16 ms·
EU opens proceedings against X over efforts to combat information manipulation
- stephen_g 3y agoMore discussion of this topic here - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38681312 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38681312
- impossiblefork 3y ago[flagged]
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoYep... or the ukraine war, so many misinformation from the western media, but since it's "our propaganda", it's "all good"... be it a ghost from kiyev to putin being out of missles since spring last year.
- viraptor 3y agoDoes the Digital Services Act apply to the television? Is SVT a very large social media platform? If not, why compare them here?
- impossiblefork 3y agoIt's funny because there's rules for dealing with alleged disinformation on social media platforms, but SVT, which is literally Sweden's official state television, get to distribute this actual disinformation which directly provides rhetorical cover for ethnic cleansing. That is, the situation represents a kind of hypocrisy-- a small thing is attacked vigorously, by an entity which does something much, much worse.
- rsynnott 3y agoSwedish TV is largely outside the purview of the EC; it’s Sweden’s problem to regulate. As a general rule, most EU states are broadly okay with media, including state media, lying. (I’ve no idea of the context of the incident you mention.)
- impossiblefork 3y agoIt was in September, after the Karabach-Armenians agreed to the opening of Agdam road into Nagorno-Karabach, which was to be opened along with the Lachin corridor. After letting through some small amount of supplies Azerbaijan then invaded along the Agdam road instead, putting them in a position to bombard Stepanakert with artillery, which of course, they did. When the Karabach-Armenians then fled, SVT said that 'Armenian separatists have agreed to leave Azerbaijan', which is of course incredibly misleading.
- zazazache 3y agoThere are institutions like Medieombudsmannen and pressens etiksråd that work with enforcing the rules of press ethics in Sweden. Your allegations against SVT is them spreading misinformation directly, the EU is investigation how Twitter as a platform handles misinformation being spread. It’s a different thing Please show me where on the doll Jane Josefssons questions made you uncomfortable, lol
- impossiblefork 3y agoI've shown it to you on the 'doll', haven't I? I provided an English translation of the quote from Aktuellt, where they claimed that what was in fact an ethnic cleansing that was achieved through starvation and then artillery bombardment, that was left unmentioned over the many months over which it went on, was that 'Armenian separatists have agreed to leave Azerbaijan'. I might well report it. I have in fact considered doing so, but it remains hypocrisy to spread disinformation while accusing others of doing so. This is also quite special, since it is in fact support for ethnic cleansing. There is nothing more heinous, when it comes to pressetik, than what SVT have done.
- hiatus 3y agoWhy is social media held to a higher standard than journalism?
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoHe was probably speaking about the concept of disinformation, especially when it suits the current political climate, and not the law itself. If we're talking about disinformation, pointing it out in other places is important too, doubly so if the media is owned by the same government who points fingers at others.
- impossiblefork 3y agoI am indeed.
- robin_reala 3y agoFor those following along, a “very large provider” is a provider with more than 45 million monthly users. The population of Sweden is around 10.5 million, so the answer is a definitive no.
- retSava 3y agoWell SVT is a joke. Examples too many to count, but my two favorites are probably first, when they reported on a police notice on a rape, and republished the description of the perp, with all from the police notice (height, hair, eyes, clothes, etc) but not the skin color. No explanation given on why they felt it necessary to leave that out, and actually harmful since valuable witness reports may not surface. The second favorite is a "boo-hoo"-interview with a person that risked deportation, hence why he lived in a shed in a forest since two year back to avoid being arrested. He was given ample opportunity to solicit empathy for how hard it was and how insecure he felt. He also said that he was running from a prison sentence in Syria for smuggling guns and had been declined asylum on several applications and hence was living illegally in Sweden. No questions from the reporter on that. They're a joke, simple as that.
- impossiblefork 3y agoYes, but it takes something special to cross the line into supporting ethnic cleansing through starvation and artillery bombardment. SVT went from having problems to something at the edge of a folkrättsbrott.
- hulitu 3y agoThis is satirical. If they really want to do this they shall start with state media and with the EU institutions.
