18 ms·
Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread protests
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dataengineer56 3y agoI've seen the suggestion "why not let Reddit Premium subscribers access Reddit through third party apps" which seems like a fair compromise - Reddit gets cash in exchange for not being able to serve ads at that particular user.
- teeray 3y agoBecause some MBAs always want to double-dip: collect the premium fee and serve ads at that user.
- mschuster91 3y agoMake it a triple dip. Third party apps don't provide any analytics back to Reddit which is what Reddit really wants - they're A/B experimenting all the goddamn time and to be honest it's annoying that stuff always shifts around or gets shipped in a half broken state. Also, clearly defined APIs take a lot of flexibility away from them, which is yet another thing that beancounters don't want.
- Terretta 3y agoThird party apps are just a client. My web browser doesn't provide them analytics back either, nor do I see their ads. I dislike Reddit's narrative -- the Apollo dev himself is visibly gaslit by this one -- that the apps are "generating" API calls. Nonsense. Users generate API calls over client(s) of choice. As soon as you understand that, you can apply first principles to the rest.
- DownGoat 3y agoThe users that pay for premium is probably also the most profitable ad viewers
- jedberg 3y agoPremium users get the option to turn ads off. It's one of the main features of premium.
- mrtksn 3y agoThat's very reasonable actually. Pay for the product or be the product, whatever suits you. I'm curious how the laud power users would react to this though. I suspect they won't like it because it's not the same as using the product on VCs dime. The good old internet that we all love and adore was built on VC money or creative people's content. Unfortunately, the VCs are not into philanthropy but in money making and the creative people need to be compensated too, so this can't last. I really really hope that we can leave this behind and have good quality paid platforms as standart. Paying through extra steps(advertisement) or paying through political power transfer(free curated content with agenda) is bad for the society.
- adrianN 3y agoMost of the content on the good old Internet is made by people who don’t expect any money for it. This comment for example.
- mrtksn 3y agoThat's true but it wasn't a static situation. As it evolved, new cool things came because VCs poured money in it. With Web 1.0 people were sponsored by their parents or institutions and they created the early tools and content. They were not personally looking to profit from it. However early VCs were pouring money into infrastructure or bets, so the thing was getting professional and serious, so can evolve. The most demanded content was content created prior-web, and that content was shared freely(the mp3 and divx era) on platforms created by people who were looking for clout and not necessarily monetary compensation. With Web 2.0 the content was created by people for free but the platforms were completely VC paid. In this stage everything become professional and as it matured we ended up in this horrible state. Arguably, HN is a reminiscent of the early stages of Web 2.0 and the place has good quality because it's paid by VC who expect to have reach(to the talent and market). IMHO HN is possible because it's not optimised to it's full monetary potential.
- rightbyte 3y agoHN could easily be run as a classic forum. The VC money just makes it possible to have one (?) FTE which makes it alot simpler to not mess up concessions when admins get tired. But ye it is suprising that Ycomb don't want to mess it up. Someone somewhere has good judgement against short term profits for long term?
- politelemon 3y agoIt isn't about ads exclusively, that's a common misunderstanding though. A lot of issues are down to moderation tools as well as accessibility.
- blantonl 3y agoThis is the exact model that I use on RadioReference.com. We have an API that exposes our entire radio database to end users, but they must be premium subscribers to access the data through the API. This spurred the development of tons of radio programming and other apps in the ecosystem. It's literally a win-win for all of us. It's easy to detect "abuse" or "commercial use" and we contact those users and license them accordingly for such use cases. We also went one step further and completely eliminated advertising on RadioReference.com. Given the user base is very niche and highly technical, the goodwill alone we got from that move gave us a sizable increase in premium subscription revenue. Plus, the quality, of Internet advertising has become so poor it's barely worth opening the space up to advertisers.
- goda90 3y agoTaking something free and putting it behind a paywall of any size is going to anger users.
- olivierestsage 3y agoI've often wished for this (a system where some users pay to circumvent tracking/ads, others get the "general experience"). One theory I've heard as to why companies don't go for this idea is that the paying users are the ones that that are valuable to advertisers, because they are actually willing to pay money, vs. the free users who would be endlessly mined for little gain.
- devsda 3y agoYou can create a reddit account without giving out email but when payments come into picture you are not anonymous anymore.This will limit anonymous or throwaway accounts to official apps which again have tons of tracking. I hope they also figure out a way to use apps while preserving the anonymity like revenue sharing or ads etc.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- srvmshr 3y agoI moderate a reasonably sized community (50k - 100k users). Without using an external app like Sync or Apollo, it is insanely hard. Their own app is so clunky: sometimes it just fails to load posts or the feed. At times the video doesn't load - instead showing a screengrab. The worst offender is that sometimes the UI shows moderator controls for even some communities one doesn't moderate (This is a known bug going on for several months in the official Reddit app and the admins/devs acknowledge it). You have to go about closing the app and clearing the cache. For e.g., here's a screenshot, which shows a warplane subreddit that I don't manage (having mod controls): https://imgur.io/a/4yOY4Vo https://imgur.io/a/4yOY4Vo Keeping third party apps open for Premium users is one way out. Another alternative would be to keep API costs low enough that developers can reasonably pass that cost to subscription users. But the current state would just lead to massive disruption. They will end up killing the golden goose.
