25 ms·
> I assume the intent is to help disadvantaged people have opportunities that more priviledged people have already. Right? I mean, I can get behind that. But t
by pjc50 3y ago
> I assume the intent is to help disadvantaged people have opportunities that more priviledged people have already. Right? I mean, I can get behind that. But then why the entire detour with race?
Up until about 1971 (possibly later, but that's the date of Loving vs Virginia), the US had formal, legal discrimination against black people. On finally removing that, there was at various times discussion of whether people who had been legally discriminated against all their lives should be compensated, as if they had been wronged in a tort sense. This would obviously be extremely expensive, and anyway impossible to quantify, so it never happened.
Harvard, and many other colleges, has a big base of "legacy" admissions, as well as a certain amount of generational knowledge and connections - you're more likely to get into Harvard if your parents went to Harvard, over and above mere class status. Since black people were under-represented in this category, people came up with the idea of putting a thumb on the other side of the scale and artificially increasing their rate of admission. Can it balance exactly against the disadvantages of discrimination? No.
> I genuinely don't get why the race thing is part of the equation. Shouldn't this just be run-of-the-mill social democratic "lets hand out some extra opportunities/benefits to the poor" program?
America is not in the least social-democratic, but racism and anti-racism have been there since the beginning and will probably dominate US politics until the last person who remembers the KKK is dead.
(It could be worse: Haitians who had freed themselves from slavery by the mass murder of their oppressors were made to pay a huge amount of compensation to them!)
- nailer 3y agoLoving vs Virginia was decided in 1967 https://www.oyez.org/cases/1966/395 https://www.oyez.org/cases/1966/395
- MaokaiLin 3y agoStop treating all minorities like they are in a single category. The ones that are hurt most in the cases are asian americans. They do not have advantage in "legacy" admissions over other minorities, and they are also discriminated over a century. Why are they paying the price for reparations?
- mcv 3y agoYeah, every time the discussion comes up about, for example, reparations for the descendants of slaves, I start out thinking: it's been 150 years! Some of those descendants are very successful now and some descendants of slave owners are probably very poor now. And some people are descendants of both. And then I learn about the Jim Crow period, and then you hear that even the GI bill explicitly excluded black people, and lynchings into the 1950s, and the extremely hard fight the civil rights movement had, and even legal discrimination up to 1971, not to mention tons of possibly illegal but still very real discrimination after that. And then I think: you can't just stop doing a bad thing and pretend it didn't happen. You've got to try to make things right. Have things been made right by now? I have no idea. I do know plenty of black people still live in fear of the police, and that when black people call the police, there's the non-zero chance that they're the ones who end up getting shot. Not to mention that many universities also have affirmative action for children of alumni, who are still predominantly white and rich, partially because of the legal discrimination uo to 1971, and partially because universities are ridiculously expensive. Has that affirmative action also been struck down? > America is not in the least social-democratic, It used to be, though. The New Deal and many of the social policies of the 1940s and 1950s were very social democratic. Well, except that they tended to exclude black people.
- faeriechangling 3y agoI don’t see how any of that morally justifies discriminating against Asians though.
- EatingWithForks 3y agoAdditionally we had issues where banks were being prosecuted for not giving housing support to primarily black neighboorhoods all the way still to STILL IN 2023! https://apnews.com/article/city-national-bank-redlining-settlement-b55eade5ccdbf0974ff77f011a5d8af9 https://apnews.com/article/city-national-bank-redlining-sett...
- 93po 3y ago> Have things been made right by now? I have no idea. Ask any black person and there's your answer.
