16 ms·
‘Nearshoring’ Push Is Fueling Tech Job Demand in Latin America
- TexanFeller 4y agoThis will get big pretty soon. It's been a trend for a while, my last few jobs we've had LATAM contractors. No time zone issues like with overseas and much less of a language and cultural barrier, like basically nonexistent compared to India. Average skill of LATAM devs is still low compared to the US, but they will learn and grow as more work moves there.
- mmaia 4y ago> Average skill of LATAM devs is still low compared to the US I'd say it is a sample bias of the developers working as contractors (average devs with good enough English). Top LATAM talent moves abroad or works as employees at international companies that pay way more than nearshores.
- CalRobert 4y agoI worked with great LATAM talent, but they weren't contractors, they were at Auth0 (founded by an Argentinian, incidentally).
- ldec 4y agoThere is a lot of top Latam talent who want to stay in Latam because of family and culture issues, and also because earning in US$ while working remote from Latin America can provide a much higher quality of life than you would be able to get in the US.
- mmaia 4y agoYes, that's actually my case. But, getting a salary on par with your skill set may require you to work directly with the employer or a lot of negotiation. I've seen cases of top developers earning almost 50% less than their peers because they were hired via subcontractors.
- fernandotakai 4y agoi consider myself a good developer. when i was working as contractor for us companies, my fees were on par with my US colleagues (low six digits USD). but it was not worth it for me to keep doing it, so i moved to europe (which was also quite easy given my resume).
- moneywoes 4y agoCan you please provide more detail on why? I would’ve figured it would be an amazing situation being in lcol earning a lot
- local_crmdgeon 4y agoAgreed. The skill isn't even an issue - you just hire them for the right roles. Having the same definition of "no" as Americans is huge. Indians have a really tough time saying something isn't going well, or that we shouldn't do a project, for cultural reasons. That's great! Culture is great. For work though, something closer to the culture of the outsourcer makes it a lot easier to deal with. Flights are also so much easier, everyone I know speaks at least SOME Spanish (unlike Hindi/Tamil/Tagalog for the other big destinations) and that helps rough out the edges a LOT. I'd bet on Mexico, hard, right now. Same with BA and Colombia.
- ethbr0 4y ago100%! I've worked with a ton of great Indian folks, but the "no" cultural translation is hard. Just yesterday I was working through an issue, came up with a clear plan that critically involved notifying the customer before making any changes, after they'd been burned by previous uncommunicated changes. Was in the middle of a busy day, so I didn't think and quickly asked if there were any problems or everyone was onboard with the plan: "Yes." 5 minutes later, as I'm typing an email to the customer, I get pinged: "The changes have been implemented. Kindly confirm with the customer they took effect as desired." FML. My fault... but really hard to keep yes/no mapping in my head constantly, at all times.
- peteradio 4y agoI don't understand what your alternative was? How was this your fault?
- jghn 4y agoIf you're aware of the situation you can change the questions you ask and how you probe in to account for the difference in "no" in order to get to the truth. I believe they're saying that due to them being busy they didn't think about it at the time even though they should've known better.
- 4y ago
- theryan 4y agoAt a previous company we had some contractors from Brazil and I was really quite impressed. Super knowledgeable and it was great not having a huge language barrier.
- Jcampuzano2 4y agoAt my current company we started doing hiring in Brazil, and a few in Colombia. In both cases they are in general pretty exceptional devs. I have spent a lot of time in Colombia myself and there is a boom in entrepreneurship and tech in my opinion there (and not just among expats since there are plenty there). I can only assume the same of places like Brazil as well. My last job we also worked with devs from Mexico, and same thing. I have worked with some great Indian colleagues but I would say in general I work a lot easier with devs from Latin America compared to overseas. Though I am a bit biased since I speak Spanish myself at a C1 level. Rarely do I really need to flip to Spanish for anything but it helps to be able to bridge the cultural gap.
- MPlus88 4y ago[dead]
- heyjamesknight 4y agoIt's pretty big now. Uruguay's entire tech labor pool has been consumed by nearshoring agencies. Competition in Argentina and Colombia is catching up. Disagree on skill level. The average US dev is pretty bad. Most of us on HN just have the privilege of working at 1% companies with 1% developers. Those same people exist in LATAM, they're just 1% of the population there too!
