15 ms·
Emissions are no longer following the worst case scenario
- orwin 3y agoThis is good news, somehow. Here is how the earth 'greenhouse effect' really works: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=oqu5DjzOBF8&pp=ygUlZ3JlZW5ob3VzZSBlZmZlY3Qgc2FiaW5lIGhvc3NlbmZlbGRlcg%3D%3D https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=oqu5DjzOBF8&pp=ygUlZ3JlZW5ob3V... This is why Co2 do not have any effect until it reaches the high troposphere. That takes 20 years. The average climate we have right now is caused by emissions from 2003. I'll repeat that in the comments of every climate article I read by the way, sorry for the repetition. M
- seren 3y agoRCP 4.5 is still quite horrible in terms of consequences anyway
- kitd 3y agoWhich suggests to me that CO2 extraction from the air should be the next big target for innovation?
- lozenge 3y agoWho's going to pay for it? At 400ppm, you need a million cubic feet of air to go through your system to get 400 cubic feet of CO2 out. That has an inherent cost. Whether the CO2 is pulled from the air or from more concentrated industrial sources, the carbon sequestration industry would need to grow to the size of the fossil fuel industry (in terms of mass moved). But instead of extracting resources and selling them for financial gain, it will be a pure financial loss for an ecological gain. Under capitalism it's as impossible as water flowing uphill.
- Swenrekcah 3y agoIt’s not impossible if you can earn credits that can be sold. This is why the majority of the world needs to agree on a carbon tax system, yesterday.
- lozenge 3y agoWhat happens when people feel it's too expensive or disruptive and vote in somebody who undoes it?
- owisd 3y agoOther countries are implementing carbon taxes on their imports from countries that don’t tax carbon so companies will end up paying it indirectly on import taxes if their own government doesn’t levy it.
- aziaziazi 3y ago> not impossible > the majority of the world needs to agree Mmmhhh, not sure if betting on a world economic agreement to protect our climate and biodiversity is a good idea.
- Swenrekcah 3y agoAre you expecting the world to overthrow capitalism instead?
- badpun 3y agoWe actually already have water flowing uphill, in the pumped-storage hydroelectricity facilities. So who knows.
- lozenge 3y agoNext you'll be telling me that clouds are made of seawater!
- bootsmann 3y ago> it will be a pure financial loss for an ecological gain Not true, under the current EU emissions trading scheme you can actually earn money by selling the certificates for the CO2 you remove. If you check the price of it you can see that well defined markets can actually get the power of capitalism to work in your favour, with the price jumping from $30 to $90 within last year.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 3y agoI'd like to see some proof that these trading scheme work. I know how it is gamed, and how much speculators like them though.
- roelschroeven 3y agoCO2-extraction takes energy though, quite a lot of it. Using energy from fossil fuel for CO2-extraction is worse than doing nothing, since you're never going to extract as much CO2 as is emitted by the power plant. That leaves using clean energy, but clean energy is a limited resource. Using clean energy to replace current uses of CO2-emitting energy is likely going to be more effective than using it to extract the emitted CO2 back out of the atmosphere.
- TazeTSchnitzel 3y agoI read somewhere that sulfur emissions from global shipping have been making the part of the world where such shipping is most active (i.e. around Europe, North America and China) cooler than it otherwise would be. But now we're using low-sulfur fuels, so things might rapidly get worse in these latitudes.
- Wowfunhappy 3y ago> I'll repeat that in the comments of every climate article I read by the way Please don't do that. Thank you.
- Swenrekcah 3y agoIf it’s true then why not?
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoBecause I will have already read it and we don't want to have the same discussions in every thread. To quote dang, it makes comments uninteresting and raises the signal to noise ratio.
- matkoniecz 3y agoCan you link something that is not a youtube video but a text?
- orwin 3y agoI have slides? It's quite interesting because the first hypothesis "isothermal atmosphere at the same temperature as the ground" show exactly hw climate change doesn't work. From pages 32 onwards: https://www.lmd.ens.fr/legras/Cours/L3-meteo/radiatifNN.pdf https://www.lmd.ens.fr/legras/Cours/L3-meteo/radiatifNN.pdf
- eimrine 3y agoAm I right that the source does not count pollutions created from warheads explosions? Those are also exploating fossil fuels and exposing the greenhouse gases and amount of warheads spent is not being declared anywhere.
- usernew 3y agoI'll put it to you this way: all the militaries of all the countries in everything they do, are responsible for 6% of the CO2 emissions. I'll let you figure out why explosions alone were not mentioned at all.
