20 ms·
Nine US states are teaming up to accelerate the adoption of heat pumps
- vundercind 3y ago> Death is coming for the old-school gas furnace—and its killer is the humble heat pump. Uh, you still need a furnace (though it could be electric) if you live somewhere that ever really gets cold, right? [edit] I mean, seeing it presented as a furnace replacement is weird to me. I’ve always seen it sold as an air conditioner replacement that also happens to heat (with weird characteristics that often confuse people—they’ll think their heat is broken, because the air coming out is only kinda warm, not very-warm like furnace heat) when it’s not really cold out.
- loeg 3y agoHeatpumps have resistance heating backup for the exceptional periods when it is too cold to make use of the compression system. Most people live somewhere a heatpump would work well.
- vundercind 3y agoOh, I’ve not see that kind, only the sort where the “e heat” feature on the thermostat is tied to a separate furnace.
- heironimus 3y agoProblem is, if everyone has resistance backup and it gets really cold, I doubt if the grid could keep up.
- giantg2 3y agoThis also assumes a resilient grid, which may not be the case for large areas of the rural US.
- spiderice 3y agoYes. I live in Utah and have a heat pump and gas furnace. I am told the heat pump is really efficient at medium-cold temperatures, but not so much on really cold days.
- loeg 3y agoI believe heatpump technology has improved over time. Also, "less efficient but still functional" is an adequate option for really cold days.
- Loughla 3y agoLess efficient but still functional means my home was 50 degree inside instead of 67 when it was -1 for two weeks here. On older homes, with much worse insulation, this would immediately be a problem. Heat pumps are great, but they absolutely need some kind of emergency heat back up.
- loeg 3y ago> Less efficient but still functional means my home was 50 degree inside instead of 67 when it was -1 for two weeks here. No, that's just not functional. "Less efficient" means consuming more joules of electricity but still providing the required function. > Heat pumps are great, but they absolutely need some kind of emergency heat back up. They include it. You were sold an inadequate pump for your situation.
- adastra22 3y agoHeat pumps are still more efficient, but you’d need damn good insulation (or a really big heat pump) in super cold weather. Furnaces scale-up pretty well on the other hand. If your locale gets life threateningly cold though, I’d feel more comfortable with a furnace because of the fewer moving parts. Burn gas, get heat, dead simple.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y agoFunny enough in the short term I've lived in my house, I already had a winter where the furnace quit. It's a high-efficiency one with a control board (Nobody can convince me FCS isn't Fire Control System) and a separate draft motor. One of the vacuum sensors went out and the furnace couldn't prove it was safe to run, so it would turn on the draft motor, suspect a clog, and then shut it back off. An easy fix but not as simple as lighting a Bunsen burner. And I haven't seen the electrical cord for it, I'm not sure how I would hook it to a generator if I lost power. The water heater oddly enough is battery-powered, so I guess I could just fill the tub with hot water.
- Workaccount2 3y agoCutting edge heat pumps can now work down into the sub zero (F) temperatures. Manufacturers have really been pushing hard on this in recent years. But these units still are more expensive than your run of the mill ones.
- nitsuaeekcm 3y agoThe best mental model for a heat pump is that they can maintain a certain temperature differential, say 80F. If it gets to be 0F outside and you want it to be 70? You don’t need to switch to a fully separate heating system, you just need to warm up either the incoming or outgoing air an additional 10 degrees via a small resistance heater. The super wide range heat pump systems will do that automatically, and the principle really applies to any differential you could want.
- VBprogrammer 3y agoThe wide range ones are basically two heat pumps back to back using different working fluids. They should only be used in applications where they are really required as there are obviously impacts to the COP.
- JadeNB 3y ago> The best mental model for a heat pump is that they can maintain a certain temperature differential, say 80F. If it gets to be 0F outside and you want it to be 70? You don’t need to switch to a fully separate heating system, you just need to warm up either the incoming or outgoing air an additional 10 degrees via a small resistance heater. Are your 70 and 80 switched? What you describe doesn't sound like it needs any addition.
- kj4ips 3y agoI have a pair of heat pumps in a dual zone setup, each of them has a backup electric furnace as part of its indoor air handler. Newer ones can keep running without that even into quite cold areas. The thermostat just sees the resistive heaters as another phase, so I have three phases, and if it doesn't see a temp rise within a certain time of calling for phase 1/2, then it goes to phase 3. Mine also has support for an external temperature probe, that can skip 1/2 if it is already too cold. I also have other ways to make heat if I have a prolonged electrical outage, but outside of maintenance, I've not used that.
- loudmax 3y agoWhat's really cold? There are heat pumps that are advertised as working at -15F. On the days when it gets that cold, your heat pump will need to switch to electric heat. So on those days, your heat pump is no better than an electric furnace. On all other days that the heater is running, the heat pump is a far more efficient option.
- epiccoleman 3y agoFrom my limited experience, I'd say yes - you still need a furnace. I converted my garage into my office by adding a mini split AC/heat pump. The garage walls, door, and attic are insulated - but it's still a garage, which means that it's not nearly as well insulated as a regular room in a house. The unit is 18k BTUs, which is quite oversized for the size of the garage. I made this choice because the heat pump BTUs are significantly less than cooling BTUs. This is definitely obvious, experientally - the unit can make my garage uncomfortably cold even in the peak of summer. But even though this unit is supposedly rated for operation in temps down to about -20F, when winter gets really cold, it struggles to keep the space warm. Once the temps are below about 20F or so, I usually add a space heater to the mix, which, combined with warm clothes, makes working out here at least tolerable.
- rootbear 3y agoI live in Maryland and the first townhouse I owned, in the late 80s to early 90s, had a heat pump. It included an auxiliary electric heater for days that it got really cold. I don't remember it coming on all that often. (There was a light on the thermostat to indicate when it was on.) My current townhouse has a gas furnace. I plan to move soon into a single level home, more appropriate for an old greybeard, and I'll have to evaluate then if I want to switch to a heat pump, if the house doesn't have one already.
- rimunroe 3y agoNote: this is only true for air-source heat pumps. Ground source-heat pumps aren't affected by ambient air temperature, but they're also much more expensive and require suitable ground. Also, I hear air-source heat pumps have made significant advances lately in how well they handle sub -15 °C temperatures.
- mikeyouse 3y ago> Uh, you still need a furnace (though it could be electric) if you live somewhere that ever really gets cold, right? For now - and only in part of the country. Most of the newest models can output 100% of their rating down to something like -5ºF -- they're easy enough to oversize as well, so if your 99% heating load is e.g. 48,000BTU, a 60,000BTU heat pump that's only outputting 80% of rated BTUs due to the extreme cold can still cover the full design load. Here's the spec sheet for the newer Mitsubishi hyper heat models - 87º output at -4ºF and 76% output at -13ºF -- very few places in the states ever get that cold: https://static.appliancesconnection.com/attachments/D5bf57097bbdd4.pdf https://static.appliancesconnection.com/attachments/D5bf5709...
