21 ms·
Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions into public housing
- seper8 3y ago[flagged]
- keiferski 3y agoI wouldn't describe Paris as a super nice place by any means, more "gritty but cool," but the area near the Eiffel Tower is a tourist zone and always has been. Average Parisians rarely go there. I wouldn't call Times Square a nice place either. Your comment would be more convincing if you said Le Marais, Belleville, or the 13th were getting bad.
- orwin 3y ago(the 13th and the 17th are getting better imho, but it's probably because I don't live there anymore :))
- sakex 3y agoI have the same feeling, growing up in Paris and then moving to Switzerland. Paris seems more and more dangerous and dirty. And people seem to become less and less happy.
- rmbyrro 3y agoWhat does it all have to do with the subject here, if I may ask?
- TwoFerMaggie 3y agoHaving lived in an actual third world country for a couple decades, I personally can't take statements such as "xx is becoming more like a third world country" seriously. I get the sentiment behind it though. If I compare, for example, my experience living in cities in China vs cities in Europe, I would argue that the relative freedom of movement forces residents in Europe to confront the inequality in their everyday lives. In China, on the other hand, such inequality can be easily covered up by either confining the migrant workers (an artificially created underclass of people without hukou[0] registration in the city but still seek opportunities there) in urban villages[1], or sometimes, simply cracking down on and expelling them through policy changes with little resistance[2]. I don't doubt the fact that you're not a sheltered person, but even the average urban residents in China can be oblivious to the plight or even the existence of such an underclass. I'd argue that one can be quite sheltered even if they live there, which is also by design. And this is actually quite common in relatively wealthy Asian countries, see this example [3] in Singapore of how people talk about maids. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hukou https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hukou [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urban_village_(China) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urban_village_(China) [2] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/nov/27/china-ruthless-campaign-evict-beijings-migrant-workers-condemned https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/nov/27/china-ruthless... [3] https://youtu.be/QH9fX4KIhZg?si=Yp5KjI59Owc09fvd&t=1007 https://youtu.be/QH9fX4KIhZg?si=Yp5KjI59Owc09fvd&t=1007
- rangestransform 3y agoI don’t want to be confronted with inequality every day
- TwoFerMaggie 3y ago(forgive me if it's sarcasm and I missed it) Nobody wants confrontation because it's uncomfortable. But inequality like this is literally the inescapable reality migrant workers live in. Your average locals might be able to turn a blind eye to it, they can't. Seems at least a little bit hypocritical to enjoy the life made easier by (often imported) cheap labor while not wanting to be aware of their troubles, or you know, live with them in close proximity.
- bombcar 3y agoThe people who have to live with them are not the rich or the people making the decisions by any means - it's just the middle class who has to put up with it. The rich don't take the metro, they are driven from place to place.
- Phil_Latio 3y agoThis is stupid argument. He/She was talking about something relative, that is, relative to what it was 5, 10, 15, 20 years ago. You can't come along and pick some worse example from another place. With the same logic you could say wages don't need to increase for the next 20 years, or police can be defunded because more crime is not so important, because the 3rd world is off way worse...
- TwoFerMaggie 3y ago> with the same logic you could say... The comment I replied to said "it's feeling more like a third world country", I replied "no it's not even close to an actual third world country". I don't see how you could then derive that I meant "therefore it's not important". Are third world countries the only place where things need fixing?
- bedobi 3y agotell me you're racist without saying "i'm racist"
- Ylpertnodi 3y agoAt first read I was recoiling, but several reads later the poster said nothing racist. What did I miss?
- bombcar 3y agoYou missed that anything against "illegal migrants" must be racist, at least according to some. There cannot be any other reason.
- gadders 3y agoLast time we drove out of Paris after staying with friends, my wife spotted a large farmers market that she wanted to stop at. It turned out to be a homeless encampment filled with immigrants to France.
- foldr 3y agoSome people just don't like cities. Google pretty much any major Western city and you can find comments complaining that it's dirty, riddled with crime and has too many immigrants. Paris is a real place, not a theme park.
- intalentive 3y agoWestern cities weren't always like this. They don't have to be like this.
- foldr 3y agoIf you take a reasonably long historical perspective, Western cities are a hell of a lot cleaner and safer now than they were in the past. Sewerage goes a long way.
- testingParisGPE 3y agoEncampments have an big and long history in Paris even after the 2nd world war... It's not great, just people looking for a better place to live and survive.
