17 ms·
U.S. and China wage war beneath the waves over internet cables
- RedCondor 4y agoI like Jiang Shigong's perspective on all of these "Two Sides" "Cold War" articles: >The reason why I emphasize here that this is a new type of “world empire,” instead of accepting Darwin’s “world-system” designation or the usual “liberal international order” from international political theory, is that the theory of sovereign states obscures the imperial essence of Western hegemony. This “new imperial history” narrative, based on postmodern theory, diminishes the political dimension of imperialism. The framing of “U.S.-China relations” or “U.S.-China competition” that is so commonplace today, premised on the concept of sovereign states, is actually deceptive and misleading. It is deceptive and misleading to portray China and the United States as two equal sovereign states, ignoring the three faces of modern Western imperialism, and the fact that the imperial system of the United States is even more complex than the British Empire’s ever was. The United States operates an imperial arrangement within its continental territory, followed by a second imperial core in the form of the Five Eyes alliance, followed by a system of vassal states in the guise of allies such as the military domination systems of Europe, East Asia, and the Middle East, operates Latin America as a “backyard,” and, of course, it also has control over other supplementary “world-systems” such as the Internet, finance, and trade. Thus, the U.S.-China relationship is better characterized as China, a rising sovereign state, facing the U.S.-dominated world empire or world system. It’s not a question of managing a relationship between two sovereign states, but a question of how China faces the U.S.-dominated world empire. The “U.S.-China decoupling” that has been the focus of public discussion in recent years would be better understood as an effort on the part of the U.S. to expel China from the “world imperial system.” Therefore, the U.S.-China struggle is not only about the fate of the two countries, but also about the future of the world order itself, i.e., is the whole world subservient to the U.S.-dominated world empire, or will it establish truly equal international relations between sovereign states? When the U.S. and Soviet superpowers were trying to build two different types of world empires, the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) that emerged in countries like India and China intended to create a more fair and rational international order. Today’s U.S.-China rivalry represents a struggle over these two world visions and the shared destiny of humanity. https://redsails.org/jiang-on-empire/ https://redsails.org/jiang-on-empire/ edit: Some HN anti-"spam" mechanism is restricting me from replying to people downstream. I'll try to get around to it later. Anyone saying "China also wants an empire" or "Empire is inevitable" is categorically wrong, though, or at the very least has not at all engaged with the essay above. As Jiang Shigong points out, Lenin's imperialism isn't the incorrect and idealist "power thirst expansionism" of liberal theory, which doesn't really explain anything. It's the inevitable outcome of fully developed capitalism. If China continues to be socialist and repress their capitalists, they'll easily be able to inaugurate a new and pluralist peaceful era. It has nothing to do with idealism or with good morals, but rather with optimal economic planning and carving out one's own course. After all, fewer and fewer people in China covet the arrangement that the U.S. built up for itself: >Eurasia Group Foundation finds “28% of Chinese respondents reported an unfavourable view of the US, up from 17% a year earlier, while the number reporting a favourable view fell to 39% from 58%.” https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3126180/chinas-millennials-generation-z-leading-nation-away-hollywood https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3126180/c... >According to Harvard University’s large-scale 2003-2016 study tracking the evolution of public opinion via 32,000 individual respondents, at the time of the study’s conclusion “95.5 percent of respondents were either ‘relatively satisfied’ or ‘highly satisfied’ with Beijing.” https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2020/07/long-term-survey-reveals-chinese-government-satisfaction/ https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2020/07/long-term-sur... >According to data from polling firm Dalia Research cited by Bloomberg News, 84% of Chinese believe “Democracy is important” and 73% agree with the statement “My country is democratic.” For comparison, here are some other countries and their equivalent scores: Brazil (83/51), Japan (60/46), U.S. (73/49), Germany (85/67). https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-06-26/which-nations-are-democracies-some-citizens-might-disagree https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-06-26/which-... As for voices around the world: >Though it came as a shock to Western audiences, who understand China to be a tyrannical state-capitalist authoritarian regime, observers in the imperial periphery have always seen things rather differently. As far back as 2004, Fidel Castro argued that “China has objectively become the most promising hope and the best example for all Third World countries,” [4] and in August 2014, he reaffirmed this sanguine outlook: “Xi Jinping is one of the strongest and most capable revolutionary leaders I have met in my life.” [5] In May 2018, Professor Yanis Varoufakis, former Greek Minister of Finance, assuaged an anxious member of the audience at a Cambridge Forum: “I have to tell you that, from my understanding of China, it’s a very interesting social experiment, in the sense that at the local level or the regional level you now have a boisterous democracy, with popular success stories in overthrowing local authorities, local bureaucrats who have been corrupt.” [6] Later that same year, before his 2019 ouster in a US-backed coup, Evo Morales said “I trust China very much. China has always accompanied us in many of our aspirations in the social, cultural, political and economic spheres” [7] and that “China’s support and aid to Bolivia’s economic and social development never attaches any political conditions.” [8] In 2020 the former Liberian Minister for Public Works W. Gyude Moore bluntly wrote “China has built more infrastructure in Africa in two decades than the West has in centuries, China is also our friend,” [9] and in 2021 Iran signed a 25-year cooperation agreement with China. Despite the vehement insistence of Western punditry, world consensus against China’s “tyranny” fails to materialize. https://redsails.org/china-has-billionaires/ https://redsails.org/china-has-billionaires/ Generally speaking the world doesn't envy America, and those who do envy America tend to go there, creating a distorted idea that everyone would go to America if they could. In reality, America is something that the rest of us have had to deal with without recourse. Its driving principles—capitalism—are not eternal, nor inevitable.
- reb 4y agoI haven't bumped into his work before, this was an interesting read. What do you like about it?
- RedCondor 4y agoI think presenting the situation like "China and the U.S. are fighting beneath the waves" sweeps under the rug how the preceding state of affairs—unchallenged U.S. dominance—was utilized by the U.S. to cut off countries like Cuba from the internet or finance with impunity, and makes it seem like China's challenge to this system is a scary departure from "peaceful normalcy" rather than the slow and difficult return of justice. Just look at this map of undersea water cables to see how embargoes and sanctions designed to torture Cubans have led to silly and wasteful design decisions: https://www.mccormick.northwestern.edu/images/news/2015/10/research-shows-cubas-internet-extremely-poor-h.jpg https://www.mccormick.northwestern.edu/images/news/2015/10/r... (And yes, that single connected spot in Cuba is Guantanamo Bay.)
- celu 4y ago"The slow and difficult return of justice" and the current regime ruling China are not two things most people would ever put together
- beebeepka 4y agoCuba is still taking it for those missiles, after how many decades. The world is not just at all. There is no reciprocy and not all voices are being heard. Thanks for your input. That's all Edit: you got downvoted while I was typing this. The status quo defense force is working overtime these last few days
- yamtaddle 4y agoNobody cares about the missiles anymore, nor the embarrassment of our failed invasion of the island. I mean, hell, we're friendly with Vietnam these days. It's almost entirely due to one of the shitty aspects of how US elections work. Enough Floridian ex-Cubans and their descendants, who got their land and businesses seized, are against warming relations at all, that moving that direction is seen as risky for Presidential hopefuls—which would hardly matter if we had a national popular vote for President, but instead, it's state-by-state and (mostly) winner-take-all at the state level, so that constituency's power is greatly multiplied by their mostly living in one "swing" state with a high elector count. Miami doesn't want us to stop stepping on Cuba's throat, so we keep doing it. Why do we listen to Miami? Because our elections are dumb and bad and we (and Cuba) were unlucky with where Cuban refugees/exiles settled.
- pneumatic1 4y agoBook recommendations on this topic? International internet infrastructure in general, not China/US relations.