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> Harvard, and many other colleges, has a big base of "legacy" admissions, as well as a certain amount of generational knowledge and connections - you're more likely to get into Harvard if your parents went to Harvard, over and above mere class status. Harvard also gets lots of Asians (well, Chinese) who are obviously not legacy admits, and there is/was active discrimination against them at Harvard (they don't want the student body to be too white and asian?). The decision specifically calls this out: > The high court found that Harvard and the University of North Carolina discriminated against white and Asian American applicants by using race-conscious admissions policies. Also see: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/15/us/harvard-asian-enrollment-applicants.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/15/us/harvard-asian-enrollme... Using merit alone, it is totally possible that Harvard would be mostly Asian very quickly. However, it doesn't fit the narrative that the system is biased towards white legacy admits.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoThis decision was a big win for Asians. Who right now are being discriminated against. Before race based admission was used “as a positive” for minorities, it was being used to keep ivy leagues from being “too Jewish”. It doesn’t take very long to see what this is, but the topic is always about removing the benefit, not preventing the abuse.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoAsians do have a general leg up in terms of family income (which correlates to education success), so if we were discriminating based on income, then we could come up with something fair that gives poorer people (which can act as a proxy for disadvantaged minorities) more opportunity, but at the expense of rich people since we don't have unlimited resources. The problem being that now you are denied getting into Harvard because your mom and dad are too rich...and I don't think many people would think that is fair either.
- firesteelrain 3y agoMay not be fair but its Constitutional unlike Affirmative Action.
- NoRelToEmber 3y ago> Harvard, and many other colleges, has a big base of "legacy" admissions, as well as a certain amount of generational knowledge and connections - you're more likely to get into Harvard if your parents went to Harvard, over and above mere class status. Let's explicitly look at how this affected race (instead of leaving it to readers imaginations), since that was the issue the court was asked to consider. The student body of the US Ivy League looked as follows, circa 2019 (international students excluded): Ivy League US Ratio Mean nationwide SAT score [1] Jewish 17.2% 2.4% 7.16 Asian 19.6% 5.3% 3.71 1216 White (incl. Jewish) 50.3% 61.5% 0.82 1148 Hispanic 11.4% 17.6% 0.65 1043 Black 7.8% 12.7% 0.61 966 White (non-Jewish) 33.1% 59.1% 0.56 ~1141 (lower bound estimate) SAT score seems to offer no benefit, up until the magic cutoff somewhere between 1142 and 1216. The numbers don't sum to 100% because multi-ethnic students, a few minor ethnicities (American-Indian, Pacific Islander..), and students categorized as "unknown" or "other" by the universities were excluded from analysis. Data on university undergraduate demographics was taken from the universities own diversity reports. Jewish representation was gathered from http://hillel.org/college-guide/list/ http://hillel.org/college-guide/list/, https://forward.com/jewish-college-guide/ https://forward.com/jewish-college-guide/, and https://ejewishphilanthropy.com/how-many-jewish-undergraduates/ https://ejewishphilanthropy.com/how-many-jewish-undergraduat..., taking the lowest estimate when sources conflicted. ejewishphilanthropy.com (eJP) points out flaws in Hillel's data gathering (e.g. showing Harvard as 30% Jewish, when eJP found it only 16%) Hillel seems to have since fixed these flaws, as the estimates they now give are in-line with those of eJP. No correction has been made to look at only the college-age population of the US, or only at the Northeastern US where all the Ivy League universities are located, so that may be a source of some bias. [1] https://www.ednc.org/eraceing-inequities-the-influence-of-race-on-sat-scores/ https://www.ednc.org/eraceing-inequities-the-influence-of-ra... Edit: Clarified that the SAT scores are nationwide, and not just of the Ivy League students. Thank you to stanford_labrat for bringing it up.
- stanford_labrat 3y agoIf anyone was confused at first glance as I was, these are the mean SAT scores nationwide and not at the ivy league institutions. I was very surprised for a moment to think the average SAT score at these colleges was in the 1200s...
