17 ms·
It's time to admit that genes are not the blueprint for life
- booleandilemma 3y agoWell what are they then?
- kardianos 3y ago[flagged]
- 303uru 3y ago[flagged]
- kardianos 3y ago[flagged]
- Luc 3y agoThis is an excellent book by a science writer with a long reputation. You’ve completely got the wrong end of the stick.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoIt’s an open discussion not settled in any direction.
- dekhn 3y agoThere are many open questions in biology, but this article is by and large the current consensus in genetics and molecular biology. There are enough facts by now that we can conclude environment plays a big role, real traits are multigenic, the lock-and-key hypothesis was misleading, and evolution has a number of tricks up its sleeve that were not previously appreciated.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoOh, if your point is that both environment and genetics (and circumstance/luck) plays a large role in development then we completely agree. If you're saying that the role of genetics is overstated or insignificant then I strongly disagree.
- pdonis 3y ago> DNA/Alleles do in fact encode the "blueprints for life". Not really. They are more like incomplete recipes that depend on external factors to fill in the missing information. However, this has been known for decades and is not a new discovery. So I agree that this article is not describing any kind of breakthrough.
- samtho 3y ago> Not really. They are more like incomplete recipes that depend on external factors to fill in the missing information. As someone who has worked in construction, you have literally described blueprints. Blueprints specify key elements of a building, what sort of material is to be used, rough locations, routing of utilities, etc, but it’s up to the installer to use their knowledge of building practices and building code to perform the installation correctly. Sometimes materials can change due to availability (or budget).
- yreg 3y agoThe same applies to recipes. Recipe = Blueprint.
- pdonis 3y agoNo, recipe is not the same as blueprint. As I posted just upthread, a blueprint has a lot more detailed information than a recipe. In addition to that, a blueprint has a different kind of information. A blueprint for a human body, for example, would tell you the general plan of the body, where the organs go, how things are connected, etc. Yes, it might leave small details, like the exact location of each minor blood vessel or nerve fiber, up to the constructors, but it still is giving you an overall plan. DNA, however, does not do anything like this. DNA information is more like (I'm giving time frames off the top of my head here, so they're probably off, but I think the general idea is correct) "at week 1 after fertilization, split into three layers; at week 3, start differentiating cell types in each layer; at week 5..." and so on. And even that information is very incomplete; it's depending on a lot of external factors to be a certain way, like blood supply from the mother, particular hormones being present at particular times in particular concentrations, etc. There is nowhere in any of that where it says "the final body in general has a head, torso, two arms, two legs, the heart goes here, the brain goes here", etc. All of those things are emergent results from the process. So much more like a recipe than a blueprint.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- a1o 3y agoI don't understand what the word queer is doing in the sentence above. I also don't think your last paragraph works with the previous one. I do agree with the idea of changing the goalposts in the above article because as you mentioned DNA do in fact encode the "blueprints for life".
- gm678 3y ago> Reality: DNA/Alleles do in fact encode the "blueprints for life". This seems to be talking past the article, which notes: "genes’ activity — [e.g.,] the length of protein that they encode — depends on myriad external factors ... and each trait can be influenced by many genes. For instance, although the HCN4 gene encodes a protein that acts as the heart’s primary pacemaker, the heart retains its rhythm even if the gene is mutated. > This paper is a perfect example of a process called "complicating" a field, like they tried to do with the feminist glaciology paper Could you share an aspect of the book or a quote from the article which you think illustrates such a similarity?
- contingencies 3y agohttps://github.com/jdomingu/GameOfLifeLisp/blob/master/game-of-life.lsp https://github.com/jdomingu/GameOfLifeLisp/blob/master/game-... + https://woodrush.github.io/blog/posts/2022-01-12-lisp-in-life.html https://woodrush.github.io/blog/posts/2022-01-12-lisp-in-lif... = https://laughingsquid.com/wp-content/uploads/jacob-appelbaum-donald-knuth-20091107-141918.jpg https://laughingsquid.com/wp-content/uploads/jacob-appelbaum...
