16 ms·
Mercedes-Benz previews its operating system MB.OS
- badRNG 4y ago> The company is confident that this strategic approach to software and hardware development will be the basis for lifetime revenues as well as additional contributions. Already in 2022, Mercedes-Benz generated more than 1 billion euro in software-enabled revenues with products and services such as navigation, Live Traffic or online map updates. Get ready to pay a monthly subscription to use features that come stock on your car.
- gigatexal 4y agoAll it needs to do is support CarPlay. Honestly car manufacturers should just let Apple do the whole car takeover. I’ve not met a stock system I liked. I’d rather it be powered by my phone.
- sokoloff 4y agoI added a $200 CarPlay radio to our old Honda and it blows away every factory nav unit for usability (and sounds adequate). At this point, I’m only buying a car that has, or can easily have added, wireless CarPlay.
- speedgoose 4y agoI like the BMW and the Tesla ones. I also heard good things about the Polestar Android. The current OS on the Mercedes looks very laggy and not very user friendly, but if they fixed these major issues it could be quite nice. The high end Mercedes has a huge oled dashboard, it’s not something Apple CarPlay supports.
- rootusrootus 4y agoTesla's is fairly good, but the way they handle text messages leaves me really wishing I could just have CarPlay. I may install a third-party screen somewhere so I can have it back.
- drewg123 4y agoWhat's the legality of hacking these things, assuming you own the car? For example, BMW charges $18/mo to turn on heated seats you already own. Am I legally allowed to hack their software to enable heated seats w/o paying? How about installing a wire and switch and running them manually?
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoOf course you are, otherwise jailbreaking would be a crime.
- izacus 4y agoWell, depends on how much do you want a 5000-15.000$ warranty repair on your 80.000$+ vehicle to be rejected because you messed around with it. It's not about difficulty of hacking, but with just how easy it is to put in DRM measures that will make sure that official repair shops will reject the repairs (and unofficial ones are really struggling due to lack of access to DRMed service tools necessary for new modules).
- moremetadata 4y agoI'll give Google their due, their satnav maps apps was accurate enough and fast enough to not need a co driver on unfamiliar roads with my Colin McRae head on. Thats more than can be said with MB's Becker Maps.
- qrohlf 4y agoI was recently an owner of a Merced-Benz commercial van, and the software was by far the worst part of that whole experience. It had obvious race-condition type bugs when it came to the user interface layer, but most frustrating was its tendency to succumb to some kind of memory leak on long drives where the entire head unit would just lock up and crash to a black screen after 6-7 hours of being turned on. Because the vehicle kept the computer system "warm" for up to 30 minutes or so to avoid doing a full (and slow) bootup process every time you stopped for fuel, this was a real problem on long trips and couldn't always be solved by power cycling the vehicle. Had a dealer try to update it twice, which didn't seem to meaningfully impact the system stability at all. Then there were multiple other, non-head-unit related glitches like the lane assist and cruise control features being incompatible with the state of Nevada (if the system fails to detect any other vehicles for a period of more than about 90 minutes, it assumes that there is a sensor fault, and refuses to operate [1]. Unfortunately it is quite easy to spend hours on the road alone in many southwestern US states, triggering this failsafe mode) Suffice it to say that I am very skeptical of any software coming from Mercedes these days. [1] https://www.winnieowners.com/forums/f265/2019-sprinter-cruise-control-design-flaw-362188.html https://www.winnieowners.com/forums/f265/2019-sprinter-cruis...
- coffeebeqn 4y agoI’m also horrified by the trend to put more and more of the meters into the UI. My Ford has done the booting thing before on a highway as well as once it flipped the screen horizontally until it was shut down and started again. I can’t imagine the quality is any better for the display components that will replace speedometers and such
- mmastrac 4y agoThe media head-end software tends to be much less robust than the digital dash display software. I've had the head unit crash and act poorly on many cars, while digital dashes boot quickly and tend to be pretty solid. The only time I had an issue w/a digital dash was in a Volvo that had a battery that was nearly flat. The screen itself would glitch in various ways, but the data itself was still solid.
- ElijahLynn 4y agoYuck: > MB.OS is designed and developed in-house to retain full control You better have some world class software engineers to pull this off, a LOT of them. And retain them. If not, you better go open source. You can still retain full control with open source. Good software is the KEY to good cars, especially electric ones. Why are we inventing 100 different models of cars every year? What a waste of human potential.
