22 ms·
Vertical farming company raised $500M, and then it all but disappeared
- silexia 3y agoFarmer here. Enormous US government ag regulations severely harm both farmers and innovation in farming. For example, did you know that there are only four meat processors in the United States due to USDA regulations (full regulatory capture) and they have monopolized meat processing so much that farmers get the same prices for their cattle they received twenty years ago while meat prices have gone up multiple times? Or that food handling regulations are so archaic and overdone that it is nearly impossible to bring healthier options to market? Dramatically shrink or eliminate the USDA and regulations and you will see an exponential increase in new ideas and better products at lower prices.
- mharig 3y agoThe combination with Aquaponics might perform better. E.g. a non-vertical Berlin startup: ecf-farm.de (german only) https://www.ecf-farmsystems.com/?lang=en https://www.ecf-farmsystems.com/?lang=en Edit: they work partly vertical. https://video.wixstatic.com/video/4b00a0_eae82fb329a7432396e48405c54972af/480p/mp4/file.mp4 https://video.wixstatic.com/video/4b00a0_eae82fb329a7432396e...
- azubinski 3y agoI used to call a flying taxi and fly to a vertical farm for fresh strawberries. Well, what to do now?
- mynameisnoone 3y agoThis is Webvan 3.0. 1. Vertical farming is only for where farming in greenhouses would be impossible. 2. There is nothing particularly special or defensible about farming. Anyone can get into it. And why not just use large greenhouses with open frame, endless conveyors? I think it can and will need to be done to ensure the food supply from weather and other hazards, and to increase yield and water efficiency, but it doesn't need to be anything other than any ordinary business that seeks continual process and capital optimizations. One desperately needed goal of an improved food supply approach is fully-ripened organic food, not this pretty, artificially-ripened trash offered at commercial grocery stores. "Live Lettuce" and such, but extended to tomatoes and more.
- psychlops 3y agoIsrael, Ukraine, Climate Tech, Green Tech, there's a little bit of everything for everybody in this article. There's a common theme in all these things. Ah yes, disappearing money.
- KevinMS 3y agoNo surprise, an idea this dumb could only be used to separate investors from their money.
- jairuhme 3y ago> “Some of the facilities figured out way too late, ‘oh we should probably be checking how much we’re paying for electricity per month.’ That’s pretty basic when 30-40% of the cost of the crop is electricity,” he says. > “Those things were just overlooked because investors will pay for it, it doesn’t matter,” I'm always amazed when startups operate like this. I'm equally in awe when they get capital and VC's don't notice this either. I guess the later could be naive and just assume that the tech required to make it works requires this, but it is still baffling that nobody thinks its a good idea to get one of your bigger costs down
- bsenftner 3y agoColossal due diligence failure; I'd say the investors in the VC funds that financed Infarm have a lawsuit.
- Ekaros 3y agoI always found it extremely weird that no one runs even the most basic back of envelope calculations on things like this. Like how much power and at what cost we need to input or what is the throughput of some system and then how much we need to charge just to cover the building costs... Most simple multiplication and division... Just to get some idea of unit economics. Thus do things make sense even in your own fantasy world of ultra-rich tech workers.
- brianwawok 3y agoVery simple reasons actually. VCs dont fund people based on logic, but on ability to BS. Go hang out with some bootstrapped founders. They will have great common sense. If not they are dead.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoWhat's stopping VCs or their staffs from double checking or keeping track after the money has been disbursed?
- 3y ago
- mc32 3y agoVertical farming is a nice PoC but it’s not financially viable when there is ample land for farming. Indoor Automation for leafy greens and some high value produce like edible/gastronomic mushrooms and others like controlled drug producing products does make economic sense, but it’s overkill for other things when you have proven transportation networks to bring things to market from the hinterlands. Ok it may make sense in st Helena and Tristan da Cunha islands for some things.
- bell-cot 3y ago> it’s not financially viable when there is ample land for farming. I've not heard of it being financially viable even when farmland is very constrained - say, in Holland. The numbers probably work on the ISS, Moon, or Mars...so those places will probably be "stars of the show", in the next round of hype which vertical farming companies use to bilk idiot VC's. (St. Helena has a reasonable latitude and low population density - so at most you'd need some greenhouses.)
