publishers stand to gain more by locking down their content from third parties and creating their own shared distribution platforms (e.g. search engines, aggregators)? As it stands today, Alphabet and Meta make far more money selling actionable data to advertisers than anything else.
- nayuki 3y agoI watched this fight play out in Canada last year and the result has been a disaster. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_News_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_News_Act First, Google and Facebook both put out articles explaining why the act is harmful and what steps they would take against it. After some months, Google eventually caved and agreed to pay money to Canadian news organizations to keep the ability to link to news content in search results. Facebook, on the other hand, started banning links to all news sites, Canadian or not. But they way they did it is very heavy-handed yet imprecise. Various "soft news" and industry-sponsored sites don't get banned, creating an artificial class divide. I don't think there's a legal requirement for Facebook to pay to display non-Canadian news, but they're banning international news anyway. When browsing the site, the shadow-banning of news for Canadian viewers creates a split-brain syndrome in big international discussion groups, where people outside of Canada can still see certain posts/comments/links but Canadians don't see them. Old posts, even from yourself, are retroactively hidden and you can't even see them, not even with a placeholder. People in Canada, when discussing among each other and not with international peers, work around the news-sharing issues by posting screenshots of the news article or obfuscating the URL so that the text is obvious to a human viewer but not obvious to the machine. Finally, the banning of news links on Facebook sparks continual debate in groups and among friends over big tech, power, money, journalism, and government. It splits opinion down the middle, where some people think big tech companies have too much power and the government was right to force them to pay for journalism, and other people think that linking is a fundamental freedom of speech and that we should never pay or be extorted for the act of referencing content.
- pritp0 3y agoThe law canada passed that was similar, but Google stayed and Meta pulled out - is really killing the smaller independent media who relied upon that.