- mightyham 3y agoDoes anyone have more information about what the infringements are? It would be very obviously hypocritical for the EU to be publicly alleging "breach of transparency obligations", if they arn't willing to be transparent about the allegations.
- stainablesteel 3y ago[flagged]
- sanp 3y agoSo do Facebook, Faux News, Sky (and anffiliates in the continent) and any number of other right-wing media sources. Do we see federal or EU regulators going after them?
- stainablesteel 3y agonope just elon, which is exactly my point
- layer8 3y agoMore details here: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_23_6709 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_23_... Note that they are now starting a formal investigation, whose purpose is to determine whether there are indeed infringements or not.
- mightyham 3y agoI'm still not seeing any reference to specific violations by X, just some surrounding context and listing of allegations. The EU has broad discretion to start formal inventigations, but specifically CHOSE to begin litigation against X for specific reasons. I would expect a transparent governing body to provide a litany of information to the public about why they are choosing to take that action. If there is a lack of said information, that would lead one to suspect that information is being purposely concealed and/or that it is a targeted partisan political action.
- greentext 3y agoI totally get the mars thing now.
- mustafa_pasi 3y ago10€ says, it's not "the EU" but some (probably not European) lobbyists using the EU as an attack dog, because they are so conveniently corruptible. We are going to be seeing more of this in the future. American/Foreign elites using EU apparatus to attack other American/Foreign elites.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y agoIf anyone wants to have a closer look at the mindset of the EU bureaucrats driving this, take a look at Thierry Breton's Twitter account and despair: https://twitter.com/ThierryBreton https://twitter.com/ThierryBreton Whatever good the EU does, if free speech is the price, I'm not willing to pay it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dmos62 3y agoThere's something called information warfare, which basically means manipulating public discourse to further one's political goals. Russia is notoriously good at it, for example. West sucks at it (it has Hollywood at least). These regulations aim to help. It's the same type of regulation that attempts to prevent a teacher telling kids that the earth is 6 thousand years old. I think stellar education together with good journalism is the wholesome way to address this, but obviously we don't have that. So we're playing catch up: ban the Nazi symbols, hand-slap liars, etc. If you don't have an educated and informed populace, how to even reach a practical consensus on what's acceptable? You can argue for absolutely zero regulation, but demonstrate that you understand the thousand ways that would be abused.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>West sucks at it (it has Hollywood at least) Except Hollywood doesn't represent "the west" or even western values, the same way how McDonald's doesn't represent the cuisine of most western nations. I don't think it even fully represents much western values at all since it started self-censoring it's own content that wasn't woke enough, and especially since they started pandering to China by removing POC and LGBT content. It's just another soulless cash-grabbing enterprise from the US that bends over to wherever there's money to be made regardless of any values.
- bluecalm 3y agoI think it's a problem with democracy: there is zero incentive to pursue the truth or get things right. As the decisions of governments rarely have direct immediate consequences for your life there also isn't a fast enough feedback loop to correct your mistakes. By mistakes I mean supporting politicians who don't have your interest in mind not even some higher good or whatever. In other words there is no reward for seeking the truth or trying to understand various issues and there is no penalty for being a moron. As long as it's the case it's just a war over who gets to have access to the most efficient propaganda machine to get the gullible masses on their side. I agree it makes sense for the legislators to ensure that's someone local instead of foreign power though. At least they are close enough to the pitchforks if it comes to that.
- DarkmSparks 3y ago"and to protect their services against manipulative techniques." Oh the irony.
- DaiPlusPlus 3y ago[flagged]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoI wonder with the EU the way it is if the social media space is ripe for a USA only company. The EU has a lot more regulation than the US and a lot less free speech protections. A company that caters only to the US market might be worthwhile.
- pavlov 3y agoThere are several social media companies that are in practice US-only: Parler, Truth Social for starters. But if you wanted to make them places that regular people would want to frequent, then it would be pretty much the same product process as complying with EU rules.
