17 ms·
Why don't we get our drinking water by taking salt out seawater? (2008)
- konschubert 3y agoIsreal does. California also has desalination, no? If power costs are the driver then solar will be the answer
- retrocryptid 3y agoBecause it's expensive. There, saved you a click.
- motohagiography 3y agoIf you want anything to be economical or "worth it," you create the conditions where you are providing something to external parties, and the money will come in to sustain it. The economics of desalination are trivially viable if you can set up a stable financial regulatory environment in the region that has competitive taxation internationally. Desalination is economical in the middle east because they export oil. In Israel it's economical because they export tech knowhow, and have foreign income sources from their diaspora networks. Some people will moan about "tax havens! for the filthy rich!" But really it's just viable habitation for locations without a lot of resources to export. Favourable capital rules are a valuable export. We do this in customs-free zones around the world today. If you have those rules in an area that needs a desalination plant to survive, I guarantee you it's going to work really, really well.
- dukeyukey 3y agoSame in Australia - you've got a very wealthy population, living on the coastal outskirts of a wind/solar/coal heavy desert. Basically the perfect combo for desalination.
- AnotherGoodName 3y agoThe coastal areas of Australia have literally some of the highest rainfall anywhere in the world. Sydney has more annual rainfall than 'rainy' Seattle or London. For Australia the correct thing is to store the damn (or should I say dam) water that falls where people live.
- mr_toad 3y agoTransport costs are everything. There’s water on the coasts, but the cost of transporting it inland is too high.
- midoridensha 3y agoWhy would you transport it inland? The people live on the coasts. Are we talking about water for use by people, or for agriculture?
- dukeyukey 3y agoI imagine agriculture, but wow, I knew Australia's population was mostly coastal, but I looked it up and out on the 25 biggest Australian cities, only Canberra is inland.
- defrost 3y agoIn a delicious moment of turnabout is fair play, Jack Davis frequently referred to European Australians as fringedwellers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Davis_(playwright) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Davis_(playwright) https://ia.anu.edu.au/biography/davis-jack-17788 https://ia.anu.edu.au/biography/davis-jack-17788
- koyote 3y agoWhich is why the Sydney desalination plant is entirely (I believe) powered by renewables.
- golemiprague 3y ago[dead]
- parentheses 3y agoKnowing that the vast majority of water use is not the water flowing to homes for drinking, plants and washing, the government (local or federal) could subsidize it for individuals while taxing industrial water consumers. As mentioned in another post. Basic utilities can easily become affordable with proper regulation.
- shaunxcode 3y agoYet. Why don’t we yet.
- superb-owl 3y agoIt'd be helpful to know the minimal energy requirement to desalinate a gallon of water. With perfect technology, how expensive (in terms of energy) would it be? What's our current level of efficiency?
- Enginerrrd 3y agoDepends a lot on what you start with and on some of the other assumptions you make, but for seawater, the theoretical limit is probably ~3 kJ/kg, and the absolute state of the art full scale desalination is probably 11-14 kJ/kg
- nsenifty 3y agoOr about $0.20 per US person per day. Given average water use per person in US is 310 liters/day (82 gallons) [1] and average electricity cost/kwh is $0.17 [2], and assuming 14 kJ/kg. 310 * (14 / 3600) * $0.17 = $0.20. [1] https://www.epa.gov/watersense/statistics-and-facts https://www.epa.gov/watersense/statistics-and-facts [2] https://www.bls.gov/regions/midwest/data/averageenergyprices_selectedareas_table.htm https://www.bls.gov/regions/midwest/data/averageenergyprices...
- digdugdirk 3y agoHoly smokes, 82 gallons per day is wild. Is this inclusive of all tangential water usage as well? (industrial reasons, lawn watering, etc)
- fbdab103 3y agoI need to see a median number because 82 gallons indeed sounds outrageous for a consumer. Unless it is all-in calculation (agriculture + industry + consumers): America uses XXX units of water per year / # Americans.
- rpearl 3y agohttps://www.sdu.dk/-/media/files/om_sdu/institutter/iti/forskning/nato+arw/literature/residential+end+uses_of+water.pdf https://www.sdu.dk/-/media/files/om_sdu/institutter/iti/fors... This study found these uses for indoor residential use: 18 gpd toilet (~10 flushes), 15 gpd washer (~1 load every few days), 11 gpd shower (~5 minutes), 11 gpd from faucet (~5min of flow, this one surprises me), 9.5 gpd from leaks, 1 gpd dishwashing that's 65gpd right there. A ten minute shower and slightly more frequent laundry would easily get you 82gpd on indoor use only, ignoring any irrigation / outdoor use. Is that wild?
