16 ms·
Nepal bans TikTok and says it disrupts social harmony
- terminous 3y ago> Nepal has banned all pornographic sites in 2018.
- skullone 3y agoAll we had back in my day was our imagination anywars
- wkat4242 3y agoYou didn't have a modem? Even in the 80s there was an animation format called GL (not at all related to OpenGL) for pornographic animations. Which were pretty repetitive and basic but they served the purpose. Also pay TV channels at the time were full of porn and pretty easy to crack for a horny tech teenager. And if "your day" was even further back the 60s and 70s were pretty wild with actual in person sex (tbh I wish society hadn't reverted back to prudeness from that but luckily there's plenty of communities that aren't) Ps banning porn is pretty severe IMO.
- steve_taylor 3y ago“reverting back to prudeness” is a matter of perspective. We’re a species that has domesticated itself for its collective good. Part of making progress towards that was changing our approach to mating from a free-for-all to something strictly regulated by culture. It could be said that we’ve been reverting back to our pre-civilisation free-for-all for the last 60+ years.
- wkat4242 3y agoI don't really care about our species. More about self discovery without artificial social taboos. Mating was so regulated by culture (mostly religion though) due to the obvious link to the procreation thing, but these days those are no longer coupled so the taboos aren't necessary.
- kelipso 3y ago> I don't really care about our species. People would be smart to ignore you then.
- wkat4242 3y agoThat's fine, our species is still growing by the billions so enough people are taking care of that. They don't seem to take care of leaving the planet habitable though, which is IMO a much more urgent problem than any perceived social decline.
- SpaghettiCthulu 3y agoIt sounds like you need to discover something bigger than yourself.
- wkat4242 3y agoI like discovering other communities but not our species as a whole. In fact it makes me pretty depressed reading the news lol. We're not very good at looking after ourselves or the planet.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- otabdeveloper4 3y ago> artificial social taboos Like consent? The "I do" in the marriage isn't a romantic gesture, it's a legally binding contract for consent to sexual relations. Society has accidentally rediscovered that marriage is the only way to have sex that isn't technically rape.
- wkat4242 3y ago> Society has accidentally rediscovered that marriage is the only way to have sex that isn't technically rape. Ehhh no. Simply asking for an explicit yes is fine here too by law. Of course taking into account that this can be revoked at any time and must be obeyed. And even within marriage it's not legal to force someone to have sex. At least here in Spain it's much more about spending ones life together, shared ownership and parenthood etc than about sex. Of course you wouldn't marry someone you don't ever want to have sex with but it doesn't mean you are obliged to do so. Marital rape is unfortunately a thing. On the other hand, open marriages are also a thing. I often engage in sexual practices with married people with the spouse even present (and often active with someone else). It's not rape :). Just harmless and fully consensual fun. Consent is actually a huge thing in the more promiscuous communities these days. Often people even make contracts (though this is more common in BDSM than in the Swinger community)
- 1over137 3y agoMaybe not only prudeness, but the rise of STDs like AIDS.
- wkat4242 3y agoI doubt it. Condoms are a pretty great solution for that.
- aodonnell2536 3y agoConsidering AIDS wasn’t around yet at that time, I’m pretty certain that the rate of AIDS had increased drastically since then
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoPrudeness? You have no idea what you're talking about. This accusation of "prudeness" is precisely the kind of insult predatory men hurled at women during the '60s and '70s to try to coerce women into bed. "What are you, a prude? A square?" It is actually libertinism that has bred the widespread sexual dysfunction that we are seeing. Pornography is utterly deranging, and in such an insidious way, the poor schmuck doesn't even know how damaged and warped he's become, how enslaved. Its production and distribution at the very least should be criminalized, and taboos that shame and stigmatize its consumption should be revived and promoted in the media. Alas, corrupt governments back pornography because of its utility in controlling the populace.
