21 ms·
Internet-connected cars fail privacy and security tests conducted by Mozilla
- husamia 3y agoSo we need to redesign the internet before our cars will be safer?
- nhance 3y agoI've got a 2018 Jeep Grand Cherokee and I've been searching for where the sim card is for the built in cellular modem so I can rip it out. It astounds me that there aren't more people interested in cutting off the constant telemetry and to be honest it wouldn't surprise me if the car refuses to operate correctly when I do figure out where it's at and pull it.
- Sander_Marechal 3y agoThere probably isn't a physical SIM card anymore. It probably just has an eSIM.
- ben-schaaf 3y agoJust gotta break out the soldering iron then.
- yardie 3y agoIn 2018? I doubt car manufacturers can move that fast. Apple didn't implement eSIM until 2018 for the iPhone XS. No way an auto maker has it before consumer electronics maker.
- glogla 3y agoGiven the Wikipedia page about eSIM says: The European Commission selected the eUICC format for its in-vehicle emergency call service, known as eCall, in 2012.[23] All new car models in the EU must have one by 2018 to instantly connect the car to emergency services in case of an accident.[24] I'd say they have been around since then. edit: here is a great talk about how eSIMs work from last CCC https://media.ccc.de/v/camp2023-57190-demystifying_esim_technology https://media.ccc.de/v/camp2023-57190-demystifying_esim_tech...
- yardie 3y agoFor a very long time now you have never needed a SIM to call emergency services. Maybe it's different in the EU but US car models that include telematics (ie Onstar) have been able to call emergency services without a subscription.
- codedokode 3y agoShouldn't emergency services be accessible without a SIM? On the other hand, using a SIM allows government to track car's movement.
- hedora 3y agoThe cell modem has a separate unique identifier, so the government should be able to track sim-free devices.
- catchnear4321 3y agooverwhelm the brain with input. to hold onto threads like this one, you have to be fairly healthy or fairly mad. not strapping on tin foil hat, this likely isn’t some massive coordinated effort. it could be done “better.” this is just making the most of the situation. at scale. if you simplify the question, “Who wants to let their car manufacturer surveil them?” - the answer is also simple. very few hands are going to be raised. most people don’t get the tl;dr - they drown in the firehose. what isn’t out there is a friendly, accessible version of what you’re looking for - multi-manufacturer information on snipping the sensors, why and how, and what you lose in the exchange. if it is out there, it isn’t friendly enough to be readily found.
- s3p 3y agoI'm not sure what you're suggesting here.
- catchnear4321 3y agopeople are tired, stretched thin, even in the most powerful nations. information access has become so ubiquitous that it has become more challenging to filter than to find. for many people, there are far more pressing concerns to address than if nissan knows how the back seat was used last night. they would need the time and space to slow down and consider the information, and likely have means to do something, for it to elicit a response. some people would love to have the issue, that would imply having means to get a new car. no, they wouldn’t love the issue, but it is out of reach, so it isn’t deemed worth the effort spent. right now it’s like saying your cell phone spies on you. most people won’t be getting rid of their phones. some might get foil bags. faraday cage around your car, on the other hand, isn’t happening.
- ranger_danger 3y agoNone of that matters when the info is either routinely sold to others with more time and motivation on their hands, or simply leaked to the public whether on purpose or not.
- vuln 3y agoIt’s an eSim. Not a physical SIM card afaik.
- monkpit 3y agoDo you have a source for this?
- vuln 3y agoGoogle. I’ve searched and searched. I have a 2018 Truck from a different manufacturer and I completely went down the rabbit hole of attempting to remove it. It’s not possible. It’s an assumption that most manufacturers are following the same logic due to economy of scale.
- joezydeco 3y agoYou'd probably have more success finding the external antenna and clipping the leads at the sharkfin.
- b112 3y agoJust make sure you do something, like use a resistor to ground the antenna lead, because I did that, and would still get connectivity at times. EG if the cell tower was very close. Was fine after I used a resistor to turn that power into mild heat.
- joezydeco 3y agoI wonder if one could build a metal cap, shape and color matched to the sharkfin, that goes over the antenna and couples to the roof of the car. Would that be enough to make a small Faraday cage over the antenna? Would leakage though the mounting hole still be enough to let a signal through?
- r0b1n 3y agoYou could maybe just stuff the inside of the sharkfin full of tinfoil.
- ragnese 3y agoI've tried stuff like that before on other things and haven't been very successful. Those damn EM waves really like to find their way through.
- brian-armstrong 3y agoI don't think you really need to get that sophisticated. If you unplug the antenna and send too much current down that antenna line, whatever's on the other side is not going to like it.
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoIf it is similar to eCall in VAG ECUs, then there might be internal antenna inside the ECU itself.
- vorpalhex 3y agoThere's often times a small cellular modem in the sharkfin on vehicles but I believe Jeeps still have whip antennas. Could use an SDR or emf reader. It'll take a while since you need to catch a cellular keep alive but otherwise should be fine.
- pgeorgi 3y ago> it wouldn't surprise me if the car refuses to operate correctly I know of a car (Renault in EU) whose SIM access is broken somehow that still works fine, just can't call home. No guarantee that every car will handle it gracefully, but at least some regions don't seem to mandate any enforcement if that module happens to "break".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throw3747874747 3y agoI am pretty sure that is (or soon will be) illegal in EU. Car needs to be able to call emergency, if accident is detected.
- justinclift 3y ago"Oops, how did that happen..." ;)
- throw3747874747 3y agoIt is EURO5 or EURO6 emmision norm. It also handles firmware updates, reaction to Volkswagen cheating. Car needs to be online, check for latest firmware and all sort of nasty DRM. There is also a black box, that records position and speed. It may call emergency if it detects crash. If DRM is violated, car may refuse to start, or only drive like 50 kms. I don't have a source, but anyone should be able to find relevant articles.
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoThat's just creating a blackmarket for people that can crack the DRM without the car losing functionality.
- loloquwowndueo 3y agoThe manufacturer may have to legally include the functionality in cars they sell but in pretty sure the owner isn’t obligated to use or keep the functionality untouched. By comparison if your seat belts are all frayed and you don’t wear them anyway that’s on you, manufacturer sold you a car with seat belts in good condition and that as far as the “compliance” requirement goes.
- tpmoney 3y agoMight depend on the wording of the law and how that system is tied into the rest of the car. For example in the states, it is illegal to tamper with any part of the emissions control system on your car. This is mostly about making sure emissions testing via OBD II can’t be gamed, but it also would target modifications like “rolling coal” or turbos and superchargers that allow user controlled fuel mapping. But in the crossfire it catches completely reasonable reasons to modify your emissions system like a flex fuel upgrade, or replacing the computer of your old car with an aftermarket one because the engine immobilizer unit died and they’re paired together and OEM computers and immobilizer kits are either too expensive or not obtainable anymore. Laws against tampering with vehicle safety devices would easily have a similar effect on your built in phone home systems.
- swader999 3y agoThere's likely five Sims at various places and even 3d printed into the frame.
- delecti 3y agoThey're eSIM these days, so it's actually zero physical SIM cards.
- noman-land 3y agoCheck out the manual, find where the fuse is for the cellular modem, and remove it.
- orev 3y agoThat’s quite a big assumption to think that it would be clearly labeled, and also that it would have a dedicated fuse. It’s not like that would be such a huge power draw that it needs its own fuse. Pulling the fuse would likely cause the whole infotainment system to go down.