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI like the redundancy of natural gas. So far, in less than 40 years, I have been kept warm for multiple days on 3 separate occasions by having access to gas while the electricity did not work. Also, I was able to keep cooking. One of the states in the article is Oregon too, where I have family that just a few weeks ago lost electricity for 4 days, but were able to use an electric generator to keep the air handler going and gas to heat the the house and cook. I fear heat pump only heat will fail exactly when I most need it not to.
- vundercind 3y agoYeah if my heat were 100% electric I’d have to install a wood heating-stove to feel like I wasn’t being irresponsible. Or maybe get a couple portable kerosene heaters.
- VBprogrammer 3y agoI think a sensible option, if you live in a place where electrical grids goes out for a couple of days fairly routinely, would be a transfer switch and a generator. If sized well enough you could use it to run a resistance heater (the cheap portable type) to keep one or two rooms warm in an extreme scenario.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y agoTechnology Connections seems pretty happy with his. I think he lives in Chicago, admittedly not the coldest place, but it does snow every winter in that region. He said 2.9 coefficient of efficiency average over a heating season for him - https://youtu.be/7J52mDjZzto?t=1522 https://youtu.be/7J52mDjZzto?t=1522
- orwin 3y agoDepends on the heat pump, and the quality of your house. Hopefully houses in northern US states are of better quality than houses in California or West Virginia/South Ohio, so a furnface might not be needed. Because for the scandinavians reading the thread and with the "It works in my country", US house build quality, in my experience, is even worse than UK houses build quality (and that's a pretty low bar).
- carapace 3y agoNo, you need better insulation. (And maybe a rocket stove combined with a heat storage hypocaust.) https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2017/03/heat-storage-hypocausts-air-heating-in-the-middle-ages/ https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2017/03/heat-storage-hypoc...
- switchbak 3y agoThey make ones that handle the cold quite well, but in my mind dual-fuel is where it's at, especially if you're doing a retrofit. Unfortunately there does seem to be a desire (even with the rebate systems) to kill the old furnaces.
- bagels 3y agoThe capabilities work fine for much of the country that doesn't get exceedingly freezing temperatures. It only gets down to about 26F on the coldest of cold nights here once or twice per year.
- avery17 3y agoTried to get one in NJ and no one wanted to install one. Everyone we got a quote from tried really hard to talk us out of it. We ended up going with gas cause it was cheaper but I'm not happy about it. Gas is just the new oil, once everyone is hooked they'll jack up prices like they did with oil.
- herpdyderp 3y agoThe states listed are: - California - Colorado - Maine - Maryland - Massachusetts - New Jersey - New York - Oregon - Rhode Island
- nostrademons 3y agoSo the usual blue-state suspects, minus Washington and a bunch of the New England states.
- virtue3 3y agoplaces where heat pumps are not going to work well when it drops to freezing / below freezing.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoOur Diakin was working at -15F but Po Lil PumpPump was struggling. I had to have floorboard heat on for that week. So, it does work (not if you buy a cheaper unit not made for your climate) but it works a lot better above freezing.
- bluGill 3y agoSeveral red states (the TVA) have had heat pumps as normal for decades. Now heat pumps work better and so they should extend to the other states.
- 082349872349872 3y agorepresenting ~1/3 of 2022 GDP (via https://www.bea.gov/sites/default/files/2023-12/stgdppi3q23.pdf https://www.bea.gov/sites/default/files/2023-12/stgdppi3q23.... )
- jtbayly 3y agoI don't see how the GDP has anything to do with this. What percent of the population those states make up might be somewhat interesting at least. But even then, 90% of new installations requires us to know what percent of installations those states make up, and population isn't necessarily (but could be) a good corollary for that.
- danans 3y agoA big issue right now is the oversizing of heat pumps by HVAC contractors who are used to sizing gas furnaces using very simple btu/hr/sqft calculations. A contractor should do some kind of heating need analysis, at the least by studying old utility bills, and ideally by doing a Manual J heat loss calculation for the house. But almost none of them do that. There are some startups attempting to handle these design steps as a service, but the construction industry is slow to adopt new technology.
- jacobolus 3y agoCan you explain why this is a big issue?
- zbrozek 3y agoThe simplest devices are on or off. If they are grossly oversized they cycle a lot and make homes less comfortable by pushing a huge volume of hot or cold air briefly. Variable speed compressors are better, but blowers may not also be variable speed. So you'll get better efficiency but may still suffer a feeling of draftiness. A properly sized variable speed unit will operate within some optimal band of efficiency and constantly output nearly the minimum necessary air volume to achieve the target temperature.
- jlawrence6809 3y agoWhen I was shopping for a mini split recently all the models I could find seemed to be variable speed compressor and blowers, unless I was reading something wrong. So maybe this isn't an issue anymore? I oversized mine but wish I went even bigger after a cold snap we just had in the pnw this last winter.
- zbrozek 3y agoMini splits are better in this regard than traditional ducted installations.
- danans 3y ago
- genmud 3y agoWhat a clickbaity, poorly written and sensational article.
- kspacewalk2 3y agoThe only thing that's holding me back in electrifying more of my life is my jurisdiction's track record in long-term planning for grid and supply capacity. If I switch water heating, home heating and transportation to electricity, and they fuck up again, that'll affect me way more when rates start rising or shortages begin. I'd rather they work out the kinks without me and be a late adopter. For example, I will not be among the first 50% of drivers to switch to fully electric. Being a one-car household I believe we've already done more for the environment than 2 car EV households simply by taking one vehicle off the roads.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y agoYeah I'm waiting for a carbon tax to pass somewhere. I'm an environmentalist but why spend extra money being good when there are still assholes driving lifted pickups with loud exhausts and widened axles they don't need? My next car will be a plug-in Prius though. My old boss had one and almost never had to put gas in it. All-electric commute with a range extender / emergency heater
- vdaea 3y ago>“It’s a really strong signal from states that they’re committed to accelerating this transition to zero-emissions residential buildings,” Heat pumps are zero-emissions now. Shipping them and replacing your gas furnace also emits no carbon.
- firebat45 3y agoHave you ever tried running a gas furnace off of a solar panel? "Accelerating a transition" != "this has been 100% accomplished"
- vdaea 3y agoI skipped the part of the article that says that the heat pumps will always be accompanied by solar panels.
- supertrope 3y agoThe idea is that electrification enables a future where electricity generation transitions to low emissions. A gas furnace will always burn gas. In Canada electricity is called hydro because it nearly all hydroelectric. So buying an EV zeros out tailpipe emissions and electric generation emissions are also very low.