- wkat4242 3y ago> Prudeness? You have no idea what you're talking about. This accusation of "prudeness" is precisely the kind of insult predatory men hurled at women during the '60s and '70s to try to coerce women into bed. "What are you, a prude? A square?" It is actually libertinism that has bred the widespread sexual dysfunction that we are seeing. We can have a consent culture and healthy and open sex lives. For example swinger clubs and polyamory are becoming more common again despite explicit consent being totally normal these days. But the other side society of seems to frown more and more on such things. And I'm not accusing an individual of anything. Just describing society as a whole. In particular people are becoming more and more concerned about what other adults consensually do in the bedroom again. Even though it's none of their business. Like transphobia, homophobia, porn.. 10 years ago people wouldn't pass judgment on those things. > Alas, corrupt governments back pornography because of its utility in controlling the populace. So instead of this you advocate... controlling the populace using legal, media and social pressure?: > Its production and distribution at the very least should be criminalized, and taboos that shame and stigmatize its consumption should be revived and promoted in the media. I'm sure you know that telling people what to think isn't going to work.
- quickthrower2 3y agoRelevant comedy skit. NSFW and shared history (but not explicit/porn): https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UArQNEqZjAY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UArQNEqZjAY
- Waterluvian 3y agoFree speech is just the best thing ever.
- quickthrower2 3y agoAlways defend free speech!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 698969 3y ago(read: all the popular ones at the time)
- rvz 3y agoRecurring fines in the hundreds of millions is much more better than an absolute ban. The regulators get millions out of repeat offenders until TikTok caves and complies with the demands of the regulators. Win for regulators, Win for users and Tiktok can still operate as long as it follows the rules.
- vasdae 3y ago>Win for regulators, Win for users That's assuming that citizens want censorship. Most of the time citizens do not have the same goals as the state's censors.
- uoaei 3y agoPersonal interests extend far beyond personal desires. We cannot impose Western interpretations of "win" via libertarian interpretations on Nepalese society and culture.
- coffeesque 3y agoIt's a win for them because they're better off not being users in the first place
- vasdae 3y agoThat is something for them to decide, not the state.
- bee_rider 3y agoIt doesn’t necessarily assume citizens want censorship. They might not want it, but they might be better with it.
- proxiful-wash 3y ago[flagged]
- swatcoder 3y agoImagine if a regional power with a territorial dispute with your country had opportunity to individually and untraceably curate exactly what your next generation watches for hours each day on their phone. Nepal can’t necessarily know if that’s happening with but they have to consider that it might be. If that’s a concern in allowing TikTok, fines wouldn’t address the problem very well since money isn’t hard to come by if it buys enough value.
- proxiful-wash 3y ago[flagged]
- ironmagma 3y agoOn the one hand, I agree Tiktok is an abomination that shouldn't be used. On the other hand, there shouldn't even be such a thing as "banning an app."
- hsbauauvhabzb 3y agoWhat if we get to a point where an apps ability to manipulate minds impacts society even more deeply? Think heroin level addiction but in app form..
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- aaomidi 3y agoMy conspiracy is that the US is worried about TikTok because it’s actively been pushing younger folk to the left. It has been a huge awakening to folks to learn and hear about topics that their education system has failed them on. I’ve noticed a general awareness increase of western atrocities of the past century amongst folk. Note this is just my feelings on this and I don’t have the data to back this up (tldr source: I made it up)
- atleastoptimal 3y agoPersonal anecdote but my girlfriend has been pushed to the right due to her TikTok habits. At least what is considered the "right" in the US.
- ceejayoz 3y agoIt may be to China's benefit to encourage moves in both directions.
- makingstuffs 3y agoDivision is everything. It is immeasurably more difficult to control and manipulate a unified mass than it is to manipulate multiple different fragments of said mass. This applies to pretty much everything from flat-pack furniture to society.
- ketzo 3y agoIt is psy-op 101 to push people to any extreme you can; left, right, up, down, doesn’t matter as long as they’re mad as fuck.
- _huayra_ 3y agoIt's pretty telling how effective China thinks it is, given their restrictions on Douyin ("internal Chinese TikTok"). iirc kids can only use it for <1 hour / day.
