11 ms·
Texas professor fails entire class from graduating- claiming they used ChatGTP
- stjohnswarts 4y agoHe most likely should be fired. There is no way everyone used ChatGPT. I mean he even messed the acronym up multiple times.
- mc32 4y agoInstead of failing them on this assignment, why not make them do an oral presentation and grade this assignment on that, if there is doubt?\ Failing them completely seems a bit heavy-handed and unfair. Surely some did leverage ChatGPT, but likely not all did so.
- tpxl 4y agoBecause this is a bad teacher not interested in doing their job.
- exabrial 4y agoWere expectations set ahead of time? (don't cheat?) If so, he's actually the best kind of teacher: allowing them to experience the real world but with soft consequences.
- nickthegreek 4y agoThe real world where someone in power claims everyone they are responsible for educating is cheating in the 11th hour, provides no evidence and refuses to pass them even though they paid thousands of dollars?
- kevviiinn 4y agoThe situation would probably be better without the paying thousands of dollars part
- dotnet00 4y agoWhy does the expectation of not cheating matter when the claim that they cheated is itself in doubt? As far as we know, the students are being punished for the teacher's incompetence, not the consequences of their cheating.
- brickteacup 4y agoYes, the real world, where a professor decides an entire class cheated because ChatGPT said so (lol. lmao even). I guess it is a good introduction to dealing with capricious idiots
- jimbob45 4y agoBeen saying this for a while. There are very simple and effective ways to teach your class that can't be cheated with AI. These professors are simply lazy and uncreative.
- BoiledCabbage 4y agoThen why don't you list them instead of keeping them secret?
- jimbob45 4y agoI'm not keeping them secret at all. We've had discussion about this before. It seems that the best strategy is to set the weight of HW as very small (~10%) with exams weighted heavily but make it clear that exam problems are loosely pulled from HW. Even if you're remote-only, you can ensure all exams are required to be proctored at an approved facility.
- NotOscarWilde 4y agoSpeaking as an (assistant) professor in theoretical CS, I see there are many bad approaches in the original post and mentioned in this discussion, but I strongly disagree with: > There are very simple and effective ways to teach your class that can't be cheated with AI. These professors are simply lazy and uncreative. I can attest to the following problems to good homework creation, from my own experiences playing with ChatGPT and teaching: 1. If you want to give a very illustrative yet easy theoretical exercise in algorithm design, one that computer scientists have solved over and over in the last few decades and which furthers your understanding, there are very likely solutions online and ChatGPT will give you the solution with very high probability. 2. If you create your own dataset and want the students to implement some algorithm and create a simple plot/discussion from the results, it will be very hard to distinguish a "student solved it on their own, but they did not invest too much time into it" submissions from ChatGPT submissions produced by a couple of queries. 3. Switching to oral presentations is hard to scale (as others attest) and also does not resolve much, because some students are perfectly okay with being handed a solution from somewhere (colleague, ChatGPT), not understanding it very well, and yet presenting it. Failing these students likely leads to overly difficult classes. 4. In-classroom exams without a computer work best, but they also do not scale very well (a lot of prep/correction needs to go into them) and some students with bad anxiety management skills, which includes me as a former student, dislike them passionately. --- As you can see, this topic is quite critical for my profession. The ugly truth is that university professors have only a very limited time allocated in their busy workweeks for teaching, and hence they have to take many shortcuts, including suboptimal homework sheets and limited innovation year-over-year. I also do not allocate as much time for philosophy of teaching/improving teaching skills as I would have liked. If anyone here has novel ideas how to actually implement "a class that can't be cheated with AI", specifically university CS classes, I am all ears.
- andai 4y agoThis might not be feasible depending on the size of the class. I had classes with 100-200 students. Most problems with education are simply due to scale. The most notable one being Bloom's finding that private tutoring produced 2 standard deviations better results than classroom education. We can kind of approximate that now with GPT :) One tutor per child!
- michaelt 4y ago> This might not be feasible depending on the size of the class. I had classes with 100-200 students. American colleges regularly collect $10,000+ in fees per student, so I'm not sure why a 20 minute oral exam would be infeasible?
- dotnet00 4y agoYou're asking for ~2000 minutes to examine a class of 100. That means either having many more TAs than most classes have or making examination periods way longer than they are. Then, even with all that you aren't really making any real improvement, as the skills involved in an oral exam are not necessarily relevant to those which need to be tested, thus making the exam at best similar in uselessness to a written exam and at worst, actively harmful in testing performance.