- droptablemain 3y agoI read this article twice, and I'm still not sure why it exists. It seems like a lot of flowery and vague language to basically say nothing other than "we should think about things differently because it's 2024 and old ideas are bad."
- sohkamyung 3y agoI'm now reading the book the article is reviewing. Like previous Philip Ball books, it is a dense but enjoyable read. Like other books on genetics and biology, it is best to read it while it is still fresh: in several years time, parts of it might be obsoleted by new biological findings.
- mcphage 3y ago> I read this article twice, and I'm still not sure why it exists. It’s a review of a book.
- doctorpangloss 3y agoA significant amount of research output from life science labs right now is descriptive single cell RNA sequencing papers. It is perhaps the single largest present genre of basic science research, and it is sucking all the air out of the room. I agree this article is pretty vague about criticizing this research. It doesn't name RNA sequencing.
- taeric 3y agoThis is tough for me. "Instead, we must let our ideas evolve as more discoveries are made in the coming decades." is a very appealing statement. My concern is admitting that something is complicated is different from saying it is not the case. To that end, is there anyone that thinks genes are a simple blueprint for life? Seems far more accurate to say that they are part of the blueprint for life, and that even with that, we have not defined the execution environment for how that blueprint is carried out. Do we present an even more simplified model to students? Especially young students? Absolutely. As we do to laymen. But things being markedly more complicated does not mean that models are bad.
- dbdappoiabab 3y agoThis always confused me as well. It’s all nature in the end - your genes will react to a certain environment in a certain way. Of course we have some control over environment so it’s worth making the nature vs nurture distinction, but how you react to an environment is predetermined. Not that we can easily predict any of this given the staggering complexity. Additionally, what’s the deal with the almost doublespeak in the article? The author plainly states that genes aren’t code, but then goes on to say they’re just more complex code.
- gary_0 3y ago> admitting that something is complicated is different from saying it is not the case. I agree. I do think "too many people take convenient science metaphors as literal" is a valid concern, especially when it comes to pedagogy, but the situation is not so bad that everyone is wrong about everything. No scientist goes around thinking molecules are made of little colored plastic balls.
- Mistletoe 3y agoFrom meeting identical twins in my lifetime, yes I’d say they are quite a blueprint for an organism. A blueprint doesn’t mean things are exactly the same, yes there are environmental factors, but there is a lot going on there that is the same. Identical twin studies done with twins separated at birth and experiencing different environments will show you that. https://www.gu.se/en/gnc/what-have-twin-studies-taught-us-about-essence-conditions https://www.gu.se/en/gnc/what-have-twin-studies-taught-us-ab...
- colordrops 3y agoIsn't this a matter of semantics? A blueprint for a computer could be stored on a computer, and it's obvious that the blueprint doesn't contain everything needed to build a computer.
- samtho 3y agoThis is a problem with using metaphors. Blueprints very accurately describe the role of genes by the way the article here describes them. I think they don’t have a precise understanding of what blueprints are, which means now semantics of the metaphor are critiqued rather than the actual content.
- samatman 3y ago[flagged]
- Xeamek 3y agoScience and ethics are connected literally for ever
- ninthcat 3y agoYou linked to an editorial about ethics. I'm not sure what to make of it, are you against conducting research and communicating it in an ethical way? Or do you disagree about something specific in that article? Either way I'm not sure I'm seeing the connection between what you're saying and the original article.
- huytersd 3y agoTo pull out a dusty old saying- “Reality has a liberal bias”. Many objectively scientific views end up running counter to preexisting ideologies.
- Xeamek 3y agoIt always surprising to me when people on programming related forum, a discipline that in a sense is all about viewing the world trough different levels of abstractions, get defensive when exposed to the fact that real world also do have them. Be that sociology, history or even 'hard science', simplyfing the world is inherent to comprehending it. Now, ofcourse, there are still 'good' abstractions and bad ones. But even the best one, by definition, hides some details away. As for the article itself - I do agree that it is mostly a fluff, and not something revolutionary. But also nothing to criticize it for, either
- zizee 3y ago> This burst of activity represents a frustrated thought that “it is time to become impatient with the old view”, as Ball says. Genetics alone cannot help us to understand and treat many of the diseases that cause the biggest health-care burdens, such as schizophrenia, cardiovascular diseases and cancer. Does anyone actually subscribe to this "old view"? Surely the majority of scientists, medical professionals, and laymen alike understand environmental factors play a huge part in this. Why make a call to action to address a imagined state of affairs?
