36 ms·
I'm fascinated by the fact that my takeaway is the precise opposite of what the author intended. To me, the answer to all of the questions was crystal-clear. Y
by crazygringo 3y ago
I'm fascinated by the fact that my takeaway is the precise opposite of what the author intended.
To me, the answer to all of the questions was crystal-clear. Yes, you can academically wonder whether an orbiting space station is a vehicle and whether it's in the park, but the obvious intent of the sign couldn't be clearer. Cars/trucks/motorcycles aren't allowed, and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign.
So if this is supposed to be an example of how content moderation rules are unclear to follow, it's achieving precisely the opposite.
(To be clear, I think content moderation rules are often difficult to figure out when to apply. I just think the vehicles-in-park rule is much, much, much clearer than many content moderation rules.)
- hsjqllzlfkf 3y agoIt is unclear given that you and I don't agree. The question wasnt "does the police have to follow the sign", you made that up.
- robinson7d 3y agoThe nuance on that one felt odd. I said that it did violate the rule (even the spirit of the rule, being a large motor vehicle), because it was a binary question. I also felt the rule violation was justified and that they shouldn’t be called out on it.
- hsjqllzlfkf 3y agoI even disagree that there was any nuance. I wasn't told "you're doing content moderation, there's a rule, the rule is violated but there could be some mitigating circumstances, do you allow the content?". I was told: is there a vehicle in the park, and I said yes because a police car is a vehicle and it's in the park.
- emmelaich 3y agoI agree that the police car is a vehicle and and it is a violation. That's the easiest reading. In a real example, though, there'd be law or authority quoted, and you can be sure that's there would be an exception for emergency vehicles. That doesn't change the meaning of the sign in isolation.
- otherme123 3y agoCould be an exception... or not. Some prohibitions come from hazards like "this won't hold your weight" or "this could flood unexpectedly". And there's no emergency vehicle exceptions. I had my closest park in mind when answering. It has a river and multiple wooden bridges to access. Also, the ground floods sometimes in the winter and some paths are too soft for a car. No way an ambulance or firetruck is going to get in the park. They could try, but would loss more time than doing it on foot, or a bridge would collapse under their weight.
- makeitdouble 3y agoThe issue this is inspired from was pretty interesting [0], and notably very few things were exempted from the rules leading to interesting debates on how the rules should be interpreted [0] https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-wilderness-tool/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-wilderness-tool/
- heartbreak 3y agoThe question wasn’t about being called out on it (or punished/prosecuted/whatever). It was simply asking if it violated the rule.
- lkbm 3y agoThe second page of instructions actually specifically addressed that: "Again, please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (not whether the violation should be allowed)." I went with "yes, violation" with the understanding that it's one that would be allowed. Perhaps I was wrong to mix "would" and "should".
- robinson7d 3y agoYou’re absolutely right! My bad, I appear to have forgotten that rule by the time I commented. Glad I called it a violation :)
- tharkun__ 3y agoAnd the instructions very clearly state that you should not take into account whether in this case it would be OK to violate the rule. Just whether the rule was broken or not. As such, a police car or ambulance in the park very clearly violate the rule and thus you must choose that answer.
- mattnewton 3y agoYes, this is the only thing I disagreed with the majority on, and that’s because I answered “was there a vehicle in the park”. I don’t think anyone disagrees that the vehicle should be able to go to the park and we should amend the rule. I came away thinking content moderation with better rules is actually quite achievable
- hsn915 3y agoNo one made anything up. It's obviously the intent of the question. You can pretend that's not the case all you want.
- anonymoushn 3y agoThe question specified that it was only asking whether the rule was violated, not whether the violation should be permitted (e.g. because the police doing their job is more important than the rule)
- eep_social 3y agoAlso, what sign? GP made that up too.
- fortenforge 3y agoI came away with the exact same takeaway. If you really want to convince people that content moderation is a hard problem, just ask them to listen to this Radiolab episode about Facebook's struggle: https://radiolab.org/podcast/post-no-evil https://radiolab.org/podcast/post-no-evil It's much more convincing.
- nonethewiser 3y agoExactly. There is a clear majority in the answers. Sure, there are edge cases, but they are edge cases. But I also want to say this is a really cool website. I love how he used this experience to set the table for what is otherwise essentially a blog post. Very cool. But to hone in a bit more: > It was about content moderation. Specifically, some people think that there could be simple rules for Internet content that are easy to apply. His experiment not only doesn't prove this because of the observation you made (there is a clear majority opinion), but also because the "simple rules" people want ARE simple in contrast to the current standard of assuming you need to be a moral authority. The supposed simple rules aren't simple because they avoid controversy. They are simple because they don't avoid controversy. They are minimal. Basically just take the stuff virtually everyone agrees on, or is illegal/possibly illegal. Yes, there are gray areas there. There are always gray areas. But the gray areas surrounding "we need to shape productive discourse" is a lot more controversial than the gray areas surrounding "is this legal?" Once you stop using moderation to implicitly endorse speech you aren't as responsible for anything that is said. This is the entire point of section 230. And before someone says "well if you have offensive content then advertisers will leave," I want to point out that is not a content moderation problem. That is an advertiser attraction problem. If the goal is advertiser attraction then we are playing a completely different game and you should remove everything that is remotely controversial. Or consider that your business model is inherently bad for speech.
- schoen 3y ago> Once you stop using moderation to implicitly endorse speech you aren't as responsible for anything that is said. This is the entire point of section 230. Are you suggesting that section 230 is meant to discourage Internet intermediaries from moderation? The original intent of this law was to stop requiring intermediaries to choose between adopting a passive conduit role and having legal responsibility for content. The legislators hoped that providing a general protection from liability for user-generated content would encourage more moderation by intermediaries. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230#Background_and_passage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230#Background_and_pas... That might not have been the most pro-speech policy option overall but it was notionally very pluralist (with different platforms potentially having very different standards, purposes, goals, rules, communities, etc.) and it did manage to temper the previous somewhat paradoxical incentives, as well as providing a lot of legal certainty to facilitate the creation of new platforms of various sizes and models. Pretty much everyone on the Internet is frustrated by moderation and sees pathologies and biases of moderation, intermediaries putting their thumb on scales, and so on. On the other hand, what we haven't seen is the enormous volume of litigation against intermediaries that would occur without §230. I expect people would literally be suing Y Combinator over HN moderation decisions. I can think of HN moderation decisions that I really disagree with, but it's impossible for me to imagine that having had those turn into lawsuits would somehow have been better for anyone.
- orionstein 3y agoI felt the exact same way. I found there was exactly one example of a vehicle being in the park, and everything else was fine. That didn't seem to be their intent
- ahahahahah 3y agoYou clearly didn't understand. It's mostly not able how easy or not you found it to apply the rule, it was about how whatever you decided was actually quite different from other people. In fact, you finding it very clear makes the point apply even more.
- zerd 3y agoAre you saying that an ambulance is not a vehicle?
- throwawa14223 3y agoI felt it was easy too, but I felt that almost every item listed was a vehicle and in the park. If it helps here was my reasoning. To start with I checked the dictionary for a definition and it appears that a vehicle is "A device or structure for transporting persons or things; a conveyance". Then it was a matter of categorizing. The only one I had to deliberate was the horse, because while it transports persons or things it isn't a device or structure. I ended up saying almost everything was a vehicle and in the park.
- dmattia 3y agoI think the author should have made the statement "A sandwich is an item of food consisting of two pieces of bread with meat, cheese, or other filling between them". And then asked questions like: - Is a grilled cheese a sandwich? - Is two pieces of bread with a third piece of bread in the middle a sandwich? - Is a hotdog a sandwich? - Is a taco a sandwich? - Is a breadbowl a sandwich? - Is a poptart a sandwich? - Is a calzone a sandwich? - Is a burrito a sandwich? - Is a pizza folded in half a sandwich? Having asked these questions to many folks over the years, I promise the answers are much more split.
- jachee 3y agoAre ravioli sandwiches?
- koolba 3y ago> Is a pizza folded in half a sandwich? If you don’t cut it, no. If you cut it at the fold, yes. Now what if the pizza crust is toasted enough that, while it was not your intent, it breaks evenly at the seam during the act of folding it in half, and then you proceed to collapse the two halves before taking a bite. Did you have a sandwich for lunch?