- seiferteric 3y agoHeat pumps look great and definitely planning on getting one (or many) when my hvac system needs replacing, as well as a heat pump water heater. In NorCal I think they are a no-brainer since it doesn't get that cold to begin with, though I am unsure of what options exist to replace a central AC/furnace system, or if it is better to get several smaller ones throughout your house. Though I have to laugh since it was only a few years ago there were news articles decrying air conditioning as a climate disaster are now claiming heat pumps are a climate savior...
- Slevin11 3y agoIt is technically the correct climate; but unfortunately the incorrect place for them, given the electricity costs and propensity for large power outages during storms (read: times when you actually need heating). If you are in one of the cities with public utilities where electricity is cheap, then go for it, great choice. But on PG&E, the monetary proposition is awful compared to a gas heater, modern wood stove, or masonry / rocket mass heater. Given the extreme excess of wood in the region (that otherwise ends up in huge forest fires), it makes a lot of sense to be running an efficient wood stove / masonry / mass heater. The big loss is of course automation, so it pays to have some automated backup source of heat for when you are out of town, but that could just be whatever heating method you are using already. If you are already heating using electric baseboards though, yes, definitely move over to a heat pump. It will save you a lot of money. Not as much as natural gas or the others, but savings are savings. Also, there are plenty of ducted air source heat pumps that work as drop in replacements for gas furnaces. Use one of them if you already have a ducted system that works well and do a heat pump replacement.
- masklinn 3y ago> Though I have to laugh since it was only a few years ago there were news articles decrying air conditioning as a climate disaster are now claiming heat pumps are a climate savior... Because they’re completely coherent but for some reason you’re not thinking any further than “they’re essentially the same device”?
- samatman 3y agoIt's substantially cheaper in energy to cool buildings in the hot parts of the world than it is to heat buildings in the cool parts of the world. I've seen the sort of articles you're referring to, in the US at least, they're thinly-disguised political screeds based on nothing other than the fact that there are more Republicans in the air-conditioned parts of the country.
- scythe 3y agohttps://archive.ph/NkfeK https://archive.ph/NkfeK
- scythe 3y agoHijacking my own comment: I feel like I started talking about heat pumps a long time ago. I'm unable to find evidence for this before 2021. Anyway, it's certainly hit the cultural mainstream really fast over the last couple of years, and the story on the street is... manufacturers are running at capacity, installers have long waiting lists, some people are getting systems installed that aren't right for their space (too big or too small) and regretting it. It's good that we're doing this, but it feels like a microcosm of our general cultural impatience. There's a limit to how much government subsidies can speed the adoption of a new technology. There are going to be issues with hiring a bunch of technicians to install heat pumps really fast if they suddenly don't have as much work in five years. The Spanish solar-energy debacle of the early 2010s rings in my head. Maybe instead of setting big, distant, ambitious-sounding targets, we should set shorter, smaller, more gradual targets, and update every couple of years to accelerate in a sustainable way. It's pretty easy to say that the way to decarbonize the economy is "as fast as reasonably possible"; forecasting how fast that will be is hard, unnecessary, and potentially distracting.
- chankstein38 3y agoThank you, that's all I really cared about but I had "read my last free article" so I couldn't even find that out. I'm so tired of the internet.
- mrpopo 3y agoI want a "Netflix of information". Let me pay 30€/month for unlimited information access, quality, no clickbait and no ads. Of course, seeing what happens with Netflix now, I guess it wouldn't last long until things turn back to the old way...
- jzawodn 3y agoI guess that's sort of the value proposition of Apple News+ if you're in their ecosystem, right?
- ashryan 3y agoIn general, yes. But it's also the "Netflix of information" in that discovery is difficult, and you're fighting an opaque algorithm working behind the scenes. I'd love the information subscription but with, say, a NetNewsWire-style interface: reverse chronological feeds and search box.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pocketstar 3y agoinkl has pretty good variety of news sources for a reasonable subscription fee, i subbed for years then started using apple news. Unfortunately i cannot recommend inkl because you have to email support to cancel your subscription, they offer a 50% discount if you try to cancel but that business practice of sign up with one click, email support to cancel i cannot condone.
- deeviant 3y agoIt's the most obvious thing ever, and it, of course, will never happen. The new media companies seem completely oblivious to how people consume information. I touch 10+ news sources a day, at a minimum. There is no way in hell I'm going to subscribe to 10+ new services.
- rconti 3y agoBay Area, just beginning a remodel+expansion of our home. We've never had air conditioning, and our gas furnace is well over 20 years old. We'd likely need to upsize the furnace anyway, and for resale reasons if nothing else, adding A/C (and the attendant larger ducts or whatever else) is a no-brainer while we have the house apart. A heat pump is absolutely a no-brainer in our case. I like being able to get away from natural gas, although I must say, moving all electric means we'll be held hostage more and more to PG&E. (We have solar, but it'll be well below our needs once we had square footage and the heat pump, and don't want to get screwed by NEM 3.0).
- zbrozek 3y agoPG&E electric rates are so high that it's operationally more expensive to use a heat pump than a condensing gas system. The heat pump is the better deal practically everywhere else in the contiguous US. I'm installing a heat pump system in PG&E territory as part of a remodel, but pairing it with a large solar system.
- TheBlight 3y agoAren't PG&E gas rates substantially higher than their electric rates?
- samatman 3y agoThere are a couple ways to interpret what you're saying: that PG&E charges a higher rate relative to the national average for gas vs. electricity, which is what I think you mean, and that PG&E charges more for a joule of gas than a joule of electricity. Presuming you meant it the first way, it's still possible that heating with gas is cheaper, since the national average for a joule's worth of natural gas is quite a bit cheaper than the same for electricity.
- zbrozek 3y agoTheir price per joule of electricity is higher than per joule of gas by more than the coefficient of performance of a heat pump. You are better off getting thermal energy by burning gas if your energy provider is PG&E. The story only gets worse once you start carefully accounting for baseline allowances.
- readthenotes1 3y agoEvery state should be doing it it's a part of the inflation reduction act https://www.rewiringamerica.org/app/ira-calculator https://www.rewiringamerica.org/app/ira-calculator Plus a lot more
- david422 3y agoI recently got heat pumps in the hopes that I could phase out my oil furnace. What I can say so far is: The temperature is wildly inconsistent. I don't know if this is a software issue, a hardware issue, or just the way heatpumps work. I've had the installer come back and look at it, I've had the heat pump rep come and look at it too. They basically checked everything and tried to convince me this is normal. With oil, I can set the temperature to, say, 70, and the temperature will stay at 70. With heatpumps, I can set a temperature and it can vary by ... let's say 8 degrees. That's a lot. I have my bedroom temperature at 66, and the wall thermostat often gets up to 73+. I look at the software and it tells me the room is 68. Is the hardware not reporting the right temp? Does the software just suck? The heatpumps also vary in efficiency, so when it's warm outside it tends to overheat, and when it's cold outside it tends to struggle. Wondering whether I got lemons or if other people have similar experiences.