- jokethrowaway 3y agoParis was much better 20 years ago; sure it still smelled like pee (no idea why it was and it is such a problem in Paris and literally nowhere else) but nothing was wrong. I've been in 2019 and that's the last time Paris will ever see me: immigrants touching you trying to sell you stuff, people defecating in front of the supermarket in broad daylight, homeless camps, I've had a drugged up homeless jumping on me. Shame, because the bakeries are top notch.
- trueduke 3y agohttps://archive.is/wx7yj https://archive.is/wx7yj
- afpx 3y agoIs Paris considered a great place to live? I've been there a couple times in the last few years, and it just seemed like every other big western city. (except for the police walking around with assault weapons.)
- wk_end 3y agoThis is hard for me to imagine. Where in Paris were you? Which big western cities specifically do you feel like it resembled?
- afpx 3y agoSorry my communication skills aren’t great. It was a genuine question. I spent a total of 14 days there, but I’m an adventurous walker and covered much of the city. My expectations were too high, probably. (Too high expectations lead to disappointment)
- torus 3y agoThere's even a name for this specific case of disappointment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_syndrome "the disorder is caused by positive representations of the city in popular culture, which leads to immense disappointment as the reality of experiencing the city is very different from expectations: tourists are confronted with an overcrowded and littered city ... and a less than welcoming attitude by French hospitality workers like shopkeepers, restaurant and hotel personnel without considering the higher safety risks to which tourists used to safer cities are suddenly exposed."
- cm2187 3y agoI think like every city it has good parts and bad parts. Food is great, lots of stuff to do, employment is ok, the city is generally superb. But the population is irascible, the metro is a dark, overcrowded, grafiti covered, piss-stinking place, and the city is one gigantic traffic jam. Health and education is cheap, though state-run schools are in free fall and parents rush to put their kids in private schools. And the city is surrounded with poor neighbourhoods that are a ticking timebomb (with regular riots that are now spreading inside Paris).
- bko 3y agoThe problem with charging below market prices for anything is that it necessarily leads to a mismatch of supply and demand. So the question is how do you allocate that supply? One way is to have hidden costs. This could range from straight up bribes, to paid consultants to fill out a lot of forms or talk to the right people, to just knowing someone Another way is a lottery which benefits a tiny percentage of people. Sure it's "fair" but the incentive to rig it is huge But even with a lottery it's still inefficient. If you give someone an apartment with a market rent of 4k for only 1k you're effectively giving them a 3k apartment subsidy. But if you handed them 3k, maybe they would spend 1k dollars on extra apartment and 2k for something else. There are other distortions. Overall these are the worst kinds of policies because it's all hidden costs. If we realized that with a system like this we're giving 1 out of 1k eligible people the equivalent of a 30k a year transfer, we'd likely realize it's a ridiculous policy. But instead we just say how nice it is so and so is paying only 600 Euros to live in the center of Paris
- bedobi 3y agoI used to think like you but no longer do. A city NEEDS to have people of all ages, backgrounds, income levels etc in it to not die. Yes those people who live in that most central subsidized housing are in some ways winning a lottery ticket, and the real policy is to build a lot more housing as close to the city as possible. But Paris are doing that! AND adding new public transit etc etc. This multifaceted approach is better than just sterile economista policy. Vienna does it very successfully as well. Almost no one owns their home there, they're all renting very cheaply very high quality beautiful homes, including inside and very close to the city.
- bko 3y agoOk,think of the politician you dislike the most. Now imagine the discretion of "people of all ages backgrounds income levels etc" would fall to his or her purview to decide. Would you still support the system? We should have a clear objective system of governance that allows even terrible people to oversee it
- 3y ago
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago"A city, if it’s only made up of poor people, is a disaster," said Mr. Apparu, who now works for a property developer. "And if it’s only made up of rich people, it’s not much better." From a human+social position, I strongly agree with this. The value of social benevolence isn't limited to the direct beneficiaries and has positive impacts beyond the economics.
- greyman 3y agoBut that literally never happens, each city contains both rich and poor people.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoStrictly sure but the quote more addresses the experience that visitors, residents and prospective residents have.
- kome 3y agoit's not benevolence, it also makes economic sense. who does the menial job anyway? you should keep them close. if they will go to live far, their cost will increase, or their cost in time of traffic and pollution.
- bedobi 3y agoThe Mayor of Paris has bigger balls any other Mayor except maybe Barcelona ...and they're both women! The confidence to make radical, meaningful changes for the better of the people and tell the opposition to get stuffed... I wish all politicians had that.