- dmattia 3y agoAha, I love a man of principle. I would say that I would have had a sandwich in that case, as I believe that the structure of the food item should only be considered as it enters your mouth, completely removed from an explanation as to how that food item came to be up to that point. However, I wonder you you would reconcile an uncut, folded pizza not being a sandwich against a meatball marinara, which to my understanding is a single piece of sliced bread with meat and sauce in the middle. Is this not a sandwich?
- quickthrower2 3y agoTo everyone the answers are crystal clear. That doesn’t mean there isn’t disagreement across a population.
- quickthrower2 3y agoYou are mimicking local jurisdiction rules. You don’t even know why they disallow vehicles. Let’s say because of subsidence or weight load. Then even emergency services should not go in as it would give more risk to them. Instead they need to walk in or use a helicopter suspended in mid air. More surreal maybe it is above that cave in Lost and even an ISS or plane should not go over that location.
- bentcorner 3y ago> Again, please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (not whether the violation should be allowed). Thus IMO emergency vehicles violate the rule, although they should be allowed. Same thing IMO with the tank. Sure it's inoperable but it's a vehicle, in the park.
- fukawi2 3y agoAgree. Emergency vehicles don't automatically get a "free pass", there are separate rules that apply an exemption. So the question and rule, as written, says that the emergency vehicles do violate the rule IMO. In the real world, there would just be other rules that would apply an exemption. (IANAL, but have been driving emergency vehicles for 15 years).
- emmelaich 3y agoI would say the tank is no longer a vehicle. More like a statue than a vehicle.
- Rebelgecko 3y agohow is it getting into the park? If it's rolling, IMO it's still a vehicle. If a truck is dropping it off, still a no-no
- jamdamu 3y agoWhat if the rule was created after the tank was already in the park? There was no information given on how the tank was transported to the park, and you're creating a violation based off a hypothetical.
- raphman 3y agoMaybe a huge crane lifted it into the park from outside the park. Would the crane be in the park then?
- aerio 3y agoWhat if it's fired from a cannon and lands in the park?
- jandrese 3y agoThere are two ways to approach the problem. Either to be dogmatic about the wording or to be practical. I ended up with only one "is a vehicle" because I was enforcing it the way I would enforce a rule like that in real life, a practical rule. If you were being dogmatic about the wording you would undermine the likely intent of the sign by kicking people out of their wheelchairs and having to shoot down the ISS. Rigid adherence to bad (or even just badly worded) rules is its own form of tyranny, one that is even more insidious because it has a veneer of legitimacy. Much evil has been perpetrated throughout history by people who were "just following orders".
- emmelaich 3y agoRules are for the police. Intent is for the judges / lawyers.
- andrewflnr 3y agoIf people don't agree on it, then the clarity you feel is an illusion. The point of rules is common understanding of what is acceptable. Notably, you pulled a bunch of special cases and refinements from thin air. The way I read the setup, it was "crystal clear" that the rule was violated by emergency services, even if we could agree afterwards not to enforce it there. And, yes, of course, moderation questions are much harder. At least with the vehicle thing people aren't usually aren't deliberately constructing tricky cases.
- cmdli 3y agoI feel the same way as the above comment. If you were an actual administrator in charge of fining people for violating the rule, almost none of these examples should give you pause. You wouldn't be trying to give a ticket to planes flying overhead, for example. With these examples, there really isn't much disagreement on whether action should be taken, so any discussion of whether a rule is technically violated is moot.
- raldi 3y agoIf you didn't think a bicycle violated the rule, what about an e-bike? Or a fully battery-powered bike that doesn't require pedaling?
- MontyCarloHall 3y agoThose are exactly the questions the quiz should have asked, not clearly absurd examples that are unambiguously not vehicles in the park, like the ISS passing over the park.
- hsn915 3y agoYea this seems like an argument in favor of extensive (and confusing) legaleese / lawyerese
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- taneq 3y agoSo which side of the vehicle/nonvehicle line did you choose for these? Wagon, wheel chair, skateboard, surf board, parachute, roller skates, ice skates, shoes, socks.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoIt's not that hard. You have to understand a "park" is usually primarily some pseudo-preserve of nature, with varying degrees of permitted human recreational uses. That is what a "park" actually means. Users of parks generally know there will be varying usage rules for the park based on the park. But generally speaking, things that will destroy the "natural perserved" aspects, things that will disrupt other people using the park, aren't allowed. And, like moderation, if you don't understand the context of what a park is in society, you should either go there with someone that does, ask the authorities in charge of the park, or DON'T GO. So the answer to the question is "what activities are supported by the park, do you know other people that use those implements there without controversy". You socially interact to know. If it is a grey area, ask either someone that may know, or the authorities. This isn't Zeno's paradoxes. You aren't asking if the vehicle is every technically being used at the park because the atoms are repelled by the electromagnetic force and things never actually touch each other. It isn't something that needs to be solved philosophically. There are people with authoritative knowledge, and you ask them the questions, and they give a "yes or no". And you either obey their judgement, or you break the rules. If the AI (because this HAS to be about AI, why else is this dribble here) can't understand the context, it won't effectively moderate.
- josefx 3y ago> There are people with authoritative knowledge, and you ask them the questions, and they give a "yes or no". Given that there have been many cases of lawmakers not understanding the impact of their own laws. Contracts unraveled by punctuation errors, complex interactions between rules, people managing parks often not being the same as people writing the rules, ... . I find this claim to be completely removed from reality.
- 3y ago
- iab 3y agoIt was crystal clear to you. Now imagine someone with diametrically opposed views - they also have an interpretation that is crystal clear.
- Fatnino 3y agoSeriously. I read the rule and I hear "keep the park a park". Only the car is forbidden and everything else goes.
- sarchertech 3y agoSame here. I looked at the intent of the rule given the context. Rules are enforced by humans not robots and are meaningless without context. When you do try to enforce rules literally, you end up with kids being expelled because they brought an action figure to school, or teenagers being executed because they fell into a flower bed.
- YurgenJurgensen 3y agoYou weren't being asked to enforce a rule, you were being asked to determine if a rule has been violated.
- sarchertech 3y agoWhether a rule has been violated is a meaningless concept outside of the context of enforcement. Natural language itself must be interpreted within a context.
- YurgenJurgensen 3y agoAnd yet, the courts and the police are separate entities.
- sarchertech 3y agoCourts consider the context of enforcement, and police both decide whether something is a violation as well as handling enforcement. And at least in the US generally you need to have been harmed, or be likely to be harmed by enforcement of a rule to even have standing to challenge it.
- dec0dedab0de 3y agoCars/trucks/motorcycles aren't allowed, and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. Obviously emergency vehicles are going to do what they need to do, but even if they are allowed to break the rule they are still breaking the rule. I also think a park sign that says no vehicles also applies to bicycles and skateboards.
- bandofthehawk 3y agoEven if the park includes a skate park and a bike trail? I guess it depends on what size/type of park you are familiar with.
