26 ms·
Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California
- oblio 3y ago"Slow and steady" better than "move fast and break things"? :-)
- seydor 3y agobreak people
- ajross 3y agoDefine better? A Tesla will do exactly the same thing[1] and just nag you every few minutes to tug on the steering wheel (those nags are getting rarer every release as the driver monitoring camera improves, FWIW). The Mercedes driver can have their hands doing other things, but still needs their eyes out of the cockpit because the second traffic speeds up to 40mph they need to take over. In practice, this is "Level 3", but only within an ephemeral subset of driving conditions that aren't going to be consistent enough for you actually exploit that autonomy. [1] Actually much more, obviously, but it at least does this.
- zaroth 3y agoPeople forget the status quo is millions of deaths and trillions in property and economic damages. Moving slow condemns millions more to die.
- qwytw 3y agoThose millions (especially in developed countries where the per capita number of accidents is highest) won't be able to buy Teslas anyway. Statically you could decrease the number of deaths by 20-30% by just banning cars older than 10 years. There are some other (cheaper) things that can be done as well.
- HDThoreaun 3y ago40k+ people die per year in car accidents in the US alone. I would say "move fast and break less things" is better.
- waffleiron 3y agoWe can get that to 60k!
- oblio 3y agoYou know how you could REALLY fix that? 1. Actual car checks everywhere. I've seen some crazy cars in the US that would be impounded ASAP in most of Europe. 2. Add pedestrian safety requirements for new cars, which would practically ban tall cars (trucks and SUVs) except for professional use. 3. Something for smartphones, not really sure about the best attack angle. This "might not ever happen" self driving shtick is just moving the goalpost into the middle of nowhere.
- pms 3y agoYou're fooling yourself to think that Tesla is the solution. First, most of the fatalities are in cars that cost much much less than Tesla. Their owners will never afford a Tesla. Second, the only realistic way to prevent some of these deaths is to empower public transport, the way it's done in Europe. Third, although that's the least important point, Tesla statistics of miles driven between crashes are biased, because they turn off autopilot before crashes [1]. Please be careful not to conflate the goals of capitalism with the goals of technology and science. [1] PDF https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2022/INOA-EA22002-3184.PDF https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2022/INOA-EA22002-3184.PDF
- HDThoreaun 3y ago> Second, the only realistic way to prevent some of these deaths is to empower public transport I'm the one fooling myself?
- HDThoreaun 3y ago> Second, the only realistic way to prevent some of these deaths is to empower public transport I'm the one fooling myself? That's in no way realistic
- porphyra 3y ago... only when driving under 40 mph on highways. So it is pretty useless. The main thing is that Mercedes Benz will take liability for anything that goes wrong. But the system as a whole is far less capable than Tesla FSD.
- oblio 3y ago> The main thing is that Mercedes Benz will take liability for anything that goes wrong. But the system as a whole is far less capable than Tesla FSD. "It's less capable except for the minor fact that if we <<kill>> someone, it's <<our fault, not yours>>". You know, that minor factor called "life or death". > ... only when driving under 40 mph on highways. So it is pretty useless. If Waymo/Tesla/whatever would do this, they'd be the darlings of the internet. If Mercedes does this, no one thinks: "ah, it's the first iteration, they can you know, <<increase>> the speed later on".
- belter 3y agoAlso known as "draw the rest of the owl"
- sidibe 3y agoAt least they started with an owl shape. Tesla is starting with a square before "draw the rest of the owl"
- oblio 3y agoMercedes has drawn a lot more of the owl than anyone else. Accepting liability is huge. It's putting their money where their mouth is. Musk is putting his mouth on a lot of things, I guess that makes him a baby?
- diebeforei485 3y agoYou aren't going to kill people while going under 40mph on a highway (cars only, no pedestrians) anyway. Under 40mph is like stop and go traffic. This is a marketing stunt. They've taken a well-solved problem (stop and go) and taken responsibility for it, and getting headlines by screaming something about J3016 level 3.
