17 ms·
Booking.com makes a fortune – so why is it leaving its bills to hotels unpaid?
- say_it_as_it_is 3y ago[flagged]
- tyingq 3y agoOr perhaps just some group of hotel owners that's tired of not being paid?
- MakeThemMoney 3y agoA multi-billion dollar corporation is withholding payments from smaller businesses. Is that not enough reason to publish such an article?
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoAre you saying that Media does not publish articles unless a multibillion dollar corporation or its multibillion dollar competitor needs one? That sounds newsworthy itself!
- possiblelion 3y agoThe prevalence of PR work means that such direct hit pieces are usually at least nudged by a competitors actions, yes.
- meepmorp 3y agoCui bono is a fine question to ask, but why let booking.com off the hook for stiffing smaller players?
- lawlessone 3y agoDoes everything have to be second guessed? A big rich company not paying their due is stuff most journalists would jump on.
- terminous 3y agoThe "competitors" who would benefit the most from this article are the individual independent hotels who have to eat the cost of stays booked through booking.com and aren't part of a big chain network that has a big enough legal team to be taken seriously.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Nextgrid 3y agoAs a general rule, the reason a company does something nefarious is that it knows it can get away with it. We need to fix the broken & corrupt legal systems so that companies have not just equivalent penalties like individuals would (the equivalent of jail would be that all profits go to the state for the duration of the "jail" term), but be given even less leniency/benefit of the doubt since massive companies have way more resources to investigate & comply with laws than individuals do.
- mouse_ 3y ago"We need to negotiate a better living arrangement with our evil vampire overlords" I'm not convinced
- mschuster91 3y agoOh, the EU shows that even the biggest corporations can be brought to knee if they pull off too much bullshit. Apple had to introduce USB-C and will have to open up their App Store and NFC interface, Meta got slapped with a billion dollar GDPR fine, Microsoft to this day has to sell European versions of Windows that don't come with a media player or that allow everyone to choose their default browser...
- dantheman 3y agoThe EU is just shaking down foreign companies because they can't compete.
- orwin 3y agoThe EU has actually enforce anti-monopolistic laws, even if it's quite slow. You should compare history of the food industry in Europe and in North America, I think this show well how much the US politicians changed over the last 50 years.
- vertis 3y agoThe EU is protecting it's citizens. You don't have to spend very much time comparing the EU (and Europe in general) to the US to find differences in philosophy. US has a very individual centric attitude where everyone is an temporarily inconvenienced millionare and Europe has a much more collective attitude. I will take the European attitude over the US one any day of the week (and I'm from neither, I'm Antipodean). Every billionare is a policy failure.
- unsupp0rted 3y agoI've 2 times out of 2 successfully done credit card chargebacks against Booking.com for their customer support's tomfoolery when their "third party hotels for whose actions we are not responsible" messed with me. You processed my credit card, so now you're gonna deal with my refund too.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- schultzie 3y agoDitto. I stayed at a hotel that had bed bugs, the hotel was uninterested in refunding us or giving us a new room (I had only been in the room shortly before discovering them). I went back to Booking.com and they said I had to be refunded via the hotel and they would only act as arbiters. After showing proof the hotel wouldn't refund me, they continued to not refund. To really add insult to injury I wrote a review of the hotel explaining the situation and it was removed!
- whstl 3y agoAmazing, I had the exact same thing happen to me. They instantly flagged and deleted my review claiming I only stayed one night (I did – in a sleeping bag no less) instead of four. This claim from them actually helped in the chargeback.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- unsupp0rted 3y agoI made the mistake of telling the apart-hotel owner in Turkey I work in IT, so he would knock on my door at 2am and Whatsapp me over and over to help him solve router problems. "It's urgent" "Can I talk to you?" "Can you please come downstairs? Just 2 minutes." (it's 2am) "There is a big problem" (with me not being willing to pay a network tech to deal with my IT problems instead of badgering my guests) No thanks. I had booked a month and left after a week.