- mackman 4y agoI’d be surprised if this isn’t just another Android fork.
- guluarte 4y ago>Offering flexible upgrades do you want to buy the headlights DLC ($0.9 first month, then $29.9)? Y/n
- juice_bus 4y agoSorry, your package only allows you to turn the volume up to 45%, would you like to upgrade?
- Hamuko 4y agoI'd personally love if manufacturers actually offered upgrades on their older cars. I had an older Mercedes-Benz and I would've absolutely given Mercedes-Benz money if they had a first-party CarPlay solution for my then car.
- unglaublich 4y agoYou're effectively saying that you want more disabled features, just in case you want to upgrade your property at some point.
- babypuncher 4y agoNo, they're saying they would pay for new software. Many ~10 year old cars have all the hardware necessary to support things like CarPlay, but because CarPlay didn't exist yet they do not have it. A lot of people would probably happily pay $200 to add it to their car without having to shoehorn in a third party head unit.
- ryanianian 4y agoNot really. CarPlay didn't exist when the car was made. The car manufacturer had to add software integration even if the hardware was already competent. Parent comment is saying they'd pay to receive this added integration.
- abfan1127 4y agoI think it was more about offering features on cars manufactured prior the new feature was released...
- shdshdshd 4y agoThe MBUX is awful. Unresponsive, lagging, buggy, unstable, anything that could go wrong is going wrong. Looking forward for fixes or more interest towards the user.
- jagged-chisel 4y agoWhy does the automobile industry insist on keeping these things in-house when they are clearly terrible at them? I recall an interview with a Ford manager a few years back where they were asked something about adopting Car Play and the response was something like “we have people that can write software for us, so we won’t be using that.”
- akira2501 4y ago> The company is confident that this strategic approach to software and hardware development will be the basis for lifetime revenues as well as additional contributions. I think they're pretty blunt as to "why." What they seem to be hazy on is the "how."
- gangstead 4y agoIt seems like they go through phases of we-can-do-this-in-house followed by let's-just-buy-something-that-works. MB seems to be in the in-house part of the cycle.
- Bud 4y ago[dead]
- corbulo 4y agoMoney. Why give that up when the customer is really only going to use bluetooth audio anyway? Anyone who cares enough about navigation is gonna use an app on their phone. Native car navigation is a superficial value-feature not a use feature. The edge that Carplay gets is really minimal. I'm repulsed by the new car market, its many multiples over-connected anyway. When it comes to digital features my gut says only the safety ones drive sales.
- jagged-chisel 4y agoIn that case, why even spend money trying? Just deliver cars with room for the customer to add what they want.
- 4y ago
- whiplash451 4y agoLots of negative comments in this thread, which I can understand. But let’s be fair, for a car manufacturer, carplay is the kiss of death.
- chrstphrknwtn 4y agoHow so? I mean, they're still manufacturing the actual car itself.
- rm445 4y agoFor software-eating-the-world reasons, I'd guess. A chance to differentiate your product as software does more and more, versus a big chunk of the experience being within someone else's control and the underlying vehicle being an interchangeable commodity. I haven't tried it personally, but people seem pretty passionate about the software on the leading electric vehicle brand, plus its associated do-everything phone app letting you control the vehicle, find a charger, or even order a new model. The situation will probably be like smart TVs for quite a while: lots of janky experiences and user-hostile behaviour, because it's just so valuable to own a software platform that every company tries.
- astrange 4y agoYou could already replace the stereo in a car if you didn't like it, but you still bought the car.
- kcb 4y agoNot really anymore. Most cars don’t have a discrete radio head unit anymore. The radio is way too integrated with vehicle controls.
- astrange 4y agoMaybe so, mine's 10 years old so I haven't checked more recently. I assume you can stick a CarPlay supporting screen on top of the existing dashboard at least, but it'd be hard to integrate.
- udev 4y agoMB.OS stands for Monetization Backdoor Operating System.
- tpmx 4y agoAh, this will be fun to watch. I give this about a 3% chance of producing something the end users will actually enjoy using. Hardware manufacturers are generally extremely bad at building software teams. It's against their DNA. Their executive leadership culture tends to actively reject people who are good at leading software teams, nevermind how much they want that sweet UI/software. (Yes, Apple exists and they are a hardware company that's pretty good at software.) Then add a German extremely hierarchical largeco culture to the mix...
