11 ms·
YouTube's plan backfires, people are installing better ad blockers
- Madmallard 3y agoCan’t they force you to inject ads into the video feed? Or is that in some way illegal
- timbit42 3y agoThere are already ways around that such as SponsorBlock.
- Madmallard 3y agoIf they match the bitrate and such of the source video and make it seemless how would that be reliably detectable?
- asadotzler 3y agoCommunities come together to mark video segments, possibly aided by AI which looks for and identifies significant changes in production that suggest injected ads.
- g-b-r 3y agoNewpipe, a YouTube-like website :facepalm: (I can't believe no one made a remark about that yet)
- bee_rider 3y agoI worry that the arms race will continue, and eventually Google will activate the nuclear option: ban somebody’s google account for ad blocking on YouTube. It just doesn’t seem worth it. Youtube mostly hosts bottom of the barrel garbage anyway. Why stick around?
- gwnywg 3y agoI was reading here posts of people who lost their google account (can't remember url) and when I have first seen it I moved everything away from google and from other huge email providers- I don't want to live in world where I have to be affraid of loosing something for using a browser plugin...
- rcMgD2BwE72F 3y agoI don't access Youtube with a Google account so I wouldn't be impacted. I'd actually like that move actually, as it would certainly foster some alternatives to Youtube (e.g PeerTube), as most owners post their content on Youtube only because it's just free and the most popular video website.
- eur0pa 3y agoLike clockwork, each time an article like this one is published, individuals emerge to pressure others into watching advertisements with remarks like "poor trillion dollar corporation," label them as "entitled" for not wanting to invest time in continuous ads (bearing in mind that time only moves forward and can't be reclaimed), or assert that paying for a premium subscription is not a significant expense. It could be $1 for all I care. Let us commence from the beginning. Perhaps not all of Hacker News' user base came online when the internet was still characterized by freedom and openness, and "content" was created to share information, whether accurate or not, or simply for entertainment. This state of affairs persisted for a few years during YouTube's early days, but the situation began to deteriorate around 2010. From 1997 to 2009, one could argue that the internet was, to a large extent, a tolerable place to be. The aggressive monetization and profiling tactics pursued by the mega-corporations that have tightly gripped the internet, driven by the unrelenting pursuit of endless year-over-year growth, have turned the internet into a breeding ground for scams and content designed to evoke manipulable emotional responses such as anger, sadness, and regret. I am unwavering in my refusal to tolerate advertisements, whether in videos, music, or on websites, regardless of how vigorously these companies or their supporters attempt to persuade people to sink more of their time passively being bombarded with ads. Even engaging in debates with these individuals serves their purpose because, like Jehovah's Witnesses, their objective is to shift the argument and move the goalposts until they can declare victory, or gain the moral high ground defending the trillion-dollar corp. For me, YouTube is a pastime, not a profession or a job. If beer money can be derived from it, that's wonderful. Nowadays, most YouTubers feature videos with non-skippable ads inserted by Google, run Patreon campaigns for direct support, sell merchandise, and include sponsored segments within their videos. I only realized the extent of this when I used SponsorBlock for a couple of years, and its API failed a few days ago. Google does not require my financial support, and I have no intention of squandering my valuable time on their unskippable advertising. Nor do I wish to be profiled by them. If they are truly facing financial difficulties, they can reduce their relentless year-on-year growth. A well-established, consistently profitable company can support families without exploiting the user base. I feel no guilt in employing every means at my disposal to counteract their ceaseless efforts to make the internet a less enjoyable place: it's my device, and my rules. The day Google demands payment for its services similar to Netflix, I will simply cease using it altogether. Until then, I remain indifferent to the opinions of internet strangers or corporate advocates who label me as "entitled"—their words