- romanovcode 3y agoRight, I agree about Holland. Same would apply to Belgium or Luxembourg. But what about 90% of the countries that do not have this problem? Everything east of France is just fields and fields of nothing.
- orangepurple 3y agoThat's not true. There are lot of forests and mountains. To get to nothing you have to go all the way to Ukraine. It is relatively featureless south and east of Kyiv.
- lightedman 3y agoMost of the big hydroponic cannabis growers here in SoCal use vertical farms for sea of green operations. Financially-viable? Those people rake in MILLIONS yearly. Those systems consume very little in the way of resources, with tightly-controlled NFT hydroponic application and targeted-spectrum LED lighting running the show.
- soneca 3y agoOff-topic English question, if I may. ”all but disappeared” means it disappeared, right?
- mc32 3y agoIt’s an understatement but there may be monies lying around in equipment and IP and some other corners.
- pyb 3y agoYes
- js8 3y agoNo, it actually means "everything else" happened, except disappearing. The usage in the title is wrong, IMHO, but I aḿ not a native speaker. (Though I would bet there is David Mitchell video out there ranting about this topic.)
- the_mitsuhiko 3y agoWhy wrong? The website is still up. There are remnants still around.
- RugnirViking 3y agoYou're correct, but the specific usage "all but disappeared" is used in English in this case to mean it has declined so much that there is almost nothing left (everything bad has happened to it, the only thing left is for it to be gone completely). Like right now I would say the snow we had last week has all but disappeared, because there technically are small piles where people had shoveled it or built snowmen, but it has functionally gone. Mitchell is funny but I doubt he ranted about this one because it strikes me as old-timey and posh, and he tends to rant about new things ;)
- BobaFloutist 3y agoNope! It means it got as close to disappearing as possible without fully disappearing.
- 3y ago
- mjhay 3y agoThere's nothing about vertical farming that wouldn't be better done by a greenhouse outside of a city. Or, in many circumstances, just a regular farm.
- chewmieser 3y agoThe point of vertical farming is that land is scarce (particularly in cities) and the idea is to reduce the footprint of the farms. So yeah, of course what you’re suggesting works since it already works today…
- romanovcode 3y agoIf you go 50km out of any major city (which is 30min drive with a truck) you always see lots and lots of space that can be used for farming. I literally don't get it. Why not just incentivize more farming work like reduce taxation?
- ta988 3y agoBecause then you get money from traditional banks which costs you a lot. VC money is free, especially if you fail. And the next time is always easier because they like people who failed "they learned something".
- romanovcode 3y agoYou are right, and it makes me sad. If a guy shows up and says "Give me 25 mil to open 10 acre potato farm" nobody would give him money because there is no chance of 10x+ return on investment. However his contribution to society is 10x+ than 99% of the startups.
- blovescoffee 3y agoMany many many farmers rely on loans to start their ventures. VCs fund because of possible returns to them not to society. Banks and Gov do the heavy lifting on ag funding.
- cushychicken 3y agoFormer AppHarvest employee - similar company, similar outcome. The absolute naivety / arrogance of some of these green tech companies is astounding. The basic assumption of a lot of these types of companies are “We’re smart tech people who are good at fundraising. We are absolutely equipped to solve this problem of indoor horticulture.” Almost all of them think that they have nothing to learn from an existing industry with decades of experience in growing produce at scale in greenhouses. Warning signs: 1. Not hiring anyone with prior experience working in industrial scale greenhouse ag. (They’re the sort of people you would expect to know about basic operations, labor, pest control, etc.) 2. Not listening to those people once they did hire them. 3. Trying to position / advertise themselves as tech companies rather than agriculture companies for the express purpose of inflating their valuation. The experience really soured me on green tech and agtech. The problems they need to solve aren’t technological at all. They have to do with distribution of the produce. Jonathan Webb and the entire AppHarvest leadership team can absolutely go fuck themselves. They are at best disingenuous, at worst, cash-grabbing liars.
- nitwit005 3y agoThese companies are often about scamming investors, which is what you get at with your third point. Maybe some of them still expect to succeed, but I suspect failure is often the plan.
