18 ms·
Sweden Is a NATO Member
- gitaarik 3y ago"Sweden’s instrument of accession was deposited with the United States Government, as depositary of the North Atlantic Treaty." What does this sentence actually mean? What is an instrument of accession? What does it mean for it to be "deposited with the US government"?
- Vecr 3y ago"Instrument of accession" is the document that says Sweden is now in NATO. "Deposited with the US government" means physically deposited, within the continental US.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoMan the shillbots are out hard for this one. you seeing this u/dang? GPT is a genie out of the bottle and it's an election year, so it's only going to get worse.
- timka 3y agoAny 50+ Europeans here?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lawn 3y agoFinally. I'm going to celebrate by opening a bottle of red wine from Ukraine, seems fitting.
- rsynnott 3y agoI was about to say that it'd beat a bottle of wine from Sweden, anyway, but felt the need to fact-check my joke, and apparently Swedish wine is a thing!
- hinkley 3y agoThere’s a little wine country just off of Lake Superior. The water buffers the temperatures enough to keep grapes happy. I know the Baltic is probably colder than Lake Superior, but it sounds like it works anyway.
- rsynnott 3y agoLooking at the weather averages for Duluth (chosen at random), no, that actually looks probably colder than the heavily populated bits of Sweden, certainly in the winter.
- hinkley 3y agoThe wine region is the little corner of Michigan just north of Indiana. They also do apples and cheese. I’m not sure how far north the region extends, but I’ve been there a few times. So that’s quite a bit farther south than the Swedish peninsula.
- rsynnott 3y agoSo, _London_ is further north than anywhere in the contiguous United States. But obviously much warmer than a lot of it, particularly in winter (London rarely gets far below 0 Celsius). Latitude very much isn’t everything.
- hinkley 3y agoYeah the ocean does a lot. If you look at the prevailing winds off of the eastern atlantic, it looks a lot like Southern Sweden gets the same air that London does. Plus there's a couple of considerable lakes along that path, so grapes do seem plausible.
- tharmas 3y ago[flagged]
- gruturo 3y ago>Was it worth it What extremely stupid question is that? They didn't choose to get invaded. You think we shouldn't have helped? Pity we're not helping enough.
- tharmas 3y agoWhy is it a stupid question? Their country is destroyed. The demographics are abysmal. All the youth destroyed. The USA and Ukraine should've negotiated a deal years and years ago that Ukraine would be a neutral state and NOT join NATO. Ukraine will never join NATO. USA knows that that will trigger Nuclear War.
- Gibbon1 3y agoIf Russia uses nukes the president will order a non nuclear strike that kills Putin.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Hamuko 3y agoAre you trying to say that Ukraine would've preferred to be completely taken over by Russia?
- ethbr1 3y agoOn the one hand, Ukrainians are being killed (although GP is incorrect -- Ukraine has specifically been drafting older, non-youth people) and their industry is being bombed. On the other hand, they're still a sovereign, free state. Opinions may vary on which of those is more important. As historical context, I would point out that the last time ethnic Russians controlled Ukraine, they killed 3M+ of them via starvation. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor
- euroderf 3y agoTry their beer. Obolon is good stuff.
- iam-TJ 3y agoLooking at the flag colours I cannot but think that Sweden is paving the way for Ukraine's membership.
- tharmas 3y ago[flagged]
- dralley 3y agoAnd here I was thinking that "arrogant" was expecting a neighboring country, whose nation, identity and language you claim "aren't real", whose people you call "little Russians", would fall at your feet within days. And flagrantly violating every agreement that has ever been made w/r/t Ukraine. And killing political opposition with impunity. And giving medals to every soldier in the units stationed in Bucha a few days after of the massacres were uncovered. And "annexing" regions of Ukraine where your soldiers haven't even reached, and putting them on official maps of Russia. And using chemical and radiological weapons to conduct assassinations on UK soil. And blowing up Czech ammo depots. And telling the world that if there were any Russian soldiers amongst the "little green men" in Crimea, they were merely on vacation. And this trash: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-60562240 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-60562240.
