13 ms·
Largest island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island (2007)
- eesmith 4y agoThis 2016 posting is outdated. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recursive_islands_and_lakes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recursive_islands_and_lakes points out: "Until 2020,[15] Vulcan Point was an island that existed in Main Crater Lake on Volcano Island in Lake Taal on Luzon in the Philippines.[16] Main Crater Lake evaporated during the 2020 Taal Volcano eruption,[15] but the water in Taal Lake has returned and has a new island. Vulcan Point became a peninsula" Wikipedia's sole entry for "Islands in lakes on islands in lakes on islands in lakes" is https://geohack.toolforge.org/geohack.php?pagename=Recursive_islands_and_lakes¶ms=62_39_04_N_97_47_14_W_ https://geohack.toolforge.org/geohack.php?pagename=Recursive... , commenting also that "Moose Boulder" - another contention - was found in 2020 to be a hoax.
- xbmcuser 4y agowow no wonder I was curious if it would be visible on google earth https://www.google.com/maps/@14.0091737,120.9958504,179m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@14.0091737,120.9958504,179m/dat...
- sdf4j 4y agoI wonder what GPT-4 replies to that prompt
- 4ggr0 4y ago"The largest island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island is Vulcan Point. It is a small rocky island located within Main Crater Lake, which is on Volcano Island. Volcano Island is situated within Lake Taal, which is on the island of Luzon in the Philippines. Although Vulcan Point is not very large, it holds the distinction of being part of this unique geographical formation." The title it automatically set for the chat is "Islandception: Vulcan Point" EDIT: GPT 3.5 "The largest island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island is known as a recursive or nested island. There are a few examples of such islands in the world, but the most famous one is located in Canada. The island is called Victoria Island and it is located in the Nunavut territory of Canada. The island itself is the eighth largest island in the world and has an area of 217,291 square miles. On Victoria Island, there is a lake called Island Lake, which is approximately 10 miles long and 4 miles wide. Within Island Lake, there is another island known as Mystery Island. Mystery Island is about 0.6 miles long and 0.3 miles wide. On Mystery Island, there is a small lake known as "Unnamed Island Lake". This lake contains another island which is unnamed and not well documented, but is believed to be the largest island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island."
- NeoTar 4y agoSo someone else was listening to the 'No Such Thing as a Fish' podcast this morning.
- ljf 4y agoSimilar HN posts from the past: 2015 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9104777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9104777 2014 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7902628 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7902628 2011 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2317624 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2317624
- igyigyigy 4y agoThis was a recurring set of posts back when Digg was popular too
- ljf 4y agoYeah, I actually thought it had been posted more recently (in the last 5 years) with a bigger discussion thread, but I couldn't find it. Interesting regardless!
- dang 4y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Recursive Islands and Lakes - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30263137 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30263137 - Feb 2022 (1 comment) Recursive Islands and Lakes - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23504158 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23504158 - June 2020 (2 comments) An Island on a Lake on an Island on a Lake on an Island - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9104777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9104777 - Feb 2015 (2 comments) An Island within a Lake on an Island within a Lake on an Island (2011) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7902628 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7902628 - June 2014 (8 comments) Largest island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6154898 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6154898 - Aug 2013 (5 comments) Two islands in a lake on an island in a lake - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2317624 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2317624 - March 2011 (1 comment) Islands in lakes in islands in lakes ... - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1580779 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1580779 - Aug 2010 (56 comments)
- ljf 4y agoCheers dang - thanks for all you do to keep this site great btw.
- leobg 4y agoAlmost as confusing to my brain as SQL JOINs…
- leipert 4y agoMy geography teacher used to say: “On small islands you won’t find rivers. There is a mnemotechnic verse to remember that: ‘On small islands you won’t find rivers’” Don’t know if it is even true. Stuck with me to this day, if I ever meet him again, I will ask about whether small islands can have lakes or not.
- yreg 4y agoMakes sense, right, as you need to have a sufficient area to capture rainwater. Depends on the interpretation of `small` and `river`.
- quickthrower2 4y agoAn island is defined as small if it is strictly smaller than the smallest island with rivers.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> Depends on the interpretation of `small` and `river`. I think it's the other way around. If there are rivers, it's not a small island.