- nindalf 3y ago> I wish all politicians had that. Even the politicians you disagree with? So for example, AfD in Germany making the radical, meaningful change for the better of the German people by removing non-Germans from Germany ... and telling you to get stuffed ... you'd love that presumably? What you love is this policy. Don't confuse that with the method, which you clearly wouldn't like if the shoe was on the other foot.
- arlort 3y agoEither I missed the part where the article mentioned the policy in paris being unconstitutional or that equivalence is overly-exaggerated at best
- baud147258 3y agoit's mostly continuing the policies from the previous mayor... (who was male, but I don't see the relation).
- throw__away7391 3y agoNY is a mess of policy failure and rampant corruption in the implementation of these policies, policies which have for decades been championed by the NY Times, frequently by naive portrayals of policies in Western European countries like this one. Once imported at 5 times the cost and half the quality these become irrevocable subsidies for well connected landlords and administrators. The city needs to get basic things like sewage, security, and transit working before plowing any more money into subsidized housing.
- darby_eight 3y ago> security Oh come on, the NYPD swallowed 5 billion in public funds, the most of any city on earth. Crime is near an all-time low. Hell, they could probably slash half that budget without causing the crime sprees the NY post implies could happen at any time. This is the worst excuse to avoid funding subsidized housing when the latter would probably have a greater impact on whether people were desperate enough to turn to crime. Saying NY needs to be more secure is just fear mongering at this point.
- throw__away7391 3y agoThis is simply not true. > they could probably slash half that budget without causing the crime sprees You're living in a world painted by your politics and oblivious to reality. I plan to return to the city someday if things improve, but things are horrible now and not moving in the right direction.
- darby_eight 3y ago> but things are horrible now and not moving in the right direction. Nobody ever backs shit like this up. You've been had and in the most obvious and shallow manner.
- cm2187 3y ago> One quarter of residents in the French capital now live in government-owned housing, part of an aggressive effort to keep lower-income Parisians — and their businesses — in the city. I think they meant "...and their votes"
- tetris11 3y agoexpand?
- eschulz 3y agoThe article mentions a woman who wept with joy when she received a "steal" of a lease for a new government owned building, and the article mentions that certain political parties have made this program a priority. Perhaps this woman will support such political parties with her vote in future elections.
- cm2187 3y agoThe socialists who control the city have a majority but not a structural one (Paris was voting conservative for a long time). The gentrification of Paris would normally deplete their electorate, so you can see their efforts to buy prime real estate at high price to convert it to social housing as a very expensive vote-buying exercise.
- teloli 3y agoOr perhaps they try to do what socialists are supposed to be doing, namely giving the people a place where they can live.
- maeln 3y agoNot the same guy, but if a class of people have to move out of the city because they are being priced-out, they will not vote in this city anymore (but in their new city in the suburb), shifting the current political balance. The current Paris mayor is from the Parti Socialiste (left-wing / moderate left-wing - for France), and may get a lot of their vote from the working class people living in Parisian social housing. Therefor, they have an active interest in keeping them within the city. The political theory is true but I have no idea if the people living in social housing do vote more for the current mayor though. So it is just theory.
- dangus 3y agoThis article reminded me of a thought I’ve often had: that the USA is a great place to live for the upper middle class and above, but it’s one of the worst wealthy countries to live in when you’re poor. From the context of the USA it seems downright amazing to see a society where public housing isn’t automatically assumed to be a number of bad things: taxpayer waste, crime haven, and antiquated disrepair. The benefits of the tenant management system also seems like it’s good for everyone in society. Our daily surroundings really shouldn’t be a race to the highest bidder for high-rent tenants like McDonald’s to come in, underpay employees, and poison local residents with junk food. The approach to the city as a public landlord being selective and building a neighborhood through balancing available goods and services seems incredibly desirable. In the US this is all inverted the wrong way: the wealthy neighborhoods are the only ones that can keep chains like McDonald’s and Walmart out, walkability and positive urban fabric is a luxury amenity for the few (e.g., NYC, Miami, and Chicago’s best neighborhoods), and the wealthy are the ones that are subsidized instead of those who are low income or middle class.
- theGnuMe 3y ago>Our daily surroundings really shouldn’t be a race to the highest bidder for high-rent tenants like McDonald’s to come in, underpay employees, and poison local residents with junk food. A good term I heard for this was "strip mine society".
