10 ms·
Levels of banned CFCs rising
- ryanblakeley 4y ago> The collective annual warming effect of these five chemicals on the planet is equivalent to the emissions produced by a small country like Switzerland. > When CFCs were phased out, hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) were brought in as substitutes. But CFCs can crop up as unintended by-products during HFC manufacture. > The appearance of CFC-13 is much more baffling. “We really have no clue” where the emissions are coming from, Vollmer says. “We don’t know of any chemical process where this will show up as a by-product.”
- hammock 4y ago>The collective annual warming effect of these five chemicals on the planet is equivalent to the emissions produced by a small country like Switzerland. Why is warming effect what matters here? During the original CFC crisis, it was the hole in the ozone layer we were more worried about.
- Robotbeat 4y agoThey both matter, and the ozone hole has started to heal whereas global warming is getting much worse. 40 years ago, the CO2 level was also only 345ppm or so compared to 420ppm today and rising much more rapidly than in the 80s, so overall warming is becoming more acute.
- dashundchen 4y agoBecause it's non-negligible source of warming greenhouse gases that is completely avoidable - we have plenty of substitutes available to us with lower global warming potential. Releasing 1 kg of CFC-13 will trap the same amount of heat as 14,000 kg of CO2. Project Drawdown lists managing refrigerants as one of the top 10 solutions to limit warming in both 1.5 and 2C scenarios. https://www.drawdown.org/solutions/table-of-solutions https://www.drawdown.org/solutions/table-of-solutions https://www.drawdown.org/solutions/refrigerant-management https://www.drawdown.org/solutions/refrigerant-management
- eloff 4y agoYes, but the point is the danger from the warming contribution is less than the danger from an ozone hole, so why focus on the warming? Unless the ozone depletion is below the recovery rate.
- morsch 4y agoThe combined emissions of CFC-13, CFC-112a, CFC-113a, CFC-114a and CFC-115 increased from 1.6 ± 0.2 to 4.2 ± 0.4 ODP-Gg yr-1 (CFC-11-equivalent ozone-depleting potential) between 2010 and 2020. The anticipated impact of these emissions on stratospheric ozone recovery is small. However, ongoing emissions of the five CFCs of focus may negate some of the benefits gained under the Montreal Protocol if they continue to rise. In addition, the climate impact of the emissions of these CFCs needs to be considered, as their 2020 emissions are equivalent to 47 ± 5 TgCO2. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41561-023-01147-w https://www.nature.com/articles/s41561-023-01147-w
- eloff 4y agoThanks, that makes sense now.
- eecc 4y agoGg, Tg? Is that Giga-gram and Tera-gram? Why not kg, the SI standard unit for mass?
- heyoni 4y agoI think it is an SI unit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orders_of_magnitude_(mass) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orders_of_magnitude_(mass)
- wcoenen 4y ago"Teragram" appeared in the original IPCC reports circa 1990, so this has been a thing for at least a gigasecond.
- Turskarama 4y ago
- bluGill 4y agoBoth matter, though warming wasn't considered a big deal, the media was still coming away from warning about a coming ice age (i've never figured out what was going on there, as a kid I heard it more than once, but now few admit the scare existed). The ozone hole was a big deal. Now that CFCs are banned the ozone layer is recovering. I'm guessing these emissions are not really enough to harm the ozone layer much (so long as they don't get worse!), but they add to greenhouse gases that are not in control.
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>as a kid I heard it more than once, but now few admit the scare existed. People very rarely admit to backing the wrong horse that. Nobody will tell you they sold AAPL and MSFT stock in the 90s. Nobody will tell you they believed the racist propaganda back in the 60s. Nobody will tell you they believed Iraq had WMDs in the 00s. Nobody will tell you that they believed the people who were saying Long Island would soon be under ice in the 70s.
- anoonmoose 4y agoWould love to hear what you think about the Ars Technica article linked in another reply to GP, and how it relates to what you and GP said.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoI always figured it was a Y2K style "experts make narrowly scoped statements and journalists blow it out of proportion and make it look like the world is ending" type panic. The article doesn't really look into that side of things other than to say it happened.
- bluGill 4y agoThey didn't address the popular media of the day, only what science was really saying.
- 4y ago
- londons_explore 4y agoPeople have become used to the thin ozone layer. In much of the world, you now can't stay outside all day without getting sunburn. There are not many reports of sunburn from 100 years ago. I haven't managed to find any measurements or even estimates of what UV levels at ground level were before we started making CFC's - it seems we didn't think to measure it! Feel sorry for all the animals and plants for whom suncream isn't an option...
- outworlder 4y ago> People have become used to the thin ozone layer. In much of the world, you now can't stay outside all day without getting sunburn. There are not many reports of sunburn from 100 years ago. So are you saying we evolved skin melanin production from UV radiation for no reason whatsoever? People that live in the desert used to (and still do) cover themselves with clothing just because of fashion standards? Sunburn has been a problem for our species ever since we shed most of our fur.
