9 ms·
> In summary, I believe there would still be a market for Software Developers in the foreseeable future, though the nature of work will change This is precisel
by JohnFen 3y ago
> In summary, I believe there would still be a market for Software Developers in the foreseeable future, though the nature of work will change
This is precisely what I dread. When it comes to software development specifically, the parts that the AI cheerleaders are excited about AI doing are exactly the parts of the job that I find appealing. If I wanted to be a glorified systems integrator, I would have been doing that job already. The parts that the author is saying will still exist are the parts I put up with in order to do the enjoyable and satisfying work.
So this essay, if it's correct, explains the way that AI threatens my career. Perhaps there is no role for me in the software development world anymore. I'm not saying that's bad in the big picture, just that it's bad for me. It increasingly appears that I've chosen the wrong profession.
- ActionHank 3y agoAlso if there are fewer humans involved in the code production there is a lot of room for producing code that "works", but is not cohesive or maintainable. Invariably there will be a point at which something is broken and someone will need to wade through the mess to find why it's broken and try to fix it.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoNah, you just throw it out and have the AI generate an all new one with different problems!
- Jensson 3y agoI really look forward to all programs now having new strange bugs every release. They already do, but I expect AI to do that more at first.
- CuriouslyC 3y agoThat's how bads use GPT to code. The right way is to ask GPT to break the problem down into a bunch of small strongly typed helper functions with unit tests, then ask it to compose the solution from those helper functions, also with integration tests. If tests fail at any point you can just feed the failure output along with the test and helper function code back in and it will almost always get it right for reasonably non-trivial things by the second try. It can also be good to provide some example helper functions/tests to give it style guidelines.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoIf you're already doing all of this work then it's trivial to actually type all the stuff in yourself Is GPT actually saving you any time if it can't actually do the hard part?
- CuriouslyC 3y agoIt's not really "all this work," once you have good prompts you can use them to crank out a lot of code very quickly. You can use it to crank out thousands of lines of code a day that are somewhat formulaic, but not so formulaic that a simple rules based system could do it. For example, I took text document with headers for table names and unordered lists for table columns, and had it produce a database schema which only required minor tuning, which I then used to generate sqlmodel classes and typescript types. Then I created an example component for one entity and it created similar components for the others in the schema. LLMS are exceptionally good at this sort of domain transformation, a decent engineer could easily crank out 2-5k lines/day if they were mostly doing this sort of work.
- c-cube 3y agoNow your description of "good prompts" to reuse has created an abomination in my mind. I blame you. The abomination: prompts being reused by way of yaml templating, a Helm chart of sorts but for LLM prompts. The delicious combination of yaml programming and prompt engineering. I hope it never exists.
- 3y ago
- AlwaysRock 3y agoThis is the future imagined by A Fire Upon the Deep and its sequel. While less focused on the code being generated by ai, it features seemingly endless amounts of code and programs that can do almost anything but the difficulty is finding the program that works for you and is safe to use. To some extent... This is already the world we live in. A lot of code is unreadable without a lot of effort or expertise. If all code was open sourced there would almost certainly be code written to do just about anything you'd like it to. The difficulty would be finding that code and customizing it for your use.
- Normalcy294812 3y agoThanks for the Book Title. It looks like an interesting read.
- scubbo 3y agoCaution - lots of people like to talk about this "code archeology" idea as if it's a central driving point of the book, whereas in fact it's mentioned once in passing in the prologue and is never again relevant to the story. Don't get me wrong, it's still a decent book on its own merits - but don't go into it expecting that to be the main point of the book (I did, and disappointed as a result).
- JackMorgan 3y agoAs a counterpoint, the main nemesis of the book comes from software that is found in archaeological expedition. While software archeology doesn't show up after the first chapter, the ramifications of what happens in that world due to so much software is pretty central.
- scubbo 3y agoThis is certainly true, and doesn't detract from my disappointment not to have actually seen the software archeology in practice.
- 3y ago
- broast 3y agoCertainly many of us here already have a good amount of experience debugging giant legacy spaghetti code-bases written by people you can't talk to, or people who can't debug their own code. That job may not change much.