- svdr 4y agoThe use of touchscreens has made handling devices and machines a lot less pleasant. We will soon see a reverse movement, where physical buttons become more important again. So much more satisfying. Of course, this can still be combined with plenty of software.
- ryanianian 4y agoI'm surprised the StreamDeck family of gizmos hasn't caught on as a popular aftermarket car mod. It's just little LEDs inside clear buttons. I'd love about 5 of them right on the center console that I could somehow program to do routines for me.
- wnkrshm 4y agoThose decks are a single screen with a mask and mechanical button overlay - you can argue that there is additional cost to a regular screen without buttons, so maybe it's additional cost they avoid.
- mempko 4y agoIs this using Jolla's Android AppSupport? https://jolla.com/ https://jolla.com/ I use a Sailfish OS phone and it works amazingly well. I know they have been pushing hard into the auto industry after pulling out of Russia because of the war. I would be very pleased if Mercedes is helping fund Jolla.
- mpol 4y agoIn the past few years Jolla worked together with MB. In the latest Sailfish release there were a lot of Android updates, and it seems of high importance to Jolla. At the same time, Jolla could use a new investor, but there was no news that MB would be interested in becoming an investor in Jolla.
- haliskerbas 4y agoThe best car OS so far (even better than Tesla IMO) has been Apple CarPlay. Just be dumb and let my phone handle it, and make the touch screen decent. Bonus points if you implement the multi screen CarPlay concept! Just give up!
- babypuncher 4y agoYes! Every car infotainment system should only cover the basics (bluetooth, radio, critical car controls). Then act as a dumb terminal for CarPlay and Android Auto. Cars are trying too hard to do things our smartphones already do way better.
- antipaul 4y agoThis is the saving grace. And luckily, the next generation CarPlay will span the entire dashboard, including in front of the driver [1] I can’t wait to abandon my native “infotainment” cluster** [1] https://www.macrumors.com/2022/12/28/next-generation-carplay-features/ https://www.macrumors.com/2022/12/28/next-generation-carplay...
- neuralRiot 4y agoThis is a nice idea if don’t plan to have your car for more than 2 years or to never actually own it.
- woobar 4y agoIt will still require stupid touch screens and will not integrate with custom hardware (HUD anyone?). It is subpar experience now, and using multiple screens to show even more "widgets" is strange value prop. The widgets I am interested while driving are not coming from some app. I want these screens to show information related to the car - cameras and parking sensors, cruise/lane control data, tire pressure, etc. Not a meeting reminder or current time in Tokyo.
- kalleboo 4y agoThe 2 main things I look at on my car screen are "now playing" and navigation, both of those come from third party apps and both would be handy to have situated between the dials so I don't have to look off to the side
- kensai 4y agoSoftware is what legacy car manufacturers have been lacking so it’s a move to the right direction indeed. Curious also about the future OSes of BMW and VW Group.
- k8sToGo 4y agoVW tried to do their own software with the ID series and failed horribly to the point the CEO had to be replaced.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoCar is an appliance, like a fridge. I don't want to have an internet connected display showing me ads and "upgrades" on a fridge, nor a car, nor a TV.
- rad_gruchalski 4y agoI take any “legacy manufacturer” vehicle over the “modern manufacturer” car. If my only choice is VAG, I take Skoda.
- maldev 4y agoEveryones talking about alot of negatives. But I have a E53 AMG 4matic+ coup. It looks amazing, like constant compliments, i've even had people compliment it and give me their number in a wendy's drive through. But the OS(MBUX 2) is actually really good, at first I was a bit negative on it. But the way they have everything integrated that isn't really possible with apple play is nice. The dash is customizable, I have my setup with speed, an array right in the center on when to turn, and the right is a mini map so I can see the road. On top of that the screen in the center is amazing and has a few views. The voice assistant is really nice, does everything I want, they have it baked in so each seat can activate it and it knows based off a mic. Can't do that with apple play. So when a girl in my car says "Turn on the massage" or "Turn the temperature to 70", it only does for their side. And honestly, besides the map not having police checkpoints, it's a bit better than apple maps or google maps. And on top of that, I can lookup the location on apple maps on my phone, then send it to the car. And according to my dealer, most people forgo using carplay for anything other than music in alot of the benzes.
- oellegaard 4y agoI have an EQB and I totally agree. I insisted on getting CarPlay but I used it once and I don’t see any need for it. Much happier with MBUX. However, this new Android based OS isn’t good news and I’m not sure I would want to get a new car with an Android based OS in it.
