16 ms·
Shields Up
- chrismsimpson 4y agoAm currently working on this.
- swader999 4y agoThe power button on my monitor already does this.
- silisili 4y agoIt sounds like this guy just doesn't like people at large anymore. Not really an insult, I feel about the same every time I hear of a new tiktok challenge and such(junk to me). Sadly, we'd need societal change rather than just a mega content blocker to really effect change.
- assimpleaspossi 4y agoParenting comes to mind.
- pixl97 4y agoAfter the pandemic a large number people I know that liked people stopped doing so. It's like we broke society.
- silisili 4y agoYeah, between the pandemic, mask mandates, anti vaxxers, anti maskers, the tp shortage, the election and so called 'insurrection', 2020 was a huge turning point. Everyone found a reason to hate everyone. I'm guilty of this as well. I'm not a big doomer, but I've never witnessed the country so irrevocably divided.
- nigamanth 4y agoCan't this be made though? Just use the same adblock algorithm and then filter clickbait and block it out?
- j5155 4y agoAdblock is easy because ads are usually hosted on a different site to main content. Clickbait, however, is not.
- angarg12 4y agoIt is exhausting. I get bombarded daily by a deluge of hustle culture paraphernalia. Start a side hustle. Monetize your hobbies. FIRE by 30 (I'm too late for that). Build the next big thing. Optimize your life. 10x your productivity. Rather than inspiring, I find this content draining and anxiety-inducing. Instead of materially improving my life, it makes me feel inadequate compared to more successful people. I'm becoming better at blocking and ignoring this content but there is still a long way to go.
- all2 4y agoThis is the kind of thing that makes me want to throw away all my electronics and move to a farm in the middle of middle America and have a farm. The problem is, with property taxes of any kind, you have to have a "day job". :/ I just want a farm, a family, and to be left alone.
- taneq 4y agoYour family’s gonna want things, though. And you’re gonna want things (eg. medical care) for your family.
- reaperducer 4y agoFarmers have things.
- LostLetterbox2 4y agoLooking at supersize me 2 farmers either have an employer, debt, or are a megafarm themselves!
- TylerE 4y agoThe vast majority of farms in the US are now owned by giant conglomerates like ConAgra, not small family farmers, who barely exist anymore.
- 4y ago
- ericskiff 4y agoI've build several little scripts in my browsers over the years to deal with this. As an example, I have a stylus script that cuts the salacious celebrity and entertainment sections off CNN.com. I've also added to my lists in ublock origin to nuke taboola and other bottom of the barrel content ads that used to be hawked from the bottom of every blog. Today I actually just consume a lot less news and media, and much less direct from the news sites. Community aggregation like HN, Lobsters, and a few subreddits lets me stay appraised without being intentionally distracted
- BLKNSLVR 4y ago> Today I actually just consume a lot less news and media This is the norm for me, and I think is likely to be the norm for those who consciously consume news as opposed to zombie consumptification of whatever happens to be on-screen.
- wins32767 4y agoI wonder if this would be a viable use case for a browser plugin that talks to an LLM for the text stuff at least. Have it summarize bits of content and then apply some rules on categories you don't want to see.
- raincole 4y ago> No celebrity gossip. No conspiracy theories. No weight loss breakthroughs. Yes, let a big button to decide what are facts, what are opinions and what are conspiracy theories for us. Exactly what this society needs.
- DaiPlusPlus 4y agoAll of those subjects are just topics: a simple Bayesian classifier can identify those kinds of stories, arbitrating "the truth" (or lack-thereof) doesn't come into this. If empowered with this kind of filter I can assure you that I'd block-out stories about whoever this year's disgraced musician is, or whatever Prince Andrew's getting up to now, regardless of whether they're true or false.
- none_to_remain 4y agoI'm also imagining if this guy already had his tool - "you're taking """Ozempic"""? never heard of it"
- jaqalopes 4y agoIt's not for society, it's for the author's specific needs. On Twitter, you can filter certain keywords you don't want to see. Why not build a tool to do that sort of thing for the entire web?
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoA regular ad blocker already goes a long way by removing the chumboxes. Taboola chumboxes being allowed to bypass Adblock Plus via Acceptable Ads was my main reason for giving up on the Acceptable Ads concept.
- KrugerDunnings 4y agoIn my world this shield blocks the content of this blog
- benatkin 4y agoYou might not like his content, but he seems to be a pretty sincere guy. I've been following him for 15 years now and there was never a time when I didn't think he was trying to be helpful. And he's taken on ambitious projects like the altMBA.