- YesThatTom2 3y agoWe need to figure out how to make cell phones out of the refuse salt / salty sludge. We’d find new ways to desalinate in a week!
- fullspectrumdev 3y agoI mean, we probably could extract industrially useful chlorine and sodium from it, if sodium batteries ever actually take off as a lithium replacement that could be extremely viable.
- wheelerof4te 3y agoWhere's that guy advocating for the desalination plants in Phoenix now?
- thunkshift1 3y agoAll comments seem to focus on the cost/energy requirements of the filtration process.. but the elephant in the room is the waste. How to safely dispose off the waste water after filtration completes? That water is virtually useless
- samtho 3y agoRun long tubes (1-3mi) out into then ocean with perforations so you can diffuse the highly salty water back into the ocean without disrupting local ecosystems.
- lovemenot 3y agoOcean-going vessels could be fitted to take on brine as ballast in port and gradually replace it with sea-water during their voyage.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThis has the useful side effect that it should prevent the transfer of invasive species in ballast tanks, as most cannot survive high salinity conditions.
- niemandhier 3y agoAre state of the art systems more efficient than the ion-pumps in cell membranes? I remember reading about light driven sodium and chloride pumps, if we could make these transport ions across some biomembrane we could desalinate water.
- jokoon 3y agoWhat about that small cheap device invention thing that can be used by people who live on the coast to produce enough drinking water?
- whatshisface 3y agoA kettle.
- drbojingle 3y agoSame reason as always: cost. If it was easy we'd be doing it long ago kn every boat and every coastal city.
- runjake 3y agoSpoiler: desalination requires a lot of energy.
- konschubert 3y agoSolar is cheap
- grej 3y agoSolar is cheap when active, and the good news this is one of the cases where intermittency doesn't really matter. We should really explore more use of intermittent power for cases like this where the limited reliability of wind and solar is less significant.
- nwiswell 3y agoIt's still significant if it means that your desalination plant is only active 50% of the time, since it means you need twice the capacity.
- grej 3y agoTrue. This condition only holds in situations where the energy costs dominate the physical plant costs
- lopis 3y agoFortunately, water usage is correlated with sun intensity.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Groxx 3y agoIf solar was cheap enough, it would be used. In a handful of places, it is. In the rest, it's so much more expensive than alternatives that it's borderline insanity to use it. Like ice: ice is cheap in Antarctica! But importing Antarctic ice to a desert would be absurd.
- bagels 3y agoArticle puts the cost to produce a cubic meter of water at $1-$2 In the bay area, I'm paying ~$2.80 per cubic meter. I don't see why it's not feasible. Yes, there are transmission/pumping costs. Assuming the water we're getting now is free, that's still only ~50-75% increase in cost over current costs.
- labster 3y agoArticle is 15 years old, energy and labor prices have increased a lot. We need a new cost estimate.
- pstuart 3y agoSolar prices have plummeted, and that use case can skip storage issues (just run when there's power available). Obviously land, labor, and infra cost are not so simple.
- RagnarD 3y agoNew technology is making it easier and cheaper. There's also the fact that environmentalist suppression of nuclear power has made electricity much costlier, intermittent, and much less reliable. https://scitechdaily.com/new-device-purifies-saltwater-over-a-1000-times-faster-than-standard-industrial-equipment/?expand_article=1 https://scitechdaily.com/new-device-purifies-saltwater-over-...
- graeme 3y agoThere’s an enormous amount of lithium in desalinated water iirc
- userbinator 3y agoWe actually do --- we just let the sun do it for us. ;-)
- labrador 3y agoI wonder how much it would cost in electricity to run a current through salt water to produce hydrogen and oxygen, then run the hydrogen through a hydrogen powered generator to recover most of the electricity and the fresh water byproduct?
- eterevsky 3y agoAlso Scientific American, 8 years later (2016): Israel Proves the Desalination Era Is Here (https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/israel-proves-the-desalination-era-is-here/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/israel-proves-the...)
