15 ms·
Today I realized I now trust Microsoft more than Google. What is happening?
- joker_minmax 3y agoFrom the comments: >When you become a publicly traded company, promises like "Don't be evil" cannot be honored I'm usually the king of cynicism... but is this really what people believe?
- mikece 3y agoAnd Kevin Hart is taller than most female gynmasts. It's hard for any organization (aside form Congress and Facebook) to not be more trusted than Google.
- slavapestov 3y agoTimes are changin’. All you young whippersnappers wouldn’t believe that back in my day, Microsoft was evil, Apple was on the verge of bankruptcy, and Google was the scrappy upstart who prided themselves on not serving ads and irrelevant fluff on the search results page.
- foobarian 3y agoWell. They were proud of no fluff on the home page. But they had ads on SERPs, though they were text only ads with strict styling. This was good because they replaced evil Flash ads.
- manuelabeledo 3y agoIf you go back enough, Microsoft was the scrappy upstart, sort of. They were this small software company loved by most, the creators of Windows and Excel and all that. The amount of fuckery going on the background never saw the light of day back then. People seemed to be happy with them bundling more and more crap in their products, a move that killed most of their competition. They haven’t given up on that, to the point where they still bundle up apps that only play nice to each other. Google may be terrible, I won’t argue otherwise. But Microsoft has and will always try to control the entirety of the stack, from hardware to servers to operating systems to applications, in a way that would make any Apple exec salivate thinking about vertical integration.
- adventured 3y ago> Microsoft has and will always try to control the entirety of the stack > from hardware to servers to operating systems to applications, in a way that would make any Apple exec salivate thinking about vertical integration Apple has the world's most valuable integrated stack. At scale nobody integrates more tightly or better than Apple, and nobody makes more money from that tight integration. It's the foundation of their entire business and has been for a long time. That's a pretty bizarre premise to suggest Apple is lacking in the integrated approach. That's exactly what they do, very aggressively. Imagine Microsoft building their own processors and then Windows only running on those. You have the integrated salivation inverted, it's the other way around - Microsoft execs can only dream of the business gain they could have if they actually had Apple's level of ownership (over its ecosystem) but over everything Windows touches. Microsoft doesn't even have a play in mobile OS / mobile app stores. Whereas Apple is one of the duopolists in that critical segment.
- hx8 3y agoApple's vertical integration really ends at the cloud. There's iCloud, but that's a small offering. Microsoft has Azure, which extends their vertical integration in a direction Apple doesn't even try for.
- manuelabeledo 3y agoiCloud is not even a cloud, just a set of services running mostly on GCP.
- manuelabeledo 3y agoI think you may have missed the point here. You could start your computer, then your browser, then visit a few websites, and never interact with any product not owned by Microsoft, minus perhaps routers and switches. Your traffic could even be routed through some of the undersea cables owned by them, to ad networks ran in their massive cloud. > Imagine Microsoft building their own processors and then Windows only running on those. I’m old enough to remember the amount of leverage Microsoft has with the entirety of the x86 platform, e.g. [0] Microsoft does not need a proprietary hardware platform, although the hasn’t stopped them from trying to lock other OS out (see TPM). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....
- its_a_random_ac 3y agoGreat, now I'm thinking of my edgy teenage days calling them Micro$oft or just M$ on Gamefaq's forums.
- vouaobrasil 3y agoWhat's happening? Google is a company where you are not the customer, you are the product. They have also reached a mature stage where the only thing left to do is squeeze society tightly for short-term gain through psychological manipulation. I trust neither the company nor anyone working there.
- fgsfds028374 3y agoWindows 10 and 11 treat you as monetizable eyeballs now, too. It's not a clear cut dichotomy.
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoI am absolutely Google's customer. I give them money, they give me services. They don't sell ads to me. I even have a phone number I can call. It doesn't make them magically trustworthy or not.