hold no sway over me. I will continue to pursue my course of action and assist those who share the same stance. You are free to disable your ad-blockers and subscribe to the premium service if you so choose. I will not, and I will support (to me) worthy content creators on Patreon where applicable. Google shan't see nor earn no money from me. Now, for those who find themselves entangled in this bog and wish to eliminate ads: * Firefox, Chromium etc: µblock origin [0] + SponsorBlock [1] * Safari: Invidious [2] and Piped [3] * iOS (no jailbreak needed): uYouPlus [4], uYouExtra [5], Yattee [6] * Android: ReVanced [7], GrayJay [8] * Android TV / Shield / FireTV / FireStick: SmartTube [9] * webOS (LG TV): dev mode + sideload [10] My own setup: µblock origin on Firefox in Windows, Piped on macOS, uYouPlus on iOS, SmartTube on a FireStick for the LG C2. SponsorBlock is either directly and natively integrated or enabled separately where needed. [0] https://redd.it/17j6ygs https://redd.it/17j6ygs [1] https://sponsor.ajay.app https://sponsor.ajay.app [2] https://api.invidious.io https://api.invidious.io [3] https://github.com/TeamPiped/Piped/wiki/Instances https://github.com/TeamPiped/Piped/wiki/Instances [4] https://github.com/qnblackcat/uYouPlus https://github.com/qnblackcat/uYouPlus [5] https://github.com/arichorn/uYouPlusExtra https://github.com/arichorn/uYouPlusExtra [6] https://github.com/yattee/yattee https://github.com/yattee/yattee [7] https://revanced.app https://revanced.app [8] https://grayjay.app https://grayjay.app [9] https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube [10] https://github.com/webosbrew/dev-manager-desktop https://github.com/webosbrew/dev-manager-desktop
- gwnywg 3y agoI'm Firefox user and I do have adblockers installed, but on youtube I have them disabled since they are threttening to ban users with adblockers. Now I read some people still got banned (even in this thread) and that makes me thinking I'm glad I'm not using youtube much anymore, and moved most of my stuff from google in case their algorithms decide I have to be banned. Regarding ads quality, I have 2 channels I check for new videos every now and then. One of the channels includes their own ads (they sell merch related to their content)- for that reason I don't care much about ads Youtube wants me to see, I have already watched creator's add and I'm actually visiting their online shop to look around for gift ideas. The other channel's videos are mostly demonetized, so I don't watch adds there. The channel runs patreon link so I still have a way to pay for content if I feel it's worth the price..
- pretext 3y agoI wonder why nobody posted it here. LibRedirect: A browser extension that redirects YouTube, Twitter, TikTok... requests to alternative privacy friendly frontends and backends. https://github.com/libredirect/libredirect https://github.com/libredirect/libredirect
- RockRobotRock 3y agoHN: Sustaining yourself with ads is a dying business model! also HN: Of course I won't pay any money, how dare you! Go ahead, try and make it into this crusade to make the internet better. At the end of the day, you're justifying taking money from creators instead of paying (with ads or premium). You make software dev money, grow up.
- kobalsky 3y agodid you just build an imaginary opponent that you could strike down? I use HN and I pay for YT premium so at least part of your assumptions are wrong
- RockRobotRock 3y agoI decided to make my own top level comment instead of arguing with 10 people individually. But you’re right, it was hyperbole.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoI prefer to redistribute the savings I get from ad-blocking(vs premium -Youtube is completely unusable with ads) to smaller creators via patreon. I honestly couldn't care less about the huge youtubers. They're usually quite diversified and tend to also have a good chunk of die hard fans that practically shove money down their throats. They also get paid a lot more for sponsorships. They'll be fine. Smaller creators really need the little ad revenue they get. And they have to work really hard for it too. So I actually do feel bad about blocking ads in those cases, and whenever possible I find other ways to send them some money.
- stubish 3y agoYou forgot 'modern advertising is non-consensual psychological manipulation and should be illegal'. Maybe if we decided to not allow our minds to be polluted for other's profit, the business model would collapse and allow a better one to replace it. One that actually rewarded creators rather than offer a minority table scraps.
