13 ms·
U.S. cities opt to ditch their off-street parking minimums
- elektor 3y agoThere is a thorough book on this topic, Paved Paradise: How Parking Explains the World. Highly recommend it if you're interested in the causes of so much of our dysfunction in housing costs. https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/634461/paved-paradise-by-henry-grabar/ https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/634461/paved-paradi...
- r00fus 3y agoInteresting. I also listen to podcasts like The War on Cars [1]. [1] https://thewaroncars.org https://thewaroncars.org
- nayuki 3y agoThe Urbanist Agenda by Jason Slaughter / Not Just Bikes is a wonderful companion podcast: https://www.youtube.com/@theurbanistagenda/videos https://www.youtube.com/@theurbanistagenda/videos
- _dain_ 3y agoAlso "The High Cost of Free Parking" by Donald Shoup.
- pramsey 3y agoYep, good read and wonderful on the vicious cycle that led to the downtowns of most US cities looking like WWII bombed out zones by 1975.
- adventured 3y agoThat's not the cause at all. Extreme minority poverty and the potent bifurcation of incomes, education and wealth in the US is the cause. Parking won't fix any of that realistically. You can push minority poverty to the suburbs, which for example is what France does, however it doesn't solve anything about the bombed out look, it merely redistributes the problem to somewhere else. You can gentrify the cities and push poor minorities to the suburbs and inverse how it's arranged in the US now, it will make the suburbs look bombed out - until you fix the minority poverty problem.
- ponector 3y agoRoot cause it's poverty, it is zoning laws and taxes for real estate.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoLowering housing costs is a pretty good way to reduce poverty, isn't it?
- toofy 3y agoas usual, it’s probably a mixture of many things, and poverty is one, property prices is another, and there are certainly many many others. we (engineering types) have this terrible habit of declaring that it is One Thing when in reality, complex problems are… complicated. shocking, i know. it isn’t a simple math problem with a one answer. human problems are significantly more chaotic and fractal. i don’t want to imply that we shouldn’t look at these and add our ideas, only that id love to see us lessen our crutches of “You’re wrong, it’s X!” and recognize that others are probably correct as well.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kjkjadksj 3y agoHonestly that would be fixed with expanded immigration. Look at places where the limited immigrants we have had in recent years primarily ended up and have changed the demography, like LA county or Miami-Dade county, and they don’t look like those midwestern or great plains cities. In fact there are almost no vacant parcels anywhere today, with majority latino populations now reflecting the recent waves of immigration.
- ljsprague 3y agoYou're confusing correlation with causation. Immigrants are more likely to go where there are jobs.
- bluGill 3y agoImmigrants have a lot of motivations. Jobs are one, but unless the immigrant was recruited for a specific job (which is common) it isn't primary. There are jobs everywhere, even in blighted cities. Immigrants with no particular job in mind look for places where the cost of living is low: they tend to have much worse job prospects than normal, so a minimum wage job in a low cost of living area is better life than double minimum wage in a high cost of living area. Immigrants often have poor English skills (or whatever the local language is). They often are used to food not common in the country. So if they can find a community of other immigrants that means people they can comfortably talk to, and also makes it more likely that someone can figure out the process of getting food they like into local stores.
- carom 3y agoLA has extremely dysfunctional housing policy. A wave of immigration does nothing but increase demand for housing and drive up prices on rather limited stock. It has not lead to an increase in housing stock or better commercial districts. Adding more people who don't really speak the language laws are written in doesn't change the laws that prevent you from building vibrant cities. There is very little mixed use. Majority of the city is zoned single family. The only reason there are no parking minimums is because the California changed that law. It has nothing to do with expanded immigration. LA, despite the immigration, is in massive need of a zoning overhaul to build a vibrant city. Very little is walkable, it is very car-centric, and the zoning is the strong opposition to all of this.
- nunez 3y agoYou got me super interested in this book now. This is a pattern that I've kept seeing in my visits to lots of other cities in the US (especially cities in the South) and I always wondered why that was (aside from white flight and big auto, though I figured those weren't the _only_ reasons).
- hardcopy 3y agoThere's a lot of people commenting in this thread that would benefit from reading this book...
