15 ms·
Apple joins opposition to encrypted message app scanning
- TillE 3y agoYet another example of an insane, unworkable internet policy from the UK which will never actually be implemented. I don't know why they keep doing this. Even if they were serious about it, they're a tiny country that lacks the clout to push around American tech giants. They lack the leverage of even Ireland, where most of these companies have their European tax base.
- derelicta 3y agoIt WILL be implemented. Remember: both the EU and the US are pushing these laws. And soon they will be extended to cover terrorist propaganda, drug trafficking and calls for unlawful protests.
- ghughes 3y agoThey get to print something along the lines of "we tried to protect the children and those irresponsible American tech giants stopped us" in the Daily Mail.
- xinayder 3y agoThis is the same mentality that got UK to pass a referendum for Brexit. As absurd an idea might be, it doesn't mean we can stand still and do nothing because we're sure the idea is so dumb it won't come to fruition. We need to fight it to prevent it from becoming a reality.
- 0xParlay 3y ago> they're a tiny country that lacks the clout to push around American tech giants I'd wager the power dynamic is more along the UK's membership in five-eyes and their ability to be a useful sigint ally. For all we know the NSA wants a better way to spy on Americans using Signal. How does that work? Get the Brits to do it.
- hellojesus 3y agoBut there is no reason signal would ever comply with some law like this passed outside their jurisdiction. Even if a law like this was passed in the US, you could just move your headquarters to Egypt.
- ghughes 3y ago> companies should only implement end-to-end encryption if they can simultaneously prevent abhorrent child sexual abuse on their platforms And houses with walls should be banned unless the builder can guarantee no children will be harmed inside.
- amf12 3y agoWhile I agree with your point somewhat, the scale is completely different. Its not a black and white thing. I know a lot of people will disagree with this statement though.
- Moldoteck 3y agoWhat do you mean the scale is different
- 8note 3y agoYeah, how many houses are there?
- aaomidi 3y ago[flagged]
- Tade0 3y agoThe main issue in preventing child abuse is that there are simply not enough resources allocated to handle each case - especially in a timely manner. More surveillance just means more cases in the backlog, so contrary to what people wanting to implement it are saying, it doesn't get us any closer to the goal.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoI would like to present examples: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-06-21/ombudsman-investigation-child-protection-failings/102502594 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-06-21/ombudsman-investigati... https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-05-09/child-protection-workers-leaving-kids-with-carers-no-checks/102304240 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-05-09/child-protection-work... https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-05-06/high-risk-paedophile-prison-release/102312516 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-05-06/high-risk-paedophile-...
- sneak 3y agoIt's crazy, because Apple already maintains a backdoor in the e2ee crypto of iMessage which permits them to read all iMessages and attachments and scan them serverside for CSAM (if they desire). iMessage endpoint sync keys (for "Messages in iCloud") are backed up in the non-e2ee iCloud Backup (on by default), allowing Apple to use those sync keys from the backup to decrypt iMessages and attachments in realtime. Note that enabling e2ee iCloud Backups (a new feature) on your device won't close this hole as the conversation partner for each iMessage is also escrowing keys. I assume this is just brand marketing for Apple.
- altano 3y ago"Advanced Data Protection" is an optional feature you can enable for iCloud that makes that not true. See the table at https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 and note that iCloud Backup (including device and Messages backup) stores the keys on your trusted devices only when Advanced Data Protection is enabled: "Advanced Data Protection: iCloud Backup and everything inside it is end-to-end encrypted, including the Messages in iCloud encryption key." These sorts of laws make Apple not able to support Advanced Data Protection in jurisdictions that pass them.
- lrvick 3y agoExcept Apple can remotely execute any code they want on your phone at any time. That is how proprietary software works. If Apple is ordered to ask a given device to return all keys in plain text, it can. So can any Apple employees also on payroll for state actors.
- sunshinerag 3y agoYep same for Google/android and Microsoft devices
- lapcat 3y ago> Except Apple can remotely execute any code they want on your phone at any time. That is how proprietary software works. No, that's not how any code works, proprietary or open source. I've written proprietary software for 16 years, and none of it could remotely execute any code that I want.
- barrysteve 3y agoThis is the same argument that ISPs should be liable for piracy.. and they're not because of common carrier status. From the early 2000s. Tech always finds a way to remain separate from it's delivered content. I bet these revealing encryption policies will become implemented laws, 5 minutes after some research paper shows a better secret messaging concept is technically possible.
