15 ms·
Google CEO: “can we change the setting of this group to history-off” [pdf]
- qazesxedc 4y ago[flagged]
- tdba 4y agoThen, nine seconds later, Mr. Pichai apparently attempted (unsuccessfully) to delete this incriminating message. lol
- thakoppno 4y agoIt really seems to me that to succeed in business in the US one has to skirt the line of legality with regularity.
- dragonwriter 4y agoAt least, to succeed in substantive illegality, it becomes necessary to skirt and even cross the line of procedural illegality to conceal the substantive illegality. Whether substantive illegality is necessary to succeed in business is another question, but it seems to be a common choice.
- jacquesm 4y ago> Whether substantive illegality is necessary to succeed in business is another question, but it seems to be a common choice. You'd hope not. But there is this proverb that 'at the root of every great fortune lies a great crime' which has been around for long enough that even if it may not be a necessity it may well be strongly correlated.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> to succeed in business in the US one has to skirt the line of legality with regularity This is the conclusion of those with short memories. It’s why we consistently see idiotic insider-trading schemes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sega_sai 4y agoAlso this: "When asked under oath about the attempted deletion of the message, Mr. Pichai had no explanation, testifying “I definitely don’t know” and “I don’t recall.” "
- Dylan16807 4y agoThough if you asked me about deleting a message months ago I probably wouldn't remember it.
- intelVISA 4y ago[flagged]
- jimsimmons 4y agoWould it have been better if they had these conversations in person and never left a breadcrumb trail? Not saying what they did is ethical but why would anyone have an expectation of forthrightness here?
- Mistletoe 4y agoWhen I read things like this I see why Mark Cuban tried to make his CyberDust thing for execs happen.
- gwbas1c 4y ago> Would it have been better if they had these conversations in person Probably because they weren't in the same room? Same building? Same state? Same country? The value of chat is that it's a very lightweight conversation; especially in a distributed team. It's also a good way to start a conversation with someone if they might be concentrating and need a few minutes to put down what they're doing. Either way, I would assume that in-person communication was impractical. (Granted, I can see the need for "history off." Perhaps you need to discuss a personal matter, like an inappropriate advance of another co worker.) > Not saying what they did is ethical but why would anyone have an expectation of forthrightness here? Many people have different values than me. Personally, whenever I communicate through any electronic means I assume that whatever I say might be recorded and used against me. It basically makes it hard to do crime; and I really don't want my employer to do crime; and I am not a criminal or politically persecuted. I think the fact that much of our workplace day-to-day communication is recorded may expose that some people treat these matters different than you and I.
- Ferret7446 4y agoSo who wins exactly if this precedent is set and companies all move back to less efficient but "safer" channels of communication? That would represent a huge loss of productivity and efficiency for society. Because there will always be such channels used in private business. Or is the government going to enforce mandatory private monitoring?
- 4y ago
- sieabahlpark 4y ago[dead]
- natnat 4y agoRegardless of the merits of the case, this is a really funny exploration into how bad Google's chat products are.
- ehPReth 4y agough, yes. Google creates a new type of 'space' (unthreaded/threaded v1/threaded v2) - and... you can't change the space's type. You have to make a new space. They released a 'new threading system' a while ago. So you now have rooms with two types of threading systems and can't 'upgrade' the old ones. So one organization has at least 3 types of spaces depending on when they were made and they can't be changed at all. (Also, you can't switch from unthreaded to threaded or the other way around.) Your only solution is to kick everyone out of the space (can't be made read only) and make a brand new space (losing any history/context/shared files in the space). No one's going to do that so you just live with having all these different room types even if another would work better. Recently, Google rolled out a new 'announce only' setting where only "Space Managers" can post messages. Cool! Let's apply it to an existing space that we are already using for that purpose (company announcements) and prevent other people from... polluting it as they sometimes do. NOPE - you can't! Either "live with it" or create a brand new space with that setting and abandon the existing one. I could maybe see you not changing space types but something as 'simple' as changing who can send messages to a space? Force everyone to leave the old one and make a new one??? Really Google??? Are they just super lazy over there with developing features or what's their major malfunction?