- belter 3y ago"Conditionally automated driving: Mercedes-Benz DRIVE PILOT further expands U.S. availability to the country’s" - https://media.mercedes-benz.com/article/81a29ac5-4d02-4b58-be74-b85368067a95 https://media.mercedes-benz.com/article/81a29ac5-4d02-4b58-b... ”Mercedes-Benz DRIVE PILOT is the world's only SAE Level 3 system with internationally valid type approval. It builds on a very robust foundation, setting new industry standards. DRIVE PILOT uses a highly sophisticated vehicle architecture based on redundancy with a multitude of sensors enabling comfortable and safe conditionally automated driving. The certification by the authorities in California and in Nevada once again confirms that redundancy is the safe and thus the right approach.” "...Mercedes-Benz is focusing on SAE Level 3 conditionally automated driving with the ultimate goal of driving at speeds of up to 80 mph (130 km/h) in its final iteration..." "Mercedes-Benz S-Class DRIVE PILOT Sensors Details" - https://youtu.be/9m-VS55w9HA https://youtu.be/9m-VS55w9HA
- cj 3y ago>"Mercedes-Benz S-Class DRIVE PILOT Sensors Details" - https://youtu.be/9m-VS55w9HA https://youtu.be/9m-VS55w9HA - LiDAR - Radar - Cameras - Ultrasonic sensor - Road moisture sensor Curious how this collection of sensor compares with Tesla and also with run of the mill cars with ACC / lane keeping.
- belter 3y agohttps://youtu.be/BFdWsJs6z4c https://youtu.be/BFdWsJs6z4c
- cj 3y agoI'm aware of Elon's opinion: "LiDAR is lame. LiDAR is lame. Lame. Losers use LiDAR. LiDAR is expensive." I can't stomach watching a video that starts out like that.
- pyinstallwoes 3y agoDo you use LiDAR when you drive?
- dbcurtis 3y agoL3 is profoundly unwise. L3 can disengage at any moment. The attention required of the human in order to drive safely exceeds that required in L2, and is much more difficult to maintain.
- belter 3y agoIt will give a 10 second warning - https://youtu.be/1gjweWq8qAc https://youtu.be/1gjweWq8qAc
- dbcurtis 3y agoI have verrrry limited connectivity RN so can’t watch video. If they really do give 10 seconds, then does the system remain engaged for the “dog/kid darting out between parked cars” scenario? And engage a collision avoidance trajectory planner? 10 seconds is an eternity, even in 35 mph zones. (60 kph)
- Retric 3y agoYes L3 must handle the dog running into the road situation, this Mercedes will even do evasive driving when possible to avoid a collision.
- foepys 3y agoMercedes' system will always give the driver a 10 seconds warning before disengaging. Enough to put away your phone and assess the situation.
- Gasp0de 3y agoHow is that different from L2? SAE Levels 0-2 demand constant supervision and the ability to take over at any moment. Level 3 is actually better, as it only requires you to be able to take over after a short (e.g. 10 second) notice. Levels 4 and 5 do not require the driver to be able to take over (e.g. drunk, sleeping, no license). https://www.sae.org/blog/sae-j3016-update https://www.sae.org/blog/sae-j3016-update
- megaman821 3y agoHeadlines like this really speed up the decline of media. While it is factual it really exploits what a common person would interpret the headline to mean. Tesla is exploring autonomous driving on most roads and conditions. L3 autonomous driving is not binary, you can get it at certain times, in certain places, under certain weather conditions yet the comparison is anchoring it to a system that isn't aiming to operate under those constraints. So the headline is taking a decent accomplishment for Mercedes and turning into catnip for Tesla haters.
- belter 3y agoMercedes achieves Level 3, while putting their money and responsibility, behind what is a life and death scenario. Tesla fans call it "decent". It's worst than a religion..it's a cult.
- megaman821 3y agoAddress nothing about the misleading headline. Call the person that points it out as part of a cult. Maybe you should take a harder look at yourself.
- justapassenger 3y agoMercedes shipped a system that’s legally self driving, under some set of conditions. Tesla sells system that’s not legally self driving under any set of conditions. You’re always driving, and Tesla will fight you in court if you want them to take liability for any action it took. There’s nothing misleading about this headline.