- Amorymeltzer 3y agoEasily one of the best books I read last year, and probably the one that had the biggest lasting effect on the way I look at things.
- voisin 3y agoIt’s one thing to ditch parking minimums, but it has to be matched with investment in public transit. Simply eliminating parking spots doesn’t eliminate demand when there are no other options for getting around. And I suspect the public transit investment will be way more controversial and difficult to implement.
- r00fus 3y ago[flagged]
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> Nothing changes overnight but it allows for denser development esp. around existing public transit lines. The problem is there a barely any decent "existing public transit lines" in Austin. Existing public transit line, singular, perhaps, and in a decade or so we'll get some more. In the meantime it just means traffic gets much shittier with no real alternatives.
- Eisenstein 3y ago> The problem is there a barely any decent "existing public transit lines" in Austin. Existing public transit line, singular, perhaps, and in a decade or so we'll get some more. In the meantime it just means traffic gets much shittier with no real alternatives. "Let's keep doing the same thing that doesn't work and complain when anyone decides to try something else".
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoExcept there is no real sane plan to actually do something else. If they were, say, replacing street parking with light rail lines, I'd be onboard. This is basically just ignoring the problem and pretending like "alternative transportation methods" will magically spring up.
- Eisenstein 3y ago
- jmyeet 3y agoThe amount of money we collectively spend subsidizing driving is utterly insane. Yet every public transit measure is jet with the same tired dogma of “it’ll raise our taxes” or “it will run at a loss”. Street parking tons at a loss. Why is this never brought up? Significant money is spent by the likes of the remaining Koch brothers to fight public transit infrastructure in every city. Yet taking drivers off the road will make driving better and faster. The shortsightedness of this is bewildering. Parking minimums are a start, particularly for building more affordable housing but it’s barely scratching the surface and even this small gesture will often be met with fierce opposition.
- swozey 3y agoThe middled/old-aged NIMBYs in the suburbs don't use Uber/Pub-trans so they don't care and don't want to ever vote for it being improved or "taking my tax dollars." They still equate public transportation with being poor and not how millions of people who live IN the city get around, nor how THEY can benefit from being able to come downtown or go to the mountains skiing more frequently. You know who wants tons of parking spots? Those people with their Suburbans and 6 kids who only come downtown for a sports game once every 3 months but complain about how scary and stressful being downtown is. If you want a concrete example of this- when Austin caused Uber/Lyft to exit the market in 2016 (iirc) based on them "not fingerprinting drivers" one of the big arguments for letting them leave from one of (or the most) important council members was some comment along the lines of, "Well I've never needed an Uber/Lyft before in my life. Why can't you use cabs?" Ironically this person lives in Clarksville (or Tarrytown) which is one of the most expensive suburbs right outside of downtown and they probably never NEED an Uber. I bartended back in 2016 when this was going on and it SUCKED when they left. We had already gotten them into Austin WAY later than most other cities and it finally felt like I could travel around without a headache and the bullshit that yellow cabs bring with it ("Sorry sir, my credit card is not working tonight! Cash only but we're here already, so you must find ATM!") People who actually go out and do things and didn't want to have to go back to cabs not showing up, potentially getting a dwi/dui, etc were angry beyond belief at the council. https://www.austinchronicle.com/daily/news/2016-05-14/dear-mayor-adler/ https://www.austinchronicle.com/daily/news/2016-05-14/dear-m...
- TexanFeller 3y agoA big problem with this is the incredibly long payoff time. You make parking go from miserable to insufferable, but it will take a decade minimum for good public transit and making popular areas bikeable/walkable. Sad experience with government projects tells I’m being generous on the timescale. If you make the infrastructure problems in Austin more painful for a decade there will be a migration away and we might have a death spiral from losing the tax base to pay for all that shiny public transit. Car free areas also raise objections about accessibility for the disabled. How do you get your wheelchair to the middle of that car free area half a mile from the public transit stop closes to where you want to go.