- 8ytecoder 3y agoTo me - very simply put - merit doesn’t make much sense when one set of people didn’t get any of the opportunities the other set did. It’s like comparing height with one person standing atop a stool. The nuance here is to find the lost potential in marks and tests due to a lack of opportunity. Race is a crude proxy and it really doesn’t have to be based on just race. But it’d mean admins spend more time interviewing and verifying people’s background and make subjective decisions based on that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tomp 3y ago> Harvard, and many other colleges, has a big base of "legacy" admissions, […] Since black people were under-represented in this category, people came up with the idea of putting a thumb on the other side of the scale and artificially increasing their rate of admission. This is a nice story, but actually not true. If it were true, Harvard etc wouldn’t also discriminate against Asians. Maybe they weren’t as oppressed as blacks in the US, but they should thus get at least equivalent treatment as whites and hispanics, not worse.
- jensensbutton 3y ago> If it were true, Harvard etc wouldn’t also discriminate against Asians. This logic makes absolutely no sense. Why can't they have a legacy admits AND discriminate against Asians? Are you seriously trying to claim Ivy League schools don't have legacy admits?
- LudwigNagasena 3y agoYou missed this part: > putting a thumb on the other side of the scale and artificially increasing their rate of admission
- mahdi7d1 3y agoThis legacy system in likes of Harvard boggles me. If someones parents went to Harvard it might be actually logical to be harder for him to get into not easier. His educated parenting is already a huge plus for him and if he is unable to get into the same university it's on him.
- skotobaza 3y agoWell if your parents went to Harvard then they had money to pay for Harvard. And they probably have money to pay for their children.
- tourmalinetaco 3y agoHarvard and similar universities are all about “donations” to the school, so yeah. It’s definitely an assumption of generational wealth.
- gmarx 3y agoYou are making some assumptions about what Harvard is attempting to do when filling its classes. If its goal is to have a class full of people who did the most with what they had you have an argument. If their goal is to maximize alumni support (financial and otherwise) then maybe not
- TrackerFF 3y agoWhat you need to know about Harvard is that they are a business. Their business is to amass donations from alumni and the likes. Their endowment fund is currently over $50 billions. Rich and successful alumni means more donations, so it makes sense to take in the kids of rich and successful people.
- jankyxenon 3y agoHarvard tries to be a pretty progressive organization - the way they justify legacy admissions is probably by arguing that the large endowments let them fund underprivileged students with needs-based programs. They’re also in the literal business of prestige. They use mega-donors for mega-endowments which allows them to attract and fund mega-researchers. It’s also why it needs to be super exclusive (small class sizes).
- skrebbel 3y agoAppreciate the context, thanks. It doesn't feel less weird to me yet but maybe I gotta let things sink in a bit first.
- Georgelemental 3y agoMany beneficiaries of "affirmative action" are not generational African Americans whose ancestors experienced slavery and Jim Crow, but immigrants or children of immigrants from Africa: https://www.msnbc.com/podcast/harvard-s-complicated-relationship-its-black-students-n1285276 https://www.msnbc.com/podcast/harvard-s-complicated-relation...
- akiselev 3y agoPasadena, a decent sized city in Los Angeles County that houses Caltech of all places, was forced to officially desegregate in the 1970s but they've still got tons of policies left over that discriminate in housing [1]. South Pasadena real estate agents unofficial redlined the neighborhoods well into the 1980s and possibly even the 1990s. Schools, especially in Altadena, were still highly segregated when I went to elementary school there in the 2000s. In the 21st century, for f**k's sake. And that's in a city adjacent to Los Angeles. We don't see many rebel flags in Southern California but the segregation is just staggering. IME it's even worse in the East coast cities, especially with the way roads, highways, and mass transit are built. I'll admit I had no idea what true segregation looked like until I lived in Ft Lauderdale/Hollywood in Florida (in the mid-2010s). [1] https://makinghousinghappen.net/2020/06/23/pasadenas-racialized-history/ https://makinghousinghappen.net/2020/06/23/pasadenas-raciali...
- kbelder 3y agoFrom that article, I don't see any racially discriminatory laws still in place in Pasadena. Plenty of laws discriminating against the poor, though.
- greedo 3y agoOh the racism spread to the West very early in those states histories. Look up sundown towns, and Portland's history.