- local_crmdgeon 4y agoYes yes yes. This also is why devs in places like India working at body shops like TCS aren't great - MS etc have sucked up all the best talent. Worked with the Office team in ... Bengaluru? Fantastic engineers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- red-iron-pine 4y agoSame. Been seeing a lot of stuff operating out of Mexico City, and to a lesser extent, Greater Baja California for West Coast timezones. Did several projects with Mexican PMs but Chilean or Uruguayan support, esp. out of the Zona America in Uruguay. On top of all of the reasons mentioned, Mexico is also attractive due to the NAFTA TN Visa, which makes it fairly easy to bring a resource across the border. Basically just need a valid job offer, enough experience and qualifications to check the box, and a fairly trivial application fee. No H1B nonsense, and quick turnaround. I'd also disagree with the low skill of LATAM devs, I found they were generally pretty good compared to India or PI. If we had an SAP expert in MX we could feel pretty confident they'd know their stuff, while Tata or Cognizant would scrounge up anyone who could spell SAP and try to convince us they were qualified.
- prepend 4y agoI’ve had two ex-coworkers move to Latin America while working full-time remote. One to Mexico City and one doing digital nomad for a few years in Argentina and Chile. I don’t work directly with them but see their updates on LinkedIn and they claim, and have sustained GitHub activity at least, that they work exactly the same as when they were in the New York suburbs and Miami suburbs. I read Eastern Standard Tribe [0] by Cory Doctorow maybe 10 or 20 years ago and have been looking forward to remote work aligned by time zones for quite a while. [0] https://craphound.com/category/est/ https://craphound.com/category/est/
- nisegami 4y agoI really hope this takes off, it would be a huge deal for my country and me personally.
- chrisjc 4y agoFrom what I see, and what I'm experiencing, it is and has been taking off. For the last few years I've been interacting with members from other teams in Latin America and it's been nothing short of a pleasure. Now in the process of building out my own team with engineers from Latin America. Their abilities, experience, communication and maybe most importantly, attitudes/personalities are fantastic. The downside is competition is heating up. That's my downside, but probably an upside for you :) Which country is yours btw? How is your related infrastructure/economy/etc for tech jobs? Broadband, WFH situation, etc? Doesn't seem to be a problem for my colleagues in Latin America.
- commandlinefan 4y agoAs an American dev who speaks pretty good Spanish, I kind of hope so too. Maybe I'll get a couple of free trips down to south america ;)
- ps_on_brazil 4y agoThis has been happening for quite a while now, I'm in Brazil and most of my career (11 out of 17 years) was built working for companies in the US and eventually Europe. I know many that followed the same path. One thing that I'm surprised is not happening more, and I'd love to hear your comments about the reasons, is the move of senior engineers from places with high cost of living to countries with much lower cost of living, specially for those that are already remote. Another person commented of such move but considering how much more disposable income one would have I'm very surprised this isn't happening much more often. I certainly understand how complicated such a change is, specially if you have spouse and children, but the difference in purchasing power and cost of living is so dramatic that a senior eng making 120k USD per year could easily afford a nice house (mortgage), a decent(bilingual/international) education for the children, healthcare for the family (private that wouldn't bankrupt you) and would still have a considerable amount of disposable income for whatever else they think is relevant (I'm using south of Brazil, where I live, as a reference for that). If you are in such position, have you considered it? If so, what is stopping you right now?
- bluedino 4y agoYou can have the same with that income in the USA assuming you don't live in Seattle or SF. You can live in Indiana or Texas. Brazil doesn't exactly have a great reputation.
- chb 4y agoNeither does Texas
- selimthegrim 4y agoLouisiana is more fun
- danielrpa 4y agoMy wife's family is from Louisiana. I love visiting, the people are very warm and the food is great. But after 3 days I want to go back to Atlanta. Louisiana is a terrible place to live, unfortunately.
- brianbreslin 4y agoFor anyone who has worked with a tech company based in Florida, this has been the norm for 15 years. It started with Buenos Aires/Argentina based devs in early 2000s and then clusters started popping up in Bogota, Mexico City, Santiago, and now in 2nd tier Latam cities too. In mid 2000s there was a big push in universities across LatAm to teach OSS tools. One of my friends had a team of 250 engineers in Guatemala like 10 years ago. There was a brief period 6-7 years ago when Venezuela was in between dictators that they had hints of a blossoming nearshoring industry. Eventually situation got too dangerous and all those that could left to other countries. So these teams can be built, and this is not new.