- hwillis 3y ago
- dukeofdoom 3y agoI don't really have an opinion on TikTok, but maybe more on the social harmony part. But just an observation as I'm getting older. Restricting your choices in life, can often lead to good outcomes. Like what you eat, drink, who you socialize with, what you watch, who you sleep with, what you read...it's a long list. Choice is great, but can be overwhelming. Not that I'm for minimalism. But I'm guessing Nepal has a religious government...Buddhist? And like many other religions, part of it is restricting the behaviour of the adherents. Which like I mentioned before, is not always bad. If the majority of the country feels this way, why should you push your Western Values on them.
- Waterluvian 3y agoIf there’s a majority who support this then they should just self-regulate and go on their merry way. This is always about imposing one’s beliefs on others. “Social harmony” is intentionally vague. Everyone will imagine their own meaning of that and be inclined to think, “yeah that’s something I’m on board with.”
- rayiner 3y agoThat’s just libertarianism applied to social issues, and has the same problems as libertarianism as applied to economic issues. People need social support to help them understand what decisions are good, and make good decisions. How many overweight and obese doctors and nurses are there? They’re only slightly healthier than the general population: https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/healthcare/why-don-t-doctors-and-nurses-have-more-healthy-lifestyles https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/healthcare/why-don-t-doctor.... Smart, educated Americans can’t force themselves to limit their eating. But in say east Asia, extensive social shaming over weight helps people stay slim. Humans didn’t evolve to be libertarian sovereign individuals. They’re members of communities and their welfare can be increased by allowing community reinforcement of good behaviors and decisions.
- Waterluvian 3y agoI dunno… I apply this sentiment to Christian Republicanism and it concerns me greatly. They also have a lot to say about what disrupts social harmony. And of course, it’s what they’ve decided “social harmony” means to them.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago""The government has decided to ban TikTok as it was necessary to regulate the use of the social media platform that was disrupting social harmony, goodwill and flow of indecent materials," Saud said." TikTok "was disrupting ... flow of indecent materials".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- toasted-subs 3y ago[flagged]
- zeroCalories 3y ago[flagged]
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago[flagged]
- enva2712 3y agoI parsed as though there was a semicolon after goodwill - (disrupting …) and (flow of indecent materials) rather than disrupting flow of indecent materials
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- boomboomsubban 3y agoMeanwhile nearly half of Nepal's population is on Facebook, something I'm sure happened completely organically and there's no chance Facebook influenced this decision at all.
- addicted 3y agoThe U.S. government hasn’t loaned Nepal tons of money to build an airport using Chinese companies and labor that will likely never be used and will almost certainly not pay itself off and was significantly overpriced to begin with putting Nepal in severe debt to China and is currently under investigation by the anti-corruption unit of the Nepalese government, as one simple example of why they might be more suspicious of a Chinese company rather than an American one.
- boomboomsubban 3y agoOn top of the decades of money and labor given by the US government, >The U.S. government hasn’t loaned Nepal tons of money to build an airport using Chinese companies and labor The US government has done that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gautam_Buddha_Airport https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gautam_Buddha_Airport
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoIs the US encroaching on Nepal's border? https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-60288007 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-60288007 If China can ban foreign apps for "social harmony", then Nepal can do so too.
- ilkke 3y agoAfter reading the article, all that can eventually be concluded is that China is establishing a tighter control over the hitherto very loose border, and that exactly where the border is remains unclear even to people living close to it. But the narrative structure of the article - of a leaked government document (!) about Chinese buildings on Nepalese sure of the border (!!) which China denies (!!!) and Nepal sends military to investigate (!!!!) only to find there aren't any (oh) - is an insult to journalism. Maybe I'm naive but I feel BBC used to have higher standards. As for Nepal banning TikTok, good for them!
- yalogin 3y agoSo they should ban instagram too. I have a feeling tiktok is probably more moderated and enforces stricter content rules than instagram. Of course may be tiktok is just more popular and so has the target on it.
- karaterobot 3y ago> So they should ban instagram too. A great start!
- TerrifiedMouse 3y agoInstagram doesn’t have an algorithmic feed that introduce you to content - not that I know of. You pretty much only see instagram content when you visit a specific person’s page and that’s all you will ever see.
