14 ms·
Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years
- mrlonglong 3y agoIntel needs to stop gouging customers for 10GBe NIC cards because they've got all the patents on the technology. Greed is _so_ ugly.
- formerly_proven 3y agoAre you sure about those patents? Those would be expiring in a few short years anyway, 10 GbE is more than 20 years old and 10GBASE-T will be soon, too. Though 10GBASE-T just doesn't feel like a super-sensible PHY to me.
- longtimelistnr 3y agowhat is the primary use you would have for them? do you have a 10GB connection? if so, very lucky
- Vecr 3y agoProbably NAS transfers or similar.
- mrlonglong 3y agoI want a network with that much bandwidth but prices are astronomical.
- ihattendorf 3y agoEthernet != Internet. I have a few SFP+ 10 GbE connections internally that are useful for large file transfers.
- goalieca 3y agoI remember wiring up cat5 gigabit about 20 years ago in an industrial workplace. My house of that age also has cat5 everywhere and it’s aged very well. 1gig is still the standard for wired with few but expensive 2.5g and very expensive 10g home and small business options.
- AdamN 3y agoEven now 1gbps is plenty for virtually every end user and I suspect it will be good enough for a long time (maybe VR changes things??).
- api 3y agoNeural compression is an emerging field and already shows some striking compression abilities, especially if the compressor/decompressor includes a large model which amounts to something like a huge pre-existing dictionary on both sides. Stable Diffusion XL is only about 8 gigabytes and can render a shocking array of different images from very short prompts with very high fidelity. 1gbps might be enough for more than we think.
- dwighttk 3y agoDeterministicly?
- api 3y agoSure. The only reason image generators aren't deterministic is that you inject randomness. Set the same random seed, get the same image. Download Stable Diffusion XL and run it locally and try it. There are models that can be run in both directions. Take a source image and generate a token stream prompt for it. That's your compressed image. Now run it forward to decompress. CPU intensive but massive compression ratios can be achieved... like orders of magnitude better than jpeg. It's lossy compression, so we're not violating fundamental mathematical limits. Those bounds apply to lossless compression.
- globular-toast 3y agoI like that it talks about coaxial cable. In case anyone is curious, like I was, twisted-pair cabling is used in practice because it's much cheaper and easier to work with than coax.
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoI think it's slightly more complex than that. There's a relationship between the cost and complexity of repeater technologies vs. the cost and complexity of the cabling and its necessary topology that really drove 10BaseT adoption.
- bluGill 3y agoCoax is cheaper, or at least was when I used it in 1995. However since coax went from machine to machine it could be more expensive if the machines were not near each other. What killed coax was a problem anywhere took down everyone, and so there were too many problems.
- globular-toast 3y agoYou're talking about a different topology, though. Twisted-pair is cheaper per metre so allows you do to star topologies which work better. Especially so if you consider equivalent cables, so a hypothetical Cat6A equivalent coax vs Cat6A UTP or whatever.
- bluGill 3y agoCoax per meter was cheaper than cat-3 twisted pair (Cat5 existed but nobody was using it). That is before the star topology required a lot more meters of cable for twisted pair. Twisted pair was easier to work with than coax, and star topology avoided a lot of trouble with other topologies so it won out anyway, but it wasn't cheaper at first.
- baal80spam 3y agoI really loved the "no bullshit" approach that Ethernet authors took, as described in the "Where Wizards Stay Up Late".
- WillAdams 3y agoIt still kills me that this name was used for a wired, rather than a wireless setup.
- jasonjayr 3y ago> It reflected a comment Thacker had made early on, that “coaxial cable is nothing but captive ether,” PARC researcher Alan Kay recalled. From the article on the origin of the name.
- WillAdams 3y agoYes, but ethernet does not does not communicate this in such a way that it communicates that this is a cabled system, nor is there is a matching phrasing for one which doesn't need cables.
- dhc02 3y agoI think about this every single time I read or hear the word ether. "It means an invisible transfer medium. What were they thinking!?"
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agoThat's Aether.
- dwighttk 3y agoSynonyms
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agoSo it is, I didn't know that. In that case the other poster point stands, I'm guessing they used the word to indicate the magic of the network?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dale_glass 3y agoIt's only a pity that things fossilized on 1500 byte packets. Yeah, we can compensate for that with hardware, but it's ridiculous to do 100G or even 10G in 1500 byte chunks.