- mcphage 3y ago> Does anyone actually subscribe to this "old view"? I think that’s how genetics is communicated… if you have gene X, you’re Y% more likely to get a disease. Stuff like that.
- jevoten 3y agoEven in this most simplified form, it's clear genes don't determine all of the outcome. You're Y% more likely to get a disease, with other factors affecting how the dice actually fall.
- b450 3y agoI can personally attest that some medical professionals have a pretty dismal broad understanding of genetics and evolution. And besides, even if the book isn't breaking new ground, or is targeting a more a popular audience, a good writer synthesizing developments in a field and providing fresh metaphors for understanding it can be tremendously beneficial, even to the academic side, I think. There's also an element of marketing and puffery in how authors talk about their new books. All that said, yeah. I've for a long time liked the simple idea that the organism is the product of interaction between genes and their environment. That simple notion alone banishes many of the supposed misapprehensions under attack in this article.
- antisthenes 3y ago> Why make a call to action to address a imagined state of affairs? Because it's easier to argue against windmills than actual opponents.
- cosmin800 3y ago[flagged]
- dekhn 3y agoMany biologists will say that studying evolution and development is the key to understanding how phenotypes arise. I agree. Watching the development of an organism- say, a tardigrade egg that grows over a few days and then hatches- is remarkably edifying. You can see individual cells growing and moving around and then look at another tardigrade egg and see exactly the same cells growing and moving around to the same exact places (this is a feature called eutely- they have a predetermined lineage of cells all arising in the same tree structure from the same original egg cell, which (in many tardigrade species) is in fact a clone of its mother (no fathers rrequired- known as parthenogenesis). I think many people would see that, along wiht other observations, and easily come to the conclusion that specific behaviors were encoded for by individual genes, or that genes act like an architectural blueprint, exactly specifying either intermediate or final states. Instead, in each of those cells is a blob of jelly filled with the genome, which is decorated with all sorts of proteins that are flying around, binding to vairous specific sites, activating and deactivating other sites, which then get turned into RNA and ultimately specific proteins. These proteins execute a plan encoded in the genome, but they do so probabilistically, with noise immunity, following physical behaviors that can be understood rationally (although in most cases, the number of actual variables is far too large to work with). And that encoding is extremely complex, more like a collection of weakly linked PDEs (a lot of weakly linked PDEs). There is massive feedback, both positive and negative, that contributes to automatic regulation of components so that the plan proceeds normally. Many of these regulations lead to extremely non-linear, complex behaviors. Yet, for all this complexity, fairly straightforward actions that are similar to tardigrades happen in nearly all life. A sphere forms from an egg. The egg splits in two cells, then four, then many, retaining the spherical shape. At some point one of the split cells develops a polarity- one side grows more actively than the other. This leads to a body development plan (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blastulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blastulation) that self-generates with mostly local interactions (IE, there's no central controlling cell, it's more that the cells are just pushing against each other and the result is the right shape). Understanding how genotypes lead to phenotypes has been a massive journey and I have had to unlearn much of what I was originally told, as new data has subsumed previous ones. That mendelian model of peas with discrete characteristics that segregate on different chromosomes is useful, and does show up in biology, but from what I can tell, it's just an easy, special case that we saw early, then geneticists overfit new data on that model. When viewed through evolution as well as development- we start to see how complex phenotypes begin, then evolve to become far more complex. Early eyes and wings had utility, similar to modern eyes, but far less capable. Through mutation and selection, the organisms whose eyes worked slightly better were more likely to generate offspring that inherited those properties,leading to even more radiation (into many different types of organisms that all share similar eye properties). I used to think that by this time in my career (I'm 51), we'd have been able to address a simple question I asked when I was 18: why is my nose this funny shape that doesn't look like other people's noses? What genes "encode" the "blueprint"? And to be honest, we're still really far from answering questions like that, but through a combination of data collection and machine learning, scientists actually are beginning to understand the complex process that leads to funny nose shapes. For those who made it this far, here's your prize. A video of a tardigrade being born while its two younger siblings continue to prepare for life. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snUQTOCHito https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snUQTOCHito
- GenesAreDefCode 3y agoOf course "cells are computers and genes are their code" is an oversimplification, but it's not a terrible analogy. It seems to fail the worst if either - you stretch the analogy too far, as is the case with all analogies, or - you don't understand much about computers or code. A given set of code can produce different results when compiled by different compilers, or on a different computer, or for a different computer, and a given executable can produce different results depending on whether or not libraries or peripherals are available, etc. No one will ever be able to make a one-sentence analogy that will satisfy every scientist, but in spite of that many analogies are incredibly useful. If someone doesn't like the "cells are computers and genes are their code" analogy, I'm all ears for a better one.