- selimthegrim 3y agoCaltech itself famously had more black students in the 1970s than it did in the following three decades
- whymauri 3y agoThere's a network effect at Caltech, which does not practice AA, because it's so small. Basically, if you get into Caltech without AA, chances are you got into an equally good university with AA. However, it's clear to the outside observer that your single-digit hispanic or black prospective classmates at Caltech are generally more miserable than your prospective classmates at MIT, Stanford, Harvard, etcetera. They are usually the only person like you in their dorm, or in their year, or in their major. So you don't go to Caltech.
- makomk 3y agoLegacy admissionss are part of the problem with Harvard's affirmative action scheme that made it really blatantly discriminatory - basically, they kept those legacy admissions and balanced them out by putting a thumb on the scale against other groups that didn't benefit from legacy admissions either, primarily Asian candidates.
- thegaulofthem 3y ago> (It could be worse: Haitians who had freed themselves from slavery by the mass murder of their oppressors were made to pay a huge amount of compensation to them!) At risk of starting a fun flame war, it’s more complicated than that. Outside of a contingent of Polish mercenaries, whom were deemed something to the effect of honorary blacks, the new former slave regime effectively genocided the whites of the island. Men, women, children, the works. Not only that, but they threw in the mixed as well. Then went about taking all of everyone’s property. I don’t know where the exact reasonable line is for revenge when you’ve been enslaved, but I’m certain they went well and unquestionably over it. To that end, I don’t know where the reasonable counter-balance is for France to make claim against the former slave colony for its crimes against humanity but the idea that they have clean hands and or are owed something is an appalling revisionist history of the country.
- tourmalinetaco 3y ago> appalling revisionist history And this is where most of the problems lie. It’s like a game of telephone, someone says one thing and its passes along until its an extremely toned down propagandist version of what it was before.
- skydhash 3y ago> I don’t know where the exact reasonable line is for revenge when you’ve been enslaved, but I’m certain they went well and unquestionably over it. If so, pretty much every nation is guilty of genocide. The Spanish eliminated the natives in Hispaniola and Latin America. Saint Domingue was basically a meat grinder under the French. There were basically no international law, only allies. I don’t condemn genocide, but do you think if the rebellion failed, the French would have pardoned everyone? Dessalines was guilty of genocide, but most other nations have done worse (Napoleon and his wars). N.B. Haiti is very small. And the white population was tiny at the time. People always going on about that because black slaves killed white slave owners 200 years ago.
- adventured 3y ago> but racism and anti-racism have been there since the beginning and will probably dominate US politics until the last person who remembers the KKK is dead. The KKK has nothing to do with it fundamentally. Matters of racism and similar (it doesn't just have to be about race, this is a problem of collectivism, of which racism is a subset) will dominate the politics of any highly diverse nation (diverse not necessarily pertaining only to race of course), and without exception. See: what has been going on in Sweden the past decade (it has gotten worse as Sweden has gotten more diverse). Or see: the forever riots in France by the poor minorities there that have never integrated into French culture.
- achenet 3y agouh... as a Frenchman, I've noticed a lot of riots, but it's generally white people/native Frenchies doing the whole "fuck the government" thing. It's probably important to understand that protesting is to France what baseball is to America - the national pastime. I'd say most immigrants I know, including the largest groups from North Africa, follow an integration pattern similar to east Asians I met whilst living in the US. Furthermore, I believe that actually political views dominate race when it comes to tribalism: from https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anythin... > Okay, fine, but we know race has real world consequences. Like, there have been several studies where people sent out a bunch of identical resumes except sometimes with a black person’s photo and other times with a white person’s photo, and it was noticed that employers were much more likely to invite the fictional white candidates for interviews. So just some stupid Implicit Association Test results can’t compare to that, right? Iyengar and Westwood also decided to do the resume test for parties. They asked subjects to decide which of several candidates should get a scholarship (subjects were told this was a genuine decision for the university the researchers were affiliated with). Some resumes had photos of black people, others of white people. And some students listed their experience in Young Democrats of America, others in Young Republicans of America. > Once again, discrimination on the basis of party was much stronger than discrimination on the basis of race. The size of the race effect for white people was only 56-44 (and in the reverse of the expected direction); the size of the party effect was about 80-20 for Democrats and 69-31 for Republicans.