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoJumbo frames are a thing.
- eqvinox 3y agoJumbo frames are not a thing on the internet. The internet has fossilized at 1500 byte MTU.
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoJumbo frames could be a thing on the internet if there was a meaningful value proposition. Jumbo frames get plenty of adoption in LAN environments.
- eqvinox 3y ago> Jumbo frames could be a thing on the internet It being a thing on "the internet" would require it being a thing on a sizable majority of the internet. You'd need to get large network operators, peering points, user-facing ISPs, and even users themselves on board to change their setups. And Path MTU discovery is still sufficiently unreliable as to make it incredibly painful to have partial large-MTU networks. And if you do any of this with standard home customers, a hellscape torrent of user complaints is going to rain down on your support contacts. Which costs money. More money than is lost by the higher cost of routing smaller packets. So, no, jumbo frames could not be a thing on the internet. There's a reason it's called fossilization. There is no technical reason precluding changing this, it's just frozen into way too many places to be changed.
- NovemberWhiskey 3y ago
- smudgy 3y agoI'd love to hear all the disruptive, trendy, innovative and blockchain-focused tech that'll cost me a fortune instead of relying on cheap ethernet. ^ The '/s' is implied.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoI get you have beef with blockchain but it feels petty and intentionally detracting from the subject.
- kjs3 3y agoI get that you have a beef with an anti-blockchain heretics speaking blasphemy in the public square and are compelled by your religion to chastise them vigorously, but you aren't helping keep things on topic either.
- eigenvalue 3y agoIf you're interested in the early history of Ethernet, the Bob Metcalfe oral history from the Computer History Museum is a great read: https://archive.computerhistory.org/resources/text/Oral_History/Metcalfe_Robert_1/Metcalfe_Robert_1_2.oral_history.2006.7.102657995.pdf https://archive.computerhistory.org/resources/text/Oral_Hist...
- jmathai 3y agoThis is a comment for folks in homes with coax run for cable TV. Ethernet is great. I wired ethernet to most rooms in our remodel and set up wired access points or jacks in the office to connect directly to my computer. The speeds and consistency over wifi and mesh were remarkable. Especially consistency. We moved, and it's not feasible to run ethernet everywhere in our current home. However, whoever built the home ran coax to nearly every room in the house - it's a bit ridiculous. And I learned that you can get up to 2.5gbps data transfer over coax using the MoCA standard. So now, I can run wired networking connections anywhere in the house for wired access points or connecting directly to computers, televisions, etc.
- thehappypm 3y agoI do this too and it is terrific, literally indistinguishable from ethernet. What’s amazing is you can run cable and MoCa on the same wire at the same time!
- teeray 3y agoHow does this work with both? Is there a defined band plan standard that cable operators know to avoid? Do you need to install a notch filter on the line coming into the house?
- coin 3y agoMOCA modems looks for unused bandwidth
- spookthesunset 3y agoI think it just sits in the mutli-ghz bands. It shouldn’t conflict with cable, which uses lower frequency bands. You just gotta make sure to install a low pass filter at your demarcation point so you aren’t broadcasting your MoCA stuff beyond your home. You also have to use appropriate splitters that are rated for the top ends of the spectrum.
- a-priori 3y ago
- JohnBooty 3y agoEthernet forever. It feels like the only thing in this godforsaken industry that is anywhere near "it just works."
- NortySpock 3y agoRecent friendly wholesome interview with Metcalf , where Metcalf says he is getting into the weeds of geothermal energy production. He also says the reason Ethernet keeps getting better is because they keep rebranding new, novel signalling and encoding schemes as Certified Ethernet. It sounded like he had a grin on his face when he said it. https://hanselminutes.com/900/from-ethernet-to-geothermal-energy-with-bob-metcalfe https://hanselminutes.com/900/from-ethernet-to-geothermal-en...
- taneq 3y agoDidn't Cringley say back in Accidental Empires that no matter what actual tech was involved, you could guarantee that in X years whatever we use for wired networking would be called Ethernet? :)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smartmic 3y agoAs much as I admire the performance of ethernet in the hardware/infrastructure sector, it is all the more impressive when software remains stable for such a long time. And there are also good examples with lifetimes of 40 to 50 years. If i were to mention just a few prominent examples that are in my head, I would be doing injustice to all the others that have not been mentioned, so I'll leave it at that. What I would like to say, however, is that in an industry as young as IT, it is hard to overestimate when technologies have proven themselves over decades. All the "latest hot sh*t" ideas/technologies/brainwaves/products first have to stand the test of time (no, 2.5 years is not enough) to be taken seriously without any doubt.