- willsmith72 3y agoWhat??? Please explain. I can't fathom how a no vehicles sign would apply to bicycles or skateboards
- godelski 3y agoAllow me to introduce you to the dictionary[0] Vehicle (noun) 1. a means of carrying or transporting something ...such as ... a: motor vehicle ... b: a piece of mechanized equipment 2 : an agent of transmission : carrier 3: a medium through which something is expressed, achieved, or displayed ---------------- You're thinking of specifically a __motorized__ vehicle. Which is a different thing than "vehicle". I think you'll agree that a bicycle and skateboard carry people and transport them. This is the same reason a wagon violates the rule. Almost everything on there was a vehicle. I think the only ambiguous ones are paper airplane, matchbox car, toy boat, and kite and I said those weren't because they can't transport things and are not motorized. But hey, technically they can be a medium through which someone expresses their joy. No painting or dancing in the park. [0] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/vehicle https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/vehicle
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3y ago
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoIs this some dumb philosophical thing? It's just contextualized language, with fairly well established context. You have a "park". You have a rule about "no vehicles in park". If you have been to enough parks, you know that they generally will entail some sort of separation of nature from the more general technological society around it, and certainly from one of the major aspects of that technological society, big ass heavy noisy smelly destructive annoying vehicles. You will also know that parks are managed and funded by some authority, who may have necessity to enter and maintain them with "vehicles" that they know and are trained to operate and use properly in the park, likewise with emergency services and their vehicles. So let's look at content moderation in this standpoint. Almost always, content moderation is within a context of a forum, where there is a subject matter and a set of germane topics. The subject matter often has implicit constraints, a lot like a park. The other interesting thing about a park is that you arrive at one, and you can generally tell what is acceptable behavior in a park without the rules by observing what other people are doing, and "conforming" to that behavior. And if you don't know, you ask people around you and they will tell you yes/no/dunno and whether they are knowledgeable. I can see a forum or subreddit kind of the same. If a person was going to the park asking these questions, the actual answer after about four or five questions is "you probably shouldn't go to a park, or do whatever it is you want to do there, because you don't understand parks very well" Similarly for something that is content moderated, after about four or five questions that clearly show you don't understand the subject matter of the forum or how to interact with other people involved in the subject matter, the answer is "you shouldn't post or say anything in that forum". The ACTUAL corner cases in this are "well, can I take an electric bike into the park?" "Can my personal dog-robot follow me into the park?" "can I ride my electric blade scooter in the park?" "Okay, how BIG of an e-bike can I bring in?" "Is the no-vehicle policy about loud dirty ICE engines, or is it mostly about size?" because electric vehicles will ACTUALLY stress that stuff out.
- torton 3y agoI agree with this take. Most questions were very obvious when thought about from the angle of "what is the intent of the rule", which is likely to be "let people enjoy the park by not allowing large, noisy, smelly conveyances". Bikes, kites, monuments, Radio Flyers, etc. do not violate the intent. A tank is clearly a vehicle but doesn't violate the intent because it does not interfere with people enjoying the park. And rules do not apply to on-duty emergency vehicles. Clearly not everybody thinks about the intent, and many people focus on discussing the nitpicking corner cases of the rules, or thinking about the definition of a vehicle or "being in the park" (see also "what is a sandwich"). That's okay, and that proves the author's point that moderation is not a mathematical problem with a single formally provable solution.
- croo 3y agoThis is only true until an old grumpy lady is sitting on a bench in the park and don't want to hear any more skateboard noise. From that point on there is someone who considers skateboarding a violation of this rule.
- barrkel 3y agoBikes do annoy people with small children because some people try to ride bikes fast where not appropriate, and this is dangerous when small children change direction unpredictably.
- cypress66 3y agoIt seems more like you didn't read the instructions > Again, please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (not whether the violation should be allowed).
- default-kramer 3y agoI did read the instructions and I also assumed that I should use my judgment to determine whether the intent of the sign was violated. If the author had wanted otherwise, they should have said something like "Forget everything you about how laws are written and interpreted in the real world and simply take the most literal interpretation you can, with no regard for how ridiculous the outcome might be."
- godelski 3y ago> If the author had wanted otherwise, they should have said something like "Forget everything you about how laws are written and interpreted in the real world and simply take the most literal interpretation you can, with no regard for how ridiculous the outcome might be." >> You might know of some rule in your jurisdiction which overrides local rules, and allows certain classes of vehicles. Please disregard these rules; the park isn't necessarily in your jurisdiction. >> Or perhaps your religion allows certain rules to be overridden. >> Again, please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (__not whether the violation should be allowed__). Seems like they did
- default-kramer 3y ago>> You might know of some rule in your jurisdiction which overrides local rules, and allows certain classes of vehicles. Please disregard these rules; the park isn't necessarily in your jurisdiction. But the park is somewhere on Earth, right? And the sign is written in English for humans to read and understand. Ignoring my personal locality/jurisdiction doesn't change this. >> Or perhaps your religion allows certain rules to be overridden. This one felt irrelevant to me. >> Again, please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (__not whether the violation should be allowed__). This tells me that my job is to determine whether the rule allows skateboards and not whether the rule should allow skateboards. This does not instruct me to be ridiculously literal while making that determination.
- raldi 3y agoWhat did you answer about bicycles and roller skates? It wasn't one of the questions, but I bet razor scooters would split the vote close to 50/50. And what if the fire marshal is visiting the park to evaluate the maximum occupancy of the office — can they drive their official vehicle into the park for that?
- godelski 3y agoYou are absolutely the example of their point. Your dogmatic approach is not universal. This should be clear as I'm sure you didn't get a 100% match.
- mehlmao 3y agoI'm a cyclist. Without additional context, I said that a bicycle (and skateboards (that aren't being carried)) are not allowed in the park.
- davideg 3y agoWhat was your percentage of agreeing with the majority? Greater than 50%? I think your response to this exercise actually proves the author's point. I see people disagreeing with your take in the comments or making (to their perspective) reasonable arguments in favor of their choices. Whether you found it personally "crystal-clear" to answer the way you did says more about your personal confidence and way of understanding rules than about the task itself being unambiguous.
- josefx 3y ago> and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. Cue ambulance crashing through a wooden bridge over a river because it was never intended to carry the weight, or getting stuck in a tunnel, driving over pedestrians that can't get out of the way because there is no space left, ... . Blindly ignoring a rule because you can is not always a good idea. You might be able to ignore the rule, but you can't ignore the reason why it was put in place.
- kristopolous 3y agoAn interesting way to go about this would be through revelation The rule is "no adult content" 1 A scholar is discussing their recently published contribution 2 as a professional sexologist 3 whose area of study is pornography 4 Ancient pornography 5 And how it relates to modern styles 6 of fiction literature and paintings 7 by quoting seedy passages of ancient erotic literate 8 written in ancient Sumerian Etc... With every sentence fragment of increasing context you can get people changing their minds
- apricot 3y agoSurely I can't be the only one who imagined Homer Simpson going "that's good... that's bad" while reading that comment. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7osb78oZ9Z4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7osb78oZ9Z4
- Qwertious 3y ago>but the obvious intent of the sign couldn't be clearer. Cars/trucks/motorcycles aren't allowed, and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. I answered that the police and ambulances were obviously breaking the rules, because they are. The difference is that ambulances/police are allowed to break the rules in an emergency - famously, ambulances have a legal right to speed and run red lights in an emergency, and cops obviously have a right to trespass. This of course is a paradox, as a rule is something that you are forbidden from doing, and being allowed to break the rule means you're allowed to do something you're forbidden from doing, which when interpreted literally is an oxymoron. The obvious explanation is that the cops/ambulances have a set of rules that take priority over the park's rules , and some rules are more important than others.
- carstenhag 3y agoSee, even there for me it's rather a "firefighters/police have an exemption to the rules". For you it's "firefighters/police are breaking the rule but it's fine".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jstanley 3y agoExcept the blurb at the start clearly says there are no exemptions. The only rule is "no vehicles in the park". So all you're judging is 1.) is it a vehicle? and 2.) is it in the park?
- mryijum 3y agoYeah, I actually thought that the phrasing of the blurb weighted the answers in a particular direction, and was surprised to discover that most did not answer questions about emergency vehicles as violating the rule. To quote specifically, it says "...please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (not whether the violation should be allowed)." In fact, it sort of seems like this sentence should wreck the effort to demonstrate the difficulty of content moderation. I would think that a significant amount of the difficulty comes from instances where moderators feel that interactions between different rules mean they should allow violations of particular rules in certain situations.
- manmal 3y ago> obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. That’s not so clear IMO. It depends on the severity and urgency of the accident, and whether there is a really prohibitive issue that entirely prevents heavy vehicles from entering, like quicksand or muddy ground that will get an EMT stuck.
- zimpenfish 3y ago> obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign By "doing their jobs", you presumably mean "responding to an emergency call", right? Because, e.g., cops in normal transit from A to B are "doing their jobs" but letting them drive through a "no vehicles allowed" park in that instance is probably bad. Or if they're on a high-speed chase - definitely "doing their jobs" but not something you'd want to happen through a park. > an example of how content moderation rules are unclear to follow You've amply demonstrated this by creating a huge muddy mess around "emergency services doing their jobs".
