7 ms·
Why Scientists Are Calling for the Moon to Be Better Protected from Development
- basisword 3y agoWhile I understand their concerns, it seems a bit crazy to think you have any right to tell people what to do or not do on the moon.
- olesya1979 3y ago[dead]
- KyleBerezin 3y agoI too am a libertarian moon-man.
- edgyquant 3y agoIt’s not really a libertarian thing. Society has to balance more than just the wants or concerns of scientists and they have no more right than anyone else to dictate what we do with the moon.
- KyleBerezin 3y agoIts a joke. It sounds like a normal libertarian argument, but on the moon. If you want a more serious answer though, we have multiple treaties and moratoriums on what is, and is not allowed in space and on the moon. They were agreed upon because we have mutual interests, and want to preserve humanities future of spaceflight and research. - https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/treaties/introouterspacetreaty.html https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/treaties/int... - https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/treaties/introliability-convention.html#:~:text=Elaborating%20on%20Article%207%20of,to%20its%20faults%20in%20space https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/treaties/int.... - https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/treaties/introregistration-convention.html https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/treaties/int... - https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/treaties/intromoon-agreement.html https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/treaties/int...
- edgyquant 3y agoTreaties can be updated or even ignored if new economic or technological realities come into play.
- KyleBerezin 3y agoThe impermanence of law is a different discussion. I was just providing you with the precedent that such a rule would likely build off of.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoThese kinds of threads are entertaining to me, to see how various strands of libertarian/techno-capitalist are confronted with explaining how apparently-immutable-and-eternal property rights originate. The ones where they basically admit it comes down to "who has the most guns" are the best.
- nirav72 3y agoAre these treaties binding? I know there can be other repercussions for signatories for violating treaties. But usually there are no clear rules on what the repercussions should be. Also , since signatories are nation-states, not sure how individuals could be held accountable for any violations by the international community. Such as private corporations
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoAdmittedly, it is a slightly better set of reasons than 'because it is sacred[1]'. [1]https://www.cnn.com/2024/01/05/world/peregrine-moon-mission-navajo-nation-objection-human-remains-scn/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2024/01/05/world/peregrine-moon-mission-...
- 23B1 3y ago[flagged]
- erellsworth 3y agoSerious question: What is the difference between telling people what they can and can't do on the moon vs telling people what they can and can't do on vacant land here on earth? If I go out to some remote area in the United States and start building houses, I'll almost certainly get into legal trouble, especially if I don't have any permits and definitely if I don't own the land. Who gets to own the moon? Is it just whoever has the resources to travel there and build stuff? Imagine if Space X decides to carve a portrait of Elon Musk into the face of the moon at a scale large enough it can be seen from the naked eye on earth. Would that be OK just because he had the money to do it?
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoI echo the sentiments of that famous tweet, that if I ever go outside one night and find an ad on the moon, I'm becoming a terrorist.
- nirav72 3y agoProbably because the moon doesn't have property lines and nation-state borders (For now). Vacant lots down here on earth are usually privately owned or by local or national governments.
- jerf 3y agoThe Age of Exploration has ended so long ago that we have all collectively forgotten how it works. Almost every square meter of land on Earth is covered by one group or another of People with Guns. The only ones that aren't are ones so deeply undesirable that nobody cares. But it actually works in a fairly intuitive manner. People who get to the Moon can do as they like there. Anyone who wants to stop them is invited to go to the Moon and try. This does not mean immediately by shooting them. Talking is a classic option for many good reasons that won't be going anywhere. But if you can't get there at all, you have no stake. If you can't get to the moon, you will have no say. On Earth it is easy to forget that enforcement of laws requires enforcers to be able to get to the location where it will be enforced, because humanity conquered the task of getting from anywhere people are to anywhere people are at a reasonable speed a while ago. But this is still a base requirement. It hasn't gone anywhere. It has just been a long time since it was in question and people forget about it. Space exploration will modify this for some period of time because in the Age of Exploration, people could live on the land. While people living in space require an Earth footprint to maintain themselves, that will give people on Earth a mechanism for enforcing power over the moon based on that footprint. But science fiction is full unto overflowing of space colonies going to war with Earth once they are capable of being independent for a reason; it's not so much a "trope" as a plainly obvious consequence of independence. Better treatments observe that Earth will know this and take it into account as it tries to hamstring its colonies from being independent, but A: this will eventually take the form of overtly hostile acts if space colonization continues on that will provide abundant casus belli for the colonies and B: there's a huge economic incentive to make them as independent as possible because it will always be more expensive to supply space colonies from Earth than to supply them from space resources. Getting back to the original question, what will happen is this: Anyone who can get to the moon and stay there will have a say. Anyone who can't won't. Wringing hands, abtruse philosophical arguments, having hissy fits, screaming really loudly about "rights", complaining, none of it will matter. "Power comes from the barrel of a gun" is actually downstream of "power comes from being there". If you can't be there, you will have no power. Also, I'm not particularly celebrating or condemning this in this post. This is just how it is.