- avtolik 3y agoIf the people of Ukraine want to get in NATO for protection, how is this the West being arrogant?
- tharmas 3y agoStudy great power politics and you will understand what I mean. Russia is a nuclear power. That means no matter how much you dislike them for whatever reasons you don't go giving them the finger. That's like giving the Mafia boss the finger when he has a gun pointed at your head. You might think that's brave defiance but inarguably that will get you killed. Study the outrage in the USA when Russia put nuclear missiles in Cuba, when Cuba, a sovereign country asked for those missiles (aka The Cuban Missile Crisis). Substitute Cuba for Ukraine and USA for Russia and you will be begin to understand the Russian point of view. But hey the West is Right, We are the Good Guys, always on the side of Freedom and Democracy so we can't be wrong. Just ask the Palestinians in Gaza.
- bilekas 3y agoThis is great news and NATO benefits hugely from this. I have to hand it to putin for bringing further solidarity across Europe and NATO.
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoHow does NATO benefit?
- Paradigma11 3y agoSweden and Finland came as a pack so lets talk about both of them. Benefits: It completely neutralizes the Russian Baltic Fleet. The only railway line supporting Murmansk is less than 200km beyond the finnish border, which means the Nordic Fleet is also compromised. Potential disadvantages of additional members are added political instability as can be seen with Hungary and Turkey. There is little chance of this with both countries. Basically you dont defend members, you defend borders and adding Finland and Sweden to the pact makes for a far easier and better developed front. The Finns have been building bunkers and training their population for the next Russian invasion since WW2. Having Finland as a member strengthens the position of the Baltics, who are threatened by the Suwalki corridor. Basically it strengthens and stabilizes the northern border to Russia/Belarus.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- toyg 3y agoBy having to jump through fewer hoops to get the intelligence they already got before, and likely further restricting the field of operation for Russian forces in that area.
- Hamuko 3y agoSweden has a pretty solid defense industry. Gripens and NLAWs for example are Swedish production.
- nextos 3y ago
- dralley 3y agoHere's hoping this means they can send Gripen, finally.
- ImHereToVote 3y agoSure. The US Military Industrial Complex loves to share.
- dralley 3y agoWhat does Gripen have to do with the US military industrial complex? The US isn't the ones sending F-16s anyway.
- sspiff 3y agoThe parent comment is referring to the US pressuring all European NATO members to abandon plans to acquire Saab or Dassault jets in favour of its own F35.
- dralley 3y agoAh, so mythology. Most of the European nations with F-35 currently either joined the program from the beginning decades ago, or want to participate in nuclear deterrent and have no other option (unless France decides to share their nukes, but that hasn't happened yet, and you can bet they'll want you to buy Rafale for the privilege if they do), or want stealth capabilities which nobody else can offer right now, or want greater compatibility with the US munitions stockpile which is vastly larger than what Europe has available... etc. Jets take a long time to develop, the time for Europe to get serious about "strategic autonomy" in that respect was 2 decades ago. That didn't happen, so now the F-35 is the only option if they want the capability to penetrate Russian ground-based air defenses and consistently beat the Su-57 (cough all 8 of them, but it's possible they scale up eventually).
- Vilian 3y agoi think you are giving to much credit to su-57 needing f-35 to be beaten consistently, other than that i also agree with you
- pavlov 3y agoJust in time for Trump to do the rug pull he agreed with Putin back in 2018, when they met in Helsinki and Trump took care to even destroy translator’s notes. If he wins the election, NATO is toast and Putin has carte blanche over East Europe.
- seydor 3y agoSwedes would then be stupid to join nato knowing that Trump is more likely to win, and swedes are not stupid. The US foreign policy seems to have a continuity regardless of president or rhetoric-du-jour. Just look at china
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoPutin isn't even going to take Ukraine. So how's he going to reign free over all of Eastern Europe?
- stronglikedan 3y agoWhen, not if, and that's a good thing. I don't share your alarmist view. I think the other members of NATO will just start doing their fair share, as they should.
- apercu 3y agoI imagine that the actual truth to the situation is far more complicated than either of us understand and that NATO provides substantial benefits to the United States.