- c7DJTLrn 4y agoPardon my ignorance, but why isn't Pichai allowed to have chat conversations that don't record history? Was there a case against Google already that bans this or something? And couldn't this just be circumvented by having an in-person meeting?
- habitue 4y agoThe complaint details the reason it was not allowed in this case, though would be normally: the topics were subject to legal holds. > Like Mr. Pichai, other key Google employees, including those in leadership roles, routinely opted to move from history-on rooms to history-off Chats to hold sensitive conversations, even though they knew they were subject to legal holds. Indeed, they did so even when discussing topics they knew were covered by the litigation holds in order to avoid leaving a record that could be produced in litigation. As the examples below make clear, Google destroyed innumerable Chats with the intent to deprive Plaintiffs and other litigants of the use of these documents in litigation Note: that's the argument the plaintiff's lawyers are making, not the final word on the matter
- irjustin 4y agoInteresting, is there any documentation about the legal holds details?
- cmilton 4y agohttps://support.google.com/vault/answer/7664657?hl=en https://support.google.com/vault/answer/7664657?hl=en
- irjustin 4y agommm i'm looking for the legal documentation/language that requires google to hold the data for this particular topic. because i'm in agreement with the grandparent comment that why is the topic subject to legal holds vs just having a meeting in person? Are in person meetings rquired to have a voice recorder present? it seems like a weird legal precedent.
- luxuryballs 4y agomeetings better happen in person now, cellphones in the fridge!
- jutrewag 4y ago[flagged]
- pclmulqdq 4y agoNo wonder Google execs wanted us all back in the office really quickly in 2021.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI will admit that I suspect some of the reason does indeed lie in having 'impromptu' conversations, which are helpfully not recorded anywhere. The other two pieces are real estate and 'feeling' of control. I am not sure which one bears more weight.
- hackernewds 4y agoThe largest one is likely monitoring that employees are working 8+ hours a day.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI'm not so sure - there was a lot of talk about "impromptu hallway conversations" and "the magic of bumping into your colleagues in the kitchen." I assume they surveil everyone's computers very heavily, too.
- emiliobumachar 4y agoI don't think it's related. Video calls are, AFAIK, perfectly legal to not record.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI moved from an HFT firm to Google. The attitude difference with respect to document holds was hilarious. At the HFT firm, the attitude was, "we're constantly being sued (by the SEC and others), so we treat all of our records like they're under litigation holds, just in case the SEC claims they wanted them, even the off-topic slack channels." At Google, the attitude was, "we're constantly getting sued, so we treat all of our records as being as ephemeral as possible so we can avoid having a record of what we're doing."
- ip26 4y agoFinance is default not trusted. If documents are missing, fraud is presumed. Tech doesn’t seem to have reached that point just yet.
- 77pt77 4y agoAs can be seen by the Madoff afair.
- JustSomeNobody 4y ago> Tech doesn’t seem to have reached that point just yet. It's on a high speed train heading in that direction now.
- SirAllCaps 4y ago
- xyzzy_plugh 4y agoNone of this is particularly surprising, but it's very amusing to see the litigation go this route. It's incredible common for corporate legal to recommend purging data or communications no longer relevant, or to advise avoiding specific means of communication (like email) due to retention challenges. It's incredibly dumb to explicitly discuss avoiding leading a paper trail with respect to subjects where litigation is imminent or already in progress. The point of these legal policies is generally to avoid unnecessary risk. From a legal perspective it's impossible to control communication completely but advice to reduce the scope or volume of legal holds is almost always reasonable. Legal holds can be really painful, and it's not uncommon for a lot of unrelated communications to become in-scope. This is exciting to see, I hope it triggers real change in corporate culture but I suspect it might simply make it even worse.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoI think worse they were under injunction to retain all communications. They were essentially destroying discoverable material. AFAIK the result is in the court the court can assume the material was damaging to their case and treat it with prejudice.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> None of this is particularly surprising I am not a vengeful type. But people need to be punished to a shocking degree until this is fixed. It should be surprising. And it should have terrible, if not horrific, consequences.
- hackernewds 4y agoI suspect Google will be made an example of, which surprisingly is usually the case.