- tw04 3y ago>While I understand their concerns, it seems a bit crazy to think you have any right to tell people what to do or not do on the moon. Have you stopped to think what happens to the earth if the moon were just outright gone? Because that's ultimately what the debate is about. If anything valuable is found there, you can be assured someone will strip mine it until every last piece of value is removed, and the non-valuable thing is left to float off into the universe, not their problem. I think it's EVERYONE'S right to tell anyone trying to profit off of what is at the moon what they can and can't do.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 3y agoIf someone can mine the entire moon away I say let them. What a fantastical technical achievement that would be
- tw04 3y ago"If someone can cut down the entire Amazon Rainforest, I say let them. What a fantastical technical achievement." Whether you're trolling or not, what a horrible take unless you're hoping the human race just wipes itself out. With our current rate of technological progress, someone having the ability to mine the moon to nothing is at most 500 years away, maybe sooner if they find something under the surface that makes it financially attractive.
- jasonjayr 3y agoIf there's iron there, then there's the potential for Low-background Steel ...
- firtoz 3y agoWell, until we drop some nukes on there.
- ben_w 3y agoThere's an unshielded nuclear reactor hanging in the sky just like bricks don't. I'm not a nuclear physicist so I may be orders of magnitude off, but my gut feeling is that being constantly bombarded with the solar wind might be putting into a very slightly radioactive equilibrium? (I'm thinking more along the lines of the story of the radioactive boy scout, not Trinitite, and I don't know how radioactive "normal" steel is compared to "low-background").
- palata 3y agoI understand: "Those people have valid reasons to tell people what not to do on the Moon, but I find it crazy that they could think there are valid reasons to tell people what not to do on the Moon". Is that what you are saying?
- darby_eight 3y ago[dead]
- GolfPopper 3y agoIs it any more crazy than thinking that some corporation, country, or individual has a right to do something on the moon?
- moffkalast 3y agoThe moon is well outside anything one might define as anyone's jurisdiction, nobody has any rights or responsibilities there and disputes are resolved with who gets there first and has a big enough stick to keep others away. That's the reality.
- redwall_hp 3y agoNations can, and do, punish people for crimes they commit elsewhere on the planet. Nobody can get away with staking land out on the moon and declaring sovereignty, because it's impossible to exist on the moon without a massive support apparatus on earth enabling it. It's easy enough to throw those people in a cell. And either nations take care of the offenders and form treaties, or it leads to war at the worst.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThe moon is under the jurisdiction of the UN in writing, or at least the supermajority of member states claim so.
- moffkalast 3y agoDe jure so is Antarctica, but nobody seems to give a fuck in practice.
- AlgorithmicTime 3y ago[dead]
- antegamisou 3y ago> people You mean the arrogant billionaires that think they can buy everything and anything and mostly ruin them? Cause these are the only ones that have expressed interest, instead of, you know, contributing to more menial tasks like food/water shortage, environmental protection etc.
- mort96 3y agoAnd the mining companies are better because they wouldn't be telling people what to do, they would just destroy any possibility of doing what the scientists want to do?
- acimim_ha 3y ago> locations on the moon where conditions are ideal for the study of the early universe. Doesn't get me particularly excited personally. Scientists should be aware other people have different interests. I want a futurama lunapark. In the end, government is going to decide. After some war/conflicts. Just like on Earth.
- pryelluw 3y agoI too dream with being a whaler on the moon.
- cdelsolar 3y agoWe carry a harpoon
- dguest 3y agoI want a lunapark too. Until then I'm just another stupid scientist. But I'm aware that other people have different interests. I think the people who are calling for areas to be preserved are aware too, which is why they are trying to start a dialogue.
- Aerroon 3y agoBut the dialogue is really this: >I want to study X and to do that I need Y. And you're going to give it to me because it might help our scientific understanding. Probably. Maybe. Science overall is useful, but whether any individual part of it is useful is a lot more questionable. What gets studied is about what a (willful) scientist wants to study. I suspect that people setting up something economically useful on the moon would actually end up being more valuable for science. It would mean that there will be economical access to the moon. If it's government-funded and science-led, then the whole thing might end on some political whim.