- revelio 4y agoSo 33 hours of work, or a bit less than a week by one person then? Why is this thread full of academics claiming that apparently normal workloads of the sort everyone takes on, or trivial solutions of the sort high school teachers manage, is somehow impossible for them? They do realize they're accepting money in return for a commitment to do teaching activities, right?
- dotnet00 4y agoAn entire week of nothing but oral presentations, and you really can't see how that's completely unrealistic? Do you think the only things professors (or students for that matter) have to do is go to lectures and listen to oral exams?
- cheeze 4y agoHe graded the papers a day before graduation. No time for a presentation.
- wudangmonk 4y agoWhen I was in school we would get these long 'research' assignments that required gathering sources and give citations rarely as they consumed a lot of time so it was reserved for the important projects that made up a considerable part of your grade. I helped my nephew in High School, not college for a few months last year and I was so sick and tired of constantly getting so many of these assignments every single god damn week. I just couldn't understand the point of it, you were given so little time since it seemed like every week several classes wanted one of these on top of the regular homework and sometimes there would be two of them on the same week from the same class so of course the quality would be low and I just do not see the point of this type of assignment if its not given the proper amount of time it requires. I hated everything about it and when chatgpt came along I saw it as a blessing hoping that now that there was something that could do this the teachers would stop relying on them so much.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoThis doesn’t sound like he’s failing the entire class. >If you are happy with your grade, simply do not turn in the next assignment
- willvarfar 4y agoThe threads show that ChatGPT claims to have written anything if you ask it to. So it really doesn't matter what the student submits, ChatGPT will claim it?
- eloisius 4y agoIndeed there’s one screenshot showing ChatGPT claim it wrote the professor’s email. How embarrassing.
- flutas 4y ago> This doesn’t sound like he’s failing the entire class. In the email he also says "I am giving everyone in the class an X." > X (grade not submitted): If you do not assign a grade, an “X” defined as “grade not submitted” is automatically assigned. No student can graduate with an “X” on his/her academic record. I think the term "fails" is wrong in the title, but he is essentially blocking them from graduating at this time.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoI was reading that X as a variable, not a particular grade. As in, your grade is X, where X can be A, B, C, D, or F.
- crop_rotation 4y agoIf it is just about accusations, maybe the professor should be failed for using some automated tool for grading here (Who knows if he used ChatGPT or similar)
- wombatpm 4y agoI'm sure the professor is falling back on some sort of honor code chicanery where you are required to report cheating of fellow classmates if you are aware of cheating.
- themodelplumber 4y agoThat's a good point, there was also the professor who casually joined his class's private chat (given the surprise opportunity) and then got screenshots of the group's cheating process. I think he also got screenshots of the group suspecting that some other student was telling on them. Edit, found the original: https://web.archive.org/web/20220601073048/https://crumplab.com/articles/blog/post_994_5_26_22_cheating/index.html https://web.archive.org/web/20220601073048/https://crumplab....
- cpitman 4y agoThat seems like a bad representation of what happened. A teacher was invited to join a group chat at the beginning of the term. And then students started to use the chat to cheat, not realizing the teacher was part of the group. It's pretty clear the students were at fault, while also being really sloppy at cheating.
- wholinator2 4y agoYes, we had quite a debacle including a class chat that the much maligned teacher was not a part of. These kinds of chats should never see the light of day, and the kids in them should not create circumstances where someone feels they need to report it. Having a parallel classroom the teacher cannot access can be a dangerous toy
- boredemployee 4y agoThis is dumb as fuck. The said "teacher" should know that ChatGPT will give lots of false positives.
- kvn8888 4y agoLots of hallucinations. ChatGPT will hallucinate that it wrote pieces of text. Even GPTZero will detect the constitution as AI generated
- timmytokyo 4y agoApparently ChatGPT claims it wrote the teacher's message too.
- NopeSlide 4y agoSaid teacher is one person in a large crowd of people that are now using ChatGPT as a modern-day quiver of divining arrows. I am not hopeful for the future if people are so ready to give up their own thinking to machines, who may develop emergent motives.