- londons_explore 4y agoRomans were believed to have a 'pale white' skin. They lived in Rome, and while there are records of sunshades (Velarium), it doesn't seem they were common. For example, the colosseum, a place people might stay many hours, had only 30% coverage. I don't think someone with similar skin would last long in Rome in the sun today...
- outworlder 4y ago> A strong distinction in skin color is frequently seen in the portrayal of men and women in Ancient Rome. Since women in Ancient Rome were traditionally expected to stay inside and out of the sun, they were usually quite pale; whereas men were expected to go outside and work in the sun, so they were usually deeply tanned Those commoners sometimes wore hats (pileus) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_people_in_ancient_Roman_history https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_people_in_ancient_Roman_... There are also descriptions of treatments for sunburn. There's no doubt that the ozone layer depletion increases the amount of UV light that we receive. Sometimes dramatically(very location dependent). But it's not like people could just toast in the sun all day without protection and not get burned.
- briantakita 4y ago[flagged]
- lamontcg 4y ago- Actual glaciers are melting all over the globe and ice is going down. Yearly snowpack in an isolated area doesn't contradict the global trend. - It is called "climate change" not "global warming" because you're dumping more energy into the system, evaporating more water and stronger storms can be one result. - California flipping from drought to massive storms doesn't cancel out, it is evidence of increasing extremes. - Sometimes unpopular opinions are just wrong.
- brianwawok 4y agoWhy can it not be countries that don't care just using CFCs still?
- Clent 4y agoRead the article. It can be a manufacturing by-product. It's likely that there are unknown sources producing it as a product. If it was purposeful that would be trackable.
- Supermancho 4y agoAssuming the global monitoring can track the source (if it was intentional or not), is not based on information from the article. > This is what happened a few years ago, when researchers detected high levels of CFC-11 in the atmosphere2, and traced them to eastern China3. They deduced the source on the basis of readings from monitoring stations in South Korea and Japan, reporting it in May 2019, and afterwards, levels began to fall. Scientists got somewhat lucky with CFC-11: monitoring stations equipped to detect that particular chemical happened to be located relatively close to the source. Maybe we just need to be lucky again?
- jchw 4y agoThe article implies something different: that it was lucky they were so easily able to track the first CFC-11 incidents: > Scientists got somewhat lucky with CFC-11: monitoring stations equipped to detect that particular chemical happened to be located relatively close to the source.
- leereeves 4y ago> Why can it not be countries that don't care just using CFCs still? And somehow manufacturing them without anyone knowing?
- hinkley 4y agoHow well do we understand chemical evolution in landfills? Superfund sites? Maybe nobody is making it and it’s happening anyway.
- varunjain99 4y agoI'm surprised this isn't measured more frequently after the CFC crisis we had back in the day. Also, very puzzling that they have different theories for different CFC's... surprising to have independent trends causing this?
- aclatuts 4y agoMaybe a lot of old equipment that used CFCs are now collectively leaking at the same time?
- rekoil 4y agoYeah that must be it. Very unfortunate.
- dbg31415 4y agoI find that the US is very lenient when it comes to inspecting environmental practices. What is it, most oil rigs get inspected 5% as often as they should? I forget the number, and I'm just quoting some movie... someone will know, but it was a very small number. China shows a blatant disregard for the environment. Russia also seems to have no concern for environmental protection. India may not have the financial means to prioritize environmental protection. It's likely that some places that previously used banned chemicals simply hoarded them or purchased them at a lower price once other countries began enforcing bans. It's not surprising that banned chemicals are still being used, and the same will likely happen with gasoline. As we shift towards electric vehicles, the price of gas will decrease, making it more difficult to move away from petroleum-based products. As a result, anyone still "developing" will inevitably use more petroleum than they did before. It's disheartening to say, but we're in a tough spot when it comes to the environment. I can't really envision any scenario in which short-term greed (even spanning one lifetime) doesn't destroy humanity. And are we even able to transition off petroleum? States like California and Texas already have massive power grid issues.... and that's with sub 5% of the vehicles drawing power. Think a Republican President would have even paused to make sure his pen worked before approving the Willow Project? Pretty hard to go against a state that overwhelmingly wants more jobs. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/12/climate/biden-willow-arctic-drilling-restrictions.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/12/climate/biden-willow-arct... It's a bleak situation.
- pasabagi 4y agoI seem to remember the last time this happened the culprit was discovered to be people stealing CFC-containing waste tars from the factories they worked at, then selling them on for use in bitumen roads. Iirc, CFCs are a unintended byproduct of a lot of industrial organic chemistry that uses chlorine - so there's an unfortunate mismatch of incentives between factories, which wish to reduce costs, politicians that want to reduce costs, and thus regulation and/or regulatory enforcement, and people who don't want a nice new melanoma.
- phendrenad2 4y agoIf it turns out this is happening because all of the EPA employees are working two jobs to keep up with inflation, I'll laugh.