- commandlinefan 3y agoHonestly, hearing that killing off third party apps will make moderators have to work harder to do the damage that they do to reddit is the first positive thing I've heard about this API change.
- PrimeMcFly 3y ago> I moderate a reasonably sized community (50k - 100k users). Without using an external app like Sync or Apollo, it is insanely hard. Very doable on desktop with RES though, which so far isn't going to be affected by the API pricing changes.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoI think a major problem is the conclusion that moderators are hobbled at moderating unless they use a laptop/desktop.
- nicce 3y agoIt is just a matter of time when they choose to close old.reddit.com which also ends RES
- jwie 3y agoThere will always be tension with an interface for a freemium product since it’s bad on purpose. The Apollo interface is better for the consumer, but worse for Reddit. Their interests are not aligned. Even if Reddit were to purchase Apollo they’d never reskin Reddit since the UX does what it needs to do.
- quikoa 3y agoMy prediction: Reddit just pushes these changes through maybe with a non-apology.
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoI hope you’re right, and that this is reddit’s Digg moment. Looking forward to whatever the next big thing is.
- dageshi 3y agoReddit existed and was frankly already winning the race with Digg before the Digg redesign, the "Digg moment" was just the cherry on top really. There's no obvious alternative to reddit.
- dontlaugh 3y agoSeveral banned/quarantined communities retreated to semi-private Discord servers.
- duped 3y agoWhich is a good thing for reddit, toxic communities posting toxic garbage that drifts into /r/all isn't good for users or revenue.
- dontlaugh 3y agoA minority of the banned communities fit that description, though. Regardless, I’m pointing out what is the current alternative.
- duped 3y agoScanning over lists of banned communities, I wouldn't say it's a minority. It seems like that they're pretty predominantly awful groups of people posting awful things.
- karmakurtisaani 3y agoInspired by this whole upfuckery by Reddit, I checked out a lemmy instance sopuli.xyz. It looks quite good actually, and I'm interested in starting to contribute to the discussion there rather than staying in Reddit. For more instances check out https://join-lemmy.org/instances https://join-lemmy.org/instances.
- pookah 3y ago[dead]
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoI want to be interested in things like Lemmy, Mastodon, etc, but they seem to have the same issue (or non-issue) as traditional forums; there's many of them, and finding the ones you want takes extra headspace and effort. Reddit (and its predecessors, and other social media) became popular because it's an all-in-one. You can just browse /all or comments sections and passively discover new communities to follow, instead of having to trawl the internet and actively vet everything. It being centralized also means it's centrally vetted; who knows what kind of shit there's to be found on various lemmy or mastodon instances. It sounds off, but I'd rather go to a platform with a large company behind it than something ran from someone's proverbial basement.
- karmakurtisaani 3y agoUntil yesterday I had very similar thoughts. Now after checking it out I actually like it this way. The fact that there's less posters means you can post something you like, and it won't be downvoted just because it's competition or it rubs the hivemind the wrong way. I can't say if this becomes my new go-to forum, but for the moment there is excitement there that I haven't felt about anything online for a long time. Oh, and there definitely are some insane places there. Check out lemmygrad if you want to make your head spin.
- tester457 3y ago> Check out lemmygrad if you want to make your head spin. You weren't kidding. > we would like you to know before you request an account that Lemmygrad is a Marxist instance, principally Marxist-Leninist. We like Stalin and we uphold the DPRK’s sovereignty and legitimacy over the whole of Korea. We love China’s Socialism with Chinese Characteristics.
- AlexandrB 3y agoIt's interesting to watch Reddit lose control of the narrative on this. If you read the relevant threads Reddit admins swear up and down that the new API pricing is reasonable and not intended to kill third party apps. Whatever their intent, it's definitely a failure on the PR front.
- guidedlight 3y agoThe timing is interesting. I’m convinced their API’s are either being abused, or will be imminently abused by LLM training. I wonder how much third party apps are being caught up in this other issue.
- skeyo 3y agoMy initial thought on the timing is how much it coincides with the timing of Twitter's API becoming ridiculously expensive ($42k/mo). That maybe Reddit thought they could hop on that bandwagon and make some coin. But LLM also makes a ton of sense.
- nicce 3y agoLLM does not make much sense anymore to be fair. Too late. They should have closed the APIs years ago. Biggest parties have already mined the data, which is enough for models for long time. Unless you want the model to find some specific comment yesterday.
- d11z 3y agoIt makes sense to me, but for LLM spam bots, not training. I’m assuming it’ll only increase as time passes.