- Waterluvian 4y agoThere are people who like those things. And unfortunately there’s a lot of very bright people who smugly assume those people are lesser-minded for liking those things. Personally I avoid all that stuff. But it’s not objectively junk. Being able to filter the stuff, and to develop your own filter preferences, would be wonderful.
- csours 4y agoYour attention is valuable. Bandits will attack you for it.
- alanbernstein 4y agoThere is an old browser extension called Cloud to Butt, which does nothing but replace the first string with the second. Similar concept, if the "cloud" buzzword is the most annoying thing on the web to you. In 2014 or so, I forked it and expanded the replacement list to include some celebrity names. Turns out that keeping that updated and "complete" was more effort than I wanted to put into it. But, for a while, "President Butt" was a common phrase in my browser, and it still makes me giggle.
- DaiPlusPlus 4y ago"There is no butt, just someone else's computer."
- Groxx 4y agoI made a "[in the] cloud" to "[on the] Moon" extension a while back, and I loved reading about Amazon's Moon Computing cluster, or how X company saved money by moving to the Moon, etc. And it would let me know that tomorrow's weather was going to be partly Moony with a chance of rain. It made me smile so many times. I should revive it - dumb fun is a lot of fun.
- dannyisaphantom 4y ago> tomorrow's weather was going to be partly Moony with a chance of rain It may have been Tumblr rotting my brain all throughout high school and college; but this reads as so incredibly poetic and I'm extremely happy to have made a decision to stumble in this thread to read it. It's so nice to make a silly little app and have it surprise you in the best ways.
- TylerE 4y agoThe weather app I use (Carrot) will say Moony instead of Sunny at night.
- abakker 4y agoI kinda think dumb fun is the _only_ fun.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- the_third_wave 4y agoA Dutch song from the 80's comes to mind, "Doris Day" by "Doe Maar" [1]: Nee! Er zit een knop op je TV Die helpt je zo uit de puree Druk 'em in en ga maar mee De bloemen buiten zetten ...which translates to... No! There's a button on your TV It will soon relieve you of your misery Push it and come along Let's go have fun (literally: put the flowers outside) The song is about someone inviting you to go watch some band in a pub somewhere, saying there is nothing worth watching on the television anyway so why not switch the thing off and come along? There's your junk filter, right there. [click...] +++NO CARRIER+++ [1] https://genius.com/Doe-maar-doris-day-lyrics https://genius.com/Doe-maar-doris-day-lyrics
- a_bonobo 4y agoThe big problem of language models is that we can't assess how truthful their statements are, only how grammatically correct they are. I know people are working on mathematically assessing truthfulness of a statement for the next generation of GPTs. Imagine if we'd have such a formula! We wouldn't need the GPTs, we could instead assess truthfulness in something like an adblocker - if the scanned text block is below a truthfulness cut-off, block it.
- yosito 4y ago> if the scanned text block is below a truthfulness cut-off, block it No way I'm gonna trust a corporate-controlled AI to block "untrue" content, no matter how advanced the technology is.
- vermilingua 4y agoI’m currently reading Neal Stephenson’s Fall; or, Dodge in Hell, and one of the more interesting concepts it describes is of an Editor or Edit Stream, an individual or product that tailors the info you recieve from the noosphere. By the bullshit asymmetry principle, this is probably the logical conclusion of social media.
- farnsworth 4y agoYeah, a sad but probably true aspect of that book was the way that only wealthier people could afford access to reliable information, and everyone else gets their info from the free streams which are full of garbage and lies.
- thundergolfer 4y agoThat's definitely true, not probably true. Current Affairs has a recent-ish article about this fact of media culture[1], but you don't need a long article to understand that poor people who do not pay for information are the product not the customer, and further that poor people have weaker literacy skills. Not a healthy combo. 1. https://www.currentaffairs.org/2020/08/the-truth-is-paywalled-but-the-lies-are-free/ https://www.currentaffairs.org/2020/08/the-truth-is-paywalle...
- sangnoir 4y agoSpoiler for the book follows: Didn't one of the "good guys" intentionally unleash the content-farming/bullshit-generating AI onto the net? I can't remember if it was the protagonist or not, but I couldn't get around to thinking it was a good idea on any world, but here we are with ChatGPT
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoCan you imagine the prices people would pay to optimize ways to get around such blockers? It would simply be another cat-and-mouse arms race.