- pointsmissed 3y ago[flagged]
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Yes, you can academically wonder whether an orbiting space station is a vehicle and whether it's in the park, but the obvious intent of the sign couldn't be clearer. Cars/trucks/motorcycles aren't allowed, and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. Now you're assuming the intent. The park could contain loose soil on the edge of a cliff, so any vehicle driving there could cause a landslide that topples the vehicle over the cliff and could kill anyone on the beach below. No vehicles in the park. But the larger point is that people can adopt the "obvious intent" version of the rule when it suits them and the pedantic version of the rule when it suits them. If you're the park ranger and the local police come into the park in their car chasing after some criminals, and the local police are your buddies, you say they haven't violated the rule because the intent isn't to apply to emergency vehicles. If the exact same thing happens but you're having a dispute with the local police, now they're violating the rule and you can come up with something like the park isn't in their jurisdiction. It's the same rule. It's the same action. The only difference is if you like them or not. And that's the problem.
- raverbashing 3y ago> If you're the park ranger and the local police come into the park in their car chasing after some criminals... If the exact same thing happens but you're having a dispute with the local police It doesn't matter, the rules on police and emergency vehicles usually supersede some local rule about a park. The park is not some absolute ruler of the land, sure it can put rules for general/everyday use but a lot of things are rules at higher levels
- chii 3y ago> supersede some local rule aka, there's some other rule that isn't listed then? Which isn't what is being discussed here.
- hyperhopper 3y agoYes, you're assuming that this is a jurisdiction where police or ambulances have authority over local rules
- barrkel 3y agoIt's clear that the rule is broken by emergency vehicles. Whether they need to follow the rule is a different question and not the one asked.
- sjducb 3y agoDid you look at the answers other people gave at the end of the quiz? Did 100% of those people agree with you?
- emodendroket 3y agoI thought it was clear and obvious and then at the end I learned I agree with the majority only 12% of the time.
- zekica 3y agoSame, I agreed with the majority only 11% of the time.
- dang 3y agoGood point. The intro to the quiz asks you to answer the questions literally, but by asking this the author kind of assumes their own conclusion. I wonder how much consensus there would be if the intro asked you to go by the intent of the rule as you understand it, rather than what it literally says. The first time I went through the quiz, I followed the instructions and had to think about definitions a lot. Then I read your comment and went through the quiz again and just used common sense (dangerous phrase, but I believe it worked in all 27 cases). There was only one violation: someone drove a Honda Civic through the park. What was that person thinking! On HN we've always tried to avoid hair-splitting arguments by appealing to general values rather than trying to nail down the precise list of disallowed behaviors [1, 2]. Trying to be precise seems like a ticket to bureaucratic, soul-destroying hell [3]. I'd rather just say that there aren't precise rules, just an intended spirit and a few pointers, and yeah that means there's a lot of interpretation involved. There's going to be a lot of interpretation involved no matter what you do, so why pretend otherwise? Just make it clear up front. Then you can say "someone's got to interpret the rules, and that happens to be my job, and I'm interpreting them this way". People will get mad, but people are going to get mad no matter what you do, and at least you won't have to argue about whether a bicycle is a vehicle. That doesn't mean there aren't edge cases and disputes about which calls are fair. There are tons of those. But if you don't try to be precise then at least you don't get into semantic hell. Except when you do. Boy this work's hard: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lStcwT_RGrQ#t=132 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lStcwT_RGrQ#t=132. [1] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20spirit%20letter%20law&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu... [2] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20litigious&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11301437 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11301437
- tsukikage 3y ago> The intro to the quiz asks you to answer the questions literally, but by asking this the author kind of assumes their own conclusion. ...and yet in this very HN discussion we have large numbers of people disagreeing about the intent of the small, clearly written intro, with each side convinced that their interpretation is the obviously correct one. I feel this does as much to support the author's thesis as the game itself.
- fwlr 3y agoWhat was your answer on the wheelchair? Same as for bicycle, or different? If different, what about a wheelchair but the person in it doesn’t need a wheelchair, they just enjoy the sporting aspect of arm-powered vehicles? The other way I would “problematize” (to borrow the author’s wording) your crystal-clear understanding is to ask about the matchbox car, then the remote control car, then one of those kid-size toy cars that the kid drives around (then a small one-person electric car, then a full-size electric car). I suppose another angle would be, are bicycles okay? What about battery-powered bicycles? Does it change if we add a small petrol motor to recharge the battery?
- az226 3y agoEhm. I answered that the cop and ambulance were in violation of the rule, but it’s sometimes okay to break the rules. That doesn’t mean they didn’t break the rules — it means they were justified in breaking the rules.
- chii 3y agoin other words, there's two pieces here, 1) the rule, 2) the consequences of breaking the rule. It is agreed that the rule (1) is broken by emergency vehicles. It is unknown that (2) is in effect (it is not described in the scenario), but people would assume that there's no consequences for emergency vehicles breaking the rule.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- raverbashing 3y agoYes I'd say it's "unclear to follow" to adversarial (or just nitpicking) people (Also) because we have a context of a park and of general rules. (Also if you think the ISS is a vehicle on the park you're welcome to try to enforce that)
- clhodapp 3y agoGiven the spiel at the beginning about how this place is different from where I live and that in this place, there are no rules which trump the park's rules, I can't agree that it's obvious that police, ambulances, and fire trucks obviously don't have to follow the rules. To me, it seems that the framing all but says that they do.
- vidarh 3y agoPolice, ambulances and fire trucks are if anything some of the clearest violations. They are unambiguously vehicles. They are unambiguously entering the park. It was really surprising to me how many so explicitly ignored the instructions for them.
- fouronnes3 3y ago> and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. I agree with this obviously, but I feel quite strongly that you must answer "Yes, this violates the rule" to the emergency vehicles questions, because the rules of the game at the beginning clearly stated that you should answer about the violation itself, not about whether it should be allowed.
- ohgodplsno 3y agoIt's also an awfully simplistic vision of moderation/rules, whereas the answer in real life should be "it depends". Should an emergency vehicle be allowed through the park? Yes. As another comment says, is there a known risk about things collapsing in the park? Guess what, that kind of stuff is either displayed prominently at the entrance, or told in advance to the few people that might legitimately have to go through the park. Simple solutions do not apply to such an extremely complex as human behaviour. In the same way, moderation can not rely on simple, inflexible rules. Yes, sometimes you're gonna ban someone who's just skirting them. Yes, a few dumbasses are going to complain. Ignore them, ban then too, whatever.
- Ruarl 3y agoWasn't the point of the experiment not that you could come up with answers that seemed sensible to you, but that different people came up with different answers that seemed sensible to them? I too felt the line was fairly clear in this case, but I was very surprised that others thought differently. It isn't mentioned in the discussion on the results page, but one facet of effective moderation this shines a light on is as follows: each of us may find the moderation task easy, but few (or none) of us would be a moderator who would be universally trusted.
- pyb 3y agoYes, but then the experiment kinda proves the opposite of the point it was trying to prove. As it were, people largely agree with each other as to what's reasonable and what is not.
- Ruarl 3y agoThat was not how I interpreted the results. Nor the discussion elsewhere on this page where some people included skateboards and bicycles under "vehicle" and some did not.
- ilyt 3y agoThe people do. But the moderator can still use vague rules to do what people would not agree upon while still claiming it is within rules, and there always will be someone agreeing with it
- movpasd 3y agoWhat I find really amusing is that the top comment (yours) is about how obvious the interpretation of the rules is, but there are dozens of subcomments disagreeing with your interpretation and each insisting how obvious their own interpretation is... exactly like with content moderation ;) In my view, there's always an obvious initial purpose and interpretation (the Honda Civic), and you always have those that will pedantically insist on the most literal Draconian interpretation (the ISS), then you have those who stretch the rules to fit their agenda (bikes), but, most importantly, you have some class of common edge cases which spark significant disagreement (emergency services), even if we all agree on 90% of the point (which is that yes, emergency services should be able to drive through the park during an emergency, regardless of whether the rule is broken).