- eimrine 3y ago> all the militaries of all the countries in everything they do, are responsible for 6% of the CO2 emissions I have quickly googled that statement and all I see is pre-02/24/22 data. I am sure the percent has changed significantly from the good old times.
- rhn_mk1 3y agoAh, how times have changed since checks notes last year.
- sofixa 3y agoIt's a fair argument, an active war is more intensive on emissions (tanks, trucks, planes, trains if not electrified need fuel, and especially older Soviet-era models aren't known for the fuel or emission efficiency).
- helsinkiandrew 3y agoI think pollution from warhead explosions is still negligible compared with pollution from fires or created from the emissions in reconstruction destroyed buildings or perhaps even the supply chain of delivering the warhead. The US and China military transport emissions probably dwarf everything. https://www.economist.com/international/2021/04/27/the-wests-armies-are-getting-more-serious-about-climate-change https://www.economist.com/international/2021/04/27/the-wests... archived: https://archive.ph/nFd2h https://archive.ph/nFd2h
- andersrs 3y ago[flagged]
- otikik 3y agoThis is good news, but I hope this was a real change and not “solved” by “creative accounting” (e.g. stopping counting some emissions as emissions). I will have to look at the reference data for this.
- karmakurtisaani 3y agoFrom skimming the article, it seems to be due to decreased coal burning and increased renewables. So good news indeed! However, the trajectory of progress at the moment is just stagnating emissions, not decreasing so a lot of work remains to be done.
- ImaCake 3y agoHard to argue with robust monitoring of CO2 concentrations which are now increasing linearly rather than exponentially (i.e emissions are constant instead of increasing).
- revelio 3y agoThey have never been increasing exponentially: https://gml.noaa.gov/ccgg/trends/ https://gml.noaa.gov/ccgg/trends/
- ImaCake 3y agoI am not sure... with caveats about timeseries ofc, plotting the yearly mean with a linear fit shows a curve where values in 1960 and 2010s are above the line and the between years are below. This would fit with a non constant slope that is slowly increasing in steepness. The size of the increase each year is much higher now than in 1980s even accounting for the increased CO2 value. So the rate of change has increased.
- jokoon 3y agoI wonder if COVID and/or inflation somehow started a trend of economic slowdown that allowed emissions to slow down. It means that somehow, if we care about the environment, we may have to be against economic growth and/or good economic health.
- aziaziazi 3y agoIndeed, it did [0] but only temporary. It seems to confirm the correlation of economic growth with GHG emissions. 0 https://www.unep.org/news-and-stories/press-release/covid-19-caused-only-temporary-reduction-carbon-emissions-un-report https://www.unep.org/news-and-stories/press-release/covid-19...
- p0w3n3d 3y agoI think we should live humble, but I can see that companies producing things just put on green robes and say "throw out your old car and buy this one because it's much more eco". All that forcing by law to throw out old things to get something more eco-friendly is so immoral (and insincere/hypocritical - I was missing a word)
- mschuster91 3y ago> All that forcing by law to throw out old things to get something more eco-friendly is so immoral It's not. Local emissions are a thing, too - a new car will have way cleaner exhaust than a 20 year old beater, and an electric vehicle even less. Nitrous oxide is the big issue in urban areas, the less of it is in the air the better for those having to live near high traffic streets.
- p0w3n3d 3y agohave you calculated amount of CO2 required to produce a new car? Why no one is fighting to convert those existing vehicles to electric? Why nobody produces filters for used cars? Maybe because companies do not have interest in it? And this way there is nothing change: just produce the same, but with new type of engine. Even better, because more money is earned. Meanwhile ecology is about putting down the production, but the production blossoms for some reason...
- rspoerri 3y agoRCP8.5, the scenario defined in the article as "worst case", is that the global air would have >1000ppm, looking at the referenced graph i'd guess it could go up to 3000ppm or more. A co2 detector warns if you have 1500+ ppm, where some people start to get headache and you should start ventilating your room. Imagine that 24h a day, on every place on the earth. Not to mention the effects of heating of 3.0°C to 5+°C . https://climatenexus.org/climate-change-news/rcp-8-5-business-as-usual-or-a-worst-case-scenario/ https://climatenexus.org/climate-change-news/rcp-8-5-busines... RCP 4.5 is really bad as well. In our last project it was kind of the worst case scenario we considered. It means that rich countries will have problems adapting to the changing environment. The changes will happen so fast (20 Years), no new infrastructure can be built to prevent natural disasters (for example dam's). Poor countries have even less possibilities to adapt. For example countries like Kazachstan completely rely for it's water resources in summer on glaciers. In Switzerland we already know that all glaciers will disappear or melt by 80% to 90% in all likely scenarios. https://ethz.ch/de/news-und-veranstaltungen/eth-news/news/2019/09/aletschgletscher.html https://ethz.ch/de/news-und-veranstaltungen/eth-news/news/20... edit: please correct me if i'm wrong, i am a designer that worked in climate visualsation research projects. However my short searches for the outcomes of rcp 8.5 are disastrous and no relief at all that it's now unlikely to come.
