14 ms·
Spotify will end service in Uruguay due to bill requiring fair pay for artists
- s_dev 3y agoI gave up on Spotify after the Neil Young debacle. I've tried Deezer and Qobuz both really weren't as good as Spotify they lacked the range of songs and creating playlists was really awkward -- any other alternatives people would recommend?
- johnsutor 3y agoI used to use Tidal, thought it was pretty solid and the hi-fi streaming was an added bonus.
- z3dd 3y agoI still use it, it's fine, but with enough annoyances that leaves me thinking if the grass is greener elsewhere.
- lukew3 3y agoSame. I switched back to Spotify though because I missed the vast amount of user generated playlists you can look up on spotify. Also, Spotify caches a lot more than Tidal, so it performs better when I'm walking around connected to my spotty college wifi.
- Kezzo 3y agoYoutube music is really good.
- throwuxiytayq 3y agoYouTube Music barely works, is terribly designed even by Google standards, lacks basic features any free music player had in the 90s, and they'll probably shut it down next week anyway.
- sofixa 3y agoWhich basic features is it missing? And even if it is shut down (it is the result of the shutdown of Google Play Music, and there is no successor, so unlikely in the near future), you'll still have YouTube itself to listen music on, so no real loss there.
- throwuxiytayq 3y agoSeamless (gapless) playback (that actually works). Equalizer. Cross-fade. Volume normalization. Buttons that react when you click them, not 5 seconds later. Desktop app, I'll even take a shitty electron wrapper. Literally anything related to customization of the application/playback/UI/music library. If I'm setting the bar too high, just playing audio without freezing or bugging out constantly would already be a huge improvement. > there is no successor, so unlikely in the near future What is Google's successor to Google+, Stadia, Reader, Wave, Buzz, Domains, blocklist feature, YouTube Streams, Inbox, Health, Answers?...
- avbanks 3y agoYT muisc is my favorite music streaming platform. It actually has a great algorithm for suggestions.
- sailorganymede 3y agoI’ve been using Soundcloud since I was 14 and still keep it up. It more or less has the same songs (with some exclusions here and there) and it has tons of mixes which are lovely. I love having lofi on as i code so i got a few 2 hour mixes to power me through.
- wkjagt 3y agoWould you mind sharing the lofi mixes you’re listening to? I love lofi music when concentrating on something.
- sailorganymede 3y agoOf course! I have written it all out here: https://github.com/bhurghundii/sharing-things/blob/main/lofi-mixes-i-love.md https://github.com/bhurghundii/sharing-things/blob/main/lofi... Happy listening ~
- fhd2 3y agoSoundCloud is my main thing these days, it seems to have way more of the niche stuff I'm interested in (like game music). Thought it wasn't particularly popular, but I happily recommend it.
- have_faith 3y agoI've decided to go mostly offline. Bandcamp purchases, ripping CD's from charity shops, etc... all going into a local media server. I use NTS radio for on the go stuff and discovering new music. I pay for their membership which is very reasonable.
- peblos 3y agoDo you listen to music on your phone? If so, watch OS and app are you using?
- have_faith 3y agoNot very often, trying to wear headphones less generally. At the moment though that's done with Spotify and NTS radio apps. I might mirror my music library onto the phone though. I was also thinking of moving my music library onto a server and streaming it from there, not sure with which software yet.
- ikesau 3y agoThe bandcamp app is great. You get 2-3 free streams of any album, plus an enormous catalogue of radio shows to discover new music through. It's really reinvigorated my passion for music. Once you've listened to an album a couple of times, you have to pay for it and then you get unlimited streams. If there's an artist that isn't on bandcamp (many artists on major labels aren't) then I use plexamp. The monthly bill for that server has effectively replaced my streaming bill.
- xethos 3y agoNot OP, but I absolutely adored Airsonic-Advanced and DSub from F-Droid. Caching, streaming, quality-adjustment (FLAC on wifi, lower quality ogg on data), adding music, and scrobbling all worked amazingly well. Would very highly recommend, and I have yet to find anything better.
- Semaphor 3y agoFor me: Android with Symfonium, streaming (or locally cached) from my Jellyfin server.