- noman-land 3y agoReading back at my reply, I didn't mean it to sound so authoritative. Just an idea. I helped a friend do this a couple years ago in a fairly modern car. It most certainly was not clearly labeled, but there were clues that led us to try it out. It indeed disabled more than just the cellular modem but the goal was to disable all "smart" features altogether, along with anything that collects telemetry or phones home. After monitoring how it affected the car, the mild trade-offs were deemed worth it.
- bityard 3y agoThere's more than a fair chance that the modem is built into or fused along with the entertainment systems.
- noman-land 3y agoThere's also more than a fair chance it isn't :).
- mindslight 3y agoI feel like if this were happening 20 years ago, common wisdom would develop to buy from a list of model of cars where people had already blazed the path, directions of what the cell modem looks like and how to unplug it, prominent links to a community working on a libre replacement, and majority opinion of this is just what you should do to cope in the modern world. Now with the web community being so diffuse the majority opinion basically seems to be "whatevs". Perhaps if you dug into the right threads on the right manufacturer-specific forum you could find a thread or two with some investigation, but that's about it. It's also essentially impossible to navigate/compare the amenability of different makes to this. FWIW I've got no actual experience, but given the general slowness with which the car industry moves I would guess the cell modem is just a module hanging off one of the CAN buses, receiving telemetry broadcast by other modules and injecting/interrogating commands when requested (like modern OBD2 ports). I suppose it could also be part of something like the gauge cluster that links different buses as well (at least on Hondas) but with the modular way cars seem to work I'd guess it's not likely. I'd try to track down a copy of the factory service manual for your model. Those have seem to have gotten pretty thin these days too in favor of computer-based documentation, but it should at least help you work out how things are generally connected. (No point to the readily-available Haynes manual though. Those are apparently garbage)
- wil421 3y agoRemoving the head unit and unplugging the “Bordeaux” and violet wire[1] may help and be easier to do. It’s the LTE and 3G antennae wire. I have a 2019 Grand Cherokee and I think we both have the updated head unit. Let me know if anything works. [1] https://www.jeepgarage.org/threads/uaq-antenna-connections.217097/ https://www.jeepgarage.org/threads/uaq-antenna-connections.2...
- grecy 3y agoMy 2021 Wrangler has a very obvious antenna on top of the roll bar, very easy to unplug. (There's actually two - one for SIM stuff, and one for the XM Sat radio)
- hashtag-til 3y agoI think it will be a good differentiation factor in a few years, that a brand comes up with an offline car, i.e. a car that you just refuel/charge and drive - no telemetry/connected features involved. It may be a niche thing in future, but certainly something that would be appealing to me as a consumer.
- slashtab 3y agoOpen source Car!!
- hashtag-til 3y agoThat a good idea in theory, but that has a very high bar for non-advanced users. What I meant is kind of just a regular brand that offers you a regular car with convenience features, but no telemetry/services involved. All local and offline - that's the catch for them, because what brands want is to monetize services...
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoName's all sorted too: The Oscar.
- userbinator 3y agoThe automotive enthusiast community has been building their own for decades.
- birch 3y agoOh, this would be an expensive hobby that I would embrace.
- temp_gnuser 3y agoThe rally fighter and other local motors vehicles are open source iirc, but I agree this should be the future.
- morkalork 3y agoAdd analog buttons, knobs and I'm sold!
- hotpotamus 3y agoMy 2016 econobox would email me when a tire is low or it needs an oil change. I don't think this is all that new an issue.
- stjohnswarts 3y agowhy wouldn't it just show a dash light?
- jmclnx 3y agoYes, and that is why I will never buy new unless in the contract I have; 1. No data harvesting 2. If I or anyone discovers any kind of data harvesting, at any time, I get a full refund of the original purchase price plus interest plus 2000 USD from the manufacture. If not received in 6 months, it double ever 6 months. But from what I understand, I heard due to Massachusetts "Right to Repair", all of that is turned off. But time for the Federal Gov to step in. I expect they will since some Congress Critter will complain about the Auto Industry tracking them or their children. Or, more then likely, due to how the US Gov have been operating for the last 30 years or so, Congress people will get to purchase "special" vehicles.
- 0xcafefood 3y agoHow do you buy a car that meets those criteria?
- thfuran 3y agoYou don't.
- sam_lowry_ 3y agoIn some places, this is not an option. I have a mechanical Euro-5 car without sim card nor infotainment system that I would not be able to use where I live by end 2024. Welcome to the EU and its low-emissions zones that span over many of its big cities.
- hef19898 3y agoWhat? Besides Euro-5 emissions restricting access to cities in places, thoae cars are, will be, perfectly road legal in Europe...
- TedDoesntTalk 3y agoWhat happens at the end of 2024 that your car won’t operate?
- Androider 3y agoThere's telemetry, and then there's this https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/04/tesla-workers-shared-images-from-car-cameras-including-scenes-of-intimacy/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/04/tesla-workers-sh...
- inemesitaffia 3y agohttps://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/08/apple-and-google-temporarily-stop-listening-to-siri-and-ok-google-queries/amp/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/08/apple-and-google...
- GoofballJones 3y agoThanks for linking to a 4 year old story. Now link to the follow-up stories to where Apple no longer does this and they were sued for breaking their privacy policy. Google still does it, as in their TOS they basically say "yeah, we're going to be looking over your shoulder at everything you do, as that's how we make our money".
- gordian-not 3y agoDo you know of any similar story at Google since 2010?
- TedDoesntTalk 3y agoThat will be the norm for all car companies soon enough, not just Tesla.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sharikous 3y agoChina is now the biggest car exporter, thanks to the electric car boom. Are there state security issues with Chinese cars too?
- hef19898 3y agoYeah, we ban Huawei 4/5G infrastructure, and ban them fr using western / US tech, but are totally fine with whatever data BYD and EV OEMs do. But then TikTok and Xaomi are totally fine still, so what do I know...
- api 3y agoThe entire area of connected devices is a security and privacy dumpster fire. However bad you think it is, it’s worse. Everything is full of both intentional telemetry and security vulnerabilities.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 9g3890fj2 3y agoI connect my phone to my 2015 Nissan's bluetooth, but just for music. GrapheneOS lets me prevent its access to my contacts, call history, active calls, text messages - anything but music audio. To me (but not the less tech literate, I know), if you're connecting your car to your phone, it's obvious that it is able to gather things about you. That said, because I don't know much about cars, I don't know if the car is even capable of phoning home or by what means. Is it a 4G signal? Just a radio transponder? How do I even investigate without tearing my dash apart?
- pragma_x 3y agoI dug into the article, specifically the Nissan section. It reads like the car itself _could_ be gathering information on its own. IMO, the Nissan phone app is the more likely culprit here. Unless there's something wild going on with XM, or there's a WiFi backdoor, the only other way the car is getting data out is over OBD2. And that's all engine, tires, and performance stuff: https://www.amazon.com/Turbo3-Leaf-Spy-Pro/dp/B00PMLTPN0/?tag=myelecarfor-20& https://www.amazon.com/Turbo3-Leaf-Spy-Pro/dp/B00PMLTPN0/?ta... Edit: OH. Looks like there's Over-the-air updates on some models. https://www.nissanusa.com/connect/features-apps/over-the-air-update-capability.html https://www.nissanusa.com/connect/features-apps/over-the-air... > The wireless features in your vehicle, including Over the Air Updates require use of your in-vehicle modem (if equipped). While Over the Air Updates are being made, some other wireless features may be unavailable or may require a wired connection. Please see FAQs for additional information.