- davidhunter 3y agoWould be interested to chat and hear your views on the viability of the greenhouse industry in the US if you're up for it? david [at] optimal.ag
- cushychicken 3y agoI’m not at all interested in chatting. I’ve already given enough of my limited lifetime to the ag tech space, and I never want to go back - even via a phone call. The main problem isn’t growing the fruit - it’s selling and distributing it. Mastronardi has a monopoly on North American distribution in all but name. (For tomatoes, at least. ) You can grow as much produce as you want, but they’re going to figure out a way to capture any consumer surplus produced by the growers as part of the distribution chain. That didn’t really matter so much for AppHarvest because they couldn’t profitably produce fruit at Mastronardi’s market rate. But if they did, Mastronardi would figure out a way to shift the market pricing they negotiated with them. Since they control most of the foodservice and retail grocery supply, and have those contracts pretty sewn up, Mastronardi is basically the only way to get fruit into store shelves. That gives them a ton of power negotiating with greenhouses that are otherwise commodities - water and sun go in, tomatoes come on.
- peweet 3y agoAnyone who is involved in farming knew this start up was a pie in the sky project. One thing about farming and especially farming in Europe is how regulated it is. For example, you are not permitted to spread cow manure at certain times of the year due to risk of run-off or you get fined. That is one small example amongst dozens or hundreds (for beef farming). A cow is better tracked in Europe than a person is and I am not exaggerating. It can tracked its entire life from farm to farm and its entire health history is tracked. There are genomics testing, various other iniatives to ensure standards are adhered to. If you sell produce (milk/beef) that has antibiotics or too much bacteria in it, you can forbidden to sell that produce. You cannot negotiate the price if selling to an abattoir or a creamery. The same exists for vegatables. There is no negotiation. On the Continent food prices change once a month. In the UK it is once a year. The farmer gets assessed for quality of his produce and receives a pre-determined price. No wiggle room no negotiation. Farming mostly runs at an abject loss and the idea is you have a sliver of profit that is buffetted by a subsidies. It caps at 300k. The objective of this subsidy is also to protect small farms from being crushed by bad seasons and give economic stability to far flung regions and isolated villages. Europe is also protected by immense tariffs and barriers to entry that made it difficult for crops that are washed with pesticides (ie Ukranian wheat prior the war) to get into the market. These tarriffs are reciprocated by other nations. It is functionally impossible for a US farmer to export beef or chicken to the EU due to rules on the presence of hormone, antibiotics for beef and chlorine washed carcasses for chicken. The historical objective of the farm subsidies was to: 1. protect farmers from what national governments thought of as unfair competition 2. Avoid a repeat of the 'hungry 30's' (especially in Germany). Which destroyed the support for democracy and fuelled the rise of the extremist parties. 3. Give protection to massive peasant populations and stop them from supportng Communist parties post WWII. (France and Italy most especially). In return other countries got expanded market accessses. The biggest innovation in Europe specifically in crop growing since the 90s was the greenhouse produced vegatables created mostly in the Netherlands or Andalucia in Spain. However the crops are extremely sensitive to diseasea and blights and any kind of contamination can rapidly spoil a crop. Agriculture is as highly regulated as pharmaceuticals or aviation, it is more politically rife and riven with competing lobby groups who still have immense sway in many national governments. Also the European Union as a whole has some really odd views on specific technologies. The eurocrats are very skeptical and horrified by GMO food and effectively ban any usage in this area. This would be crucial for this particular start up for the aforementioned pollution and disease control. Even pesticide you have to register your name with the local supplier and it is cross checked and verified and you can be subject to an inspection by a Agricultural officer to check if its stored correctly. My point is this industry is so complex and regulated any disruption should be viewed with heavy skeptism if it isnt coming from either a biotechnology lab or a University with a heavy bankground in Agri-science. (ie Wageningen University in the Netherlands is one of the best in the world). If you any commenter wants a decent picture of European farming have a look at 'Clarkson Farm' produced by Jeremy Clarkson.
- CrzyLngPwd 3y ago214,000 m2 of land saved...it's only 52 acres. I'm also not convinced that growing this way, essentially in a lab without the soil web etc, leads to the health-giving foods we all need.