- alberth 3y agoNever underestimate the power of cheap, "good enough" and backward compatibility. https://assets.fixr.com/cost_guides/hardwired-computer-network/hardwired-computer-network-627b97c355495.png https://assets.fixr.com/cost_guides/hardwired-computer-netwo...
- therealmarv 3y agoIt's only disappointing that the most common standard nowadays is 1GB/s. I feel like there is a big gap and standards like 2.5GB/s or 5GB/s were somehow ignored and 10GB/s is a big jump up (also price wise)
- organsnyder 3y ago2.5 Gbps is pretty common.
- mmcnl 3y agoThen please find me a 2.5G 8-port switch with PoE for $100?
- organsnyder 3y agoI didn't say it was cheap.
- ooterness 3y ago"B" = Byte "b" = bit The ubiquitous 1000BASE-T form of Ethernet transmits 1 gigabit per second (1 Gb/s).
- therealmarv 3y agoyes, you are right
- nerdbert 3y ago2.5Gbps seems to have become the new reasonably-affordable thing.
- breadwinner 3y agoMetcalfe, inventor of ethernet, predicted in 1995 that the internet would collapse the next year, because the underlying tech couldn't possibly scale. He ended up having to literally eat his own words. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Metcalfe#:~:text=24%5D%5B25%5D-,Predicted%20Internet%20collapse,-%5Bedit%5D https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Metcalfe#:~:text=24%5D%...
- stewx 3y agoWow, a truly rare instance of literally eating your words!
- manual89 3y agoMcAfee can't hold a candle to this man.
- Koshkin 3y agoThis is one of the rare examples when the word "literally" means what it says.
- layer8 3y agoLiterally not a piece of cake. :D
- quickthrower2 3y agoAre printed papers or magazines toxic?
- Galacta7 3y agoI'm curious why the audience would not accept him eating the paper pulp in large cake form? Perhaps because he couldn't reasonably eat the whole cake in front of them (and thus his words)?
- test1235 3y ago> He had suggested having his words printed on a very large cake I guess that would just be eating cake, so not really any form of penance
- karmicthreat 3y agoThe one thing I would really like for ethernet is a smaller connector. But one that is still able to handle self-made cables. So something like just throwing a Type-C connector at it probably isn't going to work.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoUSB-C would certainly work, you just need the right (wire) mounting device behind the plug. It's unlikely to be very slim though.
- fanf2 3y agoIt would be difficult to make a port that works as USB-C with ethernet as an alternate mode. In USB-C there are separate transmit and receive differential pairs, whereas in (gigabit and later) ethernet the pairs are bidirectional.
- good8675309 3y agoEthernet at 50 and still not slowing down - a testament to the saying 'if it ain't broke, don't fix it.' It's remarkable how this old-school tech has remained relevant in an age of wireless everything. Makes me think of my tech stack, Java, monolith, sql db, etc. and it keeps serving all of my paying customers reliably, even though I'm not using the latest everything.
- kibwen 3y agoIt's honestly impressive how few qualms people have with the link layer, considering all the kerfuffle that gets raised for the address layer (IPv6) and the transport layer (QUIC) and the application layer (HTTP2/3). It's nice to have at least one protocol that feels "finished" (in a good sense).
- fanf2 3y agoEthernet has been redone from scratch several times. What has remained fairly constant is its frame and address layouts - an example of Kleinrock’s “narrow waist” pattern in protocol design.
- projektfu 3y agoI think the only part that hasn't been "fixed" is that it sends frames. 10Base-T is a new topology and cable with the bus virtualized in a hub. Switched Ethernet is like a different, intelligent network larping as Ethernet to naive stations. Signaling changes as you increase data rates and media now stretches from copper to fiber and the standard has retired baseband coax above 10Mbps. It's cool that they've made it work and kept it under the same "roof" of standards, so that we don't have to make so many vendor decisions or have regret building out one vendor's network and watching another one with different cabling or signaling take off with higher speeds and lower prices.