- mempko 4y agoIt's likely using Jolla's AppSupport (no official announcements, just my guess). It's not Android Based but an Android compatibility layer. Kind of how WINE lets you run Windows apps in Linux. I have a Sailfish OS, and it's a linux system (full command line, UI built with QT) but also has Android support via their translation layer.
- izacus 4y agoAndroid Automotive has been getting very good reviews in vehicles that has it (mostly because its performance is pretty good). If you look at e.g. Renault, it's also highly customizable by manufacturers so it's unlikely you'd even notice it's Android without looking into it. Although, as far as I know MB isn't on board for it - BMW is though.
- netfortius 4y ago"Building a proprietary system:..." This will pretty much reassure everyone willing to drive under the control of such.
- _hcuq 4y agoOk... What car brand has the least bad UI these days? I have been putting off getting a new car for about a year.
- ryanianian 4y agoI have a recent Mazda. It boots to CarPlay pretty quickly. Its native controls are pretty utilitarian when they are needed (e.g. to switch to native SiriusXM when cell signal is spotty). I even prefer the look of its maps although I don't use them. Nothing in the car is a touchscreen. And, get a load of this: they still have actual and intuitive physical buttons for climate controls, defrosters, and driving modes. Oh, and the car itself is decent as well if you forgive the meh fuel-economy.
- 0x457 4y agoNot only that, mazda has properly working buttons for infotainment: if you press "nav" or "music" it will bring you back to last one you used. So if I use FM radio and Android Auto maps - buttons leads me where I want them to lead me. So many cars had physical buttons, always lead to built-in apps instead of Android Auto and Car Play.
- trpv 4y agoDo they have analog dials for speed and RPM?
- zztop44 4y agoMazda. They’re all in on being anti-touchscreen plus they support CarPlay (with a physical control).
- zie 4y agoOne with Apple CarPlay and/or Android Auto built-in, so you can avoid the car UI as much as possible.
- lallysingh 4y agoI put a quad-lock on my dashboard and just stick my phone on it. It's right next to my steering wheel. I set the stereo to bluetooth link and everything's actually great. I think CarPlay and Auto are too much. Outside of navigation and music, what overlap do we have in a car and phone? Just enable bluetooth sending of locations or full-on directions. Bluetooth music already works great. Eventually we'll have voice agent integration so that stuff nearby (e.g., bluetooth range) gets integrated into the available status/command set of one primary one. Leave all the fast-moving, upgradable stuff on the phone. Make the car platform stable and you've got the best of both worlds.
- nameisu 4y ago[dead]
- megatoaster 4y ago“In China, Mercedes-Benz is engaging in a local cloud partnership with Tencent to support its automated driving systems. An enriched UI for automated driving functions including an advanced lane-level map view is planned.” Tencent, really? How did that come about?
- nanidin 4y agoThis is how deals are done in China. You want to expose your cloud service to Chinese users? You need to partner with a Chinese company that will effectively run the cloud infrastructure, possibly run the server software, and definitely have access to all of your IP and certificates. The real question for me is what does an ADAS system rely on the cloud for? Hopefully nothing in real time.
- redtriumph 4y agoThe concern among many eastern countries regarding cloud usage is location of data storage. ADAS system could rely on cloud for - Getting updated maps (HD in some cases) - Storing/uploading camera data for analytics/replay among other things...
- jesterson 4y ago> This is how deals are done in China You seriously think deals are done differently in other countries if you are as big as Mercedes Benz?
- nanidin 4y agoYes actually, I have experience running a cloud service where we had to deploy two environments: China and ROW (rest of world). AutoOEM of the same magnitude as Mercedes-Benz.
- antipaul 4y agoThese people should be banned from making software. Some imposed penance would be good too. “MBUX” is buggy and confusing as heck in a brand new 2023 model. Apparently one of the most requested features in new cars [1] has been CarPlay - people are tired of the native “infotainment” garbage [1] It's also a top feature for many drivers and car buyers. Twenty-three percent of new car buyers in the U.S. say they "must have" CarPlay https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2021/05/29/apple-carplay-massive-success-paves-way-for-automotive-entry.html https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2021/05/29/apple-carplay-massive-su...
- dsr_ 4y agoA friend just bought a Mustang and showed it off. The driver's dashboard is a somewhat configurable screen. All I could think of was that a 1970 Mustang, treated moderately well and maintained regularly, is still a useful car fifty years later. In fact, if it's survived, the asking price is within spitting distance of a new Mustang. Is there any chance that a 2023 Mustang will be a useful vehicle in 2073? Will any 2026 Mercedes still be running and maintainable in 2076?