- credit_guy 4y agoA pretty good application for a GPT bot. It does not even need to be 100% accurate.
- timr 4y ago[flagged]
- judge2020 4y ago> There is no button for bypassing the noise of human civilization and remaining above the fray. But there is. Everyone is driven by risk and reward, you get a pretty good idea of what is true and what isn't if you are able to objectively overlook a person or organization's motives and what they have to gain from saying something and what they might lose if they are fudging the truth. For example: What did the WHO have to gain or lose from taking China at their word on how Covid-19 didn't come from Wuhan early on in the pandemic? Oh, they would've lost the cooperation of the largest country by population, and without them, the WHO basically becomes irrelevant since you lose the ability to coordination disease responses with 1/7th of the world's population.
- timr 4y agoI wasn't talking about the origin of Covid in particular; there are plenty of other examples of "facts" that turned out to not be facts in the past few years. The entire meme of "fake news" is a parasitic mind-worm that didn't exist before 2015 or so. But thank you for illustrating my point, however indirectly: the non-natural origin of Covid was a conspiracy theory, and is now just a politically flavored debate.
- Loocid 4y agoCan you give some of the other examples? The only ones I can think of are COVID related and even then there were also plenty of COVID conspiracies that were "facts" and not facts.
- doublepg23 4y agoA politically charged example would be the Hunter Biden laptop story. Supposedly it was a conspiracy theory too dangerous to even share … when in actuality it was legitimately his laptop. It was an unprecedented use of censorship that failed spectacularly.
- bagels 4y agoThis already exists as a button on most devices, the power button.
- DennisP 4y agoThis seems like something language models could actually do.
- huitzitziltzin 4y agoSubscribe to a major daily newspaper on physical paper??? No pop up ads, no auto play videos, no cookies, no tracking of any kind. Few if any conspiracy theories appear in the major national dailies. Sure you can definitely quibble with the Post, NYT or WSJ on many issues but on average and outside of the editorial pages they are very good.
- ssnistfajen 4y agoMSM still have some of the problem mentioned by the author ("urgent but unimportant breaking news", "insights about the royal family", "things that are true but irrelevant"). NYT is also prone to writing "stories designed to demean, degrade or intentionally inflict distress with little recourse available" since their style differs from WSJ whose news section are written strictly in reverse pyramid style. But yeah, reading MSM news without looking at social media discussions of those news can address at least 80% of the problems described by the author. The information explosion is irreversible and the Internet allowed higher parallelism and lower latency in consuming information compared to TV/Radio/Newspapers. Some degree of exhaustion is inevitable unless one trains themself to properly detach and disconnect on the regular.
- jholman 4y agoOne of my college profs, back in the day, alleged that all the news worth knowing about would eventually show up in, IIRC, the New York Times Book Review. Not necessarily in a timely fashion, but that's kind of the point: slow news. Seems legit.
- oakesm9 4y agoI've found myself enjoying reading the weekly edition of The Economist digitally. Regular enough to be up-to-date, but slow and small enough that it has details about important events that have happened and very little speculation about developing stories. You can get it through PressReader[1] and if you're in the UK it's very likely that your local library card will give you free access to it. [1] https://www.pressreader.com/uk/the-economist-uk https://www.pressreader.com/uk/the-economist-uk
- Extasia785 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jaredwiener 4y agoFor what its worth, I've been building https://www.forth.news https://www.forth.news. It's just news. From journalists. No conspiracies, no misinformation, just news. I'd love to hear thoughts/feedback from the HN group.
- pabs3 4y agoPlease switch to server-side rendering, it gives you a wider audience, since not everyone is running modern browsers.
- jaredwiener 4y agoMost pages should have SSR enabled. The front page is an exception, detecting if youre logged in via localStorage. https://www.forth.news/topstories https://www.forth.news/topstories might be what youre looking for.