- TimPC 3y agoI think the big issue is it's a lot harder to start social housing in 2024 when you have extremely limited historical action on it. But in general a city buying real estate is a hedge on real estate prices increasing in that city, which can be extremely useful for city budgets if you have any costs associate with housing some portion of the population. Most cities of a certain size find they can't function without some amount of social housing: the free market prices out entire occupations that cities need. Even someone as non-essential as a Barista is actually quite important in that many of the people in NYC want to be able to buy coffee. But you aren't going to get Starbucks to pay the $20+ /hour needed for them to rent within a reasonable commute of where they live. There are also questions about how much of out of control rents employers are responsible for and should bear the cost of, and how much it is the cities fault. To the degree to which rental prices are high because of politician supported NIMBYism it seems fairer for city budgets to bear those costs than third parties.
- patwolf 3y ago> Every Thursday, Jacques Baudrier, the Paris city councilor in charge of housing, scrolls through the list of properties being exchanged by sellers and buyers on the private market. With some exceptions, the city has the legal right to pre-empt the sale of a building, buy the property and convert it to public housing. What are the mechanics of how this works? If I agree to buy a property for a million dollars, does the city get a chance to match that price?
- drdo 3y agoYes, that's pretty much how it works. The city has the right to become the buyer for the specified price for any property sale.
- baud147258 3y ago> What are the mechanics of how this works? If I agree to buy a property for a million dollars, does the city get a chance to match that price? there's a French wiki page on this: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Droit_de_pr%C3%A9emption_urbain#R%C3%A9gime_actuel https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Droit_de_pr%C3%A9emption_urbai... But basically, yes, the city has 2 months to match the price. The city can also offer a lower price, which can be refused (so no sale at all) or can be argued in front of a special judge, who'd rule if the price offered by the city is acceptable, depending on the local housing market. It's not a rule that's specific to Paris, but which is applicable in most French cities.
- bertjk 3y agoSo does this mean that every sale of any building can take at least two months?
- mratsim 3y agoThey always take two months at the very minimum as well because buyers as to go to many banks or a loan broker. You have notaries involved and right to step away from a sale, no question asked for 10 days iirc.
- 3y ago
- mumblemumble 3y agoMy understanding is that excise taxation is generally agreed upon as the preferred method for governments to manipulate the market, both because it incurs fewer deadweight losses and because it tends to actually work better. So, what if we get rid of all these complicated rent control and rent freezes and affordable housing schemes, and instead just implement a rent tax, to be paid by the landlord, and make it progressive? I don't know exactly how it should scale; you wouldn't want it to be just by rent because that would have a regressive impact on families who have kids, because they need more space and more space naturally costs more. Maybe price per square foot? At least in my city this would probably also reduce real estate prices in general, because a huge source of demand for houses is actually real estate speculators who buy up houses and then put them on the market as rental units. I gather, based on one conversation with an acquaintance who had been a realtor but was looking to pivot into this line of business, is that a lot of what's fueling that is, in effect, not-exactly-loopholes in US and local housing, lending and tax laws - many of which are ostensibly aimed at making housing more affordable - that allow people with sufficient resources to financially engineer together a speculative source of income while externalizing all the risk onto everyone but themselves.
- _3u10 3y agoMost demand for houses is from people. Most price increases are due to a lack of supply that exceeds population growth. Most lack of supply is caused by it being illegal to build higher / more dense, and a variety of other rules and regulations. Landlords are for the most part capitalizing on these broader market / regulatory trends.
- catlikesshrimp 3y agoI don't understand the downvotes. I honestly think what that is saying is true in a black and white way. Grandparent says: "get rid of all these complicated rent control and rent freezes and affordable housing scheme..." I think this is fertile for discussion. Rent freezes didn't work in Argentina (extreme example), my opinion is they don't work anywhere. But oversupply does reduce prices, as happened with evergrande in China. IMO interest in not having an oversupply bursting a bubble is precisely what parent is talking about. Again, in a very absolute way of looking at life.
- mebazaa 3y agoAs a Parisian, who is generally angry at the city’s housing policy (build taller!), I find the public housing of the past few years to be a great achievement. In general, public housing sits on the outer edges of Paris, but the city has been agressive in reconverting buildings in posher neighborhoods. It doesn’t really lead to reduced rent (because no additional supply), but it decreases social segregation. That alone is critical to keep a city alive.