- convolvatron 3y agoI think its a bit harsh to condemn all of the people working at google. its one of the few places left that has corners of real work going on. but yeah, I worked there very briefly, and the degree of whitewashing is really stunning
- throw__away7391 3y agoI generally avoid Google products, but I do not understand the animosity towards YouTube, nor why anyone would not just pay the very small fee for YouTube Premium and do away with all the ads. The content being created for YouTube is fantastic, you can easily watch news from all over the world, conference talks, lectures, interviews, in-depth documentaries and deep dive analysis that blows away anything you'll ever see on any mainstream platform. One particular strength is that creators don't seem too bound to producing videos for specific length of time. There are literally informative mini-documentaries 90 seconds long while others might go on for 4 hours and they cover every imaginable topic. This is definitely the last subscription I'd give up if I had to.
- goalieca 3y ago> I generally avoid Google products, but I do not understand the animosity towards YouTube, nor why anyone would not just pay the very small fee for YouTube Premium and do away with all the ads. Much of the “fantastic” content I do watch on YouTube has sponsored content in the video. Mostly I avoid YouTube.
- ImprovedSilence 3y agocorrect, but also for me, much of the usefulness of youtube is for looking up how to do something quick. This has been ruined by google emphasizing longer vids to up the “engagement” aka add time… and so now all of youtube has become the video equivalent of a recipe site…
- BlargMcLarg 3y ago>I generally avoid Google products, but I do not understand the animosity towards YouTube It's still a Google product that does Google things. If you hate Google things, making an exception for YouTube is saying your standards have a price tag attached.
- sowbug 3y agoPolarization plays better than nuance.
- dnissley 3y agoThis is going to be one of those areas where many (but not all) HN + reddit users will need to check their bubble at the door. Both Microsoft and Google are widely trusted brands whether you slice it by consumers, developers, etc.
- porkbeer 3y agoIts a standard. People trust it to work. That is Very different than trust in the overall ecosystem that is foisted upon them. Ask anyone how much they trust any EULA.
- assbuttbuttass 3y agoIt's wrong to "trust" any company. Use the products that make your life easier, but understand that companies don't care about you. They care about making money.
- giardini 3y agoThis. And they should. In our (mostly) capitalist economy a company not making money will course-correct or fail.
- candiddevmike 3y agoThis is a dumb take. They're both equally untrustworthy. VSCode has an insane amount of telemetry turned on, ChatGPT is monitoring everything you type, and GitHub was abused to train a LLM. Microsoft and Google have both shown they would sell your data in a heartbeat to make a quick buck.
- scrollaway 3y agoYou’re comparing vscode telemetry with “selling your data”? For real? Do you think the amount of time you spend in the File menu is as monetizable as your search history?
- candiddevmike 3y agoIt's quite valuable to vendors who are trying to gauge usage and interest, yes.
- scrollaway 3y ago… what? I don’t even know how to find common ground with such a take. You’re saying vscode telemetry (which can be turned off by the way) is as bad as other data monetization because building a better product is profitable? I hope I completely misunderstood you.
- dale_glass 3y agoIt's valuable to Microsoft, but why would anybody else want to pay for data about the usage of a Microsoft product? And why would Microsoft sell it? Like would you want to sell information like "X% of users can't figure out how to change the code formatting settings"? Or if you did learn something cool and useful, why would you sell it to the potential competition?
- adventured 3y agoA lot of tech companies would pay for that vast trove of user data. There are possibly no better sources on usage for mass consumer software than what Microsoft has from the past few decades (Office and Windows in particular; the next best would be browsers and or various Apple software). Why would anybody pay for customer traffic/browsing/shopping data for inside of a Walmart store? Nearly every retailer would pay for access to that, assuming the cost is reasonable. Vendors desperately want access to it. Microsoft would be crazy to sell it openly. Its part of their competitive advantage, helping to protect $83 billion in operating income. They'd get tiny particles of revenue in comparison to the gigantic golden egg they're sitting on.
- pxoe 3y agomake this make sense? what is this literally about? what is a coherent thought here? cause all that shows is just a haphazardly thrown together table of random stuff. microsoft has just as shitty of a track record with killing products, poor privacy and overt data collection/telemetry, and just shitty/stagnating products. like, remember that time they had a myriad of consumer products going on around windows 7/8 era, and then seemingly killed them all? windows phone, nokia/lumia, zune, xbox/groove music, microsoft band, and now cortana. a whole bunch of stuff that made up a holistic experience, that just does not exist anymore, not even presently within just microsoft.