- stefan_ 4y agoI suspect nothing major will happen because as is typically the case, the judge deciding this is way way too deep into "sunk cost" territory. You can already see that in his previous findings: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23731433-23-03-28-google-play-antitrust-google-chats-fofacol https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23731433-23-03-28-go... "The court has already declined to issue terminating sanctions against Google" "the Court would like to see the state of the evidence at the end of fact discovery" You can see the dilemma in that last statement. There is practically no discovery malpractice large enough to ever have a judge blow up a case, which is why it happens over and over again.
- nightpool 4y agoRelevant, from Matt Levine's Money stuff (regarding SEC recordkeeping rules, which are similar but not quite the same as litigation holds): > We have talked before about the SEC’s probe into how the employees of big banks discussed their work in text messages and chat apps like WhatsApp on their personal cell phones. The SEC has collected big fines from the biggest banks because, it has said, these chats violated the SEC’s recordkeeping requirements. When the SEC fined 15 banks and brokers for this stuff in September, SEC Chair Gary Gensler said: > > Since the 1930s, such recordkeeping has been vital to preserve market integrity. As technology changes, it’s even more important that registrants appropriately conduct their communications about business matters within only official channels, and they must maintain and preserve those communications. > From the perspective of the banks, I have argued, this is a novel expansion of the SEC’s authority. When the SEC created its rules on recordkeeping, it required banks to retain copies of their “inter-office memoranda,” but it was 1948 and those memoranda were produced with carbon paper; they were formal business records memorializing serious policies. In the 2020s, WhatsApp chats are, in large part, substitutes not for formal memoranda but for talking to someone in person. When I was a banker, I have written, “There were some mornings when I sent more than 100 inter-office memoranda, though like 20 of them would be ‘lol’ or ‘fml.’” In 1948, the SEC would not have dreamed of demanding a searchable archive of all of the informal chats held at a brokerage: That was not technologically feasible, and also did not seem to be the point of its rules. In 2022, it was feasible, and the SEC did demand it, and when the brokers were missing some chats they paid a billion dollars in fines. > From the perspective of the SEC, as a fine-maximizing business, this series of investigations is so attractive: > - Every bank has some bankers who did WhatsApp chats, so you can fine all of them, and they all have a lot of money and depend on the SEC’s goodwill, so they’ll pay. > - You don’t have to prove bad intent, or harm: Simply finding some WhatsApp chats about deals, or clients, or market conditions, or anything, is enough to extract a big fine. If the SEC had gotten the personal messages of a bunch of bankers and found them doing a bunch of crimes, it surely would have extracted more fines from them, but as far as I can tell it never found anything like that. The bankers had normal businesslike chats about client meetings or markets or whatever, but the fact that they were on WhatsApp was enough to incur a billion dollars of liability. > - Banks will learn their lesson from these enforcement actions, and the lesson is “keep all communications on official channels and preserve all of them,” which will make it easier for the SEC to catch future misbehavior and fine it comprehensively. > If I worked at a bank I’d be very annoyed by the WhatsApp stuff, but as it is I sort of admire it: It is, for the SEC, a clever bit of business, a bold expansion into a lucrative and growing market, and an investment in making its future business easier. > The SEC clearly agrees, because its WhatsApp Fines Division keeps moving into new markets: > > Major hedge funds have been asked by US regulators to review certain employees’ personal mobile phones as part of a mushrooming probe into Wall Street’s use of unofficial messaging platforms like WhatsApp to conduct business. > > The Securities and Exchange Commission recently asked Steve Cohen’s Point72 Asset Management, Ken Griffin’s Citadel and several other firms to search through the devices for evidence of business dealings on unapproved channels, according to people familiar with the matter who asked not to be identified discussing the private requests. The SEC is also probing the practices of brokerages, money managers and private equity firms. > > Representatives for Point72 and Citadel declined to comment. Neither firm has been accused of wrongdoing. The inquiries are part of a broader request that also went to other hedge funds, the people said. The SEC declined to comment. > > The asset-management industry is quickly emerging as the new front in the SEC’s sweeping look into whether financial professionals are using unofficial communications to do things like cut deals, win clients or make trades. … > The appeal of this investigation is that at every big company there will be people who have texted about business on their personal cell phones, and the right model is to go down the list and hit all the biggest financial businesses up for fines. > It really is wild that the SEC’s official position is now that it is illegal to “use unofficial communications to do things like cut deals, win clients or make trades.” “Conduct their communications about business matters within only official channels”! Imagine if that was really the rule! You can’t have lunch with a client and talk about business, or have beers with your colleagues and gripe about work, because that does not create a searchable archive for the SEC to review. > Of course the SEC does not entirely mean this. Yet. But in like five years, technology — and the SEC’s interpretation of the rules — will have advanced to the point that banks will get fined if their bankers talk about business with clients on the golf course. “You should have been wearing your bank-issued virtual reality headset and recorded the conversation,” the SEC will say, or I guess “you should have played golf in your bank’s official metaverse, which records all golf conversations for compliance review, rather than on a physical golf course.” The golf course is an unofficial channel! No business allowed! When litigation holds were invented, they covered a certain form of formal communication—stuff that was written down, and official, and represented the considered positions of the company; not the emotional and not-yet-sanded down resentment of the rank-and-file. But now so much more casual conversation takes place in a written format then at any other point in time. It is not surprising to me that, if you pored over the thousands and thousands of chat messages from Google employees in areas around pricing, or supplier relations, you'll find some resentment and chafing at the restrictions imposed by Google's compliance lawyers.