- thehoff 3y agoWe got a heat pump put in about a year and a half ago. We kept the oil as backup for the days its too cold (which if I remember right it switches over to oil somewhere around 40 F. Our situation is the opposite. The house feels more comfortable overall. Its still a little warmer upstairs where the home office and bedrooms are but generally around the house it feels a little more consistent. You can definitely tell when the oil furnace kicks in as the air is noticably hotter. But when that happens the house gets warmer faster and gets a little too hot before it turns off again. And stays a little too hot for too long. We went with a midrange system. In hindsight I do kind of wish we went with a different installer who was pushing a more "cadillac" type system where the fan (according to him) would always be (or just about) on but be variable in speed basically keeping the house at the right temp more often and slightly more savings.
- oramit 3y agoIt sounds like something is wrong with your installation. That behavior certainly isn't normal for heat pumps and I would get a new vendor. I had a heatpump in my Condo and those things were rock solid, from 20 degrees to 110 I never had issues. In my new house we have a gas furnace and are experiencing the same behavior this winter you describe where the programmed temp and the actual temp in the room wildly diverge. Just this morning I woke up to it feeling chilly. The thermostat said it was 65 and the programmed temp was 68 but it wasn't running. When the furnace runs it works great but something is off with the controller system. I need to call the heating people....
- varelse 3y ago[dead]
- beej71 3y agoOur neighbors are getting one (Central Oregon). Install price: $15,000. Or $20k with two additional heads. I have baseboard heaters, and even I don't know if I could make up that cost before the heat pump needs replacement. Every year now, though, it seems like we add one to the number of days we need AC, something that was unnecessary when I first moved here, so that would be nice...
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] wasting our time OP Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39288940 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39288940
- readingnews 3y agoI just replaced a furnace... everyone I called for a quote would not touch a heat pump with a 20foot pole, or they wanted prices that were 2X what a separate furnace and AC would cost to install. It was very strange. This is the second home where I had this experience.. basically, they really did not want to install it. I ended up going with gas as no local person would install/warranty a heat pump, or, it was priced so high it was a non-starter (e.g. a gas furnace is $4k, the AC is $4k, making it $8k, _but_ if you want a heat pump, well, that is going to be $15,999.85.) This was recently, btw, as in last month. I am still kind of shaking my head.
- huytersd 3y agoIf you’re somewhat rural the contractors just don’t have the experience to do it so they try to quote you out of the decision. I had to shop around until I found a contractor that had done this before and I was able to get a whole home heat pump for about the same price as a regular furnace/AC system (because of the rebates).
- TheBlight 3y agoHow well do they function? Do they provide nice consistent heat? How's the noise? Sorry to clog up HN with a random request of a product quality review but I'm in the market right now to replace my furnace as well. Thanks.
- demondemidi 3y agoHeat pumps need to come with an electric heater because pumps stop working below 30 deg F.
- headsupernova 3y agoThis isn't true, the latest models work at temps far below that. There are still thresholds where you'd want another source, but they're very functional even in the upper Midwest.
- 3y ago
- nostrademons 3y agoThese states really need to get their electric rates down if they want to accelerate adoption of electrification technologies. We were planning to fully electrify our house + transportation in the next few years. PG&E rate hikes and net metering policies put the damper on that. It's now more expensive to fuel a vehicle with electricity than gas, so I'm charging my PHEV at work and using gas for the rest. We have solar + battery sized for the existing usage of our house (gas heating, cooking, and vehicles), because that's what PG&E would let us interconnect. Upgrading the size to support a heat pump or EV would make us lose NEM2, so we've just chosen to defer those upgrades until NEM3 is rolled back or NEM4 comes out or there's new technology or the Californian government falls. In a way this is the market doing what it's supposed to. There's a shortage of electricity because of everyone doing electrification upgrades, so the price of electricity rises, which incentivizes people to defer further electrification upgrades until the grid can handle it. But if states actually want adoption, they need to solve the utility bottlenecks and increase generation capacity to support all the new usage.
- shadowpho 3y ago> It's now more expensive to fuel a vehicle with electricity than gas How is that possible? Even at 20c/kWh it's still a good 4x cost difference I though
- widdakay 3y agoPGE goes up to 66c/kwh during peak now and in San Diego I think is >70c/kwh. Off peak base is 34c/kwh for PG&E. Gas is $4.5-$5/gal so break even I think ends up being near 50mpg ish for a 300wh/mi EV.
- brewdad 3y agoI'm not in CA, so genuinely curious. When you quote 66 cents/kwh is that the marginal rate for an addition kwh or is that averaging in fixed costs? I pay about $20/mo just to have an active service line to my house, even if I were to shut off the breaker and not use any power. But my marginal rate is about 18 cents/kwh. I would call my rate 18 cents but not sure if we are doing an apples to apples comparison.
- yellow_postit 3y agomoved from oil furnace to heat pump in Seattle (with electric strip backup) Seems like a perfect fit for our weather patterns but was definitely not the most economical option as it kicked off a domino effect of upgrades I wasn't missing before. Its no where near as "cozy" as the oil heat was, and the temperature of airing coming from the vents is significantly lower than the oil system. So the domino of upgrades is now looking at insulation, windows, etc. Which likely all needed upgrades in our old home anyway, but it's been a journey.
- nsguy 3y agoI did the same in Vancouver, BC. We took advantage of incentives to improve our insulation and to make the switch. E.g. we just fixed our crawl space. The heat pump did struggle a little during the more extreme cold weather we saw a few weeks back (going down to -15C) but we've kept our natural gas fireplace as backup and "assist". I'm pretty sure it's a little more expensive to run with a heat pump, so you need to be willing to pay more for reducing your carbon footprint. The incentives do help though. Similar to switching to an EV which we also did for similar reasons. I think if you're purely looking at $$$ then it's not necessarily the optimal decision.
- bullfightonmars 3y agoI did the same this past thing, the best part about it is the reduction in cost for heating from 300+/mo to ~25/mo, The downside is that it was terribly expensive to install, it ran me 40k to install the new heat pump and air handler.
- brewdad 3y agoThat's why I stuck with a gas furnace and traditional AC when I was looking a few years ago. My heating and cooling costs are only about $800-1000 a year. Spending an extra $8-10k up front in hopes of reducing that figure simply doesn't pencil out. Maybe by the time I'm in the market for a new system it will.
- case 3y agoI'm going through this process currently (getting estimates from local HVAC contractors, SF Bay Area), and their general guidance so far is to get a Hybrid electric + gas heat pump config. The electric heat pump alone isn't sufficient compared with gas, and the "add-on" you get to add more heat to the heating output is like a space heater, thus very expensive month to month.