- yieldcrv 3y ago> but it decreases social segregation. That alone is critical to keep a city alive. I agree that is a net boon to society. I think the cross drift of ideas is a net positive, the human interaction can create more opportunities for those that have less, I don't think it reduces inequality meaningfully and I'm not suggesting that was a goal only that my prior statements might lead one to believe it does, but I've seen far more segregated cities be without many services during an infrastructure failure, because the people doing those services didn't live there.
- Probiotic6081 3y ago[dead]
- spaniard89277 3y agoParis needs a new center. Like many other cities, build more places where people want to flock so you get pressure off the center. Most new developments are in dead areas because nobody wants to spend time surrounded by ugly, bland and functional architecture.
- lou1306 3y agoThe problem is, when you are competing with the center of Paris, it is pretty hard to build a compelling alternative. Say what you will about the streets being loud, chaotic and dirty, the area between the II, III, V and VI arrondissements (Latin quarter, Pantheon, Beaubourg, Jardin du Luxembourg, Tuilleries, Notre Dame, Place des Vosges) is still just swell.
- alienicecream 3y agoBut it hasn't stayed Paris, it's overrun with North African "migrants". Why put a bald faced lie on it?
- Deprogrammer9 3y agoIf the USA didn't endlessly fund war then maybe they could invest in their cities & infrastructure more. Probably not going to happen anytime soon by the looks of things.
- detourdog 3y agoWhat is interesting is that after WW2 Europe had to rebuild and the USA was left with a great industrial machine that had a capacity that outstripped demand.
- derelicta 3y agoThe Empire needs to wage war in order to expand its reach and thus sell its goods there/exploit the local labour, otherwise it falls.
- UncleEntity 3y agoI would absolutely love for European countries to pay the true cost of their defense so I can drive on nice roads and children could be taught by people who make a decent wage. Probably not going to happen anytime soon by the looks of things.
- rmbyrro 3y agohttps://archive.is/wx7yj https://archive.is/wx7yj
- thuuuomas 3y agoWhy was this headline changed in such an editorializing way? “Mixed society” is a loaded term not present in the original headline.
- lucaspfeifer 3y agoWhat do you find 'loaded' about the phrase 'mixed society'? It is more descriptive than the meaningless phrase in the original headline: "How Does Paris Stay Paris?".
- brainwad 3y agoPossibly because it presumes Paris is 'mixed', but actually the city of Paris is notably better off than the surrounding suburbs, especially the ones on the north/east. This has some good maps: https://medium.com/perspective-critique/the-geography-of-inequality-30d738139340 https://medium.com/perspective-critique/the-geography-of-ine...
- mp05 3y agoCan't help but be reminded of this classic: THE VILLAS AT KENNYS HOUSE The most sought after address in all of South park for only the very privileged few. You can take in the views from the deck spa and enjoy the mixed Sodosopa culture. Also, featuring a private fitness center, clubhouse and so much more. Welcome home. https://southpark.cc.com/w/index.php/The_Villas_at_Kennys_House https://southpark.cc.com/w/index.php/The_Villas_at_Kennys_Ho...
- TacticalCoder 3y agoYup this makes no sense. Note that the original is also wrong: "How does Paris stays Paris...". To me Paris is not Paris at all anymore. The government is in damage control before the olympic games and shall try to hide that Paris is not Paris anymore but Paris honestly became a sad thing to see. There are many tourists having an actual shock and it can be really bad: if I'm not mistaken japanese even have a hotline they can call if they're in shock when they discover the shithole that Paris as become as opposed to the rosy picture of Paris that is painted abroad.
- 082349872349872 3y agoBefore the invention of the elevator, buildings were more naturally mixed-use: shops (and stables?) on the ground floor, posh tenants on the first, all the way up to artists and baristas in their garrets under the roof. By democratising travel within a building, ironically the elevator made it possible to have neighbourhoods for which service workers had to commute primarily from the outside along the x and y axes, not merely within the neighbourhood along the z.
- bedobi 3y agothis makes zero sense, plenty of cities with housing built mostly after the invention of the elevator that have mixed use neighborhoods with tall, low and medium height buildings alike
- 082349872349872 3y agoYes, and those cities also presumably don't have the problem of segregated neighbourhoods. (also those cities don't tend to occur in my Old Country, but perhaps they've made progress there since I've been gone? Protip: never attempt to live in a "city" which is younger than you are. Survivre plutôt que vivre) All I was claiming is that the elevator is necessary but not sufficient: monocultural neighbourhoods were much less likely to arise back when number of flights of stairs put a significant natural gradient on the price point of each buildable unit.