- CTDOCodebases 3y agoReddit is good for product recommendations and in that regards recency matters e.g ask ChatGPT what ODE you should get for a Sega Saturn. By allowing LLMs low cost or free access to their users data companies like Reddit are essentially helping companies like OpenAI choke their traffic. Over time as people realise it’s quicker to ask ChatGPT a question than it is to post a question on reddit they will start losing content also. Also think about the difficulty of policing content generated by swarms of LLM bots with API access for PR campaigns.
- pookah 3y agoWhy do people think they need these big centralized authoritarian "communities" on the internet? In the late 90's and early 2000's we ran PHP forums from our parents houses.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoI'll have you know I still run a PHP forum but from my own house, lol. Unfortunately most activity seems to have moved to Discord.
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoDiscord isn’t great for slower paced and long form discussion so I never was able to really catch on to using it.
- code_duck 3y agoI've seen various forums move to Discord. It doesn't make much sense to me as Discord is essentially IRC and is not the same format as a forum at all.
- delecti 3y agoSay I spend time on r/digg, then I find out about r/hackernews. I can start browsing there without creating a new account immediately. That lack of friction between communities is probably Reddit's biggest strength. I can't even imagine how many PHP forums have leaked my email address over the decades.
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoThis doesn’t seem like that big a deal, you can still have shared logins (Google etc)
- delecti 3y agoThen you have the problem of "wait, which site did I sign up for this random forum for, google, facebook, or twitter?" and still keeps the problem of needing to establish the account, things like a profile picture, signature, email preferences, learning that forum's etiquette, the forum's organization (where's "general"?), and then only after a non-trivial investment might you find out that the mods are actually dicks so it's not worth the effort. On reddit, I can click the "random" button and immediately discover a community that I can already post in. Do I want to talk on r/entrepreneur, or r/galaxytab (the actual two first subreddits that "random" took me to just now)? I can do that right now, and while there I also see the orangered envelope telling me I got replies to comments I made on r/zelda (also a true story of what happened when I just clicked "random").
- maeln 3y agoReddit is closing on its IPO and is seemingly desperate to generate "growth" by bumping every possible metrics possible virtually. Aside from this move that is an obvious way to steer user toward the official app and have tighter control, the r/de and r/France community have find some really concerning behavior by Reddit [1]. Moderator from those community have been contacted by reddit admin to tell them that they created localized version of popular subreddit ( r/offmychest, r/tooafraidtoask, ... ) and asked them if they basically could signal boost them. In itself nothing is wrong here. The issue is that people have found that a lot of activity in those subreddit are seemingly just poorly google translated popular post from the original english sub or just plainly generic classique karma bait post (but also clearly google translated). Karma bots are nothing new but in this case, those subs are brand new, have very few member and very few karma to gain and are basically of interest only to reddit (since the communities already usually had their own better moderated subs). So there is a lot of finger pointing at reddit themselves using bots to try to force engagement in non-english community and virtually (since it is mostly bots) bump their stats before their IPO, which is very dodgy. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/france/comments/14199iu/reddit_sautoastrosurfe_encore_dans_les/ https://www.reddit.com/r/france/comments/14199iu/reddit_saut...
- itsoktocry 3y ago>Reddit is closing on its IPO and is seemingly desperate to generate "growth" by bumping every possible metrics possible virtually. If by "growth" and "metrics" you mean they have to figure out how to make money to sell themselves to investors in an almost-hostile financial environment, then yes, I agree. Beginning of the end and all that. You can't sell "community". IPO means ads, ads, ads and dodgy strategies like you describe above.
- batmenace 3y agoIPO doesn't have to mean ads, though. There are other ways to monetize a user base and to generate money based off of a 'community'. They're just ways that require more time, more concerted effort and planning to execute.
- Euphorbium 3y agoLargest 3rd party apps need to cooperate and build their own backend. They have a perfect frontend, and the users. It could be a seamless transition.
- goda90 3y agoOr they could cooperate to make an open scraping engine to replace the APIs. A large enough group of volunteer devs could have a short turnaround from when Reddit messes up the front end to having the scraper working again.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoThere's a few projects underway to do just that; I've seen Lemmy [0] being mentioned a lot. [0] https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy
- godshatter 3y agoI'm wondering if communities like Lemmy will be any more open to other ways of thinking than reddit is. My politics align fairly well with the reddit political stances, but when it doesn't line up exactly it's like I'm a far-right actual nazi or something. I'm hoping other communities will be more open to people actually thinking somewhat differently from themselves. I'm not holding my breath, though. I'm going to give Lemmy a shot and keep my head down and see how it works out. Realistically, I won't be leaving reddit until old.reddit.com goes away or my ad-blocker stops working.
- DoktorDelta 3y agoBecause Lemmy is a federated service, you can run your own instance to cater to your specific political alignment. However, other instances can choose to block content from your instance from showing up on theirs. Likewise, you can ask to 'link' your instance to others with similar ideas/rules and share posts between both. As a result, the only thing stopping someone with particularly niche political views from spinning up their own instance is the potential lack of other interested users.