- terinjokes 3y agoI've been using Qobuz (along with my own Navidrome instance) for the past year. The depth of music in some genres seems pretty good, and seems to have all the mainstream artists, but once you get past them in indie/pop/rock genres the gaps in the catalog really start to show. I've reached out to some artists, and no one seems quite clear why their releases don't appear in Qobuz when they appear in all of the competition. Unfortunately, none of the competition makes lossless streaming available (and I'm not counting Tidal's MQA, even if it was available on Linux). When I joined they had some social features, and searching for user created playlists seems possible. The last couple of times I've tried I've only gotten Qobuz's official playlists in search results. I've had to make do with syncing playlists from Spotify with Soundiiz. When combined with how inaccurate the metadata is (including the lack of ability to report the inaccurate metadata) and the lack of any new features in the past year (including lack of copying pre-saves from every other platform), it really seems like investment in Qobuz has stalled. It's too bad, because it seemed pretty promising. I really miss Rdio. :'( For listening to Navidrome on the go I use the "substreamer" app on Android. The "Podcast Republic" app also works well for listening to college radio streams to find new artists. Disclaimer: I was previously at Grooveshark.
- TheUndead96 3y agoGrooveshark, now that's a name I have not heard in a long time
- terinjokes 3y agoI debated even including the disclaimer. It's been ages since it was shut down, and it's been 13 years since I was even there. However, I didn't want to violate some HN netiquette by not being transparent.
- TheUndead96 3y agoI'm glad you included it, I have fond memories using Grooveshark :)
- _flux 3y agoI use Tidal, mostly to support an underdog, though I'm not sure how much that reflects reality nowdays.. However, they are in the process of adding better APIs for developers to use, so at least that's a plus in my books: https://github.com/orgs/tidal-music/discussions/categories/ideas-feature-requests https://github.com/orgs/tidal-music/discussions/categories/i... The default recommendations were pretty hip-hop-based for me, though, but nowadays it's better. I also subscribe to di.fm, which probably tells a bit about my music taste.
- ciabattabread 3y agoWasn’t Tidal owned by Sprint? (And apparently it’s now owned by Jack Dorsey.) Isn’t that like supporting Zune for being an “underdog”, despite it being owned by Microsoft?
- _flux 3y agoTIL :), though Block only acquired the majority of it at 2021, so relatively short time ago. Well, people bought Windows Phones probably to avoid buying Android or Apple phones, so I guess it's still the same?
- jug 3y agoYouTube Premium for both YouTube Music and ad-free YouTube without caring for any adblocking hoops? I've been considering it. Their family deal shares price with Spotify Family here and it's much better value. Some people also claim that it offers better sound quality despite similar bitrates than Spotify. Besides, more automated mixes (even an offline mix), better recommendations, and plenty of music videos and good music video discovery.
- therealdrag0 3y agoWhat pisses me off about YT is their music and videos share the same playlists. So if you import your Spotify to ytm you get a bunch of music playlists in your yt. I wish it was separate.
- musictubes 3y agoApple Music.
- footy 3y agoI gave up around that time too, initially for Tidal. These days, I've mostly gone back to buying most music I listen to. I've even bought many of the things I pirated as a teenager-I value music, so why shouldn't my spending habits reflect that? Discovery is through the came channels I used 20 years ago, plus some youtube. Record stores are great for used stuff-I picked up ten albums on CD for like $32 last month. Plus, I run a navidrome server, so I can stream (some of, I have a lot of vinyl) my own music when I'm out. I'm a lot happier with this arrangement.
- draw_down 3y ago[dead]
- frakt0x90 3y agoI would pay double for my spotify subscription if it meant better artist pay. Truly my favorite and most-used app.
- RGamma 3y agoWould be great if there was transparency to the user, e.g. the bottom line amount of pay distributed to artists from your listening per billing period. Also they should let internet radios on there and do the same because I have some smaller ones I listen to that don't support premium (higher quality/no ads) streams. All under the precondition they don't destroy indie internet radio culture along the way.
- Y-bar 3y agoIt would raise too many questions like "why did most of my money go to artists I never listened to in the first place" and Spotify does not want you to be aware of that.
- rchaud 3y agoStreaming is speedrunning cable TV economics.