- fgsfds028374 3y agoAnd the awful abortive DRM attempts that rendered your paid-for media unplayable when they lost interest. "PlaysForSure" lmao
- jrm4 3y agoInteresting, I still don't, though I acknowledge perhaps Google has the greater capacity for harm; here's why. Over time, Google absolutely has been in a position to abuse data, and to some extent it has done so -- but honestly, if you compare what they COULD do to what they END UP DOING, they're not doing so bad at all. They mostly self-correct relatively nicely. Microsoft, on the other hand, clearly does the bare minimum. They've had to be dragged kicking and screaming into actually providing a modicum of safety after more-or-less setting the stage for garbage tech security practices.
- saiya-jin 3y agoFrom my personal and limited view I agree. But to be honest, I don't trust neither, at all, probably forever. MS actively destroyed 1 decent thing I liked about them, their OS. First they tried to make it better and actually succeeded over the years (anybody who went from Windows 95/98 into 2000/XP and realized MS can actually make stable usable modern OS would probably agree, 7 was their best OS for me). And then they went with telemetry on product that really shouldn't have any, in same vein BIOS or drivers shouldn't have any. And despite overall feedback they doubled down with it in 11. No sympathy nor morality there.
- formerly_proven 3y agoAll of these companies are obviously totally untrustworthy and anyone trying to convince you otherwise is either incredibly naive, stupid or has an ulterior motive.
- jrm4 3y ago"Totally" is just unhelpful. They all have ideas and incentives and motives, and the world hasn't yet collapsed. Yes, watch them carefully, but, e.g. I don't think the world is improved if we just annihilate Google and Microsoft.
- imchillyb 3y agoNSLs and FISAs are insidious and powerful tools that the US Federal government utilizes against the populace. Once the government sets about forcing requirements, those two tools ensure that the companies, organizations, or individuals, cannot speak to the requirements or that there was a discussion at all. Never attribute to malice which can be easily attributed to stupidity. Secret courts, and secret squirrel government activities against its own populace are definitely stupid.
- karaterobot 3y agoMy model for this is that the top dog tries to change the landscape to serve their own interest, which makes them the bad guy. The underdog naturally opposes those changes, which makes them seem like the good guys, even though it's actually just self-serving. A defense. The underdog may even go the extra step and market themselves as the one who's on the user's side, the champion of privacy. I fell for this with Apple a few years ago. But really, all these entities are amoral and just looking for the best available path to pursue their own goals, and any decision made by any of them exists in the possibility space for all of them. It's not really trust that you should give them, it's an acknowledgement that they are (for the moment) the lesser of several evils.
- isoprophlex 3y agoThanks to the ongoing enshittification of big tech, it's basically pissing into an ocean of piss out there, and all these takes are all relative against a terribly odious baseline of dark patterns, customer-hostile data hovering and general cheapness. My point is... Is the observation in TFA because Microsoft is becoming more trustworthy or because Google is becoming shittier? Anyone who has had the displeasure of installing (let alone actually using) Windows 11 should know the answer.
- jasmer 3y ago[dead]
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoYou updated a bias that was originally strengthened by meme reinforcement more so than firsthand experience, after acquiring enough new facts and ideas and life experience to recontextualize it. Sounds very normal, why not ask instead why it doesn't happen more often?
- johnklos 3y agoIn my opinion, Microsoft is big and dumb, and they're evil in overt and obvious ways. Google, though, has lots of smart people, so they're cunning and evil in calculated and somewhat hidden ways. I mentally make these distinctions with other large companies. For instance, I consider AT&T big and dumb, whereas Verizon is super evil and likely has a Department of Evil (and I wouldn't be surprised if this were actually true).
- m0xai 3y agoWindows comes with Tiktok pre-installed. I don’t need to say anything else.
- huhtenberg 3y agoThe best part is that Microsoft and Google are working together towards the end goal of locking users out of their own machines. Microsoft is really pushing for its trusted OS platform, with a completely locked down kernel, that will grant them full control over what can and cannot be done on the computer. Google is pushing for the same, but in the browser space. Except their Web Integrity effort has no chance of succeeding unless there's an OS support. One guess who'll be providing that. Then, once all is in place, there will be a fully opaque content delivery pipeline from online servers to users' HDMI monitors. No peeking. And that's just one application of the trusted OS. Once people lose control over their machines, it'll open the floodgates for lot more nefarious opportunities. But, yeah, this new Microsoft is so white and fluffy that it's almost unbearable.