- stevebro 3y agoMismanagement and poor execution seems to have doomed this project, but the idea still seems viable to me. Some of the price disparities with vertical hydroponics fall away when compared against pure "organics." Admittedly, I'm no expert, but I'd be interested in a comparison of economics and impacts with regenerative farming for turning out high quality organic produce.
- fakedang 3y agoIs it truly regenerative farming, when your produce is made from non renewable energy at high cost, inside a large urban structure (which takes away land area for housing, hence more homes have to be built elsewhere) with water supply transported from rural to urban areas?
- romanovcode 3y agoThe whole idea is idiotic. There is enough land to provide agriculture development. The problem is that farmers are gettin paid too little and taxed too much.
- peweet 3y agoIf real prices reflected the production costs, the cost of meat would be 3X, 4X the cost. Milk is alreaded traded at a loss by the supermarkets. You'd also see most small medium sized farms gone within 5-10 years and see mass unemployment in many those same isolated villages Countries like Brazil will become even bigger agri superpowers and finish converting all of the Amazon into a giant pasture for beef.
- orangepurple 3y agoWill the cost be more than $32 USD (28 CHF) per kilogram or $14.53 per pound of chicken? That's what people pay for chicken at the Migros supermarkets in the tiny landlocked country of Liechtenstein which is part of the Swiss customs union. I think the closest thing to that chicken is organic free range, which cost $5.79 a pound a few years ago in the US at Trader Joes. So the 3x multiple is in line with what you're suggesting if we assume Swiss customs union area chicken cost reflects reality.
- braza 3y ago> finish converting all of the Amazon into a giant pasture for beef. I do not believe that it's going to be so simple like that, since the government has social and environment pressures as well. And being completely pragmatic, the issue with the pastures is more structural due to the Military Regime from 70s [1] in a failed strategy than to some availability of land to do it [2]. [1] - https://g1.globo.com/economia/agronegocios/noticia/2020/10/25/por-que-tem-tanto-gado-na-amazonia.ghtml https://g1.globo.com/economia/agronegocios/noticia/2020/10/2... [2] - https://mamiraua.org.br/noticias/gado-amazonia-criacao-pecuaria-sustentavel https://mamiraua.org.br/noticias/gado-amazonia-criacao-pecua...
- tamaharbor 3y agoWhere is Elizabeth Holmes when you need her? Oh wait…
- busterarm 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISAKc9gpGjw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISAKc9gpGjw Been sending this video to every charlatan pushing vertical farming for years now. The math is pretty obvious and insurmountable on this one.
- VoodooJuJu 3y agoShould send it to the investors. The charlatans know they're charlatans. They know vertical farming is bull. They don't care. It's the investors who should do their due diligence. They should know better. Alas, a fool and his money...
- lightedman 3y agoFunny, I run vertical farming and it works great. Perhaps those charlatans are listening to the wrong experts on the subject? I've been doing it for over two decades. For how long have you done vertical farming?
- Loughla 3y agoIf you don't mind me asking, what is your crop and scale?
- lightedman 3y agoThe the majority of the systems my clients bought were primarily fodder grass systems. Scale? UAE, Saudi Arabia, Yemen. Pretty large scale, you need a lot of fodder grass to help support a burgeoning livestock industry in a desert. Then I had California clients. Cannabis left and right. I only had one unhappy client and that's because the system worked TOO well for their chosen strain - the buds it produced were so thick that they got no air circulation and molded on the inside.
- VoodooJuJu 3y agoSo, you don't actual run a vertical farm, you sell the tools to run a vertical farm.
- h2odragon 3y agoI feel certain there was no shortage of people mentioning the impracticality of these schemes when the company was soliciting for investors. "Told you so" is cheap afterwards. Does anyone actually value it beforehand? Or is it no longer considered socially acceptable to avoid obvious mistakes? Is the difference "spending someone else's money?" Were people investing their own funds major participants here, or was this a darling of "fund managers" who are looting other people's purses?
- davidhunter 3y agoThe people who are said it wouldn't work lost credibility as these startups raised rounds at progressively higher valuations. After all, money talks, so clearly the naysayers were missing something...