- toxicFork 3y agoLet's assume that the world is incapable of solving this problem. What can an individual do to not suffer? Invest in oxygen masks and a mountain cabin?
- simmerup 3y ago> What can an individual do to not suffer? You should be asking what an individual can do to not starve to death or die of over heating. Most answers are: move to a rich, powerful country not in the danger zone
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Most answers are: move to a rich, powerful country not in the danger zone There might not be any. Migration pressure from uninhabitable areas will keep mounting, and some of the countries in the "danger zone" have nukes.
- captainbland 3y agoShort version seems to be "it's not the worst case any more, but it's still fairly bad" in that we need to reduce emissions, not just have them plateau otherwise we will still have a fairly bad outcome. I'm also a little wary that the apparent plateau in the data might not pan out in the longer term. Particularly because of carbon cycle feedback loops that we may not be seeing the worst of yet.
- Gravityloss 3y agoI think some new scenarios between RCP 8.5 and RCP 6 would be useful. There's the old IS92B which would be closest. I found an old presentation from 1992 [1] where it was 2.7 C by 2100. A large effect. If we don't have more specific information people can get the incorrect idea that "crisis is averted". 1: https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/2018/05/ipcc_wg_I_1992_suppl_report_annex.pdf https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/2018/05/ipcc_wg_I_19...
- fguerraz 3y ago> This is due to the rapidly accelerating energy transition.. Err, just NO. This is largely due to global trade being flat for the past 10 years [1], this is a good proxy to measure real economic growth. Don't believe GDP as an indicator of real growth, they keep on adding fictitious sources to these numbers. Did you know that rent is part of GDP? And even rent that homeowners would have paid to a landlord had they owned their home? [2] So basically this is just about the world becoming poorer since the 2008 financial crisis (and covid of course). Also, "not following the worst case scenario" is not really a reason to rejoice, 4.5 degrees is still absolutely terrible. Also, funny enough the page they link to as a source for "Global CO2 emissions (both fossil and land use) have been relatively flat" has for title "Analysis: Global CO2 emissions from fossil fuels hit record high in 2022" [3]. So, lols. I could also add that less emissions growth doesn't mean less carbon accumulates in the atmosphere [4] [1] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/merchandise-exports-gdp-cepii?time=1980..latest&country=~OWID_WRL https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/merchandise-exports-gdp-c... [2] https://unherd.com/2018/11/truth-gdp-figures/ https://unherd.com/2018/11/truth-gdp-figures/ [3] https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-global-co2-emissions-from-fossil-fuels-hit-record-high-in-2022/ https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-global-co2-emissions-fr... [4] https://gml.noaa.gov/ccgg/trends/ https://gml.noaa.gov/ccgg/trends/
- epups 3y ago> Don't believe GDP as an indicator of real growth, they keep on adding fictitious sources to these numbers. Did you know that rent is part of GDP? And even rent that homeowners would have paid to a landlord had they owned their home? Of course renting is an economic activity that should be reflected in the GDP, and it is as "real" as anything else. To focus solely on international trade feels shortsighted as well. When a doctor sees you and charges you $200, that's going into the GDP but not into any trade balance. The world is richer since 2008 by almost any metric you can think of, including inflation-adjusted per capita income which is independent of GDP.
- tuatoru 3y agoSo the country is better off if prices of non-tradable services are increased by their suppliers? That sounds like the broken window fallacy.
- shaky-carrousel 3y agoHow the fact that we're seeing a 80% reduction in insect population fits in all of this? Honestly asking, I think it's really worrysome and not getting the attention it deserves.
- Chris2048 3y agoOf Interest: https://biodiversityireland.ie/the-silent-extinction-of-insects/ https://biodiversityireland.ie/the-silent-extinction-of-inse... The tone of which suggests the studies are not wide-ranging enough: each study has its flaws and limitations, as do all scientific studies, and in combination with the North American/European bias where most of studies were conducted, this means that it would be a stretch too far to say the science currently supports global insect declines: the jury is still out on insectageddon.