- semitones 3y agoDo you have any sources or evidence to support this claim?
- _silicon 3y agoTPM, Widevine, Web Environment integrity, NGSCB; codenamed Palladium, SafetyNet…
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nextos 3y agoSafetyNet is a good example. It makes it pretty hard to run your own OS and, at the same time, useful applications such as banking ones. We take the freedom associated with personal computers as granted, but these devices might be the exception rather than the norm.
- kristjank 3y agoPluton, PSP, Intel ME, Remote attestation, Secure Boot
- 3y ago
- didibus 3y agoI don't understand why he trusts VSCode, GitHub and ChatGPT but not Android and Chromebook? What kind of trust related difference does he see between them?
- fattybob 3y agoYeah, that been a while already!! But I still use google stuff as Microsoft apps are a real a real pain to use when it come to security setups a utterly useless really!!
- cwkoss 3y agoThere are no moral megacorps and Google is bigger
- wouldbecouldbe 3y agoMicrosoft just has really good PR. I see exactly the same in Dutch government. Im absolutely not allowed to deploy on Google cloud, because of GDPR reasons, yet somehow Azure is never an issue. Microsoft has been playing the government contract game for decades, and probably the biggest leeches of public money (next to some consultancies) ever existed.
- ftlio 3y agoGoogle search has become nearly unusable, while Microsoft’s core consumer products still seem OK - you can still install Windows 11 without a Live account through a workaround. I can run games on Linux and do work on a Mac. Search is still a problem, but I am increasingly turning to ChatGPT for searching anything non current event, with Bing increasingly. I was a full Google stack, Android, Home, TV, everything, for a few years. I don’t know about trust, but Google products just flat out suck with constant disappointment, and search is no exception.
- bagacrap 3y ago> Google search has become nearly unusable This is a weird meme given how many billions of searches Google handles daily.
- darklycan51 3y agoI legit have to go to bing (or duckduckgo if I wanna keep it private or so they claim at least) to get actual search results lol...
- bagacrap 3y agoThat's a fine anecdote but apparently unrelatable to the vast majority.
- ftlio 3y agoNot as weird as this meme. You assume it’s some signal expression rather than that I would just pay Google money every month to provide search results that don’t prioritize advertisements over more accurate results that don’t calculate a margin.
- pb7 3y agoYouTube Premium exists and there are still masses of people that refuse to pay for it despite hating ads. You’re in the minority.
- renewiltord 3y agoTerminally online behaviour. Completely unhealthy. None of these companies are going to have a significant impact on your life.
- fullshark 3y agoAt this point I just believe anything i see written on these platforms is from someone mentally unstable until they prove otherwise. https://www.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/9rvroo/most_of_what_you_read_on_the_internet_is_written/ https://www.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/9rvroo/most...
- convolvatron 3y agoas a computer practitioner I think google has done immense and irreperable damage to my field as a whole as a consumer, yeah. but I can still mostly avoid them.
- NotCamelCase 3y agoWould it be incorrect to call such associating with brands/ "loving" a company more (or less) an American thing? Why even spend any moment of your finite life pondering over behaviors of random companies, let alone defending one over another?
- theknocker 3y ago[dead]
- WisNorCan 3y agoDon't trust the company. Trust the business model. Eventually a company with great intentions will be dragged to do terrible things if it required to serve their business model. Google will ruin their user experience (e.g. YouTube, Google) and push the boundary on user privacy in the interest of more clicks & higher CPM.
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoI love VSCode, I use Google Workspace for my domain, run a Mac and an iPhone (and use iCloud), a Surface Go 2 with Linux (quite workable), I host on all sorts of stuff. Uncritically associating "trust" with a brand is a mistake. Microsoft are no more on the side of the angels than anyone else (and are very clearly on the other side in some of the legal positions they stake out, such as their amicus brief in support of Oracle against Google in the Java case). Pick a sports team if you must, but don't pick a brand and support them loyally. Be an interchangeable consumer, because this is how they model your behaviour anyway. Maximise that.