- hammock 4y ago"Tubes: A Journey to the Center of the Internet" by Andrew Blum - This book takes readers on a tour of the physical infrastructure that underpins the internet, including the network of undersea cables that connect countries around the world. "The Undersea Network" by Nicole Starosielski - This book explores the history and politics of undersea cables, including the way that they have been used to connect and control different parts of the world. "The Global War for Internet Governance" by Laura DeNardis - This book examines the complex political and legal issues surrounding the governance of the internet, including the role of different countries and organizations in managing the global network. "Dark Territory: The Secret History of Cyber War" by Fred Kaplan - While this book is focused more broadly on the history of cyber war, it includes some fascinating details about the role that undersea cables have played in international conflicts and espionage. "The Big Switch: Rewiring the World, from Edison to Google" by Nicholas Carr - This book explores the history of technological infrastructure, including the development of the telegraph, telephone, and internet, and how these innovations have transformed the way we live and work.
- Herval_freire 4y agoYou can also ask chatGPT for some good recs. I say this here because it looks like this was already done.
- pneumatic1 4y agoYea I was hoping to get recommendations with a 'human who reads Hacker News' filter.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoI wonder how long it's gonna take for advertising to be integrated into ChatGPT.
- eunos 4y agoA recommended reading that explain the situation https://www.patreon.com/posts/unlocked-why-to-44491009 https://www.patreon.com/posts/unlocked-why-to-44491009
- neonate 4y agohttp://web.archive.org/web/20230407141450/https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/us-china-tech-cables/ http://web.archive.org/web/20230407141450/https://www.reuter... https://archive.ph/SsHVp https://archive.ph/SsHVp
- misterprime 4y agoI love this sort of reporting. It's enlightening to learn about the infrastructure that makes our way of life possible. I love learning how these projects are funded and who's funding them, who is implementing the projects, how they are implemented, what some of the concerns are, and the related political drama surrounding these projects. I feel similarly about oil, energy, and food production and delivery. So much goes on without most people even giving it a second thought.
- prox 4y agoMe too. I would love to see a Google earth map where we see all data on this.
- my_usernam3 4y agoMe too! To add to that, whenever I see good visuals of global energy markets, and traders in a room full of screens, I get excited in a way I use to get excited seeing a terminal being used before I knew anything about coding.
- grogenaut 4y agoI still randomly will encounter people who asked what I do and then happened to see terminal on the screen and are like oh wow you're a really technical person. One time it was a stewardess and a court reporter who saw me tailing logs on an application I was debugging. And they're like how can you even tell what's going on when all I was doing was looking for the obvious patterns of java stack traces. Another was a guy sitting at a bar next to me who turned out to be a NFL sports reporter. And same deal I opened up the terminal and he's like oh shit your real smart. As I'm literally just listing a directory and then doing a git status.
- hutzlibu 4y agoThere is a scene in Orwells Homage to Catalonia that reminds me about this: A young italian peasant militia man, stands with open mouth, astonished off his genious officers, who were reading a simple map. So, this is an old trope. Education is important it seems and while I don't think that everyone needs to get along with a terminal, everyone should at least understand what it is. For most people computers are essentially dark magic. And I think this us not doing good to society that has become so dependant on Computers.
- ck2 4y agoImagine an alternate universe where the US built up Mexico and 99% of everything was made there instead of China The only thing holding back China from more aggressive takeovers like Russia is doing the the US is such a massive consumer. But China also could destroy the US without launching a single missile, all they have to do is turn off exports for a month and we'd be killing each other over the last item in stock anywhere that is now 100 times the price because of no availability. Just imagine everything out of stock or 100 times the price, we only have a glimmer of that these days.
- splitstud 4y ago[dead]
- nigerian1981 4y agoAs the largest holder of US foreign debt China could call in that debt.
- timerol 4y agoThat's not how US debt works. It pays back on a schedule. China could stop buying new US debt, and will continue to receive payments on US debt it owns, but China can't call up the US and demand full repayment immediately.
- chihuahua 4y agoThey can call and demand full repayment, but the only response would be laughter.