- rsynnott 3y ago> all the way up to artists and baristas in their garrets under the roof. I don't think there was any significant crossover between lifts not existing and _baristas_ existing. For a start, lifts predate proper espresso machines.
- 082349872349872 3y agoGood point; please substitute the appropriate word for the service worker who doles out glasses of wine from behind a zinc counter. (or did zinc also postdate lifts?)
- hokkos 3y agoThe reality of this housing policies is that it is currently bankrupting the city of Paris with a skyrocketing debt and growing local taxes. They spent enormous sum of money to buy old buildings at the historical peak of their price, buildings ill-fitted to house poor wide families and sometimes in very expansive neighborhood where they have to travel far to get access to cheaper groceries. Also the delta between the low rent and the theoretical market rate for the housing is insane, this is equivalent to several thousand euros in untaxed shadow income, all from randomness or special favor. All with the goal to transform 40% of the housing in socialised ones, this is a power grab of the mayor to assure them votes for the future and has always been the strategy of the communist towns surrounding Paris.
- digging 3y agoI love how "giving poor people comfort" is always actually a "power grab." I'm sure it does have political benefits for the mayor, but that's also a natural outcome of good policy. (Not the only one; often good policy actually has horrible backlash.) This comment could be expressing some true ideas but I don't find it trustworthy.
- its_ethan 3y agoThere's a line somewhere where "giving poor people comfort" goes from providing good and useful social services to essentially a bribe. Where that line is varies based on who you ask - for some it's student debt cancellation (a US thing), for others it's $1000+ subsidies for housing, other people may not see any service the government provides as a "bribe" of any sort. Caring about these bribes/"power grabs" is important (even if this guys comment strikes you as trollish). Just because you agree with a social service to benefit some group doesn't mean that the people in power won't abuse their power in the future. They might abuse their support by holding these social services (or "comforts") hostage. Once you have people who have adapted to living in their subsidized housing (which can/will happen quickly) you open the door for political leaders to say "you must vote for me or tolerate my bad behavior or else this goes away". Even if the method by which "this goes away" is that the opposing political group would be the one to remove the social service, it's something that needs to be considered. To circle back, if you do something that is considered beyond the line of "comfort for poor people" and is seen as a "power grab" by enough people - you're more likely to have the opposition emboldened to eventually remove that service.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoEditorialized title. Just seems like virtue signaling to me. Unless anyone has a reason that it isn’t? I was recently in Paris, the comments here are a touch different in tone than the Parisians I talked to.
- 6bb32646d83d 3y agoUnfortunately it means it's extremely hard to live in Paris if you're middle class. If you're upper middle class/rich, you can rent/buy. If you're poor, you get a chance to get public housing. If you're middle class, too bad for you.
- jajko 3y agoYou can put this on whole France, this is general approach at least for past few decades. Ultra rich easily bypass all those populist moves to 'tax rich', poor have sometimes unreasonable protections (ie you can just stop paying rent, give big FU to the owner, change locks and maybe, theoretically after 6 months of courts he can evict you on his costs, while you trash the place into nothing without any recourse - some real cases of friends living there). Its outright the worst possible place in whole Europe to be rich (again, those ultra rich are off the quite corrupt system, just check all (super)yachts in whole Cote d'Azur), government goes after you like a rabid dog, inheritance tax is easily 40%. All the bankers I've talked to (not professionally, I am just a normal guy) advised against any investment in that country before you cross ultra high net worth line, then all this disappears. Yet absolutely nobody strikes against this corruption and unfairness, middle class just buckles up and continues, at least whats left of it.
- sangnoir 3y ago> Its outright the worst possible place in whole Europe to be rich I guess it's a good thing Europe has free movement! They are free to be rich in Amsterdam, Berlin or Brussels. If the wealth is generated in France, then they should put up with the French inconveniences.
- rastignack 3y agoDon’t worry I’m upper middle class and roughly 75% of my salary goes straight to taxes while everything that’s state provided (schools, hospitals, security, infrastructure) just collapses.