- billforsternz 3y agoI remember one such occasion back in a previous tech boom (late 90s) and it turned out the reason I couldn't talk to the guy who wrote this particular pile of Italian nutrition was that the Feds had shown up one day and taken him to jail (something to do with pump and dump market manipulation via a faked analyst report [edit: actually a faked press release I now remember. "SmallCapCorp (NASDAQ: SCC$) announces they have received a record breaking order for their next gen product / aquisition offer / something like that from RandomIsraeliCompanyThatMightNotEvenHaveExisted"]). A lot of software engineers would spend a portion of their day tracking their volatile stock / options etc. in those years.
- mbil 3y agoMaybe I'm being overly optimistic but in a future where a model can digest hundreds of thousands of lines of code, write unit tests, and do refactors, will this even be a problem?
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoIn the limit, it's all professions. :p Software development tomorrow, $other_profession the day after tomorrow. But same; if AI starts writing code and my job becomes tweaking pre-written code, I'm planning an exit strategy. :D
- warbled_tongue 3y agoThis resonates strongly with me. I don't want to describe the painting, I want to paint it. If this is indeed where we end up, I don't know that I'll change professions (I'm 30+ years into it), but the joy will be gone. It will truly become "just a job".
- sanity 3y agoI remember back in the 80s I had friends who enjoyed coding in assembly and felt that using higher-level languages was "cheating" - isn't this just a continuation of that?
- xandrius 3y agoGreat point. I think this will weed out the people doing tech purely for the sake of tech and will bring more creative minds who see the technology as a tool to achieve a goal.
- brailsafe 3y agoIndeed, can't wait for the day when technical people can stop relishing in the moments of intimate problem solving between stamping out widgets, and instead spend all day constantly stamping out widgets while thinking about the incredible bullshit they'll be producing for pennies. Thanks boss!
- xandrius 3y agoIt feels that people commenting on this post are forgetting that tools have evolved since the times of punch cards or writing only in pure assembly. I personally wouldn't have enjoyed being that kind of programmer as it was a tedious and very slow process, where the creativity of the developer was rather low as the complexities of development would not allow for just anyone to be part of it (my own assumption). Today we have IDEs, autocomplete, quick visual feedback (inspectors, advanced debuggers, etc.) which allow people who enjoy creating and seeing the results of their work as opposed to purely be typing code for someone else. So, I don't get why people jump straight to thinking that adding yet another efficiency tool would destroy everything. To me it seems to make developing simpler applications something which doesn't require a computer science degree, that's all.
- pksebben 3y agoAt the risk of exposing my pom-poms, it's not the writing of the code or the design of the systems that I find the current batch of AI useful for. Probably the biggest thing that GPT does for me these days is to replace google (which probably wouldn't be necessary if google hadn't become such hot garbage). As I say this, I'm made aware of the incoming rug-pull when the LLMs start spitting SEO trash in my face as well, but right now they don't which is just the best. A close second is having a rubber duck that can actually have a cogent thought once in a while. It's a lot easier to talk through a problem when you have something that will never get tired of listening - try starting with a prompt like "I don't want advice or recommendations, but instead ask me questions to elaborate on things that aren't completely clear". The results (sometimes) can be really, really good.
- tomjakubowski 3y agoFor me the principal benefit of ChatGPT is it helps me to maintain focus on a problem I'm solving, while I wait for a slow build or test suite or what ever. I can bullshit about it without annoying my coworkers with Slack messages. And sometimes I'll find the joy reveling in the chatbot's weird errors and hallucinations. I suppose my lunch is about to be eaten by all these people who will use it to automate the software engineer job away. So it goes
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoCall me a cynic (many have, especially on this topic) but I can't help but think that the majority of what AI will "successfully" replace in terms of craftsmanship is going to be stuff that would've never been produced the "correct" way if you will. It's going to be code created for and to suit the interests of the business major class. Just like AI art isn't really suitable for anything above hobby fun stuff like generating your D&D character's avatar, or product packaging stock photo junk or header images for LinkedIn blog posts. Anything that's actually important is going to still need to be designed, and that goes for creative work like design, and proper code-work for development too, IMO. Like sure, these AI's can generate code that works. Can they generate replacement code when you need to change how something works? Can they troubleshoot code that isn't doing what it's meant to? And if you can generate the code you want but then need to tweak it after to suit your purpose, is that... really that much faster than just writing the thing in your style, in a way you understand, that you can then change later as required? I dunno. I've played with these tools and they're neat, and I think they can be good for learning a new language or framework, but once I'm actually ready to build something, I don't see myself starting with AI generation for any substantial part of it.