- tcbawo 4y agoI agree with your general point regarding the durability of older cars. But any 1970 Mustang still running and in good shape has required a lot of maintenance and work. Part of me wonders whether the move to electric vehicles from ICE will resemble the move from CRT to LCD televisions. Less robust and initially more expensive, but high consumer satisfaction and eventually economies of scale will make it cheaper.
- levymetal 4y ago> Part of me wonders whether the move to electric vehicles from ICE will resemble the move from CRT to LCD televisions. Less robust… EVs are far more robust than ICEs from a mechanical level, as the number of moving parts is reduced by orders of magnitude. The problem is electronics, but this has been plaguing ICEs for over 30 years. There’s no reason for the electronics in an EV to any less robust than an ICE, but we are going to see far fewer mechanical failures. EV or ICE, it seems unlikely any of these cars will be running in 30 years let alone 50. Eventually the electronics fail to a point that is too difficult to diagnose or fix. Case in point - had a friend with a mid 2000s Astra. Everything worked except for the left indicator. Eventually the car was written off as no one could fix it. The car was just over 10 years old at the time.
- voakbasda 4y agoMaintenance is cheaper for older cars, and parts are readily available. New cars are much more expensive to maintain, and the cost of parts is an order of magnitude higher. All of the cars being produced today will be junk in 20 years. Actually, I take that back; they are junk the moment they roll off the line.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- catchnear4321 4y ago> Unlocking financial opportunity bazinga
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoOh yes, that's what I want - permanently online, bug ridden OS playing me ads and forcing me to buy software "upgrades" of stuff already installed in my car. What a Brave New World.
- jacooper 4y ago> Building a proprietary system: The Mercedes-Benz Operating System (MB.OS) is a new purpose-built chip-to-cloud architecture that will be central to every future product, delivering exceptional software capabilities and delighting customers with its ease of use Say bye bye to actually owning your vehicle or having any kind of privacy. Its really time for car jailbreaking.
- brk 4y agoThis just seems doomed to failure. It’s not fully open. It’s not fully closed. Trying to combine too many things, and the google tie-ins are a turn off for me. Automakers don’t make good software or UIs. But they refuse to yield that to truly competent suppliers.
- adolph 4y agoIt might actually be nice and useful if automakers operated portals that received telemetry from all their vehicles and offered owners statistics on error codes etc. It would improve the automaker processes too since the supply chains for parts could be need based, the part waiting at the dealer for the malfunctioning car to arrive rather than sending parts in response to orders. I'm aware that there is a lot of economic alignment to facilitate this but I'd like to think the future of car software could actually be helpful to people rather than renting heated seating.
- ptkanchi 4y agoYikes, I don't feel like Benz has the Software Engineering talent to pull something like this off, which will definitely make me hesitate in getting in a car that runs the OS
- radicaldreamer 4y agoA lot of people will (wisely) wait to see how this pans out before getting a car with this software in it. The car industry is full of manufacturers who decided to build their own software and failed miserably -- this continues to this day. With the exception of Tesla, very little car software matches anything like CarPlay or Android Auto and that's basically a medium sized feature of your phone.
- xxs 4y ago>matches anything like CarPlay or Android Auto Those are not any OS, just a basic graphic overlay. OS for instance would be the one communicating to AndroidAuto over bluetooth/usb, and driving the GPU that renders it.
- m3kw9 4y agoLet me guess, Android the hood
- dlahoda 4y agois it microkernel written in rust?
