14 ms·
> A 60lb e-bike can also transport a 200 lb person whilst using far less resources (both to make the vehicle and to operate it) and space. E-bikes are great fo
by Aurornis 3y ago
> A 60lb e-bike can also transport a 200 lb person whilst using far less resources (both to make the vehicle and to operate it) and space.
E-bikes are great for the situations, climates, and people who can use them.
E-bikes are not a substitute for the majority of people’s transportation needs.
I think the young, healthy people who live in moderate climates with good weather, short commutes, and little need to haul anything often forget that they’re own transportation needs don’t match the average person’s.
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> and little need to haul anything often forget The dutch created the cargo bike for this very reason. But they have the climate and biking infrastructure to support that kind of lifestyle. We (Americans) don't, I wish we did.
- tjohns 3y agoCargo bikes are great, but when I think of "hauling things" I think of items much larger than would ever fit there. You're not going to haul lumber or sheet metal in a cargo bike, and that's the easy case.
- pg314 3y agoWhy not? I do.
- porsupah 3y agoFunny you should mention such use cases.. https://philsturgeon.com/carry-shit-olympics/ https://philsturgeon.com/carry-shit-olympics/
- jeffbee 3y agoWhen I haul lumber—small homeowner amounts, not construction crew amounts—I always use my bike because with my bike trailer I can haul lumber of any length, while it's not safe to use my car for anything longer than 8 feet.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoYou aren't going to haul lumber in a sedan or a compact car either, so sure? Although, yes, you do haul lumber in a electric cargo bike in some countries (e.g. China), although I wouldn't call it a very wise thing to do.
- fnimick 3y agoMost Americans buy insanely large SUVs or pickup trucks as their family car though, for that 1 time a year they need to tow something or possibly carry something big. I'd rather not spend all my money on a rapidly depreciating asset that harms the environment around me, is hard to park, and runs the risk of running over children because I can't see them over the hood... but what do I know. Apparently supporting car alternatives is being "opposed to progress" in this country.
- sobkas 3y ago> Most Americans buy insanely large SUVs or pickup trucks as their family car though, for that 1 time a year they need to tow something or possibly carry something big. Myth that SUVs have big baggage space is a just that, a myth. Most of them have essentially less space than normal cars with similar usage pattern. Station wagons, vans and many other are better in this regards and also are safer for users and pedestrians alike.
- blq10 3y agoWe are talking about crossovers here, which are all almost universally modeled after the Outback, the only station wagon brand that is still actually producing cars. Slightly raised car like vehicles with a full fold down back row, I can and have moved regular sheet ply in one.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThat's regional. The most popular SUVs are slightly raised sub-compacts (cross overs), where I live most people still have sedans (mostly sub-compact or compact). You can get really popular as the one guy/girl with a pickup who people can call on to help them move that one time a year. I know someone who met his wife that way.
- InSteady 3y agoBelieve it or not I've seen it done with a burly e-bike and custom made bike trailer. I've even seen someone hauling a 12" tall potted tree on a trailer, and that was back before e-bikes were a thing. Not that I'm arguing it's super practical, but it's kind of neat that there are open possibilities for those who are determined and creative.
- 8note 3y agoThe climate isn't a big deal, finland has the climate for biking too, it's mostly about having the infrastructure and maintaining it. If cold was a problem, cars wouldn't work either because they'd be unable to handle snow. However, we maintain our car infrastructure and plow the roads
- briandear 3y agoCars have heaters. Bikes don’t. Transporting a baby in freezing rain on a bike is a non-starter. I’m sure it could be done, but why? Cars represent progress. Bikes as a primary form of transportation is a regression.
- skyyler 3y agoTo some people, cars represent consumerism, not progress. Most normal people take public transit into consideration when moving to a new place.
- lotsoweiners 3y agoConsumerism sounds like progress to me. It’s the reason I don’t wake up and farm my land or sew my own clothes. Sure, there is a lot of shit products nowadays but that seems caused by corporate profit seeking and globalism.
- skyyler 3y agoExactly! Corporate profit seeking is why most cities in the US don't have functional transit systems. Car ownership is forced upon us here. Some of us would prefer a functional system of busses and trains.
- snarfy 3y agoCars externalize their problems. If cars internalized their problems the tailpipe would come out of the dashboard.
- sitkack 3y agoAnd that is a new thing, they paved the canals are going down the route America did and reversed it. America got conned into a car, suburbia, new construction scam that benefited a small number of rich people. A bike lane is a street you don’t let cars drive on.