- Oioioioiio 3y agoThe question is not about what AI can do today but what we assume AI will be able to do tomorrow. All of what you wrote in your second paragraph will become something AI will be doing better and faster than you. We never had technology which can write code like this. I prompted ChatGPT to write a very basic java tool which renders an image from an url and makes it bigger on a click. It just did it. Its not hard to think further and a lot of technology is already going into this direction. Alone last week devin was showne. Gemini has a window token of 1 Million tokens. Groq shows us how it will feel to have instant response. Right now its already good enough that people with Copilot like to keep it when asked. We already now pay billions for AI daily. This means the amount of research, business motivation and money flowing into it now is probably staggering in comparision to what moved this field a few years ago. Its not clear at all how fast we will progress but i'm pretty sure, we will hit a time were every junior is worse than AI which will force people of rethinking what they are going to do. Do i hire an junior and train him/her? Or do i prefer to invest more into AI? The gap will widen and widen, a generation or a certain amount of people will stay longer and might be able to stay in development but a lot of others might just not.
- jayd16 3y agoI understand your feelings but I do also wonder if its not similar to complaining about compilers or garbage collection. I'm sure there are people that love fiddling with assembly and memory management by hand. I assume there will be plenty of interesting/novel problems no matter the tooling because, fundamentally, software is about solving such problems.
- imbnwa 3y agoSoftware engineering as an occupation grew because of static analysis and GCs (literally why the labor market is the size that it is as we speak); the opposite appears to be the outcome of AI advances.
- glasss 3y agoThe same happened with accountants and spreadsheet software, the number of accounting jobs grew. The actual work they performed became different. I think a similar thing is likely to happen in the software world.
- imbnwa 3y agoTech has already learned there’s not enough real frontier left to reap the bounty of(removing zero interest rates that incentivize mere flow of capital). This stuff is being invested in to yield the most productivity at the least cost. There will either be a permanent net decrease in demand or, being so high level, most openings will pay no more than 60-70K in an America (likely with reduced benefits) where wages are already largely stagnant.
- glasss 3y agoI think there is definitely merit to your statements. I believe the future of the average software developer job involves a very high level language, API integration, basic full stack work with a lot of AI assistance. And those roles will mostly be at small to medium businesses who can't afford the salaries or benefits that the industry has standard in the US. Almost every small business I know has an accountant or book keeper position which is just someone who had no formal education and the role is just managing QuickBooks. I don't think the need for formally educated accountants who can handle large corporate books decreased significantly, but I don't have any numbers to back that up. Just making the comparison to say I don't think the hard / cool stuff that a lot of software developers love doing is going away. But these are just my thoughts.
- Towaway69 3y agoBeing a developer, I heartily agree with you. Being a human, I realise that I as a developer have put a lot of people out of a job. Those folks have had to adapt to that change. I guess now it's our time to adapt to change. At least it keeps me on my feet!
- imbnwa 3y agoThe catch is that those people could, barring the AI advances we seem to be seeing, could retrain for an SWE labor market that lagged demand; that wont even be possible for devs put out of work in the future.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoThose people who did retrain are the same devs being put out of work - which means they got hit with the setback twice and are worse off than people who started off as devs and thus only got hit once. Like the allied bomber pilots in WWII looking down below at the firestorm knowing that there is a good chance (~45%) that they too will join their fate only later.
- JohnFen 3y ago> I guess now it's our time to adapt to change. I'm just saddened by the prospect that, for me, "adapting to change" would mean "no longer being able to make a living doing what I actually enjoy". that's why if this is the future, it's a career-killing one for me. Whether or not I stay in the industry, there is no future in my chosen career path, and the alternative paths that people keep bringing up all sound pretty terrible to me. My only hope is that AI will not achieve the heights that its proponents are trying to reach (I suspect this is the case). I see no other good outcome for me.