- nostromo 3y agoI have mixed feelings about our heat pump system. Yes, it's efficient. But it breaks about once every other year. Last winter the compressor circuit board malfunctioned and cost $5k to fix. Two years ago it was another issue entirely. All of our savings have been lost to service calls. I'm not super price sensitive, but it's still a pain when the heat goes out in the middle of winter and all the service techs are booked up. This is a Daikin system, which I thought was a pretty standard, respected brand. But like a lot of things built today, it just wasn't built to last. If we ever have to replace it, we're going to have to rip open half of the house to remove the heating lines. It'll be a nightmare. I had a heat pump water heater at our previous home, and the compressor also broke after a few years. We just operated it as an old-fashioned electric water heater after that because it would cost more to fix than it would to replace. And both sounded like a pain.
- nsguy 3y agoI got a TOSOT. So far so good.
- liminalsunset 3y agoI'm wondering if many of the failures in electronically controlled equipment are due to power surges etc. It may be worth having a whole-home (or equipment specific) surge protective device installed, which will protect the power electronics (which have very minimal surge protection built in) from anything else happening on the line (particularly if there are storms where you live often)
- stephen_g 3y agoWhole house surge protectors are now mandated in some country’s codes already. It’s a good idea, I’m looking at installing one here myself just because I have some expensive electronics.
- cyberax 3y ago> If we ever have to replace it, we're going to have to rip open half of the house to remove the heating lines. It'll be a nightmare. Why? Assuming you have a split unit, the lines are just copper pipes and will work with any other heatpump.
- prpl 3y agoWhich models are y'all using out there on HN, and for what square footage/location? I'm in SF and have a gas heater, but a 115 year old house with only 4 vents (none in bedrooms), and it's been cold. I'd like to replace, maybe DIY, but not sure.
- robszumski 3y agoOne issue with heat pumps is they are more complex in terms of modes they can be in, especially if you have multiple zones. I was troubleshooting an auxiliary heat issue and had to pull from the Ecobee API just to make sense of what was happening on cold nights across zones.
- aidenn0 3y agoAnyone know what sort of electrical requirements there are for these? We currently have a gas furnace and gas range. My electrical panel is full (we used up the last of it installing 220V for the clothes dryer), and the furnace is on the opposite side of the house from the electric panel, under a different roofline. I'm going to at some point get an electrician in to look at things and see what the options are, but my house just isn't wired for it currently.
- spamizbad 3y agoAssuming your home has 200 amp service you should be fine. Typically if your panel is out of space and more circuits are needed, you'll need a subpanel installed (just a smaller panel that handle some of your circuits). Alternatively an electrician may just recommend you upgrade to a bigger panel. Either way most of your costs are likely going to be on the labor side.
- ajross 3y agoYou don't need space in the panel as clearly you already have a circuit breaker for your existing air handler. It will be a bigger line though, my house in Portland got a central heat pump and handler that wants 40A.
- aidenn0 3y agoI would not put it past the people who wired this house to have shared circuit for the furnace blower with the bathroom right next to it, but we'll see.
- mapmap 3y agoIf you have lighting circuits that previously were incandescent but are now all LED, you might be able to combine some of them on a single 15 amp breaker.
- bluGill 3y agoIf you have AC, this replaces the AC and so uses that breaker. If you don't have AC you need space for a breaker in the panel - but this is easy to get (add a sub panel - $500) The real question is what kind of service you have. If the power company cannot deliver enough power then you need more power and this will cost you at best $4000 to replace your panel, and could be in the tens of thousands depending on what your power company wants.
- mdasen 3y agoOne of the big problems with heat pumps in New England is that our electricity costs 1.7x the US average (https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.php?t=epmt_5_6_a https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.ph...). If you're in the South, a heat pump makes perfect sense. You're going to want AC anyway and it'll be way more efficient and save a ton of money when you want heat. In most of the country, even if it gets cold your electricity prices are still a ton cheaper. Iowa/Kansas/Missouri/Nebraska get cold, but their electric rates are less than half ours. Heat pumps do work into freezing New England temperatures, but they're a bit less efficient as it gets to zero fahrenheit. That wouldn't matter if our electric rates were more reasonable, but at our high rates a heat pump would probably cost me an additional $50/mo in the winter (compared to natural gas). That isn't so bad and our electric rates might come down as offshore wind actually starts happening. Plus it might actually be cheaper than gas given that mini-splits would mean I could choose which rooms I want to heat rather than heating the whole place as a single zone. Plus there's the option to get solar power to drive down prices. But I think the biggest issue in New England (and California) will probably be the high cost of electricity. In most of the country, heat pumps are a huge no-brainer.
- bruce511 3y agoI'm not in NE, so forgive me if this is obvious, but high electricity prices might make solar attractive to you. (Unrelated to the heat-pump question.) I'm in a similar high-priced environment, but we get a fair amount of sun. I'm getting around a 16% return on capital based on electricity usage reduction.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoNew England just doesn't have a lot of light. The time to return on investment is commendurately longer. And in the winter it's much worse. NREL has solar availability maps. Alas the scale sucks; there's great monthly average views, but all done with the same yearly average scale, so during the summer everything is the same full-red potential (>5.75 kWh/m^2/d) and during the winter everything is (mostly) the same low potential (<4kWh/m^2/d). Still, one can kind of read some pattern from fall/spring & see how a lot of NE looks a lot like, say, Seattle (<<4 average). https://www.nrel.gov/gis/solar-resource-maps.html https://www.nrel.gov/gis/solar-resource-maps.html
- jwells89 3y agoI have an aging gas furnace that’s about due for replacement and a heat pump may be in the cards. Something I’ll need to research is how a heat pump would compare to electric heated flooring, though because the way my house’s HVAC system is set up the upper floor is heated before the lower floor, which exacerbates the natural temperature difference that results from heat rising and means the lower floor can be chilly while the upper floor is warm. My AC is fairly new still too which makes me think that installing heated floor in the base floor, letting heat rise to heat the upper floor with the old furnace remaining as a backup might be smarter. Electricity costs aren’t too bad here ($0.10-$0.14/kWh) so switching from consuming gas to consuming electricity won’t impact bills too much.
- sgc 3y agoYou can do both. For example: https://www.arcticheatpumps.com/radiant-floor-heating-with-heat-pump.html https://www.arcticheatpumps.com/radiant-floor-heating-with-h...
- jwells89 3y agoHad heard of this and it’s cool, but would involve tossing my still-good AC unit which doesn’t feel great unless the installer offers trade-ins or something (which doesn’t seem likely). Will consider going with a heat pump nonetheless.
- mypgovroom 3y agoEh I don't hate heat pumps, but they are not the answer
- billfor 3y agoHas anyone found a good way to control all the features of a heat pump with home automation? I’ve been lookin at Daikin and Mitsubishi but Daikin no longer has an open api and I don’t see much on Mitubishi. It seems like every heat pump comes with its own proprietary remote, and the thermostats and Wi-Fi modules (if available) don’t integrate well.