- evandale 3y ago> A bike lane is a street you don’t let cars drive on. This is the reason why motorists lose their minds over bike lanes. It takes up space on THEIR roads and they hate when they can't use roads they personally paid for with THEIR taxes. I personally find it hilarious they think their taxes cover the maintenance of even 1/10th of a km of a road let alone all of them they drive on all year.
- autoexec 3y agoMost motorists I know love bike lines because it means they won't have to deal with bikes behaving badly in the street. If the amount of space the bike lane takes up really does narrow the road enough to be a problem that road should be expanded, redesigned, or moved so that there's plenty of room for both. We do pay taxes so that we can have nice infrastructure and that makes us entitled to it. We should be upset when it's substandard. Cities just need to do their jobs and put our tax money to work for us.
- briandear 3y agoI love My car. Glad I don’t have to wait in the boiling hot weather for a streetcar going to wherever the streetcar goes. Especially these days when many US cities are cesspools of crime, addiction, and homelessness.
- fragmede 3y agoI love my car, to the point of it being a little weird, but driving it in stop and go traffic, for hours on end, every single day sucks. Or endless highways, like on the drive from Boston to San Francisco. I bet a couple of readers have a route immediately in their minds when I said that. Glad I don't have to do that and can ride a train/bus/subway/trolly/scooter/ebike/bike/onewheel, especially when many US highways are a cesspool of highways and mcmansions.
- z3ugma 3y agoThat’s false. Watch this video for a good explanation why: Why Canadians Can't Bike in the Winter (but Finnish people can) https://youtu.be/Uhx-26GfCBU https://youtu.be/Uhx-26GfCBU via @YouTube
- nerdbert 3y agoThey work for the majority of people of all ages who live in cities where the infrastructure has been properly built to accommodate bikes. Most people rarely need to haul anything and can use carshare when they do. I've demoed a multistory house down to the bricks and re-built it from the outside in without a car. Hired someone to haul off a dumpster several times. For major materials deliveries, like beams or windows, usually it was the better part of a flatbed truck anyway, so I wasn't going to be doing that in a car. Most of the rest I did with a cargo bike. I only two or three times even bothered to use carshare (e.g. for a load of tiles) even though it's cheap. I'm not at all proposing that professional builders work this way, but also a relatively small proportion of the population are professional builders. And doing it this way wasn't any kind of a drag for me.
- birken 3y agoSelf driving electric cars are much better than car shares as they'll have significantly higher usage rates and eliminate much of the need for parking spots in dense downtown areas. If you believe car shares are part of an efficient transportation future then self-driving cars are part of it!
- jackvalentine 3y agoDidn’t uber promise the same thing and end up just adding to traffic with all the dead head trips?
- cmdli 3y agoConsidering that the vast majority of US cities were built with cars in mind, we probably aren’t in a position to use bikes anytime soon. And this isn’t just about the availability of bike lanes, but also things like the density of housing, the location of shopping, the infrastructure for big box stores, etc. These things will take decades to change, at best, so improving cars in the meantime is worthwhile.
- InSteady 3y agoThis is true, but ROI on improving infrastructure and city-planning to revolve more around bikes and other alternative forms of transportation is going to be way higher in the long run if done thoughtfully. Especially as e-bikes continue to get better and more affordable. It's definitely a "porque no los dos" situation. And while I'll grant you I'm no expert, some things I've read strongly suggest that improvements to city planning that making it more friendly for bikes, pedestrians, and transit commuters also tend to benefit the vast majority of drivers in various ways.
- kiba 3y agoCargo bikes are a thing. It's also why we have ebike so we don't have to be hyper fit. The need to haul weekly grocery is greatly reduced with proper urban planning like corner stores and walkable streets. Bad weather can be mitigated through proper clothing. In Finland, people ride their bikes through the winter.
- briandear 3y ago[flagged]
- hcurtiss 3y ago[flagged]
- fnimick 3y agoYour car gives you a private benefit at a public cost. That's the problem. Car infrastructure is ruinously expensive and the effects of driving harm everyone, either from the pollution generated in the long-term or in the short-term when statistically you are 100-300x more likely to kill someone than if you were on a bicycle.