- 3y ago
- MilnerRoute 3y agoFrom this article: A Booking.com market manager in south-east Asia admitted at a recent industry event that payment delays were caused by the installation of a new payment system. Staff salaries were also affected, she said, explaining it as a risk they had to take. From an earlier article: In the company’s August results, CFO David Goulden said there were "lower than expected" IT expenses in the second quarter of this year, in part due to phasing IT spend into the third quarter, but did not outline what this IT expense included. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/oct/03/bookingcom-makes-a-fortune-so-why-is-it-leaving-its-bills-to-small-hotels-unpaid https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/oct/03/bookingcom-... Is this all just a fancy way of saying, "They 'restructured' IT and payment problems resulted?"
- 8jef 3y agoI wish someone from the accommodation industry would tell us all how the central booking system and most hotel chains are abusing everyone, from inn and hotel owners to end customers. Their contracts are pure gold, in the sense that they cloak all possibility of independence under a thick cover nothing can pierce through. Tourism, they are killing it, literally.
- gvedem 3y agoWhat do you mean by "central booking system"? As far as I know (working on a rental car contract for a couple years), there are just various travel industry standards for bookings and whatnot.
- CharlieDigital 3y agoIt's called the GDS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_distribution_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_distribution_system It started with airlines, but eventually included everything from hotels to rental cars. The space is more or less dominated by a few big players. Sabre. Amadeus. Travelport. GDS is the backbone of all of these booking platforms as far as I'm aware.
- ramses0 3y agoGDS. A Global Distribution System is a worldwide reservation system that acts as a conduit between travel bookers and suppliers, such as hotels, other accommodation providers and other travel related services.
- 8jef 3y agoI mean there is only one pipeline, to which are contributing many actors, like big agencies (booking, expedia), car rental, airlines, etc. Together, they act as one.
- jwhitlark 3y agoThere are multiple GDSs, and AFAIK neither Expedia nor Booking.com use them. The space is way more confused and competitive then your comment implies. The best writeup I've seen on the space is https://www.altexsoft.com/blog/hotel-api/ https://www.altexsoft.com/blog/hotel-api/, if you really want to dive into the details. Edit: been typing markdown all day, oops.
- croes 3y agoMaybe they make a fortune just because they leave the bills unpaid.
- em-bee 3y agothat was my first thought too ;-)
- codr7 3y agoI'm not touching booking.com again, and I recommend anyone else to stay the hell away. Made a reservation a few months ago, searched for hotel rooms that would allow bringing a dog, and got a confirmation via booking.com that said everything was ok. But when I arrived at the hotel, I was informed that they don't allow dogs at all. And since the reservation was made through booking.com, there was nothing they could do about it. So I ended up paying for a hotel room that no one slept in and have been given the silent treatment from booking.com since then despite several contact attempts.
- ferminaut 3y agoI have to ask, why use 3rd party booking sites at all? From what I can tell, the prices are usually the same as the hotel... needlessly adding middlemen into the booking process.
- LiquidSky 3y agoInertia. You used to be able to get some good deals on those sites, now they're coasting on that reputation.
- Zetobal 3y agoLike with everything... convenience.
- danpalmer 3y agoBecause there are hundreds of hotels with a hundred different websites or no website at all in any given city, and hotel rooms are largely fungible. I want to sleep somewhere and I have a budget. Searching hotel by hotel is infeasible even if you can find them, and you often can't. A "middleman", or search engine, or discovery system, or price comparison site, is worth a lot to me and to most travellers. Edit: it's worth a lot when you... don't speak the language in the country the hotel is in... when you want the consumer protections of the country you or the middleman is based in... these sorts of concerns are much more of an issue in some parts of the world, and this might be reflected in the fact that Booking.com grew up in Europe.