- r0ze-at-hn 3y agoI have given a few genetics talks this past year to technical groups and I start the talk by saying "This is no more difficult to understand than any event based system" [insert image of the Netflix micro services architecture] This gets a laugh. DNA is like an executable file written in assembly. Most of the time it makes a bunch of pure functions (but not always) and it is self modifying, lol. For most of the work I do I can presume that gene X produces a "pure function" At the next level up you have a bunch of functions that can take some arguments and spits out some stuff. The question is does that function work etc? At the next level up you have systems thinking. If I have 100 lambda servers that are all executing from a queue and then I have 20 lambda servers that are all reading from those 100 you can guess where the data is going to pile up. I am radically over simplifying, but hopefully you see the parallels to binary, code, application logic In our "designed" software you can almost never go and change one line to modify the behavior of a program. Instead you have dozens if not millions of functions that all interact depending on the lens by which you want to look. Usually it is contained in on "area" with code that matters the most, but that isn't always the case. Is it any surprise that biology is even messier? The article mentions the 300 genes related to schizophrenia. This is like me mentioning that my random Go service also uses a bunch of Go standard library code when it is executing. Debugging stuff like this is what our careers are made of. For a long time scientist were looking for a single gay gene. Poking around once I knew what to look for it only took around 6 months to figure out the whole LGBT, but in nearly all cases it involves more than just one gene. You simply have to apply debugging logic at each layer to figure it out. It is handy to understand all the layers, but depending on the problem not always required.
- picometer 3y agoWow - can you elaborate on your process to “debug” these different layers? What comprises your personal or team’s feedback loop, given that 6 months is short? (I suspect it’s a lot of sequencing?) Are there good comparisons to be made with getting acquainted with a new codebase/technical system? Are there any particular computational tools involved? Pardon all the questions, this stuff is fascinating!
- 3y ago
- aa1234556 3y ago[dead]
- belorn 3y agoI recall a simplification that said that if we used computers code as an analogy, genes would be similar to functions, epigenetics would be similar to conditions over which functions get called and when, and the environment is the argument and events in which the program get executed with.
- picometer 3y agoWe lack good metaphors here. Like genes, the following collections of information are plans, as other entities (workers, compilers, cells, etc) can reliably use them to produce larger, more complex objects: - Blueprint - Instruction manual - Recipe - Code Unlike genes, they’re all human-designed. The top-down forcing function - the “back” in the feedback loop which shapes them - is human artifice. I’ll leave it as an “exercise to the reader” to consider the differences in how their environment and execution apparatuses affect the resulting objects. Genes are like blueprints, but obviously not the same. For one, they haven’t passed the county permitting process! And living organisms are like buildings because you can point to the plan behind them. But I’ll be darned if a house has ever had to struggle for survival.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kderbyma 3y agoI still find the analogy mostly appropriate. Perhaps, it is not the 'high level source code' that is strictly typed as was perhaps believed by some, but I think it can still act as analogous to the runtime memory state of the computer. The genes are like memory mapped services which can operate on one another and change their state, and this couples with interrupts from the external environment that force changes to the state and memory, but the runtime code adapts and still has access to in-memory functions to call when appropriate, but every so often a buffer overflow can occur or be enticed and this causes other issues.