- nomdep 4y agoI have two questions: * Who is paying for it and why? Meaning, do you have a business model that can support fact-based reporting? * Is unbiased journalism even possible? How do you avoid the collective biases of the Editorial Team?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoWhy does it have to be a junkblocker button. What if there are existing ways to avoid all the garbage but they are not a junkblocker button.^1 It always seems like people commenting on the obnoxiousness of the web/mobile, often "tech" journalists, here a blogger, demand solutions that maintain the status quo (which is required for them to make money), but require no change in user behaviour, allegedly "fixing" the problem nonetheless. "I want a no burn button for when I deliberately put my hand on a hot stove." 1. I have created these for myself, they work well, and I am not a developer. That suggests solutions are not difficult. IMO, it is only artificial constraints promulgated by web investors and developers that make these problems seem insurmountable.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- paxys 4y ago> Somehow, we survived as a culture for centuries without exposing ourselves to thousands of profit-driven manipulations dumped on our living room carpet all day, every day. Ehh, it takes some thick rose-tinted glasses to actually believe this. Every mainstream social medium – whether TV, radio, newspapers, your USPS mailbox or even a literal town square – has been full of this kind of manipulation since the second it came into existence. There was never a reason to believe that the internet would be any different.
- orbital-decay 4y agoIn other words, the author wants a tool (actually a group of people) to which they can delegate the content filtering. Which is... understandable, as the amount of info noise isn't going to go down. I imagine he's aware of the downsides as well. With the current LLM advancements, a smart filter for the info noise could be built. Sure, it would a bubble just like recommendation systems, but at least it's tweaked by you, and not created by someone else. (in theory, in practice it will be a black box SaaS)
- ghayes 4y agoI am really waiting for the day we can run LLM in the browser, since then you'll be able to perform these tasks without relying on a third-party to send content to. Imagine a smart email client that doesn't rely on your email server for spam filtering or bucketing.
- nine_k 4y agoI think this very site, like a few others, is a cooperative content filter, with some fun / informative / insightful comments added.
- Arrath 4y agoI agree. I also use a few specific threads on other forums where I know the posters generally post decent, informative subjects and otherwise shoot the shit.
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- qainsights 4y agoa chrome extension would be nice to have.
- brucethemoose2 4y agoI would love to train an adversarial engagement AI. So, like, whatever Taboola and such use to pick topics and serve? The inverse of that.
- shrimp_emoji 4y agoThis would name collide with https://www.grc.com/shieldsup https://www.grc.com/shieldsup :p
- 01100011 4y agoI'm guessing this is the first thing all the old farts like me thought of when they saw the headline.
- stephc_int13 4y agoWhat we need is to build more refined and stronger intuition about Epistemology, and maybe also learn to prioritize minding our own business more than distant/unverifiable/likely distorted events.
- jaqalopes 4y agoPart of the solution is certainly better mental habits by information consumers, but it's not fair to expect normal people who are just trying to go about their business to bear all the costs of trying to stoically ignore this mental pollution—and it is pollution. It sucks that the business models of many websites apparently depend on bombarding people with 90% crap that you need to fight through to get to the 10% you want, and we ought to demand a better solution than "just suck it up."
- stephc_int13 4y agoThis is not completely new, we had tons of junk ads in mail and TV. Humans are not too bad at learning to tune out the noise, it takes some time to adapt. I've seen quite a few young people who simply decided to not play the game, they stay out of Tiktok/insta, they read books, they don't care about their phones... At some point I believe that Smartphones are going to not be much more exciting than TVs.
- mistermann 4y ago> and maybe also learn to prioritize minding our own business more than distant/unverifiable/likely distorted events. This has substantial epistemic issues, particularly if you include complex causality (since it is often not possible to accurately derive what "one's business" is, what "is" or is not verifiable in fact, or what is "likely"... All of that is driven by sub-perceptual, culturally conditioned heuristics). Epistemology is extremely counterintuitive.
- yosito 4y agoMy version of "shields up" is that I only get news from Wikipedia's current events portal and HN. I only stay in touch with my friends via group chats and personal blogs/newsletters of which I publish my own on Ghost. Honestly, it works pretty great. I find mainstream social media to be a cesspool of irrelevant junk, so I don't use them. Technically, I have Facebook and Instagram accounts, but I rarely browse anything on either of those apps.
- airstrike 4y agoSame. I do that + the Bloomberg Roku app in the evening for "top news" and WSJ alerts on my phone (which I probably only click on 5% of the time)
- webscout 4y ago[dead]
- physicles 4y agoSame. HN and BBC World News, usually just the headlines. Podcasts for slow/nuanced takes on things. No facebook or instagram or anything. The Wikipedia current events portal looks like a fantastic replacement for BBC World News though: slightly more in-depth content than just headlines. I'll give it a try.
- thehours 4y agoSimilar. 95% HN and text.npr.org. uBlock origin keeps things pretty quiet for any adventures outside those spaces (following links and other things people send me.)