- 3y ago
- userinanother 3y agoWhat are you guys currently using that’s most effective and easy to use?
- Daviey 3y agoDuring this debacle I did discover SponsorBlock - https://sponsor.ajay.app/ https://sponsor.ajay.app/ This is different from YouTube platform ad-blocking, instead it is crowd-sourced auto-skip of in-video sponsorship messages etc. Quite configurable, really appreciating it so far.
- dicknuckle 3y agoIt's a killer feature of YouTube Re-Vanced and was also in YouTube Vanced before that was shuttered.
- clouddrover 3y agoInstall a better browser too. Use Firefox. uBlock Origin works best in Firefox: https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-best-on-Firefox https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-b...
- dicknuckle 3y agoAd-nauseum is open source and based on Unlock Origin. It works on both Firefox and Chrome, but not available in the Chrome store so it has to be installed as an unpacked extension. Opera is miles better than vanilla Chrome and Ad-nauseum is available in their webstore as well.
- charcircuit 3y ago>YouTube’s efforts to stop ad blockers could result in more complex blocking tactics. These more complex tactics could lead to the creation of unintentional security holes. Just say that you want to leach from the website and not pay for it. Trying to tell YouTube to not bypass ad blockers because it would make YouTube less secure is pure coping.
- lazycouchpotato 3y agoI have my adblock on for targeted ads. I believe the lengths that these companies go through to profile you to serve you ads are terribly invasive. Even if you pay for YT Premium, the tracking does not stop: https://mastodon.social/@nixCraft/111257004092595145 https://mastodon.social/@nixCraft/111257004092595145 My adblocker is off for DuckDuckGo. DDG does not track my activity across websites. I'm one of the few suckers here paying for YT Premium. This is what I got rewarded with for being a paying customer: https://mastodon.social/@lazycouchpotato/111347456188566575 https://mastodon.social/@lazycouchpotato/111347456188566575 Precious screen real estate ruined with Shorts. They've set themselves into this monopoly position leaving you nowhere else to go, and are dead set on making the experience as terrible as possible to extract every little bit of "engagement" out of you. I don't sympathize with Google for users wanting to use an ad blocker on YT. I'd gladly support YT if any other half-decent company owned it.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI have absolutely no shame in leaching off a company with a 1.62 trillion market cap.
- arcticbull 3y agoHow do you balance that ethically against the content creators who have decidedly smaller market caps? I’m not judging by the way I’m just curious your thought process.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI donate to them directly. Zelle, Venmo, Patreon, whatever can get them fiat.
- gojomo 3y agoWith linear video, there's a hard limit to what user-loyal ad-blocking can achieve with casual in-the-moment browsing: Google can ensure the ad's clock-time duration occurs, before they serve the main video. So, even if you're hiding the video, you're still punished by the wait, as your ad-blocker simulates an ad-watch. So, next-gen ad-circumvention will probably help users queue vids for later watching, after a fake agent pretends to have watched the ads. Or, be full-fledged pirate sites that pre-cache all popular videos for ad-free watching.
- Shorel 3y ago> So, even if you're hiding the video, you're still punished by the wait, as your ad-blocker simulates an ad-watch. I would gladly accept a pause instead of an ad. I needed to stop using the android TV device because of how many ads they were pushing on 10-minute videos. It was too distracting. It just made me stop using YouTube completely on that device. No content is worth so many ads. Nothing. Now I am only using the laptop, where some kind of ad blocker still works.
- grardb 3y agoHave you tried SmartTube? https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube I use it, and while it's less polished than the official YouTube app, the ad blocking definitely works.
- beenBoutIT 3y agoYouTube should offer ad-free videos that have the ad fees paid ahead of time by the account that posted the video. Videos could be made to be ad-free for certain areas, demographics, etc. to maximize viewers as needed. In this way the video effectively becomes the ad and the viewer doesn't have any interest in blocking it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- makeitdouble 3y agoYoutube will already reinject ad rolls after some time span even if you keep a video paused, so full download of selected videos will probably be the way to go.