- KingOfCoders 3y agoNATO membership enables the US to have air bases in the UK and Turkey, Navy bases in Spain and Italy, and in other parts of Europe with overflight rights for military planes. Most of the air traffic for the US wars in the middle east goes through Germany, and most injured soldiers go back through Germany [0] Many US soldiers survive because they get through Landstuhl. Ramstein is also rumored to be the primary operation center for drone strikes, although the US military denies this. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landstuhl_Regional_Medical_Center https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landstuhl_Regional_Medical_Cen...
- pphysch 3y agoSerious question, what does this change? NATO gets a bit more revenue from Swedish taxpayers? So what?
- TomJansen 3y agoThe super strategic island Gotland, for one.
- nicolapede 3y agoIf you look at the Baltic Sea before and after the invasion of Ukraine, that was largely a neutral space (before) that has since turned into a NATO one -- excluding only the Russian exclave of Kaliningrad. I would argue this makes any further move by Russia in that space quite problematic.
- pphysch 3y agoSweden and Finland have been in the EU for almost 30 years. Sweden joining NATO does not really change the geopolitics of the Baltic.
- tw04 3y agoOf course it does. Sweden and Finland being members of the EU had absolutely 0 bearing on the US getting involved in a war with Russia. Do you honestly think Russia would've tried to invade Ukraine if they were NATO members?
- jajko 3y agoEU is economical/societal effort (or war prevention), NATO is military (and doesn't prevent members from fighting, ie Greece vs Turkey). Ever heard of actual EU army? Doesn't exist out there in the world, maybe on paper.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Ever heard of actual EU army? Well, there's Eurocorps for the last few decades, but that's not an army, just a corps-level HQ unit under which component-state forces can be slotted. OTOH, that's not a particularly poor model for a fairly loose multi-state federation. On the other other hand, its not actually an EU force, its a force of a particular group of EU states that is made available to both the EU and NATO, and has conducted operations on behalf of each.
- dataflow 3y agoDoes being in NATO obligate you to respond militarily if another member is attacked (as is commonly believed)? I failed to find this clause in the text last time I looked. Edit: for everyone telling me to read article 5: I already have, hence this question. It says each member "will assist [...] by taking [...] such action as it deems necessary". That very much doesn't appear to obligate a military response, or any response at all. To put it another way, the treaty really doesn't seem to mean much, so far as I can tell? Countries could already help each other out (or not) anyway... no?
- hyggetrold 3y agoYes - Article 5 - the absolutely key piece of NATO.
- jedberg 3y agoArticle 5 https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/topics_110496.htm https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/topics_110496.htm
- SamBam 3y agoDid you actually take a look at the text of the treaty? It's very short and readable. Article 5 is what you're looking for. https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/official_texts_17120.htm https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/official_texts_17120.ht...
- dataflow 3y agoYes? It says "will assist" and "such action as it deems necessary". That doesn't obligate them to provide a military response. What makes you believe otherwise?
- thatwasunusual 3y agoBecause no member wants to be seen as unreliable, risking their own security in the future, so everyone will in practice assist in any way they can.
- philip1209 3y agoWhat happened with Turkey's opposition to this?
- Kerrick 3y ago> Stockholm introduced a new anti-terrorism bill that makes being a member of a terrorist organisation illegal. Sweden, Finland, Canada and the Netherlands also took steps to relax policies on arms exports to Turkey. [...] Erdogan, who had sent Sweden's bid to parliament in October, linked the ratification to U.S. approval of sales of F-16 fighter jets to Turkey. https://www.reuters.com/world/turkey-set-approve-swedens-nato-membership-bid-after-long-delay-2024-01-23/ https://www.reuters.com/world/turkey-set-approve-swedens-nat...
- u320 3y agoThis law was a response to the terror attacks of 2017, and was mostly already done when Putin invaded. As a political thing, Sweden and Turkey informally agreed to pretend this was a concession so that Erdogan could look good for his election. The problem was then that this lie was just a bit too credible, so people started to believe in it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- redder23 3y ago[flagged]
- yawnxyz 3y agoYes, this is a great way to fight against Putin, but... As a Swedish citizen, I think this means in the future Sweden's forces will be dragged into another Iraq-like war down the line. Sooner or later the US or NATO will be the Putin of today, and I don't look forward to that.