- JackFr 3y ago> Up until about 1971 (possibly later, but that's the date of Loving vs Virginia) Minor nitpick, Loving was 1967.
- jenenfnfnfnf 3y ago> Harvard, and many other colleges, has a big base of "legacy" admissions, as well as a certain amount of generational knowledge and connections Had?
- mistrial9 3y ago> the US had formal, legal discrimination against black people this is misinformation; State laws had complete jurisdiction over certain matters, by design. "The US" is calling Washington State the same as Alabama. So, no.
- amluto 3y agoI think you’re missing the point. The US had state, local and private laws, regulations, and institutions that discriminated against black people with varying degrees of formality. The discrimination in question existed and was widespread in the US.
- mistrial9 3y agoI think you are missing my point. The USA itself is not one thing, and the laws are not one thing. Specifically, by design and in fact, people's rights to do a wide variety of things, were and are still, different. The language you are insisting on, is misinformation. https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/discrimination-on-the-basis-of-race-ethnicity-or-national-origin https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/discrimination-on-the-...
- amluto 3y agoThe post you replied to said: > Up until about 1971 (possibly later, but that's the date of Loving vs Virginia), the US had formal, legal discrimination against black people. And you seem to be arguing that this is “misinformation”. The best I can make of your objection is that, prior to 1967, the US did not outlaw miscegenation and that it was merely 16 states that did so and that these laws were legal in the US. This is IMO unhelpful nitpicking — the OP’s point had nothing to do with which books the laws were written in and also did not depend on all states being affected. (The connection between miscegenation and college admissions is rather more distant than, say, the discrimination outlawed not too much earlier by Brown v Board of Education, but even that is a bit of a nitpick.)
- coliveira 3y agoStates can do many bad things because the US constitution designed by the founders of the country lets them do it. So, no this scapegoat is not available. The discrimination is 100% an issue of the US as a country.
- az226 3y agoLegacy is always brought up in these discussions. The amount of students who get into Harvard because of the boost from their race outnumbers the number of legacy students who get boosted from their status 20 to 1. Basically a race and legacy blind policy would reject 20 times more minorities than legacy applicants and then if the policy is race and legacy discriminatory.
- az226 3y agoA typical class at Harvard has 2,500 student admits. Of those, 700 are black or Hispanic. If Harvard did away with legacy admissions, 25 additional Hispanic or black applicants would be admitted, so 725. However, if they did away with affirmative action, 450 would not be admitted, so you would be down to 275. Most of these 425 spots would go to Asian applicants and a chunk would go to white applicants. http://public.econ.duke.edu/~psarcidi/legacyathlete.pdf http://public.econ.duke.edu/~psarcidi/legacyathlete.pdf
- blindriver 3y ago450 spots to less deserving students would go to 450 more deserving students? That seems pretty fair to me. Unless you want to focus on the color of the skin of students and not the content of their character.
- az226 3y agoAgreed. Racial discrimination preferences won’t be missed.
- ckemere 3y agoStatus please? My understanding is that something like 50% of white students had a non academic boost (including legacy and "athletics"). *Harvard specifically, not UNC
- az226 3y agoIn a typical class of 2500 students at Harvard, removing legacy preference would increase the minority population by 25. Removing athletic preference would and another 25. Removing minority racial preference would remove 450. 450 is 18x times larger than 25. But lots of legacy whataboutism. It’s not as big of an impact as people like to think / eat the rich, etc.