- dguest 3y agoYeah I don't like entitled scientists either. It's especially disheartening to see my own community come off this way. That said, I think most of us are aware of the reality: from a funding point of view science is somewhere between a luxury and a trick to teach young idealistic people skills. Those skills can then be repurposed for industry or military applications. We aren't at all shy about pointing this out in grant proposals, so it's sad that people come off as though the scientific community is somehow entitled to anything. Don't get me wrong, I fully believe that science is important, but in a world ruled by markets science funding is always going to be a charity.
- KyleBerezin 3y agoMost of the long term scientific value of the moon sits below the regolith, down to the layers that formed from the collision with earth. There are magnetic features below the surface of the moon that we are very interested in called 'lunar swirls'. We think they are old iron rich magma pipes that have solidified and become magnetic. IM-3 launches in 2025, and has a lander with the Lunar Vertex rover, hopefully this one wont fall over. Its job is to investigate one of these swirls. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_swirls https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_swirls Edit: I should point out, If there are lava tubes, it means there are likely caves. Caves can have atmospheres.
- rockzom 3y agoCan we at least agree that realtors are not allowed on the moon?
- KyleBerezin 3y agoImagine a lunar HOA telling people they need to put their rovers in a garage.
- d_burfoot 3y agoThere was a similar theme in Kim Stanley Robinson's book Red Mars - a lot of the initial crew of colonists actually wanted to preserve the planet in its pristine state. I thought this was completely crazy. There are no ecosystems to protect, no endangered species, no green living things. Moving development from Earth into space should count as an overwhelming win for the environment.
- m3kw9 3y agoMaybe the way there is no regulations, gonna look like dumping grounds everywhere except the developed areas
- jessriedel 3y agoThe cost to bring trash (or even nuclear waste) to the moon is completely prohibitive, so the only thing it will be a dumping ground for is trash generated on the moon. And for the foreseeable future it will be entirely appropriate to dump lunar trash where ever it is most convenient.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThe cost to bring anything to the moon is completely prohibitive.
- HPsquared 3y agoProhibitive currently. Not for long, with Starship on the horizon.
- nirav72 3y ago>dumping ground for is trash generated on the moon. That might be a easier problem to solve on the moon. Considering its much much lower escape velocity. Once someone builds something like a mass-driver on the moon - they can just shoot the junk into an orbit that will eventually have it fall into the sun in a few hundred years.
- jfengel 3y agoI personally don't much care what we develop on the moon. It's a rock. I'm more concerned with Mars. Mars potentially had life, once. There's even a vague chance that it might still, somehow. Evidence for either would be extremely precarious. Unlike the Moon, every bit of waste vented into the atmosphere is going to be carried around the entire planet by the wind, tainting everything. If it were up to me, I'd declare a moratorium on humans being on Mars. Not permanent, but, say, 100 years. Enough time for us to send lots of robots to explore the planet without mixing our biology up in it. Build up whatever automated support is needed for that. It's industrial and ugly, and surely dumping out its own non-biological pollution, but that doesn't risk breeding the way the way our microorganisms do. And everywhere we go, we spread microorganisms, lots of them. (In theory they'd be contained, but accidents happen.) I'd settle for 50 years. Or even 20 years past the point where we'd be capable of the kind of rockets required to build an industrial infrastructure. Just gather a crapload of data from the planet as pristinely as we can, just because we're never going to get another opportunity. Use that time to build whatever you want on the Moon. Of course it's not up to me. There will surely be astronauts on Mars well before I think it's a good idea. It will certainly be exciting and produce a lot of great data fast. I'll just cross my fingers that they can get it while it's still there to get, before every test turns up "We found DNA on Mars... oops, it's us again."
- KyleBerezin 3y agoI think if we find DNA on mars, it would be pretty trivial to identify if it is terrestrial. There would be some crazy evolutionary divergence by now.
- londons_explore 3y agoI would argue that there is very little value to us of a few bacterial cells who might exist down some cracks on mars. There will never be a time we have fully searched for life there, and even if there was something there to find, I think we could probably identify it even with contamination from us.
- politician 3y agoNot to mention that periodic mass transfers between planets have already contaminated it; the OP is mistaken that Mars is somehow a pristine environment.
- magwa101 3y ago[dead]
- BasilPH 3y agoI can highly recommend "A City on Mars"[^0], which I recently read. The authors go into fascinating detail about what it takes to build planetary settlements, and they not only focus on the engineering questions but make a point to talk about the legal aspects of space settlement as well. [^0]: https://www.acityonmars.com/ https://www.acityonmars.com/
- AlgorithmicTime 3y ago[dead]
- edward28 3y agoNo way, I want my 24 lane elevated freeway to circumnavigate the moon. My patriotic freedoms are being impeached.