- blackoil 3y agoInsta reels and YouTube shorts are clone of Tiktok with similar feed/algo and content.
- theshrike79 3y agoEven Facebook has that vertical short video shit now spread among the other content.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoFacebook and Instagram "short video shit" is at least partially overlapping. This incidentally creates a quite grating user experience.
- syfari 3y agoInstagram does for reels and you occasionally get related pages popping up in your feed.
- 3y ago
- blackoil 3y agoWhile Chinese methods may seem draconian. I think they are only what will work. A mandatef OS+app level limit on time spent on social media, particularly for children. Parents are unable to regulate it and self-regulation of addictions is impractical.
- urig 3y agoAre they doing anything about YouTube Shorts?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- imp0cat 3y agoIs anyone actually watching YouTube Shorts? I mean, not accidentaly clicking one thinking it's a regular video, but deliberately watching them?
- consp 3y agoI installed an extension blocking them. It's VVS[1] on steroids and annoying. [1] https://nl.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verticaal_Video_Syndroom https://nl.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verticaal_Video_Syndroom
- expertentipp 3y agoFunny how panoramic/horizontal arms race between film producers and TV producers calmed overnight. I was prepared to ask a snarky question about vertical movies going mainstream but apparently there has been already a relevant festival since 2014.
- k12sosse 3y agoIt's one thing for a video to just be in portrait, but another for a video to be in portrait letterboxed to widescreen..
- expertentipp 3y agoWhat do you think about watching portrait video letterboxed to widescreen on smartphone held vertically?
- hnbad 3y ago
- xyst 3y ago> “flow of indecent materials“ Lmao. I only started using TT again recently. The amount of “thot” content is insane. Only after carefully engaging with interesting topics did its frequency decrease (yes, decrease. Not eliminates). TT algo tries to sneak in a new thot creator every now and then.
- 6stringmerc 3y agoSee I totally get your technique and report on this and thank you. I've done a write up on some free/pay dating apps and the tactics are definitely there. Like this is a community that knows what's up and still kinda skates around it.
- aembleton 3y agoWhat's thot?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- consp 3y agohttps://knowyourmeme.com/memes/thot https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/thot should give you some insight.
- graftak 3y agoPeople promoting their onlyfans content with suggestive videos.
- Biganon 3y agoAn ancient Egyptian deity, and (unrelatedly) a misogynistic term to describe a woman who has the audacity to be sexually active
- hyperdunc 3y agoNo, it's a woman who uses her sexual allure to attract and extract money from lonely boys.
- 6stringmerc 3y agoI've met more than a dozen native Nepalese men and women here in Texas. I've learned lots of names. My closest friend, N, gave me prayer beads to help me keep my path toward healing. To look at Nepal as an outsider is like dropping a senior citizen lifer from Pittsburgh into McAllen Texas and telling them good luck. In a lot of regards, if Nepal is considering a different tactic, somewhat like the French do versus the US "break shit & profit & then go to therapy or take pills" approach...well, honestly... Texas to Bosnia to Nepal is my 2024 tour plan because I'm kinda over this shit a little here.
- domatic1 3y agoThey should ban alcohol too then
- Aerbil313 3y agoWe muslims do (for muslims not non-muslims), and also advocate for a ban on such addictive and life-wasting technologies like TikTok in our countries. And guess what, it worked for millenia and still works to a great extent, even when there is no longer a ban in law in many so-called 'muslim' countries. Unlike the American Prohibition which didn't.
- yorwba 3y agoTo close the circle back to Nepal: the Nepali liquor raksi etymologically derives from the Arabic liquor araq https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E0%A4%B0%E0%A4%95%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%B8%E0%A5%80#Nepali https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E0%A4%B0%E0%A4%95%E0%A5%8D%E... which spread far and wide in tandem with the expansion of Islam.
- smusamashah 3y agoIn Turkey there is no ban on drinking. They eat halal meat but still drink freely. And do you have any examples of Muslim countries that advocate ban on addictive life wasting tech? It is such a broad term.