- hcurtiss 3y agoMaybe. It seems to me that the development of cars has coincided with radical improvement of human wellbeing on every conceivable measure. Yes, you would pollute less if you rode a bike. And even less if you walked. And even less if you never left the house. But having a car opens up a world of possibilities and luxuries that a hundred years ago were simply unimaginable. Most reasonable people would agree that those extraordinary benefits merit some trade-offs.
- fnimick 3y ago> having a car opens up a world of possibilities and luxuries that a hundred years ago were simply unimaginable. [citation needed] Many wonderful cities and regions around the world are perfectly enjoyable with no need for cars. Or are you telling me that people living in central Paris, or London, or New York, or Valencia are suffering a substandard life because they use public transit and walk or bike to their destinations instead? Even regional travel can be easily done without a car - I recently traveled from Edinburgh, to Glasgow, all the way up to Fort William, then back from Skye all the way back to Edinburgh with no car. At no point did I wish I had one. Why is this so hard for us in the US to accomplish?
- jackmott42 3y agoNo, we want to change the long commute situation and change the way roads and cars are so that bikes are not a terrifying option.
- Swenrekcah 3y agoAlmost everyone can use an ebike, to be young and healthy is not necessary. Almost never do people need to haul stuff that can’t fit in either a cargo bike or a small bike trailer. Bikes are used in all possible climates and weather, you just need to dress for the occasion. There are definitely uses for cars. They are a necessary option for people but in a city they really should be one of the last options.
- jeffbee 3y agoE-bikes and indeed bikes in general are mobility devices. About half the U.S. population is unable to drive a car for some reason: age too old or young, disability, licensure, or economic. The majority of disabled people who cannot operate a car can operate a bicycle instead. Bicycling is much more inclusive than driving.
- psd1 3y agoCould you go into the disability point a bit more? I can't believe that the common case of physical disability is that you can cycle but not drive.
- Swenrekcah 3y agoNot parent poster but I can imagine for one thing that electric cycling is an excellent way for frail people to keep their strenght while still having a practical way to go about their business. For people who have had accidents it’s proably also a good physical therapy tool.
- TaylorAlexander 3y ago> I think the young, healthy people who live in moderate climates with good weather, short commutes, and little need to haul anything The old dutch people riding their bakfietsen around in the snow show this is much more a cultural thing than a hard fact of weather and human nature - and culture can change as the need arises. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rQhzEnWCgHA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rQhzEnWCgHA As far as short commutes - that's as much a factor of public policy as are trains and other forms of public transport.
- doktrin 3y agoYou are giving culture an awful lot of credit while completely omitting geography. Culture is locally adapted, and countries that are flat as literal pancakes are particularly logical places for a bike friendly culture to develop.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoParent didn't mention geography. I was mostly replying to the comment about weather, age, and cargo capacity. Obviously the difference between the Netherlands and some other flat cold place is culture, though you are right hills can impact things. One thing we can do to reduce the issue with hills is set better (higher) power limits for ebikes. The current limit in the USA of 750 watts is way too low for cargo bikes. Even for my normal ebike which I run at 1400 watts, I find it feels safer as I can keep up with the flow of traffic on city streets (though I have a lot of lighting, safety gear, and experience and I would support licensing restrictions for higher powers). The power restrictions are even worse in the UK at maximum 250 watts, which is terribly low.
- Perseids 3y agoAt everyone who can't imagine how life without a car could be possible: Watch this video! (The video linked in my parent post.) It really captures how different transportation and everyday life can be. As a whole, reading this biking thread is an amazing example in failure to understand how a lot of small lifestyle decision lock you in a particular mode of living. I know that much of northern America is not really bike friendly. But, damn, looking at it from a German urban perspective, it does not seem like you were even trying. (And I can't blame you for that because you were missing the role models to follow.) Half of my friends don't own a car, many of them have children. They started out by not ever having a car in the first place. We chose the cities we live in, the jobs we work for, the daycare facilities we commute our children to, all with the implicit assumption that owning a car is not desirable. A second factor that is really underappreciated is habit. After about one and a half years of commuting to work by e-bike in various tolerable weather situations, I encountered the first really harsh road conditions. Not just snowy, but icy ground everywhere (which was definitely not fun for cars either). But because I was so used to dealing with bike challenges by then, overcoming yet another (though harder) bike challenge was so much more comfortable to me than working out the alternatives. Same with the day I was somewhat sick and there was intense, icy rain. (Nowadays I would have the decency to stay home when being sick, even though they "need" me at work). So basically the answer to "How could biking ever work?" is "We make it work" – like with everything in life. And in the right environments, the upsides are enormous.