- 3y ago
- olivierduval 3y agoThe article is quite... disappointing for a french Parisian. Let's make things clear: so called "mixed society" is actually a mix of "friends of the Mayor and allies" and poor-enough people that will vote for the so-called socialist Mayor. It's not about having a philosophical or idealogical view of society, only a practical view of election (a kind of "gerrymanding" if this concept is more understandable for US). There has been frequent scandals with ministers still using "low income" housing for themselves or families. The article starts with the interview of some Ms Vallery-Radot, and that uncommon name prompted me to look on internet and wonder if she is related to the https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vallery-Radot https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vallery-Radot which was until the 2000 ... State Advisor. So please... do not think that Paris is some kind of wonderful place where intelligent and humanistic leaders are working for the good of the french society as an example to the world. It's just usual political shady business, nepotism (and you'll see by yourself that the results will be bad during the Olympics for example)
- bugglebeetle 3y agoBy American standards, these would be eminently “intelligent and humanistic leaders.” NYC is ran by a crooked cop, who is under investigation for taking bribes from Turkey, while slashing the budget for schools and libraries so he can give more money to his “constantly defrauding the government” police gang. LA is such a wildly corrupt city, it’s hard to pick where to start, but several city council members were just caught on tape trying to explicitly screw over renters, rig an election against one of their left wing opponents, all while making racist comments to boot. The city also takes in billions in tax revenue for “affordable housing” schemes that go almost entirely to lining the pockets of cronies and party insiders through various fronts and nonprofits.
- smeej 3y ago> The program has allowed Mr. Chaillou and his wife to raise their two boys in the city. But he knows that the future of social housing will always face at least one big challenge: “The problem is that once you get in, you never want to leave.” I think this is the reason so many in the U.S. are skeptical of/resistant to such plans. Why work your butt off for 10 years to get to a place where you can afford a nice dwelling if you can also wait 10 years, working but not pushing yourself, and someone else will pay for it for you? And then once you have it, there's even less incentive to try to "move up" from there, because there's now a cliff in front of you. You have to make the whole jump in one go, because if you only take incremental steps, you lose eligibility for your subsidies. American culture doesn't like to think about how much of "success" is down to luck. As often as possible, we want to think it's earned. The idea of trying to make up for some of the luck factor by taking some from those with more and giving it to those with less is almost instinctively repugnant, even if it might lead to higher quality of life for everyone involved.
- jvanderbot 3y ago> instinctively repugnant To some. In very-red areas that I have relatives, they're happy to do a food drive, make donations, help pay for weddings or funerals, or show up to help repair houses. When you have 100 cousins and 10 brothers, this is a viable option. They frequent each others businesses, work on interconnected industries, and in general help out however they can. It's not instinctively repugnant to help, or to give, it's instinctively repugnant to give outside their community. That seems a more fundamental problem with tax-rich/give-poor mentality. These folks make tons of charitable donations in money, in kind, and in time, but oppose wealth redistribution.
- ericmcer 3y agoI think it is most repugnant when you are working really hard and (very slowly) building your life up. It was really easy to be charitable when I was young and working meaningless jobs for $15/hr and I had my whole life ahead, and it will probably be easy when I am retired and no longer feel the strain of 50/hr workweeks. For now though it is brutal watching taxes eat huge chunks of your income so they can spend flagrantly.
- makerdiety 3y agoDiversity needs the precondition of liberal democratic welfare support? Therefore, eliminate public goods like public housing to destroy diversity. Since diversity positively correlates to large populations and the tragedy of the commons.
- rayiner 3y agoI wonder how many of those poor immigrants who live in this public housing to serve wealthy Parisians would prefer to live in something like an American suburb if they could get jobs there.
- retinaros 3y agoall of them
- averageRoyalty 3y agoProbably none. I'd much prefer to be poor in Paris than America. https://homelessdeathscount.org/ https://homelessdeathscount.org/ (arrogent domain given it's a USA count) https://www.trtworld.com/magazine/dying-on-the-streets-france-s-homeless-crisis-52169 https://www.trtworld.com/magazine/dying-on-the-streets-franc... Even adjusted for population size, we're still talking 2-3x the death rate if homeless. > Acolin notes that France has roughly as many social housing dwellings as the United States, despite having less than one-fifth the population. https://www.sightline.org/2021/07/26/yes-other-places-do-housing-better-case-3-paris/ https://www.sightline.org/2021/07/26/yes-other-places-do-hou... Social spending in France is the highest in the world, which has a dramatically larger effect on poor immigrants. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/02/social-spending-highest-lowest-country-comparison-oecd-france-economics-politics-welfare/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/02/social-spending-highe... In France, these immigrants woild also have access to public healthcare, meaning they'd get 70-100% back on most medical appointments and reimbursement for prescription medications. There are many other social benefits too. It's also much more likely to be closer to their country of origin than the US, in the event they want and are able to return at some point. I'm not trying to be rude, but why do you think a poor immigrant would have it better in the US than France? I can't think of a single reason.
