9 ms·
The issue is that Epic doesn’t want to be Apple’s customer in the first place. They want to publish iOS apps. The fact that this requires them to be an Apple cu
by layer8 3y ago
The issue is that Epic doesn’t want to be Apple’s customer in the first place. They want to publish iOS apps. The fact that this requires them to be an Apple customer is the core problem.
Imagine if everyone wanting to publish a web app would have to be a customer of the respective browser vendors.
Everyone complains about Google and Mozilla and Safari and Edge. Luckily, that doesn’t prevent us from having our web apps running on those browsers.
- lelandfe 3y agoPublishing a Chrome browser extension more-or-less requires being a customer of the Chrome Web Store. There are plenty of other examples, folks tend to give Playstation/Xbox/Switch stores in these conversations as well.
- Phrodo_00 3y ago> Publishing a Chrome browser extension more-or-less requires being a customer of the Chrome Web Store Emphasis on more-or-less, though. You can use Chrome developer mode (which is NOT a paid option and doesn't require an account) to import extensions from files. You can't do that in iOS. That's Epic's point.
- paulmd 3y agoyou don't need a developer account to sideload an app on ios, and it wouldn't change anything legally if you did (feature tiering is legal) another classic example of android users who don't understand the things they're talking about. go on, tell me more about how "you can't copy and paste between applications in ios" or "there's not even a file browser" please. (now, still not being able to figure out a calculator app on ipad? that's a fair one lol)
- Zambyte 3y agoI didn't believe you so I looked it up, and this[0] is what I found > AltStore then signs the application with your Apple ID so the app can run. You'll need to trust the developer certificate in your device settings, but when you do, any apps that you install through AltStore will work... for seven days. Apple has put several restrictions in place to make the process as difficult as possible, but the developer managed to work around those restrictions. As the clock nears closer to the end of the seven-day period, AltStore will refresh the signing key on the app so that you can get an extra seven days of usage. This can also run in the background. > AltStore makes use of a feature Apple introduced that lets you install *up to three apps* for free using your Apple ID. > However, AltStore relies on a computer on the same network running AltServer, so you'll need both iTunes and iCloud installed on that device. [...] Is this seriously what you're talking about? Because after reading that I still don't believe you can install apps on iOS without Apples splash of iHoly Water TM. [0] https://www.xda-developers.com/how-to-sideload-apps-iphone-altstore/ https://www.xda-developers.com/how-to-sideload-apps-iphone-a...
- paulmd 3y ago[flagged]
- Zambyte 3y agoIf I can't install an app for more than a week, I can't install an app. Also: since I don't have a Windows or Mac machine, I literally can't install an app.
- phone8675309 3y agoStop arguing with trolls
- freedomben 3y agoNext tell us that we're all wrong and anybody can write and release an app for iOS because the web
- paulmd 3y ago[flagged]
- dwaite 3y agoDo you think this is a viable distribution model for web extensions, e.g. an alternative to the Chrome Web Store?
- cute_boi 3y agoYes, for user like me. I checked most of the extension I use. They directly come from github, and I generally don't update extension, so there is no fear of some sketchy website buying the extension company.
- kohbo 3y agoI think the point is that an alternative installation method is already provided in the browser
- fennecbutt 3y agoOf course it could be better, so why doesn't Apple show us all what really streamlined and well implemented third party app store support looks like?
- vlod 3y agoI use userscripts/violent-monkey for my stuff and I don't have to deal with any of them. I grant you, it's harder for people to use my stuff.
- int_19h 3y agoYes, this is indeed increasingly common. All the more reason to legislatively nuke it all as fast and as forcefully as possible before it entrenches.
- swman 3y agoThen they should just not publish for iOS lol. Don’t like it? Don’t publish to it. As a consumer I want and like the tight restrictions apple puts on the App Store. It’s not like users can’t purchase stuff without paying the 30% premium added by developers to offset the apple tax. Just go to the website and buy there. And save the 30%. My parents who are older use iPhone. They don’t have to wade through trash like android play store. Most apps are good in the iOS store. If epic wants kids to buy more stuff have their parents pay the 30% premium. If your kid is glued to the phone I’m sure you enabled that and can continue enabling it. Sorry not sorry.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- creaturemachine 3y agoApple should just not sell in the EU lol.
- siegecraft 3y agoThe Supreme Court ruled that apple must allow users to purchase from vendor websites. Apple takes a 27% cut instead of 30%
- iraqmtpizza 3y agoThey never said they didn't like iOS. You're hallucinating.