- kbenson 3y agoI've taken to calling hotels directly and dealing with them, or their chain's booking, as they offer the same or better rates usually, are more accountable, are more willing to refund or cancel without problems, and are much more interested in keeping you happy and wanting to come back.
- avgDev 3y agoNot always the case. In Dominican Republic I was told to just use an online booking site as it was much cheaper than doing it in person. Their own site was also more expensive than expedia.
- throwaway290 3y agoSimilar in Israel and Thailand, they upfront say it'd be more expensive to book at reception. I wonder if it's only different in US.
- marenkay 3y agoIf you speak Thai and do it via LINE messenger you get a much cheaper price though. Pricing seems to be inflated for foreigners.
- throwaway290 3y agoOn flip side, I bet if you are Thai native speaker foreigner in the US you will also not necessarily find it easier/cheaper to negotiate with hotels directly compared to Booking etc.
- marwis 3y agoIt's the same in US
- wordpad25 3y agoHotels always offer worse rates offline than online
- hoppla 3y ago«A Booking.com market manager in south-east Asia admitted at a recent industry event that payment delays were caused by the installation of a new payment system. Staff salaries were also affected, she said, explaining it as a risk they had to take.» It seems like there is a misunderstanding of who is on the taking and receiving end of risks
- gnu8 3y agoReal companies have competent adults build and test this type of thing so they don’t stiff their vendors or miss payroll. It’s not an area where you should let techbros move fast and break things.
- Aaargh20318 3y agoIt’s booking.com, they are notorious for not being competent adults. Just check out this article about their working conditions [1] (you might want to google translate it you happen to not speak Dutch). 1 - https://www.computable.nl/artikel/nieuws/development/6777910/250449/developers-schetsen-gitzwart-beeld-van-bookingcom.html https://www.computable.nl/artikel/nieuws/development/6777910... (
- diggan 3y ago> the developers complain about Perl programming language, which forms the basis of the online platform and to which, according to them, is held far too rigidly. Criticism of Perl may even result in dismissal, according to an anonymous source. If this machine translation is correct and the statement true, then this is borderline hilarious. I know that some companies keep their languages dearly, but that's taking it to the next level.
- laurent_du 3y agoAfter duckduckgo, this is the second time in a few days where I hear about some relatively big company using Perl for their backend.
- DrNosferatu 3y agoCall the booking.com property and negotiate a better price directly with the host. They offer virtually no protection anyway if a booking goes bad. Guests and hosts both win if you cut the booking.com middleman.
- DrNosferatu 3y agoIt’s a de facto monopoly - break them up! They don’t care about screwing up because they dominate the market so much. They’re enjoying the benefits of the existence of little alternative to them.
- ben_w 3y agoNo, not a monopoly. AirBnB is clearly a competitor in this space despite the various differences in targeted properties, and Google Maps also fills in this space. You could call them rent-seeking middlemen, but not a monopoly.
- Woeps 3y agoTough in (western) Europe they seem to have an strangle hold on almost all hotels. Sure AirBnB is there as well but they're not really usable (in my opinion) regarding hotel room. And Google maps often just brings you back to an Booking.com page
- ben_w 3y ago> And Google maps often just brings you back to an Booking.com page Really? Huh. I just looked at a dozen or two across Germany, France, Switzerland, Spain, Netherlands, Luxembourg, and Belgium, and while most had an option to book via booking.com (linked directly on the google search results) none had it as their only option, and they all had websites with direct booking forms of which only two were even styled slightly like booking.com But I didn't actually try to book a stay at any of them, just looked at the websites, so if they redirect after that I would have missed it.
- standardUser 3y agoI can't think of many industries with more competition than 3rd party travel sites.
- Nextgrid 3y agoYet they are all equally shitty and I'm sure would get up to the same shenanigans if given the opportunity.
- 0xbadcafebee 3y agoIt's a wonderful business model. They are effectively just a proxy for scheduling and payments, where they take no risk and trim a bit of revenue off as payments fly by. Their biggest hassle is probably the moderation of reviews.