- davidhunter 3y agoAfter the later rounds closed at insane valuations, the early VC investors in infarm were seen as legends. This created jealously amongst other VC investors who felt they had 'missed out' which resulted in more money being invested into infarm and other vertical farming companies e.g. Bowery/Plenty. Decisions to invest were made on FOMO, not a first-principles analysis of the farming technique which shows very clearly that vertical farming is unfeasible.
- mattgrice 3y agoNever trust an ag startup that's not near UC Davis, Salinas, Waginenigen NL, UIUC, Cornell, or Iowa State. I grew up on a farm, my parents still farm, and if anyone wants to be an ag-tech VC feel free to hire me but I'll give you one piece of advice gratis: never invest in an ag-tech company with HQ in a big city. Any farm boy could tell you this nonsense would never pencil out. Half of this ag-tech shit is so stupid I wonder if it's not just straight-up money laundering.
- Loughla 3y agoI would like to second this. There are a large amount of comments on this site, just as one example, when anything ag is talked about that are just insanely uninformed. The assumption seems to be that farming is just good old boys doing what they've always done, instead of the massively data informed, extremely sophisticated business it is, even for family operations. I was a full-time farmer until after graduate school. The guy who rents the family farm now farms to the square foot and sometimes even at precision even tighter than that (applying chemicals sometimes is based on the 1/2 square foot)! And that is over the entire 7-10k acres he rents/owns in total. The amount and variety of data he uses is startling.
- thecyborganizer 3y agoI shared this with my spouse, who worked for an ag startup in Boston (still exists, different leadership, who knows what they're up to now). They had this to say on the matter: One big competitive advantage of [company] was that we were able to hire smart, young ag scientists, especially LBGTQ+ ones, who wanted to live in a big, queer-friendly city. We had a lot of great people who were really excited that they didn't have to live in Davis or Ithaca, as well as people whose partners' careers tied them to a big city in some way (doctors, lawyers, finance). (They would also add UMich, University of Minnesota, and the Research Triangle in NC to your list.)
- tomhoward 3y agoI've been working in ag-tech for about 10 years, having spent the prior 10 years in other kinds of startups/tech companies. When I see the new ag-tech startups coming out of accelerators or being established by supposedly seasoned entrepreneurs, the ideas that keep coming up over and over are vertical farming, weed-killing laser robots and insect protein. They all seem to be based on this assumption that traditional farming/food production is antiquated and inefficient, and that what the industry needs is clever outsiders to come in and re-invent it with the latest technologies. And they all just seem to go nowhere. And in my view it's all based on a flawed premise: that farming needs any kind of technological revolution. It just doesn't. It's mostly fine. And whilst some things could/should be improved (environmental externalities and resource consumption being the most significant), these issues aren't going to be solved by outsiders with messiah complexes coming in and telling established growers/experts that they're wrong/stupid, they'll be solved via unglamorous work over many years by people who really understand the field.
- fennecbutt 3y agoFrom horizontal to vertical is a huge deal though. The US might have a load of space but plenty of others countries would massively benefit from converting land used for farming into land used for housing where possible. Additionally it means that farming can happen on the edges of towns and cities rather than in the wops, ie fewer huge delivery trucks moving produce around; it can essentially be grown down the road.
- notadev 3y agoIf not vertical farming, weed killing lasers, an ze bugs, where is innovation needed in AgTech?
- nitwit005 3y ago> these issues aren't going to be solved by outsiders with messiah complexes coming in and telling established growers/experts that they're wrong/stupid, they'll be solved via unglamorous work over many years by people who really understand the field. Many of the revolutionary changes in agriculture in the last century came from outsiders. They just stopped being outsiders once they were part of the industry. Phrasing it like these people are going and telling growers/experts they're stupid is a false portrayal. No one is going and spitting in their faces like that. They think their new idea will improve efficiency somehow, but that's not an insult.
- pard68 3y agoI worked for a hydroponic tech startup, in no world is it cost effective if you're a large company. Small scale in a basement or backyard, yes, but this stuff doesn't scale, largely because it's priced for the marijuana industry. If you are growing lettuce with your hydroponics equipment that you paid weed prices for, you will never see your way out of the red.