- arketyp 4y agoI interpreted the joke being that a mnemotechnic is like a river, poetry flowing, so you won't find one for knowledge that is already concisely formulated, like a small island.
- quickthrower2 4y agoThats XKCD hover comment level of clever
- eesmith 4y agoSo far the smallest island I've found with something people describe as a "river" is Suðuroy, in the Faroe Islands, at 163.7 km2 (63.2 sq mi). "the great cirques of upland central Suðuroy where the hilltops reach an altitude of 574 m, but overlook and to a degree shelter the summer grazings of Hovsdalur (altitude about 200 m). The whole is drained by the Hovsá, a salmon and trout river. Freshwater is ample here as everywhere in the Faroe Islands, with rivers, count-less streams and an average annual precipitation of 1334 mm (Søgaard, 1996)." - https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10745-005-4746-0.pdf https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10745-005-474... It also has a hydropower plant. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Botnur_power_plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Botnur_power_plant . Is Suðuroy a "small island"? Perhaps! I found a larger island which Wikipedia describes as small. "Rinca, also known as Rincah, Rindja, Rintja and Pintja, is a small island near Komodo and Flores island, East Nusa Tenggara, Indonesia, within the West Manggarai Regency", at 198 km2 (76 sq mi), says https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rinca https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rinca . Anyone know of a smaller island with a river?
- gradstudent 4y ago[flagged]
- ndr 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Island#Differentiation_from_continents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Island#Differentiation_from_co...
- vanni 4y agohttps://www.britannica.com/story/is-australia-an-island https://www.britannica.com/story/is-australia-an-island
- 2muchcoffeeman 4y agoThat’s not and island. That’s an island.
- tokai 4y agoIf that counts Afro-Eurasia is by far the largest island.
- cyborgx7 4y agoBeat me to it.
- yreg 4y agoThe article would benefit from a uniform style of maps and photos. It would be also nice to see the entire outermost island on the maps.
- voytec 4y agoSite's hugged to death. https://web.archive.org/web/20230414083903/https://www.elbruz.org/special-projects/islands-and-lakes/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230414083903/https://www.elbru...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kimburgess 4y agoYou can go another layer deep too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recursive_islands_and_lakes#Islands_in_lakes_on_islands_in_lakes_on_islands_in_lakes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recursive_islands_and_lakes#Is.... It's lake islands all the way down...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- javajosh 4y ago...and all the way up, if you consider Earth as an island in the lake of the solar system, which is of course an island in the galaxy, which is an island in the local group, etc.
- Wowfunhappy 4y ago> if you consider Earth as an island in the lake of the solar system I mean, "if" is doing a lot of work there! Earth is not an island because it's not surrounded by water. Poetically, sure, it's a nice metaphor, but it's only a metaphor.
- Phrenzy 4y agoWell... We are surrounded by water. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M186s319ob8&list=PLa0TgREKn12jUoCK0N4qQVgTgGalS6KDG https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M186s319ob8&list=PLa0TgREKn1...
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoEarth is not sitting in a body of water. Maybe I'm moving goalposts but c'mon now, this is not what people typically mean by an "island"! Similarly, my home is not an island even though the air around it contains water vapor. Nor is my home an island because there are some puddles on the street outside.
- aardvark179 4y agoI miss my GIS days and getting topology bugs from the national land survey of Finland.
- fwlr 4y agoThe article states that Greenland is the largest island. This may conflict with a common belief that Australia is an island; as an Australian, allow me to explain (it’s actually quite interesting!) Australia is a continent, so it cannot be an island by definition, as islands are defined as 1. completely surrounded by water, and 2. smaller than continents. It may seem like a silly technical objection at first, but it’s actually necessary to stipulate that continents cannot be islands, as otherwise the largest island would be the Americas, or perhaps mainland Asia + Africa + Europe. Perhaps the other reason Australia seems like an island (while eg the Americas does not) is that it looks mostly convex on a global map. Unfortunately, we can’t make use of this intuition in a formal way because of the coastline paradox.
- chii 4y ago> Australia is a continent, so it cannot be an island by definition So the reason greenland being an island is due to definition then? Which makes the concept of an island moot, as it's driven via definition, rather than criteria.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"So the reason greenland being an island is due to definition then?" Isn't everything, including criteria?