- gigel82 3y agoAs long as they don't try to bring back on-device scanning "for the children" we're good.
- brookst 3y agoYou prefer the Google model where nobody knows what they scan for, it’s easy to scan for different things in different countries, and there is no auditing of sources providing hashes to be scanned?
- uoaei 3y agoYou prefer false dichotomies that derail meaningful discussions?
- brookst 3y agoHuh? It’s a real dichotomy. We have one model today that all companies use. Apple proposed an alternative that people hated, so we still have the secret cloud scanning with no auditability or transparency. How in the world is that a false dichotomy? It is literally a choice betweeen two options that people were very adamant about.
- idle_zealot 3y agoYou are missing the third option: no scanning anywhere.
- nceqs3 3y ago>You are missing the third option: no scanning anywhere. What a take. Thankfully the vast majority of Americans don't agree with you in the slightest. Also private companies can do whatever they please.
- idle_zealot 3y agoI don't think "pervasive digital surveillance is bad" is an unpopular opinion here.
- gickhocq 3y agoI don't really see the problem with this. Scanning happens before the message is encrypted or after the message is decrypted (thus preserving the end-to-end encryption itself from compromise), occurs only on the device itself, and will report back only if known illegal content is detected. It seems to be the best possible method of implementing such scanning. Shouldn't we be supporting this as a proportionate safety measure?
- piaste 3y agoN-gate summed it up very well: "if a guy in Cupertino can put a U2 album on your phone, he can just as easily put CSAM on it". If you are using a device managed by Apple/Google/Microsoft, E2E is merely a roadbump - it means that your device owner needs to push a backdoored update to it, rather than simply reading your data server-side at their leisure. Which is still valuable, to be clear: it's a pretty large roadbump. Either you're such an important target that they're shipping a specific update to you alone (in which case, frankly, you didn't stand a chance), or they risk exposure. But if you install a little snitch that reads your messages and reports you if they match some complicated, necessarily hashed pattern, then that roadbump is mostly gone. All the guy in Cupertino now needs to do is update the patterns to match what they want them to match, without anyone noticing.
- gickhocq 3y agoI think I see your argument, are you saying that because the scanning involves transforming the content into a hash and comparing to a set of hashes, the problem is that this is resistant to third-party analysis? Not because of the overall behaviour of the scanner or indeed any other software on the device, which can be reverse-engineered using standard techniques, but because a database of hashes is inherently opaque as to the content it will match with?
- piaste 3y agoCorrect. Is that hashed fingerprint you just downloaded associated with the face of a known victim of abuse, or with that of a whistleblower? Impossible to tell. (The N-Gate scenario is a little different: someone who doesn't like you controls a random app that is allowed to write to your /Downloads or /Pictures folder. Puts compromising material in it, then lets the well-meaning OS scanner pick it up and report you. You spend the next X years wrangling with law enforcement, trying to convince them that you were "hacked", the same thing every criminal claims.) If the scanner program merely refused to transmit the potential match, it would be acceptable. No avenue for abuse (without shipping a malicious update, which is always possible for cloud-controlled devices anyway), and at worst an annoyance in the event of a false positive. But I very much doubt that the parties pushing for this legislation would settle for that.
- camgunz 3y agoTech workers need to unionize everywhere and create staunch opposition to this kind of garbage. We're the experts, we're the elite, we know what's best, and we have a responsibility to lead here. Doctors won't harvest organs to sell. Pharmacists won't make you poison. Engineers shouldn't make you encryption backdoors.
- derelicta 3y agoI'd love an union mouvement for IT workers. We have a small trade union in Switzerland that represents our interests but like for most other countries, engineers rarely see themselves as blue collars.
- camgunz 3y agoI look at it more like the ABA (attorneys) or the AMA (doctors) in the US. Those organizations have enormous political power, and I think tech workers could easily hang in that echelon. I say unionize because I just like unions, but either way.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> look at it more like the ABA (attorneys) or the AMA (doctors) in the US These are trade groups. Not unions. There's a meaningful difference. Unions for tech don't make sense, particularly in a world of remote work. Trade groups, on the other hand, do.
- derelicta 3y agoWhy does it not make sense? Remote workers can join an union too.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoIt’s too easy to scalp, or for an unencumbered overseas competitor to take your chips. When offices resembled factories there was at least a capital expense to be leveraged.