- jokoon 3y agoWell reddit was still able to run without money for quite a while, I wonder how it was possible, and why they wanted an IPO. Anyway they improved the new reddit, it seems? It looks like they fixed some things and it's not as bad as it was 1 or 2 years ago. Anyway the reddit model seemed quite good enough, I don't doubt that anybody could really make an alternative clone and gain users. Mastodon is also expected to slowly get more and more users as twitter seems quite threatened.
- mda 3y agoThe reddit web on mobile is a sad experience, before it was possible to shut its continuously asking about installing the app but they removed the option. Now it always asks to use the app when I navigate to reddit. And no, I don't want to use any app to read it.
- activiation 3y agoIt doesn't ask me but I use https://old.reddit.com https://old.reddit.com with an ad blocker (not sure which one stops it)
- tetrep 3y agoWhile there is much talk of protest, nobody in a position of power (like those organizing protests in various subreddits) seems to be offering a diaspora option. The protests are extremely time boxed too, so if I were Reddit, it seems like a fair trade. Very short term harm followed by getting exactly what they want. I don't see why the protests would have any meaningful impact on Reddit policy. Look at how pointless Occupy Wall Street was, and now imagine they started out by saying they'd only camp there for a weekend.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoSome of the communities have announced they will remain dark until Reddit reverses their decision, so it will vary by community. But this is, I think, where money comes into place; I fully expect some of the 'volunteers' for some of the more popular communities have found a way to make money off of it. I mean, they run communities with millions of views a day, surely there's money to be made out of that even if you don't work for reddit?
- CamelCaseName 3y agoYou'd really think so eh? Unfortunately no one wants to pay mods.
- pjc50 3y ago> they run communities with millions of views a day, surely there's money to be made out of that This kills the community. Or rather, it sets up the possibility of the same thing happening over again on a micro scale: the users (who contribute to the community without being paid) in revolution against the mods.
- mjr00 3y ago> Some of the communities have announced they will remain dark until Reddit reverses their decision, so it will vary by community. If the sub is popular enough Reddit will take it over and appoint new mods. Has happened before and will happen to some of the subs that choose to go dark as well. > But this is, I think, where money comes into place; I fully expect some of the 'volunteers' for some of the more popular communities have found a way to make money off of it. Definitely. Every (lead) moderator of a decently popular community is getting kickbacks one way or another. They do it for "free", but the only ones doing it without some compensation are absolute suckers.
- nfriedly 3y agoI wonder if this will lead to the ReVanced patches for the official Reddit app getting better? (ReVanced is the evolution of YouTube Vanced a modified YouTube app. But since they made it a generic patcher, it can now improve Reddit and other apps.) There's a patch to remove ads, and a couple of other minor things[1], but not much. I requested a feature to automatically minimize the Automod comments that are stickied to the top of every thread in many subreddits, and the request was closed with the reasoning that I could do that manually. That's true, but somewhat beside the point. [1]: https://revanced.app/patches?s=reddit https://revanced.app/patches?s=reddit
- carnewal 3y agoFollowing the revanced link ... > This page received a cease and desist letter from a multi-billion dollar tech company. I guess you have your answer.
- nfriedly 3y agoDamn, that was fast. Edit: nevermind, their website is just broken, and that's the default 404 page. I changed the original link to a working one and filed an issue at https://github.com/revanced/revanced-website/issues/106 https://github.com/revanced/revanced-website/issues/106
- quaffapint 3y agoI'm surprised more people aren't talking about the tracking in the official app vs third party apps. I was noticing a LOT of tracker dns queries in my pi-hole. It wasn't an obvious name (like having reddit in it). Speaking to a co-worker they happened to notice the same thing. Searching online allowed me to track it down to the official reddit app. I uninstalled it from my android phone and installed the Infinity app instead and I could still access reddit just fine and no more tracker queries. I will not be installing the official app if Infinity goes away.
- ddellacosta 3y agoYeah, this is what gets me--and at least on IOS you can get a sense of this simply at looking at the difference in what data the app requests access to compared to e.g. Apollo.
- bigthymer 3y ago> I'm surprised more people aren't talking about the tracking in the official app vs third party apps I don't think many engineers use the official app.
- colordrops 3y agoIf Infinity no longer works I'm done with Reddit.
- jkubicek 3y agoDo you know what those tracking queries were tracking or who they were talking to? I use Apollo, and Reddit already knows everything I subscribe to and read, what more would they get from forcing me to use the official app?
- djhworld 3y agoI've been using old.reddit.com for years, nice and snappy (enough) website and easy to navigate. Similarly I use Baconreader on my phone which is also pretty great. I've never seen a compelling reason to use "new" reddit or the official reddit app. If they want to kill third party apps then they need to make their own offering much better, which I highly doubt will ever happen.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- metalliqaz 3y agoSame (except I use RIF) I'll go a bit further and say that new.reddit is actively hostile to the user experience and is worse than old.reddit in nearly every way. It gets less content on the page and what's there is harder to navigate.