- boxed 3y agoYea, you have to keep in mind that while it's sort-of code, it's code written by random errors and selection. Obviously the code quality isn't going to be awesome :P
- RayVR 3y agoThe article's title and the words of Denis Noble are quite incendiary and come across as misinformed. Are the non-quoted ideas attributable to Ball accurate? I don't know. The actual quotes from Ball, wherein he laments the comparisons of cells to computers comes across as ill-informed. Computers operate on programs. If a program is dependent on complex state, includes random factors, error correcting codes, etc., how is it incompatible with the description of the cell? Yes, cells are immensely complex. But that does not preclude analogizing to a computer. This critique strikes me as refusing to admit the nuance of another's argument while demanding others see the "correct" nuance in one's own.
- pama 3y agoI have not read the book, but the article makes it sounds like the author thinks most scientists or laypeople are stuck in their views from the sixties, seventies, and eighties, which in my experience is unbelievably far from where scientists in academia and drug discovery stand for the last couple of decades at least. Of course it is useful to know the human genome and to study genetics more broadly, as it is to know about simplifying assumptions like a rigid protein conformation. In physics, the harmonic oscillators are a central unifying concept and yet they don’t appear in the real world so nobody stops their quest for truth at the harmonic approximation. Cells are complex machinery with many unknown pieces in them despite our best efforts to decipher them. Maybe the computer analogy to cells is not bad, however one has to think of this computer as made of floppy, flexible, self modifying pieces that exchange information and materials with their environment as they compute, and not think about your typical nanolithography or UV laser etched silicone-based chips.
- progrus 3y agoNot in the sense that any person has ever used the word “blueprint”, no.
- fuzzfactor 3y agoI don't know, I think a lot of final products don't come out that close to the blueprint to begin with, or don't stay that way for long once put to use. It's how things are expected to be constructed, but expectations are not always realized.
- progrus 3y agoThis is totally different from any design stage that is iterative or modular in that way though. It’s more like that laminar flow demo where you mix the paints in a circle and then unmix them the other way - the patterns are there but the way they emerge cannot be understood due to chaos and complexity.
- fuzzfactor 3y agoThat is a good way to say it, like the foundation is set by genetics but chaos sets in real soon and lasts forever.
- analog31 3y agoI wonder if it's still accurate to say that genes are the blueprint for proteins, and then build on that concept to the extent of what's known.
- kazinator 3y agoThe story is something like this: the genes act out in an environment. They encode information which demonstrably makes the most important and obvious differences between, say, a fruit fly and human. However, they don't necessarily encode all of the cellular environment in which they act. (Though do direct its activity and proliferation.) That environment is part and parcel of life as much as the genes.
- goodSteveramos 3y agoThe cellular structure is maintained and propagated by the DNA. If you want to say that the very first cell’s structures (the zygote) is inherited from the mother and not produced by the individual’s genes but by the mother’s genes I suppose you could define that first cells organelles as a special kind of gene ‘inherited’ from the mother, but it certainly is not what people mean by the environment in discussions about nurture vs nature.
- kazinator 3y agoThat's why I said "cellular environment". The literal biological environment in which genes act. Not the household environment in which a human baby finds itself; that's indeed something else. But I'm saying that genes are not the complete blueprint of life even in this "low level" sense. (Never mind that gene expression is in the developed individual is subject to external factors, too).
- ta988 3y agoThe interesting part is that what we call disordered is really likely to be something more akin to organized chaos in some or even many cases. Sure it is not an helix or a sheet that is all nice and tidy (and yet there are a lot of variation there as well). A bit of the same with the "junk-DNA". It reminds me a bit when unexperienced developpers join a team, they often want to get rid of what seem useless to them and "simplify".
- sinuhe69 3y agoSaying genes are not the blueprint for life is for me like saying “physics can not predict our life”. It cannot but everybody knows physics is the foundation of our universe. However, our world is ways to complex to use physics laws to predict all aspects of it. Stochastic is the intrinsic nature of every complex system.