- _dain_ 3y agoSounds like a skill issue. Paris made itself bikeable pretty quickly. As for disabled: improvements to walkability and bikeability are also improvements to disabled accessibility in almost all cases. Not all disabilities are visible, and some even preclude driving at all. And when car parking is a hard requirement, there are dedicated disabled-parking zones. EDIT: "X was built for walkability but Y was built for the car" you always hear this but it's just a lazy BS excuse not to do anything or think critically about the built environment. many of the cities people tout as "obviously this was built to be walkable" used to be clogged with cars (including Paris). it has wide boulevards! and many cities people think "oh this is obviously built for cars so we shouldn't bother" used to be totally walkable and had world-beating public transport (Los Angeles). it's ahistorical, learned helplessness, never backed by any rigorous comparisons, just vibes.
- TexanFeller 3y agoParis was originally built to be traversed by walking and on horseback. It was originally built for density and walkability with roads tacked on later as an afterthought. Many streets in the core of Paris, Rome, etc. are tiny and barely fit for cars. Not as easy in a city that grew up with cars and are have as much roadway as buildings.
- screye 3y agoBike infrastructure means some brick separators and painted lanes. It takes less than a month to build city-wide rudimentary protected bike lines. BRT is similarly quick to implement, if a little more expensive. Remove 1 lane of parking from major downtown roads & replace with a painted BRT lane. Order about 50 buses to run in 1 way loops around the downtown area. Have high frequency BRT between the out-of-downtown parking area <-> downtown core. Either should be doable under 1 year. The blockers are all political.
- 1-6 3y agoI thought a generation of remote work would change attitudes about cities. Why are we still trying to cram into small spaces?
- polygamous_bat 3y agoBecause some people are social and have fun with other people.
- codybontecou 3y agoWe've never had social interaction before the modern city /s
- avianlyric 3y agoErm, you realise that before the “modern city”, every urban area was small and walkable, on account of the car not being invented. The “modern city” or at least the US’s version of a “modern city” is the first time humans have ever lived so far apart at such scale. Enabled only because the car has conditioned so many people to think that driving 30mins to get anywhere interesting is “normal” or “natural”.
- bluGill 3y ago200 years ago 98% of humans were farmers and lived either on the farm or in a small village in walking distance of the farm. Todays cities are nothing like how people lived before modern days. If you were a substance farmer (as was your best case) you had about 5 acres of land - about what you get in the exurbs (though a modern exurb house is a lot bigger/nicer). If you were a slave (not unlikely) you lived in a very crowed boarding house with the other slaves on more land. Sure ancient Rome had 1 million people, but that was not the norm and even then most people were farmers in little villages not living in the city.
- bombcar 3y ago
- oceanplexian 3y ago> "I think our country has used its land wastefully, like a drunk lottery winner that's squandered their newfound wealth," said resident Tai Hovanky. This sounds like a comment from someone who lives in a city and doesn’t get out. There is an incredible, vast, mind-boggling amount of empty space in the US. I have flown and driven across the country many times. City dwellers are occupying a fraction of 1% of the space available. The idea that we must live in hyper-dense cities is utter nonsense. If you like that lifestyle, great, but it’s not reasonable to force it on everyone else.
- brigade 3y agoCities should be dense so rural lots don’t get subdivided into 7000 sqft suburban lots. As you say, literally no one is forcing you to live in cities. But preventing dense cities will force you to live in the suburbs.
- thinkingtoilet 3y agoHow is parking legislation like this forcing 'that lifestyle' on everyone else?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Eisenstein 3y agoWhat would you consider Austin or the suburbs of Austin? If you live in a city or close enough to one, sprawl is terrible as it gives you all the cons of car dependence with fewer benefits of a concentrated population center. The rest of the country can decide they want to live 45 mins drive from a grocery store, but fixing car dependency in cities should be a priority, and I think you'd agree with that.
- jen20 3y agoThe density of downtown Austin has increased _substantially_ since 2015, but it's still not straightforward to live there without a car. Most of the shops downtown sell tourist tat, not useful items, and most of the everyday commercial districts are inaccessible by public transit. Almost all new high rise construction just has a couple of floors of parking garage, and handles it well. I can't see buildings without that being commercially successful, especially since much of the work that attracts people who like downtown is out in the burbs (sometimes not even in the same county).
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y ago> "Austin has developed as a low density city without adequate mass transportation system," said resident Malcolm Yeatts. "Austin citizens cannot give up their cars. Eliminating adequate parking for residents will only increase the flight of the middle class and businesses to the suburbs." I think this is likely to happen. Also, as a potential customer, when I look at a business, if I see that the parking is going to be a hassle, I will pick another location even if it means it is further away. So this has potential to make the business situation worse as well.