- refulgentis 4y agoYou should see the aspiring middle managers, they saw managers doing this, insisted you could never turn on history with them, and then tried 10x’ing by claiming…its wrong to ever attribute a statement to anyone personally in meeting notes lmfao. I’m not kidding.
- sitkack 4y agoLol, https://i.imgur.com/UBO2CoN.png https://i.imgur.com/UBO2CoN.png that is L-13 material.
- mil22 4y agoAt Google in 2006, the SVP of Engineering was presenting to the entire engineering org during an all hands meeting. A question came up as regards retaining emails related to a pending lawsuit. He told everybody: "Do NOT delete any emails. <chuckles>. Let me say that again to make sure everyone has understood me correctly: do NOT delete any emails!" The way it was said, the chuckle, and the way it was repeated with the extra emphasis on NOT, sent a clear message: delete all such emails.
- kentonv 4y agoWhere are you getting this from? Is this from the complaint? Or a personal anecdote? I worked there in 2006. The SVP of Eng was Alan Eustace. He's a jolly guy, he chuckles a lot. I don't remember this specific exchange but I can hear his chuckle in my head. Knowing him, the chuckle would almost certainly be laughing at what an obviously terrible idea it would be to delete the emails. Alan Eustace certainly would not have instructed people, explicitly nor implicitly, to delete messages subject to legal hold.
- angry_octet 4y agoYeah that would be a ridiculous take. He is clearly laughing at the enormous pain that attempts to delete emails would cause.
- DoctorNick 4y agoSure, Jan.
- mil22 4y agoPersonal anecdote, personal interpretation (though shared by colleagues I discussed this with at the time who also heard the tone and phrasing of the words first hand). The SVP would never tell anyone to delete emails, and he did not do so! Did I make that clear? He did NOT do so. He definitely DID NOT want us to DELETE ANY EMAILS! No SVP would have publicly instructed anyone to do so. Unrelatedly, I would not have believed you at the time if you told me that the then CEO had entered into an illegal mutual non-solicit agreement with Apple (and Intel, Adobe, and others), suppressing employee pay by agreeing not to recruit or hire each other's workers. History and a successful class action lawsuit revealed a different story.
- DueDilligence 4y ago[dead]
- tguvot 4y agoIt's even funnier reading than famous McKinsey email: In one internal email sent in July 2018, a McKinsey executive appears to acknowledge the growing legal risk faced by Purdue Pharma over its opioid business. "It probably makes sense to have a quick conversation with the risk committee to see if we should be doing anything other that [sic] eliminating all our documents and emails," McKinsey senior partner Martin Elling wrote in an email sent to another executive at the company. "As things get tougher here someone might turn to us."
- jacquesm 4y ago> "It probably makes sense to have a quick conversation with the risk committee to see if we should be doing anything other that [sic] eliminating all our documents and emails," Gah that is so incredible dumb and the fact that he didn't check himself before hitting 'send' is just perfect. Nothing like a bit of hubris to go with the mindset of a criminal. It makes you wonder what 'anything other' referred to.