- troupo 3y ago> I think this means in the future Sweden's forces will be dragged into another Iraq-like war down the line This doesn't follow from the NATO treaty. Perhaps the U.S. will have it's freedom herring moment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_fries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_fries
- screenobobeano 3y ago[flagged]
- partiallypro 3y agoNATO countries only have to react if other member countries are attacked. NATO did not participate in Iraq; some members did but as a coalition they did not. They did participate in some operations in Afghanistan post-911 however, because that was a direct attack on a NATO member. Also saying the US or NATO are remotely similar to Putin is both-sides-ing nonsense.
- CogitoCogito 3y agoWell Sweden could later leave the alliance if it no longer fit its interests. I doubt they would leave just to get out of being "dragged into another Iraq-like war" since well supporting your allies is the whole point of NATO, but if the US or the rest of NATO took the place of Putin, then maybe Sweden really would leave the alliance. edit: Also wasn't article 5 invoked by the US against Afghanistan and not Iraq? (Maybe I'm not remembering right.)
- realityking 3y agoGermany and France, both NATO members, did bot participate in the Iraq war. Also NATO itself did not as there was no consensus among the members to be involved. In Afghanistan there was the necessary consensus (and Article 5 was invoked) so NATO took an active role and ran ISAF - to which Sweden contributed quite significant troops.
- alecco 3y agoGreat War vibes.
- Teknomancer 3y agoGreat, now they help pay for this mess!
- screenobobeano 3y ago[flagged]
- richrichie 3y ago[flagged]
- heroiccocoa 3y agoThe destruction, death and injuries seen in occupied Ukraine are already absolutely equivalent to nuclear war, minus the radiation. Also, I imagine the next nuclear weapons to be used in conflict will try to minimize their lingering "dirty" nature. So the added threat of nuclear annihilation is inconsequential.
- somenameforme 3y agoHiroshima and Nagasaki killed over 200,000 - almost entirely civilians. And those were tiny little bombs relative to what exists now a days. The biggest nuke ever tested, Tsar Bomba, is more than 3,000 more powerful than those. And many don't seem to realize what nuclear war will be like. It's not going to be two sides launching little tactical nukes at each other's armies. If nuclear war breaks out, the involved countries are going to try to eliminate the other country. Not their army or their military, which can be rebuilt, but literally completely destroy the other country. US nuclear targets were declassified some time back. [1] While we did of course focus on trying to eliminate Soviet air capability, we were also planning to extensively bomb civilian population centers, medical production centers, industry, and more. And it's 100% guaranteed that the Soviet target list looked pretty similar. Conventional war is nothing even remotely comparable to what nuclear war will entail. [1] - https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/23/us/politics/1950s-us-nuclear-target-list-offers-chilling-insight.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/23/us/politics/1950s-us-nucl...
- renegade-otter 3y agoBeing a NATO member gives a nation more security than nuclear weapons, effectively. Nuclear states can and HAVE gone to wars - but no one wants to mess with the devastating conventional power of NATO. After the recent gutting, Russia has a few dozen SU-34s that can fly. NATO has thousands of planes.
- __loam 3y agoIt also just got a lot more Gripens.
- rickydroll 3y agoit did?? can you point me to articles on this?
- Oath 3y agoI think they are referring to Sweden adding Gripens to NATO, not that Russia is receiving any.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y ago> Russia has a few dozen SU-34s that can fly And Ukraine is about to receive their F-16s
- danlugo92 3y agoIs this similar to sending ammunitions or "worse"(e.g. more provoking of WW3)...?
- candiodari 3y agoThe problem with that is simple: if one side believes they are at war, 2 sides are at war. And Russia has explained why they believe they are at war, the insane dictator at the top explained that in the 13th century it was really unfair that some army marched from Poland to what is now Chechnya (even Tucker Carlsson frowned as hard as he could and needed about 6 seconds to collect his jaw from the floor) and therefore Ukraine isn't a "real" nation and should be part of Russia. And that, in any case, Russia has the borders it chooses, as does any large country.