- Capricorn2481 3y agoI hate that it seems every community seems to start on Discord nowadays. That being said, is this not just a huge gift for Discord to eat Reddit up? A huge portion of Reddit users are millenial gamers and likely have Discord installed already. Speaking for myself, I have found it increasingly difficult to get questions answered or find useful discussion on Reddit. For seeking information on a niche topic, you can get much more helpful information in a Discord community dedicated to that topic than posting on Reddit and hoping your post is seen. For anything related to gaming/TTRPG communities, Discord is way better.
- dingledork69 3y agoDiscord really should invest in making their "posts" feature web-searchable if the server opts in.
- 29083011397778 3y agoWhy would Discord want to do that? I get why we, as people, want that; I do not get why Discord, as a company, would want their platform less sticky. "You have to have an account we can track before we let you get an answer" is all but a literal goal for them.
- dymk 3y agoBecause you don’t even know the discord server exists. So how is what they’re currently doing attracting the users searching for communities and answers?
- andersrs 3y agoYes we do because 1) this forces the discord server owners to promote their servers on the web. 2) You're more likely to bypass Google all together and just search for open communities on discords catalog. Google is dead now thanks to SEO anyway.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lvl102 3y agoAnyone else notice Apple’s mention of Apollo yesterday? It probably helps that Apollo is built by former Apple guys but it gave me a good chuckle.
- sgt 3y agoNoticed that. Good ol' Craig Federighi. Also didn't know he is really good on the guitar.
- boppo1 3y agoYeah I thought that was an interestingly pointed mention. Idk why they'd mention it though.
- daveidol 3y agoIt was probably recorded far before this controversy started
- Brendinooo 3y agoI noticed. Was wondering if it was recorded before the controversy began or if it was shoehorned in there to give 'em some support.
- sputter_token 3y agoThe app icon has been shown in WWDC presentations before but I think this was the first time it was mentioned by name. They do record these before (weeks?) the event but they could have cut it out if they did not want it there.
- anonred 3y agoChristian interned for a summer at Apple. I don’t understand why he pushes this narrative given that Apollo is good enough to stand on its own without shady marketing tactics.
- guraf 3y ago
- cyclecount 3y agoInteresting to see Apollo mentioned in Apple's WWDC Keynote yesterday.
- Randomizer42 3y ago[flagged]
- dom96 3y agoCan Reddit really stop alternative APIs (which are free, or near-free) from taking hold when they impose pricing on their API? I created one such API[1] and hope that at the very least it puts pressure on Reddit to reconsider their pricing strategy. If not it should enable third party apps to save a majority of their cost. 1 - https://api.reddiw.com https://api.reddiw.com
- quadral 3y agoVisiting your link on Microsoft Edge triggers the phishing warning: You might have misspelt reddit.com Microsoft Edge recommends that you double-check the spelling of the site you're trying to access. Misspelt sites – with similar spellings to popular ones – are known to redirect users to sites that steal and scam your personal information. Should probably change your domain.
- dom96 3y agoI doubt developers will have a problem understanding these warnings.
- dingledork69 3y agoMeanwhile reddit is allowing their advertisers to break site-wide rules by doxxing users: https://www.reddit.com/r/tifu/comments/141zt84/tifu_by_complaining_about_a_lyft_incident_and/ https://www.reddit.com/r/tifu/comments/141zt84/tifu_by_compl...
- nubinetwork 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36179853 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36179853 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36187705 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36187705 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36196343 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36196343 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36198487 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36198487 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36202277 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36202277
- 58x14 3y agoI think it's very clear that the recent LLM boom is directly responsible for Twitter, Reddit, and others quickly moving to restricted APIs with exorbitant pricing structures. I don't think these orgs really care much about third-party clients other than a nuisance consuming some fraction of their userbase. Enterprise deals between these user generated content platforms and LLM platforms may well involve many billions of API requests, and the pricing is likely an order of magnitude less expensive per call due to the volume. The result is a cost-per-call that is cost-prohibitive at smaller scales, and undoubtedly the UGC platform operators are aware that they're pricing out third-party applications like Apollo and Pushshift. These operators need high baseline pricing so they can discount in negotiation with LLM clients. Or, perhaps, it's the opposite: for instance, Reddit could be developing its own first-party language model, and any other model with access to semi-realtime data is a potentially existential competitor. The best strategic route is to make it economically infeasible for some hypothetical competitor to arise, while still generating revenue from clients willing to pay these much higher rates. Ultimately, this seems to be playing out as the endgame of the open internet v. corporate consolidation, and while it's unclear who's winning, I think it's pretty obvious that most of us are losing. (my comment on this topic from another thread)
- Workaccount2 3y agoI can see reddit resolving this by giving certain apps heavily discounted API access. Right now at least all the backlash is coming from 3rd party app users, while ML guys are sitting quietly in the back with their fingers crossed.