- hgsgm 4y agoExplicitly writing down the crimes your peers/bosses are committing (and normalize doing so) is a way to blow the whistle with less hassle.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoEvery company does this. "Face to face meetings" = History off "We are an office culture" = We are an off-the-record culture
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Havoc 4y agoThe tech firms seem to have a very cavalier attitude about this. Only a matter of time before they get aggressive rules & fines around this like the finance firms.
- ilaksh 4y agoThe US can't regulate the monopolies adequately. The east doesn't have the same problem to that degree but in a way their solution is probably worse. Depending on who you ask, much worse. We need a new paradigm for government. It needs to be nuanced, sophisticated, balanced and yet holistic, and integrate well with technology. Or maybe due to the incompetence of current governments, the technology itself with take over.
- kmeisthax 4y agoThe US can regulate monopolies, it just doesn't want to. When the Sherman Antitrust Act was originally passed in the 1890s, the American judicial system systematically refused to apply it to business trusts. They didn't strike them down as unconstitutional, of course - they just argued that, oh no, poor old Congress doesn't know what words mean, they really meant to ban labor unions and not the monopolistic businesses they were trying to combat. This continued through several decades and multiple follow-up bills explicitly prohibiting courts from doing this (they did it anyway). For a few decades this practice stopped; mostly because the monopolists drove the world economy off the Marianas trench and there was a social democrat in the White House willing to do unspeakably authoritarian shit to the courts[0]. Also, WWII happened. This, however, was just a diversion from the mean. In 1980s a bunch of federal judges decided to pull a similar stunt, reinterpreting antitrust law not as a prohibition against economic concentration but merely one against raising prices. The resulting "consumer welfare" standard wound up getting adopted by the executive branch[1] and since then we don't regulate monopolies at all. Because here's the thing: monopolies don't raise prices. They lower them.[2] The east has worse monopoly problems than we currently do. China doesn't have a solution to monopoly, it is the monopoly. Every major Chinese corporation is extremely exploitative of their workers, and has major ties to the government and Chinese Communist Party. Chinese law has a broken welfare system, no internal freedom of movement, and bans labor unions. South Korea is democratically run[3] but the chaebols are so large that they form their own voting blocs. 11% of the country's labor force is employed by Samsung. Japan had similar problems - after Matthew Perry forced open their borders, they saw America's monopolists and, not wanting to be eaten by them, formed their own. The zaibatsu reigned until the end of WWII, where America, having now forced Japan's unconditional surrender at the threat of nuclear annihilation, used their position as Japan's occupiers to hack the companies in question up into little pieces. The solution to monopoly is to destroy the monopoly. No more and no less. It's not a problem of not understanding the new technology. The problem is that monopolists tend to be several steps ahead of you; deposing them requires sustained focus and an economically enfranchised democracy. In the case of the Internet, many very well-meaning and intelligent hacker types were pushing for keeping the Internet unregulated, because they were worried about social conservatives censoring us in the name of the moral panic of the day, or the RIAA censoring us in the name of music still being a saleable commodity. This was co-opted by the monopolists to carve out vast swaths of the Internet for themselves. The EU didn't make this same mistake and actually enforced their antitrust laws on US tech companies. Problem is, they could only really fine Google, not break them up, so for a good decade tech enthusiasts had this idea in their heads that this was just a revenue generating exercise for the EU. The amount of consumer good-will Google and Apple had (and still has), especially in the tech space, was (and is) downright obscene. [0] If that wasn't bad enough for the monopolists, there were a bunch of capital-f Fascists trying to seize power as well. The monopolists considered front-running the Fascists and having Smedley Butler assassinate FDR and crown himself dictator, but fortunately for us he had a change of heart and defected. [1] Thanks, Reagan. [2] When a large portion of goods are made by a handful of companies, those companies have significant negotiating leverage and economies of scale. Competitive free markets are actually more inefficient because you're paying a redundancy and freedom premium. [3] Only after 1987. South Korea used to be run by a military dictatorship.
- n0zmer 4y agoNot sure if it matters, but all chats at Google default to history off (deleted after 24hrs). Turning on history only keeps messages for 30days and you have to do this for every single group chat, private chat, etc. There is no archive or long held messages like Slack.