- 9g3890fj2 3y agoInteresting. I've never connected my car to my wireless network and I've never used the Nissan app. I think I used a burner email when setting things up, but that was years ago so I don't remember the details. I'll see what happens if I try an OTA update later today and report back.
- bzzzt 3y agoAll new EU cars since 5 years ago are obligated to have 'eCall' which contacts emergency services in case of a crash. Most manufacturers solve that problem by including a 4G module. Older cars also collect information. Most dealers read out the nav computer drive at service intervals so they also know where you've been, who you called etc, only a bit later.
- 0xcafefood 3y agoIt almost feels silly to ask, but is this legal even in the United States with its comparatively weak privacy laws? In many states, a vehicle is legally an extension of the home. So legal rights and protections that apply in one's home also apply in one's vehicle. Is the idea that, buried somewhere in the legalese, is a statement that the buyer is granting the automaker the right to spy?
- ocdtrekkie 3y agoYes, the US is pretty nearly lawless when it comes to privacy issues. Half the protections we have today are "it's legally required in the EU but low cost enough to just do globally".
- seanw444 3y agoConsidering the government uses the private sector as a cheat code to evade our 4th Amendment, this crap needs to be addressed.
- mindslight 3y agoThe real "cheat code" is that much of the de facto government is the private sector. Imagining some hard dividing line between "government" and "private sector" is a fallacious red herring.
- giantg2 3y agoYeah, it's pretty sketchy but it seems the courts are allowing most it, even for second owner and non-subscribers (OnStar).
- OnACoffeeBreak 3y agoI am very unfamiliar with specific state laws regarding this, but there's a federal exception for automobiles when it comes to the Fourth Amendment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_exception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_exception
- 3y ago
- jgalt212 3y ago> Kia’s privacy policy reserves the right to monitor your “sex life,” Please tell me this is lawyer CYA boilerplate, or is there a way for the shocks to tell "if this van's a rockin', don't come a knockin'".
- catchnear4321 3y agosomewhere a data scientist is cackling.
- TedDoesntTalk 3y agoThey have cameras and gyroscopes in the cabin. Pretty easy to figure it out even without the cameras.
- rekoil 3y agoProbably intentional to make sure they're not in trouble in case this happens to them: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/04/tesla-workers-shared-images-from-car-cameras-including-scenes-of-intimacy/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/04/tesla-workers-sh...
- queuebert 3y agoThis reminds me of how my insurance app thinks I'm driving whenever I bounce my leg nervously.
- gorbachev 3y agoEarlier: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37401563 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37401563
- pard68 3y agoThings like this are a part of why my newest vehicle is an '04 Suburban.
- TedDoesntTalk 3y agoBut that won’t be an option in a few . How many 2015 cars will be on the road and for sale in 2035?
- pard68 3y agoI also have an '54 Chevy, a '62 CJ, a '69 wagon, a '68 Suburban, and a '84 Ford. I have a pretty good track record of keeping old things running well. Eventually my new cars (01 and two 03s) will cease to be repairable, but I have invested time and money in a very well maintained fleet of older vehicles, it's one of my only practical hobbies.
- TedDoesntTalk 3y agoI guess you’re all set then and the rest of us are screwed?
- pard68 3y agoThat's your choice. You can buy new, convienent, modern cars that spy on you and will be dead in ten years. Or you can buy old, reliable cars that lack most modern amenities but can be repaired forever with a metal lathe and a welder.
- TedDoesntTalk 3y agoIt's my choice not to learn how to use a metal lathe and a welder, or find someone with those skills to do it for me? How is that supposed to scale to millions of people who want the same privacy?
- 3y ago
- lefuturiste 3y agoGet a bike (a muscular one) and problem solved :)
- stjohnswarts 3y agoaround here it's literally just the amount of time until you get hit by a car, everyone I've known who bikes (n=5) or motorcycles (n=4) on the regular has been hit. Only the severity varies.
- Lolaccount 3y agoLike my TV ... and my phone ... and my ... and my ink pen (connected via WIFI) ...
- GoofballJones 3y agoThe "inshitification" now extends to our cars.
- cmurf 3y agoHow does GDPR affect this issue for cars bought/sold in EU market? Is the opt out complete? Does the right to be forgotten after the fact apply?
- Msurrow 3y agoIANAL but this is clearly not even close to being legal under GDPR. Especially those collecting article 9 stuff (biometrics, genetics, sexual orientation, race, etc). I think its just a matter of time before someone buys a new car that does this and takes the manufacturer to the EU courts. The argument that concent is given when you buy/use the car will not hold up for one second. Car manufactors will have to allow you to use the car without collecting anything.
- alwaysrunning 3y agoWhere is the host file so I can block all this data from being uploaded?
- mikece 3y agoCar dealerships are notoriously horrible about privacy as well. The last time I bought a car at a dealership they wanted me to sign a release that allowed them to use photos and videos of me as part of their television and online advertisement. They were stunned when I refused and threatened to nix the whole deal and I challenged them to do exactly that before (of course) a manager was summoned and eventually I was taken to an office to complete the purchase where I could not be accidentally caught on video or photos which would result in them getting sued for using my image and likeness.
- darknavi 3y agoAnd then you get about six years of SiriusXM mailers because they sell your data to them.
- gspencley 3y agoI bought a used vehicle at a dealership back in 2018. A couple of years later my daughter was looking for her first car and so we went to the same place. We were just browsing, and were met by a different sales rep. He had to excuse himself to tend to a different customer and during that time we left to go check out other places. While we were at a different dealership I get an unexpected phone call. It was the sales rep at the first dealership, who I had never met before, and had certainly not given my phone number. I asked him how in the fucking hell he even knew my name, let alone my phone number, and he explained that the rep that sold us our vehicle in 2018 recognized me. I told him that was a very creepy and off-putting experience, that I do not consent to unsolicited phone calls from them, especially in such a creepy situation, and that I won't ever be purchasing another vehicle from them.
- CamelCaseName 3y ago"Recognized you" I wonder where they put the facial detection camera
- Bilal_io 3y agoThey have no respect for privacy. I use a Ford.com@domain.com to request a quote from Ford's official website. Apparently Ford shared my information with a dealer. That makes sense, but the dealer continued to email me and advertise cars from other manufacturers.
- vannucci 3y agoThe more I read about these things, the more I think I'll be driving my 23 year old Toyota 4Runner until the end of my life
- uberdru 3y agoI am still driving my '09 4Runner. Cheap to own/maintain, ridiculously reliable. And no touch screen. Perfection! Anything made after about 2015 feels WAY over-engineered, for my tastes at least.
- aftbit 3y agoDepending on your climate, you should probably have the right front frame member inspected for rust. My father had an '09 4Runner & got into a front-end crash. In the process that member was exposed, and while it looked fine on the outside, it was full of rust from the inside and quite thin. Don't get me wrong, I drive an '01 Ranger that is more rust than steel at this point, but it is still good to know what you have.
- wing-_-nuts 3y ago>I drive an '01 Ranger that is more rust than steel at this point You poor man. I had a 3.slow 6 cyl. 0-60 in 16s was almost an accomplishment. I guess that's what you get when you have a 155hp motor trying to pull a 3800 lb vehicle.