- nameless912 3y agoDoesn't this give reddit an easy way to censor specific apps? It would be better to have a batch API and an "app access" API that rate limits based on user accounts rather than based on API keys. I could see having tiered costs for different usage patterns, but it's hard to design correctly.
- fluoridation 3y agoIf that was the case, it would just be a matter of properly segmenting the users into the right price brackets. When I looked into Twitter's pricing I could either pay $100/month for fewer tweets than I can get using the free API, or $42000/month (hilarious number by the way, Elon).
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoWhat really sucks about these sites is that they become great open hubs of information and then they start erecting barriers.
- timmytokyo 3y agoYeah, it's called "enshittification" [1]. [1] https://www.wired.com/story/tiktok-platforms-cory-doctorow/ https://www.wired.com/story/tiktok-platforms-cory-doctorow/
- seydor 3y agoOut of the things that reddit has done before, this is the least objectionable one i can think of. They were actually late to increase the cost of scraping their content. Google has made billions out of them.
- Semaphor 3y agoThe developer of Reddit Sync (Android app) sounds like he’s ready to throw in the towel [0]: > Right now I have no idea if I should continue to work on Sync but as a subscription only app or throw in the towel > A subscription + incomplete experience (NSFW etc) to me just doesn't sound like a good deal for you guys [0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/redditsync/comments/142dzy8/the_future_of_sync/ https://www.reddit.com/r/redditsync/comments/142dzy8/the_fut...
- asciimov 3y agoYou wanna know the secret to significantly raising API rates without complaints? You raise rates to a ridiculous number, drag out negotiations with devs and let them drop the news to their users, wait a bit for the revolts and news stories to happen, then make a press release saying "our bad, we love you guys so much, we 'found' a way to get our API prices down". After all of that, API prices are still higher than reasonable, but all the users and devs are all happy and news stories go out saying how the users and devs won and got a better deal. All while you got the price increases that you wanted.
- say_it_as_it_is 3y agoanchoring is not a secret
- Freedom2 3y agoAnchoring can also be used in other applications than just raising API costs - GP should revisit how they unequivocally declare their statements.
- Brendinooo 3y agoHonestly, I'd take this, because I think the far more likely scenario is that they just ignore all of this brouhaha and aren't seriously impacted as a result.
- DamnInteresting 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Door-in-the-face_technique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Door-in-the-face_technique
- shostack 3y agoAnd Reddit has done similar things before. This is cost of business to them.
- dataviz1000 3y agoTo recreate Reddit, only the backend is needed since there are several apps that function as the front end. All the backend problems for a site like Reddit are known and have been solved. Today, it is a nothing burger to create a backend API for Reddit Blue and other third party apps. Imagine creating a backend for Reddit Blue and then asking all its users to switch backends. It is possible to have a toggle button in the settings to switch between the two.
- heliodor 3y agohttps://github.com/reddit-archive/reddit https://github.com/reddit-archive/reddit
- chaosphere2112 3y agoI just killed Reddit off my home screen after a decade of usage because of a totally different bullshit growth hacking thing - they have started injecting their “recommended” subreddits into my swipe stream. I have thumbs downed every single recommendation they’ve ever put in my scrolling feed, and now am being forced to consume absolutely random subreddits that their models have decided I’m super interested in because at some point in the last ten years I clicked through an r/bestof link. Sigh. Now I need to actually figure out Mastodon.
- timbit42 3y agoStart here: https://mastodon.help/ https://mastodon.help/ The key to Mastodon isn't to follow other people but to follow hashtags so they are in your news feed, and to use hashtags everywhere in your posts and comments so other people can find them.
- spiantino 3y agoIf you click the three dots on a recommendation you can select "show less like this" and you won't see recommendations from that subreddit. Also, there is a setting in user settings to prevent recommendations from subs you don't subscribe to from appearing at all, but I would give the algorithm a chance since there are interesting subs you probably aren't aware of. Also, I wouldn't call making recommendations in home feed a growth hack, fwiw.
- flanbiscuit 3y agoDidn't Twitter do this back in like 2012? I remember there being a lot of anger about it back then. I don't think it was as crippling as the most recent Twitter API changes (where Reddit seems to be taking inspiration from). > And in 2012, Twitter introduced stricter usage limits for its API, "completely crippling" some developers. While these moves successfully increased the stability and security of the service, they were broadly perceived as hostile to developers, causing them to lose trust in the platform. src: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter#API_and_developer_platform https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter#API_and_developer_plat... Some discussions on HN about it back then: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1356825600&dateRange=custom&dateStart=1325376000&page=0&prefix=false&query=twitter%20api&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1356825600&dateRange=custom&... I've been worried Reddit was going to head down this path since Twitter did that in 2012. I feel like old.reddit.com is next and that'll really seal the deal for me.