- explaininjs 3y agoAnyone else see that the embed API seems to get out of Ads scott-free? I was banned from watching videos on youtube.com proper for a bit (they’ve since given up // uBlockOrigin improved), but on my website that embeds arbitrary videos there’s never any ads presented, even with blockers disabled. Honestly it’s a bit of a bummer - I’d like for the original content creators I’m “proxying” to have the potential to be compensated.
- normaldist 3y agoAdvertisers don't like appearing on random webpages.
- explaininjs 3y agoSo is there anything to stop an adblocker from simply redirecting you to a proxy site with an embed?
- pingpongchef 3y agoA significant number of videos are disabled from embedded play
- explaininjs 3y agoPerhaps, but I've yet to encounter one.
- nomilk 3y agoIn addition to better adblockers, I also learned how to use them better. For example, to update ublock origin's filter lists (which I now do every few days), click the ublock chrome addon icon (top right) -> cog icon -> 'update'. I also never knew there were sites that give you exactly the same youtube videos, but without ads (and improved privacy). One such site is called 'invidious'. I made a very basic chrome addon that places the invidious link right next to the actual (youtube) link, so now if youtube blocks me, it's only ctrl + click to watch the same video ad-free. https://github.com/stevecondylios/invidious-linker#invidious-linker https://github.com/stevecondylios/invidious-linker#invidious...
- cedws 3y agoClient side ads clearly don't work. It's a matter of time until YouTube DRMs everything or puts the ads in the video stream itself like Twitch.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoIt's funny, people are talking about YouTube, but for me it's the opposite : uMatrix stopped working for YouTube ads years ago, meanwhile I hadn't seen Twitch ads for years. Then coming back to Twitch a few days ago, I started seeing Twitch ads again - I wonder what changed ??
- kjkjadksj 3y agoThen you scrub forward like tivo
- prirun 3y agoBut they can't send me different ads than you if they put the ads in the video stream, ie, it'll screw up their targeting I think.
- phantomathkg 3y agoDynamic ad insertion means that the ad will be stitch to the video dynamically. For the same piece of content you and I request, the ad being shown to you and me could be drastically different. Google IMA SDK can do that. https://support.google.com/admanager/answer/6147120?hl=en https://support.google.com/admanager/answer/6147120?hl=en
- cedws 3y agoVideo stream doesn't have to be static.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoOn Twitch it still blocks the ads, you just have to wait until they finish streaming. Waiting beats being mind raped by ads so it's still a great experience.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago"If you're looking alternatives, extensions like uBlock Origin still work when used on Firefox. There's also the option of biting the bullet and paying for YouTube Premium." Let's see. (a) Use Firefox when watching YouTube or (b) pay money to the company that is the source of the problem, in order to keep using a browser they designed to support surveilance advertising services, where the terms allow the company to keep collecting data about you. Difficult choice.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoWhat the hell is a "creator economy". A website full of so-called content that the website operator did not produce, which for the website operator, a trillion dollar advertising company, serves one purpose: as bait for ad targets. Would this be an example of YouTube "creators" https://www.wired.com/story/youtube-obituary-pirates/ https://www.wired.com/story/youtube-obituary-pirates/
- xNeil 3y ago(c) pay money to the company that spends extraordinary amounts of money to host and serve you these videos while simultaneously paying creators, carrying the creator economy, helping companies advertise their products and recommending you videos you may like, while giving you the ability to watch these video from any browser of your choice.
- leereeves 3y agoThey spent extraordinary amounts of money to capture the market and drive competitors out of business. It's called predatory pricing and it should be punished, not rewarded.
- lolinder 3y ago(d) pay for Nebula, which is run by creators for creators, and get ad-free content (including sponsorships removed from the videos) while simultaneously supporting the development of smaller YouTube alternatives rather than feeding the beast.