- jason_wo 4y agoI just found this presentation with technical details: https://group.mercedes-benz.com/dokumente/investoren/praesentationen/mbsu-os-2023-presentation-markus-schaefer-magnus-oestberg.pdf https://group.mercedes-benz.com/dokumente/investoren/praesen... I guess it is not a typical OS, but more like a collection of tools that build on already existing OSs. This is comparable to ROS (Robotic Operating System), which are just some programs, middleware, services and conventions to build software for robots on Linux. It seems like this should integrate and abstract different "OS" (Linux, QNX, AUTOSAR) and run on very different platforms (high power application processor for infotaiment, microcontrollers) (Slide 13). These are widely different systems: 1. Linux needs a Memory Managing Unit (MMU), which only comes with high(ish) powered application processors, e.g. Arm Cortex-A9. These are obviously not hard-realtime because a page fault can occur non-deterministically (except when you can lock everything to RAM). This might be used for infotaiment. 2. (Classic) AUTOSAR is used without a operating system on a microcontroller like the ARM Cortex-M or a automotive MCU like the Infinion TriCore, which can run two cores in lockstep to verify each computation. AUTOSAR is kind of the operating system and you buy an "adaption"/HAL of AUTOSAR to the each MCU from a vendor. This is widely used in many ECUs for hard real-time control, e.g. to control something in the engine, and other stuff like the electric windows. AUTOSAR is a huge pain in the ass to develop for. You usually configure "it", which takes a lot of time. Then a software generates a huge amount of code. The software is from another vendor, e.g. Vector or Elektrobit. The developer fills out the function stubs implementing the actual function. Alternatively, you can generate the code from MATLAB/SIMULINK models with a code generator from yet another vendor (model-based-development). The upside of this, that the HAL and code generators are certified and everything is somehow standardized. The downside is that normal developers want to kill themself, you learn no transferable skills, and the huge amount of generated boilerplate code, that is hard to read. 3. There is also a newer Adaptive AUTOSAR, which can run on Linux or QNX. I guess (page 8) they want to use it for infotaiment (point 1), interior control (lights, climate control; probably point 2), automated driving and "central driving" (point 1, point 2). I am not sure if this includes typical fast hard-real-time tasks like engine control or chassis control (=vehicle dynamics control). I am not sure if really want to abstract it all or just extend the "OS" (Linux, QNX, AUTOSAR) with libraries and components, mostly in user space. If you look at slide 13, you might guess that they will adapt Linux and QNX to run their UI MBUX (in QT). They extend it with services that communicate with ECUs in the car and their servies in the internet. Moreover, they allow to install sandboxed apps from Mercedes, Android Auto (e.g. Spotify) on top of it. They also come with an app store: https://faurecia-aptoide.com/ https://faurecia-aptoide.com/ The real-time ECUs in the car running AUTOSAR will just get additional components to easily communicate with other MB.OS parts and support some newer features like OTA update. I have not seen any details how this relates to ADAS functions. These are typically (partially) run on a compute node made by an automotive supplier with a hardware accelerator from NVIDIA, e.g. ZF ProAI (https://www.zf.com/products/en/cars/products_64166.html https://www.zf.com/products/en/cars/products_64166.html) or from Valeo (https://www.valeo.com/en/domain-controller/ https://www.valeo.com/en/domain-controller/).
- fwungy 4y agoEMAAS - electricity and mobility as a service This is the new direction for car companies, they're getting out of the car business and into software. What could possibly go wrong? ERROR: vehicle unavailable due to network instability
- neverrroot 4y agoWhy oh why would they want to re-invent the wheel one more time?
- nforgerit 4y agoGerman Software Engineer here. I'd rather chop off my left pinky than working on any software product any German car manufacturer is developing: 1) Their management hierarchies only consist of MBA suits that think short term and treat their engineers like apes in a zoo. This frequently leads to engineers actually behaving like apes in a zoo. 2) German culture is deeply based on thinking in silos. They divide everything into boxes in order to organize it "the right way" and don't understand network effects that occur if you focus on building a great (software engineering) culture. Instead, they mindlessly copy-paste whatever fancy thing they see in a silicon valley context. 3) My hypothesis of why German IT products are almost always horrible is that they're rarely thinking from customer's (or developer's!) perspective. They may be proud of some specs of their products but the overall thing is then often just a bunch of related subsystems "pragmatically" tied up with some duct tape. They still obviously don't understand why they're being outsmarted by Apple, Amazon, Google and others. They're aggressively arrogant and rather lobby the German gov't or cheat to achieve short-time success instead of reorganizing their structures to still be leading in 10 years. I bet, they internally expect industry leading products 2 years after launch and then will quietly kill the whole thing when they realize that their bet was insane from the beginning.
- KETpXDDzR 4y agoA friend is working for Mercedes research. He can confirm all your points.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoI also worked in the German car SW industry and can confirm what he said. They just don't value SW development. The only way to make decent money there was to become a manager and climb the corporate ladder. Programming was never valued and always under the pressure of off-shoring or throwing the work to talent on a visa from abroad who won't have high expectations. The closer you were to the money, like financial controller as said by the sibling, or upper management, the more you were valued, while the closer you were to "the trenches" the less you were valued.