- TheFattestNinja 3y agoSeconding that. The moment the old ux is not available anymore is the moment I stop using it. There was enough pushback at the redesign in the first place that they were forced to make it default on demand in your profile. I hope people at reddit read this and heed the prophecy.
- yung_steezy 3y agoDoes anyone know if teddit uses the reddit API? I believe it is inspired by nitter which is a twitter reader which circumvents the twitter API.
- BonoboIO 3y agoThe problem with previous competitors of Reddit was, that they were created by people that were not wanted on Reddit. Toxic people, trump and fake news subs, hate subs and more. Apps like Apollo and other have a good opportunity to change that. They have a „normal“ userbase that could easily converted to new user on a new platform with a simple popup on app startup.
- moomoo11 3y agoReddit should be free to implement whatever policy it wants to do as long as it is legal. If people can make full fledged client apps that rake in millions of dollars that need corporate structures around it, they can certainly take that pull and build communities that offer Reddit like experience (I mean, you have the UI built already right?) without the Reddit like bullshit. So what if reddit decides its data is valuable to itself and it doesn't want to share it on your terms? Maybe you can capitalize on your position as it is right now and strategize your way around it.
- moojd 3y ago> Reddit should be free to implement whatever policy it wants to do as long as it is legal Yeah but that isn't the argument. Just because someone has the right to do something doesn't mean you can't criticize it or, in your own words, capitalize on your position as it is right now to hopefully persuade a change of direction. I don't have a dog in this fight but I dislike when the legality of something is used to dismiss criticism.
- moomoo11 3y agoCriticize it, sure. But when you have millions of people potentially riled up, the cards are in your hand. Or at least, you have a decent hand. Nobody really "likes" reddit. They tolerate it. I don't care about reddit the corporation. I like the user generated content there. Since reddit sucks and does things like gatekeep people from viewing their site without mobile app, and other annoying things like that, these app developers should just try to turn those users onto a new reddit-like platform. I would love to see reddit shaken up from its position as a place for people to have discussions on topics where the comments can be on a wide spectrum. It used to be fun, and it can be again. But it needs a Napoleon.
- George83728 3y ago"He cleared the subreddits with a whiff of grapeshot."
- tomjen3 3y ago
- grounder 3y agoHave third-party apps like Apollo, etc. been using Reddit's API for free for all of these years? They've been building businesses and making money on the back of Reddit for free?
- charonn0 3y agoOr, reddit has been getting free mobile app development for all these years.
- Forgeties79 3y agoI'm sure we have our fair share of reddit mods here on HN, so apologies for rehashing what I'm sure plenty already know. But I've been chatting a lot with other mods on discord as we get this effort organized, and the general consensus is "reddit has definitely been very generous with their API up to this point and it's totally reasonable of them to charge now, but the price is wildly out of line with everyone else." I say this because the reddit admins keeps trying to hyper focus on things like "Apollo is inefficient" (it is) or "bots will still work" and other secondary concerns in an effort to avoid the very simple issue: their cost is exhorbitant and no amount of vague "we will adjust based on usage" and "non-commercial tools will be fine" comments are going to assuage our fears. A quick story: a mod from /r/blind told us all about how heavily they depend on 3rd party tools just to be able to do basic moderation. Despite reddit having an app for seven years they still do not even remotely adequately cover the needs of the visually impaired/blind/etc. The mod said several members who are completely VI will have to step down under the new changes because the app is unusable for them in its current state. Why should they trust reddit will suddenly fix it if they've largely ignored their tickets for 7 years? Why should any of us believe any of their vague promises when this has occurred over and over again? Mods/users get angry, reddit says "we hear you," and everyone calms down. They're panicking at this point because frankly they know we're too cynical/skeptical for their "trust us" spiel and we actually care about this. I know I am probably coming off as over-dramatic here - reddit is not the center of the universe - but this stuff does matter in my opinion. And I am for one am glad to be participating in this blackout.
- neilv 3y agoWould any of the following measures help with Reddit growth and retention of users? 1. Make an official Web UI (responsive to desktop/tablet/phone) that users like, plus iOS and Android apps that people like? (Maybe make a responsive Web UI that's closer in spirit to old.reddit but with polish, and appeals first to smart power-users, while still quite usable by others? And then make the iOS and Android app store apps that appeal first to the more casual doomscrolling demographic that's still not even comfortable with nested comments and just wants to engage with their reactions to content?) But don't kill third-party apps before then, when Reddit isn't known for good UI after old.reddit. 2. Improve their image and video hosting, and then nudge people to use it (rather than leaning on bandwidth of third parties who sell ads that Reddit could be selling, who eventually try to poach users, or who eventually disappear and take down Reddit-initiated content with them)? 3. Discourage other poaching by third-party services, like subreddit mods of recent years stickying posts advertising the "official" Discord for that subreddit, and try to supply whatever genuine appeal that third-party has as part of the Reddit monolith? (If there is any appeal, and the fragmentation/poaching is not just driven by the mod's self-interest.) 4. Make sure Reddit is getting their share of all the LLM training epic goldmine value of the Reddit corpus? (Maybe this is part of what's behind the API lockdown, but that cash cow might've already left the barn, and maybe there are other angles to also be pursuing urgently?) These questions have come to mind, but I don't have data or internal business info to answer them.