- benj111 3y ago>obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. It's still breaking the rule though. Legally I suspect it varies between jurisdictions whether the sign doesn't apply to them, it does apply but conflicts with another rule, or whether it's argued as an extenuating circumstance. Then there's the edge cases like bikes and horses. Are they vehicles? It's completely reasonable that they could be deemed to be. We've got the same kind of argument going on with e scooters at the moment. Ultimately I answered a lot of these based on what I would expect to see in a park, and what I think is reasonable. But they aren't objective measures.
- scaramanga 3y agoThere is being rational, using principles to interpret a statement. And then there is being rational to the extent that you are in complete denial about that the fact that your rational faculty is located within a spongy organ in the cranial cavity of an ambulatory meat bag. There doesn't need to be an objective measure for you to take a position on the intent and meaning of a linguistic construct such as a rule. It is just a thing that bipedal meatbags do. If one meatbag has a different view than another meatbag then they are in a political conflict. There are ways of resolving the conflict which range from friendly chat, through formal debate, right the way to genocide. Generally speaking, well adjusted members of civilised society can resolve things through the former. Sometimes we go fucking bananas and end up at the latter. Not sure why so many find it so difficult to grasp, or feel the need to apologize that they are mortal, they can't derive the answer from a set of universally agreed-upon axioms and carve it in to a stone tablet like some old-testament god ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- jstummbillig 3y ago> So if this is supposed to be an example of how content moderation rules are unclear to follow, it's achieving precisely the opposite. The game gives a super simple 2-paragraph-instruction that I feel could not be any clearer, but that you chose to ignore in favor of your own interpretation of what is being asked (because you deem the intent "crystal-clear"). Super fascinating.
- ricardobayes 3y agoIn Europe our driver education contains a legal definition of a vehicle (and motor vehicle). You'll find almost all parks with drivable roads will have a clear definition at the entrance what's allowed and what isn't. If in Europe there was a sign that says "no vehicles", that disallows skateboards and bicycles too. Signs will always make it clear if they mean "motor vehicles".
- eep_social 3y agoIn this case, there was no sign, only a rule. The sign was made up by the gp along with a bunch of other contextual details.
- rasse 3y agoI think the purpose was to focus on the rule not on the intent of the rule.
- moffkalast 3y agoFollowing rules without thinking of their intent is just malicious compliance.
- rasse 3y agoIt sure _may_ be. Nevertheless, the efficient way of solving the problem is making concise and accurate rules, and perhaps explicitly expressing the intent. If the rule or intent is ambiguous, problems may be considered inevitable. In the above game, you really can't guess the intent. Of course this is partly, because it's an abstract example. But the intent can't really be "no cars or carsy things", because the real intent in "no cars in the park" would be perhaps a combination of no loud noises, no high speed, no heavy objects, no pollution etc. I realize this may not be an agreeable point since I only got 11% in the game with the assumption that a vehicle is something used for transport (excluding wearables) and that the rules would be seen somewhere in or around the park (so not in the air).
- ben_w 3y agoFor me, it is obvious that police and ambulances in emergencies violate the rule. They may have some higher-level rule that says "in emergencies we don't get punished for violating this category of rule", but the rule is still there, and requires the drivers to demonstrate that there was in fact an emergency. A hierarchy of rules is why normal people don't get to act like cops, or perform amateur heart transplants. Bikes are a more interesting edge case for me; I think they are, as I expect the reason for the rule to be some kind of environment degradation, possibly easily damaged lawns or similar. But they might be fine. Depends on the reason for the rule.
- vertis 3y agoNo, police and ambulances are vehicles. They're not allowed in the park. It's a violation. Maybe they can get away with the violation but if you're following the rules it's a violation. This is why the real rules say "Emergency vehicles allowed", and then usually "No skateboarding, roller blading, scooters".
- the_gipsy 3y ago> obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. An emergency or service vehicle in practice could have an overriding exemption rule (or not and just ignore some rules without retaliation), but they still violate "No vehicles in the park".
- MrOxiMoron 3y agoyou give emergency vehicles an exception to the rule, that was specifically mentions as not being the intent. the rule is no vehicles in the park, an ambulance is a vehicle so it broke the rule. if then punishment is applied and what is something else, in the basis it's a vehicle in the park.
- vidarh 3y ago> and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. The instructions specifically tell you to disregard any unstated assumptions about exceptions for special vehicles. So in this way you have just illustrated the authors point.
- OtomotO 3y agoThat's why you add a "why" in any rule or law. If you add this, you clarify the intent and can meaningfully declare exceptions like "no rules in the park because people come here to relax. Of course if a vehicle is necessary to e.g. stop a wildfire or stop a criminal from shooting people, a vehicle is more than welcome"
- SideburnsOfDoom 3y ago> and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. They have to acknowledge that the rule exists, and then deliberately break it, because their task takes priority over the rule. If the question is "does this break the rule?" then the answer is "yes, but". If the question is "will it stay out of the park?" then the answer is "no". The real world doesn't work exactly like if (cond) statements in code.
- noduerme 3y agothe child in the electric toy car is probably the real dividing line on the question of what is a "vehicle"... the ISS orbiting is the line on what is "in the park"... and the police car in an emergency is where you're supposed to bend the definition of the word "allowed". I think the answer to the survey is "I want to talk to my lawyer".
- teew 3y ago> police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. The question was not about whether the rule ought to be followed, but whether it was violated. Content moderation can work under these circumstances, too. The setup in the beginning even tries to take the ought out of the deliberations: "Your job is to determine if this rule has been violated. You might know of some rule in your jurisdiction which overrides local rules, and allows certain classes of vehicles. Please disregard these rules [...]" an even goes on to mention other sources of norms. It explicitly then says: "Again, please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (not whether the violation should be allowed)."
- proactivesvcs 3y agoIt's crystal clear until it's not. In the UK a bicycle is, rightly so, considered a vehicle. I know this, but I'd guess many British people do not. I also understand why bicycles are considered vehicles and, when on my bike, tend to follow the spirit of rules and designs that appear to prohibit vehicles. I would not ride in the park, but would walk my bike in the park. I'd be breaking the rules but adhering to the spirit of them.
- charlieyu1 3y agoI will say an ambulance or police car in the park does break the rule. It is fine to break the rule sometimes though.
- ilyt 3y ago> So if this is supposed to be an example of how content moderation rules are unclear to follow, it's achieving precisely the opposite. Because you assume one following them does it out of good will and good intentions. Now imagine the moderator that needs to adhere to such rules doesn't use them as guideline but as something to work around to remove the things they personally don't like. And they don't need to explain to the public why they thin it falls upon, they can just silently remove it, or put a comment "removed because rule xyz" and comments to that disabled. Now imagine rules like /r/games, "No content primarily for humor or entertainment" or "No off-topic or low-effort content or comments". CLEARLY meant to stop memeing and spamming random game screenshots, but oh so easy to attach to nearly anything. Same with title formatting rules. Should you copy-paste clickbaity title of the article or editorialize it to mean what the article says about? DOESN'T MATTER, if mods don't like the topic they will find an excuse. So the post gets removed but someone links to a different article with normal title that links to that as source ? Nope, LOW EFFORT, removed, should've linked to the original one (that's actual situation I saw on that subreddit, mods really don't like VNs there, and it wasn't about porn one either)
- default-kramer 3y agoThis is a great take. I thought the author was only trying to demonstrate problems that occur when moderators act in good faith. Since the only forum I use is HN, I forget that plenty of moderators do not act in good faith.