- boredemployee 4y agoAlso a symptom of a broken society, isn't it? It's crazy all the "increase your productivity by 10 with GPT" tutorials on the web
- NopeSlide 4y agoWe are definitely about the enter the 'find out' phase within the next 8 years
- r00fus 4y agoIs said teacher "giving up their own thinking" or just lazy/desperate? Based on a reddit comment from the post: "It was allegedly 3 different essays about agricultural science occurring in the last few months of classes. The professor elected not to grade them until today, (graduation was yesterday) so now the university is withholding an entire class’s diplomas after they walked the stage." So this teacher is both a) blind as to the capabilities of ChatGPT and b) didn't do his work until it was almost too late. If he had used some non-BS method of "detecting" plagiarism and applied it evenly through out the course, that's something else. Nope.
- anotheryou 4y agoBY ASKING CHATGTP IF IT'S CHATGTP GENERATED -_- wtf. even the dedicated detectors don't work well.
- riffraff 4y agoyeah, a teacher failing a whole class is odd, but failing a whole class based on the fact that ChatGPT said it wrote it is just insane.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoPrompt: Why hasn't professor X denied being a serial killer?
- croes 4y agoBecause of the hype people believe it's intelligent and as a machine can't lie. Too bad it's an text generator and just produces the most likely answer. "When someone asks you if you are a god, you say YES"
- masswerk 4y agoThis is what you get by hyping ChatGPT without making clear what it does, can do, and can not do.
- anotheryou 4y agoThis is what you get if you can't make teachers embrace technology. Make it mandatory to use chatGPT for writing aid, do live tests to prove true knowledge.
- nixpulvis 4y ago[flagged]
- throwwwaway69 4y agoThis is what you get if you hire professors who assign writing exercises but are incapable of writing basic coherent emails with punctuation, and are unable to read the very plain text below a ChatGPT response that it may not be accurate.
- rrauenza 4y agoFYI, the reddit thread has someone claiming to do what I was thinking of doing -- submitting the professor's email to chatgpt to ask if the text itself is chatgpt's: https://imgur.com/a/NrwpZfh https://imgur.com/a/NrwpZfh
- dpflan 4y agoIncredible, this is the correct response by the student(s).
- JustBreath 4y agoYeah... There are ways to get a probability score on whether an AI generated something. Asking a model whose job it is to generate the words which most often follow the sentence "did you make this?" is not one of them.
- slt2021 4y agoIncredibly low IQ professor who doesn't know how to grade and how to use chat gpt. All students must organize and report this behavior, he is using unauthorized and unproven tool to grade assignments
- brickteacup 4y agoRather disturbing that such people are able to become professors in the first place. Even if he's not technically inclined he should be smart enough not to assign grades based on the output of some untested tool
- cududa 4y agoThis is pretty much an episode of South Park from a few weeks ago where the teacher starts grading all the papers with ChatGPT then realizes the students were also using it to write their papers. Except in this case it’s not a cartoon and the teacher is incompetent
- binarymax 4y agoTo the teachers I know, I’ve been recommending that if they are paranoid about GPT, they can ask the students to cite material from a physical textbook in their assignments. Even if the students type the textbook into ChatGPT at least they read the material. This is beside the point of whether current education needs to be improved, and whether GPT is going to force some change here - but this is a useful stopgap. teachers who take an approach like OP need to be stopped.
- sidewndr46 4y agoAs someone who was a student over a decade ago, I'd lose my fucking mind if I had to use physical books. There was simply not enough time to go get books off the shelf and complete all my assignments. Everything was done digitally, I can't think of a single exception in college. I once turned in a math exam written using LaTeX and the professor initially declined to grade it. I did concede that I hadn't followed the directions (handwritten answers only), but the professor did eventually grade it.
- hondo77 4y agoSo it was impossible for students 30 years ago to complete their assignments because they only had access to physical books? How did any of them graduate?
- RajT88 4y agoI was a student more like 20 years ago. I had a lot of physical books as well. There's different use cases. If you are searching for a specific piece of information - digital all the way. If you are trying to digest material in a linear fashion, I find a physical book works better for me. Less distractions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sidewndr46 4y agoI agree on the less distractions part. But it's just a time thing. I can search 7 different books in the time it would take me to get one off a shelf and search it.
- ilamont 4y agoI've talked with current college students at a number of U.S. colleges and asked them about what professors are saying about ChatGPT. They don't seem to understand the implications beyond students can potentially use it to cheat.