- CydeWeys 4y agoYes, these settings were chosen specifically to destroy evidence, and the courts are increasingly unhappy with that. All conversations involving people on legal holds (such as the CEO!) should be retained indefinitely.
- kyrra 4y agoIn-person and video/audio/phone conversations do not have the same requirements. What makes text chat that is meant to be ephemeral to be different than an in person chat?
- Spivak 4y agoI'm kinda sympathetic to Google in this case because the law makes it basically impossible to communicate with writing in a way that doesn't leave a paper trail. Messages being at minimum temporarily stored so you can read them is inherent to the medium. It does seem reasonable that there should be some way, (outlined by the courts) to ephemerally text that gives it the same protections as an unrecorded phone call. Because in a world where it's not the 60s and business is done over text instead of phones we lost a lot of privacy with no change in the law itself.
- burniemcburnfce 4y agoWould MicroSoft Teams meetings (including 1:1 private calls between individual employees) be converted from Voice to Text and stored? Could those turn up in FOI's or SEC requests one day, or even just be viewed by higher-ups at the company with access? I'd guess what's said in 1 on 1 calls could be quite sensitive
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DesiLurker 4y agoso much for DO NO EVIL good guys. I distinctly remember conversations with my very down-to-earth & practical tech friends in SV. they all were totally bought into the notion that google can do nothing wrong .. because conscientious engineers & management. I kept telling them all it takes is a few bad quarters & all that goes out the window. of course people looked at me like am a cynic & out of touch.
- scarface74 4y agoI don’t see a problem with this. If they spoke in person in a conference room would all of their conversations be recorded? Are they required to record all phone conversations?
- usr1106 4y agoI don't think their dirty tricks and legal consequences are the main point here. The question is poorly political: Do we want a functioning market economy or not? I take only the mobile phone operating system. We have a high end walled garden segment. By its price point it will always have limited market share. And we have a all-the-rest market segment. Competition between these market segments exists but it is by nature limited to a middle spectrum, some customers that could chose either options. Within those rather fixed segments there is zero competition. (I said I limit my consideration to mobile operating systems, on phone hardware the situation is slightly different.) Zero competition is not market economy, so for me that means that Google's Android business must be regulated in an unprecedented way. Whether they gained their monopoly completely legally or not is just side topic. In practice that would probably mean that the Android business needs to be separated from the rest of the company and run as an utility or a non-profit until serious competition has developed again. I don't have the ready solution. The monopoly is unprecedented in history, so the solution needs to be so, too. I am European, so the situation is even worse. Europe just waits and sees how US politics is busy with nearly losing democracy. A monopoly in the mobile operating system market is not very high on this agenda. So what should Europe do? Create another Airbus? Introduce a heavy mobile operating system tax? I don't have good solutions, but just standing by is worse.
- bjornsing 4y ago> The monopoly is unprecedented in history, so the solution needs to be so, too. What makes you think the Android monopoly is any worse than the Windows monopoly of the 90ties?
- usr1106 4y agoFar fewer PCs in the 1990s than mobile phones today. You could live perfectly without a PC in the 1990s, everything was available using paper, phone or personal service. Yeah, but you have some point.
- DesiLurker 4y agoyou didn't need to pay microsoft a tax to run an application on 'their' devices.
- elango 4y agoAt a famous Investment Bank, the guideline is “imagine what you type or say is a headline in front page of newspaper”
- Lazare 4y agoThis is....amazing. As I understand it: Chats at google by default have 24 hours of chat history. (That is, after 24 hours, the chat history is delelted.) You can opt in to having 30 days of chat history instead. And when under a legal hold, Google continues to delete chats in the 24 hour history mode, but will not delete chats in the 30 day history mode. That is, Google's theory here seems to be that if you have a policy to destroy certain letters and memos 24 hours after receiving or creating them, then you don't need to stop doing that and preserve them even if under a court ordered legal hold. But if your policy is to destroy certain documents 30 days after creating them, then you must stop deleting them and retain them if ordered by a court. Which is....a.....theory! I think it's fine for Google to have a policy to delete chats by default after 24 hours, and...probably fine for some executives to strongly prefer to use the 24 hour history mode by default just in case they get sued sometime in the next 30 days. What I don't understand is what argument exists for why you can delete relevant records after you're under a legal hold. I guess there's a little complexity here in that Google seems to have called (and thought of) these chats as being off the record - that is, they weren't chats with recordings deleted automatically after 24 hours, they were chats that had no recordings and just happened to have chat history that stuck around for 24 hours. From a technical point of view, that's nonsense; the chat history is absolutely a recording, and slapping a label on top saying "off the record" doesn't change that. But eh, maybe it'll be more convincing to the judge.