- bequanna 4y agoThat isn’t how debt works. They could sell the debt that they currently hold, sure. The response would likely be a short term rise in interest rates followed by the Fed simply intervening and purchasing Treasurys.
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoThey can’t because this isn’t make-believe world where there’s some sort of world police enforcing nonsense. If someone tries to destroy your country you just say no. “Sorry china, we aren’t paying lmao” And then they can’t do shit. Then you embargo them for being aggressive and destroy their country.
- jonbaer 4y ago"Chinese scientists have developed a high-speed quantum key distribution (QKD) system to generate secret keys at a rate exceeding 110 Mb/s over a 10 km standard optical fiber, setting a new world record in the field."
- outworlder 4y agoAll this connectivity and yet the country is hampered by the incredibly slow Great Firewall. The filtering is bad enough as it is, but even locations that are supposed to be accessible are hampered by high latency, packet loss and bandwidths that sometimes get to dial-up speeds.
- kccqzy 4y ago> U.S. tech behemoths Google LLC, Meta Platforms Inc and Amazon.com Inc were major investors in at least one, or in Meta’s case both, of those cables, according to public announcements made about the projects. The delays and rerouting of the cables cost each of those companies tens of millions of dollars in lost revenue and additional costs, four sources who worked on the projects said. I wonder if the U.S. government would somehow compensate those American companies for disrupting their business plans. A bit surprised to see Meta here but totally understand the need for ever more cables for Amazon and Google.
- d3vmax 4y agoIt does mention in the article that the threat of sanctions makes the more expensive SubCom offer, cheaper in the long run. No compensation required.
- toast0 4y ago> A bit surprised to see Meta here I worked at WhatsApp until 2019. Without details, Meta has a large global userbase, serves lots of video, and stores a large amount of user data in several datacenters (sometimes with replication across oceans). Being a partner in undersea cables is a good way to get committed international bandwidth at relatively low prices. Meta has lots of cash, and there's a clear ROI, so it's an easy decision. Take a look at peering DB, Meta is at many (most?) major peering points, because it improves their product, and having dedicated backhaul from peering points to the datacenters makes the service from the peering points better too.
- kccqzy 4y agoAn (possibly) apocryphal story at Google is that when Gmail first launched, they figured that email delivery isn't latency-sensitive, so they purposefully set up compute-intensive jobs (like spam analysis) to be cross continent. When it's night time in the U.S. people aren't doing a lot of web searches, so U.S. servers are relatively idle and the entire world's email delivery processing happens in the U.S.; when the U.S. wakes up all those email processing gets done in Europe. My takeaway is that for large companies cost of international bandwidth isn't such a big factor, at least relative to compute.
- misssocrates 4y agoAre we already in a war? Instead of guns, it's being fought with bytes and financial instruments?
- genmud 4y agoYes, but the US didn't realize it was in a war for like 30 years and is just now starting to recognize the reality of the situation.
- flerchin 4y agoCompetition? Yes. War? No. There's no violence, invasion, bombings, etc.
- klibertp 4y agoNo violence? Maybe no deaths, but when you do something shady so that a company loses its contracts and is forced to fire swathes of employees, then that's a competition only if you're another company. If you're a nation state, that's not competition - that's plain aggression that puts people's livelihoods at risk. War? Maybe not, but definitely not a fair competition. It's hilarious how the "free trade" propaganda is collapsing before our eyes, unraveling so quickly despite decades of indoctrination.
- synergy20 4y ago[flagged]
- bushbaba 4y agoUs has a public school crises. Left is fighting an ideological war at expense of stem. Right is fighting a religious war at expense of liberal arts. My only hope is Supreme Court allows parents to take their education dollars and use it to subsidize private school tuition.
- synergy20 4y agothe post is flagged and buried in no time, which is again expected, we as a nation is so screwed up and hopeless.
- angelbreakfree 4y agoWith all due respect, altho it may seem that it was to you, I do not thing it was very relevant.