- bluecalm 3y agoIt's interesting to see prevailing negative sentiment about booking here. My experience is completely different: usually a very nice place, no surprises, two times the host has done something wrong (cancelled my reservation or didn't respond) booking support was very quick to help me. On the other hand I consider Airbnb to be a scam enabling company that does everything to screw the customer and appease the hosts. Their reviews are worthless as they remove mentions of problems regularly and you will never know what you're getting until you arrive at the location. Forget about getting your money back if the host screws you as well - they will string you along from one support call to another and then pretend none of this happened. It's no surprise shady hosts prefer Airbnb to booking as it's easier to keep your trap offerings online for longer.
- skilled 3y agoHmm, this doesn't make any sense whatsoever, > A Booking.com market manager in south-east Asia admitted at a recent industry event that payment delays were caused by the installation of a new payment system. Staff salaries were also affected, she said, explaining it as a risk they had to take. What do you mean a new payment system? How do you not create a fallback for this situation when you're dealing with hundreds of millions of dollars in transactions? I mean I am willing to give Booking.com the benefit of the doubt here in case that is actually the root cause, but it doesn't compute for me. You don't just throw thousands of people (who drive business for you in the first place) under the bus by not properly preparing for a software rollout. You still have the old system or whatever it is that you were using, how hard would it have been to detect an issue if they did a A/B or a gradual rollout at first. As a Booking.com user myself - I am pissed that this is a thing.
- JonChesterfield 3y agoStart from the axiom that computers don't make mistakes. Then change to a new computer system at lower cost, because it's cheaper and computers don't make mistakes. So cheaper is better. Don't need a roll back plan, all computer systems work fine. Then put on your best surprised expression and wait to see if you manage to unwind the errors before a competitor exploits them. It is fascinating how much faith people have in computers, even after at least a decade of watching them fall over. Sure it crashes a lot but it couldn't get the answer wrong.
- jimt1234 3y agoThis reminds me of a job I once had that was about 50% travel; the company required employees to charge travel expenses to their personal credit cards, saying they would be reimbursed. The company consistently dragged its feet on the reimbursement, sometimes for several months. They scrutinized reported expenses to an absurd level, or simply refused to pay. I once had a layover on a flight (because the company required the least expensive flight, which was generally not direct) that was cancelled. I was stuck in Denver for 9 hours, waiting for an available flight. I got something to eat and reported it as a travel expense. Denied; I was told the expense didn't occur in the city where I was working, so it was personal, not business-related. A colleague had her credit card maxed with business travel charges, and could only afford to make the minimum payment for several months. She requested the company pay the interest on the carried charges. Take a guess how that went? Denied. She ended up quitting, and last I heard the company refused to reimburse her because she was no longer an employee. I ended up quitting, too. But yeah, this article reminded me of that situation. When it's known that you're basically powerless to collect on a debt, you can expect to get screwed.
- tpmx 3y agoI suppose many of us are lucky to work in high-margin software businesses. I spent 15 years often travelling for work (typically very distributed companies) before the pandemic. Four separate companies. Everything paid on my personal CC. I preferred it that way so that I could optimize the flights/etc to make it fit my personal life. Everything reimbursed swiftly with zero questions since I never did anything really stupid. The only real bottleneck was myself; filing all of those damned receipts for every trip. Having some kind of centralized travel booking service that "took care of everything" would likely have caused me to find another job. For one company I did a monthly 6h travel + a few days of hotel + 6h travel thing for a decade. Not being in total control over that would simply not have been feasible. I have no idea how people doing a large amount of travel for stereotypical low-margin large companies manage to get by.
- justinclift 3y ago> high-margin software businesses. I've heard similar stories to this from people working at high-margin software businesses before too. It could be something along the lines of "depends which team you're in", as to who's being screwed over or not.