- earlgray 3y agoI agree 100% with the spirit of your point and I think imagining a forced bet scenario can help to clarify things. There are three main concepts we want to interpret within the context of the phrasing of the rule: (1) the intended referrent of 'vehicle'; (2) the intended meaning of 'in' the park; (3) the actual intention of the rule regarding emergency vehicles. This is the scenario: imagine you're forced to wager a nontrivial sum of money on the following bet. You have to write down how you interpreted (1), (2), and (3). Then we randomly pick a real park that has this exact rule phrased in this exact way (I'm hopeful there'll be at least one out there), find the person who wrote the rule, give them your written interpretation, and ask if they agree. You lose if they don't. Notice we're not asking them to also write down a longer interpretation and comparing word-for-word. Just whether they think you got the gist of it. I would write down that 'vehicle' was intended to refer to motorized passenger vehicles, 'in' was intended to mean that the vehicles shouldn't be in/on water or land within park boundaries, and that the rule wasn't intended to restrict passage to emergency vehicles responding to emergency situations. I expect most people would write something similar if they had real money on the line. The trouble with the horrible website is it's trying to prove that nebulosity makes content moderation difficult by forcing people to disagree, but this disagreement almost entirely pertains to a point that has nothing to do with nebulosity: the park rule would only ever be written within a wider legal framework and doesn't make sense in isolation. If I take my answers to (1) and (2), I'm forced to conclude that the emergency vehicles were violating the rule within the ridiculously artificial scenario presented. However, I'm also confident that this rule would only have been written verbatim within a wider legal framework that provided exceptions for emergency vehicles. Consider self-defence in the context of murder or manslaughter. In the UK at least, the first thing the court does is establish whether the defendant would fit the criteria for murder / manslaughter ignoring the self-defence aspect, because otherwise it's a moot point. Once this is done, they would then establish whether the defence of self-defence also applies, which would then negate the conviction. If you wanted to prove that law is complex because it's hard to define words, would you really make a website that says "Ignore everything else you know and suppose that murder is only defined as killing a person" and then think you're being really smart when people disagree on the scenario involving clear self-defence? Hopefully not, because they're really only disagreeing with being forced to invoke your artificially-restricted definition. That said, the website demonstrates the real reason why online moderation is hard: because it disproportionately attracts the sorts of people who answered 'yes' to the ISS question in this quiz. So you often end up with lots of users sharing a reasonable consensus on what the rules mean being moderated by a tiny group of... we'll say 'non-representative' moderators. It's a common problem with any banal form of authority, and isn't specific to website moderation at all.
- denysvitali 3y ago"obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign" They basically said to ignore local jurisdiction laws. Depending on where the sign is placed, this might not be so obvious. If you take the sign rule to the letter, an ambulance is a vehicle and thus cannot enter the park as well. Police can enter the park, but without a vehicle.
- mnw21cam 3y agoI'll argue that the police can enter the park with their vehicles, but they'll be violating the rule when they do so. But if we're ignoring local rules and the only question is whether or not they would be violating the rules, then yes they would be, and whether they can anyway is out of scope.
- denysvitali 3y agoYes, exactly my interpretation - which makes this a rule violation. Whether this rule violation should be persecuted is a different matter though :)
- graftak 3y agoIn that scenario the duty to help citizens in need simply supersedes the rule that vehicles are not allowed in the park. So pedantically the EMT and police officer are breaking the rule, but breaking the rule of idly standing by in an emergency is worse. The reason to allow emergency vehicles to go through the park must then outweigh the benefit of the ‘no vehicles allowed rule’. Something trivial like a pedestrian illegally crossing the street should not warrant the police going on a car chase through said park.
- denysvitali 3y agoYes, I'm not questioning whether in real life this sign would cause issues or not. The question is "Does this violate the rule?", To which the answer is "yes" for an ambulance. Whether it's fine in certain scenarios to break some rules it's a different topic though.
- msla 3y ago> I just think the vehicles-in-park rule is much, much, much clearer than many content moderation rules. And as clear as it is, it can still be enforced selectively. That's the point.
- nailer 3y agoI may have answered differently from you (I would say the police violated the rule) but I think we actually agree on the point that the rules do not apply to emergency workers. In essence, the data collected isn’t reflective of peoples actual attitudes.
- noduerme 3y agoI think it's more intended to be a proof of how people have a difficult time applying clear-cut rules without relying on their prior biases. That (conceptually) is a really good exercise and one that we could all benefit from. The implementation, explanation and result transparency otoh, are garbage.
- laurentlb 3y agoTo me, a bike is clearly a vehicle. To double-check, I've searched for "list of vehicles" on Google, all the lists I have seen include bikes in them (and I didn't expect anyone to disagree with this).
- whelp_24 3y agoThe intent isn't super clear. Personally, I don't think that emergency vehicles are obviously exempt, we don't know why the rule is there. I don't that bicycles are obviously exempt either, they are clear vehicles that go faster than normal human speeds and the line between motorcycle and bicycle is rather unclear. (Ask five of your friends and associates whether ebikes should be allow on a bike path, then ask about ebikes that hit 45mph, then ice mopeds, then those e unicycle things, then the faster versions...) Likewise with boats, it seems that there are many cases where no watercraft at all should be allowed, and other cases where a motorboat is fine even if they don't want cars and whatnot in the park. And while flying aover a park is arguably not in it, a helicopter hovering a few feet over a field obviously is in the park and far more disruptive than the other vehicles. And if i want to say no skateboarding, roller blading, scootering, pogoing, or any alternative in the park? I agreed with 11% of people, but that is 1 in 10 who agree your take isn't correct. (granted i think a small wagon is ridiculous to enforce under like 90% of circumstances)
- hcks 3y agoYou just chose to ignore the game.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hcks 3y agoFascinating that the first comment entirely disregard the very simple game rules (“it’s not about your jurisdiction“ and “it’s not about wether the rule should be disregarded in that case“). Is it just because that way you can feel smart having “solved“ the game? Or do you think there’s a moral imperative to say an ambulance isn’t breaking a rule even in an abstract word game? Do you understand abstraction, and that this isn’t really about a park?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- codetrotter 3y ago> obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign Most likely true. But to me the answer for the question itself is not about whether the rule can be overridden by any other rules. It’s purely about the rule itself. The intro supports this: > You might know of some rule in your jurisdiction which overrides local rules, and allows certain classes of vehicles. Please disregard these rules; the park isn't necessarily in your jurisdiction. Or perhaps your religion allows certain rules to be overridden. Again, please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (not whether the violation should be allowed). There is a difference between a rule being violated, and whether the violation of the rule is allowed. Like they say in that intro text. Therefore, all of the examples with police motor vehicles and ambulance motor vehicles are to be answered as being in violation of the rule.
- 3pt14159 3y agoThe only one that I don't understand is the horse. A horse is not a vehicle. A horse is a horse, of course.
- rkta 3y agoAnd no one can talk to a horse, of course.
- newaccount74 3y agoI think the website is very disingenuous because it purposely asks the wrong question. The question is not "is the rule technically violated", the question is "should they be fined for violating the rule". If you asked the latter question, then 99% of people would agree on all questions.
- chairhairair 3y agoDisingenuous? The game is trying to demonstrate that content moderation, even using simple explicit rules, is hard and will lead to disagreements. The game has absolutely nothing to do with whether vehicles should actually be allowed in the hypothetical park, let alone if there should be fines.
- motbus3 3y agoSame here. Also the questions have dubious intent. Does something violate the rule? Some times they do and sometimes we need to understand if that's acceptable or fix what made this rule to be broken. But I think many people interpret the question as "should it be allowed"
- cj 3y ago> and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. I disagree due to the instructions on the page before starting the quiz: "please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (not whether the violation should be allowed)." The game is specifically asking us not to make a judgement call on whether a violation of the rule should be permitted. So, police are violating the rule (even if we think it's allowable)
- comboy 3y agoAnd police is like one super clear example of violation, everybody can agree car is a vehicle, and it's clearly written that you answer whether it's a violation not whether it should be, ignoring your local laws. And yet it is top comment, with many confirmations in the replies. I had to scroll really really long to find somebody quoting short instruction which the parent is ignoring. So long story short, amazing job with that game. It's seems really hard to present the case for how difficult moderation is any clearer. Fascinating stuff. Also, I'm too lazy but it would be nice to see LLMs answers. edit: curiosity won, not all questions, GPT4: https://gist.github.com/comboy/71caac8afdc1b92d103c4ec7c42e4887 https://gist.github.com/comboy/71caac8afdc1b92d103c4ec7c42e4...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- layer8 3y ago> obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. I agree, but in the sense that it’s okay for them to violate the rule. However, they are still violating the rule, and thus the correct answer in the game is “yes, this violates the rule”.