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoPoor man? Sounds like a happy man to me! I drove a '93 Ranger with the 98 horsepower 2.3L 4-cylinder and the 5-speed manual in the late 2000s from 130,000 miles to 280,000 miles; it carried the supplies to paint dozens of houses and got me through college without any debt on car payments or tuition. My wife still mocks me for the purple pinstripes and the fact it was shorter than her, but I was driving it when she was just an acquaintance and I was still driving it home from our wedding, so clearly she actually liked it and just won't admit it. It could eventually achieve 70 mph on the downhills with a slight tailwind, but it's not a vehicle for people who are in a hurry. I never entered it into any kind of drag race, so I didn't worry about the 0-60 time. Sadly, it died when a neophyte mechanic tried to lift it by the body instead of the ladder frame; the body mounts were able to keep the sheet metal from sliding around but the rust gave way when they tried to put them in tension. No, it would not have been safe in a rollover... I like to imagine there's one still dry and rust-free in a barn somewhere in the Southwest that just needs some hoses, fluids, and a clean paint job (with purple pinstripes, that's important!) I would pick that over a new Maverick any day, never worry for a moment about it selling my data, and I'd have a stupid grin on my face every time I saw it. The only thing that could make it better would be if I could bolt an EV motor to the flywheel, elevate the bed by 6", and sandwich a battery pack under it.
- photochemsyn 3y agoThe best way around this for those wanting an EV car is to get a classic car that's been well-maintained and do an electric conversion. The only 'infotainment system' anyone needs is a tablet or phone; a charging system for electronic devices shouldn't be too hard to set up either.
- Waterluvian 3y agoOkay so you wanna hear something absolutely horrifying? My new CPAP machine has a 4G modem and it shares all my sleep data with the company. There’s some people at the local office who can tell precisely when I’m asleep and how asleep I am. Could you possibly want any better data for when to rob someone? I’ve put the thing in airplane mode and they called saying they can’t get the data needed for the first month, required for insurance purposes. Nope. My last machine had an SD card. How about you do that instead?
- empyrrhicist 3y agoIt just seems to get worse and worse. We desperately need a consumer privacy bill of rights.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- madethemcry 3y agoI had to look it up: CPAP = continuous positive airway pressure; to treat sleep apnea disorder I do have sleep apnea disorder but probably a mild one as I don't feel exhausted at all. Reading your comment sparked the idea that it might be a good idea to verify the severity. If there will be any CPAP machine involved I will for sure think of its privacy impact.
- kkfx 3y agoI have a new EV (a modest MG ZS long range 2022) and I'm not much concerned about privacy BUT much, much, much more about remote controls ability from the factory AND potentially someone else due to some crapware vulnerabilities who happen to be vast https://samcurry.net/web-hackers-vs-the-auto-industry/ https://samcurry.net/web-hackers-vs-the-auto-industry/ My take is simple: - all cars can be connected BUT the connection must be user controllable, meaning the car must run on FLOSS easily installable by the formal owner; - all cars can offer remote controls BUT in a classic ssh-alike fashion, meaning it's ok to have a web(cr)app for end users, but not proxyed by the OEM only. OEM might act as a proxy to circumvent NAT, but the user is free to choose a DynDNS and other P2P/distributed solution hosted alone. In mere privacy IMVHO my car can snoop videos of me/anything surrounding / capture audio no more and no less than an Android or iOS macrospy also know as smartphones. So I'm equally concerned BUT so far such smart devices can't potentially lock me outside in the middle of anything, making me crash on some people and than state I'm a terrorist crushing on purpose and so on. Witch limit much the risk surface.
- bradley13 3y agoI want to know how these license agreements work, legally speaking? We bought a new car and signed the purchase agreement. Nowhere was there anything resembling a software license. Some months later, the display has a pop-up "our terms and conditions have changed". Um...which terms would those be, and when did we ever agree to them? Anyway, how can they make a one-sided change to a contract?
- verisimilitude 3y agoHere's the relevant legalese from Toyota: "By purchasing or leasing a vehicle equipped with an active Connected Services system, you specifically consent to our electronic collection and use of your account information and vehicle data and our storage of such data wherever we designate." "Fun" right?
- AnonymousPlanet 3y agoDoes the new owner of a used vehicle have to sign this too? And if this was skipped during the selling process, is the data now collected in the name of the previous owner?
- jklinger410 3y agoAlso, as a PSA: Your local state government sells car registration data to data brokers and car manufacturers. It is often used for behavioral targeting.
- Tangurena2 3y agoI used to work for a state motor vehicle agency. Federal law requires the manufacturers get your up to date mail address for recall purposes. Legislators make sure that the agencies sell that data (this is the source of those "we've been trying to reach you about your vehicle's warranty" letters/calls). Sometimes they interfere to ensure that their buddies/lobbyists don't pay for it.
- vel0city 3y agoI doubt these datasets have anything to do with the "we've been trying to reach you about your vehicle's warranty" calls, as I know people who got a lot of those calls but never owned a vehicle (some were even minors!). Every time I listened to one of their messages it never had any actual targeted car information.
- jen20 3y agoEvery time I've bought a car recently (which for Reasons has been a few times), I've ended up with utter scum sending mail designed to look "official" while skirting the actual reserved terms trying to scam me into extended warranties and so forth. If I had more time I would use their free return address to ship boxes of broken bricks.
- nologic01 3y agoOnce you normalize this state of affairs in one digital sector (social media, search, whatever), you've normalized it, period. You can't say: X and Y can milk this, but Z and W cannot. Everybody will want to get a piece of action from such a lucrative scheme. In turn once the managing elites of all these formerly non-tech sectors that get increasingly digitized (mobility, finance, insurance, health etc) get satisfied that their legal / reputation risk is manageable they will invest further in this direction and lobby hard to preserve their investment value against "intrusive and innovation limiting regulation". It all follows logically and it is a dystopic downward spiral that has no bottom.
- catlover76 3y ago> You can't say: X and Y can milk this, but Z and W cannot. It is totally doable for the government to regulate social media differently from automobiles--it's happening right now!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- netbioserror 3y agoI have a 2019 Subaru Outback. I also use GrapheneOS on a Pixel 3A. I have noticed that, when my phone is plugged in and I have location services enabled (for navigation), when I'm NOT using navigation, the icon in the top bar indicating location services being used pings once every 30 seconds. I'm sure onboard cell modems can be used to triangulate well enough, but just knowing that my car likes to hitch a ride on my phone's sensors has creeped me out forever. I'll definitely be looking for an old beater car as my second when the time comes.
- tristor 3y agoOf all the horrible things go on with privacy these days, this is the one I hate the most. I’m a “car guy”, but not the sort that obsesses over old cars (although I do love 60s and 80s cars). I like new tech, I like the advances in engineering we’ve made in new vehicles, I like EVs even. Nonetheless I’ve been in the market for a new car for months and haven’t bought because it’s hard to find any cars that meet my requirements (after all most companies primarily make trucks and shitty crossovers, not even cars). The two things that consistently hold me back are either things like this (crazy telemetry / touchscreens everywhere / half-ass safety tech) or insane dealer markups. I’ve pretty much figured out the new Toyota GR Corolla is the perfect car for my needs, but you can’t find them anywhere without a $25K+ dealer markup and many dealers won’t sell them to out of state residents. It’s truly a crazy time in the new car markets and the used market isn’t really any better.