- baz00 3y agoWell clearly this thread demonstrates the HN bias towards deregulated capitalism and spewing any garbage at any cost however much damage it does to society. Our technology industry has a bright future. Shame about everyone else… Edit: this should be read in context to the initial replies all of which have been flagged and deleted.
- vitiral 3y agoFirst, know your audience. Second, this thread has like 10 replies and is 6 minutes old. The only people who have time to post are those offering their "first reaction" take. Note: my response is a "first reaction" to your post and probably missed some elements of nuance and depth that were just below the surface.
- baz00 3y agoThe nuance is wiped clean by the rampant flagging of loons that the start of any regulatory thread brings. The end game is it’s difficult to make a point about dead bodies when someone has taken all the corpses away. The point is those people still own businesses and write code and contribute to society and we take little to no responsibility as an industry of the bad actors, referring them to heroes and role models. I might write something to track this.
- refurb 3y ago”spewing any garbage at any cost however much damage it does to society.” Indeed all this support of free speech is horrible to see. /s
- tstrimple 3y agoExcept for TikTok. Something must be done about TikTok. It's Very Dangerous!
- lakomen 3y agoDang is a piece of shit dictator wannabe
- perihelions 3y agoHow's the EU's investigation into the EU's illegal manipulation on X going? https://noyb.eu/en/noyb-files-complaint-against-eu-commission-over-targeted-chat-control-ads https://noyb.eu/en/noyb-files-complaint-against-eu-commissio... ("noyb files complaint against EU Commission over targeted chat control ad campaign")
- baz00 3y agoEU is a big org. There are good and bad players. Twitter is a cesspool of bad players. The whole point of this investigation is to flush out bad players from many places. Propagandists, partisans and manipulators.
- mustafa_pasi 3y agoThe "propagandists, partisans and manipulators" that label themselves "journalists" and "media companies" want to dictate what posts should be allowed on Twitter. They are no better than the Russian and Chinese counterparts after all. You cannot deviate from the agenda without getting censored.
- qsdf38100 3y agoYou can criticize the eu, but pretending everything is at the same level is either ignorance or bad faith.
- ethanbond 3y agoI see extremely intense critiques of western political leaders 24/7. What planet do you live on?
- coldtea 3y agoThe planet were "critiques of western political leaders" are increasingly stiffled, and governments and "independent" third parties and "fact checkers" (funded and working with said governments) dictate what's allowed to say and what's "disinformation".
- lettergram 3y agoIt’s hard for me not to see this as power play by the unelected bureaucrats in Brussels. Their “misinformation” is probably opposition parties commenting about Ukraine, internal politics, etc.
- ExoticPearTree 3y agoIt is exactly that, misinformation is anything that goes against the party line.
- thsksbd 3y agoSure, but it was also very predictable. Even 20 years ago individual European states started wielding the censorship bludgeon to keep their societies from exploding. Heck, has there ever been freedom of speech in Europe? Just consider the classic films France has censored (paths of glory, Battle for Algiers) over the last 70 years while allowing the most deprived smut unchallenged. The UK's censorship has a wiki entry (including reservoir dogs and Battleship Potemkin!!). And those are the most liberal speech countries in Europe.
- duringmath 3y agoAbsolutely disgusting. These people are trying to pass off censorship and government overreach as though it's some benevolent thing. The epitome of a nanny state right there.
- seydor 3y agoReally not a fan of the EU as a speech arbiter, especially considering that they are one of the biggest spenders of political ads on facebook in most european countries: https://www.facebook.com/ads/library/report/ https://www.facebook.com/ads/library/report/ unchecked power is dangerous
- lm28469 3y ago"You criticise society yet you live in it" type of vibe from this comment
- vetinari 3y agoThat's kind of a point, no? I want the society where I live to get better. Other societies have their own citizens, it's their job to improve theirs.
- lm28469 3y agoI fail to see how the EU advertising on Facebook demonstrates why the EU should not be allowed to enforce laws in its border. They can both use the system and be critical of it
- pydry 3y agoAre you more or less of fan of Elon Musk/[ insert billionaire here] taking that job instead?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- layer8 3y agoThe EU has separation of powers. I don’t see the European Commission (who opened the present proceedings) listed as an advertiser under your link. And ultimately it is the judicial branch who will decide.