- megaman821 3y agoThey could make things better rapidly by have a downtown bus loop with dedicated lanes and a park-and-ride to the north and south of downtown. They don't have to solve the whole city at once just incremental improvements every year.
- siliconc0w 3y agoI should be for every n sq ft contribute a parking space or $$$ to mass transit. Otherwise people still need a car and live a miserable life of shuffling their cars around, taking public spots that should be reserved for commerce or occasional use, like guests, not permanent parking.
- georgeecollins 3y agoIn Los Angeles there are ~ 3 parking spaces per car, and < 1 housing unit per person. We mandate a bunch of parking for every new building, but no housing. Its no wonder that people live in cars.
- smt88 3y agoLA is a disaster for transit and housing, but your numbers aren't a problem on their face. Any car being used will need >1 space at all times: one at home and one wherever it's being parked when its driver has gone somewhere. If you have <=1 space per car, the car is either being unused or it's parking illegally sometimes. We need far more parking spaces per car in LA once we consider the millions of people who are driving in the city and live outside of it. As far as housing, we'd have a 100% fully housed population with <1 house per person because a large percentage of people live with one or more people.
- chimeracoder 3y ago> LA is a disaster for transit and housing, but your numbers aren't a problem on their face. Any car being used will need >1 space at all times: one at home and one wherever it's being parked when its driver has gone somewhere. Actually, those numbers are a problem on their face. They're an illustration of why cars, and societies that are structured around enabling automobile transit as the primary (or even sole) means of transit, are inherently unsustainable and inefficient.
- up2isomorphism 3y agoBefore you abolish an old infra you need to build new ones, however, since US politicians can get away with not building anything, so they opt for abolishing old infra as their credit for the next move, and as a consequence people suffer with lower and lower quality of life. BTW, I lived in China and Europe for many years and exclusively ride bicycles for a long time, it was not the same experience. If you believe what current US politician is getting you one step closer to that, you are just deluding yourself.
- tmaly 3y agoCities obviously cannot or do not build housing. Given that, beyond say SimCity, has anyone developed simulations of how these new regulations / incentives would actually affect housing?
- everforward 3y agoThis seems like something where the outcome of the simulation is dramatically influenced by the starting assumptions to the degree that the results are useless. It allows plots of land to be smaller, but is the extra space taken up by housing or businesses? Is the housing single family or high density? How do wider economic trends interact with developers' interest in building/not building? I would think interest rates interact with developers' willingness to build and what they want to build. Those factors feel very subjective to me. Not to mention that if a model existed that could accurately predict this, I would eat my hat if the model wasn't immediately bought out by a fintech firm for some absurdly large sum. Being able to accurately predict the housing market is a blank check for printing money.
- c0nfused 3y agoThe city I live in added "transit oriented development" a few years back along with a bus rapid transit along the same area. The results appear to be a full bus, the whole sale replacement of one and 2 story buildings along the bus line and a general consensus in the city that it worked pretty well. We just approved ending parking minimums and by right auxiliary housing units, read anyone can put in an apartment over their garage, this summer so the jury is out on it as yet city wide.
- unethical_ban 3y agoCome visit San Antonio or Denver and see the apartments built in the past 10 years.
- kleiba 3y agoWhere I live, politicians are also all for reducing the availability (amount + affordability) of city parking. At the same time, they cry about city centers (with their traditional shopping miles) dying out. Go figure.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- floatrock 3y agoA traditional shopping mall won't die out. A post-1950s suburban-experiment strip mall might be affected. You can't get rid of parking on its own. If there's plenty of mixed-use development around so people can walk/bike/transit to their destination, then things will be fine. If you're getting rid of parking AND the nearest residence is a mile away AND the only way to get around is by car AND you're not building anything new, then yes, it's silly.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoMostly because good transit implementation is so expensive only like a half dozen cities in the US are financially capable of building new rail transit or hiring a lot more bus operators. Also the fact bike lane projects in this country are seemingly done like a half mile at a time to the lowest standards, rather than a one shot whole network wide rollout of lanes that would make suburbanites feel safe to bike to errands. A robust bike network seems difficult only if you forget its just a matter of how you put paint on a road thats probably already regularly budgeted in routine road surfacing work, over having to spend real money and actually expand budgets. This all goes to show how timid politicians have become in recent years towards stepping off into the unknown and actually diverging from the status quo.