- q-base 4y agoThanks a lot for the "text-only" news site. Do you know any others like that?
- vinc 4y agoSame! I made myself years ago a little web app to fetch Wikipedia Current Events, the top n articles of the day (or the week) on HN, and a few subreddits and that's it. I also progressively stopped using Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. Things are quieter now. When it's not enough I switch to text browsing via rss and gopher/gemini. Wikipedia Current Events is very important to make sure that I'm not cutting myself completely off from the world, and after years of using it it's good enough when complemented with the local news from the people around me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- resource0x 4y agoWhat's good about ChatGPT is that the bloggers like Seth will have hard time finding the audience for their empty, virtue-signalling rants. Anything that might raise a suspicion of being a product of AI will be instinctively filtered out by the users. Maybe this will be the start of a new era in journalism? :-)
- rektide 4y agoPersonally I think 10 years ago I would have found this content to be not that inspiring, feel like it didn't challenge enough. Today I feel like Seth does a reliable job of surfacing a lot of solid essential basic-ish ideas, but equivocating the idea well, and I find the world in dire need of essential basic sense. Seth is a reliable person illuminating the way. Maybe the AI can outproduce him, but as a waymarkerof sense, Seth has been deeply reliable over a long period. Your position that the words matter, that this sense making can be co-opted seems foolish to me. Navigating the context of the world, as Seth does, & highlighting core essentials, is not a task I think we'll see real meaningful output from AI on. It will be a cheap pastiche assemblage with no broader sense, for a long time. A vaguely choosey averaging. I'd counter ask everyone & yourself to ask, what are you signaling?
- resource0x 4y agoHis mention of conspiracy theories triggered me :-) "Conspiracy theory" is a label assigned to anything you disagree with. I really need a button to automatically filter out bloggers complaining about "conspiracy theories". This expression alone betrays a phony.
- operatingthetan 4y agoGodin being one of the original "guerilla marketers" is directly responsible for the signal/noise situation he's crying about.
- draven 4y agoMy thought exactly. Welcome to the world you helped create.
- davidrong 4y ago[flagged]
- davidrong 4y ago[flagged]
- SMAAART 4y agoPersonal AI content filtering.
- tikkun 4y agoThis is now possible. If anyone wants to build this as a freelance project, email me (email in profile), I'll hire you to make it. Some things I'd like with it: 1) Rewrite everything on a webpage in a peaceful and neutral tone 2) Rewrite everything on a webpage to be assertive/direct, instead of passive aggressive (e.g. lots of negative comments could be replaced with simply "I don't like this" or "I want other people to know I dislike this and agree with me") 3) Add emojis inline in text so that pages are easier to skim 4) Add topic based filters/flags/emojis so I can highlight things that I care more and less about All of them would be toggleable, of course.
- sdrinf 4y agoI'm in with $500 for someone to build this.
- localhost 4y agoI did an experiment where I got ChatGPT to rewrite headlines in neutral tone based on the content of the article. Works great. What you want is a great idea!
- RugnirViking 4y agosounds like a fun challenge. I'm a little concerned about the latency though, I imagine it would take 20-30 seconds for most sites
- healthysurf 4y agoI made this project a while back which has some alignment with your goals: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/healthy-surf/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/healthy-surf/ Right now it filters out entire posts on reddit/comments on youtube/sidebar items on Twitter. But I've been meaning to: 1. Expand the sites where it filters, and possibly have it automatically determine which HTML elements to remove instead of me defining it on a per-site basis 2. Make the filter list user-customizable, and change it from static words and phrases to sentiment analysis 3. User-created list of opinions you don't want to read (e.g. any arguments that are anti-nuclear energy/pro-nuclear energy, depending on your perspective). This one is especially important to me because I find contrarian opinions on certain subjects to be both exhausting and boring, and I find myself engaging with them far too often in a "someone is wrong on the internet" sort of way. I see the value of your request, too. Sometimes it makes sense to see what a consensus is on something, but the language used to dissent can be sort of toxic.
- OliverGilan 4y agoWhenever I read articles like this I have a lot of sympathy and also a little confusion. Maybe it's because I DO have an adblocker but this just isn't my experience on the web. It feels so easy to use the web and generally avoid the deluge of shit OP talks about. I pretty much only go to sites on my bookmarks. I don't read the news (maybe that's a big part of this), I read blogs, forums, and then do some shopping. The rest is just work related stuff. The only time I'm ever really exposed to this sort of crap is Twitter but I curate who I follow and I try to stay on my chronological follower-only feed. Yet every time I see my parents using the internet it looks like an entirely different experience. It's unfortunate and sad
- Nick87633 4y agoYeah, just go to any news website or turn off adblock and scroll past your actual content, you get into the swamp real quick.