- qmarchi 3y agoI have a suite of LG Minisplits installed in my apartment. While there isn't a distinctly open API, there's an integration that you can add to Home Assistant for access to the platform. From there, I've got a few automations including: - Automatically turning off "conflicting" units (Heat vs Cool) - Schedules (set bedroom to cool at night) and "Away" modes - Temperature overrides using custom built temperature sensors (BME280 to the rescue) - Access and control via voice (via Google Assistants) Unfortunately, the integration is reliant on the cloud, but you can connect a "traditional" relay based thermostat to them as well (with the loss of variable load control for the outside unit).
- thebestmoshe 3y agoI’m in the same boat as you. As far as I can tell the only option is something like Sensibo, which uses IR. I would love to know if there is a better way to do this.
- lsllc 3y agoI have a Trane/Mitsubishi mini-split for a garage and it works via a Nest thermostat, so that's how I monitor/automate that. Google have APIs for Nest ... YMMV.
- callalex 3y agoEvery home in America should have a Heat Recovery Ventilator. They are extremely simple mechanically, yet because of their rarity they are still way to expensive to justify the cost instead of just opening a window. Policy could help a lot here.
- newhotelowner 3y agoWe use PTAC at the hotel and we only buy with a heat pump. It reduces electricity bills significantly in winter. It's not a new tech, but it has gotten more efficient over the years. I am surprised that all these companies are charging arms and legs for heat pump units. PTAC is about $100 extra if you get it with a heat pump. If you don't have access to natural gas, heat pump water will save you a lot in winter.
- readams 3y agoI recently had to replace my air conditioner, and I looked into a heat pump, which in theory should be almost the same thing as an air conditioner, but it was so much more expensive than the AC that it was impossible to justify.
- photonbeam 3y agoNeed to bring down electricity prices for this to be viable in many places
- endisneigh 3y agoI looked into heat pumps in north east - didn’t make any sense financially given cost of installation. break even was 10+ years. With that timeline I might as well wait.
- ursuscamp 3y agoAs always with these things, if they actually increase the value for home-owners, then people will naturally begin to select them on their own over time. However, if they do not increase value, then you will just be hamstringing your state by forcing people to use inferior products.
- freetime2 3y agoI hear a lot of horror stories on HN every time the subject of heat pumps comes up. Things like high costs, units not defrosting properly in winter, etc. Most of these stories tend to be for central air conditioning units. I think that mini-splits could be a much better introduction to heat pumps for a lot of folks. They are cheap, easy to install, and the units in my house have been running 12 years as our only source of heating/cooling with zero maintenance. (The manufacturer recommends replacing after 10 years, but they are still working fine). This is in an area where we get a lot of snow in winter, but temps almost never fall below -10c. And you can keep your existing furnace as a backup or secondary heat source.
- exitzer0 3y agoMini-splits seem like they are the future for the value conscious and light-weight DIY crowd. These systems are quite simple in design and implementation while also offering a pretty effective way to control temperature in a zoned way in various parts of the house. They also can be had in 120V sizes making them far easier to accomidate for solar-powered households, etc.
- bamboozled 3y agoI run mine in a similar climate to what you’re describing. Air based, not ground or water. Absolutely zero problems at all. Either I have some magic heat pump or a lot of the horror stories are overblown or based on using out of date technology.
- stainablesteel 3y agothose states specifically? every time they do something in unison it turns out bad imo
- JustLurking2022 3y agoThe only thing stopping me from buying a great pump is how unreliable the power grid is in my area. Lines are above ground, with numerous trees overhanging them so a snow storm is high risk for a power outage at a time I can least afford it, as road conditions may prevent seeking shelter elsewhere. Conversely, with a furnace and a small generator to run the blower, I can keep heat on through a couple days without power.
- bagels 3y agoWe lose gas heat when the power goes out (frequently) here too because the forced induction fans need electricity to run.
- JustLurking2022 3y agoYes, but it only takes a very small generator to power the fans vs. a huge one to power a heat pump.
- torpid 3y agoI live in an old furniture factory converted into lofts. LEED certified of course, with mini splits instead of forced air in each unit. This is in the midwest. For the past 11 years, every season it's failed to maintain minimum temperature of 68 degrees when it hits below 5 degrees outside, or maintain cooling in the summer. Another adjacent building built 2 years after this one with the exact same setup, same story. The complex had resorted to providing residents temporary space heaters up until this year where now they are prohibited by the city from using it to maintain minimum temps thanks to changing the code. The sheer amount of costs associated they've dumped into the maintenance of this mini split system, along with the electricity costs (electricity is included with rent) is mind boggling and certainly will offset any gains.
- jrockway 3y agoEmergency heat was under-installed. In the midwest, you have to have it, and it will suck down a ton of electricity for the handful of days a year you need it. Being entirely reliant on mini-splits without resistive emergency heating is a very strange choice, and it's not what heat pump advocates are recommending. The idea behind heat pumps is to eliminate the need for the natural gas distribution infrastructure. As the infrastructure ages, more pipes will crack (emitting greenhouse gasses, not to mention blowing up), and the cost will go up. Meanwhile, more renewable electricity is coming online, driving the cost down. (It is a much harder problem to replace every gas furnace in the US versus replacing every power plant in the US. That's why the process is starting early with "hey, maybe you don't want to replace your furnace".) Right now, it probably doesn't make a lot of sense to have a heat pump for the average midwestern house unless you have a pretty big solar installation. But in the future, the day will come where "we're going to pipe explosive gas into your house" is simply not done anymore. That will come in the form of gas companies not being able to maintain their infrastructure at the prices they charge, declining fossil fuel reserves, international demand to lower emissions, etc. It's not a crisis today, but today is not a bad day to start looking towards the future. (I'm looking forward to replacing my gas stove with an induction stove. CO2 levels are through the roof whenever I cook to the point I have to open windows. I don't need to be breathing all of that.)
- 3y ago
- bamboozled 3y agoIt’s so strange why we’re doing all this now. Why not 20 years ago? Better late than never but it’s a shame…
- kccqzy 3y ago20 years ago the best heat pumps still weren't good enough for cold days.
- bamboozled 3y agoDo you really think it took twenty years to bring them up to speed ? Honestly ? I’m mean if the interest and investment were there innovation would’ve happened sooner ?
- kccqzy 3y agoOh yeah absolutely it didn't need to take 20 years.