- levanten 3y agoUnless you come from a very religious background, many Turks don't care if their meat is halal or not.
- mda 3y agoKinda. Note that in most cases even the least religious would not eat pork, which is strictly prohibited. For others, definition of Halal is a bit vague, e.g. Kosher is considered halal by most.
- 3y ago
- lazyeye 3y agoIve never understood why TikTok is allowed to run their app in the West whilst China blocks all foreign apps within its own borders. How is this not a simple trade issue?
- TotoHorner 3y agoThe user-base on TikTok (in the US at least) leans extremely left (because they're all young) so the news media has idiotically made this a left vs. right issue. Yes, any neutral observer can see that it's incredibly foolish to let a company with strong connections to our largest geopolitical rival have control over 1-2 hours of attention (every day) of young people in the US. We literally have no idea if TikTok is boosting certain political/social values amongst American youth. Even a slight nudge could have a huge effects (because of the scale at which TikTok operates) and it would be impossible to detect. The idea that there's some "iron wall" between US and Chinese data has already been proven false. US user data has repeatedly been accessed from china - https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/emilybakerwhite/tiktok-tapes-us-user-data-china-bytedance-access https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/emilybakerwhite/tiktok-.... "I feel like with these tools, there’s some backdoor to access user data in almost all of them,” said an external auditor hired to help TikTok close off Chinese access to sensitive information, like Americans’ birthdays and phone numbers."
- jowea 3y agoGood question now that I think about it. I guess because it was not a real issue until now because there was no Chinese app popular outside its borders? And the whole app/internet economy is still somewhat new compared to the speed at which international trade law gets written I guess, so there are no established rules. The EU has just started enforcing their opinion on it with some recent laws, and the US started doing something about TikTok under Trump.
- pjc50 3y agoThe West was trying to get China to open its markets, which required opening ours first and reciprocally. Because we can't just force them to buy opium at gunpoint any more.
- HeartStrings 3y ago[flagged]
- cultureswitch 3y agoI'm not against a TikTok ban. It is essentially a slot machine. And it is explicitly designed like one. My problem with this is that it is this design which should be illegal, not one app or another. Instagram and Facebook feeds aren't any better than TikTok.
- dan-robertson 3y agoWhat does ‘better’ mean here? Eg TikTok is better at personalising recommendations where facebook tends to give more generic content, so TikTok may better give people what they want but also be more addictive/have a stronger filter-bubble effect.
- andai 3y agoThere's one TikTok for me, and one TikTok for thee. The Chinese version promotes educational videos, and has a strict daily time limit. The "export" version is literally designed to make you retarded. Agree that other apps aren't much better though (especially now that they've redesigned themselves after TikTok's model...)
- wruza 3y agoWhy banning it then? Don’t US/EU have power to force educational content and time limits? This “oh, all feeds are bad, we should think of maybe banning them all” will lead nowhere 100% of times. Feels like China absolutely doesn’t even have to do anything bad because the US don’t know what they want.
- edgyquant 3y ago>why banning it then? Because it’s the most logical thing to do and not doing so is a national security nightmare
- mistermann 3y ago> The "export" version is literally designed to make you retarded. Then why does it have so much philosophy content that can reveal the naivete of the many comments like this one reads about "TikTok"?
- alephnerd 3y agoThe reason TikTok was banned in Nepal was due to the ongoing communal violence between Hindus and Muslims [0][1]. It's gotten pretty bad - the videos I've seen are very similar to those I saw of Gujarat 2002. It's also election season in India, so there will be massive blowback in Nepal, as several provinces in Nepal are ethnically the same as Uttar Pradesh and Bihar - two major swing states in Indian elections. The last time a similarly divisive election happened in Bihar, Nepal ended up getting blockaded [2] [0] - https://apnews.com/article/nepal-lockdown-nepalgunj-hindu-muslim-protests-67d33b313237d757ad8e5fb7f21ec81e https://apnews.com/article/nepal-lockdown-nepalgunj-hindu-mu... [1] - https://www.thehindu.com/news/international/nepal-town-imposes-lockdown-and-beefs-up-security-to-prevent-clashes-between-hindus-and-muslims/article67380662.ece https://www.thehindu.com/news/international/nepal-town-impos... [2] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_Nepal_blockade https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_Nepal_blockade
- bipop5000 3y agoThis is completely not true. There were small skirmishes between Hindu and Muslims on small city in the western part of Nepal but there is no communal violence as you think there is. Nepal arbitrarily bans things without any due diligence, well because we have inept leaders.