- woutr_be 3y agoI’ve been using YouTube way less since they did this. I watch YouTube on 3 devices; iPhone, iPad and my desktop. On two of those I’m already forced to watch ads, and I accepted it. Now besides the ads content creators already put in their videos, I’m also being forced to watch at least 4 ads in a 10 minute video. I get that they’re not going for user experience with the ad milking, but how many people will just give up on YouTube, like me. Or do the forced ads just make up for the people leaving?
- realprimoh 3y agoLess people is fine. People who watch for free (with ad blockers) technically cost more than if they just leave. I guarantee most people will either shell out for YT premium or just keep watching with the ads. People who watch ads > people who pay for YT premium > people who don’t use YouTube > people who use adblockers on YouTube.
- tmtvl 3y agoFewer people is only fine if they watch for free with ad blockers. If people who don't use ad blockers start leaving because of proliferation of ads then problems will arise.
- j283736551538 3y agoI've also dropped Youtube (for now!). This experience has been the single most effective mechanism I've encountered for preventing my occasional late night, low energy YouTube doom scrolling.
- pb7 3y agoWhat difference does it make if you stay or leave? You never contributed any revenue anyway. That’s the whole point.
- woutr_be 3y agoDoes YouTube not make money of all the ads I watched?
- Slow_Hand 3y agoAnecdotally, I was hit by the Youtube clampdown on Ad-Blockers and it worked. I couldn't watch without disabling my blockers. My workaround strategy then became to open the link I wanted to view in a private (Firefox) window where I wasn't logged in to my Youtube account. It was inconvenient, but it did the trick for my needs. Now, in the last five days, I am no longer being stopped by Youtube's message when clicking on videos. As if the entire initiative has gone away. Has anyone else experienced this turn of events? One theory is that one or several of my ad-blockers (Ghostery, UBlock Origin, Enhancer) have since implemented a workaround that defeats Google, but I have yet to do any serious tests.
- aantix 3y agoWhat about using a proxy, and rewriting the YouTube api response as a means of an ad blocker? Zero second ad clips. Is anyone trying this approach?
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoDetail more how you think it could work.
- aantix 3y agoJust attempted to look at the YouTube ssl api requests using Charles proxy. Looks like their app uses certificate pinning, so this approach won’t work.
- gnicholas 3y agoIn another HN thread, someone said that the playback speed for the ads is the same as for the videos. This makes it seem like an easy workaround (for now) is to use an extension that allows arbitrarily fast playback. When an ad appears, hit the 'increase speed' button half a dozen times, and it'll be over in a few seconds. Of course, this may end up being a game of cat and mouse, but it might be uncommon enough for YT to never end up blocking it.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoDoes uBlock Origin bypass YouTube Anti-Adblock? This website will tell you. https://drhyperion451.github.io/does-uBO-bypass-yt/ https://drhyperion451.github.io/does-uBO-bypass-yt/
- O1111OOO 3y ago> Does uBlock Origin bypass YouTube Anti-Adblock? This website will tell you. > https://drhyperion451.github.io/does-uBO-bypass-yt/ https://drhyperion451.github.io/does-uBO-bypass-yt/ I don't know what it is about this link that I love so much but thanks for sharing. Have been a uBlock Origin user for many, many years. While I wouldn't want a dashboard (of sorts) for all my extensions, I am thrilled to have one for this one vital piece of software.
- tracerbulletx 3y agoDoes anyone write articles that aren't just to serve a pre-existing bias anymore? You can't make the claim in the title without knowing the impact on Ad revenue at YouTube, some shuffling of installs of adblockers doesn't mean it's backfired. It's entirely likely YouTube considers it a huge success but people just write whatever they want. The same thing happened with Netflixes ad tier and password sharing mitigations, if you just read the articles you'd think the whole world cancelled their accounts! Score one for the little guy. But it's obvious from their earnings reports it's been a success.