- lunias 3y agoI currently own a 2012 VW GTI that I bought new 11 years ago. It has 123k miles and lots of modifications. I recently compiled a short list of both EVs and ICE vehicles to compare against it; the Toyota GR Corolla was on my list: 2023 Toyota GR Corolla AWD 3285 LBS / 300 HP = 10.9 LBS / HP RANGE: 25 mpg * 13.2 gallons = 330 mi PRICE: 44k -------------------------------------------------- 2012 VW MK6 GTI (K04) FWD 3000 LBS / 330 WHP = 9.1 LBS / WHP RANGE: 23 mpg * 14.5 gallons = 333 mi PRICE: < 30k (to buy a used GTI and install the same mods including labor) -------------------------------------------------- I think the GR Corolla is great, but even after 11 years it's sadly not really a convincing upgrade for me. The GR Corolla is less powerful (in both torque and horsepower), it has one less cylinder and less displacement, it weighs more, it gets essentially the same mileage and has the same range, and it costs much more. The Corolla does have AWD though. Here's the common "upgrade" for me: 2023 VW Golf R AWD 3400 LBS / 315 HP = 10.8 LBS / HP RANGE: 28 mpg * 14.5 gallons = 406 mi PRICE: 47k -------------------------------------------------- Again, the Golf R is also great, but it's also less powerful and weighs more. It gets slightly better mileage than my current car, but costs even more than the GR Corolla. Finding something new that is "better" out of the box than my 11 year old GTI would cost me at least 56k (Toyota GR Supra RWD) or if I want AWD then it's more like 66k (Audi RS3 AWD). If I want something electric and "better" then it's at least 89k (Tesla Model S). These prices are really high to begin with; when you add in dealer markups they become insane propositions. For your money you'll also have to contend with with touch screens, capacitive buttons, and a bunch of other tech that you don't want or need. The market seems to be in a pretty sad state for car guys. Unless something changes I'll be rebuilding my engine with forged internals and continuing to drive my GTI.
- taylodl 3y agoThis article doesn't go into any benefits to the driver/user, if available. With all the cameras and microphones in cars these days they can at least send the insurance companies all the data when an accident occurred. Were you on the phone? Driving the speed limit? Have your seat belt on? Braking hard to avoid (or cause) an accident? Heck, give me a monthly riding report with information such as how fast I accelerate, how hard I brake, how often I speed, and stuff like that. Then provide tips on how to improve my driving. At least that would be useful.
- lost_tourist 3y agothat sounds like a nightmare to me and should have to be opted into, I would never purchase a car with that. I'll just get a motorcycle and risk my life.
- taylodl 3y agoNightmare? It's a black box. It can save your bacon if you're falsely accused. Cars have a lot of sensors these days and if those two cars get into an accident you can re-create the entire accident.
- kayodelycaon 3y agoI have a new Toyota and the owner’s manual mentions the car has a black box that records a number of parameters.
- Nifty3929 3y agoThe biggest problem I have is tracking that the government has access to. We're in a situation where the government knows everywhere your phone has been, and everywhere your car has been. I doubt we're far from the gov't being able to de-activate your car at will also. I would like to have privacy from corporations, but I really wish we'd keep the focus on privacy from our governments, since they have such ultimate power over us.
- kornhole 3y agoKill switches are now required for cars produced after 2026. https://www.musclecarsandtrucks.com/biden-infrastructure-bill-vehicle-kill-switch-2026/ https://www.musclecarsandtrucks.com/biden-infrastructure-bil... It is for your safety. ;)
- eficek 3y agohttps://apnews.com/article/fact-checking-402773429497 https://apnews.com/article/fact-checking-402773429497
- plagiarist 3y ago"It's not a kill switch, it slows the vehicle to a stop instead of being instant." I fail to see the practical difference. I don't want my car incorrectly deciding I am impaired and "coasting to a gentle stop" on the way to a hospital during a medical emergency or something.
- kornhole 3y agoMaybe kill-switch is not the best definition of the feature. The required technology monitors the driver to prevent starting the car or forcing it to pull over. In the context of the parent article which explains how the overall monitoring systems fail on privacy and security, we can see how these combined with the car stopping feature can be used against us. We are ultimately trusting the companies and government to do what is in our interests rather than theirs. Some people trust Apple not to use or share their data with government to be used against them. Trusting the largest corporation in the world and the most powerful government in the world is a major leap for me, but everybody theoretically makes their own choices.
- mantra2 3y agoI think I'm alright - I mean - my FJ Cruiser doesn't even have carpet.
- b8 3y agoAlso as shown in Mr Robot, the LE can remotely stop a car via OnStar.
- flangola7 3y agoIs that really a thing?
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoYes, and it has been.
- bjnewman85 3y agoCan't capture audio info when i'm blasting music at max volume with the windows down on the highway yelling at my friends. Privacy Win!
- lost_tourist 3y agoThat's one reason I'm saving up for an EV conversion lol. I just need a car to go from A -> B. I don't need self driving, constant updates, a blackbox, cameras everywhere, etc. Just an EV, with a good drive train, decent range, etc. It's the only reason I'm still using a dino car. Legislation for privacy will needs a huge overhaul in preference to the rights of individuals rather than corporations.
- ricktdotorg 3y ago> The worst offender was Nissan, Mozilla said this is ironic; my wife bought a brand new 2020 model year Nissan 370Z 50th anniversary edition in 2021, and it feels like it is from the late 90s. no touch screen (actually no screen at all!), no GPS/navigation, no tracking, no Bluetooth audio streaming(!!) it does have mobile phone Bluetooth connectivity and a terrible backup camera but those are the only bits of modern in-car tech it has. it feels like a very analog modern sports car without any of the crap that most modern sports cars have. more of this please! sadly, seems like the new Z coupe went all-in on the in-car tech, much like Nissan's other offerings.
- EricE 3y agoHow can it have no screen? They even forced Mazda to put a back up camera in the Miata - which is beyond idiotic.
- bas3l1ne 3y agoBackup cameras weren't required in vehicles until (i think) 2018. My guess is that (similar to banning popup headlights), it was only required for new vehicle models released. The 370z had a ridiculously long production run starting in 2008, so they weren't required to put one in
- ricktdotorg 3y agoit really does have no screen at all! the backup camera shows up on the rear-view mirror, taking up about ~40% of the width. it's really the jankiest thing and is shockingly bad for a 2020/2021 car! (edited for clarity)
- bas3l1ne 3y agoAhh interesting! Ive never seen or heard of a car manufacturer putting the backup camera screen in the rearview mirror (probably bc, for the reasons you mentioned it's a terrible idea!)
- jeffbee 3y agoThe funny thing is normally privacy hawks hate google but the unified privacy policy of Android Automotive is way tighter than any of these. The automakers with their own stacks want to collect, use, and sell any and all data.
- wahnfrieden 3y ago>The kind of information collected varies from personal information like medical data to how drivers are using the vehicle itself — such as how fast they drive, where they drive, and even the music they listen to. Both Nissan and Kia are noted to allow the collection of information regarding a user’s sex life. >Eighty-four percent of the reviewed car brands share personal user data with service providers, data brokers, and potentially sketchy businesses, according to the report, with 76 percent claiming the right to sell that personal data. >Tesla was the worst-ranked brand in the study, getting flagged in every privacy category — only the second time this happened. >Alongside the report, Mozilla also published a breakdown explaining how car companies collect and share user data. This can include anything from the user’s name, address, phone number, and email address to more intimate data like photos, calendar information, and even details on the driver’s race, genetic information, and immigration status. Mozilla says it also couldn’t confirm that any of the automakers could meet the organization’s minimum security standards regarding data encryption and protection against theft. In fact, it claims dating apps and even sex toys typically provide more detailed security information about their products than cars.