- sagman 3y agoEU is really the innovator at investigations and regulations. With the number of laws they have to protect their customers and prevent monopolies, I am surprised how they only have one big software company and four major car companies. Or maybe those rules are only aimed to help their monopolies.
- pydry 3y agoThe Chinese have done stuff like this for years. If your immediate reaction to that is "no but actually they just want to substitute American propaganda for their own" then youre closer to understanding the EU motives than you realize.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sagman 3y agoAgreed. But in the western media they are not depicted as similar to the CCP. Maybe because compared to CCP they are terrible at it. At least the Chinese policies gave rise to homegrown giants like Baidu, Alibaba and more recently Bytedance.
- lm28469 3y agoOr maybe there is more to life than tech and car companies, who knows ??
- paganel 3y agoThe EU senses competition when it comes to propaganda, hence the backlash. They (meaning the EU) have started putting advertorials about their benefits even on the bus stations here in Bucharest, I guess they're sensing that they're losing their hold over the hegemonic discourse. Good riddance.
- qsdf38100 3y agoWhy are you so happy with eu downfall? Are they too woke? Too weak? Who are you cheering for instead?
- 4RealFreedom 3y agoNot the OP but how about cheering for no one? Centralization of power leads to oppression - covid, hate crimes, centralized banking. Maybe you think these are worthwhile pursuits but they are designed to control.
- ajvs 3y agoWhy get rid of one propaganda overlord just to replace it with another?
- 4RealFreedom 3y agoWhy take a shower everyday when you're just going to be dirty again tomorrow? It takes time for power to solidify.
- paganel 3y ago> Are they too woke? Too weak? Because as a citizen I have no control over them, while they do have lots and lots of control over my life and the lives of my fellow citizens around this part of the continent. For comparison, I couldn't care less about Musk or X or any other private company involved in what some State-like power labels as "propaganda".
- crote 3y agoOr perhaps they're trying to avoid a repeat of Brexit, which primarily happened because UK media and politicians blamed the EU for literally anything going wrong for several decades, while claiming all the benefits as their own. If you want a well-informed population who can meaningfully vote in EU elections, it's pretty much a requirement to make sure the population actually knows what the EU is doing.
- qsdf38100 3y agoCrazy how this site becomes anti-anything any time Elon or any of his business gets criticized. Thanks to Elon, Twitter has turned into a disinformation-as-a-service platform for maga and foreign actors. But the eu should just watch its population be turned into conspiracy following zombies, and do nothing? Hmmm, I wonder who benefits from this.
- jorge-d 3y agoIt's also funny how every thread related to UE regulation turns into the UE being depicted a "no-free speech" / "corrupt" / "undemocratic" etc. Yeah we're living in an absolute hellhole here in the UE, damn those institutions for trying to protect the general population against megacorps / missinformation. (/s) It honestly feel more like the comment section on Youtube or Facebook sometimes around here.
- thsksbd 3y ago[flagged]
- ImHereToVote 3y agoThe Hunter Biden's scandal was misinformation lite. The fact that it benefits Putin, means it is misinformation enough to be silenced. The fact that you are bringing it up is essentially you being a supporter of Putin. /s
- thsksbd 3y agoThat we got downvoted about something so easily verifiable and so shockingly corrupt really says a lot about the length humans go to grip to a delusion. Back in 2020 those of us that had followed the Ukr war since 2014 knew that the material in the laptop was real. It's 2024; by now even the NYT has admitted the laptop and its contents are his.
- qsdf38100 3y agoWhy the /s ? You actually said the truth, but it seems you aren’t aware.
- TeeMassive 3y agoI've seen a lot of false posts on X. Most of them were corrected by Community Notes.