- rebuilder 4y agoOne thing that comes to mind is that by the time a judge orders a hold, more than 24 hours will have elapsed since any chats that hold applies to. That is, if such a hold only applies to records created before the hold - do these orders apply to future records as well?
- tempestn 4y agoYes, they apply to future records while the hold is in effect.
- Lazare 4y agoThe brief answer is that if you know, or can "reasonably anticipate" legal action, you have to take steps to preserve evidence related to it. So if Google has been sued about, let's say, how they negotiate Revenue Share Agreements (RSAs), then they need to 1) take active steps to ensure any records they have about RSAs are retained, including making sure they aren't caught by any document retention policies and 2) they need to preserve any future records that might be relevant. And they also need to do that if they can "reasonably anticipate" they might be sued, which means (at a minimum) that if someone sends them a formal note telling them that they're planning to sure about RSAs (or whatever) they need to start retaining evidence. If all your communications are either unrecorded or are deleted after 24 hours, then when you get sued (or receive a notice indicating someone is preparing to sue) then: 1) You likely have almost no retained records you need to prevent being deleted. 2) And in fact you can very likely argue that it took you more than 24 hours to implement the legal hold, so actually all your existing recorded conversations will probably end up deleted. 3) But everything going forward will be covered. And since these lawsuits drag on for years, that's likely to be quite a lot of material. Unless you keep deleting most of them, of course. Which doesn't seem like a good plan, but I suppose we'll see how it works for Google.
- siliconc0w 4y agoIronically at google's scale(size and global timezone footprint) the inefficiency this default setting creates likely burns millions every day from work that gets blocked or knowledge that isn't discoverable. Organize the world's information, except if it might make us look bad. This is the pennywise pound foolish leadership that has taken over.
- Paul-Craft 4y agoSeriously. It's hard enough for me to find stuff in my company's Slack instance, never mind if everything auto-deleted after 24 hours or 30 days.
- nielsole 4y agoI have lost maybe a dozen hours of work to Chrome's hard-coded 90 day history limit. Frustrating if you remember this internal tool from a year ago, but can't find it again. I wonder why they chose not to make it configurable.
- quickthrower2 4y agoConversations in real life get deleted after 0s! The trick is to not use chat as documentation. Documentation as documentation is way more useful. The process of creating it is valuable to clear thinking too.
- HPsquared 4y agoIt's such a boost though, to have everything recorded and searchable by default.
- okdood64 4y agoSure, maybe in some ideal world where everyone has unlimited time to write documentation. Sometimes it's just nice just to be like "Oh what exactly did that person say/link a few days ago? Seemed relevant to what I'm working on, let me search the chat history..."
- ggm 4y agoIn many circumstances "Can we talk off the record" is conspiracy (to commit future crime)
- Haga 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gorgoiler 4y agoCan a legal-hold require you to wear a wire 24/7 and record everything you say? Can they require that you do not speak in person to anyone else at your company unless it is by email, and each email is cc’d to Epic Games? Those would be my naive tests for whether a judge can require you to use instant-messaging with permanent history over ephemeral history. Edit: my armchair lawyering doesn’t add nearly as much to this discussion as the other responses here. Deliberately going on record as saying “let’s hook the email printer up to the auto shredder and claim innocence winking-smiley-emoji” when a judge has told you not to is indeed the kind of behaviour of which a court should take a very dim view.