- simondotau 3y agoAll of that is technically correct but isn’t the point the OP was making. These are products with wildly different aspirations and at different stages of achieving those aspirations.
- justapassenger 3y ago
- elif 3y agoLevel 2 FULL self driving is way harder of a problem than location limited, condition limited, maneuver limited, speed limited level 3 so to me it is hilarious to call Tesla beat in any sense of the word. 40mph single lane travel during clear skies and daytime down certain highways can be done by any number of naive driver assistants from many manufacturers. Tesla's autopilot from 2015 could certainly accomplish that, let alone the 2023 FSD versions. The only thing Mercedes has accomplished here is ambitious paperwork.
- justapassenger 3y agoYou really think there’s no engineering difference between system that’s designed to actively kill you, and others if you don’t pay attention vs system that’s designed not to do it, and company putting their money behind that statement?
- elif 3y agoYou really think Mercedes legal filings guarantee a safer system? It is more important to focus on the technical capabilities of the systems than who can add more asterisks to their crash statistics. You are comparing a mature system with billions of miles of testing to a system which you will struggle to keep engaged for 2 mile intervals.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoTesla FSD is not mature, it’s just old
- justapassenger 3y agoOk, let’s focus on the technical aspects. Tesla has no safety life cycle process and as a result FSD is inherently unsafe, from the engineering point of view. You can try to hand wave over that, but if you are an engineer working on the safety critical systems (it’s an actual engineering field), that’s all you need to know about FSD.
- 3y ago
- lvl102 3y agoIt doesn’t take a lot to retro-fit roads with autonomous guardrail markers when we repave. It’s going to take a federal-level effort to accomplish this (which should have been apart of pandemic infrastructure stimulus). I strongly believe this would improve safety for autonomous vehicles by 1000x.
- justapassenger 3y agoDetecting lane is mostly solved problem. Detecting AND predicting what other things will do on the road (not only cars, but people, animals, trash, etc) is not.
- pfannkuchen 3y ago> predicting what other things will do on the road… [like] trash At least we do have a model for this one (physics). I wonder what additional signals the car would need to accurately simulate trash movement? Wind?
- justapassenger 3y agoWind, yes. But even without it - thing get tricky, when you’re traveling at 80mph. You need to detect enough of movements to be able to predict future path. It not easy, even with very advanced sensors. And you cannot “play it safe and assume it’ll collide with us”. You get phantom breaking, which is very dangerous.
- MattRix 3y agoI don’t think you could ever accurately simulate trash movement. Trash is irregularly shaped, even with the highest resolution cameras, it’d be impossible to know what the far side of the trash is shaped like. Then on top of that there’s no way to predict highly localized gusts of wind. The best way to deal with trash is to just have an ML model deal with lots of it so it can make predictions about what it is likely to do (which is basically what Tesla is already doing).
- ikekkdcjkfke 3y ago
- throwaway_ab 3y agoMany people are saying Tesla FSD is far more advanced, and I've seen videos of A Tesla driving around LA for 2 hours completely autonomously so I agree Tesla FSD is the world leader by far and blows what Mercedes has built out of the water. However Mercedes are taking liability whilst their system is in use which implies Tesla takes no liability whilst their system is in use. I'm surprised Tesla is scared to take legal responsibility for their system and I am surprised lawmakers are allowing autonomous systems when the manufacturer doesn't believe in it enough to take responsibility whilst it's in use. How is Tesla getting away with this? Of course they can beat the competition especially if they do not need to take legal responsibility for any deaths/accidents that occur when it's in use.
- notyourwork 3y agoIf I were Tesla why would I take responsibility for something no one is forcing me to take responsibility for? Lawmakers are responsible for this charade and its embarrassing to me that a company can be so misleading with marketing and get away with it.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoBecause it means the feature is actually useful. If the human "driver" is liable for what an autonomous car does, it means you have to watch the car like a hawk. At that point, may as well be driving.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoBoth state and capital can be bad at the same time y’know
- prmoustache 3y agoI wouldn't do any business with you for example if that is your default level of ethics.