- a_c 3y agoIt seems the UK is good at self inflicting damage. First the brexit, now this online safety bill. Brexit had half the population in support while the safety bill didn't garner much attention from the public (or I've missed them). The pattern seems to be using a generic solution to specific problems while the blast radius of the generic solution is asymmetrically larger than the intended specific problems.
- heavenlyblue 3y agoIt seems like online safety bill is such a low-hanging fruit compared to building affordable housing so they concentrate on "achievable" results, even if these results are not really that important at all. PS: I am against online safety bill.
- a_c 3y agoIMO UK has so much potential in being economically and technologically relevant. It is english speaking, got top universities, healthcare is decent when compared to the US (not saying it is without problems), capital abundant, birth rate among the heathiest in europe (12, after sweden and france 12.1, norway 12.2, iceland, iceland 13.6, ireland 13.8, and greenland 14.3) [1]. It pains me to see UK giving up on their potential [1] https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/birth-rate-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/birth-rat...
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoTo say nothing of the Commonwealth: London is a more natural capital harbor for India, Australia and South Africa than New York or even Singapore.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- okeuro49 3y ago> It seems the UK is good at self inflicting damage. First the brexit... I voted remain, however I'm still a Eurosceptic. The two issues aren't comparable.
- LatteLazy 3y agoQuick note: the UK's current governing party has been in power for 13 years. They are completely out of ideas. The main opposition is similarly short on anything to actually offer beyond "the same as those guys, but better!". All the major issues facing the UK (debt, the economy, housing, education, brexit, democratic collapse) are issues where people are not willing to actually support action. So all there is left for parties is either dumb shit like this or fake wedge issues (like pretending trans people are pedophiles). That is why this keep coming back.
- GordonS 3y agoDo you honestly believe Labour won't be pushing the same agenda once they're back in? Sure, their last term was a while ago now, but still, Starmer is exactly the kind of person that pushed the anti-privacy, pro-surveillance agenda that Labour was also very fond of.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nologic01 3y agoThe UK is for some reason very surveillance-friendly. CCTV's were prevalent there much earlier than most other countries. I guess since Orwell was British they think they are on top of this.
- scott_w 3y ago> I guess since Orwell was British they think they are on top of this. I don't think Orwell has anything to do with this. British society is very different to, say, American society in many ways. History will probably help explain things. Like many European feudal societies, there's a long-standing expectation that government is expected to care for the citizens. In spite of how individuals acted, there have been laws to protect peasants from predatory landlords (even if their application wasn't perfect). In addition, it was the role of the local "government" / community to care for their homeless for a very long time. What I'm trying to get at is that the suspicion of government is not really there in the way that it exists in the USA. This allows the government to hold vast powers and, for better or worse, be trusted that it's not going to abuse that (against its own citizens at least). On CCTV specifically: in the modern day, in practice, most CCTV is concentrated in London. This means that the vast majority of the UK is not really affected by this surveillance. Also, I do recall most CCTV is privately operated, not state, and most organisations delete it within a few weeks to save money. What this means is that, in practice, you don't have a Bourne Identity situation where the police can watch a live feed of someone running through London. They have to acquire that information afterwards through a series of requests and subpoenas to different companies.
- JimDabell 3y ago> Also, I do recall most CCTV is privately operated, not state, and most organisations delete it within a few weeks to save money. In practical terms, the numbers are pumped up by things like corner shops having shitty live feed cameras with limited recording capability and no networking to deter shoplifters when there’s a single shopkeeper who can’t see the whole shop from where they stand due to tall shelves and cramped spaces. Yet it seems common for Americans to imagine this as Enemy of the State style omniscience where the authorities can view anything happening in London at any time. It’s got no connection to reality.
- activiation 3y agoJust ban privacy, because some criminals benefit from it ...
- JTbane 3y agoMany governments are really trying, in the "freest" part of the world.
- apexalpha 3y agoDidn't apple also recommend on-device scanning for these kind of pictures as well a while ago? Glad to see they now oppose it but it's hard to gauge how sincere it is given their history of trying to implement it themselves.
- grrywlsn 3y agoI’d argue their attempts at having a plan for CSAM were preempting these exact types of arguments being made in bad faith by governments like the UK, who are actively engaging children’s charities to give their goal of breaking e2ee have some emotional societal weight.
- camhart 3y agoCSAM is a real problem. Its not merely emotional weight.
- mikestew 3y agoI don’t believe that anyone is saying that it isn’t. That doesn’t preclude the government from preventing a “real problem” going to waste.