- consumer451 3y agoWas the ~"EU is heading towards civil war" post made by the owner of X, community noted? I realize that would be tough to fact check, but I've lived in the EU for the last 6 years and "civil war" is a take from another universe, and really felt like projection. Was he suggesting that Orban & Co's politics is going to invade the rest of the EU, with violence? Can someone explain to me what one of the most influential people on the planet meant by that? I respect so much of what Musk has accomplished but that left me at a loss for words.
- hcurtiss 3y agoCan you explain to me what regulatory framework you would use to address such posts? Are you willing to trust some European bureaucrat to decide how likely civil war might be? Doesn’t that strike you as profoundly dangerous?
- consumer451 3y agoI was asking about the self regulatory framework of community notes.
- TeeMassive 3y agoWhich is an opinion and thus cannot be fact checked nor be determined to be false or true by nature because it is ultimately a prediction in nature.
- Darmody 3y agoI don't think he's wrong, to be honest. And, sadly, I know many people that think the same. Maybe not a civil war per se but we're heading towards many internal conflicts. And the more we wait to solve things, the worse it'll be.
- alkonaut 3y agoCan't really see what the harm is if we believe DSA is a good thing and there is real reason to believe they aren't fulfilling the requirements then go ahead and investigate. Interestingly, yesterday a Swedish newspaper published a story about conditions for child workers in africa mining minerals that go into the batteries of many car manufacturers. Many manufacturers were called out in the article, but Tesla were singled out in the headline (By far the biggest customer of these minerals so nothing strange in that). Twitter/X instantly placed a warning that the article link could be harmful. My trust in EU as a steward of free speech isn't unlimited, but it's massively higher in my trust that Elon Musk being the same.
- andsoitis 3y ago> Interestingly, yesterday a Swedish newspaper published a story about conditions for child workers in africa mining minerals that go into the batteries of many car manufacturers. Many manufacturers were called out in the article, but Tesla were singled out in the headline (By far the biggest customer of these minerals so nothing strange in that). Singling out Tesla is not surprising to me, given the recent labor action. But this headline just blinds us to the wider issue, as reported by Amnesty International already in 2016 about companies using child labor for battery minerals, including Apple, Samsung, Mercedes, Dell, HP, Microsoft, Vodafone, LG, etc. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2016/01/child-labour-behind-smart-phone-and-electric-car-batteries/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2016/01/child-labour-... > Twitter/X instantly placed a warning that the article link could be harmful Do you have a link to this? I’d love to see
- alkonaut 3y ago> Do you have a link to this? I’d love to see This is the article https://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/a/jlWAOA/sa-kopplas-tesla-till-barngruvorna-vi-foljer-sparet https://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/a/jlWAOA/sa-kopplas-tesla... Here is the X post where the journalist posted the link to the newspaper https://twitter.com/staffanlindberg/status/1736311263968326046 https://twitter.com/staffanlindberg/status/17363112639683260... If you follow the twitter link and click the newspaper link (image), you'll be shown the warning, and have been since the post was made yesterday. For posterity: this is the warning redirect in case it's removed from the link: https://twitter.com/safety/unsafe_link_warning?unsafe_link=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.aftonbladet.se%2Fnyheter%2Fa%2FjlWAOA%2Fsa-kopplas-tesla-till-barngruvorna-vi-foljer-sparet https://twitter.com/safety/unsafe_link_warning?unsafe_link=h...
- lhnz 3y agoApparently the dissemination of illegal content refers to the October 7th videos of the Hamas terrorist attack against Israel that galvanized American support for Israel [0]. I personally don't think it's in people's interest to have this kind of thing hidden from them and I really dislike the EU for attempting to censor this. Musk is really under a lot of financial pressure and it might be a losing battle to try to fight the EU over this in court. To be honest, I hope he is able to pull out from the EU without cratering the company, but he is now being pulled into lawfare with multiple actors across the globe so Twitter might have no choice but to accept is role as a conduit of censorship for state-level actors. [0] https://twitter.com/prestonjbyrne/status/1736707341070860689
- alkonaut 3y agoOne can think anything about the particular line-drawing about what is and what isn't something X should moderate. By operating in the EU they do agree to the DSA though. And no one is saying that the content in question is or isn't something that twitter has handled incorrectly. All that's happening is that there is an investigation into it. There really isn't much to talk about (yet).