- intrasight 3y agoI just don't see this issue getting much traction until something really bad happens to a large group of powerful people. But even then it may not come to light as said people will cut a deal with car companies to exclude them from telemetry sighting "national security". They of course won't publicize this and when it inevitably becomes public they will just shrug. It won't get traction for the average person because the immediate effects are positive (lower insurance) and the dangers are very theoretical (a bad actor knowing where my car is). People are much more concerned about the near and present danger of bad actors hacking their financial accounts and stealing they hard-earned money.
- kornhole 3y agoI spent a lot of time researching all this a few years ago when looking for a new car. Despite the ability to afford any car, I am still riding a bike and taking public transit because of what I discovered. I know this is a difficult option for people in many places, but I am happy. Car makers should take notice that a growing number of people like me want a FOSS OS rather than an Iphone on wheels.
- renegat0x0 3y agoIn modern era everything mechanical, or analog is being replaced with digital, or with something "as a software". Product is replaced with "service". When everything becomes in the end connected with the Internet, everything is dependent... A system crash of AWS, Google, or any other monolithic provider will have drastic results. A system crash could halt many cars in a country. In the future Hackers could stall entire country transportation. With oligopoly,monopoly the power player can decide with very granular precision what you can, and cannot do, where you can go. You have no power to object. Even government bodies could be against you, or could be too small to fight big corporations. More - cameras in cars. What they will detect? If I am drunk, or something more? Will there be glitches to record more stuff? Will the cars have back doors for governments? - what kind of data will cars collect? Audio? Video? Biometrics? Facial data? Hate speech? - they can analyze where you go, why you do something, maybe for analytics, for governments, or for ad business - they can define terms of conditions, which of course can allow the producers to sell your data to third parties for cheaper models of cars At first you will be able to mitigate. You will be able to buy older cards. Eventually we will not be able to choose a different life. There is no really opt out if everybody implements techno-feudalistic software patterns.
- enriquto 3y ago> There is no really opt out if everybody implements techno-feudalistic software patterns. I have bad news for you: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> cameras in cars. What they will detect? If I am drunk, or something more? The more would be if you are watching your phone, in 99% of cases.
- whoChumpedwho 3y agoexactly the wrong question will not be asked. at any rate, you built this theme park; you protect this theme park. no worries
- charles_f 3y agoThis is very much in line with the industry trying desperately to get into the tech recurring revenue model. > the manufacturer collects information including sexual activity, health diagnosis data, and genetic data, though there’s no details about how exactly that data is gathered How is that even possible? Without more details about what this means and how it's done, this sounds a bit fishy to me. > Mozilla said it was unable to determine whether the brands encrypt any of the data they collect Given the auto industry's track record at security, I'm gonna go ahead and assume they _all_ store all that in a 2005-era non updated mysql database protected by root/password exported nightly as a clear-text csv file to an open network folder. And since they all do it they can call it an industry standard. > Berg said the MercedesMe Connect app gives users privacy settings and the ability to opt-out of certain services. Given that these folks try to sell you everything in the car you already bought as a service, that's a nice way of saying "if you're concerned about us collecting stool sample while using rated seats, you can use your car as a decorative piece in your garage if you want,l".
- lambdasquirrel 3y ago> How is that even possible? Without more details about what this means and how it's done, this sounds a bit fishy to me. Did you visit some explicit site without VPN (or at least a private tab)? Bingo. The data brokers will correlate you. Once your data can be correlated, whatever they gather is thrown into the pool. I'll bet that there's some back-scratching going on somewhere. Hey we know all about where John is at when he's driving, and we'll sell/give you that data and in exchange we'd like to buy/trade some ads on those other sites-of-interest he/she goes to.
- charles_f 3y agoWhen it comes to privacy data handling, the term "collecting" is a very specific term that means they are directly collecting it from you, so, unless they use the term in a non standard way, that means they supposedly collect your genetic material and sexual preferences _from you_. Which, erk, but also, how?
- 3y ago
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoWho wants to see my impression of an HN commenter? OK, here it goes: "I'm tired of Mozilla's agenda and politics!! They should only make a web browser!!"
- spacemadness 3y agoOK? I don’t think that sounds like an HN commenter at all.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- OnionBlender 3y agoThe other thread delivers. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37406265 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37406265
- ecf 3y agoKeep on donating to Mozilla so they can keep doing these little pet projects with absolutely no impact while paying executives millions of dollars.
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoI see you are better at doing impressions than I am
- temp_gnuser 3y agoFYI, on many systems you can rip out or otherwise disable the lte/sat boards and prevent data transmission. Sometimes it takes a touch of soldering.
- charles_f 3y agoNote that this is all based on this source material. https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/categories/cars/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/categor... I haven't dug too much into the methodology, but it seems like it's done based on privacy policies rather than actually looking into the car telemetry traffic. It's also written in a very caaual and sensationalist "omagad" tone that doesn't serve well the seriousness of the topic or findings
- sfaxon 3y agoI own a VW ID.4. For reasons I wanted to reverse engineer some of the API. After authenticating to the account tied to my car, the landing page (https://www.vw.com/en/owners.html https://www.vw.com/en/owners.html) makes calls to a lot of analytics trackers. I'll just list what pi-hole defaults block: analytics.tiktok.com sp.analytics.yahoo.com googletagmanger.com universal.iperceptions.com cdn4.userzoom.com snap.licdn.com secure-ds.serving-sys.com bat.bing.com ct.pinterest.com adherent.com And a few others. I would guess the phone app (which has access to the car location) has a similar list of trackers. I hope to get some time to MITM the app to be able to know for sure.
- creeble 3y agoJust to be clear, these are trackers from the web page, not trackers called by your car, correct? I'm never surprised by the web trackers (which my ad blocker generally filters too), but 3rd-party trackers called from devices/vehicles seems more insidious. Although the car / IoT companies can just as easily outsource the data once they have it anyway.
- TheRealDunkirk 3y agoA lot of people are making comments about defeating the telemetry, but it's not just about selling ads this time. This is about actual surveillance and (eventually) control, and the governments of the world will make this a requirement, and make circumvention of it as illegal as copyright infringement. In the US, the government will throw up it's hands and say it's not us; it's the "free" market, and this must be what people want, while all the automakers collude to do it, collect the data, and either let the NSA have it, or don't resist when they tap into it. And some people will think this is a good thing, because then we could throw literally everyone who was at J6 in prison, but then a conservative government gets thrust into power, and now they can go after everyone who was present at a BLM protest that turned violent (but I repeat myself). Whatever power "we" let "them" have will eventually be used against "us."
- EricE 3y agojust wait until insurance companies demand access to your telemetry or they triple your rates.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoWhy would they triple your rates? Insurance regulators do not let insurers increase premiums unless they have evidence showing the new data indicates a higher risk factor. So if you are getting your rates tripled, then you were being subsidized by safer drivers before, which seems like something that should be fixed. Dash cams have already probably given insurers a better idea on who is a riskier driver and who is not since collisions can now be more accurately attributed to the at fault party.
- ReactiveJelly 3y agoThey'll probably increase my rates because if I refuse the telemetry, they have to assume I'm a terrible driver. The fact that I am the most tight-assed speed-limit-obeyer I've ever known, with a dashcam, means nothing to them since it's my hardware and not theirs.