- BLKNSLVR 3y ago> give their goal of breaking e2ee have some emotional societal weight. Breaking E2EE is their goal. CSAM is the McGuffin.
- yieldcrv 3y agoCan your elaborate on your trigger here? Why did you feel that the phrasing minimized it enough to miss the point?
- bee_rider 3y agoI don’t read their comment as particularly triggered, but if you honestly think they were triggered by a reference to CSAM, this is a wildly inappropriate question to ask. In general I think it is better to not project some emotional reading onto other people’s posts.
- cced 3y agoCurious. They develop a feature, receive tons of opposition, go quiet, now they oppose it? Waiting for this to inevitably pass and for then to get to play the good guy card.
- mikece 3y agoI resent as immoral the argument that if one is for e2ee message and data encryption then you're in favor of CASM. Why I want my messages private is my own business but for GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS to lump me in with child predators who need to be summarily executed when caught is beyond wrong. This is also a symptom of the laziness of police: rather than getting out and properly investigating crimes they would rather sit on their asses, eat doughnuts, drink coffee, and grep the personal data of all citizens.
- DocTomoe 3y ago> for GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS to lump me in with child predators So ... sue them individually and personally. It's libel. Make the cost of such generalisations too high to sustain them.
- lngnmn2 3y agoIsn't "encrypted messages" implies the impossibility of any scan? Oh, could it be that they store all the msgs as a plain text on the server and the "encrypted" is just a meme for only a TLS connection? Rhetorical question, of course.
- meepmorp 3y agoE2EE messages aren't encrypted until they're sent and are decrypted on the receiving end. Scanning can be mandated to happen at either or both of those points.
- pxoe 3y agotangential, but interesting how they choose to be loud about this, yet don't say or do anything about imessage downgrading to unencrypted sms with anything outside imessage. no warning about a less secure message being sent, no byline that'd be like 'unencrypted text' or like a tiny little open padlock or something, no effort to make messages encrypted where it could be possible, not even a 'snarky ad campaign' or something that'd point out that 'green bubbles? sms? that's insecure'. it's almost like... "encryptedness" and "privacy" isn't really the point. it's more of a 'marketing point' and 'ecosystem dynamics' - lock-in, network effect, and all that. actually implementing outside encrypted messages for their users? mmmeh.
- LispSporks22 3y agoThe amount of stuff you can accomplish with "save the children"...
- cwoolfe 3y agoBig tech already knows more about kids than parents do.(1) If they want to protect kids on their platforms we don't even need to talk about end-to-end encryption yet. What would help is big tech sharing daily summaries of child on-device activity with parents. There are lots of parental control apps that do this, and yet they have had to fight Apple for permission to operate.(2) Parents don't want their kids abused either. We can definitely find a win-win situation here if we work at it. References: (1) https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-target-figured-out-a-teen-girl-was-pregnant-before-her-father-did/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-targ... (2) https://www.kaspersky.com/blog/apple-fas-complaint/26017/ https://www.kaspersky.com/blog/apple-fas-complaint/26017/
- stjohnswarts 3y agoIf you want to spy on your kids then install software and do it. I don't think normalizing corporations spying on kids is a great idea. Sure they do it, but normalizing it only makes it worse and more acceptable.
- judge2020 3y agoI thought that it was universally understood that spying on your kid's activity is bad parenting? Limiting what your child has access to in the first place, and setting time limits, is a good way to set barriers on viewing activity that you can break down over time as you continue to educate and talk to your child about the dangers of the real world accessible over the internet: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201304 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201304 And Apple is continuing to introduce privacy-preserving (and safe-from-russian-companies) solutions to kids seeing inappropriate content https://www.apple.com/ios/ios-17-preview/#privacy-security:~:text=Privacy%20and%20Security https://www.apple.com/ios/ios-17-preview/#privacy-security:~...
- Timber-6539 3y agoWhat has changed since calling those who opposed their intentions to introduce CSAM scanning last year as the screeching voice of the minority?
- secretsatan 3y agoProbably everyone yelling at them not to do it changed their minds
- Timber-6539 3y agoNow if only they would listen to everyone who's yelling at them to make the App store fees reasonable and open up the in-app purchases ecosystem.