- iso1631 4y agoThe unambigious definition would be a contiguous landmass surrounded by water at sealevel, which would be in descending order of area Afro-Eurasia * Americas * Antarctica Australia landmass Greenland * This of course depending on how rivers and man-made canals of Suez, Panama, and other canals like Kiel, or ones linking rivers, are treated, there could be arguments that Suez should be included (no locks), but Panama shouldn't be, or all should be, or none should be, or Suez and Panama should be, etc
- seesawtron 4y agoWikipedia entry [0] aruges there is only one "Islands in lakes on islands in lakes on islands in lakes" in Canada but this article points to another one in Philippines. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recursive_islands_and_lakes#Islands_in_lakes_on_islands_in_lakes_on_islands_in_lakes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recursive_islands_and_lakes#Is...
- mkl 4y agoThe article is out of date since a 2020 volcanic eruption in the Philippines changed things. See eesmith's comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35567362 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35567362
- zelphirkalt 4y agoSo bascially ... fractal island, you are saying?
- Trufa 4y agoSomeone from Sweden please help me, there I learned that you can say something like “Ö in å” which means island on a river. (Im sure im butchering it, but I’m not to far away) Maybe you can make this look insane :)
- valvar 4y agoThat is indeed true! The most famous example can be found at the bottom of this page: https://www.alphadictionary.com/fun/tongue-twisters/swedish_tongue_twisters.html https://www.alphadictionary.com/fun/tongue-twisters/swedish_... å: stream ö: island i: in ä: not correct, but used to represent dialectical pronunciation of "är", i.e. "is"
- korla 4y agoFurther: e: dialectal version of "det", i.e. "it" öa, åa: adding an a on the end of a noun is a dialectal way of expressing "the 'ö'" and "the 'å'", respectively.
- kzrdude 4y agoWouldn't "e" just be a contraction of "en" in this sentence? Is it "det" in the dialect?
- CRConrad 4y agoNo, you're right, it's "en": "...en å, och i ån är en ö". "Det" would be totally ungrammatical, dialect or no dialect.
- CRConrad 4y agoBut the 'e' doesn't precede any of the forms 'åa' or 'öa', but only the indeterminate 'å' and 'ö'. The 'e' is definitely 'en', not 'det'.
- CRConrad 4y agoThat seems to be (an expansion of) a little bit from a poem, Dumt fôlk by Gustaf Fröding: https://sv.wikisource.org/wiki/Dumt_f%C3%B4lk https://sv.wikisource.org/wiki/Dumt_f%C3%B4lk. But that only has "...e å, å i åa ä e ö" -- not the bit about "å i öa ä e å" from that tongue-twisters page, which seems to be a later addition. Ungrammatical, too: I'm sure even värmlänningar would say "på öa", not "i öa". (Oh, and "e" is of course a contraction of the indeterminate article "en", a/an.)
- silverfrost 4y agoreturns an empty page for me
- hardlianotion 4y agoLooks like the owner was frightened away
- Forbo 4y agoI'm getting to taken to https://www.elbruz.org/blank.html https://www.elbruz.org/blank.html when trying to visit the link, anyone else? I thought it just didn't like me using a VPN at first, but it does it even without that. Might have gotten the hug of death.
- croisillon 4y agonope, got https://www.elbruz.org/empty.html https://www.elbruz.org/empty.html instead
- Forbo 4y agoNow I'm getting that, too. The fact it changed is even weirder.
- ollemasle 4y agoHere is an archived version of this page: https://web.archive.org/web/20230414083903/https://www.elbruz.org/special-projects/islands-and-lakes/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230414083903/https://www.elbru...
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]
- metanonsense 4y agoThis reminds me of a fun computer science class back in university called "Programming Challenges", which followed the Springer book of the same name. Over two or three weeks, we had to solve one problem every day. That was really fun! Edit: Forgot to mention that the recursive "lake on an island in a lake ..." problem was one of the excercises.
- marktani 4y agohaha it was funny to read your comment. I was wondering where the connection was! Thanks for the edit
- mercwear 4y agoToo early in the morning for this brain twister of a post title!