- notyourwork 3y agoIt's not about me. This is exactly what Tesla is doing and for some reason no one seems to care and continues to hand Tesla money for subpar quality cars with fake FSD. I don't get it.
- gzer0 3y agoFriendly reminder that this system is HEAVILY limited, with the following restrictions: - Must be under 40 mph - Only during the daylight and only on certain highways - CANNOT be operated on city/country streets - CANNOT be operated in construction zones - CANNOT be during heavy rain or fog or flood roads And for comparison: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjZSZTKYEU4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjZSZTKYEU4 Tesla FSD navigating the complex city streets of LA for 60 minutes with zero human intervention. This seems like a marketing gimmick by Mercedes at best; the two technologies aren't even in the same league. Any comparison is laughable. They are outmatched, outclassed, and absolutely outdone. Karpathy (now @ OpenAI) and the Tesla FSD team have really done an incredible job.
- karaterobot 3y agoSkeptical but genuine question here: if Tesla's Level 3 system is more advanced, why don't they have authorization to release it? And why does the article quote Tesla as saying they only have a level 2 system?
- jeremyjh 3y agoThey aren’t pursuing it, and stopped publicly reporting disengagement data. They found out their stans are happy to buy the cars and use FSD without liability protection or safety data, so why bother? Whenever one crashes it’s the driver’s fault by definition.
- akmarinov 3y agoIn the end, Mercedes assumes liability for its system, where Tesla doesn’t. Tells you all you need to know.
- simondotau 3y agoHow exactly is Mercedes accepting liability? I mean to say, how does this work in practice? Who absorbs the demerit points if your car is accused of going 40 in a 30 zone?
- barbariangrunge 3y agoWe’ve actually had nearly self driving vehicles for over a century. They’re called trains. We should invest in some. The navigation problem gets way easier
- Spivak 3y agoDriverless trains are actually a pretty new thing, being on tracks is not as set/forget as people assume. If you mean "transportation where I'm not driving" then sure but taxis also fit that bill.
- katbyte 3y agoSky train in Vancouver bc has been driverless for near 40 years now
- DanielVZ 3y agoSubway trains have been able to be autonomous since at least a decade.
- masswerk 3y agoParis Metro introduced driverless on all their MP 55 train sets in 1967.
- brooke2k 3y agoProportionally, they are far, far closer to self driving even with multiple people driving the train. A ratio of just 1:100 drivers:passengers is a vast improvement on personal cars which would probably be what, 1:1? Maybe 1:2 on average?
- LelouBil 3y agoParis had it's first fully automated subway line in 1998. Today there are 2 fully automated ones and one other mixing manual and automated. The sofware was developped by Matra transport international (now Siemens Mobility). It can even dynamically add/remove trains in service to best match the demand ! It also apparently uses a 48 bit cpu architecture. [0] https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syst%C3%A8me_d%27automatisation_de_l%27exploitation_des_trains https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syst%C3%A8me_d%27automatisat...
- sidcool 3y agoSeems like a mistaken title. The limitations are so significant, it can't be called autonomous driving.
- renewiltord 3y agoI see. This car is good enough for a morning commute in Bay Area traffic. The question is the disengagement mode. 40 mph on the highway means it only makes sense in traffic, but when the conditions are no longer met how does it decide to hand over control? If it can reliably wake me up or pull over at the off ramp then it's good enough.
- Vecr 3y agoIt can try to wake you up, but you only have 10 seconds. You should probably only use it for reading books/using computers and that sort of thing.
- kbos87 3y agoWhat exactly do people think it means when Mercedes says they will “take liability”? Decisions about whether to prosecute a driver when something bad happens are local and state level decisions. Mercedes can’t protect you when a local prosecutor decides to say “yeah level 3, whatever, you were behind the wheel.”
- jupp0r 3y agoI assume they can only take over civil, not criminal liability.
- arlcode 3y agoAs another user posted at least in Germany the laws were changed to account for this.