- NickC25 4y agoI'm in South Florida. All big companies here have a big tech presence in LatAm, especially Argentina & Chile. The last company I worked for had maybe 5 developers tops locally, the rest were based in Argentina. Funny enough my old landlord is not technical at all yet runs a near-shoring dev shop, primarily in Argentina....she charges a pittance in pure USD terms compared with local devs but somehow she's managed to make a very solid living for herself. I also lived in DF (Mexico City) for a little while, the tech scene there is very strong. IIRC, YC has funded a handful of companies based there - I don't blame them as that city is growing, modernizing quickly, and is a fast, direct flight to any major tech hub in the US. Plus the cost of living is low, and the street food is genuinely incredible. Highly recommend it to anyone who wants to dip their toes into LatAm but doesn't want to fly all the way to Santiago, Sao Paolo or Buenos Aires.
- haliskerbas 4y agoHow did she connect her devs with her clients?
- NickC25 4y agoThat, I do not know - I'd have to ask. I'm guessing she acts as an intermediary/agent of sorts, and probably has 1-2 PMs or lead engineers here in the US, so all external calls are with that group, and then the work is partitioned off from there to the team in Argentina.
- Pete-Codes 4y agoI think people underestimate how much people want to hire from their own country for cultural reasons as well as logistics/HR reasons.
- ldec 4y agoHi, Lachlan de Crespigny co-founder of Revelo here (my cofounder is quoted in the article). This is absolutely a trend and I really believe it is a massive benefit for the US and for Latin America - more innovation in the US and more good quality jobs in Latam. Once your team is remote, as long as the developers are technically strong, speak English, and work in your timezone, why do you care at all where the person is based? Do you even know where they are working out of? Culturally Latam devs are pretty similar to US devs, they have proven their technical chops with a bunch of mega-success companies built by Latam devs, and there is less Latin senior executives in the US so it is not as competitive to hire as Asia.
- throwaway1777 4y agoI care where my coworkers are based, but not for business reasons as much other than preferring in person work for some tasks.
- raphar 4y agoIn the last two years hundreds of nearshoring companies have appeared in the region recruiting devs. I am based in Buenos Aires so I can say that the number is really large. What do I have look in such companies to choose it as an employer? What advantage does Revelo offer over the rest? PD: of course I saw Revelo ads.
- bluedino 4y agoMexico missed the boat on this big time. Some schools, infrastructure, some training, and they could have had a huge piece of the call center and body shop work that India ended up with. The USA was already shipping factory jobs over there.
- chrisjc 4y agoI'm not convinced the boat isn't coming, or hasn't already arrived back to port. Lots of great talent in Mexico, and I'm not referring to call center jobs. I'm talking about first class engineers.
- timbit42 4y agoMexico may be behind on remote work but they have the big advantage of being the prime location for manufacturing. Both US and Chinese companies are moving manufacturing to Mexico.
- slackfan 4y agoI actually worked for a firm the staff of which was 99% near-shore contractors. Had some great folks there that I had the pleasure to work with. Can't really say as much great things about the US-based C-level structure, but that's neither here nor there.
- huevosabio 4y agoI can speak for Mexico. We have so much going for it. 1. A robust manufacturing economy (unlike the rest of LATAM) right on the border with the #1 consumer. 2. A culture that is easy to digest for Americans and Europeans alike. 3. People that are welcoming of foreigners, and used to them thanks to decades of tourism. 4. A relatively educated and increasingly educated population. 5. A very comprehensive free trade agreement with the US. 6. A geopolitical environment that is pushing for "Nearshoring" and "Friendshoring". 7. A visa system that allows foreigners to live up to 4 years without paying local taxes as long as they are emplyed elsewehre. 8. A robust tourism economy. 9. A hard working culture. In the last 5-10 years, I've seen big changes in the presence of foreigners that are in Mexico to work. Digital nomads in CDMX or in Puerto Escondido, lots of Japanese execs living in Leon, lots of foreigners buying property in small towns, labor scarcity in the border towns leading to high salaries. Really it's Mexico's time to shine. However, we also happen to have the worst admin to handle these tailwinds. AMLO has been slowly eroding institutions, backing off from free-trade, making dumb investments and canceling obvious infra projects, flirting with the cartels. For manufacturing, AMLO's energy counter-reforms have made access to power the main bottleneck for setting up shop in Mexico, it's just to hard to get a permit from the power company. Safety has been spiraling out of control in the areas where the cartel's dominate, and instead of pushing for the state's monopoly of violence, he has repeatedly appeased them. I wonder what a difference it would have made to have had a more competent man sit on the presidential chair during these times.