- bamboozled 3y agoThe only explanation I can think of is no one cares because they were told it wasn’t going to happen in their lifetimes. Now it’s accelerated , people care
- switch007 3y agoI don’t have a good feeling about retrofitted heat pumps at all. The government is pushing too hard. In the UK we have poor insulation, noise concerns (dwellings very close together), high electricity rates, periods of sub zero temperatures in winter and from what I can gather a lack of skilled fitters in this space. All together it doesn’t make a convincing argument Plus all the comments here about broken systems, high electricity costs, inadequate temperatures etc doesn’t fill me with hope Yes I’ve heard every rebuttal (“but Nordics”, “your fitter was bad”, “you under specced”, “you over specced” etc) Building code should have solved insulation issues decades ago. Heat Recovery systems etc instead of relying on drilling holes in to window frames as the primary source of ventilation
- nelblu 3y agoI have mixed feelings about heat pumps. Where we live winters aren't too harsh - our coldest night would be around -18C and for the most part January/February hovers around -10C at night. Our main heating is oil-based hot water baseboard radiator which I think is THE BEST type of heating solution from comfort standpoint. But few years ago we installed two mini-split heat-pumps which work great and save us a ton of money - BUT they don't heat the house evenly and you must leave all indoor doors open for effective heating. There is an option to convert the main heating to a geothermal heat-pump heating up the water but that is quite an expensive solution right now. For now I am never giving up oil in the foreseeable future.
- jcalvinowens 3y agoI have NEM2 solar, so obviously a heat pump is a big win. But I'm convinced the heat pump I installed a couple years ago would save money even without the solar: I pay $0.30-$0.40/KWh for electricity, and $0.08/KWh for natural gas ($2.35/therm) *. My heat pump has a COP of 3.62 when the outdoor temperature is 47F: it uses 1KWh of electricity to move 3.62KWh of heat into my home. The old gas furnace was 80% efficient ("AFUE"): it used 1KWh of gas to dump 0.8KWh of heat into my home. So, at 47F, as long as the ratio between the cost of electricity and natural gas is less than 4.53x (3.62 / 0.8), the heat pump saves me money. In my case, this means I save money when electricity costs less than $0.37/KWh, which it does almost all the time. At $0.30/KWh-electricity, I effectively pay $0.083/KWh-heat with the heat pump, a 17% total heating cost savings over the $0.10/KWh-heat the old gas furnace cost. Heat pumps do become less efficient as it gets colder outside: at an outdoor temperature of 17F, my heat pump COP is only 2.44, which would cost more than my old furnace ($0.123/KWh-heat vs $0.10/KWh-heat). Extrapolating linearly between the 17F and 47F COPs from the manual (it only gives those two points; this isn't strictly correct, but close enough), the temperature below which my heat pump starts to cost me more money than my old gas furnace is roughly 30F (3.0 COP). In the decade I've lived in the bay area, I've never seen it get that cold, which is why this is such a perfect climate for heat pumps. * These numbers are from August 2022
- vladgur 3y agoIs your $0.30-0.40/kwh rate based on your Solar cost? The non-solar rates[1] in Bay Area right now range starting from $0.42/kwh on tiered plan which you will blow through if you elect heat-pump heating and going all the way to higher than 50 cents per KWh if you are on one of the Time of US plan. [1]https://www.pge.com/assets/pge/docs/account/rate-plans/residential-electric-rate-plan-pricing.pdf.html https://www.pge.com/assets/pge/docs/account/rate-plans/resid... As much as i love the efficiencies offered by heat pumps, unless i splurge $10-$20k on a solar system with a battery backup, heat pumps are too expensive to operate with CA electrical rates. My gas(which i use for heating) during same period cost $2.54 per therm, although i dont know how to compare it to kwh for heating purposes. Update: I just checked my electrical bill for January. My total cost for generation and delivery of 478 kwh which is what my household used in 32 days, cost me $209 after fees and taxes which makes my rates around 44 cents per kwh on average.
- art_vandalay 3y agoWhy is this here?
- Vincentduff 3y ago[flagged]
- Prashanthills 3y ago[flagged]
- ab_goat 3y agoI converted my small (~1400 sqft) MA log cabin house at 1500' elevation to a heat pump as main heat source in 2017. We also added a 8kW PV system at the same time. It was a great choice, and we've been net negative since installation. We also get a lot of passive solar via low angle sun through large windows. I think passive solar in winter is a completely under-appreciated benefit. On sunny days in winter we do not need heat for ~10 hours of the day. We supplement our heat with a wood stove in very cold weather (< 20ºF). It's not necessary, but brings a cozy warmth.
- rapjr9 3y ago"supercharge the gas-to-electric transition by making it as cheap and easy as possible for their residents to switch." If you really want to make it super easy to switch, design new heat pumps that people can install themselves without having to pay a contractor to install one. Start with window units that look like air conditioners.
- Retric 3y agoWindow heat pumps already exist. Ex: https://www.lg.com/us/air-conditioners/lg-lw1216hr-window-air-conditioner https://www.lg.com/us/air-conditioners/lg-lw1216hr-window-ai... or https://www.compactappliance.com/koldfront-12000-btu-heat-cool-window-air-conditioner/WAC12001W.html https://www.compactappliance.com/koldfront-12000-btu-heat-co... Mini splits are also fairly easy to install and don’t take up a window.
- rapjr9 3y agoThese units use electric resistance heating, they do not heat using heat pumps. Mini splits require some gas handling equipment like a pressure gauge that most people will not have. I'm talking about something plug-n-play that anyone can install easily without hiring a contractor. There were a few actual heat pump window units in the past but they are no longer sold and they never made many of them to start with (or promoted them much). I think window heat pumps should be ubiquitous. Even if they don't heat/cool the entire house/apartment, they would be a very quick way to reduce some significant use of fossil fuels. For any solution that requires a contractor, the contractor will become a bottleneck to deployment and also raise the cost. If you want a quick global warming benefit enlist the millions of ordinary people to make a difference. Don't wait on the utility companies and government.
- Retric 3y agoWell that’s deceptive. Here’s one that lists 8000 BTU and caps at 1.2 kW so that’s a heat pump. The stated COP of 3.0 at 47° isn’t great, but it’s fine for a backup heat source. https://www.geappliances.com/appliance/GE-J-Series-Window-Built-In-Heat-Pump-8-000-BTUH-AJHS08AS https://www.geappliances.com/appliance/GE-J-Series-Window-Bu...
- justinzollars 3y agoWired is owned by Condé Nast. Condé Nast is owned by Advance Publications. Advance Publications, a private, family-held business that owns and invests in a broad range of media, communications, technology, education, and live entertainment companies, including Warner Bros. Discovery, Charter Communications and Reddit. This is corporate propaganda. Its expensive and won't be adopted. Expensive technology is stupid. People won't adopt it because no one has $100,000 to trench their yard - save a few tech workers in Atherton who wish to virtue signal. Politicians in these states are virtue signaling. We need abundant low cost energy. If it has to be carbon free - nuclear is the answer. I personally invest in Uranium because life is a struggle for energy and capital is really a form of stored energy. Nothing is more abundant in potential energy than splitting atoms. Its the answer we will reach. California is experiencing huge annual increases in energy costs because of virtue signaling. This is more virtue signaling. Yes we can heat our homes with heat pumps. But it will cost 10 times as much money.