- lhnz 3y agoEven though we don't know everything about what is happening in this particular instance, I do think there should be a global conversation on the ability for state-level actors to directly or indirectly pull strings in order to coerce Twitter into censoring information on their behalf. I think this should be of particular importance to the US which has fudamental rights protecting freedom of expression. I'm very worried about co-ordinated lawfare against Musk-operated companies being used as a tool to force his compliance with systems that exist to get around laws against the US government's direct involvement in censorship. I'm also worried about the EU's lurch towards Chinese-style censorship of social media. And, I think we should be able to talk about it now while we still can.
- alkonaut 3y ago> I think we should be able to talk about it now while we still can. What does that even mean? Are you saying the debate about free speech itself is somehow silenced?
- Daneel_ 3y agoThe number of anti-EU comments here surprises me, frankly. My understanding, as an Australian, is the EU is just enforcing rules regarding transparency and moderation reporting - they’re not setting some speech-controlling agenda. Seems reasonable to me?
- Nathanba 3y agoOf course they control speech, that's absolutely on the EU agenda. Hate speech is not legal in the EU
- alkonaut 3y agoAs far as I know there are no common laws surrounding that. There is a legal framework/agreement requiring states to have some kind of hate speech laws though, but they'll vary wildly. E.g. in Germany you can't be openly Nazi. In Denmark you can't burn a Quran etc. So there is no agreement of WHAT constitutes hate speech across the EU. The framework: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=LEGISSUM:l33178 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=LEGISSUM... It's extremely vague. It's more an understanding that "hate speech is bad so bad you should all draw a line... somewhere".
- g1a55er 3y agoThe DSA itself imposes EU-wide requirements on the “mitigation” of “illegal hate speech”, although it does not define the term. Section 35, 1(c). My amateur guess for how this would end up is that large European wide platforms will be expected to take down hate speech that is illegal anywhere in Europe, but I don’t think we have seen an example for certain. It’s possible this enforcement action will bring more certainty. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex%3A32022R2065 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex%3A... I think this is going to inevitably create more and more tension between EU and American contexts, because hate speech is affirmatively legal in the U.S., most recently ruled under Snyder v Phelps.
- wand3r 3y ago> The DSA imposes new rules on content moderation, user privacy and transparency. Any firm found in breach faces a fine worth up to 6% of its global turnover. The EU has been rent seeking on FAANG and US tech for a decade. They want control and money. Thanks for USB-C but they can keep their fucking cookie banners. This will create huge problems for the whole world when an arbitrary agency can "impose rules on content moderation" and "privacy[1]" and levy a huge fine. The US tech companies should form a bloc and force them to be reasonable [1] Which I'm sure mean anti-privacy.
- okeuro49 3y agoLike it or loath it, X is the best place for free speech. It's rather incredible that X was investigated first, given that bin Laden's "Letter to America" recently went viral on TikTok. However it's worse still that the EU thinks its role is to investigate what should and should not be considered "misinformation". It was not that long ago that saying Covid came from a lab leak was "misinformation". The whole concept of bureaucrats becoming the arbiters of truth arguably breaks the EU's subsidiarity principle, which "aims to ensure that decisions are taken at the closest possible level to the citizen and that constant checks are made to verify that action at the European Union (EU) level is justified in light of the possibilities available at the national, regional or local level." https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/glossary/principle-of-subsidiarity.html https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/glossary/principl...
- wredue 3y agoSaying Covid came from lab leak is still misinformation The virus still shows genetic markers for natural origin. The “evidence” for lab leak is “it’s happened before. China. There was duct cleaning sometime” Saying something over and over doesn’t magically make it more true. There is absolutely no good evidence what-so-ever for lab leak, while there is strong evidence (genetic markers) for natural origin.
- tjpnz 3y agoBringing a virus into a lab for study doesn't automatically alter its genetic markers.