- kfk 4y ago
- birdymcbird 4y agoall sounds good…to be honest read some paragraphs but not whole page. step 1 for Mercedes Benz is to make a vehicle reliable especially at their asking price. had a mb c300. lots of oil leak after warranty period. sensors also bad, constantly complain about low coolant level, even when it good. transmission also slipping. purchase car brand new. never abused engine..always put high octane gas..did all routine maintenance from mb dealer. Will NEVER buy mb product. when i read about new software to me they just bunch of fancy talking clowns. have a 2012 hyundai elantra now driven by me daughter. more reliable than mb c300. even hyundai more reliable than mercedes benz.
- PebblesHD 4y ago> …and receive offers tailored to their interests… The day my car starts showing me advertisements of any kind is the day I take a sledgehammer to its infotainment system. For a luxury car brand to even include this in their copy they send out is a bit worrying.
- harry8 4y agodo you remove all their advertising badges, model numbers, logos from the outside of your car too?
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoOut of the park non sequitur.
- harry8 4y agoWhat? Someone hates advertising and especially with their car. Absolutely reasonable position to take. I ask them how far they go with that? Reasonable to go absolutely hardcore and get rid of /all/ of it. Reasonable to say that level of advertising isn't that annoying so not worth the effort. I ask which because I'm interested in the response. None of that looks particularly controversial to me and I'm not seeing a non-sequitur. I refer you to the guidelines recommended by the house which are here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html See what you make of them.
- saagarjha 4y agoDo you not see a difference from a Mercedes logo on the hood and and McDonald’s ads blaring from the infotainment system?
- harry8 4y agoObviously they are different. You think they are beyond what I just painstakingly pointed out as one of degree and a degree that you are entitled to feel differently about each case? How do you think your comment advances the discussion, just out of interest? Fwiw I don't tune my radio to commercial FM. I do have badges on the outside of my car and I kinda wish I didn't but not enough (yet) to have done something about it. I don't wear clothes that turn me into a flipping nike/ralph lauren/chanel/gucci/whatever billboard either but I can see this puts me in some kind of strange minority but I still find wearing advertising without being paid really weird. Sadly badges on cars are a little harder to not buy or remove. You? Where are you drawing your line?
- osrec 4y agoMercedes has been disappointing me over and over again. Their car body designs are becoming difficult to look at, especially the electric range (the EQS is one ugly car). Their software is HORRENDOUSLY buggy. Their 2007 S-Class is a smoother ride than their 2022 model. I love what Mercedes used to stand for, but right now they are pretty much selling cars on brand value, not because they're actually great cars. The new S-class even feels like a step back from the previous model in terms of basic aesthetics. Plus, loaded up with cheap electronics, ready to break before your next service.
- rad_gruchalski 4y agoThose cheap electronics are the main selling point of the car. Flashy, blinky, lots of nvidia chips. That’s all there is to it. It happens to all brands slowly. Cars have no longer any excitement to offer so manufacturers load them up with this cheap crap.
- jesterson 4y agoComments like this actually turn me off buying MB again. I used to have a lot of MB cars back in 90s- 200xs - C-klasse, S-klasse, and then a number of V-klasse and every time it was a pleasure in every sense. Never had any unreasonable problem with them. Buggy software? It was unheard.
- demarq 4y agoI can see it now, 2dollar monthly subscription to the glovebox compartment
- michaelteter 4y ago> The next generation of SAE Level 2 automated driving will start in the Entry segment, leveraging the full potential of machine learning. Forgive me, but my expectations for the "full potential" of machine learning are not so high. They're definitely not high enough to trust my life with.
- rad_gruchalski 4y agoIt doesn’t matter. The legislator is sold on this, it’s required by law, nobody cared what we think. Number of accidents goes down annually and nobody cares that edge cases like you or me are pissed off that we’re no longer in control. Because, you see, apparently driving a car is a privilege and not a right.
- YPPH 4y agoIt's strange seeing the word "proprietary" used as if it's a positive thing for consumers.
- pjmorris 4y ago'Unlocking financial opportunity: Software-enabled revenues to evolve to high single-digit billion EUR figure by end of decade;' Does this mean MB owners will have to pay subscription fees to unlock, eg., heated seats, in their vehicles?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Animats 4y agoIs Mercedes actually building an entire OS, or does this really have something off the shelf underneath?