- alienicecream 3y agoAdding another western European country that's under no threat from anyone to NATO isn't going to do anything. We should be adding backwards countries that share borders with or are targets of major enemies, like Georgia and Taiwan. You can't control the world if all you're doing is protecting yourself and your buddies from yourself and your buddies. We need to get Israel in NATO so that the next time Hezbollah fires a missile into an Israeli town we can finally invade Iran. We need to antagonize the other major powers by putting military bases in small countries all around their borders.
- tharmas 3y ago[flagged]
- yakshaving_jgt 3y ago[flagged]
- tharmas 3y ago[flagged]
- unethical_ban 3y agoI'm told by maps that Crimea, Donbas and Donetsk regions are part of a nation called Ukraine, and Russia sent tanks, jets and bombs to destroy cities against the wishes of the government of Ukraine. That's what is known in international diplomacy as a "dick move".
- yakshaving_jgt 3y agoI have residence in Odesa, Ukraine. As do most of my friends. I have spent countless nights sheltering from missiles and drones launched by the terrorist state of russia. Miss me with this bullshit.
- deleted 3y ago
- miroljub 3y ago[flagged]
- btmiller 3y agoI had the same question and I don’t think I can squint enough to make this post make sense. I really enjoy coming here for the tech/hacker concentration, though I do miss the general audience topics you’d find on old Reddit. While I don’t use Reddit any more, I’m concerned that allowing general audience topics like this is a path toward diluting the best thing about HN.
- dralley 3y agoHow is this less relevant to HN than, say, tidal locking, or bird brains, or sourdough bread, or jetliners, or god forbid the Gaza conflict?
- safgasCVS 3y agoLemme be the guy who farts in the elevator. Sweden has managed to avoid entangling itself in military conflicts around the world for centuries and by joining NATO it’s got itself security but at the expense of potentially involving itself in conflicts regardless if Swedes want to be involved or not. Anyways it seems popular in Sweden but the naive lefty in me still thinks it’s a shame at the collective high-fiving
- droopyEyelids 3y agoPossibly. Article 5 only says every other member "will assist" with "such action as it deems necessary" International law is in many ways a ghost of what we think of as law. There are no enforcement mechanisms. If Sweden failed to involve itself and the USA/NATO wanted to push the point, we'd just apply trade pressure & sanctions to them. But we could and would do that same thing without Sweden being in NATO. (That's how we established the 'coalition of the willing' for the Iraq invasion, and how UN votes are organized)
- Hamuko 3y agoWikipedia would suggest that the Kingdom of Sweden has involved itself in multiple military conflicts in the past century or so, including NATO ops. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_involving_Sweden#Kingdom_of_Sweden_(1905%E2%80%93present) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_involving_Sweden#...
- tshaddox 3y ago> potentially involving itself in conflicts regardless if Swedes want to be involved or not The Riksdag voted 269–37 to pass the NATO accession bill, and my understanding is that this is representative of the majority of the Swedish population. Since NATO’s rules regarding military conflict are a rather conspicuous part of NATO membership, I’d hazard to say the Swedes are being quite explicit about the sort of involvement they desire.
- ProjectArcturis 3y agoWhy should we celebrate neutrality in the face of evil? Surely Sweden would be more proud of its history if it had fought against the Nazis rather than helping them. WW2 would have been shorter as well.
- seydor 3y agoThis is actually very significant, this time NATO expands to the west, and who knows where next. I wonder what was the debate in Sweden all this time (beyond the waiting for some dictators to give them the final approval)
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoIt's time for the USA to step out of NATO. Will surely happen when Trump comes to power.
- unethical_ban 3y agoExtraordinary opinions call for elaboration.
- moogly 3y agoThere was practically no debate this time. Not because everyone was on board, but because any debate was basically suppressed. There was some debate in the past couple of decades however.