- satyrnein 3y agoThey don't have insight into what the actual artist gets. Spotify pays distributors and labels, who have their own contracts with artists.
- londons_explore 3y agoYou can just sign up for two spotify accounts if you want to do that...
- whyoh 3y ago>I would pay double for my spotify subscription if it meant better artist pay. I doubt most people would be willing to do the same, however. So, an expensive Spotify would lose to cheaper alternatives. But the crux of the matter is that most artists are willing to work for pennies; either for the small chance of future success or simply because they like doing it (it's just a hobby for them). There's an oversupply of "good enough" talent, undercutting everyone else (except the top 0.01% who are already rich and famous).
- circlefavshape 3y agoSpotify take 70% of their revenue and distribute it split by stream count. I honestly fail to see what's "unfair" about that
- addandsubtract 3y agoI mean, a more fair way would be to split each subscriber's bill by the artists _they_ listened to. That would favor small / local artists more.
- braza 3y agoBut in terms of unit economics, the bigger artists/labels (or the artists that bring more users) are responsible for funding the entire platform, no? In other words: A small artist can _bring_ users to the platform, fair enough, but the platform that gives access to other artists and enables that needs to take the bigger share.
- Retric 3y agoNo, users are funding the platform not artists. If someone doesn’t listen to major artists then revenue from them shouldn’t go to said creators. Spotify however wants to maximize its cut and so has incentives to shift money from less popular artists if it can entice major labels to its platform. This has absolutely nothing to do with what’s fair, it’s simply about profit maximization and reducing the risks of competing platforms.
- braza 3y ago> If someone doesn’t listen to major artists then revenue from them shouldn’t go to said creators. Well I do not have the numbers here, but I would argue that this is definitely not the case in reality. > Spotify however wants to maximize its cut and so has incentives to shift money from less popular artists if it can entice major labels to its platform It’s the other way around, because the platform has competing interests: Spotify wants to have the labels to sell an “optionality” to the users (I.e. get the money from subs) but in terms of reproduction/execution Spotify wants to reproduce the maximum of podcasts and/or long tail artists because in those 2 cases Spotify does not spend a single penny. The labels has a very high bargaining power over Spotify due to its catalog, so as expected this is the biggest expenditure. That’s one of the reasons why Spotify is desperately pushing podcasts like crazy.
- sleepyfran 3y ago"Spotify already pays nearly 70% of every dollar it generates from music to the record labels and publishers", yet musicians still get paid incredibly bad. Maybe if the only way of making your business model sustainable is by underpaying artists, your business is just not sustainable.
- willvarfar 3y agoartists sign the deals with the labels, who license it to spotify and the other streaming services? The problem isn't that spotify isn't paying for the content, the problem is that artists sign away the rights to their content? Is spotify the baddie here?
- justsomehnguy 3y agoThere is no shortage of artists. Note: the parent changed their comment
- TheOtherHobbes 3y agoYes, it's an industry problem. Spotify is just the latest and nastiest incarnation.
- boesboes 3y agoyeah, just get a better paying job!
- Karellen 3y agoYes, artists have the wonderful choice of being able to sign for one of three labels, with no meaningful distinction between the deals any of them offer, because that's just how oligopolies roll. And they collude^Whave deals with spotify. Maybe spotify and the labels suck? https://www.promarket.org/2022/10/03/why-streaming-doesnt-pay/ https://www.promarket.org/2022/10/03/why-streaming-doesnt-pa...
- troupo 3y agoAnd what would you have Spotify do in this situation? Sign artists directly? And draw the ire of those three labels who will immediately pull all their music from the service?
- klelatti 3y agoThis may be an unpopular opinion but streaming music prices have to rise for artists to get a fair deal. Current prices are an incredible bargain and only so because they don’t reflect the true value of the product. Anything else is just trying to square the circle.
- School-Cotton 3y agoThey can’t demand higher prices because their main competitor, piracy, is free. I’ve long been opposed to piracy and thought copyright laws should be more strictly enforced, for exactly this reason. Yet most people seem to balk at that idea and think they have an absolute moral right to free content. I’m not sure why.
- klelatti 3y agoPiracy did well for a while in the CD era. There is no evidence that current prices represent a ceiling for what would work in 2023 before people would turn again to piracy.