- belter 3y agoThat was handled in Germany by changing existing laws. I would imagine equivalent laws were made or are being prepared for California and Nevada. "Germany will be the world leader in autonomous driving" - https://bmdv.bund.de/SharedDocs/EN/Articles/DG/act-on-autonomous-driving.html https://bmdv.bund.de/SharedDocs/EN/Articles/DG/act-on-autono... "...The Autonomous Driving Act took effect in Germany on July 28, 2021, introducing significant and comprehensive amendments to the German Road Traffic Law..." - https://www.ippi.org.il/germany-autonomous-driving-act/ https://www.ippi.org.il/germany-autonomous-driving-act/ Law here (German): https://bmdv.bund.de/SharedDocs/DE/Anlage/Gesetze/Gesetze-19/gesetz-aenderung-strassenverkehrsgesetz-pflichtversicherungsgesetz-autonomes-fahren.pdf?__blob=publicationFile https://bmdv.bund.de/SharedDocs/DE/Anlage/Gesetze/Gesetze-19...
- toast0 3y agoWell, they can provide a rigorous criminal defense, perhaps. But I don't think there's a lot of criminal prosecutions for driving on highways at speeds under 40 mph.
- fnord77 3y agoI have been riding around San Francisco in a Waymo all afternoon with no driver.
- B1FF_PSUVM 3y agoYeah, and seems Cruise is also doing well, but their cars are not for sale.
- as-j 3y agoThe actual title is: > Germans beat Tesla to autonomous L3 driving in the Golden State Which mashed a lot more sense since Waymo, Cruise and Zoox all have L4 autonomous cars on the road today in California operating with no human inside at all.
- ripe 3y ago> Waymo, Cruise and Zoox all have L4 autonomous cars on the road today Wonder why you can’t buy these L4 cars. No Level 4 cars are commercially available in the US. [1] What you are describing are pilot programs propped up with a huge, expensive, unprofitable infrastructure of remote monitoring, support vehicles, and backup drivers. Waymo’s technology might be promising, but today these companies are bleeding money. In contrast, Mercedes is selling retail cars with Level 3 features to consumers and taking responsibility for them. [1] https://www.autopilotreview.com/self-driving-cars-sae-levels/ https://www.autopilotreview.com/self-driving-cars-sae-levels...
- pnw 3y agoI tried to buy the Mercedes EQS with that feature. All the dealers had a $50k markup , you had to wait months for delivery and most of the cool features in their marketing were not available due to parts shortages. So call me skeptical…
- ryanwaggoner 3y agoSkeptical? Because it’s so popular that it’s very hard to get?
- empiricus 3y agopopular would mean at least 100k-1mil. is this mercedes really popular like this?
- hef19898 3y agoTesla's sell at 100k - 1 mil mark up?
- frenchman99 3y agoI think they mean 100k to 1 million units sold
- hef19898 3y agoOkay so 10%, assuming one million unit roughly, of what the likes of Toyota, VW and others build every single year across their models.
- Dylan16807 3y agoWhen it's an "extremely sold out" kind of popular, that can definitely be a reason for skepticism. It's easy to sell out if you barely make any, and when it comes to halo products with significant flaws you want it to be sold out.
- guerby 3y agoI searched and it looks like the Mercedes L3 is available for 7430 EUR on top of 149900 EUR for the base EQS 450+ model (link below, in french). Anyone looked if there's a cheaper way to get this Mercedes L3? https://www.lesnumeriques.com/voiture/drive-pilot-mercedes-commercialise-la-conduite-semi-autonome-de-niveau-3-n182459.html https://www.lesnumeriques.com/voiture/drive-pilot-mercedes-c... https://www.lesnumeriques.com/voiture/essai-mercedes-eqs-450-amg-line-quand-electrique-rime-avec-excellence-et-performance-n172049.html https://www.lesnumeriques.com/voiture/essai-mercedes-eqs-450...
- Havoc 3y agoComments are surprisingly negative - I would have thought hn would celebrate such an advance
- warkdarrior 3y agoOnly Elon is allowed to make advances in the automotive, space, tunneling, and tweeting spaces.
- sebzim4500 3y agoI think with a different headline the comments would have been positive, but this one is misleading at best
- TulliusCicero 3y agoOver the last handful of years, it does seem like HN commenters have become much more negative about tech advances.