- tuatoru 3y agoAlso arable land loss through erosion, desertification, poisoning and salinization, loss of coral reefs, overfishing ocean fish populations to extinction, and creation of anoxic dead zones in the ocean. And more! Destruction of coastal mangroves. Groundwater over-extraction. Pollution of freshwater reservoirs and rivers. Destruction of tropical rainforests and their collections of many possibly useful organisms. A while ago (2010?) the US Defence National Intelligence Council's report on threats labeled climate change a "force multiplier". That's all it is, really: the least of the things we're doing wrong, that we will have to fix this century. It makes the real problems a bit worse. People are going to be really disappointed when we change the car fleet to 100% EV, but somehow things still keep getting worse.
- singularity2001 3y agoI agree: fixing the global biocide of Bayer & monsanto is probably even more disastrous and should have even higher priority than climate change. There MUST be more sustainable ways of farming than killing the biosphere.
- bratbag 3y agoIt doesn't. It's a different problem.
- ttiurani 3y agoWhat's very important to note is that a big bulk of the recent reductions have come from picking low-hanging fruits, i.e. by replacing coal with natural gas. This does not mean that going to zero will be possible with just more of the same.
- logifail 3y ago> a big bulk of the recent reductions have come from picking low-hanging fruits, i.e. by replacing coal with natural gas US and Europe, maybe. What about China and India? "China permitted more coal power plants last year [2022] than any time in the last seven years, according to a new report released this week. It's the equivalent of about two new coal power plants per week. The report by energy data organizations Global Energy Monitor and the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air finds the country quadrupled the amount of new coal power approvals in 2022 compared to 2021"[0] [0] https://www.npr.org/2023/03/02/1160441919/china-is-building-six-times-more-new-coal-plants-than-other-countries-report-fin https://www.npr.org/2023/03/02/1160441919/china-is-building-...
- tsimionescu 3y agoThe thing is, India is emitting less than either the USA or the EU even in absolute terms. In per capita terms, it's negligible. And in total emissions to date, it's not even a blip. Even China is far better in these metrics than the US and EU. So, at least morally, they seem to have every right to increase their emissions, and it is up to us, the largest historical polluters, to contract our economies if we are serious about both climate change and moral rights. Why should we expect to live in luxury in the EU while peasants in India live without electricity just because they can't afford a non-coal power plant? Of course, an even better approach would be for the large historical polluters to contribute funds, manpower and know-how, freely, to build clean power and clean industry in China and other places. And finally, I am also well aware that this is higy idealistic and none of this has any chance in hell of happening. We'll just keep pointing fingers at China and India (and the USA, speaking as an EU citizen) and avoid too much actual change.
- 3y ago
- Yizahi 3y agoI may be out of depth here, but does anyone else also thinks that measuring "emissions" is a kind of bullshit? First it is not very precise in the first place, but let's assume it is. Second - the effects of the GH gasses in atmosphere is not linear, scientists hypothesize about different thresholds which can be reached at certain global temperature points. Like for example west Antarctic shield detaching, Gulfstream interruption, sedimentary ocean methane release, permafrost methane release etc. All these can rapidly change our climate while "emissions" would be steady or even receding. Third - even "level" emissions would still continue heating up the planet, and heating rate would increase even with the "level" state of emissions, simply because "old" already emitted gasses are still in the atmosphere. I think it is more fair to measure temperatures directly, as we already do, and make estimates from there. It's not the CO2 which would harm us (at least not that much), it's the temperature, so we need to base our analysis on the thing that interests us directly. And not on the derivative of the derivative of it (emission rates). I suspect it doesn't matter how good are our models or how good are humanity's efforts in green tech. Until we are actually removing gasses from the atmosphere permanently, the planet is fucked. Just faster or slower, doesn't really matter.
- Yizahi 3y agoOh, and while we are it, I have problem with correlating author's graphs of emissions with this graph of actual gas in the atmosphere: https://keelingcurve.ucsd.edu/ https://keelingcurve.ucsd.edu/ You don't even need to be a big wig scientist to test this assumption. Open the graph on the big monitor and put a ruler or anything straight like a piece of paper to the median points corresponding to years 2000-2010. If emissions were "level" in the last decade then we should have 2010-2022 datapoints at most at the same line or even below the line. But in reality we see that the curve is raising up faster, meaning that the rate of emissions increased between years 10-22 compared to years 00-10, which contradicts author's graphs.