- pompino 3y agoAh yes, the classic "Think of the innocent children and grandmas" . Sorry, that isn't an argument anymore. It never was convincing before and isn't now either. >Don’t like it? Don’t publish to it. Yeah, why protest at all? Just leave the country. Why fight corruption? Just go somewhere else where there is less of it. Really, why complain at all?
- dns_snek 3y agoThe number of bad faith arguments here is impressive. > Don’t like it? Don’t publish to it. That's not how laws work, Epic have a perfectly valid complaint against Apple because Apple isn't complying with EU law. As far as valid outcomes go, Apple can either comply, face fines, or leave the EU market. > As a consumer I want and like the tight restrictions apple puts on the App Store. That's great, but it causes demonstrable harm to the proper functioning of our supposed "free market", so we've outlawed them. > It’s not like users can’t purchase stuff without paying the 30% premium added by developers to offset the apple tax. Just go to the website and buy there. And save the 30%. Except they ban you from even mentioning that this alternative exist. More harm to the free market. > My parents who are older use iPhone. They don’t have to wade through trash like android play store. Most apps are good in the iOS store. Nobody is forcing them to wade through alternative app stores. If most good apps are indeed on iOS, and Apple's fees are indeed reasonable, then those apps will stay in the iOS App Store. Nothing to worry about! > If epic wants kids to buy more stuff have their parents pay the 30% premium. If your kid is glued to the phone I’m sure you enabled that and can continue enabling it. Sorry not sorry. This legislation benefits everyone, not just Epic.
- samatman 3y agoWe don't have to imagine, we have 40 years of game consoles existing.
- m4rtink 3y agoWhich is also wrong, especially given how most modern consoles are basically PCs. Just see what all you can do with Steam Deck in comparison to the locked down consoles.
- ben_w 3y agoI was wondering around a local store, MediaMarkt I think, and I saw a random handheld games console — two sticks, a D-pad, XYAB buttons — with the well-known video game Microsoft Excel pre-installed and visible on (I think, I'm not a Windows person) the start menu.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>especially given how most modern consoles are basically PCs. people always obsess over the hardware in these arguments when the value is in the software. You probably can eventually run windows on a PS5, but that's not what people buy a PS5 for. They don't advertise it as being able to install whatever OS you want (they made that mistake on PS3, took it back, and then got fined for taking it back), and the value for most customers is playing PS5 games. The onyl non-gaming thing you can do these days on a PS5 is watch streaming services. So at best it's a media center Just because you can install doom on a pregnancy test doesn't mean a pregnancy test is a general purpose computer.
- m4rtink 3y agoStill as long as you buy the hardware, you should not be prevented from running whatever you like on it. A case of this is the Nintendo Switch, which does not even have a Web Browser (possibly due to Nintendo being scared to death of JIT exploits breaking their walled garden). Want to look up a game guide from the Internet, on a device perfectly able of doing so ? Fat chance, need another device for that! You mentioned consoles supporting some streaming services - why should the manufacturer of the hardware be in business of deciding what streaming services you can use ?
- threeseed 3y agoYou are in many respects a customer of the browser vendors. They can choose at any point to harm your business e.g. Apple restricting first party cookies.
- Invictus0 3y agoThey're not a monopoly though. Apple can disable safari's video playback capabilities, but somehow I doubt that would kill YouTube's business.
- joemi 3y agoTo be fair, Apple isn't killing Epic's business by denying them to bypass the app store, or even by kicking them off the app store. Epic's doing just fine without apple.
- layer8 3y agoThat’s a lot closer to a desktop OS update possibly breaking your software. This doesn’t make you a customer of Windows/macOS/Linux. If an OS vendor would target a specific software that way, however, that also would likely have legal consequences.
- beezle 3y agoA better analogy might be if a tire company could only sell its tires through the Ford/GM "store"/dealership. Nobody would put up with that.
- ab209 3y ago[dead]
- m4rtink 3y agoYet people put up with hardware lock-in on printer toner and cartridges (which is also very wrong).
- alt227 3y agoNot willingly. Theres plenty of uproar and lawsuits around that one too. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2024/01/hp-sued-again-for-blocking-third-party-ink-from-printers-accused-of-monopoly/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2024/01/hp-sued-again-for-bl...
- johnnyanmac 3y agoI don't. I barely have a need to print to begin with but just enough that I have a printer. Printers aren't continually iterating in what and how they can print so I can survive on 10+ year old printers.
- yakkityyak 3y agoI don’t quite understand why they happily subscribe to this model with Xbox PlayStation and Nintendo, but are adamant about getting their way with Google and Apple.