- BobaFloutist 3y agoBut is that the cost of fabrication, or the cost of off-the-shelf? Like you said it's priced for the marijuana industry, but if you scale up enough you can make your own manufacturing deals, no?
- pard68 3y agoThe company I worked for had three "core" child companies. A consumer online store, brick and mortar stores, and a "we don't respond to your emails unless you're talking six figures per transaction". Even the at-scale business was running sticker prices that make it hard to do business if you're not growing something with a marijuana-level return.
- shellfishgene 3y agoThere are large companies that produce hydroponic lettuce commercially, and have for a long time, making good profits.
- pard68 3y agoI'd love to hear about these. I joined that startup because I wanted to be a part of the alt-ag world, I left because I found out I was just part of the stoner world.
- tiew9Vii 3y agoGoogle "Hydroponic lettuce farm Australia", a few big farms come up. They're not new, I think some have been running 30+ years. Most of them look to be NFT using PVC drain pipes on a large scale.
- ensocode 3y agoThe idea of vertical farming doesn't really appeal to me. I mean it sounds efficient, but as we see we are throwing electricity to simulate natural processes. With all the organic hype isn't there a much higher demand on traditional grown food in an organic way. The idea of growing food in a city laboratory seems counter-intuitive to me. Isn't there much more market in developing supportive technology for efficient classic organic farming? Or am I completely wrong here?
- CaptainFever 3y agoThere's a lot of interest in vertical farming in city-states like Singapore that want to become more self-sufficient with food. There is just legit no land here for any traditional farms. I'm sure for non-city-states there are other factors like eco friendliness (efficient on land and resources), lowering transport costs, etc.
- braza 3y agohttps://archive.is/brXAt https://archive.is/brXAt
- thelastgallon 3y agoVertical farming is based on the premise that land is no longer available. Technology can be used to free up land from understanding where it is wasted. We waste ~160 million acres for biofuels[1]. 60 million acres just in the US[2]. A small fraction of this land can be solar PV, or even zero[4]. You can drive about 150 times as far from a solar-powered electric car compared to using corn bioethanol[3]. Switching to EVs starts a virtuous cycle of (1) accelerating renewables (EVs are parked >90% of the time, have flexible demand, perfect for solar/wind), (2) freeing up 160 million acres of land and the associated water usage, fertilizer, etc (3) Freeing up water usage, 47.5 trillion gallons (just in US!), 40% of water withdrawals[5,6]. Availability of this 40% water allows us to farm a lot more land than whats possible currently. EVs + renewables will also free up 40% of global shipping, stop 10 million deaths from air pollution and save us trillions in fossil fuel subsidies [7,8,9]. --- [1] For bioethanol and biodiesel combined, total land use worldwide is at least 155.47 million acres: https://hungermath.wordpress.com/2015/10/29/how-much-farmland-is-used-for-biofuel/ https://hungermath.wordpress.com/2015/10/29/how-much-farmlan... [2] The US uses 60 million acres for biofuels (most of it for corn). That’s 25 million hectares. This is about the size of the United Kingdom: https://cfpub.epa.gov/ncea/biofuels/recordisplay.cfm?deid=353055 https://cfpub.epa.gov/ncea/biofuels/recordisplay.cfm?deid=35... [3] https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/us-corn-biofuels https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/us-corn-biofuels [4] Solar land usage can be zero from agrivoltaics and from not using farm land at all, covering water bodies (lakes, reservoirs) or land along the highways. [5]https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=50698 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=50698 [6]According to the U.S. Geological Survey, electric power generators are the largest source of U.S. water withdrawals and account for about 40% of total water withdrawals in the United States: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=37453 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=37453 [7]https://qz.com/2113243/forty-percent-of-all-shipping-cargo-consists-of-fossil-fuels https://qz.com/2113243/forty-percent-of-all-shipping-cargo-c... [8]Air Pollution Kills 10 Million People a Year. Why Do We Accept That as Normal?: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/08/opinion/environment/air-pollution-deaths-climate-change.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/08/opinion/environment/air-p... [9]https://www.axios.com/2023/08/25/oil-government-subsidies https://www.axios.com/2023/08/25/oil-government-subsidies
- tyho 3y agoI don't understand vertical farming for anything other than crops that aren't eaten for their calorie content. To me, it seems like an expensive way to increase the land needed to grow food. Land use is increased, assuming the energy to light the greenhouse comes from solar panels. You need ~ 10 m^2 of solar panels to provide 1 m^2 of sun-equivalent light, sure there might be some optimization to be done with wavelengths and intensity, but I haven't seen anything to indicate you could ever break even. Why build a solar farm to convert light to electricity, then a big greenhouse where that electricity is converted back into light? Just plant the crops where you were going to put the solar panels!