- foobarian 4y agoWhat is the situation with cartels? I like the idea of Mexico but tbf I'm terrified of even visiting for tourism because of the shooting/kidnapping stories. For example for the '24 eclipse I'm just sticking to Texas
- gloryjulio 4y agoInterested in this too. Hope op replies
- washywashy 4y agoLots of shark attacks too
- MPlus88 4y ago[dead]
- programmertote 4y agoI have worked with (managed) 6 colleagues from Colombia while I working for a multi-national corporation (one of the big 4 advertising firms). In the same company, I also worked with 12+ coworkers from India. I have to say that I found my colleagues in Colombia just as talented and motivated as the ones in India. In fact, because the coworkers from Colombia are direct hires, I have an easier time managing them as opposed to the coworkers in India, who are from a contract firm. Like others have said here, the timezone difference makes things easier too. I still am in contact with 4 of my ex-coworkers in Colombia because I knew that one day, I might want to have my own business and I would hire them all without hesitation.
- moneywoes 4y agoHow did they direct hire them from Columbia, something like Deel? Curious how they were vetted
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- peruvian 4y agoMy company employs contractors from South America and they are great. I am South American myself (moved to the US when very young) so it's nice having people of my background and language around.
- moneywoes 4y agoAs a dev with 3 yoe in canada ( so not a big market like Seattle or SF) what can I do to tell an employer to use me instead? Communication skills?
- gumballindie 4y agoLower cost perhaps? Canada being cheaper than the us it may be an incentive.
- carlosjobim 4y agoDo you want to be in Canada?
- gumballindie 4y agoA bit like in europe with eastern europe. Fun part is that given the lower taxes and cost of living people there earn more than those in the uk even if pay is lower is 20-30%. Thanks to ir35 and an insane drive to increase taxes that’s becoming more and more common. More expensive than india but also higher quality.
- EMM_386 4y agoI am a lead on a project that uses a 'nearshore' team to augment a very small team of very senior devs. 20+ years each respectively. That decision was made above me, but has turned out well. Code quality is good and the pay should cause concern US developers. This is an enterprise system with an Angular 15 front-end. Just the front-end is complex enough that it requires strong understanding of how to write proper Angular/RxJs reactive code, with a highly dynamic UI, on top of all of the Angular fundamentals. The code is of quality you would expect from an experienced developer, and done on time. I look at some of the salaries for similar front-end work in SV/SF and it is so out of line compared to this I don't know what to say. "High cost of living" can be discussed all day, but then companies can just hire someone who isn't in a high cost of living area who can do the same thing. For a lot less. US software engineering is facing multiple challenges on all fronts. We have a lot of junior developers out of bootcamps who can't find work due to saturation, we have nearshore companies with skilled engineers that cost a fraction of what the US employee would cost, and now we have AI like GTP-4 that is very strong when provided with the right prompts. We'll see how this all turns out.
- carlosjobim 4y agoUS developer salaries are not high because their employers want to be nice, they are high because the employees deliver work that makes/saves much more money than they cost. So in fact there is money to give remote devs in Latin America the same high salaries for the same reasons. If they instead press salaries down, then I guess the solution is for US devs to move to Latin America and reap the increased quality of life. There is really no good reason for the typical young programmer to live in hostile environments like the US or Europe. In the long run the result is that Latin American based business might out-compete North American, since the talent is there and the customers are world-wide.
- 908B64B197 4y ago> Code quality is good and the pay should cause concern US developers. > I look at some of the salaries for similar front-end work in SV/SF and it is so out of line compared to this I don't know what to say. "High cost of living" can be discussed all day, but then companies can just hire someone who isn't in a high cost of living area who can do the same thing. For a lot less. The devs you hired know about this. Now, they have experience at an American company on their resume. Making it easier for them to jump ship to these jobs in the Bay Area.
- rhaway84773 4y agoWhy does anyone think this is replacing employees in Asia, as opposed to replacing employees in the US?
- itsdrewmiller 4y agohttps://archive.ph/1yvX5 https://archive.ph/1yvX5
- heyjamesknight 4y agoWe've hired ~15 engineers in LATAM over the last year and a half, mostly in Argentina and Uruguay. If anyone has any questions about the process, I'm happy to answer them here. Or feel free to email me at the email in my bio.
- zrozinskiy 3y agoWe have been working with Latin American and European developers for years now. We use a recruting/staff augmenation company Mirigos (http://mirigos.com http://mirigos.com) to help us with search and compliance. Has been a much better experience for us than finding local developers. We chose between Europe and LatAm based on the needs as personalities and cultural fit differes.