- verisimi 3y ago> Does anyone write articles that aren't just to serve a pre-existing bias anymore? There never were articles that were free from bias. It's just that the bias is now overt to you.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoThose are slightly different questions. One of the stories about Theranos is that a journalist was detailed once to go talk to some happy customers and write a story about how great Theranos was. So she arrived, and she saw people waiting in line, and she said what she was there to do, and everyone waited around for a while, and then someone pulled the fire alarm and everybody left. No story. I saw a conversation about this on HN back when Theranos was a current scandal, in which one person asked "well, isn't it suspicious that you arrive to do your puff piece, and everyone eyes each other nervously, and then there's an unscheduled fire alarm? Couldn't that have supported more investigation?" and the answer was "no, 'suspicious doings at shady company' is a different type of story from 'heroic company brings medicine to happy patients', and if you're assigned to write one of those stories you can't write the other one instead." I don't know to what degree that last claim is true, and it seems like it'd be different at different outlets. But it's a good illustration of the difference between "article was written with a bias" and "purpose of writing the article was to serve a bias".
- verisimi 3y ago
- otteromkram 3y agoI don't get why people are so against ads. How else should creators of content you enjoy get paid? Should users be forced to watch at least one ad per YouTube session for "subscribed" content and make watching an ad optional for other content?
- blarg1 3y agoBecause some ads are really irritating with loud music and annoying voices, advertising things I have no use for. And they keep playing me the same 2-3 ads over and over. If they would just advertise things I was interested in, and skip/block the ones I'm not, then I would watch them.
- lightedman 3y agoI would assume you don't know about the days of drive-by advertising malware, and the fact it came from ANY type of media. Animated .gifs, video streams, vulnerable .mp3 files, javascript injection, and worse. Ad blocking is basic security on the internet. It is literally security 101.
- lolinder 3y agoNearly every creator who makes money on YouTube these days takes sponsorships, which I don't mind at all. Sponsorship segments have no tracking, are very skippable, and some creators make them fun enough to be worth watching in their own right. They're integrated into the video at a logical break point (rather than interrupting at odd times), and the creator can choose to avoid a sponsor that doesn't line up with their values. Similar methods include merch drops, writing a book and selling it through your existing fan base, and having a Patreon that you plug during the video. All of this is preferable to the nightmarish ads that YouTube typically serves and the insane amounts of tracking they use which somehow still manages to completely miss the mark when finding topics that would appeal to me.
- charcircuit 3y ago>Sponsorship segments have no tracking No, the creator gets anonymized stats for their videos of the viewer's demographics. These get shared with brands. In some ways there is less privacy than normal YouTube ads.
- akomtu 3y agoYoutube is like a drug dealer that sells a mix or sugar, opium and poison in 8:1:1 proportion. Sugar is the flashy junk that gives an illusion of fulfillment. Opium is the behavioral tricks that rattle the primitive emotions and desires. The poison is ads - a variety of synthetic substances provided by the dealer's customers; those substances mess with the neural transmitters with the goal of implanting certain images and associations into the brain.
- ta8645 3y agoIn the short term, there will be ways around Youtube's ad technology. But in the not too distant future, it will be painful enough to not really be viable for the vast majority of people. If we truly want a way to reward content creators, and avoid the rent-seeking and privacy disrespecting behavior of Google, a much larger conversation really needs to be had. They enjoy a very strong first mover advantage, coupled with the benefit of almost insurmountable network-effects. There's no obvious answer.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoNot exactly first mover : they bought YouTube (and let Google Video to die).
- ta8645 3y agoI'm not aware of anything they created in-house that was ultimately successful, other than the original search engine. But YouTube does have first mover advantage, even if it wasn't owned by Google at the time.
- asadotzler 3y agoI've noticed the same two or three HN usernames pushing YouTube Premium in several of these discussions now. It's almost like a coordinated effort.