- Balgair 4y agoOnce, not so long ago, inexplicably, I waded into the fetid swamp that is a new article's comment's section. There was a particularly unhinged commentor, we'll call them Pat, that was railing against the newspaper's staff. For some strange reason, I looked up Pat's past comment history, and it was mostly, though not entirely, all screeds against the paper. The paper is the Denver Post. The Post is a paper thin shell of itself, gutted by the machinations of hedge funds too greedy to realize that sub-prime newspapers are even worse investments than world class ones. The Post even ran a picture of the wrong stadium for Opening Day for a few years, I think. Most of the Post's good staff had left years ago for the 'greener' pastures of purely online journalism. Pat had further filled out their entire profile for commenting and said that they were a proud resident of Des Moines, Iowa. Seeing as they spent nearly all day commenting on the Denver Post, I had questions. So, I made a profile, got a free 30 day subscription and ability to comment, and then asked Pat the questions. Namely, are you a real person, are you really living in Iowa, and why are you spending all your days on this earth railing against a zombie newspaper in it's comments sections? Pat confirmed that they were real, and that they lived in Des Moines. Further, and I'll not forget this, Pat said that the reason they spent all their days attacking the Post was "I just really fucking hate the Post, Rocky Mountain News was better and should come back" Rocky Mountain news had been truly dead for a decade at this point and was never coming back. I could ask them more questions, and try to dive into their strange psychology, but lets be real, Pat is crazy. I have since returned to my policy of never reading the comments section. Thar be the weirdos.
- hombre_fatal 4y agoSeems like someone wanting to have their cake and eat it too. Most of us have vices like Twitter and Reddit and TikTok and even HN, yet we do everything but quit them when we decide that the juice isn't worth the squeeze. In this case, instead of deciding on better ways to spend his attention, he imagines an increasingly complex technological solution so that he doesn't have to change his habits.
- selfhoster11 4y ago> In this case, instead of deciding on better ways to spend his attention, he imagines an increasingly complex technological solution so that he doesn't have to change his habits. What's wrong with that, exactly? Technology should serve us, not the other way round. Nothing wrong with a technological solution, if it works.
- mdasen 4y agoI think the big issue is that it's hard to determine what falls into that category sometimes. We live in an era where any editorial decision is treated as "cancelling" someone. Even if you get it right 99.9% of the time, the Streisand Effect will catapult the rare mistakes to the forefront and erode any trust in your decisions. One person's Ponzi-scheme or MLM is another person's crypto-revolution democratizing finance. One person's pump-and-dump is another person's GameStop. One person's irrelevant information is another's call to action. I think a lot of people also aren't receptive to being told that they're wrong. Lots of people are posting about tech companies doing layoffs while having record profits, but then when I actually look at the profits, they're actually down. Is that misinformation? If I'm running a system (either a site where people post or a browser plugin that removes content), I would get roasted for taking that down. If I took down things meant to demean, degrade, or intentionally cause distress, I'd be taking down a lot of Republican content. They'd yell that they aren't demeaning a trans woman by calling her a man and that they're just stating a fact. Which one of us is correct in our judgment? All that said, I do think there's a ton of value in Seth's idea and his presentation of it. I think he really hits on something important when he talks about things that might be true, but are irrelevant and things that are really just mean. I'd also add that there's a certain kind of post/article that's just meant to produce a visceral emotional reaction (usually anger) without anything really actionable or meaningful - I think that's what he's getting at in other terms. I think there's a lot of value in trying to get that junk out of one's life, but it's hard. It's also hard for platforms who live and die by engagement. It's not just about the ad views. It's also about being the app/website that people instinctively open constantly. If you widdle down the content to the calm stuff, do you end up as an app that people forget about because the visceral emotional reactions aren't making them think about opening the app again? If they open it and there isn't new stuff, do they go somewhere else to fix their boredom? All that controversy drives more content. Crazy tweets from Musk lead to lots of people who dislike Musk to quote-tweet him dunking on him. All those dunks drive engagement. A right wing person can say something and that will get so many people agreeing and disagreeing and fighting on a platform. All that irrelevant stuff like celebrity gossip offers a constant stream of easy to consume bits for people. A good article requires thought, patience, attention, etc. A celebrity gossip pic works well for mindless doom-scrolling. If a platform doesn't offer that, does it just become too small and end up losing the traffic to competitors who then have a war chest to fight off the "good" platform? To an extent, HN is a counter example. At the same time, would HN have survived if it weren't a bit of a passion project of YC? Competitors aren't looking to "kill" HN because it's clear HN isn't really looking to expand and become a big business. Likewise, HN doesn't have management looking to figure out how to maximize profitability or what the next big thing will be. It might be harder for more commercial platforms where they might start losing engineering talent to competitors whose engagement engines print money which they can use to lure engineers. We've seen many articles talking about tech giants hiring lots of people in part to prevent other companies from having talent. I think there's lots of value in Seth's proposal. At the same time, I think it's tough.