- duxup 3y ago> Uncritically Blindly pick one to trust sure that’s a poor choice. But we make choices based on our experience and what information we have. I won’t trust anyone forever blindly, but I will pick some for now over others who I find untrustworthy.
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoRight -- I mean if I was compelled by some weird fascist law to pick one brand to trust, I'd probably pick Apple. The fascists with the nicest things, for one thing, but they have also made commitments to privacy against which they can be measured. But I find it uncomfortable how much brain time we allow for making value judgements about brands -- it's a purely one-way emotional judgement, because as a general rule, not a single one of the people who run them would so much as piss on you if you were on fire in return. [ Edit: This is not particularly to be taken as an argument for open source; I don't think people in the open source space are inherently more trustworthy; they have just built mechanisms where I don't have to trust them individually or severally. We have to stop supporting "teams" in the tech world -- even at the level of employee loyalty. It's damaging, and not just to open source, but to human progress more generally. ]
- bee_rider 3y agoIMO the fact that the open source folks built those mechanisms indicates they they are inherently more trustworthy. I mean, in many cases the honest party is also the one happy to do things in the open.
- debacle 3y agoMicrosoft is a known entity. I know (or expect) that my outlook.com account is heavily datamined to the fullest extent of the most permissive interpretation of the law. Google was supposed to be not that, and so it's not that I trust Google less, it's that I don't know how much they can/can't be trusted in general.
- rrdharan 3y agoI don't know how anyone could trust Microsoft to do anything after the two biggest security blunders I've ever seen for someone of this scale: https://www.wiz.io/blog/bingbang https://www.wiz.io/blog/bingbang https://www.wiz.io/blog/storm-0558-compromised-microsoft-key-enables-authentication-of-countless-micr https://www.wiz.io/blog/storm-0558-compromised-microsoft-key...
- jvanderbot 3y agoI've said this before, and until I said it the first time I thought the oldies who said it were just being curmudgeonly boomer types ... It's all cyclic. One generations hero is the next's villain, and as we all move away from the villain we find new heros, those become villains as old heroes re-invent and we all move zigzag into the future. Just look at what happened with compiled / static vs dynamic / "productive" languages from the 90s to 2030s. It's been less of a roller coaster and more of a pendulum.
- darklycan51 3y agoI never will fully trust Microsoft for obvious reasons, but man I do sometimes snap back and look at how disgustingly closed everything has become ever since Google introduced their "guidelines" back during web 2.0 and just cringe
- arter4 3y agoIt's about the kind of power they have. Microsoft cannot get GPS data from your smartphone (no one uses Windows phones anymore), Google can. Microsoft cannot get the searches you made from your smartphone (see above), Google can because, regardless of whether you're an Android or iOS user, you most likely use Google as a search engine. Nowadays, people spend a lot more time on smartphones than they do on their personal computers. So, Google is far more powerful than Microsoft and arguably even Apple.
- esalman 3y agoWhile VSCode itself is open source, some of its most useful add popular Microsoft-owned extensions does not seem to be open. And I hate how reliant I am on those. The list includes remote ssh, Python etc. Without these extensions VSCode loses a lot of edge over other editors like sublime or notepad++.
- tlogan 3y agoI trust Google products less than Microsoft’s primarily because Google’s primary revenue stream is ads. This means their decisions are likely influenced by their ad division. While no tech giant is entirely trustworthy, we all have relative trust levels. It all about trusting and understanding their business model. If Google spun off their cloud division as an independent entity, I’d trust Google Cloud more than Microsoft’s offering.
- endisneigh 3y agoWhen I was a kid I’d spend time on these phpbb forums where people would argue about Nintendo vs Sony. Later that included microsoft too. Now it seems I have learned nothing since now I’m on forums where people are arguing microsoft vs Google vs Apple. “No company is your friend”, is what I’d say as a kid, and is what I’ll say now too. It must be something about human nature that creates this behavior.