- Dylan16807 4y agoBecause the post started off inflammatory and stupid. Schools barely mention trans people, but if they did it would take one lesson. And if half a percent or one percent of people are trans that seems like it's worth the time. Also not being distracted by dysphoria should help with learning effectively. There's a lot of talking points that don't come at the expense of real education at all. If you want to discuss real problems let's look at school district funding and curriculums that are overly focused on standardized test results. You don't need to make fun of non-binary people as if that's some kind of wasteful hobby rather than just an attribute.
- genmud 4y agoThat actually can make things significantly worse. Most school districts are chronically underfunded to begin with and many of the federal dollars are the difference between a 30:1 teacher ratio and 60:1 ratio. In many school districts where voucher programs have been implemented, they are facing HARD financial burdens, since they had 10/20/30 year plans based on a certain amount of income from taxes. I am generalizing, but the people who could afford or want to send their kids to non-public schools already have been doing so for years. As more money pours out of public school districts, the more cost cutting has to take place to have a budget that works, which means the quality of education goes down, which accelerates anyone who was on the fence to remove their kids from public schools. The problem with private schools is they are effectively subsidized by all the work from public schools, yet don't contribute in the same way. Think about coursework that is developed with state / local funds, testing standards that are built in these schools and decades of experience administering these programs.
- jmclnx 4y ago>Eavesdropping is a worry too. Spy agencies can readily tap into cables landing on their territory Well if the US and other western countries got fully behind with End to End encryption without backdoors, eavesdropping would be no issue. Instead they are trying to force "backdoors" into encryption people already use.
- amrocha 4y agoEh, even if we use encryption it'll still be a problem in a couple decades thanks to quantum computers
- LightBug1 4y agoLet me see, shall I have a heart attack today? Or in a couple of decades? I'll get back to you (possibly).
- philprx 4y agoYes, it is a problem now because of SNDL: Store Now Decrypt Later programs running around the world. Capture is performed and encrypted data is stored, waiting for quantum computers to be available and cheap to then break in the future what we exchanged securely today. It counts on having the half life of data greater than the average time for quantum computers to arrive. Post quantum cryptography algorithms exist (PQC) and some open source implementations are there. Even for SSH. and NIST has an active crypto challenge on that.
- hanniabu 4y agoThey don't want e2e because they want to spy on US citizens too
- InCityDreams 4y agoI thought they said they wouldn't do that sort of thing?
- deleted 4y ago
- photochemsyn 4y agoThis is an amusing take: > "But the U.S. government, concerned about the potential for Chinese spying on these sensitive communications cables, ran a successful campaign to flip the contract to SubCom through incentives and pressure on consortium members." The U.S. government is equally concerned about losing the ability to spy on cables itself, although the above statement is not false either. Both parties want to collect, filter and mine all the traffic on the global Internet trunks, that's obvious enough. There's always the submarine spy option I suppose: > "(2014, pdf) In 2005 it was reported that the submarine USS Jimmy Carter was being used to transport technicians to the bottom of the ocean to tapfiber-‐optic cables. This would indicate that the NSA continued the practice of mid-ocean cable taps until at least as recently as nine years ago..." That's a risky operation, however, compared to: > "...the easiest and most reliable way is to have the consent of the transit company and split the wires. Given the apparent relationship the NSA has with telecommunications companies and its history of tapping AT&T’s cables, it seems likely that it has gained companies’ consent and access to landing stations or otherwise to install splitters." https://surveille.eui.eu/wp-content/uploads/sites/19/2015/04/SURVEILLE-NSA-paper-based-on-D2.8.pdf https://surveille.eui.eu/wp-content/uploads/sites/19/2015/04...
- pacija 4y agoaes-256-gcm Good luck ;)
- avidiax 4y agoMetadata is still very useful.