- throwaway675309 4y agoAdd any video where the title includes superlatives or the word "react" and I'm sold.
- jaza 4y agoI feel like I've got a pretty robust filter built in to my brain. I've never felt the need for ad blockers, my ignoring of (Google, Facebook, YouTube, in-site, TV, radio, etc) ads is so instinctive, it's like I literally don't see or hear them. Same with (mainstream, social, etc) media content, my ignoring of various categories of "news" (sport, celeb gossip, beauty, lifestyle, real estate) is so instinctive, it's just a blurry spot on the screen / page for me. I suppose that some people have this ability more than others, but then again, I imagine that almost anyone should be able to up their ability to a somewhat useful level, with a bit of practice. In my opinion, the above, plus being reasonably selective about your main news sources, will always beat any hypothetical AI, in terms of achieving a signal-to-noise ratio that's optimum for you, as an educated, informed, and reasoning human.
- unrealp 4y agoI think there is also a hidden cost of this, which is, the filtering that the brain needs to do prevents you from seeing other opportunities. We have X amount of time and attention and these things fill that up. For example, when it comes to improving personality/body language, there are lot of tools in theater/acting that can be useful. Mainstream media never talks about these opportunities. I came to know about these very late, accidentally.
- ssnistfajen 4y agoYellow journalism has existed for longer than a century. In industrialised societies this hasn't been exactly a new phenomenon.
- none_to_remain 4y agoI don't so much want this for myself past adblock, but I want others to have it so fewer feel the urge to censor what I see
- thewebcount 4y agoI subscribed to AppleNews for a while because I thought, I’ll get some news without being on something like Facebook, and I can like/dislike things for signal and avoid all the celebrity crap. And the thing is, it mostly worked, but not quite enough. For example, I found that downvoting every article on a topic wasn’t enough to give it the signal, “stop fucking showing me this topic.” (And this was true even when there were literally hundreds of articles on the same topic. I had to do this with Elon Musk-related news around the time he bought Twitter.) Then I learned you could block entire topics. That helped, except when it didn’t. Despite having downvoted hundreds of articles on a topic, and then actively blocking the topic, sometimes it would just show me news articles about the specific thing I asked it not to. At this point I’ve lost any hope of finding a solution to getting the news I want without a ton of extra crap. I have ad blockers, but the news sites are so shitty to use. I wanted AppleNews to work, but there are too many ads and it doesn’t actually show you just the stuff you want. It’s constantly trying to push other stuff at you, the very thing I was paying to avoid. I give up. I’ve just stopped reading news altogether. This is what the industry has come to. It no longer contains enough value to even deal with.
- euroderf 4y agoI for one miss the World Weekly News. At one level, it was pure entertainment. But of course at another level, the choice of themes reflected the communal Id.
- mmahemoff 4y agoMy media habits are configured to mostly avoid this junk, but I think I also have developed a "junk blindness" similar to the "ad blindness" filters that cause people to not even look properly at blatant ads. If you visualised brain activity as someone views a feed of recommendations, you'd probably see a lot of that nonsense content is skimmed over autonomously by folks who aren't interested in it.
- Guthur 4y agoThis filter already exists, don't turn on the computer, don't talk to anyone, lock yourself in a dark sound proof room. I'm not even being all that facetious. Every interaction, every book, every news article is full of covering of the truth in some fashion or other. We carry the baggage of millennia coverings of what humanity actually is, so how could you hope to see past that to the truth of it.
- langsoul-com 4y agoMy shields up is blocking all up votes/karma/YouTube view count with unlock origin cosmetic filter. Seeing YouTube views just makes me judge the content based on its popularity, rather than the content itself. Same with sub count.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoI have a feeling GPT will be used for that soon. And I will certainly pay for it.