- wredue 3y agoThe worlds leading microbiologists and virologists with billions of dollars of dedicated equipment and tests vs the massively biased opinion of @tjpnz because being wrong destroys your position You’re wrong.
- throwawa14223 3y ago
- SiempreViernes 3y agoHey, what a nice coincidence that this happens the day after links to a Swedish tabloid report noting child labour in the Tesla supply chain is marked as "potentially harmful"[0] on twitter! [0] https://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/a/76rPL3/x-varning-efter-granskning-om-glimmer https://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/a/76rPL3/x-varning-efter-...
- andsoitis 3y agoThe article links to an exchange between Musk and Thierry Breton in which the latter says that X violates EU regulations intended to combat fake content (do they really mean "fake news"?) and the glorification of violence.
- hn1986 3y agoIt's unfortunate that Musk has become anti-free speech at this point. The last few years have radicalized him to the extreme right. Excellent post here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38675539 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38675539
- akomtu 3y agoThere is, right now, a big immigration wave of Arabs into Europe. Hamas has attacked Israel, and EU has a choice: support terrorists (Hamas) or condemn them, making arabs look guilty in the eyes of laymen. The latter may spark riots.
- raxxorraxor 3y agoI am very critical of mass immigration because in large numbers people tend to not integrate and I prefer western values to Islamic fundamentalism by a large degree. Many of those western values is certainly not reflected by the EU right now and a core of western values is certainly that government has absolutely no capability to determine truth from falsehood. Not even the judiciary would pick up that mantle. So all that is left is bad policies like this. I don't think censorship would benefit anyone, neither Israel nor Hamas, that is a completely different topic, it tends to benefit particular interest that decide about truth
- snowpid 3y agoIt is very sad that it almost impossible to discuss EU regulations in HN. The noise of angry Americans is too loud ("EU dictatorship!!!!"). I like the expertise on technical topics but tech regulation (which does affect me very much) is very bad here. Also HN gave me a very negative view on Americans, if on HN ill find more educated Americans. It is not a surprise that Trump is a real possibility.
- hawski 3y agoI think to avoid ambiguity it should be always written as social media platform called "X" (formerly known as Twitter). I don't think I will ever be able to get used to the name.
- goalieca 3y agoWhy doesn’t the EU and other concerned government run a good counter-intelligence campaign going so far as to sanction especially evil governments. Instead they seem to want to control the narrative through positive censorship.
- butz 3y agoOr just open Mastodon instance for EU governments and citizens, and forget about that X thing ever existed.
- polishdude20 3y agoWhy do they go after X and not the individual account holder that posted the "misinformation"?
- mazurnification 3y agoI am true admirer of US style free speech regulations, but as EU citizen I agree with this action though. Why? Because Twitter already cave in (and rather easily I must say) to the Turkey request for pre election lets call it "special moderation". So the solution is either heavy anti-monopoly regulation requiring splitting of Twitter to several competing entities (though preferable, probably not feasible w/o US agreeing and enforcing it) or less than ideal some kind of content regulation. Otherwise we are giving away ability to speak and censor to autocrats (again Turkey) while doing nothing. Kind of stupid. If it is already censored and regulated (again Turkey) I do not see big deal if it regulated according UE rules.
- hn1986 3y agoFinally, X hasn’t allowed researchers access to the platform for auditing purposes, violating a principle of transparency which is enshrined by the Digital Services Act. Following changes to the platform, access to data for research purposes has been severely curtailed: Social media researchers have canceled, suspended or changed more than 100 studies about X, formerly Twitter, as a result of actions taken by Elon Musk that limit access to the social media platform, nearly a dozen interviews and a survey of planned projects show. […] A majority of survey respondents fear being sued by X over their findings or use of data. The worry follows X's July lawsuit against the Center for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH) after it published critical reports about the platform's content moderation. https://werd.io/2023/x-and-the-digital-services-act https://werd.io/2023/x-and-the-digital-services-act
- lakomen 3y agoIt's the EC, not the EU. They even boast about it on their Fediverse profile and how they're going to issue fines if they don't comply