- esbranson 3y ago> I'd rather be poor in Miami Beach or NYC than the EU. It has much better benefits than Romania. Sorry I couldn't help it. Comparing an EU member state to the US is akin to comparing a US state to the EU. These are big places and Paris and even France are a very, very small part. Europe has some real, real crappy places that really, really mess up Europe's statistics. Once places like Bosnia and Ukraine get in, the stats will get even worse. I doubt Romanian and Ukrainian social spending is very high. Compare to US states and cities in you're comparing EU states and cities, and comparable ones.
- freddealmeida 3y agoWho is paying for all this?
- sylware 3y agoSingapore? 80% of public housing? true?
- javier_e06 3y agoHong Kong has some is highest skyscrapers next to housing that rents cages for people to sleep in: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bedspace_apartment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bedspace_apartment People live in the same neighborhood and there is a cruelty factor of understanding and accepting that in your city poor people live in cages. And people in the US live in tents. At least nobody profits from that.
- GardenLetter27 3y agoPublic housing is terrible - why should the government steal my money (income tax) to pay to house criminals and drug dealers nearby which devalues my property and endangers my life and family? We just need a true Free Market - let people build and invest how they want, where they want. And ensure that everyone has a stake in the property they own and the area they live in.
- epolanski 3y agoBecause as a society we progress at the pace our weakest progress. We don't say China moved ahead because the rich got richer, but because it lifted hundred of millions from poverty. And if anything, a poor social net tends to create more dangers, not less. When people have no roof, no jobs, no help, they will turn into criminals. Hell if I need to eat, or worse, I need to feed my family, I could not care less about becoming a criminal too. Zero. I've seen the dystopia of private neighborhoods with gates and security, the ghettos, the crumbling neighborhoods, endless tents anywhere you look in many major US cities. We don't want this in Europe. I'd rather pay more taxes that help the weakest, not just taxes to punish them and send them to jail. A society with more desperate people makes my life worse, not better just because I can find a more isolated/secure prison where I can avoid looking at them.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago>We don't say China moved ahead because the rich got richer, but because it lifted hundred of millions from poverty. I was under the impression the poor in China moved ahead due to working, not because the Chinese government subsidized their housing or other basics. Although, the Chinese government did subsidize their ability to find and get to work via huge infrastructure projects.
- epolanski 3y agoChina has always had planned housing welfare, it was the only way of building houses for decades. Liberalized housing started in the 90s along the rest, but planned housing projects have kept existing and had huge budgets till the late 2010s. Even today around one in twenty development housing projects is still state funded. Anyway, I was mostly talking about them as a society lifting more and more of the weakest. And yes, building houses has been a major contributor of this obviously as well as a stimulus for the economy.
- rdmreader3319 3y agoI can't pass the paywall but does it mention Paris is losing people? I was living in the 15th arrondissement and this family area turned into a violent zone in a couple of years as they put public housing everywhere. Drug dealers, violence at my kid school, theft... My street became a spot for druggies and I had to pass them with my kids. 15 minutes from the Eiffel tower... I left this city 3 years ago and found safer land. All my friends did the same. There is no sane reason to stay in an area with so much violence. Parisians will deny this but will just say "you have to avoid this and that, have a pepper spray, do not wear a skirt, do not go there at night..."
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20240317093631if_/https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/17/realestate/paris-france-housing-costs.html https://web.archive.org/web/20240317093631if_/https://www.ny...
- wtcactus 3y agoThis measure, as most welfare measures, punishes the middle class - the ones that pay, out of their own pocket the taxes that fund the welfare state. It’s the same story all over Europe: the middle class sees close to 50% of their income taken away in taxes and contributions, and then is left paying for most of their expenses out of their own pocket. Meanwhile rich people only pay a fraction of what they earn in taxes, and “poor” people get most stuff for “free”. The saying is really correct: if you take half of someone’s wage to distribute for two people that didn’t do the same effort, you loose a vote, but you gain two.
- JudasGoat 3y agohttps://archive.ph/IELmI https://archive.ph/IELmI
- rldjbpin 3y agobeing a broke outsider in the city, it has been very difficult to exercise my rights especially in terms of housing. from my limited experience it seems that while in richer neighbourhoods there might be some diversity, it is not the case everywhere. there has been a move to grow the city outwards and move newer social housing further out. but the historically poorer neighbourhoods more or less seem to remain in their older state. however you rationalize it, one ends up questioning whether it is worth living in the city given the challenges in finding a place.