- nine_k 4y agoAny channel that really cares about eavesdropping transmits constantly, at the same rate, mixing real encrypted packets and random data to keep the bit rate unchanged. This, of course, eliminates any possibility to share the bandwidth with any other users, so it's more expensive.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y ago
- crispyambulance 4y agoJust a simple question. When they say that these cables are susceptible to "espionage" what does that actually mean? How does one do espionage on an undersea fiberoptic cable? I can imagine not wanting to hand over management of the optical transport link to a Chinese company-- because they could then do anything they want with the signals once the cables enter their own facility. But an undersea cable? What kind of James-Bond-type operation would that require? Is it even possible? Wouldn't the extended outage from such an operation raise flags and be obvious?
- sandworm101 4y agoFiber optic tapping. It ain't easy, but can be done without breaking the connection. Doing it underwater ... That would be James bond stuff. "...the USS Jimmy Carter, a nuclear submarine, was modified to allow tapping undersea communication cables." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiber_tapping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiber_tapping
- crispyambulance 4y agoOK, but that would require a submarine or a very advanced ROV. And then, there's the matter of actually opening up the cable without interrupting the signal. These are not trivial housings. They're not like patch cables in a datacenter. (https://www.reddit.com/r/cableporn/comments/3asakn/cross_section_of_an_undersea_cable/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cableporn/comments/3asakn/cross_sec...).
- imwillofficial 4y agoThis is done with some regularity. See the Jimmy Carter mentioned above.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoSource for that? There is no way of knowing how regularly it's been performed.
- segfaultbuserr 4y agoCompare the narrative of this Reuters article, that the construction of the SeaMeWe-6 submarine cable is a proxy war and cold war between US and China, with the narrative in the Wired article Mother Earth Mother Board (1996) [0] by Sci-Fi writer Neal Stephenson, that the construction of the FLAG submarine cable was the beginning of the new Internet age, which would eliminate national boundaries, end monopolies, bring diversity and create a multi-polar world order... One has to say that the era has really changed, and the utopian dream by digital libertarians is coming to an end. It's hard to imagine that 1996 was almost 30 years ago by now. [0] https://www.wired.com/1996/12/ffglass/ https://www.wired.com/1996/12/ffglass/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrewflnr 4y agoHow worried are we really about surveillance on undersea cables, by China or otherwise? Almost everything over those fibers is already encrypted. Are we worried about metadata? Assuming the hostile power in question already has a bunch of TLS private keys to work with?
- itake 4y agoIf there is a war, whoever owns the cables could control what traffic flows through them. DNS queries are plain text.
- fishsticks89 4y agoAn idea is that nations are storing the encrypted packets now to decrypt them once they have access to a number of sufficiently fast quantum computers (store/harvest now decrypt later). This assumes the data will still be useful in the future.
- aunty_helen 4y agoPreposterous. You would need massive data centers to do that… https://i.stuff.co.nz/business/131661727/government-has-been-secretly-building-a-300m-data-centre-at-an-auckland-air-force-base https://i.stuff.co.nz/business/131661727/government-has-been...
- golem14 4y agoNot just the surveillance. The other fear is that an adversary can just shut out countries at a whim. Of course, it's easier to just change a policy at an endpoint you control, rather than cutting up undersea cables and shooting down satellites. "Oh, a fishing trawler has cut your country's internet access ? Tzz, tzz, tzz, those sub-par american cables ... No worry, you can buy ours that happens to be much sturdier and at the low, low price of whatever you paid before the cable was cut".
- imwillofficial 4y agoThe US fails to see that the more they hold other down for their own benefit, the less others will tolerate it, and the more other countries will push for self sovereignty. When that happens, the whole dollar based global financial system will collapse like a house of cards. The US is over playing their hand, and the results will be disaster.
- nebula8804 4y ago>When that happens, the whole dollar based global financial system will collapse like a house of cards. The common rebuttal to this is what will replace it? Whenever Chinese open up capital controls for their currency people rush to get their money out and into USD/Euro so much so that they have to shut it down again. They also manipulate it like crazy. The currency with the highest trust is the one that stays on top and it appears that the USD is the least worst option for the foreseeable future.