- PodgieTar 3y agoI'll add to this as well, since it's a comment I see a lot. I'm not convinced that people would be willing to go back to Piracy. I think the convenience of being able to listen to any song at any time immediately without having to connect your iPhone to your PC, drag the file over, get them recognised, maybe add some metadata. (I know there'll be more modern approaches to this. I don't think they'll be quite as easy as Spotify) That's not even mentioning music discovery. Most of my music is now from Discover Weekly.
- ghaff 3y agoThe power of convenience is definitely more a thing than I really appreciated in the Napster era. But I also don’t think people would generally subscribe to $50 per month streaming music.
- 3y ago
- rjmunro 3y agoThe article doesn't say what the new law requires in any way at all. How is what Spotify already pays not enough under the new law?
- judiisis 3y agoThis seems like a disaster bill similar to Canada's bill c-18 about news
- distcs 3y agoIs there a service that actually gives MP3 downloads? Call me old fashioned but I'll happily pay for a service that actually gives me MP3 files that I can download and keep offline.
- jack_pp 3y agoBandcamp
- crtasm 3y agoand when something isn't on there: Junodownload, Qobuz, Bleep, etc.
- occz 3y agoBandcamp?
- drcongo 3y agoBandcamp, iTunes, Beatport, there's an absolute ton of them.
- acdha 3y agoMP3 isn’t as popular due to its inherent poor quality but the iTunes Store (not Apple Music) still gives you non-DRMed AAC files (I don’t believe any lossless files are available that way).
- crtasm 3y agoMP3 is fine and still by far the most common format people are using.
- acdha 3y agoIt’s okay for non-demanding music but even at high bit-rates there are types of sound (e.g. cymbals) which it can’t reproduce well. Smaller, better sounding files are usually going to win and indeed they have for the most common ways people listen to music.
- JCharante 3y agoGreat. I love when companies just exit the market when countries enact silly laws.
- marcodiego 3y agoYour "silly law" may be someone's else fair law. I love when companies just behave better when countries enact fair laws. Of course it may not be easy to define what is a "fair law" but if it weren't for them, there wouldn't be workers rights or abuse prevention in many forms.
- Spivak 3y agoYes but in this case it's silly because Spotify licenses music from artists and record labels under specific contract terms. Making it illegal to execute that contract in country A while being bound by that contract in country B was never going to turn out well. For this law specifically it's a shitshow because they have their current math for the rest of the world which consumes 70% of their revenue and this law simply says yes and pay more. They can't rebalance the money to comply with the law because they would immediately get sued by record labels and so it would have to cut into the 30% which is just pure loss for them. When you write a law that guarantees you'll lose money in an entire country with no way out you're kinda backed into a wall. Small artists should get paid more but this change can't come like this because there's nothing for Spotify to actually do in response to the law.
- 93po 3y agoConceptually this doesn’t feel different than minimum wage laws to me. Companies pay local required wages across countries all the time. I can appreciate why they’d pull out of a small market that would be unprofitable for them. My hope is that more countries would follow bc artists are getting a very raw deal
- JCharante 3y agoI hope more countries follow suit and then artists realize their music's value is closer to 0 than they think.
- imchillyb 3y agoValue is determined by the purchaser not the seller of goods and services. Sellers only suggest price. The market, IE people, decide what to pay or if they'd rather sail the high-seas in search of their goods rather than pay extortionate prices. Humans value music enough to purchase it, but we don't value it enough to purchase it for the prices the industry suggests.
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- sod 3y agoMaybe there is a market for a "patreon for musicians". A platform that distributes your music to all streaming platforms but doesn't steal the rights from you. And additionally lets fans subscribe monthly for favorite arists (like patreon) for early access to music and discount to concerts and merch. IMO the patreon model is so good to lift artists out of poverty if they provide value to a small number of people without them having to loose all their creations to some publisher they signed off to in the begining. Maybe if myspace didn't kill itself, it could have been it.
- satyrnein 3y agoYou can get all your music onto all streaming platforms without giving up any rights for about $20/year. The Patreon part, presumably you could use Patreon itself for this?
- joeframbach 3y agoThis sounds like Bandcamp.
- luizsantana 3y agoSad for Uruguay, but also small country with little return