- karteum 3y agoI found this a few years ago (uses only a simple low-tech design, simple materials, and heat from the sun. I don't know how efficient it really is) http://www.gabrielediamanti.com/projects/eliodomestico/ http://www.gabrielediamanti.com/projects/eliodomestico/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eftychis 3y agoFun fact: A good number of Greek islands end up using desalination. E.g. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/partner-content-where-our-water-goes-greece#:~:text=Greece%20already%20has%20enough%20desalination,island%20with%20complete%20water%20autonomy https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/partner-c.... And this is not by choice: Greece has to deal with extreme volatility in resource consumption throughout the year. Add to that it has ~6000 islands (around 200 being inhabited year round -- 227 as I google). And the tourist island/islet focus changes throughout the years. With this context, there can be no "I will create a pipeline of fresh water" or any other project like that really.
- yodelshady 3y agoRight, islands (and Israel) normally do because there's not the space for a large enough reservoir. We're playing silly buggers with economics again here; when it's rainy, "DeSaL iS uNcOmPeTiTiVe", because the "market rate" for water is pennies per meter cubed. Except, oh wait; suddenly it's dry, the "market rate" skyrockets" and large parts of your economy collapse. The "market rate" was always giving a massive* surplus to consumers, and now it's gone. This is A Bad Thing. Turns out it would have been better to have a slightly more expensive water source that was reliable. This fact is somehow obvious to everyone except economists, who should (at least in Europe) be called out as frauds for universally advocating along such idiotic lines.
- danbr 3y agoPractical Engineering just did a great video on Desalination. Why Is Desalination So Difficult? - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mxqOPdEUNTs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mxqOPdEUNTs
- afinlayson 3y agoI've read that we are starting up use other sources of heat to do desalination projects. There's so many sources of heat that we are just dissipating into the atmosphere. Nuclear or other power plants is an obvious choice.
- drawkbox 3y agoConcentrated solar stills is one way [1][2] A great thing about desalination with stills is it uses the natural water cycle, the water that comes out is cleaner than any other as it uses that. > A concentrated solar still is a system that uses the same quantity of solar heat input (same solar collection area) as a simple solar still but can produce a volume of freshwater that is many times greater. While a simple solar still is a way of distilling water by using the heat of the sun to drive evaporation from a water source and ambient air to cool a condenser film, a concentrated solar still uses a concentrated solar thermal collector to concentrate solar heat and deliver it to a multi-effect evaporation process for distillation, thus increasing the natural rate of evaporation. The concentrated solar still is capable of large-scale water production in areas with plentiful solar energy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_still https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_still [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concentrated_solar_still https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concentrated_solar_still
- jaimex2 3y agoCan desalination and electrolysis be combined so we have two useful bi-products? Clean drinking water. Hydrogen for for fuel.
- clement_b 3y agoFeels like a problem that will be solved as soon as incentives will be here, and cost of fresh water from other sources depleted or protected. The costs mentioned in this 15 years old article aren't that high in a world where we have to be careful with water. I wonder what is the reality now.
- squarefoot 3y agoWhy not using the sun to evaporate it, then collect the salt? Temperature have risen in the last 15 years, unless one wants to extract water only by desalination, it should be feasible, and could at least help less densely populated areas near the sea. Maintenance aside, energy costs would be negligible.
- jacooper 3y agoTLDR too expensive. It depends on the country though, countries like Saudi Arabia get most of their water though desalination.
- _0ffh 3y agoIIRC Israel even produces enough fresh water to establish a flourishing export business.
- nir 3y agoI don't know about exports but for certain there's quite a lot of water Israel transfers to Jordan as part of the 90s peace accords. That's a huge deal in the Mid East. For decades, the weather report in Israel would include the water level of the Sea of Galilee, the only real lake in the country and the source of most of the nation's drinkable water. It would be a major concern during droughts. Now there's so much desalinated water that some are actually being pumped into the lake, for environmental reasons.
- mhb 3y agoAlso big cruise ships.
- reaperman 3y agoQatar has no groundwater or surface water anymore AIUI. But they have an incredible oversupply of natural gas that they can’t build enough export capacity for. So it mashes sense to use the gas they can’t export to desalinate water, and they do.
- politelemon 3y agoIt would be ironic if they become a supplier of water to other countries too.
- Xeoncross 3y agoWhy don't we... money. Think of everything good in the world we could have but don't because we and everyone else want to keep as much money as possible.
- xcv123 3y agoThat's not how money works. Otherwise you could solve these problem by printing money.
- Xeoncross 3y agoThat's exactly how money works. People want it, so they cut corners and/or hoard it instead of being generous with it. Printing money would just mean someone would hoard the printed money (which, as you can see, already happens). Collecting money is just a side-effect of people being selfish.