- u320 3y agoThere was no debate because everyone was on board. I'm so sick and tired about people lying about this online. There was an election! And many, many polls! ALL OF THEM SHOWED LIKE 80% SUPPORT! But the anti-Nato people are butthurt and feel the need to rewrite history to foreigners. Din jävla fjant.
- hnthrowaway0328 3y agoIt would be nice if EU seek independency from US eventually.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- freedomben 3y agoI don't necessarily disagree as IMHO a diverse world that more accurately reflects the desires of local populations is a good thing, but I'd be curious to know why you would like the EU to seek independency from the US. What do you mean by that? Economic or more? Do you mean more home-grown tech companies for example?
- solardev 3y agoNot the OP, but in context, the US is a huge part of NATO's overall defense (and offense/force projection) capabilities. The EU on its own would have a harder time defending itself against aggression.
- somenameforme 3y agoIt's effectively impossible to invade a country that has nuclear weapons. There might be small scale border skirmishes, but large scale organized invasions are essentially a nonstarter. The main purpose of conventional weaponry, for nuclear nations, is to invade non-nuclear nations, or to engage in proxy skirmishes to try to expand one's geopolitical power. We're rapidly approaching a century with 0 major and unrestrained wars between two nuclear powers. That's completely unprecedented in the entirety of our history, and it's not a coincidence.
- eduction 3y agoDo you think UK or France would use nuclear weapons in response to a non-nuclear Russian attack on other NATO members (e.g. Germany)? Are they obligated to do so?
- AlgorithmicTime 3y ago[dead]
- ignorance_bliss 3y ago[flagged]
- mellutussa 3y agoDu gamla, Du fria!
- diamondfist25 3y agowhy don't NATO add Russia in and together they can fight off US?
- luuurker 3y agoProbably because the US isn't making threats to invade or nuke European/NATO countries and Russia is? Just a guess.
- nostrebored 3y agoI get that we've decided 'NATO Good' now -- but are people really so sure that it's sphere of influence is geopolitically stabilizing? I don't see how it could be. If I were Russia, or an ally of Russia, an expansionist NATO would be galvanizing for me and would accelerate a counterbalance alliance. Creating a potentially entrenched conflict in countries that have surface-to-surface access to Moscow would be in my benefit. Ukraine falls into that category.
- antris 3y agoUS is literally sending weapons to the perpetrators of a genocide. Genocides do not make the world more stable, just the opposite.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- miroljub 3y ago[flagged]
- lawn 3y agoYou do realize that Russia invading a peaceful country that was turning more towards democracy and away from dictatorships like Russia is what pushed Sweden and Finland into NATO, in fear of Russia invading and terror bombing them? Not protecting yourself, and letting Russia do whatever they want, is what countries did to Nazi Germany for years. Have we learned nothing from history?
- api 3y agoIrony: NATO maybe was considered of questionable necessity before Putin invaded Ukraine to supposedly contain NATO, which ended up being a gigantic ad for NATO. Now it's on track to become the de-facto EU military. Putin is yet another fabulous counterexample for the anti-democracy crowd. He spent hundreds of thousands of Russian lives, hundreds of billions, tons of military hardware, and incurred sanctions to earn... a massive increase in the strength and prestige of one of his (again supposed) major adversaries. Not only is NATO growing but the EU is ramping up its own domestic military industries. Absolutely massive own-goal. Even if he "wins" in Ukraine to some extent it's a strategic net loss at this point. Starting to wonder if China is going to do the same thing with Taiwan: invade and set gigantic amounts of money on fire and implode their economy. Even if they "win" the damage might far exceed the gain.
- chasd00 3y ago> Absolutely massive own-goal. never interrupt your enemy when they're making a mistake
- jasonvorhe 3y ago[flagged]
- the_why_of_y 3y agoThe mythical biolabs are trending again? https://agora.echelon.pl/notice/AWHLxjJzNg2olbuy3c https://agora.echelon.pl/notice/AWHLxjJzNg2olbuy3c https://carnegieendowment.org/2020/06/25/ex-soviet-bioweapons-labs-are-fighting-covid-19.-moscow-doesn-t-like-it-pub-82203 https://carnegieendowment.org/2020/06/25/ex-soviet-bioweapon...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tclover 3y agoPrivate army of big capital claims another nation its hostage
- roschdal 3y agoYeah, the expansion of NATO to the east is so successful and peaceful, best thing ever.