- tsimionescu 3y agoThat is exactly the wrong model. Genes are only a part of how your body is formed, and two identical genotypes will not produce identical phenotypes if the environment, especially the very very early environment of the egg/uterus, is different. That's why we can't grow babys in vats, for example, and are having massive issues even trying to grow tissues in vitro (and growing whole organs is not even a dream for now). Consider also that your neurons, your red blood cells, your muscle cells, your liver cells, your fat cells etc all have the exact same genes. And yet, they are vastly different between each other, and you'll never see a fat cell divide into a red blood cell and a neuron, even though they are "built of the same blueprints".
- Jensson 3y ago> Genes are only a part of how your body is formed And blueprints are only a part of how a house is formed. Two different teams of workers can build very different houses from the same blueprint. So what you say here sounds just like a blueprint, I don't see why that is wrong. Edit: > Consider also that your neurons, your red blood cells, your muscle cells, your liver cells, your fat cells etc all have the exact same genes. And yet, they are vastly different between each other, and you'll never see a fat cell divide into a red blood cell and a neuron, even though they are "built of the same blueprints". Yes, and us programmers tend to deploy the same code to many different servers and tell some of them to be databases, others be frontend etc. It is just simpler and more robust to share code and then then just flip a few settings on startup to change what the server is. A single blueprint describing many things that are working together and you can build any of those things is very common.
- 3y ago
- niemandhier 3y agoAstralCodex discussed this recently. I am not a fanboy, but it’s one of his better articles: https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/its-fair-to-describe-schizophrenia https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/its-fair-to-describe-schizo... I just wish he’d apply the same reasoning to his believes on the genetics of intelligence.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 3y agoThe thought which had occurred to me some time back is that genes are less a blueprint than a bootloader.
- vemv 3y agoOr the early version of a bootstrapped compiler
- dredmorbius 3y agoThat's another good analogy, yes.
- samuell 3y agoSlightly OT but has anybody built an aggregator for bio-related content on HN?
- Ekaros 3y agoBlueprint evokes this picture of house, or car, or plane... Which we really do not have, we do not have ability change a bit and add extra pair of arms for example. To my understanding genes are more like massive collection of recipes, which of products interact in myriad of ways eventually producing something quite consistently. Something being wrong can results some condition from time to time in what is produced.
- singularity2001 3y agoThere are hoc genes though which pretty much lay out the pattern of tissue (best seen but far from exclusive in the example of butterfly wings) of cause there is a whole mess of other genes and functions, so a more correct that would be: genes don't __only__ represent blueprints for proteins and tissue
- LarsDu88 3y agoI have a PhD in biology and I work in machine learning today. After years of study my takeaway is that reductionist analogies are helpful for giving folks something to grasp on, but at a certain level, you have to step back and appreciate the complexity of certain things. At some point, only machines will be able to fully grok what is actually going on. Does that mean reductionist thinking is bad though? How does GPT4 think? A piece of data getting multiplied by a gazillion parameters you will never understand. How does one cell become a human? A gazillion chemical reactions happen in parallel you will never understand. What is consciousness? The firing of a gazillion synapses you will never fully understand. The three challenging phenomena I described may seem intractable to reductionism, but have seen the greatest progress from reductionist approaches. Most of the greatest and most useful knowledge will be very reductionist in nature. How many transcription factors are needed to turn this skin cell into a stem cell? About 4. What is the best architecture for machine translation? Fits on the back if a postcard? What chemical transmitter underpins human happiness? Can be synthetically manufactured in your mother's basement...
- 3abiton 3y agoCan a reductionist approach be good enough to control life independently? Or do we need to emulate the full process? I am not sure if the point of the article is to bash reductionism, but maybe push for full understanding. Kind of like Newton's law fits well within Genera Relativity. A first step.