- davelondon 3y agoTheir support is pretty bad.. they refused to refund a £20 booking when the hotel was 500km away from where it was shown on the map. There were no other contact options, so I took them to the UK Small Claims Court... They paid up before the case went to court.
- croisillon 3y agoit's the other way around: booking.com is leaving its bills to hotels unpaid, and makes a fortune that way
- dreamcompiler 3y agoI had a few horrible experiences with Booking.com and the others where I'd arrive at the hotel and they'd never heard of me, or I'd ask for an extra day in person but the hotel couldn't help me because I didn't book directly with them, or they didn't serve breakfast but Booking said they did and the hotel was in the middle of nowhere etc. I finally wised up. Hotels basically hate guests who book with a service like Booking.com and they will not lift a finger to help you if anything goes wrong. Now I use Booking.com, Kayak, etc to find hotels in the general area I need, then use google or DDG to find the website of the hotel (a process much easier said than done because the booking sites SEO the hell out of search engine results), then book directly with the hotel or its parent chain.
- wink 3y agoI guess this will never satisfy everyone, because my experience is the opposite. I've been using booking.com for about 10 years and the only things that kinda went wrong were when I didn't. So yeah, I've not had to test their failure procedure yet, but at least I've never experienced anything I booked not being available. (I had one hotel take my card payment on arrival and it was also done via booking but I blame the weird hotel here, booking refunded without problems).
- zeagle 3y agoThere is other good discussion here about booking direct vs resellers so I won't rehash it, but I just wish savings or other benefit were passed on by booking direct more often, e.g. room upgrade priority or breakfast. I've had that experience with airlines before having status.
- dcdc123 3y agoThis sounds like a trigger for hotels to treat booking.com customers poorly. I imagine people would be better off booking somewhere else. I would suggest directly with hotels but that pretty much always costs more money than booking through a third party so maybe Expedia/Hotels.com or something.
- justinclift 3y agoBearing in mind that booking.com famously offshored most of their customer support staff last year: https://skift.com/2022/02/11/booking-com-to-eliminate-2700-customer-service-jobs/ https://skift.com/2022/02/11/booking-com-to-eliminate-2700-c... Seems like that's going as well as everyone except their executive team predicted. ;)
- JonChesterfield 3y agoMy last hotel booking had offshored their entire customer support system to a 90s style chatbot. Walk the state machine in circles kind of thing. Booking had a real person pick up the phone, know stuff, and fix it. Not a native English speaker but still far more helpful than the software alternative.
- justinclift 3y ago> My last hotel booking ... How long ago?
- JonChesterfield 3y agoCouple of weeks. Picked it by distance from a conference venue instead of on more sensible grounds. Positive experience contacting booking though.
- mempko 3y agoReminds me of the quote from that Simpsons episode with Bill Gates "buying out" Homer's internet business. Bill Gates says: "I didn't get rich by writing checks".
- robbywashere_ 3y agowhy was hertz practically issuing arrest warrants? Because they can. Malicious artificial intelligence is here. The boring part is its these faceless bureaucracies they behave (intelligence?) without responsibility or repercussions whatsoever. That AI bogeyman your think of, its just going to be these kinds of companies blaming it on amok algorithms, in place of which is now some sort of 'failed process'
- rurban 3y agoBecause it's a perl shop
- totallywrong 3y agoI used it a whole lot when I was doing the nomad thing but avoid it now if I can help it at all. I can recommend the trip.com app if you want actual support when you have any issues. With booking you're on your own, it's terrible. Unfortunately they usually have the most options though.
- jononomo 3y agoSeems like this is just more enshitification, which is the general direction that everything on the internet is taking. If you think about it, it doesn't make any sense for Booking.com to pay its bills because then they'll just have less money.
- donkeydonut 3y agoIs this the real cause? Reports of scam coming from booking.com live chat, with victims from Singapore. https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/hotel-booking-scam-claims-at-least-30-victims-losses-of-41000 https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/hotel-booking-scam-cl...