- alephnerd 3y agoFair, but the implications and chances of a communal flair up are high after what happened to the Nepali migrant workers in Israel. I'm sure the Nepali Govt doesn't want a repeat of 2004. Mix that with the rise of Hindutva, a bad economy, and divisive discourse across the border for the 2024 elections and things can probably get ugly if precautions aren't taken. Shutting down TikTok is a small price to pay to prevent actual communal violence.
- bipop5000 3y agoHinduvta does not exist as a driving political force in Nepal. You are thinking of India. Nepal is secular albeit there is a small faction vying for power based on hindu ideologies but they are a very small portion of nepal politics. Again there is no communal flair that has entered into national discourse like we see in India or some ME countries. Nepal is pretty chill in that regards, surprisingly so given the whole country has multitudes of ethnic groups. There are still caste based incidents in remote areas but not so much in urban cores. Knowing the decisions the nincompoop leaders have done out of whim over the last decade or so I am fairly certain that this decision was also not done with due dilligence.
- luzojeda 3y agoWhy do threads about TikTok _always_ have posts with whataboutism regarding Instagram and other social network apps? It's a pattern I started noticing.
- wccrawford 3y agoBecause Tiktok is also a social network app, and they all have a lot of the same problems, if not all the same problems? Why wouldn't you talk about 1 thing being banned but not other things like it?
- osrec 3y agoSeems to be justified whataboutism though... The same content exists on almost any platform, yet only one is banned.
- mistermann 3y agoA similarly interesting question: why do so many humans find "Whataboutism" so persuasive, yet worship science for it's attention to detail?
- schmudde 3y agoThe context of China destroying Tibet should not be overlooked here. Nepal shares much with Tibet culturally. Perhaps China isn't an immediate threat to their sovereignty, but it's certainly an existential threat.
- curiousgal 3y agoI genuinely don't understand the obsession with China.
- huytersd 3y agoYou should, it’s a country trying to normalize authoritarian governments.
- curiousgal 3y agoAs opposed to the countries spreading democracy? How's that worked out so far? Better yet, who's got more blood on their hands?
- huytersd 3y agoPretty well? The world has statistically never been safer, more educated, richer and more connected.
- curiousgal 3y agoTell that the kids who lost their parents because democracy was delivered to their neighbour's wedding.
- hackerlight 3y agoNepal is a small country bordering on a behemoth (China) that has a fairly authoritarian autocratic government that is asserting itself in multiple territorial disputes with other neighbors. It's wedged between India and China. It is correct for Nepal to have geopolitical concerns about the future. Nepal is the kind of landlocked country (e.g. Poland or Ukraine in Europe) that tends to become the unwitting victims.
- lobocinza 3y agoThere's a reason why TikTok is banned in its parent country.
- Sorek 3y agoNo, its not actually banned there. Its just called with different name there and they have different kind of rules. Rules what makes it more harmless for brains. For example concent in Douyin is more educative etc.
- kuchenbecker 3y agoThe presumption that information warps minds consistently leads to free speech restrictions. My perspective you need to proove harm, then proving Tiktok caused the harm, and showing banning is the only remedy. I'm not sure even sure Tiktok causes harm, let alone more harm than other social media.
- lobocinza 3y agoThis is misinformation. TikTok is banned on China as you can't access it there. Douyin may share the same software but it isn't TikTok. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_of_TikTok https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_of_TikTok
- pRm0638206954 3y agoรถราการทำความเข้า
- huytersd 3y agoThat’s Thai bud. Based on the South Indian Tamil script. It doesn’t have much to do with Nepal.