- lr4444lr 3y agoThis is good, but it also leaves out that the Civil Rights Act legislation made this kind of "thumb on the other side of the scale" for "disadvantaged races" patently illegal. Affirmative Action was, therefore, a recognized court exemption - explicitly stated by judges as a temporary measure - and which has been further narrowed in multiple later cases brought to it (cf. University of California v. Bakke, Gratz v. Bollinger). A more recent group, Students for Fair Admission, largely cited the anti-Asian angle its effects were producing. Affirmative Action was never part of formal U.S. law, and never designed to exist indefinitely.
- stevenwoo 3y agoI just read The New Jim Crow (I'm late) and it makes a pretty strong case the USA prison industrial complex/drug war is simply an extension of Jim Crow since drug laws are not enforced equally and the Supreme Court through a series of decisions has made it so the prosecutors and law enforcement have to admit to racism to show that anti-racism laws have been broken and they cannot be forced to reveal any evidence that shows this via discovery, overturning much of the post civil war/civil rights reforms. It's a crazy catch-22. I've heard there is a simpler way that does not consider race that would level the college admissions playing field, make it so there has to be equal admissions based on income level per zip code, but that would kills the grandfather clauses most colleges use to get relatives of graduates entry.
- wesapien 3y ago> > I assume the intent is to help disadvantaged people have opportunities that more priviledged people have .... > America is not in the least social-democratic, but racism and anti-racism have been there since the beginning and will probably dominate US politics until the last person who remembers the KKK is dead. .... Joy and pain will always be there. In group and outgroup will always be there. Society doesn't need to forget anything. Wisdom is drawn from both good and bad experiences. Those who forget are doomed to repeat the sins of the past.
- bagels 3y agoThey could, gasp, not have legacy admissions, but that'd cut in to their firehose of money.
- aauchter 3y agoThe legacy argument is a fallacy at this point. What's true is children of professors/admins get preferential treatment, as do 7 figure donors. Legacy has barely mattered for the last couple decades.
- cperciva 3y ago(It could be worse: Haitians who had freed themselves from slavery by the mass murder of their oppressors were made to pay a huge amount of compensation to them!) Not to diminish the injustice of the slavery from which Haitians freed themselves, but I think there might have been a solution short of genocide. In particular, the systematic torture and execution of children was probably not necessary. (Incidentally, the compensation in question was paid for lost property. The French government apparently considered that to be more important than the lives which were lost!)
- sacnoradhq 3y agoRedlining and racist real estate deed clauses did exist. The KKK embodies American white supremacy. In 1925 and 1926, 50k white hoods marched down Pennsylvania Ave. 4% (5 million) of Americans were Klan members. There were numerous mass lynchings and murder during the 1919 Red Summer. This was the surfacing of simmering racism because of an influx of Jewish and Catholic refugees from WW I and the increasing household wealth of black people. Somehow, black people, Jews, and Catholics were responsible for all of the ills, lack of wealth, and loss of privilege for the average American white Christian male. Henry Ford was Hitler's hero and wrote antisemitic editorials and books. In 2023, it's still the case that some social clubs, private preschools, universities, apartment co-ops, and more require photographs with applications because it provides an easy way to discriminate without being openly honest about it. Blackballing (secret ballot cast by colored rocks) is also used to deny people arbitrarily.
- sh34r 3y agoUp until 1945, Asian Americans were held in concentration camps after being stripped of all their property. Affirmative action made sense in 1971. Things change. Now it’s just discriminating against another group that’s historically been the victim of white supremacy. A crabs in a bucket situation. And how do we make any sense of these racist laws when there’s more and more mixed race kids applying to college anyway? Our first “black” President is half white. Our first “black” Vice President is half-Asian. If this chicanery went on for a couple more generations, every kid’s gonna be like Liz Warren, looking for any trace of victim in their DNA… Race is a social construct. These remnants of apartheid are completely illogical. The rules are made up and don’t matter. There is only one objective race: the human race. It’s about time we started deconstructing it if you ask me. Sinophobia is getting extremely out of hand at the moment. We need to condemn systemic racism against Asian people and reject the model minority myth, before we repeat some of the ugliest chapters of US history… both parties are way too eager for war in Greater China.