- bob1029 3y agoI don't know that "trust" is the right word for the conversation that we are really trying to have... Looking at a corporation consisting of >100k employees to me means that any notion of trust is a very diffuse concept. You could talk to multiple small towns worth of humans and interact with their products & services without ever seeing the other half of the business. I believe I "trust" (in terms I think we are using here) Microsoft more than Google - for purpose of business - simply because of decades worth of inertia and ongoing happenstance. Not because of some principled notion of good vs evil manifest as corporate anthropomorphism. Little things like "I can still directly run my 90s code on my windows 11 box" provides very strong degrees of this for me - but only in isolated scopes. Who knows what the hell the xbox or office teams are doing over in their dark corners? Blowing away all this detailed nuance for "aggregate name good/bad" is (to me) the most hilariously shitty way to go about navigating technology when working with vendors who have trillion dollar market caps. On the other hand, I would "trust" Google to entertain me more than Microsoft via their products & services. I don't get much fun out of bing videos these days. If I had to get one thing across to the principled crowd - Pretend like you are playing an RTS when working with megacorps. Try to zoom your mini map in just a tiny bit so you can see how the one big red square is actually a shitload of smaller ones.
- croes 3y agoI trust Google less than MS because Google lost my trust and MS gained none.
- happytiger 3y agoI don’t trust either of them as far as I can throw them, and you shouldn’t trust them either. Businesses’ singular pursuit of short-term profits over the past four decades has kept wages down, utterly destroyed the environment, and eroded the global working-class. It is thus now difficult to trust the same corporations to “do the right thing” or “lead us to a better tomorrow.” Fool me once… Finding more or less trust in the newfound altruism of the very same companies at the heart of the system that created or supported all these negative externalities suddenly espousing new and reformed values is rich. I can’t believe anybody actually trusts them after looking at the state of the world they created. I grant the argument that you might trust one more than the other, relative to one another, but one thing the past century should have taught all of us is that we shouldn’t lend our trust to profit-seeking private companies as they aren’t incentivized to “do the right thing” generally. I’m all for collective efforts and even companies changing the world for the better. I just don’t think the current crop will suddenly reform with Aquarian awareness and become model benevolent entities suddenly worthy of extending our personal trust. Maybe after 4 decades of good behavior…
- uwagar 3y agothey could all be colluding with each other with master keys with the US govt.
- globalreset 3y agoYou got to be an idiot to trust any public or vc company. You can use their products and services when it makes sense, you should never trust them.
- zeruch 3y agoThe mistake is to trust either. The areas where one should scrutinize either may have deltas, but there is massive overlap between both (and really, all of the industry big players) on "trust"
- amelius 3y agoYou shouldn't trust any company, be it Google, Microsoft, Apple, Amazon, ... etc. etc.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- JEDI-HACKER 3y ago[dead]
- frankohn 3y agoI do not like when people take a shortcut and say that ChatGPT is from Microsoft. ChatGPT is from OpenAI. OpenAI is not part of Microsoft. They made an agreement of some sort but OpenAI is not part of Microsoft.
- camdenreslink 3y agoMicrosoft at least sells products. For Google, you are the product.
- pb7 3y agoWhich products? Like Windows which collects data about you to inject ads throughout the system and resets settings that turns it off with every auto-update that you can’t permanently turn off? How noble of them to also charge people for that privilege.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nologic01 3y agoBinary choices are better than no choices but chasing the 'least bad' option is really a sad state. Forcing interoperability, applying anti-trust, outlawing agressive adtech etc. are perfectly valid steps and would help create a large amount of competition and choice around technology. In such a scenario there would be also more opportunity for open source business models.
- smegsicle 3y agomicrosoft has been trying to remake their public image to court the os devs they previously shunned google hasn't needed to market themselves like that feeling any sort of 'trust' towards either, outside the context of something like a legitimate business contract, seems to me like a media literacy problem
- crabbone 3y agoI use GMail and Android. My job makes me use MSTeams, but I would've never used it if I had a choice. I probably use random bits of code contributed by both big companies to various programs on Linux... but this is about it. Also, the reason for me to use GMail is that I want to stick with the same email address, and migrating from GMail would've made it very painful. I use Android because the alternative is to use iPhone, which is even worse. If a free alternative becomes more realistic to use, I'll switch in a heartbeat. I worked for Google (through acquisition), and I know people who worked for Microsoft. I'd never apply to work for Microsoft. At least based on the impression I've received from people who work there. Of course, there are plenty of businesses Microsoft owns but doesn't actually "run", and things are probably very uneven across the board. Same is true for Google. So, when it comes to trust... It's obviously a very complicated subject. Different divisions in different organizations will have very different ability to generate trust. In my own experience, and when it comes to things that mattered to me throughout my career, I developed a strong distaste for anything branded with Microsoft's name just based on technical merits alone. Everything Microsoft was making for developers was designed to impress the rich people in the management who probably don't as much as own a computer. Since forever and to this day, Microsoft's products seem like idiotic ideas implemented by legions of slaves, who don't care about the outcome, but the complicated system of equally unmotivated slave drivers ensures the minimum acceptable quality. Google, on the other hand, gives out a very different vibe: there are a lot of motivated and competent people working for the company, and on an odd day once every few years they get to make a decent product. And then they move on and the product dies. Based on this completely personal and based on no thorough research feeling, I'd trust the first to make the worst but functional programs and the second to make programs of very uneven quality -- more of a gamble, but with much higher payoffs, if you win.