- creatonez 3y agoHeat pumps represent roughly the same goal as nuclear -- the physics makes it possible for great efficiency gains and just needs engineering & clever management of installation lifecycles to get the cost down. To be clear, digging up your yard is for highly specialized geothermal heat pump installations. We should be skeptical of these projects because the geologic sites that allow it to be cost effective are quite rare. Normal heat pumps are just an air conditioner with a reverse configuration (not to minimize some of the difficulties of both implementing and then successfully retrofitting this)
- ta8645 3y agoAsking this question out of sheer ignorance: Aren't (air-to-air) heat pumps simply bidirectional air-conditioning units? If so, was AC incorrectly maligned for years as being inefficient and expensive?
- acomjean 3y agoYes. We replaced the central air ac this house came with, with a heat pump, so we get heating and cooling. My understanding is the tech has gotten better and more efficient. Running heat or ac off electric can be expensive. But climate control is fairly important.
- daleswanson 3y agoHeat pumps are air conditioners that are run in reverse, ie, you are air conditioning the outside. Another way to think of any AC/heat pump/refrigerator is as a heat mover, you can move (or pump) heat from one place to another. So in the summer you move heat from inside to outside, and in the winter you move heat from outside to inside. ACs/heat pumps are over 100% efficient (in terms of joules of heat energy moved/joules of electrical energy consumed), because they aren't turning electrical energy into heat, but rather using electrical energy to move existing heat. So, a heat pump should always be more efficient than normal resistive electrical heating, because that is just converting just about 100% of the electrical energy into heat energy. Heat pumps may or may not be cheaper than gas/oil/whatever fossil fuel based heat, depending on fuel and electric prices in your area, and that will likely change over time. The reason that AC is seen as wasteful/inefficient, I think, is just because historically most places people live, you can get away with just opening windows and being a bit uncomfortable during the warmest parts of the year. The opposite isn't really true, it's not really feasible to live without heat in most places people live. Additionally, heating or cooling in any form is just very energy intensive. So, any "optional" form of that can be seen as a luxury. To be clear, I'm a big fan of AC, and am not suggesting people should go without it if they need it, just trying to answer the question of why it was seen as inefficient when it is technically very efficient.
- Jakesben 3y ago[flagged]
- Animats 3y agoAre these reversible, as air conditioners? I'd expect so, but the article doesn't say.
- vgchh 3y agoI live in the New England and last year got a quote for replacing my existing boiler and furnace with two heat pumps. MassSave offers a good rebate program with $10k rebate. The problem is that the installers have bumped up the prices to the point where even after the rebate it would have costed me $35K. With that kind of price, and high electricity rates, I have no hope of saving money compared to my current setup.
- jakubsuchy 3y agoI have heat pumps and currently pay 31c a kWh in New York. Starting to regret them. They need to address electricity prices
- pie_flavor 3y agoNo. As technologically cool as electrification is, the power occasionally goes out. When that happens, the heat should not. Not everyone has access to a generator, but gas lines don't need that. Same reason we don't electrify toilet flushing despite potential water savings.
- saalweachter 3y agoOil burners and gas furnaces also use electricity, to modulate the fire and circulate the heat. The only thing they don't use electricity for is generating the heat. In a power outage it just sits there, not able to turn on.
- jtdev 3y ago[dead]
- simonjgreen 3y agoFor those complaining of the cost of electricity vs natural gas, consider if the cost matters when you are comparing to burning something you shouldn’t be burning in the first place. It’s a bit like complaining it’s cheaper to steal food from a store instead of pay for it. And I know electricity production is not renewable everywhere in the world yet, but at least it’s on a path and possible. Burning natural gas doesn’t have that course.
- turing_complete 3y agoTerrible analogy
- kenmacd 3y ago> I know electricity production is not renewable everywhere in the world yet, but at least it’s on a path and possible And somewhat counter-intuitively, even if you are going to consume that natural gas, it still works out better for the power plant to use it to generate electricity that's used to run a heat pump than to burn it directly for heat.
- naijaboiler 3y agoYour response is only true if using electricity to heat is cheaper than using gas to heat. It isn’t for resistive heating. For heat pumps it can, but it has to be high efficiency heat pumps that start efficient even at cold winter temps
- GhostVII 3y agoInstead of artificially boosting adoption, why not just price gas and electricity to match the negative externalities, and then people will just naturally choose the most efficient option. If heat pumps are cheaper, people will use them
- DeathArrow 3y agoWhy fix the price and not let the free market decide?
- perryizgr8 3y agoIf you need the state to use its authority and other tools at its disposal to accelerate the adoption of a technology, more often than not it means the technology is not good enough. On its own merits, it can't compete, so you need to help it by creating artificial incentives using taxpayer money. Very similar to public transport services or passenger rail. It probably just doesn't make sense.
- effnorwood 3y ago[dead]
- swimorsinka 3y agoI live in Colorado, so I'm in one of the colder climates with a decent amount of time spent below freezing each year. I've had a Mitsubishi Hyper Heat mini-split system with 2 outdoor units and 3 indoor heads for ~7 years now. I'm trying to move houses to get away from it. It's crazy noisy during the winter, the temperature control is whacky, and it's 2-3X the price to run than a gas furnace with electric vs gas rates around here. Not only that, with new 95% or 96% efficient furnaces, I'm not sure heat pumps are any greener. Don't get me started on the install costs and the fact that your average mini split unit is barely sized to heat a room, let alone a full house. For me, it was better than the electric baseboards I replaced, but I'd still prefer a standard furnace. I think we need to be very careful forcing everyone to convert to these until the tech is more mature, especially in the Northern states and places like Colorado. I looked on forums recently to see if the tech has evolved in the last 10 years, but many of the recent buyers still had the exact complaints I listed here.
- ip26 3y agoWho is your utility? It really shouldn’t be 2-3x much more expensive to operate, but could depend on your rates. Colorado is actually a relatively heat pump friendly climate; it can reach incredibly low temperatures some winter nights, but once the sun is up it’s back to 20-40F. Compare this to months of continuous deep cold near the Great Lakes.
- swimorsinka 3y agoXcel Energy. I'm usually at $300/month for electricity from November-March. A comparably sized house with an efficient furnace would be $100/month in this area (or so I've been told). My non-heat electric usage works out to something like $50-$75/ month. Our electric rates average 13-14 cents per KWH, but we just moved to timed metering, so that can vary a lot depending on peak hours.
- ip26 3y agoWow, that's nearly 70kWh/day for the entire winter. Most units are only 4-8kW, which suggests your system is running 50-100% of the entire winter. Using these numbers and an average COP of 2.5 (guess) you're at about 6 therms of gas per day, or about $5-6 while the electricity sets you back about $8. When was your home built? When I was in the northern front range, we averaged maybe 1.5-2 therms of gas per day.