- olliej 3y agoDoes Mercedes accept liability for any crashes that occur while its system is in control?
- cryptoegorophy 3y agoAll these comments are a perfect example and a study of confirmation bias.
- sixQuarks 3y agoI love reading the mental gymnastics the anti-Elon folks in here are doing to actually believe Mercedes has beat Tesla in autonomous driving.
- claudiug 3y agobecause is not like that?
- sixQuarks 3y agoAnyone who is knowledgeable about the subject knows it is not. They’re not even in the same league, it’s really laughable.
- FinnKuhn 3y agoThan why is Mercedes able to sell me a system where I can legally watch youtube, etc. while in traffic on a highway without being liable for anything happening and at least 10s until I have to take over control of the car while Tesla can't?
- sixQuarks 3y agoBecause it's a party trick that requires a vehicle in front for tracking and can only be used under 40 mph on the highway. It's a joke. I can do the same thing. Why can Tesla offer FSD beta which can drive around on any roads while Mercedes can't?
- FinnKuhn 3y agoIt is not a party trick. It literally allows you to do anything while stuck in traffic, which is definitely not a rare occurrence. Meanwhile Tesla's FSD beta doesn't allow me anything I can't do with another car, as I still need to pay the same amount of attention and hold the same liability. Mercedes could offer a similar service, but won't as their assistants already offer a similar experience without the dangers of Tesla's FSD.
- pvorb 3y agoBy the way, Mercedes tested a self-driving van in 1986[1]. [1]: https://www.politico.eu/article/delf-driving-car-born-1986-ernst-dickmanns-mercedes/ https://www.politico.eu/article/delf-driving-car-born-1986-e...
- TheAlchemist 3y agoClickbait title to say the least ! While Tesla did amazing things for EVs adoption, and self driving (even if one may say the main contribution is hyping it) it’s hard to see them as leaders anymore. Fact is, Mercedes is taking responsibility for its system while Tesla is not. Tesla claims (and especially it’s fanboys) starts to look like Theranos. Yeah it almost work and it will be a game changer. Yeah well… I’m curious about those Tesla videos that are everywhere - is there some kind of dataset somewhere with videos of similar situations, annotated with which version it is etc, so one can make a kind of historical evaluation of its progress ? (Would also like the history of Elon tweets claiming each version fix this or that to go along in the dataset)
- onethought 3y agoIs there a database of videos of Mercedes? I know “they take liability” but if I’m dead, that still sucks. What has Mercedes ceo commented about it? I think you’ll find Mercedes just don’t publish anything, where as Tesla pretty much develop in the open. Regardless of the sausage, some people just don’t like knowing how it’s made.
- TheAlchemist 3y agoI don't think there are enough users of this Mercedes thing - and even it there were, they are most certainly not the type of people who will post their videos on youtube... Tesla publishes very limited and extremely biased numbers - they don't publish raw numbers allowing anybody to do the work. "Tesla pretty much develop in the open" - that's the issue though - should something like car auto-pilot be allowed to be developed in the open ? My request was not a shot at Tesla, I just think it would be a very interesting to see - say you are able to isolate and filter all situations of some type (say left turn) from all youtube FSD videos - and compare across the different versions in time. I would love that !
- onethought 3y agoAgree, so that’s at least possible because Tesla allow people to share. Literally no other company has anything like that kind of data in the public domain. Except that stupid “collision self reporting” register California keeps for self driving systems.
- jjmorrison 3y agosuch clickbait
- worik 3y agoWhat do we want from self driving cars? Naturally I wand a car I can summon from the pub that will drive me the 20km, over country roads, to my house while I mix cocktails or have a nap. That may never happen, current technology does not seem up to it. Then what? Modern cruise control, that keeps my car a constant distance form the car in front (unless it roars off at a speed higher that what I am comfortable with) is great. Helpful, especially in city driving. I would appreciate "automated rumble strips" that warns me gently if I veer out of my lane. Stopping at a parking spot, push a button, and park my car for me, less useful but still worth it. But unless I have L5, and can turn my back on the road as I drink my vodka drink, (would that be L6? The impossible dream....) I am not interested in anything that lets me take my hands off the when whilst driving on any road. It seems too dangerous. As a computer programmer I make my living building complex machines, and I have a very deep distrust of machines built by my comrades, at Tesla or Mercedes.