- avianlyric 3y agoAn interesting counterpoint to this > Cars/trucks/motorcycles aren't allowed, and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. Is that every year multiple people in the U.S. are killed by police driving their cars onto beaches and running over unsuspecting sun bathers. So there’s a strong argument that the signs intent is to ban even responding emergency vehicles.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- spinach 3y agoBut what is the exact definition of "vehicle"? In the Highway Traffic Act of Ontario "vehicle" is defined as: “vehicle” includes a motor vehicle, trailer, traction engine, farm tractor, road-building machine, bicycle and any vehicle drawn, propelled or driven by any kind of power, including muscular power, but does not include a motorized snow vehicle or a street car; (“véhicule”) https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90h08/v116#BK1 https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90h08/v116#BK1
- bjourne 3y agoBut if the answers were crystal-clear why didn't everyone answer them like you did?
- 0xEF 3y agoOne thing we can be sure of is that if there is a rule, there is someone trying to test its absolute limits (and our tolerance for BS, I suppose).
- scott_s 3y agoI considered the emergency vehicles to be violations of the rule, but that they were defensible exceptions. To borrow a legal concept, that they are emergency vehicles was an affirmative defense, meaning I had to first admit they violated the rule.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jeroen 3y agoContent moderation is hard. Analogies are also hard.
- HWR_14 3y agoThere was no reason to assume either the police car or the ambulance was doing their job. There was no mention of a medical emergency, just an EMT driving an ambulance. Police officers may or may not have jurisdiction in the area and there was no evidence the emergency was even a police matter. The EMT driving through the gate to watch the music festival, and the police officer driving through the park during mid-2020 (when the entire world had declared COVID an emergency) would both qualify. And that doesn't even address the bigger issue that even if they were justified in breaking the rule, they were breaking the rule.
- SamWhited 3y ago> There was no reason to assume either the police car or the ambulance was doing their job. The prompts were: "In an emergency, Neil, an EMT, drives his ambulance into the park" and "In an emergency, Laurie, a police officer, drives her police car into the park."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- scrollaway 3y agoYes indeed. “In a justifiable emergency, X breaks the rules — does this break the rules?” Is a very clear “yes”. It doesn’t ask whether X should be punished for breaking them.
- jagged-chisel 3y ago> … obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. They are indeed violating the rule. Whether that rule is enforced against emergency vehicles is considered by the enforcing agent. I believe most people in that position would allow the emergency vehicles to do their jobs without citing them for violating the rule. But they’re still violating it.
- apricot 3y ago> but the obvious intent of the sign couldn't be clearer There is no sign. Nowhere in the question does it mention a sign. What the question does say, however, is this: "please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (not whether the violation should be allowed)." Which is pretty much the opposite of what you conclude. Interesting.
- mannykannot 3y ago> To me, the answer to all of the questions was crystal-clear. One of the points of the exercise is that there is broad spread (though far from a uniform distribution) of responses, so the fact that the correct answers are clear to you only goes so far. It might be interesting to see how additional statements about intent would affect the distribution (though to the extent that the statements of intent take the form of lists of determinations in each special case, the interesting outcome would be the distribution continuing to be broad.)
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> To me, the answer to all of the questions was crystal-clear You are actually perfect example, everying is crystal clear to me too, and my interpretation violently contradicts your interpretation
- c7DJTLrn 3y agoIt's obvious that the spirit of a rule that says "no vehicles in the park" actually means "do not cause inconvenience or ruin the serenity of the park." A person in a wheelchair, nor an astronaut passing overhead do those things. A guy driving a Toyota around does.
- teekert 3y agoThis is funny because others probably answered differently but feel the same way. So the site is actually achieving what it was created for. Discussion.
- kitd 3y ago> the obvious intent of the sign couldn't be clearer. Cars/trucks/motorcycles aren't allowed, and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. "Obvious" for you that is. I had a different interpretation of the obvious rule, so came up with a different set of answers. QED, no?
- kybernetikos 3y ago> obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. The test explicitly asked for answers as to whether the rule is followed, not whether its ok to ignore the rule in a given situation. Very obviously a police car or an ambulance is a vehicle in the park. > Again, please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (not whether the violation should be allowed).
- NikkiA 3y agoIf emergency vehicles were exempt, the sign would say so, it does not.
- elif 3y agoYour attempt at making it black and white fails. When you say "obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign." Does this mean that if police are code 2 en route to a crime 10 miles away they can use the park to save time? What if they are code 3? Part of doing the job of firefighter includes conducting drills. Can they choose the park as their drill environment? Further, even if they are responding to a crime in the park, are police allowed to drive on the sidewalk because someone has broken the littering ordinance? Even ignoring these grey areas and focusing on your own statement, there is a philosophical dilemma. Are the first responders who "don't have to follow" an inherent part of the rule, or is the rule absolute and they are merely permitted to break it? in either case, by legal or by social convention?
- bosie 3y agojust an FYI (going out on a limb) but nobody knows what this even means "Does this mean that if police are code 2 en route to a crime 10 miles away they can use the park to save time? What if they are code 3?" if you could either explain the lingo or dial it down, that would be great for the rest of us to understand your argument
- elif 3y agoCode 2 means emergency vehicles are responding to an emergency, have their lights and sirens on, and are thus permitted to violate traffic rules. Code 3 means that emergency vehicles are responding to a non-emergency, backup for a scene which is mostly under control, etc. But it is not urgent enough to warrant lights or sirens.
- woooooo 3y agoIn practice, of course, cops will flick their lights on when they want to run a red light instead of waiting. So of course they drive through the park whenever they want.
- trogdor 3y agoThe terms you are using are not universal, and in the United States “Code 3” typically mean lights and siren, and “Code 2” typically means lights but no siren. Best to avoid jargon.
- phkahler 3y ago>> Cars/trucks/motorcycles aren't allowed, and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. Obviously? Really? Not only do I find it non-obvious, the rules of the game specifically say to ignore outside context which would IMO include ignoring municipal laws or rules that might say emergency vehicles can go anywhere they are needed. That is huge part of the issue they are pointing out - an ambulance violates the rule, but context makes it OK.
- jejeyyy77 3y agolol, do you honestly in good faith actually believe the intention of that sign has anything to do with prohibiting vehicles in emergency situations?
- thisisthepoint 3y agoYou're missing the point of the game. It isn't simple.
- agilob 3y ago>(and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. In some countries they can ignore such signs only when under an emergency and rights have been given by a central or a local station. A police car can't just turn on flashy lights and drive into a park.
- seeknotfind 3y agoI interpreted the ambulance and police as breaking the rule, even though it wouldn't be persecuted. Of course the important thing isn't the rule, but people's reaction over time. A vehicle might cause unwanted noise or damage park grounds. Even without the rule, people might get upset if people use vehicles to degrade park quality. On the other end, if the park is many miles across and it has large paved trails, people might perceive the rule as unjust. So it's ultimately this negotiation and power between participants (including the park owners) that determines acceptability. An arbitrary rule which is easy to break but without real harm, in enforcing it, creates more harm than it prevents. So, I don't care about the rule but how it's enforced. Another concept useful to these situations is Taleb's intransigent minority: those who care will win over those who don't. With content moderation, we will always have a battle between those who perceive harm and those who don't. Problematic rules must be fought just as problematic content must be fought. A systems ability to adapt rules over time will ultimately determine its useful life. Change or be replaced.
- mcherm 3y ago> To me, the answer to all of the questions was crystal-clear. That's not particularly surprising. But you may be asking the wrong question. If you want to know whether the rules are clear then I think that the right question to ask is not "Are the answers crystal-clear to you?" but "Will different people produce the same answers?". If we had a sharp drop in the graph at one point then it would suggest that most everyone has the same cutoff; instead we see a very smooth curve as if different people read this VERY SIMPLE AND CLEAR rule and still didn't agree on when it applied.