- xcv123 3y agoFalse. The median balance for savings is only $5k in the richest country in the world. That is nothing. People are living paycheck to paycheck. https://time.com/personal-finance/article/average-american-savings-account-balance/ https://time.com/personal-finance/article/average-american-s... "American households, on average, have $41,600 in savings, according to data last collected by the Federal Reserve in 2019. The median balance for American households is $5,300, according to the same data."
- kelnos 3y agoIn this case, that's not really the issue. Yes, the issue is money, but it's not as nefarious and cynical as you make it sound. People don't want desalination, they want fresh water. If there are cheaper ways to meet water demand than desalination -- which is currently the case for most (but not all) places in the world -- then there's no need for desalination. Certainly as water scarcity becomes more of a problem, we'll have to re-evaluate this situation, and at some point desalination may end up being competitive with the alternatives. We also might find more efficient (cheaper) ways to do desalination, which could tip the scales toward it earlier.
- Arnt 3y agoThe article sidesteps something that seems important to my naïve eye: Water is easy to store if you don't have very much of it, so this is the kind of thing you can do when the sun is shining and store for nights and rainy days. Storing water for a year or two would be hard, of course.
- slv77 3y agoReturn on capital and deprecation tend to exceed energy input costs for most plants so it makes sense to run them 24x7x365 rather than over-size them and run them when energy costs are lower.
- Arnt 3y agoThey tend to exceed energry costs because energy costs are dominated by the cost of purchasing oil, which is as easy to store as water. We're moving away from that now, towards a world where solar power plants produce power at stunningly low prices some of the time (like €0.01114/kWh on the top google hit just now) and those who need a lot of power and can adapt their usage to match solar power plants can make use of those prices.
- quertered 3y agoThere are also times where energy cost is negative and you'll actually get paid to consume it. Consumers don't typically see this of course
- nonethewiser 3y ago> They tend to exceed energry costs because energy costs are dominated by the cost of purchasing oil The energy costs are tied to oil because thats the cheapest option. Well, besides coal. If solar were cheaper wed be using it.
- kelnos 3y agoSolar is cheaper anywhere you get a decent amount of sun. Much of the resistance to solar is not due to cost, it's political: all those places with big coal economies get pissed off when their services are no longer needed, and vote you out of office if you push renewables too hard. Ditto for oil.
- blurker 3y agoIt's surprisingly difficult to separate salt from water to the point that it's drinkable. That difficulty translates to it being very costly and that cost is so prohibitive that most places will choose another option. Like even building massive pipelines to transport water across 1000's of kilometers is probably going to be a better option. It's pretty much always going to be more economical to use the water that the earth is naturally desalinating for us.
- slashdev 3y agoActually it's quite cheap, and Israel does it at scale, among other places. It's just still much more expensive that just pumping free fresh water from rivers, lakes, and ground water. So you'd only do it if water were actually scarce. I think this is why the scare-mongering over fresh water availability (agriculture excluded) is mostly just hot air. Fresh water is only scarce at ridiculously low prices. Raise the price and the market will solve the problem quickly. That matters for agriculture, but not for human consumption. Even many dry regions that are far from the ocean, like the southwest US, only have water problems because most of it is used for agriculture at ridiculously low prices. Price it appropriately and that will end very quickly and there won't be any shortage.
- zbrozek 3y agoThough the southwest is a great place to farm if you have the water to leverage the sun and the relative dearth of pests. Given the economic potential of a huge fraction of the country, I'd wager that getting water there will be worthwhile within my lifetime. I'd love to see an aqueduct covered in solar panels roughly along I-40. Drain the too-wet southeast to irrigate the too-dry southwest.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> Though the southwest is a great place to farm if you have the water to leverage the sun and the relative dearth of pests. Given the economic potential of a huge fraction of the country, I'd wager that getting water there will be worthwhile within my lifetime. The reason for the dearth of pests is that it's a desert. If you change that, the pests will arrive just like everything else does.
- klaustopher 3y agoGreat video explaining this in some more detail: https://youtu.be/mxqOPdEUNTs https://youtu.be/mxqOPdEUNTs
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoIs there a video of a physicist answering this question? Why is this problem so difficult?
- Metacelsus 3y agoSee also: a way to potentially do this with no energy input (exploiting density differences): https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.183.4121.157 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.183.4121.157 Basically you put a reverse-osmosis membrane at least 231 meters deep in the ocean. If you put it deeper, you could potentially extract both freshwater and energy.