- rodolphoarruda 3y agoIs the concept of trust related to privacy somehow? Do I trust X because it won't share my data with Y? Well, that concept has been blurred to me. I live in a country where prosecutors can demand me to give them all my digital devices and the credentials to all my self-hosted and online accounts. So this fact by itself makes my trust on MS, Google or alike irrelevant from a data privacy perspective.
- jzymbaluk 3y agoYou can tell a lot about a company's priorities by how they make most of their money, and if you do that you see that Google is an Advertising/surveillance company disguised as a tech company, while Microsoft is a professional/enterprise services company disguised as a tech company. Obviously this isn't perfect because both Google and Microsoft are giant diversified companies with lots of revenue streams, but I think you can roughly understand the way they will behave by looking at them through this lens. This is why Google sinks resources into Android, but retires projects like their domain registrar: because android is an excellent advertising/surveillance platform: they can not only serve ads using Android, they can collect surveillance info on users to sell better ads. Conversely, Microsoft invests resources where they do because they want to make the Windows/Office useful for professionals at work. They are sinking billions into OpenAI so that they can develop their Office Copilot to make their Office/Windows platform more appealing to C-Suites writing emails and memos in Outlook and Word
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- binkHN 3y agoWindows 11 has become an ad platform that's worse than ChromeOS.
- MegaDeKay 3y agoOne plus I will give to Microsoft is their moves in the direction to Right To Repair. Most recently they've made spare parts for an xbox joystick available to order [0], having done something similar for Surface laptops a while back. OTOH, Google pushes planned obsolescence hard the way they limit OS updates for Android devices and (to a lesser extent) Chromebooks. [0] https://www.techspot.com/news/99615-you-can-now-repair-xbox-controller-using-official.html https://www.techspot.com/news/99615-you-can-now-repair-xbox-...
- leoc 3y agoAny discussion of what happened to Google has to start with the two individuals who together still control most of the shareholders' votes and together still have (IANAL) effectively almost completely control over it, Page and Brin. (Yes, they put someone else in as CEO: so what? Yes, they've largely disappeared from public view: so what? Page and Brin still exist and still control Google even if they have a lower profile than eg. Zuckerberg and even if they aren't jumping up and down in public like the current owner of Twitter: see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Object_permanence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Object_permanence . If Sergey Brin is able to start poking around inside Google again because he's worried about competition from OpenAI https://www.forbes.com/sites/richardnieva/2023/01/31/sergey-brin-code-request-lamda/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/richardnieva/2023/01/31/sergey-... then he's also perfectly well able to come back to scotch the Web Integrity API. The fact that he hasn't done the latter is simply a choice that he has made.) Some people are too young to remember, and some seem to have forgotten, how much Google's rise to dominance was enabled by the perception that Page and Brin were two fine young men who could be relied on to act with restraint and a sense of public responsibility—a perception which Google itself of course encouraged. If they'd had the same public reputation as Bill Gates or Larry Ellison then the early history of would likely have been very different. (Now, more fool the rest of us for putting stock in that perception, of course, but that doesn't let Page and Brin off the hook either.) So, what happened there? HR scandals and maybe health issues seem to have helped drive them out of public view. The end of Google's all-hands meetings also seems rather significant, though it doesn't seem clear whether it was more a cause or a consequence of other changes (Back in 2019 Steven Levy wrote "That’s why, when Google said Thank Goodness It’s Finished, it ended a lot more than a weekly meeting. Winter has come to Silicon Valley. And no beer for you." https://www.wired.com/story/google-shakes-up-its-tgif-and-ends-its-culture-of-openness/ https://www.wired.com/story/google-shakes-up-its-tgif-and-en... , which now seems prescient.) It also looks as if they simply got bored of running Google, and seem to believe that simply running Google is beneath them. Cut off from normal life, it also seems likely that they've been radicalised by an antisocial subculture of billionaires and cent-millionaires. But others must know much better than I do.