- keeganjw 4y agoIf the site isn't working for you, try this: https://archive.ph/gDsQA https://archive.ph/gDsQA
- menssen 4y agoI thought this was going to be about "Moose Boulder," whose existence was (rather unconvincingly, I think) "disproven" a couple years ago, and which begs the interesting question about how we define "Largest Lake." https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/moose-boulder-debunked https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/moose-boulder-debunked
- alhirzel 4y agoI thought the same; the alleged Moose Boulder is in my general back yard area and I've thought about doing some "citizen science" on my next trip to Isle Royale.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rbrown 4y agoMy brain hurts
- ryukoposting 4y agoHaving fun imagining how someone would go about researching this. Make a Wikipedia crawler that looks for lists of lakes on each island. For each lake, read its wikipedia article to find each island. Repeat.
- sleight42 4y agoI almost never comment here anymore but, well, here we are. Says something about software people that we find such fascination with recursion. Also, I can't help but reflect on a brilliant quote from Community: "Stop being meta. Stop taking everything we do and shoving it up its own ass." -- Jeff Winger With <3
- ajmurmann 4y ago> Says something about software people that we find such fascination with recursion. Interesting! I would have thought everyone would finds this fascinating. Is that truly not the case?
- biggu 4y agoInteresting that you find that interest interesting
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> Says something about software people that we find such fascination with recursion. Yes, I've always been fascinated by the way software people find fascination with recursion.
- adamgordonbell 4y agoWikipedia seems to say Treasure Island is the world's largest natural island in a lake on an island in a lake. Not sure which source is right? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasure_Island_(Ontario) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasure_Island_(Ontario)
- zapdrive 4y agoBut is the last lake on an island?
- dmix 4y agoThe linked website is outdated (the maps should be a signal) the last Lake in the list doesn't exist anymore > Up until the 2020 eruption of Taal Volcano there was a crater lake on Volcano Island. It was known as Yellow Lake and Main Crater Lake and contained its own small island, Vulcan Point. Vulcan Point was thought to be one of few third-order islands in the world. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taal_Lake?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taal_Lake?wprov=sfti1
- a_cardboard_box 4y agoBut then the page for the crater lake says it came back after a series of typhoons, but it gives no citation for that claim. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taal_Volcano_Main_Crater_Lake#Disappearance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taal_Volcano_Main_Crater_Lake#...
- grumple 4y agoYou can see the lake for yourself on the latest satellite images on google maps.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThey agree. Treasure Island is #7 from the article: #7: Largest island in a lake on an island in a lake Island in Mindemoya Lake on Manitoulin Island in Lake Huron (CAN)
- eimrine 4y agoThe last photo is beautiful, three layers of land and two layers of water is clearly visible.
- LegitShady 4y agoI remember learning about crater lake waaaay back in university geology, because the way the prof started talking about it was always absurd. "Crater Lake is not actually a crater, its a caldera. A caldera is a special type of crater..." "So you're saying its a crater." "It's a caldera." "...which is a type of crater." "Yes but on a test you have to pick caldera from the options."
- mikrl 4y agoLake Huron also has the #1 and #2 longest freshwater beaches in the world (8.7mi and 7mi) , both fairly close to Manitoulin island!
- gmiller123456 4y agoHow are "beaches" defined? Because Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore has a "beach" named 12 mile beach. And, having paddled next to it the whole way, it certainly qualifies as a beach in my mind.
- michael2l 4y agoAnybody else suddenly have the urge to play Civilization?
- ftxbro 4y agois this the 'steve buscemi worked as a firefighter on 9/11' of hacker news
- AlbertCory 4y agoThis reminds me of something I did once here: What country has the highest lowest place? ChatGPT does know the answer to this, which you probably don't unless you've seen this question before.
- darknavi 4y agoI'd think somewhere like Nepal that is up in the mountains.
- AlbertCory 4y agoSo you would think.
- yamtaddle 4y agoWell it's gotta be landlocked, and it'll probably be small. Wikipedia reveals that it's... Lesotho. Sure enough, landlocked and small. I'd never have guessed it, because I didn't realize that part of South Africa was a big mountainous plateau. Nepal evidently has some quite low points, as it's nowhere near the top of the list. Bottoms out at 59m/194ft. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_elevation_extremes_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_elevation_extremes_by_... Sort by minimum elevation, descending. The "Lesotho" page confirms its #1 status for highest-lowest-point. It wins by a large margin.