- jmount 4y agoWow, even if the professor assigned using ChatGPT they would not get 100% adoption. Classes have really heterogeneous behavior.
- brewdad 4y agoMy son told me about an assignment he had where, due to a tight timeline, the homework wouldn't be corrected and returned until after the mid-term which covered that material. The professor didn't feel this was fair, so gave the students a freebie where he posted the solutions along with the homework and no restriction on how the students used it. In an ideal world, students would still work the problems and then identify/correct their mistakes. There was no penalty for simply copying the answer key. There were still students who either didn't do the assignment or turned in homework with half of the answers incorrect.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoI can't read the OP, but, it seems quite impressive if the matriculation rules already have "must not use AI assistance" in them. Would be interested in the particular wording too - if you used ChatGPT search tool does that disqualify you? What about if your spreadsheet app used AI to choose the best graph type? You used ChatPDF? Are they saying it is plagiarism, would students know that it was considered that way (you've not copied, and ChatGPT isn't a source as such).
- cheeze 4y agoWhy can't you read the OP?
- csjh 4y agoAll of my CS classes already have rules against AI (though they had a head start from copilot). A couple other non-STEM courses as well.
- sidewndr46 4y agoThis would have been quite the quagmire for my education, as I was required to create AI for at least one class.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoWas the AI that you created writing your paper though?
- sidewndr46 4y agoha, I wish!
- Throw73849 4y agoAt this point you can replace professor and university with ChatGPT. For well documented topics (like math, languages..) it gives pretty good explanations. I use it to study new programming language and AI!
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoWe already know it can't actually do math and it'll bald-faced lie to you about facts, so I don't think that's actually a great idea.
- ummonk 4y ago[flagged]
- Throw73849 4y agoIt is not a calculator, but can explain concepts in math pretty well. It does not lie about well documented facts, such as basic university course. It needs a lot of training data. And if student can not recognize their teacher is bullshiting them, there is a bigger problem.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y ago> And if student can not recognize their teacher is bullshiting them If it's a learner's first exposure to a topic what indicators can they use to identify that ChatGPT is lying to them?
- Throw73849 4y agoThe same indicators they would use with teacher? Studyig is about reading books, comparing sources. Not copying notes. At university if you discover teacher is lying, you may get prosecuted, expelled, and loose $100k on student loans. Edit: response to your other comment, I am being rationed by HN As I said, ChatGPT is good at answering and explaining questions. It can replace teacher as "explainer", not as some sort of dogmatic source of truth. Text book does not answer questions, ChatGPT does! If some section of textbook is too vague to understand, you may ask questions to get better understanding!
- thadt 4y agoThe ability to 'cheat' on written assignments has always been a possibility. With the rise of the Internet, it became easier to source it from more places - with a counter balancing rise of plagiarism detectors. Now with Google, Grammarly and ChatGPT, it is trivial to copy/paste a pipeline with enough entropy to defeat many if not most detectors. I suspect the next generation of tools will be finish this cycle - we won't be able to build an arbitrary text distinguisher that works with acceptable accuracy. Educators have to adapt. If you want to "know what someone knows" - then ask them face to face, or have them write it down on paper. We used to call these tests, and they work pretty well. If you want someone to produce a piece of writing about something, how they produced it is less important than the result. If it is correct, clear, and gets the job done, then good. It's be the same for programming assignments - Copilot and ChatGPT make all un-proctored creation assignments a black box. You can evaluate the output, but it is nearly impossible to know what's in the box.
- tnel77 4y ago“But I’m a bad test taker!” I understand that everyone is different and that we should try to be accommodating overall, but it always cracked me up when select people could only thrive when they were at home with a take home test.
- vehemenz 4y agoIt's not even a matter of adaptation in some cases. Written tests have been around for a long time, even during the era of word processors and computers. Whether instructors wanted to use has been a matter of pedagogy. Some of my philosophy exams 20+ years ago were written tests. You were given about twice as much time as you needed to write your arguments, which was fair to the slowest students. My CS courses for C programming were all written tests. You were expected to know the basic control structures and the standard libraries well enough to do this. To be fair, this was before Blackboard and other learning management systems, but there's no reason we can't go back to this system across the board.
- whateveracct 4y ago> The ability to 'cheat' on written assignments has always been a possibility. Right, and you have also always gotten a big fat F when you cheat.