- QuercusMax 3y agoCompared to adding more lanes for cars, buying/leasing buses and hiring drivers has gotta be way cheaper. Road construction is expensive, especially if you have to get additional space in the right-of-way.
- thelastgallon 3y agoLot of comments on building public transit first, before removing parking minimums. Public transit takes forever to build and its impossible to build usable transit with suburban sprawl. Usable transit --> reach destination in a reasonable time. Instead of public transit, cities should encourage Uber/Lyft. Car payments + insurance + gas + repairs/maintenance + parking might be close to $800 - $1000/month for most people. Thats probably just the amount that works for ditching car and just use Uber.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Moldoteck 3y agoPublic transit can be built fast. Replacing ppls cars with uber is nonsense: most trips are when ppl go to work and to home, so at peak hours all ppl need cars, so you need abt the same nr of cars with uber just like with personal cars, you don't solve congestion. That's why public transport wins, you get one unit to transport a lot of ppl, that's why uber/lyft are total bs for replacing good transit. There's no way you'll get faster to the destination if all ppl used uber vs a good built tram system, each tram with 7 wagons, 5 mins max between stops, priority at semaphores+dedicated lanes, the capacity is basically unbeatable by cars, it's just math and physics
- bombcar 3y agoThe average passengers per bus-mile in the USA is incredibly depressing. (It is very hard to have a transit system that handles capacity at load and still provides short enough head times as to not be annoying off-peak.)
- Moldoteck 3y agoThat's bc it's poorly designed and low density. A transit with own lane+priority on intersection will mean you get reliably to the destination every single time and fast. Ditching park mins will allow building more housing and as result will increase the density too. That's chicken and egg problem and cities must start tackling it by having some budget loss at the beginning by building better transit
- shadowgovt 3y agoI yearn for American cities to discover what London has. The city's mass-transit is intensely effective, and if you have to grab a car from point A to point B, there's never a taxi far away. It turns out if you don't have parking, a professional driver class can afford to make a living on being ever-moving luxury transit for people (and I bet most cities can rought-out a mass transit solution with a clever combination of buses and closing roads to cars / replacing them with delivery-only vehicle access, otherwise open-walkable).
- swalling 3y agoThis isn't really a new trend, Texas is just a laggard because it is an unusually car-dependent state. Most major cities have been trending toward eliminating parking minimums, at least in downtown cores. Here's a map from 2015: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2015/11/18/a-map-of-cities-that-got-rid-of-parking-minimums https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2015/11/18/a-map-of-citi... And one updated as of 2021: https://parkingreform.org/resources/mandates-map/ https://parkingreform.org/resources/mandates-map/
- aegypti 3y ago> Austin is the biggest city in the country to eliminate its parking mandates citywide > Austin removed parking requirements for its downtown area a decade ago Here’s an article from 2024 :) https://www.npr.org/2024/01/02/1221366173/u-s-cities-drop-parking-space-minimums-development https://www.npr.org/2024/01/02/1221366173/u-s-cities-drop-pa...
- swalling 3y agoThat article is technically true but misleading. Most of Manhattan eliminated parking minimums back in 1982. Seattle eliminated or reduced minimums anywhere close to transit (which is a huge part of the city obviously) back in 2012. The entire state of Oregon eliminated parking minimums and single family zoning last year. Austin isn't setting a trend here, they're just catching up because the city has grown so quickly recently.
- aegypti 3y agoMost of Manhattan’s unilateral action 42 years ago probably doesn’t relate to a modern day trend. Oregon sounds like it is setting a pace, I’m glad Austin managed to end single family zoning last year alongside it. I hope Seattle, and every single other major city government in the US will manage to one day remove citywide parking mandates alongside the unusually car dependent laggards in Austin.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoParking minimums are a nanny-state interference in free markets. It's no wonder Republicans hate them so much /s
- electrodeyt 3y agoTook them long enough
- lukas099 3y agoI vote we ban all free public parking and let the free market determine how much parking there is and where.