- yafbum 3y agoThe article is not very clear about whether this kind of abusive data collection is actually happening and they can prove it, or whether they found the text of the privacy policies to be overly broad. I have no idea how a car would infer my sexual orientation.
- drdebug 3y agoMay be if you drive often near bars or places with specific orientation?
- dangus 3y agoBingo. Lawyers write extremely broad TOS and EULAs but it’s really a mystery whether any of this data is actually being collected. Mozilla can’t see any of the code so they can’t really say what’s going on. Yes, it’s bad that it’s a mystery and it’s bad that consumers have little control over it. We need more comprehensive national privacy laws.
- absoluteharam 3y ago[dead]
- bigbacaloa 3y agoThat's easy. But they know that already anyway.
- MarkusWandel 3y agoPossibly the high-end ones more so. My new, relatively low-end Honda Civic EX-B appears not to have cellular connectivity (no HondaLink) and no Wifi connectivity. The only cameras are the ones looking out the front and back. Of course it does have an interior microphone for the Bluetooth. But all in all the car seems "old school" and not spying on me. Am I wrong?
- lapcat 3y agoIt appears that Mozilla simply read the privacy policies of the manufacturers and did not actually test any cars. Features vary widely among models, of course (as the owner's manual says repeatedly).
- uranium 3y agoI've been shopping for a new car recently, and got it down to the Chevy Bolt and the Hyundai Kona [because I want long-range electric and have a narrow garage]. On the Bolt it looks like you can just yank a fuse to kill the cellular radio, and on the Kona, there's a modem you can remove. I've even gotten the dealer to agree to have their shop do the removal, so as not to void any warranty =*).
- bilsbie 3y agoOven been thinking of getting a pickup truck from the 90s and just keep replacing the engine and transmission if needed. I’m just wondering about the safety.
- bilsbie 3y agoIt would be cool to buy an older car you like and convert it to electric yourself. Are there any good services or kits for this?
- helf 3y ago[dead]
- whalesalad 3y agoI have a RAM 1500 that updates itself with new software over the air. Much to my surprise it works pretty well and happens quite often. Seeing as this is an FCA/Stellantis product I fully expected the first update to completely brick my system. Thank you Java for being older and more reliable than dirt.
- ashafer 3y agoCertain cars let you physically disable this. For example, the Tacoma has a "Data Communication Module" (DCM) that performs all of this and has a cell radio to phone home. There's a fuse in the fusebox you can pull to prevent the DCM from getting any power. Only side effect is the in-cabin microphone stops working and you can reconnect the fuse at any time. It's as if the engineering team didn't want to develop a spying product and made a convenient way to disable it...
- EricE 3y agolol - if they were only that altruistic. Toyota doesn't make the tech, they buy modules from suppliers and integrate the tech. Better hope someone doesn't come out with a fancy super module that has everything integrated because there will be no disabling it as soon as that happens :/ Don't forget Toyota was the manufacturer that was going to charge a monthly subscription just for the key fob (!) to work until they got a massive backlash over it. A freaking key fob that doesn't use cellular or the cloud at all - it's 100% local between the fob and the car. And don't think for one minute that they won't try to sneak it back in.
- RealityVoid 3y ago> Better hope someone doesn't come out with a fancy super module that has everything integrated because there will be no disabling it as soon as that happens :/ Well, hello there, zone ECU!
- philsnow 3y ago> Better hope someone doesn't come out with a fancy super module that has everything integrated because there will be no disabling it as soon as that happens I was just thinking about how to find and disable all the microphones in a car and realized that, with software, any speaker can be used as a microphone, so the logical conclusion is that you'd have to disable all the speakers as well.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoFWIW, getting to that fuse is a massive, massive pain in the ass on some of their newer cars like the 2023 corolla. It's basically not possible. The alternative requires taking off the dash and manually pulling out some wires. In the process you may lose some functionality like some speakers, the radio, wireless android auto, microphone, etc.
- motohagiography 3y agoThe problem when you don't have competitive markets is that companies collude to use their oligopoly power and start exploiting people instead of making products for them. It's socially destructive because without privacy and moral context, all that is left is nihilism. Without privacy for the human exceptions to ideals, who gives a fuck if you lie, cheat, drive recklessly, cultivate morbid sexuality, or worse, as you're being monitored the whole time and nobody is doing anything about it, so there are no consequences, and even when there are, they are random. It's the social equivalent to being in a jail. Surveillance has become the most socially destructive force in our society today. I'm looking at getting a new truck after driving an old wrangler without infotainment or even power windows, and part of that is looking for aftermarket services to disable most of this distracting and dangerous crap. Maybe that's going to be my next product play.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- EGreg 3y agoModern cars use a variety of data harvesting tools including microphones, cameras, and the phones drivers connect to their cars. Manufacturers also collect data through their apps and websites, and can then sell or share that data with third parties. Do I understand this correctly? So all my conversations in a modern car potentially ARE actually being recorded and sent to be indexed and used against me later? Or to sell me stuff based on what I said in the car? Is this like when ISPs sell my data?
- lisper 3y ago> Some of the cars tested collected data you wouldn’t expect your car to know about, including details about sexual activity, race, and immigration status, according to Mozilla. It's not just that I would not expect my car to know about these things, it's that I cannot imagine how my car could possibly know these things. Immigration status? Sexual activity? WTF? How?
- SubiculumCode 3y agocameras, mics? and/or uploading pics from your phone
- lisper 3y agoWho uploads pics from their phone to their car??? Is that even possible?
- umeshunni 3y agoI think Mozilla's definition of 'tested' is made up here.
- godelski 3y agoThis is the first "Mozilla" thread I've seen in awhile where HN isn't getting all up in arms about them. So I take it we're cool with this type of stuff? Beyond FF? Because honestly I really appreciate this work.
- ecf 3y agoI’m not. Mozilla “foundation” is a cancer on the browser I used to love.
- yumraj 3y agoI’m assuming that this is not an issue if the phone is not connected to the car via Bluetooth, yes? The worst they’ll track is my locations and some other telemetry. I know this is not ideal, but personally I’ve never connected my phone to the car and I’ve managed. So maybe that’s what I’ll need to keep doing. Also, can I not control this via iOS permissions?
- codedokode 3y agoIsn't "free market" supposed to provide a choice between privacy-respecting and disrespecting products? No regulation required. Well, it seems like market forces do not work for minorities.
- kredd 3y agoFree market can’t decide on things it doesn’t really understand consequences of. Ideally, that’s why we would have specialists from different fields in the government to make unbiased recommendations.
- jcrash 3y agoThe actual article: https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/articles/its-official-cars-are-the-worst-product-category-we-have-ever-reviewed-for-privacy/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/article...
- alexfromapex 3y agoThis type of authoritarian tracking is extremely egregious but the good news is that we are hackers and can detect the RF and other signals with detectors and disable them if we really want to. At any rate, it's a sad state of affairs.
- bick_nyers 3y ago"Data signal has been lost for the last 3 days. Disabling car startup. Please tow to your nearest local dealership to re-activate."
- eximius 3y agoI don't understand. This seems clearly illegal to have policies like this that claim consent by sitting in the car but the "user" has never been presented the policy in a way to consent to! Is this just a good lawsuit away from being thrown out but no one has done it? Is there some particularly fucked up legal precedent that makes this tenuously legally stable?