- Dah00n 3y agoOne difference is that most (all?) consoles are sold at a loss and they survive on profits from games. Apple would do perfectly fine with no income from games while Xbox and PlayStation would be DOA. Strictly my opinion, but I also believe that where Sony sends engineers to help developers that struggle (case in point, Helldivers 2 mass influx of gamers after it became a social media darling causing the servers to bog down), Apple would be more likely to use their massive data from iPhones to launch a direct competitor to any app that became a big hit rather than help them out (case in point, Spotify Vs. Apple Music and the other apps Apple tried to buy, and when denied, cloned).
- Zambyte 3y agoThe arbitrary limitations on computers that are obviously general purpose is more clear than the arbitrary limitations on general purpose computers that are marketed as special purpose computers (gaming machines). In reality they're all equally bad.
- tracerbulletx 3y agoGaming consoles are not really special purpose anymore.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoThey pretty much are. They don't even had facilities that older consoles had like an accessible web browser or custom theming. Just because they have general computing hardware doesn't mean they are general purpose computers.
- Zambyte 3y agoThat's why I called them "general purpose computers that are marketed as special purpose computers".
- jimscard 3y agoEveryone who publishes software that runs on iOS devices is an Apple customer, though. This isn’t the same thing as a browser — apps running on iOS devices consume APIs on the device, utilize Apple services, etc. Also, when it comes to web apps, in most cases, the developers are also customers of the browser vendors -- from using browser developer tools and SDKs, for example, https://www.google.com/chrome/dev/ https://www.google.com/chrome/dev/ , https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/developer/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/developer/ , and https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/?form=MA13LH https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/?form=M... to name three. Safari’s dev tools etc. you get with your Apple Dev subscription. And those browser vendors, like Apple, also provide developer training, developer support services, early access to upcoming product versions, opportunities to provide input into future product designs and features, etc. In other words, this is not a problem, much less the “core problem”. This is normal industry practice. In fact, on some platforms, there are royalty fees due for the SDK runtime components that are required to run the software a third party developer provides. Just look at mainframes — you might buy XYZ Accounting system from them, and have to pay an additional annual license payment for the cobol runtime it requires. That fact, by the way, is what the half a Euro per ‘download’ technology fee is about. Part of the DMA requires separation of the “app store fee” from the fee for using iOS services. It’s also important to note, when people talk about the 30% app store fee as being high — the app store is essentially the same thing as a retail store. Back in the days when you bought software in a physical store, rather than downloading it, the margin at the retail level ranged between 30% and 50%. E.g., we would pay the distributor $25 and sell it for $49.99. The distributor in turn would buy the software in bulk from the manufacturer, for somewhere around $20-$22. Software developers get a lot bigger share of what the consumer pays in the current model. Some, however, are greedier than others, and leverage governments to their advantage. Epic Games doesn’t want any competition - they want to be the sole retailer of Fortnite on all platforms so that they can raise the price to whatever they want.
- int_19h 3y agoWhat you are saying is that software industry is a mess, and Apple just happens to be the poster child of many things that are wrong with it. I agree. Let's deal with all the other extortion schemes while we're at it and make the free market actually free.
- amelius 3y ago> The issue is that Epic doesn’t want to be Apple’s customer in the first place. They want to publish iOS apps. The fact that this requires them to be an Apple customer is the core problem. Indeed. It all boils down to: if I buy a product from company A, then want to use that product to do business with company B, why does company A have anything to say about it? Am I not the owner of my device?
- daemin 3y agoIncreasingly in this modern world, no, you are not the owner of the device. You're more like purchasing the right to use it for a time, in the way that the makers want you to use it. This applies across PCs, Macs, and Phones where Microsoft, Apple, and Google all try to up-sell you on their online services and now their "AI tools".
- refulgentis 3y agoHad me until 'AI tools'
- Zuiii 3y agoHopefully changing laws will cure companies from this delusional take. Most reasonable people don't think this way.
- chii 3y ago> Hopefully changing law the problem with having consumers take action is that they are completely shortsighted and will take the path of least resistence - a path that the companies will have charted out to make this transition as smooth and painless _for the consumer_ as possible while retaining as much monopolistic power as possible. There needs to be public institutions with the backing of the state to enforce property rights, including purchased devices.
- jamwil 3y agoTo offer a modest counterweight here, every iPhone owner bought the product knowing damn well that Apple keeps the OS locked down. If you don’t want that, don’t buy an iPhone. There’s no confusion about what the product is and what you can do with it.
- Copernicron 3y ago>The issue is that Epic doesn’t want to be Apple’s customer in the first place. They want to publish iOS apps. The fact that this requires them to be an Apple customer is the core problem. The issue is that General Mills doesn't want to be Costco's customer in the first place. They want to sell to Costco shoppers. The fact that this requires them to be a Costco customer is the core problem.