- Natsu 3y agoJust dig a ditch from California to Arizona, then use the sunlight to evaporate the water. Easy, right? :)
- jrockway 3y agoThat's the most common way of collecting drinking water, right? Sun evaporates water from the ocean, then it condenses in clouds, and the clouds rain into a river which we suck the water out of. Boom! Plus you can get electricity out of it.
- MarkMarine 3y agoThat is amazing! I’d never thought of leveraging the pressure of ocean depth for this, it’s a great idea. For anyone reading, the energy that OP is talking about would actually force the fresh water above the surface of the ocean without pumps. I didn’t get to the whole paper, but I imagine the challenges of keeping that membrane clean are remarkable.
- Metacelsus 3y agoYeah, I thought of it a few years ago, then realized I'd been scooped by ~40 years. But given the advances in technology maybe it's possible today?
- tinus_hn 3y agoTechnology will never advance enough to enable the perpetuum mobile device, which is what this is, unfortunately.
- AshamedCaptain 3y agoIn addition, voters complain about the taste.
- josh_fyi 3y agoIn Israel they add minerals back in because the desalinated water is too pure.
- politelemon 3y agoI've vaguely known that what the taste is related to minerals. Does anyone know what kind of minerals they're adding back in?
- theatrus2 3y agoUsually a combination of calcium carbonate (or bicarbonate for solubility), calcium chloride, magnesium chloride, and or the sulfate versions of the chlorides.
- seu 3y agoIndirectly related: https://seawatergreenhouse.com/ https://seawatergreenhouse.com/ "The idea behind the process is simple. It combines two unlimited resources - sunlight and seawater - to provide ideal growing conditions for crops in hot, arid environments. The innovation utilises the cooling and humidifying power of water vapour produced from evaporating salt water. Using modeling and simulation techniques developed in collaboration with our partners at Aston University, we are able to process local climate data to predict greenhouse performance and inform the design. The combined effect of reducing temperature and increasing humidity, together with providing a protected environment for crops, results in up to 90% reduction in evapotranspiration. This greatly reduces irrigation requirements, which can be provided by desalination, and improved growing conditions. As a result operating costs are lower, yields increase, and farmers can benefit from year-round production of high-value horticultural produce. "
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoSo many newer attempts since then it feels like, different approaches Like this Creating Drinking Water Using Ocean Wave Power (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10522700 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10522700) But what happens to them? Initiatives never seem to go anywhere far....... energy requirements.... no financial incentive/interest? Same sort of tepid interest as general climate change initiatives?
- admax88qqq 3y agoLack of drinking water is sadly mostly an issue in poor countries, so there's little money to invest/spend on new ways of creating it.
- quertered 3y agoQuestion: why is desalinated water costs calculated based on as if the water was immediately thrown back into the ocean? Wouldn't it rather be recycled after once desalinated?
- e_y_ 3y agoRecycled water is usually considered non-potable, so while it can be reused it's usually not available for drinking water and needs separate pipes.
- quertered 3y agoThough there are processes that turn it back into potable water, just reusing it even once in agriculture would bring huge cost savings compared to having to desalinate it again, which is why I wonder why there doesen't seem to be any studies of the realistic likely costs of desalinated water when accounting for reasonable reuse
- IshKebab 3y agoBecause it's easier to desalinate salt water than sewage?
- quertered 3y agoHow would salt end up back in sewage?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoWe do in some places. But in other places like California NIMBYs and greens decided putting extra salty brine back into the ocean was worse than taking fresh water run off from the inland, worsening desertification Really mostly nimbys. Greens have relented. Nuclear desalination would solve a lot of the fresh water problems but we can't have solutions now can we?
- Gibbon1 3y ago> Really mostly nimbys. Greens have relented. Head in the Sandies is probably even more encompassing. From people that tink the solution is drilling for oil in national parks to people thinking suing developers and separating their trash is all you need to do. They're stupid people. Neither should be influencing policy. Seems to me that the usual historical options aren't acceptable. Business as usual looks bad. The traditional solution, genocidal warfare seems like a really bad idea for someone living in an industrial civilization. We could degrowth. But the Khmer Rouge tried that in the 1970's and back to the rice fields didn't work very well for most people. So seems like technological mitigation is all we can hope for.
- kelnos 3y agoGreens have relented probably because there are safer ways to put the brine back into the ocean that don't disturb ecosystems all that much.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoFrom a cursory search, the greens have lost their bite simply because there isn't an alternative. Water supplies are drying up and the alternatives would end up being losing political power. The state approved 3 new plants this year alone and more are coming.