- JohnMakin 3y agoI understand study of the early universe has potentially important ramifications in physics - but scanning exoplanets for evidence of life seems pointless to me. Say we found life within 10 LY of our solar system. What would we even do with this information?
- dotnet00 3y ago10LY is close enough that given a sufficiently motivating factor, like strong evidence of life, we could build machines to study them in more detail. There are concepts for telescopes which are technically feasible with current or near future technology, albeit very expensive and long travel times, that could take much more detailed images of the planet, eg a solar gravitational lensing telescope. Hell, 10ly is close enough to feasibly do a probe flyby in a hundred years or so if we put more attention on refining relevant technologies like solar sails and nuclear propulsion. Also, the detection of life that close would have important implications for things like the fermi paradox. If we find any life within 10ly, it becomes more likely that the universe is absolutely teeming with life. But if that's the case, why isn't it absolutely teeming with intelligent life as well? Even at our relatively basic space travel capabilities, we can see that traveling between stars, or even just communicating between stars is not technically infeasible, especially for machines.
- JohnMakin 3y agoI'm not so sure that it's been proven these distances are navigable on human timescales. I know solar sails have been theorized, but aren't we very far from seeing that kind of technology as a reality? Say we spend ~100 years going to a planet to collect data. What then? What do we do with that data? If the universe is teeming with intelligent life - it would have to be very VERY local in our galaxy to make any kind of difference to us at all (and I still can't think of one). Not meaning to get downvoted here - I'm just genuinely curious what people think the real scientific value is here.
- dotnet00 3y agoTo be clear, by "in a hundred years" I don't mean that with current technology it'd take the sail a hundred years to get there, I mean that by improving the tech for a hundred years with an extrasolar destination in mind, we'd be able to send a probe that arrives there on human timescales. Currently there have only been low-orbit tests of solar sails, they need much more development to go interstellar, but not so much that it's completely infeasible to achieve in the near-ish future. Since we don't have much reason to want a closeup of planets in other star systems yet, we don't really put much effort into the associated propulsion technologies. But the detection of nearby life would change that by giving us a destination, similar to how the Moon and Mars give us a sort of 'ladder' of destinations for directing our development of space technology. Say we find that single-celled life is very common, then, considering our lack of detection of multi-cellular life, we'd have reason to put more effort into understanding the conditions which led to the emergence of multicellular life on Earth, since by the only statistics we would have, that must be a significant filter on the development of life. By having data on the environment they evolved in, we could understand our own evolution (eg if that planet is much younger than Earth, it could serve as a picture of what early Earth might have been like, if it's similarly old, we could try to understand what went differently on Earth). We could also figure out if they might be based on similar chemistry etc, all of which would feed into our understanding of the origins of life on Earth. Detecting intelligent life would have a different, more 'philosophical' effect, even if we couldn't interact with them. The galaxy is theoretically colonizable over millions of years. The technology to do so is probably only thousands of years away for us. But, since the galaxy has existed for billions of years, and has been hospitable to life for at least 4 billion years, it is unreasonable to assume that much of that intelligent life won't have been around for millions of years longer than ourselves. In which case, why aren't they already everywhere? It'd have to be some sort of nearly fundamental limitation all intelligent life runs into, in which case it'd also affect what we as a species can aspire to achieve. The more intelligent life we find, the more unsurmountable the limitation becomes.
- pfdietz 3y agoHow about "no"? Does "no" work for you, NIMBMs? It works for me.
- amelius 3y agoAs long as advertisers don't turn it into a giant Pepsi logo.
- nojvek 3y agoIf Pepsi could, pepsi would.
- IshKebab 3y agoJust how much development are they expecting??
- andrewmutz 3y agoNIMBYism is getting out of control
- rhdunn 3y agoNIMSS -- Not In My Solar System
- Ajedi32 3y agoSo many commenters seem to be missing the point of this article. None of this is about "preserving the environment". Its about how to allocate the moon's scarce natural resources, such as sites with cold temperatures necessary for astronomy, areas with no radio interference for radio astronomy, and mining sites rich in natural resources such as helium-3. Some of these sites overlap with each other and would require coordination to ensure usage for one purpose doesn't interfere with other possible uses for the same site. These are valid concerns definitely worth thinking about now.
- odyssey7 3y agoInstead of "scientists are calling for the moon to be better protected from development," it could have been titled: "scientists say they deserve first dibs on developing the lunar surface."
- odyssey7 3y agoA wish list of development projects, presented as a request to prevent development.
- osigurdson 3y agoI'd like to see a wild west on the moon. Complete with saloons and quick draw battles.
- ldehaan 3y ago[dead]