- dsign 3y ago>> to push for full understanding. The point of the GP is that that full understanding can't happen in a human brain, but reductionism may be a lever good enough for that human brain to use. >> do we need to emulate the full process? Probably not, but let's assume 'yes'. It seems likely that it would possible to optimize the emulation to a point where it becomes practical. We do something similar today with weather simulations; it's not possible to emulate each molecule in the air, and yet meteorological models manage to account for an insane amount of processes and--short term--produce accurate predictions. In a more subjective note, I believe the methods and ways of thinking in biology need to shift from "let's understand everything" to "let's produce a forecast and maybe fix some stuff". Pharma companies are already in that track, but it could be that the general public and people in academia are still in the full-complete-very-detailed-understanding wagon.
- Animats 3y agoWell, cloning does work. Remember Dolly, the sheep. Now there are two companies routinely turning out clones of polo ponies.[1] They all look the same and perform about the same. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTmVpzAnpxo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTmVpzAnpxo
- boxed 3y agoI think people who complain about these analogies have themselves too simplistic ideas of how computers and locks work :P
- kweingar 3y agoIt’s interesting that throughout history we have tended to characterize the behavior of biological systems in terms of the dominant technology of the time. At one point, it was mechanical automata. Then it was hydraulics. Then it was electrical circuits. Now it is computers. It seems that some people have become overly attached to the computer code explanation of DNA, viewing it not just as a convenient analogy to current technology but as a fundamental truth. They will ask questions like “if DNA is code, then what corresponds to functions? or exceptions? or data structures?” and end up working backwards from the analogy instead of observing what DNA does and building a mental model from there. (It doesn’t help that the code analogy is very flattering to the programmer’s ego.)
- angiosperm 3y agoMichael Levin appears to be demonstrating that cells have a goal-seeking intelligence operating more or less independently of directions from the nucleus. Since literally every cell on earth arose by fission from another cell, the lineage of this intelligence goes back in an unbroken line to their first common ancestor billions of years ago, with natural selection operating on it directly by success at solving problems of survival and reproduction in real time, not just via selection of genes. In a similar way, every membrane in every cell came from extending and then splitting an existing membrane, again more or less independently of the nucleus. Natural selection has operated directly on those membranes, besides its role in adapting the genes that code for subunits of the membranes. The nucleus might be thought of as mainly a library of apparatus that the cell's goal-seeking capacity may draw upon as needed. This analogy is necessarily limited because there are innumerable feedback control cycles encoded in genes and repressor and promoter proteins they encode, and enzymes to methlylate or de-methylate start and stop codons. But something is in charge that operates on a shorter scale than those can. We understand very, very little about that intelligence. It is far more capable than we could ever have guessed. It barely seems possible, with as few moving parts as we know about.
- ace2358 3y agoLovely insight
- 3y ago
- navane 3y agoAs someone who works with actual blueprints, I'll tell you that even those don't guarantee what the actual asset looks like.
- GTP 3y agoThis remembers me of my Philosophy professor in high school. He made analogies to help us understand complex topics, but he always stressed that all analogies have limits, one has to use it to understand the deeper concepts and then forget it.
- jl6 3y agoI understand why they went with the combative “admit” phrasing in the title. Subtextually, this is a shot fired against unsavory opinions that claim a basis in strict genetic determinism. However, that strict interpretation is an extreme fringe of belief. The interaction between “nature” and “nurture” is a fully mainstream concept, especially amongst scientists, and especially amongst biologists. What is this “New Biology” of which the book speaks? The article is arguing against something of a straw man. Worse, this manner of challenging the notion of strict genetic determinism is fuel to the terminally polarized who will snap to the equal and opposite error of assuming genes don’t matter at all - an idea which underwrites a bunch of profoundly unscientific woo.
- 0thgen 3y agoWell said. "The picture is more complex than this strawman" is being framed as "we need a new paradigm!". I'm curious what motivates this. It's not like progress in genetic research and technology has stalled (see: crispr, IVF screening, GMOs, etc). And I don't see how moving from "genetic determinism" to "environmental determinism" is any less depressing / defeatist. World politics suggests we have about as little control over our environment than our genetics
- doriss 3y agoGenes are toolbox, is it?