- robga 4y agoI typed “What country has the highest lowest place?” into chatgpt 4 and 3.5 and both explained Lesotho. Is it not correct?
- EGreg 4y agoCan’t someone go and make more of this manually inside it … and it can be the largest X in Y in X in Y in X hehehe
- cs702 4y agoCool. Is that as far as it goes? Or can someone identify the largest lake on an island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island?
- Aperocky 4y agoThat's going to be some fountain with that layout. Or a weird pool in a resort somewhere, can't be that hard to make.
- cs702 4y agoPool-sized, for sure, but I think we're considering only nature-made lakes, no? Maybe this is as far as it goes.
- teacpde 4y agoThis is where ChatGPT makes it easy > The largest lake on an island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island is said to be "Lake Matano" located on the island of Sulawesi in Indonesia. > Lake Matano is the largest lake in Sulawesi and the ninth deepest lake in the world, with a maximum depth of 590 meters (1,940 feet). The lake is located on the island of Sulawesi, which is itself part of the country of Indonesia. Within the lake, there is an island called "Pulo Mahamba" which has a lake within it called "Lake Towuti". And within Lake Towuti, there is another island called "Una Una" which has a crater lake within it. This crater lake is considered to be the largest lake on an island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island. Also tried the largest island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island? > The largest island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island is not officially documented, and it is unclear if such an island actually exists. > The concept of nested lakes and islands can create a potentially endless chain, but eventually, the size and feasibility of such geographic features become implausible. As such, it is not practical to identify the largest island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island in a lake on an island, as it may not exist. > However, the previously mentioned example of Lake Matano in Sulawesi, Indonesia, is an actual location that fits the criteria of nested lakes and islands. Within the lake, there is an island called "Pulo Mahamba" which has a lake within it called "Lake Towuti". And within Lake Towuti, there is another island called "Una Una" which has a crater lake within it, but there is no known island within that lake.
- SpaceManNabs 4y agoReading this made me happy. Thanks to the maker of this content! There is something beautiful about the next level just being present in your mind.
- nickdothutton 4y agoBut I did eat breakfast yesterday.
- niels_bom 4y agoFunny to see the website of a previous employer here: https://www.mijnlieff.nl https://www.mijnlieff.nl (if you do a whois on elbruz.org you can check it)
- Nevermark 4y agoAnyone know what the largest moon of a moon of planet would be? Around a star around a binary star around a massive star? (Star systems can be embedded. We know of double binaries.) Seriously, it would be interesting for someone to study how deeply nested a system might go, and be plausibly stable, from what we know of solar system formation and dynamics.
- freetime2 4y ago> Anyone know what the largest moon of a moon of planet would be? I had to think about this for a minute. At first thought a moon of a moon didn’t seem to be possible as the gravity of the moon’s planet would certainly make an orbit around a moon unstable. But apparently if the moon is large enough, and separated enough from its planet, it can in theory have a moon. Saturn’s moons Titan and Iapetus, Jupiter’s moon Callisto, and Earth’s Moon would be capable of hosting submoons. [1] No submoons have yet been found, though. [1] https://academic.oup.com/mnrasl/article/483/1/L80/5195537 https://academic.oup.com/mnrasl/article/483/1/L80/5195537
- twawaaay 4y ago> At first thought a moon of a moon didn’t seem to be possible as the gravity of the moon’s planet would certainly make an orbit around a moon unstable. No, that's not true. Moons can have moons with stable orbits. Not every moon can, though. If you think about it, the Moon already orbits Earth which orbits Sun. Our Moon could have satellites but the issue is that it is lumpy. It is not uniform in density and this causes huge gravitational anomalies which prevent long term stable orbits. If Moon was uniform it could have stable orbits.
- louison11 4y agoI wonder how they found those locations. Are people just browsing the entire globe or maybe using GIS queries? Must be fun writing Overpass Queries to find lakes in islands in lakes in islands.
- 11thEarlOfMar 4y agoFacinating and silly and facinating at the same time.
- firecall 4y agoReading the descriptions in the article really made my ADHD brain hurt! My brain gears got jammed up! I had a mild panic attack!
- lapama 4y agoIs the attention received by this post an indicator of some quality issues at HN?