- originalvichy 3y agoIf the Russian empire didn’t expand west under the guise of communist brotherhood, then proceeded to make every aspect of life miserable to those they controlled (not talking about purely macroeconomics here), Nato would have never been invited east.
- luuurker 3y agoI wonder what made Sweden and Finland want to join NATO...
- LtWorf 3y agoCorruption? Anyone reading the news in sweden knew they were on the lookout for a casus belli to join NATO… Ukraine invasion was as good as any.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoLet's do Armenia next.
- Georgelemental 3y agoNot if Azeri bribes have anything to say about it
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoOk, how about Japan then?
- rihards__ 3y agoOnly downside for Sweden really is that they are now recommended to spend >=2% of GDP for defense. Otherwise, congratulations. Same as Finland, Sweden is hige NET benefit for alliance, welcome friends!
- tuwtuwtuwtuw 3y agoSwedens defense budget for 2024 is 2.1% of GDP. I'm my view, with the recent events, Sweden would need to spend at least 2% with or without NATO. Now we can spend 2% but get a lot more value out of it.
- u320 3y agoOne thing that isn't mentioned a lot in connection to this: Sweden and Denmark has a VERY violent history. Hundreds of years of wars. It is said to be the worst conflict in all of human history. Now we are allied and committed to defend each other. That's a huge thing for peace.
- gitaarik 3y agoDon't all countries have a very violent history? (:
- nikolay 3y ago[flagged]
- luuurker 3y agoGood luck to those launching Sarmats too as they'll have to stop the Tridents, Minutemen, M51, etc. It's important to remember that while they don't make weekly threats, there are three NATO countries with land/sea based nuclear weapons. Realistically, there's no defending from nuclear weapons. That's why MAD, while crazy, works.
- nikolay 3y agoIt doesn't have to be even Sarmat; it could be Poseidon - options are plentiful. I doubt anyone would have the balls to respond to a nuclear attack. The issue is who's crazier to do the first one, and if one truly believes Russia and Putin are crazy evil, then one should act respectively! So far, I don't see intelligent behavior from the West - I see arrogance, which always has a high cost!
- luuurker 3y agoYou expect everyone to bend over because Putin/Russia decided to go down the "I'm a mad man, give me what I want or I'll nuke you" route... that's just not how the world works. I hope you don't use this tactic yourself, because you'll end up with a broken nose (or worse) if you do it to the wrong guy. There is certainly arrogance from the west, but what do you call what Russia is doing? They literally make threats to nuclear powers as if they're untouchable. The fact you don't see this should tell you that you're biased here. Sarmat and Posidon are "doomsday" weapons. Use them against a small country like the UK or France and they have little to lose. Use them against the US and you're likely to be wiped out. As you've said, options are plentiful, so we should all be very careful and do our best to avoid war (all = includes Russia).
- sidcool 3y agoObjectively, is this good, bad or no-impact?
- DeepSeaTortoise 3y agoPretty much no-impact. Both Finland and Sweden were NATO Enhanced Opportunity Partners.
- esarbe 3y agoGood. It discourages attacks from Russia, the only bellicist nation in the region.
- sidcool 3y agoInteresting. I learnt the word 'bellicist' for the first time.
- gen220 3y agoI think the more proper word in that context is bellicose (adjective). Bellicist is a noun. Same root as the more common words belligerent and antebellum. You may have also heard of “casus belli” (rationale for declaring war).
- esarbe 3y agoYou are correct - bellicose would have been the proper form.
- apienx 3y agoThe largest country on Earth murders people for merely expression an opinion and a massive chunk of our planet's geological wealth is funneled to fund wars of aggression. This sovereign decision is in perfect alignment with Sweden's value and security needs. Yet, that the decision involved kissing the rings of other no-good men (Erdogan and Orban) tells me we need a paradigm shift. Is it legal to crowdfund Putin's early retirement? I'm sure there's a number that will guarantee getting him out of office. Asking for a friend. ;-)
- ifyoubuildit 3y agoSo is the world closer, farther, or the same distance from nuclear war after this?