- jags 4y agoHeard it in a video somewhere that it won't be a one big blow that takes down USD, instead, it will be thousand-little-cuts. USD won't be replaced by a single currency instead countries pissed off by US will start using their local currency as and when possible. E.g. India buying oil from Russia in dubai dirhams/rubles. China and Russia doing their trades in yuan amd ruble. Here are few more examples: https://www.google.com/amp/story/s/www.wionews.com/web-stories/world/six-big-economies-that-are-ditching-us-dollar-1680521121418 https://www.google.com/amp/story/s/www.wionews.com/web-stori... I personally feel that USD dollar circulation will go down a lot in not so far away future and the domino effect will be significant on US political and economical dominance.
- refurb 4y agoThat's not so simple and has a significant cost. The reason why USD are used so much is multi-factorial: a) a huge float so massive currency exchanges don't move the price much [unlike say Dubai's currency], b) predictable US government monetary policy [so no sudden changes in value], c) no capital controls so you can move it anywhere in the world easily [unlike China], d) widespread use because of a,b,c. China's entire economy is dependent on undervaluing the currency to goose exports, so they have very strict currency controls otherwise the value would rapidly increase. And what people don't realize is that it's not exactly going to hurt the US if suddenly some other currency becomes more dominant. GBPs, CHFs, SGDs are all strong, stable currencies that aren't a global reserve currency and those countries do just fine.
- probablynish 4y agoI thought the title was worded poorly (shouldn't it be "US and China wage war over internet cables beneath the waves"?) so I clicked through - that missing hyphen really does make a difference. "US and Chine wage war beneath the waves - over internet cables"
- omegaworks 4y ago>the U.S. government believed HMN Tech could insert remote surveillance equipment inside the cable, the official said without providing evidence The US government is absolutely installing remote surveillance equipment inside these cables.
- H8crilA 4y agoGod only knows how many of them are wired for explosion (for example acoustically triggered), or can be wired on a short notice by the Russians: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_research_vessel_Yantar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_research_vessel_Yantar Because sure as hell the Russian klepto-bureaucracy has lost track at this point.
- monocasa 4y agoOr, fiber lines probably get messed with via subs like https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_submarine_Belgorod_(K-329) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_submarine_Belgorod_(... rather than surface ships.
- headsupftw 4y agoWhen you can't compete, call them commie spies.
- ftxbro 4y agoreuters would never clickbait or rattle sabre also reuters: US AND CHINA WAGE WAR ... beneath the waves over internet cables
- fnordpiglet 4y agoI’ve become increasingly convinced as I age it’s not government that’s the problem it’s nations. I hold no I’ll will towards any people on this earth. I hate the fact we’ve Balkanized into these “nations” that pit peoples against peoples arbitrarily. I’m not picking sides here, both sides jockeyed unfairly and in ways that were there no nations wouldn’t matter. The world is too small now, we are too interrelated, and I just wish we could focus on making the world better - science, technology, arts, improving efficiency and sustainability, etc, without all the nation induced BS.
- Reptur 4y agoThe result of all this won't be more isolation for China, it will be more isolation for USA.
- lenkite 4y agoYeah, folks are celebrating here at successfully applied U.S. bullying. Scrolling to see whether anyone expressed concern at super-powers applying extreme pressure and dominance in infrastructure business deals. Crickets. Bet you that the outrage if it is applied successfully the other way will be utterly deafening - 24x7 press coverage, dozens of opinions, etc.
- BartjeD 4y agoI really hate the sensationalist title. There is no violence being used. This isn't a war. This is just more strategic competition. Apart from that its interesting.
- Sugimot0 4y agoAgreed it's totally clickbaity and misleading, especially for reuters. I could see if it said cold war, otherwise I was concerned that something real had happened for a moment.
- eks391 4y agoMost war operations are nonviolent - what you are thinking of is called kinetic warfare. What determins if it is a war or not varies by country policy but can usually be boiled down to whether there are militant operations involved or if a leader has publicly or nonpublicly declared it.
- lazylion2 4y agoThis is why Starlink is a game changer
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- travisporter 4y agoI guess I don’t know what “war” means? Not a single mention of military