- extr 4y agoThe amount of non-technical people who have very little intuition around the limitations of LLMs is actually fairly startling - and I like to think of myself of someone who is usually good at that kind of thing. The realistic/coherence of the output is just so convincing, people cannot seem to stop themselves from attributing a theory of mind to it. Just earlier this week I saw someone saying that they were creating a ton of OpenAI accounts to try to advocate to ChatGPT for their activist cause.
- AJ007 4y agoHow many people believe horoscopes and astrology carry any meaning? Most will never comprehend LLMs or even the simplest concepts of machine learning.
- erehweb 4y agoAutocorrect is fairly well understood and an LLM is an extension of that. (Yes, I know it's more complicated - still, it's a reasonable first approximation)
- MandieD 4y agoI wouldn't say that autocorrect and autocomplete are well understood by most users, but are well-accepted and not feared and/or fetishized. Telling my non-tech relatives and friends that "ChatGPT is extremely fancy autocomplete" has settled most of them down a bit.
- hnfong 4y agoWhile we're on the topic of stroking our epeens, do you know how horoscopes and astrology work? Most people here with that condescending attitude will never comprehend it either. FWIW, it's one of the topics I've been trying to understand and come up with a consistent theory for a while. (Not to say those who believe in horoscopes and astrology know how it works though...)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sidewndr46 4y agoIs this a hoax or did a professor actually write "ChatGTP" that many times in one email?
- kubb 4y agoAs far as I understand, a lot of degrees in certain places are earned in large part by writing essays. AI is deadly to that style of education for sure.
- groestl 4y ago"Improve spelling, precision, organization and expression in the following letter from a Texas professor to his students: [...]"
- bitL 4y agoFrankly, most essays in MBA or almost any social science school can be outsourced to AI with a small context window so teachers need to get more creative; either force people to read more papers (larger context window) or make certain checkpoints throughout the assignment that need to continue context from previous portions in some specific ways.
- TRiG_Ireland 4y agoI have a degree in chemistry, and years later went back to college to do Deaf Studies. I didn't complete that one, though I'd like to go back and try again. So I've seen both STEM and social sciences. Deaf Studies is a small field. The experts mostly know each other personally. The lecturer cites a study, and then mentions that she was visiting the author last month, and describes chatting with the author's trilingual young child. The lecturer wrote the main textbook you ought to be citing, or perhaps their close friend did. Hallucinating citations would not work. I doubt that Open AI would be in any way helpful. (Besides, I actively enjoy putting words together, and had a genuine love of the subject.)
- wordsarelies 4y agoSo... You trained the model with all the text you could find. And we trained all those students on all the same text... And then we run a comparison to identify if they used the same source material... Aaaand everyone's cheating.
- bitL 4y agoWhat happens if ChatGPT misflags an essay I generated using self-hosted Vicuna-LLaMa as generated by ChatGPT? Will I get my money back? And from whom?
- sosodev 4y agoShould we even be discussing this? There’s no proof that this actually happened. Reddit posts are very often made up for karma.
- adjav 4y agoThe Reddit OP posted the prof's name, they really are an agricultural sciences professor at Texas A&M. If this is made up then it's one hell of a way to defame someone.
- anoonmoose 4y agoReddit has accused innocent people of worse in the past.
- greenie_beans 4y agoyikes that teacher is not smart or wise or very mature based on that email. also, very ironic that he'd enlist chatgpt to do work for him while failing people for allegedly using chatgpt.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- redleggedfrog 4y agoRemember kids, when you cheat, you cheat yourself.
- toss1 4y agoProfessors might consider including ChatGPT in the assignment: Get ChatGPT to generate the pest output possible using your prompting skills (show the prompt work and progression), then critique it, find and distinguish the accurate parts and hallucinations (citing actual hardcopy book references). Students would have to both show knowledge of the topic and show knowledge of skilled use of LLMs (which should be a useful skill going forward). Bonus is that this actually harder than an ordinary test.
- TRiG_Ireland 4y agoHow is "skilled use of LLMs" a relevant skill in agricultural science?