- kccqzy 3y agoYou want Waymo then.
- generalizations 3y agoI can easily imagine that multimodal GPT-style LMs running in real-time could do all the common sense thinking that seems to be lacking in modern self driving. That future could be just a 100x optimization away. Edit: multimodal. Does no one remember the vision + language version of GPT4 that microsoft demoed?
- l33t233372 3y agoWhy do you feel this is a language problem?
- serf 3y agoreal-time LMs that can be reasonably allowed to take part in life-or-death situations feels a lot further away (to me) than a 100x optimization.
- weakfish 3y ago
- MangoCoffee 3y agoHN just like every other forum. every time a Tesla/Elon related thread pop up. there are so many emotional bags come with it. you can't even have a fair discussion without someone's blind hate
- spikels 3y agoTroll article commented on by forum trolls
- physhster 3y agoDoes anybody know how it compares with comma.ai? I've been using it for years and seldom use the steering wheel on the highway.
- cavisne 3y agoLimited to 40 miles an hour and only allowed on freeways seem like incompatible constraints...
- spikels 3y agoIt’s a car following system for traffic jams on pre-approved limited access highways. That’s why it also requires other cars nearby.
- vivegi 3y agoSigh. > though the driver must remain behind the wheel to take over when prompted That is a modal interface and the system may also decides to switch modes at will. Anytime a human is expected to wakeup from a mode and takeover from an automated system on short notice, we have failure modes that are unique compared to a modeless system (including Full Human Drive )
- electrondood 3y agoThese articles are idiotic clickbait that try to manufacture some kind of drama by throwing the word Tesla in the title. Tesla is smoking the competition in AVs. Go watch any of WholeMarsBlog's videos on YouTube, of FSD Beta perfectly navigating rush hour San Francisco streets, or driving him from SF to LA without intervention. This is already happening regularly, and has been for months.
- maerF0x0 3y agoI think it's a shame that Cruise https://getcruise.com/ https://getcruise.com/ isn't mentioned thus far. They've been fully autonomous in San Francisco for something like a year, and are piloting in Austin and Phoenix(?) ... No need to own a car if it can be doing dozens of trips instead of paying for parking.
- 0wis 3y agoI see this as a win for everyone. Yes, Mercedes has been faster to get a legal approval but the fact that they got it is a huge win for the industry. Same as the rate of electrification, I think Tesla will not be hurt as they position themselves as enablers. Smart marketing move by the way. And as « there is no such thing as bad publicity », it keeps people talking about the concept of autonomous vehicles. Which seems to work like a charm according to the number of comments I see for this post !
- jaimex2 3y agoUgh, clickbait. Dont bother.
- Gabrys1 3y agoI just came here to say that we already have autonomous "someone-else's" vehicles out there. If you're in a bar and want to go back to your place, you call one if such autonomous vehicles. Or you want to go from home to work without needing to care about parking. They are called taxis.
- ChiperSoft 3y ago> only at speeds of up to 40 miles per hour. > on Interstate 15 These two things are not compatible.
- KETpXDDzR 3y agoOne good use-case this is traffic jams. Bosch developed the "traffic-jam pilot" a few years ago with help of DARPA grand challenge participants. I'm not sure which system Mercedes is using here. Could also be NVIDIA hard- & software (Mercedes and NVIDIA teamed up).
- chrsw 3y agoA useful public transportation system build out in a America is more ambitions than fully autonomous driving. Human-less driving is more of a technical problem than can probably be overcome with research, 10s or 100s of billions worth of development and municipal cooperation on autonomous driving infrastructure. Public transport is a cultural problem as well as a technical problem. I live in a city with decent public transportation system options. I use it frequently and I'm grateful for it. But as soon as I go even a few miles outside the city, the public transportation options are slim to non-existent. I wouldn't even pretend for a second it's a practical option. You better have a car.