- nikolay 3y ago[flagged]
- vardump 3y agoThere's no russophobia except in Kremlin's propaganda. European nations just can't take any chances with aggression and untrustworthiness of the current Russian leadership. That's just common sense. This is nothing against Russian population.
- nikolay 3y agoOh, there indeed is! I'm not Russian, but I've experienced it since I came to the States! Most Russophobes are Democrats, neocons, and people from the former Soviet bloc!
- luuurker 3y agoYou have Putin making claims about borders based on his own and very selective version of history, high ranking politicians (and their media) making threats about invading or nuking other countries, and of course there's their invasion of Ukraine... Obviously people and countries will reconsider their position and act. This is a reaction to Russia's behaviour. We can't behave like dicks and then cry when people that don't like our behaviour are not our friends or try to protect themselves.
- nikolay 3y agoHow about the agreement not to expand NATO? Or Minsk agreements? It's so funny that people talk about Article 5, but don't really know what it really says! If Russia attacks Poland, let's say, because Poland gets into Ukraine, you think America will start a WWIII, because of Poland? Get real!
- luuurker 3y agoPlease show me the document of the agreement not to expand NATO. While you try to find that, it would be great if you could explain why countries want to give away some of their military freedom and risk being dragged to other wars and join NATO. Why did the baltic countries join? Why did Sweden and Finland - two typically anti-NATO countries - recently changed their mind without public opposition? NATO should send Putin a "salesman of the year 2022" award. The guy managed to give a new life to the organisation and made both countries join, creating a "east expands to NATO" (and not a "NATO expands east") situation. This wouldn't have happened before Feb 2022... are we sure he isn't working for the "west"? If you want to talk about agreements, we can start by talking about the Budapest Memorandum from 1994 ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum ). It's only 6 points and very easy to understand, I recommend reading it. I don't know who's talking about Article 5 being used when a member of NATO starts an offensive war against someone else. I also didn't read anything about Poland joining Ukraine to fight Russia (which, let's not forget, decided to wage war). Maybe you replied to the wrong person? Not going to continue this discussion with you though. Not that the west is blameless, but I have no time to discuss with someone that blames everyone but the country that willingly started the war in Ukraine.
- mudil 3y agoFYI "The head of the Russian General Staff Academy announced the threat of a “large-scale war in Europe” The state agency RIA Novosti on Thursday reported on an article by Vladimir Zarudnitsky, head of the Military Academy of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation. The article was written in the departmental magazine “Military Thought” and was “at the disposal” of the agency. The possibility of an escalation of the conflict in Ukraine into a large-scale war in Europe cannot be ruled out; the likelihood of Russia being drawn into new military conflicts is increasing, the main idea of the RIA Novosti article is retold. “The possibility of an escalation of the conflict in Ukraine cannot be ruled out - from the expansion of participants in the ‘proxy forces’ used for military confrontation with Russia to a large-scale war in Europe,” wrote General Zarudnitsky. “The main source of military threats to our state is the anti-Russian policy of the United States and its allies, waging a new type of hybrid war in order to completely weaken Russia, limit its sovereignty and destroy territorial integrity,” the general was quoted by Reuters, which also noted that a high-ranking A Russian military officer warned of the threat of the conflict in Ukraine escalating into a full-scale war in Europe. Zarudnitsky's comments come as the West struggles to help Ukraine with more weapons and money after a failed counteroffensive, Reuters noted."
- Handsome2734 3y agoSo neutrality is all a lie.
- defrost 3y agoYou're 15 years out of date and likely wrong about any lie re: Sweden had a policy of neutrality in armed conflicts from the early 19th century, until 2009, when it entered into various mutual defence treaties with the European Union (EU), and other Nordic countries. The details appear to have been open and declared as policy in public. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_neutrality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_neutrality Can you expand on your comment at all?