- kypro 3y agoI was talking to my girlfriend about the concept of banning things deemed harmful last night. The conversation started around whether it's a good idea to ban people doing things that are dangerous to themselves (like smoking and drinking), but obviously it's hard to have that conversation without also considering broader societal consequences. Something I've noticed in recent years is how out of touch I am about the harms people claim are caused to them by social media. For example, I find Twitter to be an amazing source of real-time information and a place I can discuss practically any topic with experts in that field. I don't post on there but I have TikTok on my phone and I find it quite a fun app to use to pass the time when I have nothing else to do. I think because of my viewing habits I tend to get fairly interesting DIY, tech and political content show up which can sometimes teach me something I didn't know. Sometimes the content is lacking depth, but it's certainly not a negative experience. The same is true of me and alcohol or smoking. I don't drink or smoke. I actually had my first drink in about 3 years the other day, but it was something I wanted to do to maximise my enjoyment of the situation. Similarly, I have smoked a few times in my life, but it's only ever been a positive experience given the context. I think what troubles me when I speak to people about these topics is that most people feel they're victims of social media and other potentially harmful things like smoking and alcohol and therefore support bans. Obviously I can't deny these things can and do have negative impacts on individuals and societies, but I'd question whether they are the root cause. There seems to be a larger issue here around people lacking self-control and self-awareness, therefore wanting the government to impose the self-control they lack on them. And I think this problem is getting worse just observing how teens today use social media. I'm saying this because I think TikTok could be a positive force in society, but it's not because a large number of people today are incapable of self-control. And this is a problem because if the root issue isn't TikTok but our own self-control then we'll need to demand our government take ever more control over our lives to protect us from ourselves. For example if the government doesn't regulate my use of Twitter or out right ban me using it then I might develop an addiction to it and anxiety. If the government doesn't stop me from smoking then it's possible I might smoke a pack a day for the next decade then go on to develop lung cancer. If the government doesn't ban me from drinking sugary drinks then I might drink a can of Coca-Cola. I've flippantly joked about it before, but I do think if we can't address this underlying issue of self-control we will have to extend these bans further and further to places which seem absurd today. For example, hard to argue someone watching TikTok every day is more harmful than someone eating at McDonalds every day. Given the harms of fast food I think you could make a far stronger argument against it's legality than TikTok. I understand I'm expressing an unpopular opinion here. I'm also not saying there's nothing we can do to reduce the likelihood that people will develop harmful behaviours. For example, I wouldn't necessarily be against reasonable restrictions on social media for children. It's really this idea that adults can't choose to do things which could be harmful to themselves that I find hard to understand.
- Eumenes 3y agoI'd be supportive of this with all social media
- huytersd 3y agoSeriously, burn it all. Nothing good has come out of any of it.
- fsflover 3y agoEven with HN and Mastodon?
- _Algernon_ 3y agoHN isn't social media. There is no social graph. HN is a web forum.
- cramjabsyn 3y agoOne angle of these bans is that TikTok provides rapid person to person sharing of information via rich multimedia, and live streaming of events. Its harder to control a narrative and spread propaganda when people can see that others around the world are just like them, talk to them directly, and hear their stories. The idea that China uses TikTok to control other countries I think is backwards. The platform actually enables significant info sharing between normal people, and we’re seeing this for example in the conflict in Gaza. “Social Harmony” aka our ability to influence popular opinion
- cdot2 3y agoOther social media platforms also provide that ability. I suspect the reason has more to do with TikTok's specific algorithm advancing divisive or otherwise controversial content more than other systems.
- cramjabsyn 3y agoIt advances content by interest/topic as opposed to intentional divisiveness, follows or otherwise. You see more of what you watch. There isn't another platform today that connects you as rapidly to people with shared interests. IG is trying with feeds
- cdot2 3y ago"It advances content by interest/topic as opposed to intentional divisiveness..." Isn't this presuming some insight into their algorithms that we don't have?
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- tamimio 3y agoWhen they ban tiktok but keep other social medias, tell you that someone wants to keep the audience watching the same narrative, on TV or the internet. You might argue that TikTok has a narrative or not, but sure it isn’t controlled by the same entity that controls other social media.