- Towaway69 3y agoIf AI does achieve the hyped heights then we're all out of a job, regardless of what we do. Many people suffer through bullshit jobs[1] so we are privileged to have - at least for a time - done what we really enjoy and got paid for it. [1] David Graeber father of the term "bullshit jobs"
- barfbagginus 3y agoYou will be able to speak what human needs must be fulfilled. Then the code will appear and you'll be able to meet those human needs. You, not a boss, will own the code. And if you have any needs, you will be able to speak the word and those needs will be met. You will no longer need to work at all. Whatever you want to build, you will be able to build it. What about that frightens you?
- Pugpugpugs 3y agoWhat if we don’t hit AGI and instead the tools just get pretty good and put lots of people out of work while making the top 0.1% vastly richer? Now you’ve got no prospects, no power, and barely any money.
- galdosdi 3y agoThe only real wealth have, at the end of the day is: your health, your relationships, and your ability and willingness to eat beans.
- barfbagginus 3y agoThat's the scenario I'm assuming. Lots of people out of work, then they start working on ai and using it to solve the post-work survival problem. But this relies on a few assumptions. 1) there will be open source AI that can solve low resource survival problems, 2) civilians will be able to run these AIs on whatever computing resources they're able to scrounge together, 3) the solutions the systems come up with will let civilians survive or revolt without access to high levels of capital, 4) the systems will NOT rise to the level of independent power gaining AGIs Note that I have specifically assumed that we don't have independent AGIs. If we hit AGI, then I don't think we can assume that anyone will be able to use AI to solve the problems of post work survival. The AGI will do what it wants to do. I'm not sure how civilians should position themselves in that situation.
- JohnFen 3y agoNone of that frightens me, but I also think that none of that is in the realm of reasonable possibility.
- dist-epoch 3y agoMost knifes today are mass produced. But there are still knife craftsman. You could become a software craftsman/artist if you enjoy writing software.
- javajosh 3y agoThe market is different, and so is the supply. The market for artisanal cutlery is basically an art market. The programmer supply today is an approaching-standardization factory worker. There IS an art market for software, in the indie gaming space, so perhaps that will survive (and AI could actually really help individual creators tremendously). But the work-a-day enterprise developer's days are numbered. The great irony being that all the work we've done to standardize, framework-ize the work makes us more fungible and replaceable by AI. The result I foresee is a further concentration of power into the hands of those with capital enough to own data-centers with AI capable hardware; the petite bourgeoisie will shrink to those able to maintain that hardware and (perhaps) as a finishing interface between the AI's output and the human controlling the capital that placed the order. It definitely harms the value proposition of people who's main talent is understanding computers well enough to make useful software with them. THAT is rapidly commoditizing.
- exceptione 3y agoSince AI has been trained on the generous gifts of the collective (books, code repos, art, ..), it begs the question why normal societies would not start to regulate them as a collective good. I can foresee two forces that will work against society to claim it back: - Dominance of neoliberalism thought, with its strong belief that for any disease markets will be the cure. - Strong lobby from big corporates. You don't want to intervene to early, but you have to make sure you have at least some limits before you let the winners do too much damage. The EU has to be applauded for having a critical look on what effects these developments might have, for instance which sectors will face unemployment. That is in the interest of both people and business, because the winner takes it all means economic and scientific stagnation. I fear that 90% of the worlds' data is already in the hand of just a few behemots, so there is already no level playing field (which is btw caused by aforementioned dominance of neoliberalism).
- gitfan86 3y agoI'm the opposite. I enjoy engineering and understanding systems. Manually coding has been a necessary to build systems up until now. AWS similarly was great because it provided a functional abstraction over the details of the data center. On a personal level I feel bad for the people who enjoyed wiring up small data centers or enjoyed writing GitHub comments about which lint rules were the best. But I'm glad those are no longer necessary.
- bamboozled 3y agoPeople still wire up data centres.
- rzzzt 3y agoRyan D. Anderson's "We Wanna Do the Fun Stuff" captures this very concisely: https://www.instagram.com/itsryandanderson/p/BrY0N-lH31p/ https://www.instagram.com/itsryandanderson/p/BrY0N-lH31p/
- jacobr1 3y agoI suspect this is the wrong take. AI can only perform integrations when there are systems to integrate. The frontier of interesting work to be done isn't supervising an integration AI, but building out the hard components that will be integrated. Integration work itself already has been moving up the stack to low-code type tools and power-user like people over the past decade even before LLMs become the new thing.