- GaryNumanVevo 3y agoA farm that uses artificial light (vertical, greenhouse, or otherwise) could actually be a perfect electrical load shedding mechanism. Keep the lights at nominal levels during normal grid operation, and turn them up to absorb grid load. Preferably you're colocating this near the source of excess solar / wind energy. The farm would be providing the grid a valuable service, while also dumping that excess energy into usable calories.
- antisthenes 3y ago> Keep the lights at nominal levels during normal grid operation, and turn them up to absorb grid load. That's a great way to light-burn the sensitive plants and to shorten the life of LED lights. There are approximately hundreds of better ways to shed grid load.
- byyll 3y agoIt doesn't work, stop trying and stop falling for it. Food grown in soil and in sun has more nutrients than anything vertically grown with artificial lamps and no soil, just water.
- RugnirViking 3y agoIt can and does work, its just this company was incompetent and arrogant as covered by the article. Artificial lamps provide the same uv light that the sun does. The "just water" is regularly cycled with nutrients because yes plants need those. Different crops do better or worse with this. It's already used at scale for certain crops, ironically often because it decreases water usage (evaporation losses on large fields are enormous, plus runoff)
- byyll 3y agoIt does not. An artificial lamp will never be the same as the sun.
- mountaintimefrm 3y agoThe most successful form of vertical farming is agroforestry, or tree-based agriculture. It provides habitat, shade, carbon sequestration, and water retention while raising per acre productivity over that of 2-D cropping. Agroforestry is a well studied, widely implemented practice that big talking green tech "big thinkers" tend to ignore if not openly scoff at.
- ThePhysicist 3y agoI mean in summer, the sun delivers almost 100,000 Lumen / m² to crops for free, you'll have a hard time competing with that alone using indoor LED lighting, which has efficiencies of around 200 Lumen / Watt. Of course you don't need the full sunlight to grow crops but anyone with an aquarium can tell you that even keeping a very small number of plants thriving using artificial light and nutrients isn't cheap. So many other factors like the price of real estate in cities and the logistics seem to doom these indoor farming companies as well, I can't imagine they will ever serve anything but a niche market. There wasn't even real innovation here, Ag-focused countries like Spain and the Netherlands have the most efficient growing processes figured out for a long time, so all this vertical farming stuff was nonsensical from the beginning. Savings in transportation costs can't possibly offset the other costs either. So really the only surprising thing is how long they managed to keep alive without producing anything of value. I guess what really killed them in the end was the end of dumb and cheap money.
- lfmunoz4 3y agoWonder how much money the founders walked away with
- iancmceachern 3y agoI got caught up in this. I even had several meetings with Caleb Harper. In the end a co-founder and I had a provisional patent on a wifi controlled relay ac power strip before they were ubiquitous. He chose to not pursue the patent and ended up patenting a bunch of software nonsense that's not dependable or understandable or usable. Meanwhile the folks making the power strip are doing well. There are some ag focused ones, check out Amazon. In the end it was like a lot of VC cycles I've been through, all hat no cowboy.
- orf 3y agoI interviewed at Infarm a while back. The process was pretty great, and I got an offer. One of the founders took me on a tour of their Berlin factory, and it was super impressive - they had adapted these gigantic 3 storey automatic German tool storage cupboards for growing. I thinking I would accept, when on the last day I was walking back from a function with one of the team members. I mentioned that I was leaving because I didn’t like the amount of politics at my current place, and he stopped in his tracks for a moment, then said “yeah…”.