17 ms·
The independent review of costs for nuscale they link is brutal: https://ieefa.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/NuScales-Small-Modular-Reactor_February-2022.pdf
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
The independent review of costs for nuscale they link is brutal:
https://ieefa.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/NuScales-Small-Modular-Reactor_February-2022.pdf https://ieefa.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/NuScales-Small-...
> As currently structured, those project risks will be borne by the buying entities
(participants), not NuScale or Fluor, its lead investor. In other words, potential
participants need to understand that they would be responsible for footing the bill
for construction delays and cost overruns, as well as being bound by the terms of an
expensive, decades-long power purchase contract.
> These compelling risks, coupled with the availability of cheaper and readily
available renewable and storage resources, further weaken the rationale for the
NuScale SMR.
- metalspot 4y agoIEEFA is neither independent nor a serious research organization. The fact that they pretend to be only undermines their credibility. The paper you link to is a joke. They claim a cost of utility scale solar as $17 / MWh and then claim a cost of utility scale solar with battery as $22 / MWh. How much battery backup does that $5 / MWh provide? it doesn't say, but the answer is only a few minutes. Look at the chart of page 28 of planned installations where it shows 22 GW standalone storage being added for 60 GW of solar and wind. That means the standalone storage being installed can provide 20 minutes of backup power for the renewable resources being installed. The cost of a renewable system with battery backup that can guarantee power for even 24 hours would probably be at least 10X the cost of bare solar, so in the neighborhood of $200 / MWh, or quadruple the target cost of NuScale (based on the chart in this paper). Guaranteeing power for 24 hours is not acceptable though. A system like that would have regular blackouts given the normal variability in solar and wind. Unless someone is quoting a price on guaranteed sustained power delivery they are not serious. Try selling your electricity to a data center or any other commercial buyer and see how far you get.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoYou appear to be disagreeing with the numbers they cite from NREL. https://atb.nrel.gov/electricity/2021/utility-scale_pv-plus-battery https://atb.nrel.gov/electricity/2021/utility-scale_pv-plus-... > The utility-scale PV-plus-battery technology represents a DC-coupled system (defined in the figure below), in which one-axis tracking PV and 4-hour lithium-ion battery storage share a single bidirectional inverter. The PV-plus-battery technology is represented as having a 130-MWDC PV array, a 50-MWAC battery (with 4-hour duration), and a shared 100-MWAC inverter. Therefore, the PV component has a DC-to-AC ratio (or inverter loading ratio [ILR]) of 1.3, which is the same as for utility-scale PV in the 2021 ATB. The assumed relative sizing is consistent with existing (but limited) data for online and proposed utility-scale PV-plus-battery systems—whose inverter characteristics (shared vs. separate) are not well known. That very closely matches the ratio in the rollout they provide from the Berkley interconnection queue research. You don't just keep adding batteries, you add more renewable generation at the same time to maximize cost effectiveness. This ratio is sometimes called "near firm" as it provides power when it is needed by the grid.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoWell we'll just include an entire summer worth of storage for nuclear then, shall we? https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/07/climate-events-are-the-leading-cause-of-nuclear-power-outages/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/07/climate-events-are-t... Or alternatively we could acknowledge that using the existing fossil fuel infrastructure for 8000 hours over the next century for the tiny minority of countries without enough hydro even in the unlikely case storage never improves is preferable to using them for 80,000 hours while waiting for nuclear plants to be built. Not even 24 hours of storage is necessary in the vast majority of the world: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z
- adastra22 4y agoHe seems to be complaining that NuScale keeps increasing the energy output of its modules. Am I reading that right?
- idiotsecant 4y agoNuscale is moving the goalposts - they started off with lots of modules with small power output on each and slowly approached few modules with lots of power each. A few more iterations and they will be indistinguishable from a regular nuke plant.
- credit_guy 4y agoYou may be confusing NuScale with someone else. NuScale got an approval for an SMR that produces 50 MW of electricity (see [1], published by NRC in the Federal Register) > The NuScale reactor building is designed to hold up to 12 power modules. Each power module has a rated thermal output of 160 megawatt thermal (MWt) and electrical output of 50 megawatt electric (MWe), yielding a total capacity of 600 MWe for 12 power modules NuScale has also applied for another approval, for a slightly larger design for an SMR that generates 77 MW of electricity. The review in underway [2]. They don't have any other reactor in the pipeline. 77 MW is more than the already approved 50 MW, but it is nowhere near what a full-size nuclear reactor produces. [1] https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/01/19/2023-00729/nuscale-small-modular-reactor-design-certification https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/01/19/2023-00... [2] https://www.nrc.gov/reactors/new-reactors/smr/licensing-activities/pre-application-activities/nuscale-720-sda.html https://www.nrc.gov/reactors/new-reactors/smr/licensing-acti...