- Braini 3y agoThese are exactly my thoughts. I comfort myself by thinking that it is still a while away and also not certain, but this might just be willful ignorance on my side. Because TBH, no clue yet what else I would like to (or even could) do.
- bamboozled 3y agoWhatever you decide to do next will be automated soon after anyway…career change ? Don’t bother. Jump on the progress train
- godelski 3y agoSorry, can you clarify more? I don't think I understand. The part you enjoy the most is the integrating of systems, right? If that's really your passion, I'm not sure you're in danger of losing your job to AI. AI is not great at nuance and this is exponentially more challenging than what we've done so far. I'm just assuming that since this is your passion (if I'm understanding correctly) that you see it as the puzzle it is and the complexities and uniqueness of each integration. If you're the type of person that's frustrated by low quality or quick shortcuts and not understanding the nuances actually involved, I think you're safe. I don't see AI pushing out deep thinkers and the "annoying" nuance devs anytime soon. I'm that kinda person too and yeah, I'm not as fast as my colleagues. But another friend (who is similar) and I both are surprised how often other people in our lab and groups we work with (we're researchers) talk about how essential GPT and copilot are to their workflows. Because neither of us think this way. I use GPT(4) almost every day, but it's impossible for me to get it to write good quality code. It's great at giving me routines and skeletons, but the real engineering part takes far more time to talk the LLM into than it does to write it (including all the time to google or even collaborate with GPT[0]). LLMs can do tough things, but their abilities are clearly directly proportional to the frequency of the appearance of those tasks. So I think it is the coding bootcamp people that are in the most danger. There are expert people that are also at risk though. These are the extremely narrow expertise people. Because you can target LLMs for specific tasks. But if your skills are the skills that define us as humans, I wouldn't lose too much sleep. I say this as a ML researcher myself. And I highly encourage everyone to get into the mindset of thinking with nuance. It has other benefits too. But I also think we need to think about how to transition into a post scarce world, because that is the goal and we don't need AGI for that. [0] A common workflow for me is actually due to the shittiness of Google. Where it overfits certain words and ignores the advanced things like quotes or NOTs. Or similarly broaching into a new high level topic. I can't trust GPT's answer, but it will sure use keywords and vernacular I don't know that enable me to make a more powerful search. (But google employees should not take away that they should push LLMs into google search but rather that search is mostly good but that same nuance is important and being too forceful and repeating 5 pages of essentially the same garbage is not working. The SEO people attacked you and they won. It looks like you let them win too...)
- 3y ago
- bornAgin 3y ago[dead]
- jimbokun 3y agoIt’s interesting how all of these articles implicitly assume AI keeps getting more intelligent then at some point just…stops. There’s no reason to think AI won’t also take over all the parts you don’t find appealing, too. The whole point of the Singularity, is that no aspect of human work cannot be performed better by superhumanly intelligent machines.
- goatlover 3y agoThe point of the Singularity is that it's a futurist prediction, and we all know how often people are wrong about the future.
- jimbokun 3y agoKurzweil’s predictions from 20, 30 years ago have been disturbingly on target and there is no clear reason why the current rate of progress will suddenly stop.
- B56b 3y agoUmm, no I would not describe Ray Kurzweil's predictions as "disturbingly on target". Dan Luu checked everything and came up with 7% accuracy: https://danluu.com/futurist-predictions/ https://danluu.com/futurist-predictions/.
- poulsbohemian 3y ago> Still be a market for Software Developers in the foreseeable future, though the nature of work will change Back 25 years ago when I graduated, everyone kept saying there wouldn't be a need for software developers. Either the work was going to get sent overseas to the cheapest bidder or it was all going to get automated away anyway. I even recall CEOs making outrageous claims like "we didn't need any new software" as if all the software to run the world had already been built and would magically continue to run without maintenance. We heard the same thing once upon a time about manufacturing too, but now we see a shift back on shore for manufacturing that we once thought was gone, either to robotics or offshore. It's different than before, but still manufacturing. Software developers are still here, their compensation has overall increased dramatically, but of course the nature and the demands of the work continue to shift. Will it be different in 20 years? Of course, but it will still be software development.