- gjpolly 4y agoYou know who really wants that button Seth? Nobody. People seek entertainment, people seek hope, people seek emotion, not just facts. Reality is hard for a lot of people at the moment, and mindless stuff can be a reprieve.
- selfhoster11 4y agoI want that button. Mostly so I can get my brain back and put it to use, without slaving it to the attention machine. If I want to watch mindless entertainment, I wish to be the one to engage with it first.
- Havoc 4y agoThat’s the allure of rss
- prohobo 4y agoTry Digital Minimalism: https://www.amazon.com/Digital-Minimalism-Choosing-Focused-Noisy/dp/0525536515 https://www.amazon.com/Digital-Minimalism-Choosing-Focused-N... There are people spending billions of dollars to get your attention. You can't win this game on their terms. Treat the internet as the dangerous medium it is, and protect yourself.
- DeathArrow 4y ago> What I want is a junkblocker. Maybe a browser extension powered by AI? Or we can just crowdsource filters for uBlock Origin to block the junk.
- gnramires 4y agoI agree with him, but here's what you can personally do: use more healthy online services! Like Mastodon (and other ActivityPub or FOSS nets), well moderated spaces (e.g. /r/askhistorians), etc.. Social networks that don't value your time, your mental health, your growth and wellbeing should not be successful! It's clear by now we need some kind of collective action against socially and individually bad services like addictive games and social networks. I'm not sure if that's just information campaign or even improving incentive structures to help prioritize user wellbeing along with profit for companies. Why don't shareholder track the social good a given company is doing? And the environmental good as well?
- bovermyer 4y agoRelated, and perhaps relevant: lately I've noticed that a lot of my life is consumptive filler. Reddit's the worst source, but that's not really Reddit's fault. I want more information, more stimulation, as a fix to sitting here bored. What I _could_ be doing, like finally finishing the top half to that hutch in my garage, or working on the manuscript for a book I'm writing, often falls by the wayside because I just couldn't find the energy to change course. But those things would be much more fulfilling than doomscrolling r/all. I _know_ this. The trick is in figuring out how to overcome inertia.
- batch12 4y agoSometimes, when I encounter this, I use one as a reward for the other. Then I don't feel guilty for the pointless action because I did something productive first. The hard part for me is the gnawing desire to create something. That's when I get stuck and only come free once I have done enough work to scratch that itch.
- hobs 4y agoCold turkey is the only option that works as far as I can tell. The first few days are hard, but soon you wont miss it.
- SauciestGNU 4y agoI'm a dillitente in many disciplines and as such there's always something I can work on. Although I find myself falling into the consumptive pattern more than I'd like, I strive to learn new things and skills. For instance, lately I've been learning blender and building a model of a location I have frequent dreams/nightmares about. Art and nature are my go-to activities. Hiking, biking, playing music, and doodling in blender are all pretty rewarding.
- RugnirViking 4y agoI can second learning to 3d model for personal fulfillment. It ended up being way more useful than I expected, ive ended up using it for 3d printing which I didnt even think about when I started learning, but now I have things on my desk that I made
- ParetoOptimal 4y agoReplacing "checking for updates" with RSS can help this as well. Even moreso if you can get used to a brutalist rss reader like elfeed or gnus in emacs (I'm sure these exist outside of emacs if that's a requirement). gnus even lets you use scoring to essentialy make your own recommendation algorithm and increase signal to noise, either manually or with adaptive scoring that does things like "if you read this, words in the subject have the score increased for future rss items". https://www.gnu.org/software/emacs/manual/html_node/gnus/Scoring.html https://www.gnu.org/software/emacs/manual/html_node/gnus/Sco... https://www.gnu.org/software/emacs/manual/html_node/gnus/Adaptive-Scoring.html https://www.gnu.org/software/emacs/manual/html_node/gnus/Ada...
- MacroChip 4y agoYou don't need a Shields Up button to have a little self control on the internet. Seth is energized after a day on the internet. This blog post is about "we" being exhausted aka "you". Not Seth. If you are reading this, you can do it. Be sure to drink your Ovaltine
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoI would love a product/service like this. Seth is a brilliant man, he should start a company and build exactly this.
- sgammon 4y agoEngineers inventing the internet: We invented the internet Seth: Tear forming The one in my imagination is so much better though /s