- msla 3y ago> I think the only part that hasn't been "fixed" is that it sends frames. And this is just terminology: An Ethernet protocol data unit is a frame because it's Ethernet and an IP protocol data unit is a packet because it's IP. You could switch the terms around and nothing would actually change.
- demondemidi 3y agoXerox PARC didn’t move fast and break things. They thought hard and delivered rock solid inventions. Such a huge difference between script kiddies turning into billionaires, and actual engineers.
- tibbydudeza 3y agoThe kiddo complained about low ping for PS5 - tried PoE so eventually got a electrician to run a conduit from the router in my office through the outside the wall all around the house to the outside of her room. We have a pitched roof but there are trusses, and I am not built like a hobbit if I need to replace the cable.
- msbhvn 3y agoTo paraphrase Bob Metcalf, “I don’t know what will come after Ethernet, but it will be called Ethernet.”
- stiray 3y agoI had my mileage in wifi/routers development and I will say you just a proverb: "The one who knows how wireless works, uses cable." ;) When renovating an apartment I have put a shitload of ethernet sockets everywhere, there is no place in 80m2 apartment, where you would be more than 2m away of nearest (including toilet) and as 4 of them were not enough behind TV, I have added a router there. Wifi is just a patch if you don't have that option. On fiber, my cost to uplink is 1000/500 for 35 euros / month and I want to use it on clients too. I have 2.4 and 5GHz turned on, but the LTE is better alternative so no one uses them. I have Mikrotics everywhere and Wave 2 is an option, but really, why bother if the ethernet cable works so much better? Not to even mention PoE (+ injectors). Physics cant be broken by whatever the current fashion is. So at the end, if you cant (for whatever reason) use ethernet in apartment and your mobile sucks? Go for the latest trend in wireless. This is not an issue? Use cable, nothing comes close to it.
- 8zah6q7 3y agoUnfortunately, many smart TVs use 100 Mbps RJ45 ports, so WiFi is usually faster. Some TVs allow you to plug in a USB to RJ45 adapter, but most of the USB ports are only USB 2 speed, so the practical limit is 300 Mbps. Some nice ones have USB 3 ports enabling 1 Gbps through an RJ45 adapter. I wish the manufacturers put at least gigabit (if not 2.5 Gbps) RJ45 ports on TVs.
- jmathai 3y agoFaster, but probably less reliable and more inconsistent. For this reason, I wire my TVs into the network :)
- ipython 3y agoI would never plug a smart TV into any network, but regardless of that - when you have an individual endpoint like the smart TV (or the Apple TV, Android device, etc), what's the practical advantage of a 2.5Gbit port on that device? You aren't able to watch the movie/TV show any faster.. so you're constrained to the data rate of the content you're consuming at ~1 to ~1.5x speed (if you are in to that sort of thing). Taking a 4k stream as an example, a compressed 4k stream is not going to exceed about 50Mbps, so even a 100Mbps data rate will have a 2x safety factor - and since you're wired, you're going to get full use of that data rate unlike Wi-Fi. You're not streaming uncompressed video as that would require more than 2.5Gbps, and if you want to upgrade to 8k video, you'll need a new TV anyway... I always wire in my TV and other fixed infrastructure because, since they aren't moving, there's no advantage to using a data layer protocol that, by definition, enables mobile access. In addition, latency and jitter is always better on wire versus wireless, and keeping these devices off the wireless frees up precious airtime that the rest of my devices that do move can use instead. It's a win-win-win all around.
- phendrenad2 3y agoWhat would we replace it with? Fiber? Quantum entanglement? Telepathy? Ethernet itself is the common-sense design you would arrive at if you needed to move bits from point A to B. Of course, things like the connector form factor could have evolved radically differently. Maybe in a parallel universe Ethernet uses something more like a unidirectional USB plug.
- TacticalCoder 3y agoSomething that amazes me with Ethernet is how you can mix and match various cables and speeds and things do still work. Just for fun semi-recently I hooked a 10 MBit/s only hub (not even a switch, a hub) to a 10/100 MBit/s switch, to a Gigabit switch (that'd also work at 100 Mbp/s) and everything would just work...
- kornhole 3y agoAh brings back memories of Bob Metcalfe. Out of college I worked for him at 3Com. We were making about three million NIC's a month, and it was like a cash machine. One of my first projects to support was trying to develop WIFI. We failed at that. Then Intel integrated the NIC capability into their chipsets. Cisco made better switches and routers. We went from a high flying silicon valley company to nothing.