- adastra22 4y agoNone of that matters, really, so long as the modular reactor remains small enough to have fully passive protections and no need for large containment structures. That is the real value of small modular reactors. The linked article doesn't say if any of these properties are affected by the change, so I have no way of assessing it.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago
- idiotsecant 4y ago> nuke generation is cheap if you push all the risks for construction cost overruns onto someone else. I am a big fan of nuke as the generation source that is mostly environmentally benign right now today full stop. It's well known, though, that the main problem with nuke is that it's very expensive to build because we're quite worried about the safety so we have a lot of process and regulatory approval built into the design and construction. That extra process and regulatory approval is quite expensive. Of course it's a lot cheaper if you just disregard those things.
- pydry 4y ago> nuke generation is cheap if you push all the risks for construction cost overruns onto someone else. This is what France tried to do with the reactor they built for Finland. There was a budget hole of a few billion and an argument/lawsuit over who would pay for it. Nuclear costs are a hot potato.
- Kuinox 4y agoThe EPR design is bloated because germany wanted to sabotage the project and achieved to increase the cost through additional security no other nuclear plant ever needed.
- Maakuth 4y agoThat's an interesting idea, any source? Certainly the containment building is very heavy construction, supposed to be able to withstand a passenger jet collision. Keep in mind the design was made right after the WTC attacks.
- Kuinox 4y ago> That's an interesting idea, any source? Sadly, I had one months ago but I can't find it again. The EPR have a double containement layer where EPR2 have a single one. The EPR was also an industrial demonstrator. > supposed to be able to withstand a passenger jet collision. Our autorithy of nuclear safety says any regular nuclear plants should be able to whistand an passanger jet collision, but added extra protection on the EPR for it: https://www.francetvinfo.fr/replay-radio/le-vrai-du-faux/segolene-royal-les-centrales-sont-concues-pour-resister-aux-chutes-d-avions_1768265.html https://www.francetvinfo.fr/replay-radio/le-vrai-du-faux/seg... > Even if "they are not built to withstand such a shock without damage, nuclear power plants would offer a good resistance capacity", assures the Nuclear Safety Authority. But no evaluation exists because this type of accident was considered at the time as totally improbable. That said, after the authorities and EDF claim to have made arrangements for the construction of the future Flamanville EPR. "The specific protection against falling aircraft called aircraft hull is a reinforced concrete structure covering the following buildings: the reactor building, two divisions of the safeguard auxiliaries building and the fuel building". The fact remains that zero risk does not exist, as Jacques Repussard, Director General of IRSN, affirmed during his hearing before a parliamentary commission of inquiry last February: "I could not affirm under oath that in the event crash of a very large aircraft, loaded with tens of tons of fuel, the consequences of the fire would be brought under control"
- rektide 4y agoThis doesn't even begin to get into the cost of handling the waste. Which 70 years latter, the US still has seemingly never once found a long term answer to, as far as I am aware. Personally I would really like to see ambitious high tech safe nuclear options be a thing, and to have thoughtful long term handling plans. The Integral Fast Reactor getting canceled (1994) seems a real shame to me. A safe cheap transuranic-burning-capable low-proliferation-concern breeder sodium fast reactor could help us greatly deal with waste, could be gamechanger. But perhaps it was too soon, that it would have only been another mark against ambitious nuclear. GE Hitachi has kept the plans updated & moving along, which is interesting. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_fast_reactor https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_fast_reactor And TerraPower has recently reached out expressing interest in working together towards an IFR inspired design. https://neutronbytes.com/2022/02/03/terrapower-teams-up-with-japanese-fast-reactor-experts/ https://neutronbytes.com/2022/02/03/terrapower-teams-up-with... But given costs as is, focus on being extremely cheap not advanced makes some sense, albeit it sort of also feels like it limits the potential, & keeps us from addressing actual real total costs.
- postingawayonhn 4y ago> Which 70 years latter, the US still has seemingly never once found a long term answer to, as far as I am aware. That's primarily a political issue rather than a technical one.
- rektide 4y agoWhat countries have done the best job at tackling nuclear waste? What power-generating corporations have done the best job at owning their waste? And how many have been able to responsibly do so without it turning into a vast political issue? The US may be fucked & awful here, but I cannot imagine the rest of the world is particularly less fucked or less awful. I'm sure some folks have not gotten quite so tied up in this question, but I also don't have high confidence they have been paranoid & political enough about how properly they ought to be dealing with waste that will live for hundreds of thousand of years. If they have to come deal with really awful problems in 20k years, at enormous expense, well, that factors against the advantage of nuclear power too.
- nine_k 4y agoRenewables are not readily available when the sun goes down and the wind stops blowing. EDIT: the link to the Texas winter crisis of 2021 was here, but it's unrelated.
- doubleg72 4y agoYet the first paragraph states that lack of winter preparedness was the cause and not renewable as initially claimed by some. I'm not sure what your point is here..