- entriesfull 3y agoMy question is, if we all know now by now how privacy invasive these hardware/software vendors are, why do we still buy and support their products? Is it really so hard for open source hardware to become a thing? I'd trade in my iPhone for something built using RISC-V or MIPS ISA with all software written in Rust any day. Lastly, why aren't open hardware satellites built so that people can pay for internet that doesn't route through U.S. Datacenters? Very lastly, why not not build completely decentralized web apps were all your data is encrypted and distributed so that censorship isn't possible? "Ohhhh no but then all the bad guys will use it." Yeah well you can't censor and monitor an entire planet just because of a couple bad seeds. The bad guys also use language as a form of communication. Will we also make words illegal in the future?
- I_am_tiberius 3y agoApple is not to be trusted in terms of privacy. Nobody knows what their software is actually doing. It's all closed source. Their focus on privacy in their advertisements does not mean that their software actually protects users' privacy.
- themitigating 3y agoWhat does that have to do with their opposition to this proposal?
- hackernewds 3y agoThat they build a huge dam to block natural waterflow, and sell urine to the masses.
- jkubicek 3y agoI think you need to unpack this metaphor a bit more, I can't see what point you're trying to make.
- photonerd 3y agoProof appears to be in the pudding: the feds & law enforcement routinely complain that they can’t access Apple users stuff. Hell, they sue over it. So it seems to work oreeeeetty well
- smoldesu 3y agoOf course, it depends where you live. If you are an Apple customer of the Chinese mainland, your iCloud data just gets uploaded to government servers from the start. The Chinese "feds & law enforcement" just gets carte-blanche access to all uploaded user data. So what stops them from doing the same thing where you live? If you're relying on absolute honesty from your jurisdiction, you're bound to be disappointed the next time a Snowden type hits the news.
- 3y ago
- Dritzzka 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pierat 3y agoCSAM's going to get a lot weirder with AI image manipulation and autocompleting and nudify-ing images. And combined with this ruling about Japanese hentai with depiction of minors is legal to possess and sell: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Handley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Handley So, what happens when (not if) someone uses https://thispersondoesnotexist.com/ https://thispersondoesnotexist.com/ and gets children pictures, then generates them nude and doing sex acts? This is basically the same argument as above. The children aren't real, and the sex acts arent real. The bigger problem is "how do you tell if this image is a proof of a child rape or just AI generated?" I'm going more and more towards "CSAM is evidence of a crime, and shouldn't be a crime in of itself" side of things. However, even though I'd advocate in removing strict liability of possession of CSAM, I'm still for death penalty for any human who rapes children (we're talking under puberty, not 17yr olds etc).
- qingcharles 3y agoThe case you cited is only federal law. Many states in the USA banned CGI depictions of CSAM as a result of cases like that, so computer-generated imagery, and child sex dolls are not permitted across a large section of the country, for better or worse. I have no opinion on it as I don't know if access to items such as these which involve no real children make the majority of those interested more or less likely to physically offend. I am sure for some it mitigates their desires, and for others it accentuates them. I am not a psychologist.
- tennisflyi 3y agoCSAM AI articles have just popped up.
- buckleberry12 3y agoFramed as crime scene evidence, it is kind of strange that simply possessing it, for any reason, is a serious crime worth decades in prison. The pedophiles are voluntarily taking pictures and videos of themselves committing crimes and sharing it on the internet. I am sure that if internet sleuths were allowed to investigate such material, like law enforcement is, many, many more child abusers would ultimately get caught. Distributing it should obviously still be illegal, but banning simple possession doesn't stop traffickers (obviously) and eliminates an enormous free workforce of amateur sleuths who I am sure would seriously help the problem. They have helped solved many cold case murders that police never could. It's kind of creepy in a way when you think about it. No other crime scene evidence is guarded in that way. Is it illegal to possess photos/videos of someone getting stabbed, shot, beheaded, etc? Surely there are people who derive sexual pleasure from that material too, yet it proliferates and no one really cares. It's almost as if the powers that be REALLY don't want the general public to know who's behind some of this stuff. We already know very rich and powerful people are routinely involved in child sex rings... And the AI image generation stuff makes it even more dangerous and ridiculous. So we're approaching a time when someone can just generate some images locally with stable diffusion or whatever of what looks like CSAM (but no actual children involved), get it into your possession (either remotely or just dropping an SD card in your house somewhere you don't see) and now you are liable for decades in prison...hopefully you don't have any enemies.
- stjohnswarts 3y agoComputers are the modern equivalent of "my papers" for historical reasons. British cops can't come in and rifle through your papers at home without a warrant, there is simply no reason they should be able to come in and rifle through your phone, computer, or anything else without a warrant. Are MPs completely daft? Do they all look to Xi and Putin as examples of "the way things should be" ?