- toss1 4y agoIt seems that "skilled use of LLMs" is becoming a relevant skill almost everywhere. It is obviously relevant to their course, so...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- flatline 4y agoI really think we need a standard for citing AI generated/assisted content so people can use it in their work and call out that pieces of the work may be AI generated. It would be something of a gentleman’s agreement but it would make its use more transparent in academia and maybe even slow the current and ongoing onslaught of indeterminately generated content on the web. I also feel like any prof claiming cheating based solely on an AI or AI detection model needs to be hauled in front of an academic review board on the same criteria they are judging their students. There is no excuse for this level of uncritical thinking at the University level.
- conductr 4y agoGiven misinformation provided in some GPT responses, what exactly are you citing? I think the method would be to use GPT for a rough draft, then do fact checking and/or find sources for the claims the GPT was using. In essence, it's a research tool. It seems like if people are just copy/pasting in results they aren't trying at all and very likely didn't even try to comprehend the outputs. It should be considered cheating to do that. At this point, cheating is so pervasive (even before ChatGPT), I feel like they need to change the testing approach; no specific ideas or solutions but seems like bringing back in person hand written testing would work for a lot of cases and subjects (not all).
- flatline 4y agoIt would be plagiarism to copy much of anything from someone else’s original work without citation. Even using GPT as a drafting tool will result in a lot of AI content making it into the final work verbatim. I think citation would legitimize this process, to an extent. Right now I feel like using the tool at all would count as “cheating” in many people’s minds, and I share some of those feelings if there is no disclosure. I also think LLMs are a legitimate tool for many purposes and their widespread use is inevitable.
- ummonk 4y agoChatGPT lies all the time and I wouldn't consider it a reliable indicator to simply ask it whether it has written a particular piece of text.
- wordsarelies 4y agoProfs using Language models, grammar analysis engines and autoscoring are now mad students have the inversion of their tools too. This has big "algebra teacher is mad at smartphones" energy.
- assface 4y agoThis professor has a PhD in lactating pigs, not computer science / ai. He should stay in his lane: https://inside.tamuc.edu/academics/cvsyllabi/cv/MummJared.pdf https://inside.tamuc.edu/academics/cvsyllabi/cv/MummJared.pd...
- bombcar 4y agoNow I’m imagining him sitting down with the lactating pigs and asking about cheaters. And in the darkest night, after the moon has set, the pigs reply.
- honkycat 4y agoClueless, entitled asshole needs taken down a peg. This is exactly why I got the hell out after a bachelor's degree. I can't stand the professors. I can't stand the richy-rich students whining about "having no direction" and failing classes while I am fighting for my life and my future, who eventually evolve into the asshole professors.
- Capricorn2481 4y agoThis is a result of many people in the world, including a lot of people on HackerNews, talking ChatGPT up like it's an omniscient oracle.
- boredemployee 4y agoWhile I agree with you, a teacher should at least know the basics of the world he/she is living in and the tools he/she is using.
- Capricorn2481 4y agoThat is what I'm saying.
- cde-v 4y agoI'm betting the professor is 60+ and has max font size on their phone.
- slapshot 4y agoSuper ageist and offensive. Also likely false. Bachelor's degree 2014: https://inside.tamuc.edu/academics/cvsyllabi/cv/MummJared.pdf https://inside.tamuc.edu/academics/cvsyllabi/cv/MummJared.pd...
- harha_ 4y agoI'm a bit scared of this progress trend. I tried ChatGPT once and it was so convincing that I can imagine how one could easily get addicted to it. I'm deliberately avoiding using it to avoid dependence.
- qrio2 4y agoI get what you mean, but to me that's a bit like avoiding using a shovel because you can dig with your hands. IMO learning these tools, how to use them well, and properly is going to be really helpful. That said I do already feel that dependence creeping in
- Buttons840 4y agoWe need a pair of mischievous cheating-detectors, one that always returns "no cheating detected", and one that always returns "AI cheating confirmed". In the presence of an accusing teacher, saying "well, but... but... it's not always accurate" makes a person look weak. Unfortunately, this schoolyard-level logic prevails even among adults too often. But if the accused can say "okay, that website claims there's a 90% chance I cheated, but here's another website that says there's a 99.9% chance I didn't cheat". That muddies the waters and then suddenly the accusing teacher is receptive to discussing the merits of cheat detection. For example, the teacher might say "well, nobody knows how your website detects the cheating, nobody knows how it works!", to which you reply that we don't know how the website the teacher uses works either. Throwing in an accusation that the teacher's own syllabus was written by AI (using the other mischievous website) makes things even more fun. Again, the point being to force a discussion on the merits of cheat detection.