- lelandfe 3y ago> You promise to educate and inform all users and occupants of your Vehicle about the Services and System features and limitations, the terms of the Agreement, including terms concerning data collection and use and privacy, and the Nissan Privacy Policy Similarly, how is this kosher? Do we think anyone, even a single person, has ever followed through on this promise they’ve apparently agreed to in using a Nissan?
- nonrandomstring 3y agoIn a small informal survey we found that _absolutely nobody_ knows about the new intrusive interior and exterior surveillance from cars. https://cybershow.uk/media/episodes/watchers_2023-07-01.mp3 https://cybershow.uk/media/episodes/watchers_2023-07-01.mp3 It is, to all moral (if not legal) purposes, covert and certainly illegal in the UK on all sorts of grounds that have yet to be challenged in court. The work is in getting the message out to people.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- EricE 3y agoJust wait until insurance companies demand access to your cars telemetry for either a "discount" or even to insure you at all. I'm seriously thinking of stockpiling a few extra used "dumb" cars. This is beyond nuts.
- bick_nyers 3y agoI would love it if it was economical/possible for repair shops to do "dumb swaps" where they cut out all the "smart" bullshit and give you physical buttons and knobs on your dash.
- ReactiveJelly 3y agoIn my moments of programmer hubris I often think, "It can't be _that_ hard to make an open-source controller for a Hybrid Synergy Drive. It's only two motors and a small engine. Come on!"
- bick_nyers 3y agoHeh. My programmer hubris tells me: difficulty is just a function of time and coffee.
- Scoring6931 3y agoAlready a thing in the UK, where the cheapest insurance options require the installation of a telemetry black box in the car.
- sedro 3y agoIt's the same in parts of the US. In California, insurers are only allowed to collect the mileage.
- callalex 3y ago>In California, insurers are only allowed to collect the mileage. Hmm, I am in California and have stalker auto insurance. The app they provide me shows a complete GPS map of every trip I take. So they definitely collect that information, but maybe you’re saying they can’t price discriminate based on it? Where did you learn about that rule?
- salawat 3y agohttps://cccis.com https://cccis.com In case you were curious about one of the faces behind the tech stacks that specialize in data exfiltration w.r.t your care. They pitch as being the source of info for the actuaries of auto insurers. Interviewed for them once, and even though the offer didn't materialize, I crossed them off my list of people I'd work with after putting in some time reading up on their offerings and thinking on what you could make out of them.
- chevyboltowner3 3y agoFor many cars (like the Chevrolet bolt) the information the car collected is available for purchase at lexisnexis https://www.chevybolt.org/threads/disable-or-opt-out-of-onstar-tracking.45751/page-3#post-785488 https://www.chevybolt.org/threads/disable-or-opt-out-of-onst...
- redbell 3y ago> Many people think of their car as a private space — somewhere to call your doctor, have a personal conversation with your kid on the way to school.. The above quote was 100% true just a few years ago but it appears to be vanishing in speed light as the tech advances and the race to collect private data reaches its peak. I’m afraid we will have to check the “I Agree to Terms and Conditions” in our new cars and before even leaving the dealership parking or getting the usual message: “Hey there, we’re updating our terms and conditions, accept to unlock your car” I’m afraid that once we reach fully-autonomous driving, Ads will start showing up in the car’s digital cockpit and/or head-up display.. probably, based on your current location, mood, the radio station you’re currently listening to.. you name it.. What a time you might not want to live to see!
- kccqzy 3y agoAds in cars are already a thing in China: https://carnewschina.com/2021/10/18/does-nio-play-advertisements-on-the-vehicle-navigation-interface/ https://carnewschina.com/2021/10/18/does-nio-play-advertisem... (It has gradually occurred to me that without the safeguards of privacy ingrained in western societies, the state of ad tech in China has already surpassed the U.S. and Europe in its sophistication.)
- bonestamp2 3y agoTrue, although I have some hope -- people have been disabling the onstar hardware in cars for decades and I assume this kind of thing will expand as these systems become even more invasive. The solutions will probably have to advance. I assume the first stage will be just unplugging the telematics ECU (Electronic Control Unit). Then the automakers will get wise, and punish the driver if that ECU is offline (reduce/remove some unrelated features). Then we'll have to make hardware that plugs into the telematics and gps antenna connectors that acts like a man in middle to ensure only the minimum (and possibly fake) data is received by the ECU. Then they'll probably add something that calls home every so often and requires a valid response to know everything is ok... etc.
- fidotron 3y agoThese cars are simply indicators of what smart homes would look like if marketers got their way: mechanisms to capture the hormonal state of inhabitants to better advertise to them. That isn’t a joke btw. For example women are far more susceptible to advertising based on their menstrual cycle. Gad Saad, of all people, wrote a very serious book about basically that.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoI honestly don't get the hate for modern cars that some people have. I recently got a 2023 Corolla, and it's fantastic: * Android Auto gives me a great GPS to navigate anywhere, anytime. It watches out for traffic, accidents, speed traps, etc. and keeps me informed and on the fastest route * I can have my phone's whole music library to listen to instead of fiddling with another copy on a USB stick that I'd have to keep in sync * Automatic headlights and brights * Automatic climate control (no more adjusting!) * Amazing MPG (I can get 48 on the highway) * Tire pressure sensors * Automatic parking brake so I don't accidentally ruin the transmission * Automatic lane centering and adaptive cruise makes hour long drives effortless. It's even great in the city. * All the safety features like brake assist, pedestrian detection, etc. It hasn't saved me from an accident yet, and hopefully won't need to - but it's great to know that it's there I basically never need to touch the screen except when initially setting up my route. Everything else is on the wheel or sticks. Seriously. Cars have never been better. Yes, if you're an enthusiast who wants a fun, sporty and unique car you're eating expensive scraps at the moment. But for MOST people, it's never been better.
- tredre3 3y agoI'm not sure if you're being deliberately obtuse or not, but this is an article about how cars collect telemetry. This is what everybody is talking about in the comments. I'm sure everybody here enjoys most modern car features you've listed. They just don't like being spied on.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoI know what the article about, but the comments of the post are full of unrelated new-car-hate, at least that's what I saw.
- dicing 3y agoFYI If you don't like that, you can act with Mozilla's petition: https://foundation.mozilla.org/fr/privacynotincluded/articles/car-companies-stop-your-huge-data-collection-programs-en https://foundation.mozilla.org/fr/privacynotincluded/article...
- rabuse 3y agoThis is why I ride a motorcycle.
- Glench 3y agoI signed the petition and donated to Mozilla after reading this article. This is really important work they're doing. https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/articles/car-companies-stop-your-huge-data-collection-programs-en/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/article...
- dmitrygr 3y agoFind and unplug cell antenna. Plug in 50 ohm resistor. Live happy.
- robbywashere_ 3y agoHow long before those screens start to play targeted ads and the data is shared across your devices, but you’ll get a discount on the msrp
- diego_moita 3y ago> security tests conducted by Mozilla I just bought a Kia Niro. So I read the articles on Kia and Hyundai (Kia controller) and couldn't find any "tests" on them. Most of it is just "the privacy policy says this and that" and "they may collect this and that". Not saying I am not concerned. But I'd prefer a lot less fear mongering and more hard evidence. Like my TV, will keep my car of the internet, then.
- anjel 3y agoHow much would you pay for a service to pull the Mfr's sim chip from deep inside your new car's dash?