- vages 3y agoIt's very hard to argue without numerical data, but the graph on the Wikipedia version of the graph seems to increase linearly to my eyes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keeling_Curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keeling_Curve (Edit: No, I can see what you mean; the graph is steeper from 2010–2020 than from 2000–2010.) (To anyone a bit confused, the Keeling graph is the cumulative amount of CO2 in the atmosphere, so emissions are the first derivative of this graph.)
- andrewstuart 3y agoThat’s a relief. We can all get back to normal life then.
- ido 3y agodid we ever leave normal life?
- vages 3y agoThe last paragraph is probably one of the best ways you can phrase a “Keep up the good work” message about emissions. > Ultimately, the progress we have made should encourage us that progress is possible, but the large and growing gap between where we are headed today and what is needed to limit warming to well-below 2C means that we need to double down and light a (carbon-free) fire under policymakers to ratchet up emissions reductions over the next decade. Flattening the curve of global emissions is only the first step in a long road to get it all the way down to zero.
- Proven 3y ago[dead]
- Guthur 3y agoTertullian circa 100-200AD "The strongest witness is the vast population of the earth to which we are a burden and she scarcely can provide for our needs; as our demands grow greater, our complaints against Nature's inadequacy are heard by all. The scourges of pestilence, famine, wars and earthquakes have come to be regarded as a blessing to overcrowded nations since they serve to prune away the luxuriant growth of the human race." We have been beating this same drum for nearly 2000 years, at least. Nothing is new, we're tripping ourselves ad infinitum.
- kibwen 3y agoLest the lede be buried: > What does this flattening of emissions and divergence from the high-end scenario mean for the climate going forward? First, its important to emphasize that a flatting of emissions does not mean that global warming will stop or the problem will be solved. The amount of warming the world experiences is a function of our cumulative emissions, and the world will not stop warming until we get emissions all the way to net-zero. Even after we reach net-zero emissions, the world will not cool back down for many millennia to come in the absence of removing more CO2 from the atmosphere than we emit. > This is the brutal math of climate change, and the reason why its so important to start reducing our emissions quickly. We are already well off track for what would be needed to limit warming to 1.5C without large overshoot (and the need for lots of negative emissions to bring temperatures back down). If we do not start reducing global emissions over the coming decade, plausible scenarios to limit warming to below 2C will move out of reach as well. In other words, this is heartening progress, but not an excuse for apathy.
- bricemo 3y agoWe need to be both celebrating wins and working harder to improve further. There’s lots to do but this is encouraging to me that it’s possible to reach better outcomes. Let’s keep bending the curve!
- revelio 3y ago[flagged]
- bratbag 3y agoNever ending doomerism will breed more apathy at this point.
- Julesman 3y agoWell, that's nice. Not gunna stop sea level rise from flooding every coastal city within 30 years. But hey, a slightly better apocalypse just gives me a warm glow all over. Totes.
- freedude 3y agoThose of you that claim plant growth is nitrogen limited have not spent enough years working in an orchard. An observant orchardist will tell you the trees on the outside of the orchard always grow the most given like conditions (soil, water, etc...). How would a lowly orchardist know this when an environmentalist doesn't? The orchardist prunes the trees and knows there is significantly more pruning required on the outside edge of an orchard. Could that related to substances other than CO2? Yes. But the fact remains there is a higher concentration of CO2 on the outside edge of an orchard than the inside.
- nologic01 3y agoThere are multiple effects going on and some are hopeful, but it is worrisome that key factors seem to be the cooling impact of negative events: mismanaged financial systems, pandemics and geopolitical strife. The bigger and counterintuitive picture is that vast numbers of people do not enjoy the quality of life that is nominally achievable with todays technologies and a more peaceful and better managed world would actually enormously increase emissions unless we find sustainable substitutes for whatever really contributes to quality of life. We need to snap out of such absurd incentives and false dilemmas. The task is global sustainable prosperity and we are lucky to have a worthy purpose.
- mrangle 3y agoYou people are self-serious while naive, and it is going to be hilarious watching you watch how this ends. I hope that we get to see it together.
- tinus_hn 3y agoJust like 20 years ago though, life as we know it is going to end in 10 years!
- Andy_G11 3y agoJust living a modern urbanised life seems to be enough to drive humanity towards apocalypse within a few decades. Is that the case? If so, then I expect humanity to behave as it always does - with both good and bad elements of behaviour on display, perhaps accentuated as pressures to survive mount. Cohesive action will be fragmented and many will suffer and some will prosper. Sounds pretty much like the way things work today. I would be interested to know of any models which avert disaster that do not rely on billions of people all acting to live quite differently to how they do today.