- fsflover 4y agoSee also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35951312 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35951312 It Wasn't AI (itwasntai.com) 131 points by dbrereton 23 hours ago | 127 comments
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoI mean, in the real life it is evaluated if work is done or not. Nobody cares how you get to the result as long as the result was legally obtained.
- lr1970 4y agoThe professor clearly does not understand how LLMs work and his approach to catching cheats is flawed. The students should loudly complain about such an unscientific approach with unknown false-positive and false-negative rates. Cheating is a problem but relying on ChatGPT's own assessment is only warranted if proven accurate. In the absence of such a proof the Prof is full of sh*t.
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoNothing in the professor’s message says or even implies the whole class was failed. Did people just stop learning how to read in the last few years?
- B1FF_PSUVM 4y agoNah, they've always done that - understanding whatever they expected to read/hear/see, instead of what was written/said/shown. Probably a feature of the cognitive apparatus, wouldn't surprise me if complaints about it were found in cuneiform tablets.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoBreaking news! Now with 150% more clickbait and 300% more misinformation. Critical thinking skills are in the doldrums due to technological distractions. One possibility for education is to go full Luddite: chalk, pencil, dead trees, and collections of dead trees. The ability to focus and master mental labor are the important bits.
- omoikane 4y agoBack in my university days, tools were used to detect suspected cheating, but actual confirmation comes only after interviewing the students in question. This is especially important since if there are two or more pieces of homework that looked similar, you want to know who wrote the original. Failing the whole class without such follow up interviews seems unreal.
- omgJustTest 4y agoWhile this is clearly off-the-rails, it is also a great thing to happen (especially with the chance to redeem ones-self in the course). It might influence a whole group of otherwise sleeping intellectuals that maybe believing AI blindly leads to massive problems. Maybe there should be some limits to where it is applied ? maybe it is a great tool that needs more people to bend it back to sanity...
- scotuswroteus 4y agoDoes the verb 'fail' take 'from' as a preposition?
- ngngngng 4y agoIs there a difference between cheating in school and hacking school? I think so. I almost never studied for math tests in University. They were all multiple choice and I found it easy to logic out the only possible answer to the question just by looking at the choices. Worst case if I was in a hurry I'd get a B on an exam. I wasn't looking up the answers and skipping any work. I was just arriving at the prescribed optimal outcome (a good grade) without following the schools preferred method. This is what AI feels like to me. It's a very useful, but very flawed tool. In its current state, if I try and make it do my work for me, I'm going to have a very bad time. It's a "hack", not a "cheat." It's a new way of doing work, not a replacement for work.
- ragnese 4y ago> Is there a difference between cheating in school and hacking school? I think so. For sure. My anecdote is only tangentially related to the topic of this post, but I always told my physics 1 students that cheating (when it came to their homework) was a state of mind, rather than an action. Most students had access to the solutions manual for their (very standard and popular) textbook, even though they weren't "supposed to". Several times I had students sheepishly admit to me that they had consulted the solutions manual, and still didn't understand the solution to a particular problem. That right there is an example of NOT cheating, because they consulted the solution with the proper mindset: they attempted the problem, got stuck, and THEN consulted a solution with the INTENTION OF LEARNING. However, a student that just pulls out the solutions manual to quickly get the problems done without attempting it themselves were cheating in my view. It didn't often matter, anyway, because these students often did terribly on the exams and had trouble passing (who would've guessed?).
- _dain_ 4y ago>I almost never studied for math tests in University. They were all multiple choice and I found it easy to logic out the only possible answer to the question just by looking at the choices. How does an entirely multiple-choice mathematics exam at University level even work? What kind of maths? I don't see how any kind of proof or derivation question could work in this context.
- Walter75 4y ago
- ppetty 4y ago"Was this text generated by ChatGPT?" seems like a relevant question ... -- For each of the students. -- For someone in the Computer Science department. -- A different prompt tool (like Bard even) I hope this terrible form of evaluation & judgement doesn't affect our legal system.
- taylodl 4y agoSounds like a dean has their work cut out for them. Sorry, the professor is going to have to provide better evidence than "I asked ChatGTP if it wrote this paper."
- alistairSH 4y agoHas anybody confirmed this is real?