- ZenMasterThis 3y agoI'd be happy to use reddit's app if they would put a few bucks into it to make it not total crap.
- baby 3y agoI'm just waiting for an alternative to reddit to pop. It'll go the way digg did then. I was hopping that Facebook would go this way, but groups on Facebook haven't really evolved and aren't really ergonomics for discussions like Reddit is. It's really a shame because they have a massive userbase but haven't managed to spin off new successful apps from that besides Marketplace...
- bogwog 3y agoI wonder: what if all the major third-party apps come together to form a reddit competitor? It doesn't have to be any kind of fancy decentralized mastodon type thing, just a straight up clone of reddit that users of existing reddit apps can seamlessly begin using, maybe even with a way to transfer your account name/posts/friends/subs/etc. It seems to me like this would be the only way for these apps to survive long term, because even if reddit backpedals a bit on this fumbled policy change, it's clear that third party apps are doomed. New attempts to kill them will be more subtle.
- cm2012 3y agoIn the end - 95% of people use new reddit or the app. It's not possible to fight this tide. I still use old Reddit but I understand my time will come to an end.
- pacetherace 3y agoThis! I tried using third-party apps and for some reason didn't like them. The official app is clunky but it is not like we haven't seen similar experiences with Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, etc. I mean look at Twitter, since going private, the whole thing has been so clunky, but the parameters governing how well Twitter is doing are still hinging policies related free speech, user-abuse and content moderation.
- diogenescynic 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguis...
- weetniet 3y agoAlthough Reddit currently faces a negative news cycle, I suspect they will easily overcome it by simply ignoring the uproar. Of course, there will be a percentage of users that feel that this is truly the last straw, but unfortunately, that pales in comparison to the enormous number of visitors for whom it doesn't matter enough.
- thih9 3y agoNote that in 2017 the official response to questions about breaking changes to the API was: "the API isn't going anywhere". https://old.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/66q4is/the_web_redesign_css_and_mod_tools/dgkeuqs/?context=3 https://old.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/66q4is/the_web_red...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paxys 3y agoThere's one "widespread protest" on the site every month, and nothing has ever come out of any of them. Reddit users love to think they are on some mission to stick it to "the man", but they are more akin to children throwing tantrums because they don't want to go do bed. The only effective form of protest is to quit and use something else. How many are willing to do that?
- eterm 3y agoThat's not quite true, it has previously been effective: https://www.newsweek.com/reddit-aimee-knight-challenor-fired-hundreds-subreddits-private-protest-1578657 https://www.newsweek.com/reddit-aimee-knight-challenor-fired...
- rationalfaith 3y ago[dead]
- ggm 3y agoIt's extremely unlikely given the nature of the systems and n-squared effects here, and the absence of channels, and moderators (dang+ aside) -But I find myself wondering what we'd do, as HN participants, if we discovered there was an IPO over the shared experience here. It becomes clearer as "HN is down?" gets more frequent that there's a real-world cost to some DB lookup and ASCII
- 31337Logic 3y ago2021 - quit Facebook 2022 - quit Twitter 2023 - quit Reddit Gee, thanks for making this a lot easier for me, guys!
- DtNZNkLN 3y agoI think a key motivation behind this is that Reddit wants to be able to collect more data on users. For example, reddit can't see how long you spent reading a post or a particular comment if that is happening in a 3rd party app. FB, IG, and especially TikTok monetize data like this extraordinarily well. If reddit is trying to play in the same league as the other social media companies, keeping all usage on the platform you own and control seems to be table stakes. This is why Twitter did this recently and FB did this years ago. Own the platform, own the data, make more money.
- Macha 3y agoAs a side note, I remember the days when Reddit had to beg the community to bail them out as they were at risk of being canned from their corporate owner's disinterest: https://techcrunch.com/2010/07/10/reddit-gold/ https://techcrunch.com/2010/07/10/reddit-gold/ By all accounts, it was very successful and saved the site, also leaving them resourced enough (including in hardware resources) to embrace the userbase from the imploding digg. I think it's clear Reddit's current leadership have forgotten how the userbase stepped in for them in the past.
- kepler1 3y agoIs this a case of: "private equity / venture capital ruins everything"? And relate to that, who exactly (what person) is applying pressure to the company directors to do this, who is it seeking to benefit, and who exactly is responding with decisions to meet what amount of bar of achievement? What $ is enough, and who is deciding that?
- GivinStatic 3y agoHow does all that pricing and business decisions work with volunteer moderators? Is it just momentum?
- mohallc 3y agoGuys, Reddit won't backtrack on jacking up the price. They are preparing their IPO and need to show revenue growth for investors to adhere to the equity story..