- eande 4y agoAll major car OEM are challenged with a cohesive software development and integration. There are so many different units of ECU/ICI/ADAS/TCU/ABS/etc (and list goes on) and mostly all of them are interconnected, partial OTA, etc. Tesla having started software first and with their central ECU approach has a leading edge. Mercedes with their MB.os, VW with their Cariad, Toyota with their Arene and each major automotive OWM is coming up with their own overarching OS platform shifting to software and mobility first. Underneath is often a safety certifiable OS like QNX, combined with AutoSAR or Linux for less safety critical OS. So generally as far as I can tell most car OEM do not start from scratch and they have to work with the leading silicon supplier as well on all the OS driver support. You also have to consider full functional safety compliance across the globe, many teams/languages/etc. It truly is not that easy to orchestrate that all. On top like someone commented here, many OEM are very hierarchical structured and creating software development across these different functional units/devisions is a challenge for most automotive companies are really struggling with.
- jaas 4y agoSo they're 2-4 years away from a big announcement that they're becoming more efficient and maximizing shareholder value by not developing their own OS any more and instead they're "collaborating" with Google and shipping Android Auto. I bet chatgpt could write that future press release right now and get pretty close.
- speculator 4y agoironically there aren't any screenshots in the post to show what MB.OS looks like.
- jacquesm 4y agoIt likely doesn't look like anything other than bitstream. Think 'linux kernel' rather than 'ubuntu'. It's a foundation component. MBUX is a layer on top of MB.OS, and that does have a particular look and feel.
- stevenjgarner 4y agoNow the shake out of car companies that make software vs software companies that make cars. Reminds me of the old bellheads vs netheads. [1] [1] https://www.wired.com/1996/10/atm-3/ https://www.wired.com/1996/10/atm-3/
- steponlego 4y agoSoftware-enabled revenues? Proprietary? Built in Google spyware? Holy shit sign me up!
- ur-whale 4y agoHard to believe a company would hawk a product in 2023 by first proudly pointing out that the thing is proprietary.
- throwaway61803 4y agothrowaway account - the cheapest supplier/contractor gets the contract. Always! - the salaries in engineering are among the lowest on the market (at least in Germany). The headcount increased from 200 to 800+ in just a couple of years but so did the churn rate and focusing on the salary when hiring, means a lot of talent is skipped from the start (candidates should be happy with 20% less salary given that they work at Mercedes :shrugging Obama meme:) - (lower) managers and engineers are generally apathetic and disinterested - about the products, their teams and the company. Higher management lives in a parallel universe. - and maaaaany more issues I know I'm bitter but, looking at Maslow's hierarchy of needs, how can you expect your employees to reach their full potential when, as an employer, you don't even offer them the basics: a decent salary, support, guidance etc. </rant>
- jhoelzel 4y agoMy family had mercs since the beginning of the 90s and its very apparent when those problems started. I used to say "life behind a star is different" and now they all look the same, feel just as badly engineered as the next VW and have more plastic in them then a modern store for drinks. Your not bitter, its the truth.
- ocimbote 4y agoMBition maybe?
- throwaway61803 4y agobingo
- lucasfcosta 4y agoI wonder why would they undertake such an Herculean task when they could simply pick a non-GPL OS, or just pick Linux itself given the programs running in it wouldn't have to be open-sourced anyway.
- amelius 4y agoIs this a new kernel, e.g. realtime? Or BSD/Linux with a new graphical shell on top?
- unixhero 4y agoOoh, Nvidia Drive platform.
- fennecfoxy 4y ago>Unlocking financial opportunity Lmao, MBAs. If you don't want to spend so much money on writing software then FORK ANDROID. Or, you know, make a super dumb entertainment unit that requires a phone, AA/CP support and then you're done! Can't wait to see all of the super dangerous vulns that come out of this over the next wee while.
- leephillips 4y agoI don’t know if this was written by a computer or a person, but the result is the worst kind of corporate-speak. “MB.OS is designed to connect the major aspects of the company's value chain.” I gave up trying to extract any meaning from this article pretty quickly.
- liamrc 4y ago> The company is confident that this strategic approach to software and hardware development will be the basis for lifetime revenues as well as additional contributions. Why sell cars when you can sell SaaS? Get ready to pay a $49.99/mo. subscription for access to power steering.
- rawbot 4y agoMercedes-Benz UI for cars circa 2015 has to be the worst piece of UI I have used in the last 30 years. It is slow, unintuitive, has both touch controls and a turning knob that has no semblance of sanity, and each has exclusive UI control properties.