- Groxx 4y agoA wire will also record anything around you that is not necessarily directly related to your actions... so in some potentially-important ways they are significantly different. Though the argument for "I was not aware, being in X group does not mean I follow all messages" is also entirely reasonable, e.g. I'm in several hundred slack channels at work but I only closely follow like a dozen. But yeah, I think "let's go off-record" is almost equivalent to "let's destroy evidence" when you are informed you're being monitored for legal purposes. Innocent until proven guilty is deeply critical, but when you're informed those suspicious actions are doubly suspicious and there must be some kind of room for suspicion or criminals will always be able to avoid conviction.
- masklinn 4y ago> But yeah, I think "let's go off-record" is almost equivalent to "let's destroy evidence" Almost but not quite: the legal system very strictly segregates not creating evidence and destroying existing evidence. You can’t be compelled to create incriminating evidence, but you can absolutely be compelled to maintain and turn it over. Failure to do so is considered confession in and of itself.
- seanhunter 4y agoIt's always really funny/amazing that seemingly smart people think that the legal system can be "hacked" by doing cheap stuff like deleting history. It's going to come out and it's going to look bad. In an actual case that I was involved in, the other party was an ex-lawyer and had a rigorous practise of not keeping records in case something bad was discovered. I on the other hand had (terrifyingly, in retrospect) meticulous notes. I figured if I don't do anything bad my notes will be fine. When it came to the actual case my notes meant our side prevailed on every material question of fact because they had literally nothing to back their theories up with. Some of the notes were a bit embarrassing to be crossexamined about because they were my personal take on meetings and conversations etc[1] but it 100% reinforced my basic idea: act with integrity and don't be afraid of the record. Another widely used "legal lifehack" of this kind is to just add "Attorney Privileged and Confidential" or something similar either to the first line of the email or to the subject and then (optionally) cc a member of legal team, thinking this will prevent the document being found and used in discovery. This won't work. Attorney client privilege covers you providing facts to your legal team sufficient for them to give you some advice and them providing that advice.[2] You can't just tag any communication and think it is magically covered, and not all communications involving a lawyer are covered either. In an actual discovery (at least in the ones I have been involved in) there is a massive document production (including emails but every other kind of document also) and then the lawyers go into a conference to argue about what is and is not privileged. If you mark actually privileged conversations you can speed this process up because they don't need to sift through as much, but if you have marked a bunch of comms privileged that is not, all you are doing is making this process take longer (and thereby increasing your legal bill). Either way, you marking something (or not) doesn't actually affect whether it is privileged (or not). [1] I can say from experience that "Mr Hunter, what do you think it means when it says here this was 'a complete clusterfuck'?" is not a fun question to have to answer to a roomful of lawyers but whatever. [2] https://uk.practicallaw.thomsonreuters.com/7-506-8557?contextData=(sc.Default)&transitionType=Default&firstPage=true https://uk.practicallaw.thomsonreuters.com/7-506-8557?contex...
- rightbyte 4y agoTechnical people often see laws like literal programming rather than a fuzzy social construct.
- andy_ppp 4y agoWouldn’t it just be easier and more effective to run your business in way where you’re not breaking the law? This looks like they are doing illegal things to such a degree that they need very bizarre retention policies and adding lawyers to chats for client attorney privilege. If it’s not possible to run an effective large tech company without illegality then maybe the law is bad? How do Microsoft and Facebook handle things?
- klysm 4y agoThis would indicate that is not best for the shareholders
- matheusmoreira 4y agoIf you don't want people to know what you'rd doing, maybe you shouldn't be doing it, huh?
- jll29 4y ago"Let's go for a walk."
- jzb 4y agoHave… have they never heard of phones?
- naveen99 4y agoThe NSA still has a copy right ? Or is google the real nsa. And obviously the nsa doesn’t keep history on for itself ? How does the nsa leadership pass on history then ? Song and dance ? prayer ?
- mrobins 4y agoA fascinating angle on this is how critical chat has become to modern business communication- to the point that the highest paid execs with the highest paid lawyers use it even when doing so is knowingly flying in the face of danger. As others here have pointed out, conversations not recorded (ie phone, in person, probably Zoom) are not subject to holds. Rather than reduce risk by moving convos offline, they chose to increase risk by creating special mechanisms to flaunt court rules. That seems to indicate a calculus that said ditching chat is either a) impossible to train people to do in the right circumstances or b) too burdensome. It’s interesting that’s the case even at the highest levels.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]