- housemusicfan 3y agoThey're also ignoring that they smell terrible when arriving to the office. Nothing like showing up to work all sweaty and stinking all day because you're a "cyclist", somehow their coworkers are meant to tolerate this abhorrent behavior. Downvote all you want; it violates the unwritten social contract you accept when working in a shared office with fellow humans. Furthermore, the spandex looks silly and is worthy of ridicule.
- Aeolun 3y agoMost people cycle in their normal clothes at a sedate pace. They no more arrive sweaty at the office than someone that walked.
- barnabee 3y agoAs another commenter mentioned, you don’t have to bike (or walk) so fast you turn up drenched in sweat. But even if you do, since cycling exploded in popularity over the last decade or so, many (most?) offices here in London now have showers, and those that don’t are getting upgraded fast (as tenants are generally not interested in offices without them). Cities adapt to the needs of their citizens, it becomes a non-issue.
- amelius 3y ago> E-bikes are not a substitute for the majority of people’s transportation needs. We should probably also drastically alter our transportation needs, by the way.
- bobbylarrybobby 3y agoPeople’s transportation needs have been built around the existence of the car. The actual needs — commuting, running errands, visiting friends — can be accomplished just as easily on an e bike, if only we built cities without cars in mind.
- kodah 3y agoThis is a silly oft-repeated notion. The city of Portland had maintained bikes alongside cars for decades and was the most bike friendly city in the country - still primarily built for cars because of the snow we get up here. That only ended when we expanded buses and trains alongside getting rid of our cities traffic division.
- InSteady 3y agoI almost convinced myself you were talking about Portland, Maine because what you're saying doesn't fit at all with my experience here. We get one stretch of 3 days of snow per year on average, usually 2" or less when it comes at all. Many, many years there is nothing that sticks. Rarely do we get a week or more. IDK about the city's traffic division, but Trimet expansion has not exactly been off the charts compared to how it's been the previous 3 decades. Also, most people don't know this but Trimet is funded by Metro, not the city government (Metro is an small regional government that spans parts of several -edit 23 - cities and three counties, including Portland and nearby suburbs). Also, there is an absurd notion that you can't bike in the snow... you absolutely can. You wouldn't want to be doing much more than 5 miles unless you are in great shape, I'll grant you that, because it's much harder going. But extremely doable, you just need some basic snow-appropriate tires and gear just like you would want for your vehicle. Anyway, over half the city shuts down when we get bad snow but Trimet keeps running. Can always throw your bike on a bus (or skip the bus entirely) if the snow days happen to fall midweek, and your work needs you in. If Trimet actually shuts down that means like 90% of the city or more is also shut down, and that happens maybe once a decade. The city has never been bike friendly like Europe, with a significant percentage of routes fully physically separated from cars (eg concrete barriers). But the city is as bike friendly today as it has ever been. Potholes notwithstanding. At least that's how it seems to me, and I do get around. It's easier than ever to chart a route that avoids major arterials but has decent roads that aren't full of constant stop signs and bad infrastructure for riding quick and easy. The proliferation of greenways in the past 5-10 years has been great, and in more recent years they've created some one-ways, concrete barriers, and other impediments for drivers who try to beat traffic by blowing through the intended bike routes. I get it, traffic is terrible and getting worse all the time, but the city certainly is making an effort to make things safer for bikers and peds despite the awful commute situation and seemingly ever-shortening tempers. I'd argue the speed limit reduction to 20mph in residential areas and liberal use of speed bumps and other measures on the few remaining 25mph residential streets has done wonders for bike-friendliness that probably doesn't get as much attention as it should. They are even slowly changing stop-sign positioning on residential streets to better inhibit cars trying to cut through going parallel to major arterials and facilitate better bike-routes where you can keep the right of way for most of the route between major intersections. Sure, traffic keeps getting worse and drivers keep getting more impatient and careless. But the city keeps investing in reasonably bike-friendly infrastructure, despite the vocal minority who always complain about it. There are more safe-ish bike routes than ever. If only more drivers would look carefully both ways while doing their rolling stop at the stop sign to get across the greenway I'm riding down with the right of way... If we lost our "bike friendliest city" title I imagine that just means somewhere else is doing way better, not that we are doing particularly worse. Don't get me wrong, we could and should do MUCH better. I just don't expect much from city hall these days. We've never really recovered from the popularity and and growth that came in the early-mid 2000's. Lived here 35 years, never owned a car.