- boffinAudio 3y agoSo, its like this? DNA: a descriptive string of bytecode which describes state VM: ??? what is the virtual machine?
- evv555 3y ago>Genes, proteins and processes such as evolution don’t have goals, but a person certainly does. So, too, do plants and bacteria, on more-simple levels If we're expanding the scope of what we consider to have agency and goal directedness why stop there? Evolution is analogous to a hill climbing algorithm which also has the same properties.
- mnw21cam 3y agoI agree with most of the article, but I'll argue that there are some genes that do have a 1:1 relationship with diseases. I work investigating them. There's a spectrum of genetic variants. Most (like 99% might be an underestimate) are completely benign and have no effect. Some affect traits that you have, like your height, intelligence, or susceptibility to schizophrenia or diabetes (lots contribute to these), or eye colour (fewer contribute to this). But there are also mutations that single-handedly will cause a disastrous child-onset disease. One of the first things I learnt when starting studying genetics more than 20 years ago was that living things will break almost every rule you make up for them. So we say that genes are to make proteins - the information flows from DNA to RNA to protein. That rule gets broken in various ways - retroviruses flow the information back from RNA to DNA, some genes never get converted to protein but the RNA they produce is active instead. So the message is absolutely that most times we try and say things about genetics, and every single time it will be an over-simplification. And this applies to the article too.
- dotsam 3y agoHere is a video of a discussion between Richard Dawkins and Denis Noble (who wrote the linked article, and who was Dawkins' doctoral examiner): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLC0akD1WOE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLC0akD1WOE
- robertlagrant 3y ago> or example, mutations in almost 300 genes have been identified as indicating a risk that a person will develop schizophrenia. > It’s therefore a huge oversimplification, notes Ball, to say that genes cause this trait or that disease. That sounds as though the genes do cause the disease, at least sometimes. This article - whose author seems to have mind-melded with the book itself, providing no objectivity I could discern - seems to be arguing against a straw man. No one thinks that it's only genes that cause disease. If I catch covid, it wasn't my genes. If I get type 2 diabetes, it (probably) wasn't my genes.
- lynguist 3y agoIn the same vein I would like to challenge the tree model of life, of species, and of any genetic variation. The reality is much closer to trunks that merge and branch, similar to git. This applies to the origin of life, to differences between species, differences between populations, also to human language classification. Also to the origin of humans. The tree model I would “consider harmful”. It affects society and policy in a strong way.
- 0thgen 3y agoI think Scott Alexander's [recent post on genetic causes of schizophrenia](https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/its-fair-to-describe-schizophrenia https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/its-fair-to-describe-schizo...) is an important piece here. Basic summary is: just because there are environmental / other factors doesn't mean it's incorrect to say that gene's cause schizophrenia. In other worse, finding additional causal variables doesn't negate the causal impact of existing causal variables.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 3y agoDoes that mean we won't be able to grow mammoths and dinosaurs from their recently found dna? Another childhood dream shuttered.
- Kim_Bruning 3y ago> “So long as we insist that cells are computers and genes are their code" Dude, it would be a huge improvement already if people DID treat cells as computers and genes as their code. Or rather, DNA, including especially also the bits that are not genes. Many people really don't seem to think of DNA like they think about software at all. And those people draw all kinds of weird conclusions that they'd never draw if they realized it was at least like software. Because then they'd realize that of course it's unlikely to be able to find a (single) gene for eg. 'intelligence'. Just like there's no op-code for 'Mario' in 6502 machine code. (Not even if the 6502 is installed in a nintendo entertainment system.) Treating DNA as software is not necessarily sufficient, but it is certainly necessary if you want to make a start at getting anywhere near sufficient. > "It's time to admit that genes are not the blueprint for life" Well, yeah, blueprints are static pictures on a piece of paper, while programs can be dynamic, complex, iterative, recursive, undecidable and/or fundamentally weird. By the time we get to whatever this self-modifying highly evolved pile of spaghetti that is called "DNA" is; sure, we may want a separate word for that kind of phenomenon. 'Alive' might come close. But I hear that that's highly controversial. ;-)
- grantcas 3y ago[dead]