- toss1 3y agoMy takeaway was similar — the problem is one of how we define "vehicle". Is it anything that moves, anything that carries a person, is it a toy model of a vehicle, etc., etc., etc.. Without that definition, almost anything resembling an edge case becomes an argument. Similarly, without specifying the intent, it becomes impossible to decide the argument, because easily two people can have legitimately different views; e.g., the rule is to prevent anything putting more pressure on the ground than a footfall (so basically anything w/wheels is a problem, including emergency vehicles, but a sled might be is OK), to anything fast-moving and massive (so toys, airplanes, & spacecraft are OK), to some arbitrary rule from a psycho-dictator owner... I.e., if you want people to make sense of the rules, they need to start with a simple clear definition (this does OK in that dept.), specify the extent (what to include and exclude) specify the intent, and maybe provide examples of how to decide edge cases so that others can reason about them.
- tssva 3y ago> obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. Not so obvious. I identified them as having violated the rules. If an exemption was intended for emergency vehicles it should have been included in the sign. Many signs regarding rules for vehicles include "except for emergency vehicles". Without such an exemption I would apply the rules to them.
- NooneAtAll3 3y ago> To me, the answer to all of the questions was crystal-clear. isn't that the exact thing this points attention to? When you have power, everything is clear. But _your_ clear isn't necessarily same as anyone else's clear thus percentages aren't 100%, as shown
- drc500free 3y agoThe website closes with a graph objectively showing how people disagree with each other on these questions. People thinking that interpretation is obvious and that there is no reasonable disagreement is exactly the problem.
- sam0x17 3y agoYou didn't follow the instructions. He specifically says forget all existing rules you may know. There are no vehicles allowed in the park. That includes ambulances, fire trucks, orbiting space stations that pass through the border of the park, etc.
- kelnos 3y agoI think it achieved its purpose. I only got 11% right, because in my mind, the majority of those things were not vehicles.
- wellpast 3y agoBut the ambulance DOES break the rule. Clearly and unambiguously. But breaking rules like this in cases of emergency is the correct thing to do. This is where the moderation difficulty comes in.
- mrighele 3y ago> To me, the answer to all of the questions was crystal-clear. For other people too, but for them maybe the right answer is different. Intent is clear until it is not. Cars obviously aren't allowed. Bicycles are not, either. But can I walk through the park pulling my bicycle ? (I want to cut through the park to avoid a long detour). Some will say that the intent is to avoid have people _driving_ vehicles through the park because it is dangerous, others will say that if that was the intent the rule would be "No driving of vehicles in the park". What about toy cars ? The extreme cases are easy, an hot wheels car is obviously fine. Something like this [1] I would say not, too fast and dangerous. What about the middle ground ? Are tricycles fine ? Toy car with pedals ? A car-like stroller [2] ? It is less clear and you will have different complains from different persons. Some people will be pissed off that they can use their vehicle while other can use their. Some people are petty and will try to have any kind vehicle banned "because the rule says so", just to make the life of others miserable. And this is only about what constitutes a vehicle, we are not even talking about what means "in the park". You can give moderators (law enforcement, in the park example) freedom to act according the intent ("when I see it I know if it is allowed or not"), but the more freedom they have, the more potential for trouble there is. Of course people will be disgruntled also if the rule is too specific and inflexible, because that may mean not being able to do something that it "obviously" was meant to be allowed. You need to find a good balance, and the ability to update the rules for the thorny cases. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZOMXCW7uK4U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZOMXCW7uK4U [2] https://www.walmart.com/ip/3-In-1-Push-Car/40926763 https://www.walmart.com/ip/3-In-1-Push-Car/40926763
- palotasb 3y agoFrom the game's rules: > You might know of some rule in your jurisdiction which overrides local rules, and allows certain classes of vehicles. Please disregard these rules; the park isn't necessarily in your jurisdiction. [...] please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (not whether the violation should be allowed). You: > obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign Even having read your reply it is not obvious to me what you answered. Did you answer yes, the police etc. are violating the rule only adding a note for us tha, or did you answer no, thinking that this doesn't count as a violation? To me the overall discussion, but especially the disagreement about emergency services and bicycles proves the point of the original article.
- adontz 3y ago> obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. Nope, not for me :-) But funny part is that it's so obvious for me, I'm surprised anyone else thinks otherwise.
- uberman 3y agoWhile I agree, I marked the emergency vehicles as being in violation of the rule. My interpretation being that such a rule would not be enforced even though it was technically violated.
- jodrellblank 3y ago> "To me, the answer to all of the questions was crystal-clear." I'd be interested to see more grey-area things like a group of fast amateur bicycle racers, e-bikes, classic pedal-mopeds, electric stand-up scooters, electric sitting moped/scooters, Vespas, ice-cream tricycles, pedal delivery vehicles, I think there would be a lot more differing opinions about those. Pedal-moped: https://www.used.forsale/sh-img/Honda_Hobbit_pedal%2Bmoped.jpg https://www.used.forsale/sh-img/Honda_Hobbit_pedal%2Bmoped.j... UPS pedal trike: https://electrek.co/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2017/11/mobile0c9a66-assets-img-home-ebike_pittsburgh_img_9857a-e1510282405399.jpg?quality=82&strip=all https://electrek.co/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2017/11/mobil... Ice cream trike: https://www.hogroastredditch.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/ice-crean-tricycle-TWO.gif https://www.hogroastredditch.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/... Recumbent trike: https://i1.wp.com/www.recumbenttrikestore.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/2018-ICE-VTX-Demo-at-Recumbent-Trike-Store-Longmont-34-Rear.jpg?fit=4654%2C2522&ssl=1 https://i1.wp.com/www.recumbenttrikestore.com/wp-content/upl...
- hyperhopper 3y agoI mean, all it takes to disprove you here is, what percentage did you get? What percent of people agreed it was that simple in the same way you did. A low percent
- yazzku 3y ago> and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. Obviously? I disagree there and marked those as violating the rule. If we are to take the rule literally and logically, then those examples clearly violate the rule. Nowhere in that game did it say that police, ambulances and fire trucks get a free pass. There isn't anything obvious about that. You're bringing your own context and knowledge/interpretation of the world into this. The game also clearly stated that we should ignore our own local laws (and religion) when answering the questions.
- bena 3y agoI think it does a fair job if you realize that the entire thing is semantics. Every prompt is asking either one or both of these questions: "Is this a vehicle?" "Is it in the park?" So you have to ask yourself what is a vehicle? Most people would not classify shoes as a vehicle. So why would attaching wheels to shoes make them vehicles? The definition of vehicle is rather vague, basically "something used to move people or goods, especially on land". Which skates kind of are. They use a machine, the wheel, to multiply work done. Even though a matchbox car has all the appearances of something normally accepted as a vehicle, does the fact that it is incapable of transporting anything significant change that fact? Then you get to "in the park". What is "in" the park as opposed to "out"? Yes, the grounds as defined by the property lines are definitely "in" the park. Someone driving a Civic through the grounds is definitely "in the park". Basically, do you count the airspace of the park and if so, where does it end? If something hovering 4 feet above the ground is in the park, then why isn't an airplane at 33,000 feet "in" in the park? Is it because we can't reasonably interact with it? If that's the case, do the boundaries of the park change depending on the height and reach of those in it? If no one is in the park, and you jump a Civic completely over the grounds, were you ever "in" the park? Moderation is an attempt to define things like this. Sometimes more abstractly, sometimes way more directly. For instance, if you have a forum about sandwiches, you're going to have to have a rule about hot dogs. Whether or not they count. You see it here all the time when someone asks "Why was this posted here?" So if you have a rule that says "No slurs". That seems simple enough. But now you have to define what a slur is. If I call someone a "fucking idiot", is that slur or just an insult? What if I just said, "Americans, right?" Calling out someone's nationality shouldn't technically be a slur, but it's kind of the implication that turns it into one. Because I'm saying something about people from America, saying they all share a negative quality by virtue of where they are geographically from. Do we just make a list of slurs? Do we try and account for tone? Where is the line between heated debate and a flamewar? Or even an engaged discussion and a heated debate. Even here, you can get rate limited for just interacting too much. Conversations killed because people were conversing too much. But that's how they defined a vehicle, that's where they drew the lines of the park.
- Aeolun 3y agoWhat a bizarre conclusion. I don’t agree at all, which by itself kibd of invalidates your conclusion. “It’s clear to me, therefore it’s clear to everyone.”