- projectileboy 3y agoGo ahead and downvote me all to hell, but the comments in this thread from bike enthusiasts sound like Trump apologists - they are alike in their adamant refusal to acknowledge reality. Do you think any amount or quality of bike infrastructure is going to make most people willing to bike in harsh winter climates? And no, Copenhagen nor Amsterdam have harsh winter climates. Look, I too think it’s crazy that we’ve built our society around cars, but saying that everyone should ride e bikes year round is such an ageist, ableist load of horse shit that I don’t know why I’m even surprised to see it on HN.
- bitsage 3y agoWidespread bike adoption, especially in the US, is idealistic, but it’s still more realistic than self driving cars being able to solve our transportation woes anytime soon
- lotsoweiners 3y agoTransportation woes? I just want an Uber where I don’t have to make small talk. Waymo seems to fit the bill.
- abenga 3y agoAvoiding small talk seems like the most trivial of reasons to begin using autonomous vehicles. I mean, I get it, but still …
- z3ugma 3y agoFinland is as snowy and as cold as Minnesota. Yet Oulu has 22% of all trips completed by cycle and 77% of people say they cycle at least occasionally. It’s you who is not acknowledging reality. Why Canadians Can't Bike in the Winter (but Finnish people can) https://youtu.be/Uhx-26GfCBU https://youtu.be/Uhx-26GfCBU via @YouTube
- TulliusCicero 3y agoYes. Just look at Oulu, which is much snowier/colder than most cities in the states. But also remember that the objective isn't to have all or even necessarily a majority of trips by bike. Not even Amsterdam has most trips by bike IIRC.
- Dylan16807 3y agoDo you mean they can't replace almost all trips for a majority of people, or do you mean they can't replace a majority of trips? I bet they can replace a majority of trips.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoThey probably could, but it's totally fine to have walking and buses and trains too. And yes, some trips will still be cars/trucks. Even in places with the best public transit in the world, there are still cars.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- unethical_ban 3y ago[flagged]
- arcticbull 3y agoI disagree, I think they’re completely adequate for the majority of people. Between that and a backbone of busses and subways and trains, cars in the city basically don’t need to exist. They act as a crutch for shitty city planning, since you don’t have to (and sometime can’t) build communities where what you need is close to where you live.
- dumpsterdiver 3y agoNot only that, but clearly they don't live in outback, rural areas. They live in high cost of living cities. Old estimates claim that 55% of the worlds occupants live in urban areas, while 45% live in rural areas. The proposed solution leaves nearly half the population of the world shit out of luck.
- hnlmorg 3y agoBut even if they just solve the problem for the average person, that still makes the roads that much better for your edge cases that do need to rely on cars. For what it’s worth, it’s not that uncommon for European city centres to be pedestrianised. So it’s not like your options are driverless cars or nothing.
- robertlagrant 3y agoCity centres aren't the majority of transport needs.
- hnlmorg 3y agoThat depends on the city. But that’s besides the point. What I’m saying is that there are other viable options outside of driverless cars.
- dataviz1000 3y agoIn Park City, Utah you can get from any place to any other place on a bike path without crossing a road with cars. It is one of the snowiest places in North America. The residents are also the wealthiest people in America. They use E-bikes year round. Fat tires in the winter.
- ljf 3y agoMy father is 83 and struggles to walk more an a mile these days due to a leg injury and the need for knee replacements. But on his electric three wheeled bicycle, he covers a few miles each day. No matter the weather he heads out in the morning and buys a paper, milk and bread. Mid day he'll do a supermarket run for my mother, and in the afternoon they will take a 'walk' together down to the sea, where she will walk and he will cycle slowly along side her. In the rain he wears a raincoat. At the back of the trike he has a huge basket that can carry their whole weekly shop, and in the front he has one that he throws his bag in. I'll admit we are lucky to live in a town that is walkable and the distances he covers are mot vast on even UK averages, but electric bikes and tricycles are suitable for all sorts of people and covering all sorts of uses. The trike could not replace their car entirely, but it means they can go weeks without using it.
- tcfhgj 3y agoNone of this is a real requirement. Elderly disabled people can use bikes as well. Same goes for people in very cold climates. Clothing helps against bad weather. Long commutes are possible, too (maybe using a Velomobile). And with cargo bikes (can also be shared) you can haul a lot.
- cyanydeez 3y agoEbikes solve problems in very few climates. Rain and snow are routine.