- DesiLurker 3y agoPersonally, I prefer incompetence & internal politics to Malice.
- Saphyel 3y agoIf you feel like Google is becoming hard to trust, let me introduce you Apple. If someone ask which company is more evil between the Wagner Group or Apple, I'd choose Apple without thinking.
- pb7 3y agoYou are comparing an organization that indiscriminately kills people for hire to a company that makes beloved electronics. You have an extremely, dangerously skewed sense of judgment and should not be taken seriously.
- pg_1234 3y agoMicrosoft sells you a product. With Google, you're the product to be sold. But Google pretends you're a customer, so you don't resist being sold. Google's business model is inherently more dishonest.
- vGPU 3y agoI don’t. I know I can trust both to do the exact same thing: spy on everything I do, turn any good products into complete garbage, and expect me to just deal with it.
- zzo38computer 3y agoYou can trust someone with some thing but not with another one, and someone else trusting differently. It isn't merely trusting someone more than someone else or less than someone else.
- say_it_as_it_is 3y agoWhat does it even mean to trust a company? What is it that you trust about them? I trust that they'll fire and replace every single employee with AI when they can. They will grow vast fields of humans, like in the movie The Matrix, to power their AGI, if they will get away with it (they're not really humans because they were grown, not born).
- Kon5ole 3y agoGoogles entire business model is about showing you ads, which few users actually want. When all your money comes from doing things users don't want its difficult to remain a popular trusted company.
- levischoen 3y agoMe everyday for the past 7 years
- jabofh 3y agoIs that not a bit like saying "I would rather have my arms amputated than have a frontal lobotomy"? I mean, while that's likely quite true, what i would RATHER have is neither of those two...
- m-p-3 3y agoYou're simply trusting the Microsoft pendulum to not swing back towards how bad they were. It's a cycle.
- bastard_op 3y agoApparently the writer missed that recently Microsoft was pwned so much that China was issuing their own access to government office365 domains recently, even refuses to discuss the matter for fear of reprisal. Or being the recognized leader as a malware runtime engines with their Windows products miscreants adore since the 90's on the 98% of all pc's globally, great since the OS already spies and reports on everything you do already to Microsoft or anyone else that's taken over your system due to inherent insecurity. Yeah, real trust-worthy. If you've seen even passingly Microsoft's security record for the past 30 years, you'd never trust them as anything but a (sadly) necessary evil for the blissfully ignorant. Of course Apple is now competing with Mac and IOS as the up and comers as a premium malware runtime engines, becoming as popular to infect as Windows since people have been mislead to believe it's somehow any more secure, but even just an iMessage received can infect.
- user6723 3y agoTrusting any of Microsoft, Google, or Apple... ngmi
- fortyseven 3y agoWeeks ago, I was enjoying lunch and good talk with my long time tech buddies. We're all Linux nerds, infosec adjacent, and we've been doing this shit since the early 90s at least. Before we parted for the evening, I had one question lingering in my head; none of us "trusts" a corporation. We each have a healthy dislike of Apple, Microsoft, and Google. But I had to ask: balls to the wall, if the end of the world was on the line and you absolutely had to pick a corporation to get cozy with, who would you reluctantly bed with? Each of us had no choice but to go with Apple. I was surprised as anyone, but the other two had somehow simply grown that much less in our estimation. (I had to agree, and I friggin hate Apple. ;)) Don't forget, we're talking hypothetically here. In reality they can all get stuffed.
- MrYellowP 3y agoWhat's happening is that you're falling for corporate propaganda. It's like trusting someone more, because he gives you what you want and tells you what you want to hear. While that's extremely common nowadays, it's also fucking stupid.