- make3 3y agohow did Xerox invent so many things, that's crazy
- jonathaneunice 3y agoPerhaps more true to say the Ethernet brand is going strong. What's marketed as "Ethernet" today is vastly different from the 10base5 "yellow hose" originally called Ethernet. Entirely different wiring, signaling, collision management, topology, interconnection strategies, et cetera. But it's been demonstrably the biggest of wins to promote each next generation, however technically different from and incompatible with the previous generation, under the same brand name!
- eigenvalue 3y agoIt’s conceptually the same thing though, right? I guess it’s like https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus
- throw0101a 3y ago> What's marketed as "Ethernet" today is vastly different from the 10base5 "yellow hose" originally called Ethernet. The framing is compatible across all of these changes: your 802.11 NIC has an Ethernet MAC address and can talk to to a copper-connected GigE interface. Copper and fibre interfaces can also talk to each other. Part of the reasons for the concept of OSI Layers is that you could change things at lower layers (Thicknet, Thinnet, co-ax, etc) and at higher layers (IP, AppleTalk, etc) and would continue to work. The OSI Layer 2 is the same for all the "variants" of Ethernet. That makes it 'the same' as the original.
- AlbertCory 3y agoI have a true story, narrated in The Big Bucks where I briefly (2 or 3 seconds) took down the entire company (3Com), when it was running on ThinNet, which was the smaller coax used before twisted pair. The coax was in the baseboard, not in the air space overhead. No one noticed.
- drakonka 3y agoI have recently been having to use ethernet plugged directly into the wall because despite reasonable speed test results, I see a ton of packet loss during video calls when going through my router (either wired or wireless)... So it's definitely going strong in this household -.-
- RecycledEle 3y agoI'm surprised IEEE ignored Ethernet's child: Wi-Fi. Wi-Fi uses the CSMA/CD (Carrier Sense Multiple Access with Collision Detect) that was developed for Ethernet. I view Wi-Fi as wireless Ethernet.
- StillBored 3y agoI totally disagree with the idea that ethernet is "going strong". On the high end, it is a fragmentation mess of high speed (100Gbit+) technologies and mac/phy's. There is no midrange at this point. And the low end is price discriminated such that the Nbase spec couldn't even mandate all of 1/2.5/5/10 as required as part of the spec with the speeds being automatically selected based on cable quality. And its largely dead because its to expensive and Wifi is more convenient.
- Jemm 3y agoI was an ArcNet fan.
- ksec 3y agoReally wish 5Gbps Ethernet could replace 1Gbps Ethernet. I dont know why the industry went for 2.5Gbps instead ( Ok I do, cost savings ), and WiFI 7 could already make faster real world transfer than 2.5Gbps. Instead of further pushing mesh, we could have educated the market about putting Ethernet links, or we could have wired the house as if they were good old telephone cables.
- petepete 3y agoNormal people just don't need a home network any faster than their internet connection.
- elzbardico 3y agoIf only the USB consortium learned a lesson or two from Ethernet.....
- luckydude 3y agoIt might not have happened if it wasn't for me and avb. I need to write that up but the short story is that FDDI was the path to 100mbit, I wanted 100Mbit ethernet, the sun hardware engineers thought I wanted to signal over copper the same way that 10mbit did. I didn't care about that, I cared about what someone in this thread said, it's amazing that you can plug a 10Mbit hub in and have it work with 100mbit, Gbit, etc. In my mind, it was all about the packet format, if they are the same then we get cheap switches. And that is what we have today, I saw this coming around 1990. And for you guys hating on the 1500 bytes, the SGI memory interconnect taught me that bigger is not better. When you are doing cache misses remotely, big is not good. I'm doing a shit job explaining but there is some value in smaller. If you guys want, I'll try and write it up.
- Karrot_Kream 3y agoYes! Please do!
- champtar 3y agoOne thing that isn't going strong is the initially standardized framing for Ethernet, ie most traffic uses Ethernet II and not 802.2 LLC/SNAP. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethernet_frame#Types https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethernet_frame#Types
- dehrmann 3y agoA lot of this is because it of how much it adapted. Early, shared-medium ethernet like 10BASE2 wasn't viable. It survived because it switched to a star topology that enabled switching, and higher-level protocols like IP enabled routing.
- Kacidoo 3y ago[flagged]
- maaryy 3y ago[dead]