- rcpt 3y agoBest and least popular thing we could do for our cities.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 3y agoIf you let the free market decide the answer will be "a lot" and "everywhere there's business that want customers from outside walking distance" and "everywhere there's apartments and houses that don't have garages." Parking minimums are one of those things that are a huge PITA when you hit edge cases but when you go to city council meetings residents and business owners ask for more and cheaper parking because it draws in business and keeps street parking available for residents. You can't remove parking in isolation, I genuinely wish you could. You have to fix the reason people want it in the first place. And high density public transportation is unfortunately a double-edged sword because it means you need a government blessing to make an area a new hot spot and drives business and residential rents way up in the spots people can get to easily.
- sokoloff 3y ago> You can't remove parking in isolation, I genuinely wish you could. You have to fix the reason people want it in the first place. This is both blindingly obvious and incredibly frequently overlooked. Here's the 5-step plan for improving our city: 1. Remove parking spots. 2-5. We'll figure it out later; I promise.
- lukas099 3y agoYou see it that way; I see it as we are taking one major step toward the goal.
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoI'm surprised no one has mentioned the most important improvement from eliminating parking minimums: https://www.planetizen.com/news/2023/11/126192-parking-reform-pays-lower-rent-costs https://www.planetizen.com/news/2023/11/126192-parking-refor... Parking spaces are outrageously expensive. By allowing housing to be built without far more parking than is needed, the cost of rent is lower by several hundred dollars (read: $200-$1000) a month because of how expensive land is, and how much land/space is required for cars.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI'm ok with this, but I wish they would do something about on street parking as well. People are still renting apartments and buying homes without parking, and they just use on street parking. Which is fine and all, but try being a pedestrian crossing the street when a car is parked way too close to the intersection (or be a driver where pedestrians seemingly pop into view from behind cars quickly). You really can't have your cake and eat it to, streets are not the solutions to our parking problems.
- graymatters 3y ago[flagged]
- FarMcKon 3y agoYou can just say 'I don't like this' instead of making up a bunch of 'just so stories' about why. Fine if you don't like density, but the whole pseudo-science `Dense urbanization is detrimental to health, physical and mental` is just mental.
- azemetre 3y agoVery weird. My life has greatly improved since moving to a walkable city. It’s very nice to walk and get groceries for a meal that day or walk to a bakery or walk to a bar or walk to a store or walk to my doctors or walk to my friends. When I lived in FL you had to drive everywhere. I’d rather be walking. We literally evolved to walk long distances, and cars don’t seem to be making our lives better with all the externalities getting ignored (air pollution, microplastics, and noise pollution). I don’t mind if people want to drive, but they should be paying the true cost and not keep a massively subsidized lifestyle that can’t exist without massive federal funds.
- colechristensen 3y agoI live in a downtown high rise. It’s 25 degrees outside, I have a lady friend who lives a mile away. I feel unsafe riding public transit at night here, much less her. She experiences extreme harassment walking here during the day (did it once, never again, I was on the phone with her, it was horrifying). How do you propose she visit me without a car and available parking? Uber would cost her more than an hour of her workday. GP is damn right the opposition to parking is detrimental to health physical and mental as well as wealth.
- Moldoteck 3y agoYou gave an anecdotal example. I can give one too: generally medium density, mixed use, bikeble areas are much safer compared to other options, bc there are always people around, some go to work, some go to shopping, some go to drink a coffee, etc, adn ppl usually feel safer in this areas. On the other hand, low density areas are less safe bc there's no one around to call police if something happens. It's also a health problem both phisical and mental: ppl are more isolated from other ppl, it's harder to meet other ppl, it's much harder when you are old and ppl generally move less bc they must use a car for everything instead of walking/biking to the destination. In low density areas there's also a deficit of 3'rd places to meet ppl
- botanical 3y agoClimate Town has a relevant video discussing this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OUNXFHpUhu8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OUNXFHpUhu8
- jeegsy 3y agoTIL...NYC currently HAS parking minimums!
- pauldelany 3y agoTopic-related yt channel, cannot recommend this enough: https://www.youtube.com/@NotJustBikes https://www.youtube.com/@NotJustBikes